Shane Gunster
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Shane Gunster has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Darren Fleet
School of Communication, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC, Canada
2 shared publications- Matthew Paterson
University of Manchester, UK
2 shared publications Paul Saurette
School of Communication, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC, Canada
2 shared publicationsBob Neubauer
1 shared publication- Heather Earle
Simon Fraser University
1 shared publication - Imre Szeman
University of Waterloo
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 17 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 16 (5) , 645-663
Connective Action, Digital Engagement and Network-Building: A Year in the Life of Canadian Climate Facebook
This article explores how competing discursive and political formations about climate change structure and circulate in social media by mapping a year of climate-related Facebook posts and links by Canadian civil society actors. Drawing upon the concept of connective action, it traces the efficacy and impact of the social media strategies of actors favoring stronger climate action against those aiming to delay or block such action. Distinguishing between self-referential vs network-building connective action and active vs passive types of user engagement, it finds the most significant use of Facebook by Canadian civil society actors was the sharing of mainstream and alternative news sources. Such activity plays a key role in building networked publics around shared perspectives on climate change as well as generating audience subsidies through which users are mobilized to amplify particular news stories, columnists and media outlets. In Canada, conservative actors tend to be more focused upon network building and more effective in producing these subsidies, especially for right-leaning commercial news organizations and alt-right digital outlets.
- 17 February 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 16 (5) , 645-663
Connective Action, Digital Engagement and Network-Building: A Year in the Life of Canadian Climate Facebook
This article explores how competing discursive and political formations about climate change structure and circulate in social media by mapping a year of climate-related Facebook posts and links by Canadian civil society actors. Drawing upon the concept of connective action, it traces the efficacy and impact of the social media strategies of actors favoring stronger climate action against those aiming to delay or block such action. Distinguishing between self-referential vs network-building connective action and active vs passive types of user engagement, it finds the most significant use of Facebook by Canadian civil society actors was the sharing of mainstream and alternative news sources. Such activity plays a key role in building networked publics around shared perspectives on climate change as well as generating audience subsidies through which users are mobilized to amplify particular news stories, columnists and media outlets. In Canada, conservative actors tend to be more focused upon network building and more effective in producing these subsidies, especially for right-leaning commercial news organizations and alt-right digital outlets.
- Open Access
- 30 November 2021
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Communication
- Vol. 46 (4) , 22 pp
Fire and Climate: Connecting the Dots in British Columbia News Media
Background: Extreme weather events are intensifying with climate change, offering opportunities to raise the public urgency of this issue. The media’s role in communicating this connection is crucial. Analysis: This article analyzes media coverage of wildfires over a nine-year period in British Columbia focusing on how they are linked to climate change, in particular, during the 2017 and 2018 record-breaking fire seasons. Conclusion and implications: In media coverage in British Columbia, there is a marked absence of a link between climate change and wildfires and a tendency for connections to be tokenistic, decontextualized, and normalizing. More provocative narratives developed by various public figures that locate wildfires within broader narratives of climate crisis offer more compelling accounts. Contexte : À cause du changement climatique, les événements climatiques extrêmes sont en train de devenir plus intenses. Dans les circonstances, il devient pertinent de soulever l’urgence publique de cet enjeu, et les médias pourraient jouer un rôle crucial pour le communiquer. Analyse : Cet article analyse la couverture médiatique de feux de forêt sur une période de neuf ans en Colombie-Britannique, particulièrement durant les saisons des feux de 2017 et 2018 qui ont battu tous les records. L’article met l’accent sur comment ces incendies sont reliés au changement climatique. Conclusions et implications : Dans la couverture médiatique en Colombie-Britannique, on néglige de montrer les liens qui existent entre le changement climatique et les feux de forêt. Toute connexion établie tend à être superficielle, décontextualisée et normalisée. En revanche, diverses personnalités publiques ont incorporé les feux de forêt dans des narrations englobant l’idée de crise climatique, offrant ainsi une perspective plus intéressante, voire provocatrice.
