CSCarl Smith

Carl Smith

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Carl Smith has a total of 178 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Density-dependent interference reduces territorial male success in bitterling

    by Carl Smith

    Territoriality is a key element of the mating system of many teleost fishes. An experimental study was conducted to explore the impact of altering territory size in a natural population of the European bitterling (Rhodeus amarus) on male reproductive success. Bitterling are freshwater fish that oviposit in the gills of living bivalve mussels, with males defending a territory around mussels to attract females for spawning. The distance between pairs of mussels guarded by males was set experimentally between 1 and 120 cm, and each focal male was observed at four distances. Four predictions of the effects of proximity to another territorial male were tested: (1) increased aggressive interactions with rivals; (2) decreased frequency of ejaculation by the focal male over his guarded mussel; (3) increased ejaculation into the focal male’s mussel by rival territorial males and by sneaker males; (4) a reduction in the likelihood of spawning. Predictions 1, 2 and 4 were supported. Prediction 3 was supported for rival territorial males but not for sneaker males. These results demonstrate density-dependent effects in the bitterling mating system, including greater sperm competition intensity and a lower spawning rate at higher densities. Results are discussed in the context of sexual selection in the bitterling mating system, recognising that the density and spatial distribution of mussels influence traits associated with sexual selection.

  • Open Access

    The role of female reproductive fluid in mediating reproductive isolation between ecotypes of the three-spined stickleback

    by Carl Smith, Eliza Szczerkowska-Majchrzak, Grzegorz ZięBa

    Female reproductive fluid (FRF) is increasingly recognised as a potent mediator of gametic-level cryptic female mating bias in external fertilisers, yet its role in reproductive isolation during early ecological divergence remains largely untested. We examined whether FRF from three-spined stickleback ( Gasterosteus aculeatus ) females on North Uist differentially attracts and sustains sperm from armourless (acidic loch) versus armoured (basic loch) ecotypes. Using a fully crossed diallel design across four allopatric populations and a sympatric contact zone, we quantified spermatozoa accumulation in a sperm-selection chamber and spermatozoa swimming longevity in response to conspecific and heterospecific FRF versus loch-water controls. More spermatozoa accumulated in selection chambers in response to FRF than in paired controls. Both sperm attraction and swimming longevity were enhanced by FRF. Attraction was stronger in same-ecotype pairings, whereas longevity showed clear male-environment-by-medium interactions, with acid- and basic-adapted males performing best in water chemistry matching their natal habitat. FRF therefore has the potential to function as a previously unrecognised gametic barrier, reinforcing pre-mating isolation and reducing gene flow between recently diverged ecotypes in this adaptive radiation.

  • Impact of a major flood event on riverine fish community composition

    by Lidia Marszał, Carl Smith, Bartosz Janic, Dariusz Halabowski, Dariusz Pietraszewski, Kacper Pyrzanowski, Szymon Tybulczuk, Grzegorz ZięBa, Jan Kotusz

  • Variation in resistance and survival of the European bitterling fish across a gradient of Sinanodonta woodiana expansion

    by Abhishek Nair Anil, Dariusz Halabowski, Kacper Pyrzanowski, Grzegorz ZięBa, Joanna Grabowska, Carl Smith, Karel Douda, Martin Reichard

  • How to review a manuscript

    by Carl Smith, Martin Reichard

    Peer review remains the cornerstone of quality control in scientific publishing, yet most reviewers receive little or no formal training in how to perform this essential task effectively. Drawing on our combined experience as authors, reviewers, and journal editors, we provide a practical, step-by-step guide to conducting high-quality, constructive manuscript reviews for those new to the practice. We cover the entire review workflow: deciding whether to accept a review invitation, preparing for the review, conducting a structured, section-by-section evaluation, and writing clear, professional review reports. Key features include assessing expertise and potential conflicts of interest, identifying common pitfalls, providing balanced, evidence