- 30 November 2021
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Communication
- Vol. 46 (4) , 22 pp
Open AccessFire and Climate: Connecting the Dots in British Columbia News Media
Background: Extreme weather events are intensifying with climate change, offering opportunities to raise the public urgency of this issue. The media’s role in communicating this connection is crucial. Analysis: This article analyzes media coverage of wildfires over a nine-year period in British Columbia focusing on how they are linked to climate change, in particular, during the 2017 and 2018 record-breaking fire seasons. Conclusion and implications: In media coverage in British Columbia, there is a marked absence of a link between climate change and wildfires and a tendency for connections to be tokenistic, decontextualized, and normalizing. More provocative narratives developed by various public figures that locate wildfires within broader narratives of climate crisis offer more compelling accounts. Contexte : À cause du changement climatique, les événements climatiques extrêmes sont en train de devenir plus intenses. Dans les circonstances, il devient pertinent de soulever l’urgence publique de cet enjeu, et les médias pourraient jouer un rôle crucial pour le communiquer. Analyse : Cet article analyse la couverture médiatique de feux de forêt sur une période de neuf ans en Colombie-Britannique, particulièrement durant les saisons des feux de 2017 et 2018 qui ont battu tous les records. L’article met l’accent sur comment ces incendies sont reliés au changement climatique. Conclusions et implications : Dans la couverture médiatique en Colombie-Britannique, on néglige de montrer les liens qui existent entre le changement climatique et les feux de forêt. Toute connexion établie tend à être superficielle, décontextualisée et normalisée. En revanche, diverses personnalités publiques ont incorporé les feux de forêt dans des narrations englobant l’idée de crise climatique, offrant ainsi une perspective plus intéressante, voire provocatrice.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2018
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Communication
- Vol. 3
“Why Don't You Act Like You Believe It?”: Competing Visions of Climate Hypocrisy
This paper interrogates how the notion of hypocrisy is invoked in relation to climate change and offers two key findings. First, it demonstrates that invocations of hypocrisy are not only deployed by conservative opponents of climate action, but also by progressive proponents of such action. Second, this article shows that while hypocrisy discourse is used to support both anti- and pro-climate change perspectives, its nature and function fundamentally differs depending on who is using it. The article identifies four discrete types of climate hypocrisy discourse. Conservatives who reject climate change action tend to use two “modes” of hypocrisy discourse. The first is an “individual lifestyle outrage” mode that cultivates outrage about the hypocritical behavior and lifestyle choices of climate activists to undermine the urgency and moral need for climate change action. The second, an “institutional cynicism” mode, encourages a cynical fatalism about any proposed governmental action regarding climate change by suggesting that governments are necessarily climate hypocrites because of the economic and political impossibility of serious emissions reductions. In contrast, progressives use hypocrisy discourse in two different modes. The first involve an “institutional call to action” mode that uses charges of hypocrisy to attack government inaction on climate change and demand that effective action be taken in line with their public commitment to climate action. Secondly, they also employ a “reflexive” mode in which explorations of the ubiquity of climate change hypocrisy illuminate the dilemmas that virtually all responses to climate change necessarily grapple with in our current context. Overall, the article seeks to contribute to our understanding of climate change communications by (i) showing that hypocrisy discourse is not simply a sensationalist PR strategy of conservatives but is rather a broad, significant and multi-faceted form of climate change discourse; and (ii) suggesting that certain modes of hypocrisy discourse might not only represent genuine attempts to make sense of some of the fundamental tensions of climate change politics but also help us understand the challenge that the “entanglement” of personal agency/choice within broader political structures presents, and thus heighten positive affective commitments to climate change action.
- 6 November 2018
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Communication
- Vol. 3
Open Access“Why Don't You Act Like You Believe It?”: Competing Visions of Climate Hypocrisy
This paper interrogates how the notion of hypocrisy is invoked in relation to climate change and offers two key findings. First, it demonstrates that invocations of hypocrisy are not only deployed by conservative opponents of climate action, but also by progressive proponents of such action. Second, this article shows that while hypocrisy discourse is used to support both anti- and pro-climate change perspectives, its nature and function fundamentally differs depending on who is using it. The article identifies four discrete types of climate hypocrisy discourse. Conservatives who reject climate change action tend to use two “modes” of hypocrisy discourse. The first is an “individual lifestyle outrage” mode that cultivates outrage about the hypocritical behavior and lifestyle choices of climate activists to undermine the urgency and moral need for climate change action. The second, an “institutional cynicism” mode, encourages a cynical fatalism about any proposed governmental action regarding climate change by suggesting that governments are necessarily climate hypocrites because of the economic and political impossibility of serious emissions reductions. In contrast, progressives use hypocrisy discourse in two different modes. The first involve an “institutional call to action” mode that uses charges of hypocrisy to attack government inaction on climate change and demand that effective action be taken in line with their public commitment to climate action. Secondly, they also employ a “reflexive” mode in which explorations of the ubiquity of climate change hypocrisy illuminate the dilemmas that virtually all responses to climate change necessarily grapple with in our current context. Overall, the article seeks to contribute to our understanding of climate change communications by (i) showing that hypocrisy discourse is not simply a sensationalist PR strategy of conservatives but is rather a broad, significant and multi-faceted form of climate change discourse; and (ii) suggesting that certain modes of hypocrisy discourse might not only represent genuine attempts to make sense of some of the fundamental tensions of climate change politics but also help us understand the challenge that the “entanglement” of personal agency/choice within broader political structures presents, and thus heighten positive affective commitments to climate change action.
- 6 August 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Politics
- Vol. 28 (4) , 707-726
(De)legitimating extractivism: the shifting politics of social licence
Most scholarly accounts of social licence define it as a public relations strategy to legitimate resource development. In Canadian pipeline politics, however, it has had the opposite effect, crystallizing widespread concerns about industry capture of regulatory processes and affirming the democratic rights of local communities. This assessment of the concept’s critical, counter-hegemonic potential to challenge the policies, practices and logic of state-sponsored extractivist development situates social licence as a key discursive battleground in the struggle between politicization (which accents agonistic confrontation between competing alternative futures) and de-politicization (which defuses conflict and builds consensus around the perception of common interests). Frame analysis of news media and advocacy group texts is used to investigate how opponents of a pipeline project bridged the idea of social licence with movement frames concerning identity, injustice and democratic agency to transform the concept from a public relations term meant to enable corporate activity into a critical trope used to constrain it.
- 6 August 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Politics
- Vol. 28 (4) , 707-726
(De)legitimating extractivism: the shifting politics of social licence
Most scholarly accounts of social licence define it as a public relations strategy to legitimate resource development. In Canadian pipeline politics, however, it has had the opposite effect, crystallizing widespread concerns about industry capture of regulatory processes and affirming the democratic rights of local communities. This assessment of the concept’s critical, counter-hegemonic potential to challenge the policies, practices and logic of state-sponsored extractivist development situates social licence as a key discursive battleground in the struggle between politicization (which accents agonistic confrontation between competing alternative futures) and de-politicization (which defuses conflict and builds consensus around the perception of common interests). Frame analysis of news media and advocacy group texts is used to investigate how opponents of a pipeline project bridged the idea of social licence with movement frames concerning identity, injustice and democratic agency to transform the concept from a public relations term meant to enable corporate activity into a critical trope used to constrain it.
- 11 June 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 12 (6) , 773-793
Climate Hypocrisies: A Comparative Study of News Discourse
This paper conducts a comparative study of how the idea of hypocrisy was invoked in media coverage of climate change in 12 newspapers from four countries (Canada, Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States) between 2005 and 2015. It develops the concepts, and explores the characteristics, of three distinct types of climate hypocrisy: personalized (which attacks the moral character of individuals based on inconsistencies between their stated beliefs and behavior); institutional-analytic (which identifies contradictions between institutional rhetoric and ongoing policies and practices); and reflexive (which develops sympathetic accounts of the struggles individuals face in reconciling the tension between values and actions). It explores how these types are used to undermine the credibility of climate advocates as well as to argue for more aggressive climate action, and maps out key features of climate hypocrisy discourse including ideological attributes, targeted actors and behaviors, affective intensity, and regional variations. It outlines a number of surprising key findings, such as (i) hypocrisy discourses are more frequently invoked by “progressives” supporting climate change action than by “conservatives” resisting climate change action, and (ii) while both groups use hypocrisy discourse, they tend to use very different types of hypocrisy discourses which each likely have very different impacts on climate change discourse.
- 11 June 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 12 (6) , 773-793
Climate Hypocrisies: A Comparative Study of News Discourse
This paper conducts a comparative study of how the idea of hypocrisy was invoked in media coverage of climate change in 12 newspapers from four countries (Canada, Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States) between 2005 and 2015. It develops the concepts, and explores the characteristics, of three distinct types of climate hypocrisy: personalized (which attacks the moral character of individuals based on inconsistencies between their stated beliefs and behavior); institutional-analytic (which identifies contradictions between institutional rhetoric and ongoing policies and practices); and reflexive (which develops sympathetic accounts of the struggles individuals face in reconciling the tension between values and actions). It explores how these types are used to undermine the credibility of climate advocates as well as to argue for more aggressive climate action, and maps out key features of climate hypocrisy discourse including ideological attributes, targeted actors and behaviors, affective intensity, and regional variations. It outlines a number of surprising key findings, such as (i) hypocrisy discourses are more frequently invoked by “progressives” supporting climate change action than by “conservatives” resisting climate change action, and (ii) while both groups use hypocrisy discourse, they tend to use very different types of hypocrisy discourses which each likely have very different impacts on climate change discourse.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2018
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Communication
- Vol. 43 (1)
From Public Relations to Mob Rule: Media Framing of Social Licence in Canada
Background Social licence refers to the idea that corporations and governments require broad public support for resource development projects from affected communities, citizens, and stakeholders. Talk of social licence has become pervasive in media discussions of resource development in Canada and especially prominent in debates around oil pipelines. Analysis This article explores changing Canadian newspaper coverage of social licence over the past two decades. It identifies and analyzes the formation of four distinct “logics” of social licence: corporate, regulatory, oppositional, and conservative attack.Conclusions and implications This analysis provides a more robust framework for understanding how different groups have advanced competing visions of social licence within the public sphere, while illuminating the active role that news media have played in shaping the definition of social licence to fit their own editorial cultures.Contexte « Permis social » se rapporte à l’idée que les sociétés commerciales et les gouvernements requièrent, pour le développement des ressources, l’appui des communautés, citoyens et parties prenantes concernés. Cette idée de permis social apparaît souvent dans les discours médiatiques sur le développement énergétique au Canada, surtout par rapport aux oléoducs.Analyse Cet article explore les changements dans la manière dont les journaux canadiens ont traité du permis social au cours des deux dernières décennies. Par rapport à ce concept, il identifie et analyse la formation de quatre « logiques » différentes : corporative, règlementaire, oppositionnelle et conservatrice attaquante.Conclusion et implications Cette analyse fournit un cadre plus robuste pour comprendre comment divers groupes ont mis l’accent dans la sphère publique sur des interprétations divergentes du permis social. D’autre part, elle élucide le rôle actif joué par les médias d’information dans la définition, selon leurs orientations éditoriales, de ce qu’est le permis social.
- 15 March 2018
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Communication
- Vol. 43 (1)
Open AccessFrom Public Relations to Mob Rule: Media Framing of Social Licence in Canada
Background Social licence refers to the idea that corporations and governments require broad public support for resource development projects from affected communities, citizens, and stakeholders. Talk of social licence has become pervasive in media discussions of resource development in Canada and especially prominent in debates around oil pipelines. Analysis This article explores changing Canadian newspaper coverage of social licence over the past two decades. It identifies and analyzes the formation of four distinct “logics” of social licence: corporate, regulatory, oppositional, and conservative attack.Conclusions and implications This analysis provides a more robust framework for understanding how different groups have advanced competing visions of social licence within the public sphere, while illuminating the active role that news media have played in shaping the definition of social licence to fit their own editorial cultures.Contexte « Permis social » se rapporte à l’idée que les sociétés commerciales et les gouvernements requièrent, pour le développement des ressources, l’appui des communautés, citoyens et parties prenantes concernés. Cette idée de permis social apparaît souvent dans les discours médiatiques sur le développement énergétique au Canada, surtout par rapport aux oléoducs.Analyse Cet article explore les changements dans la manière dont les journaux canadiens ont traité du permis social au cours des deux dernières décennies. Par rapport à ce concept, il identifie et analyse la formation de quatre « logiques » différentes : corporative, règlementaire, oppositionnelle et conservatrice attaquante.Conclusion et implications Cette analyse fournit un cadre plus robuste pour comprendre comment divers groupes ont mis l’accent dans la sphère publique sur des interprétations divergentes du permis social. D’autre part, elle élucide le rôle actif joué par les médias d’information dans la définition, selon leurs orientations éditoriales, de ce qu’est le permis social.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2018
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Communication
- Vol. 43 (1) , 3-10
Communicating Power: Energy, Canada, and the Field(s) of Communication
Communicating Power: Energy, Canada, and the Field(s) of Communication
- 15 March 2018
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Communication
- Vol. 43 (1) , 3-10
Open AccessCommunicating Power: Energy, Canada, and the Field(s) of Communication
Communicating Power: Energy, Canada, and the Field(s) of Communication
- 24 November 2017
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 173-186
Journalism, Climate Communication and Media Alternatives
- 24 November 2017
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 173-186
Journalism, Climate Communication and Media Alternatives
- 17 February 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 120-143
Contesting conflict? Efficacy, advocacy and alternative media in British Columbia 1
This chapter reports the results of interviews with alternative media journalists, editors and publishers, and leading environmental activists and advocates and exploring their perspectives on the relationship among news, politics and public engagement with climate change. The participants work within a diverse array of British Columbia (BC)-based alternative and independent media, political advocacy groups, environmental organizations and think tanks. British Columbia offers an ideal site for exploring the intersection of communication, efficacy and engagement around climate and energy politics. It embraces a radical role for journalism in which the critique of power, inequality and injustice – and the empowerment of citizens and social movements – mediates a more traditional emphasis upon neutrality and balance in the portrayal of conflict. The chapter focuses upon enlightening influentials also suggests an approach to social change which prioritizes getting useful information into the right hands over more confrontational strategies of political mobilization and activism.
- 17 February 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 120-143
Contesting conflict? Efficacy, advocacy and alternative media in British Columbia 1
This chapter reports the results of interviews with alternative media journalists, editors and publishers, and leading environmental activists and advocates and exploring their perspectives on the relationship among news, politics and public engagement with climate change. The participants work within a diverse array of British Columbia (BC)-based alternative and independent media, political advocacy groups, environmental organizations and think tanks. British Columbia offers an ideal site for exploring the intersection of communication, efficacy and engagement around climate and energy politics. It embraces a radical role for journalism in which the critique of power, inequality and injustice – and the empowerment of citizens and social movements – mediates a more traditional emphasis upon neutrality and balance in the portrayal of conflict. The chapter focuses upon enlightening influentials also suggests an approach to social change which prioritizes getting useful information into the right hands over more confrontational strategies of political mobilization and activism.
- 17 February 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 49-76
Engaging climate communication
Most communication about climate change generally assumes that providing accurate information about its causes, consequences and solutions will necessarily improve public awareness and understanding of the problem, generate increased levels of care and concern. The alarmed and the concerned possess high levels of issue involvement and are predisposed to accept and carefully process information about climate change. This chapter offers four deliberately provocative suggestions which could help shift climate journalism in this direction: prioritize audiences who are most likely to engage with news about climate change; make greater use of a climate justice frame which spotlights the ethical, political and normative dimensions of climate change. The suggestions also includes foreground and 'activate' cultural values which are most likely to promote pro-environmental attitudes, beliefs and behaviour; and cultivate social norms of civic engagement and political efficacy with greater attention to the stories, experiences and emotions of people and communities who are working together to address climate change.
- 17 February 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 49-76
Engaging climate communication
Most communication about climate change generally assumes that providing accurate information about its causes, consequences and solutions will necessarily improve public awareness and understanding of the problem, generate increased levels of care and concern. The alarmed and the concerned possess high levels of issue involvement and are predisposed to accept and carefully process information about climate change. This chapter offers four deliberately provocative suggestions which could help shift climate journalism in this direction: prioritize audiences who are most likely to engage with news about climate change; make greater use of a climate justice frame which spotlights the ethical, political and normative dimensions of climate change. The suggestions also includes foreground and 'activate' cultural values which are most likely to promote pro-environmental attitudes, beliefs and behaviour; and cultivate social norms of civic engagement and political efficacy with greater attention to the stories, experiences and emotions of people and communities who are working together to address climate change.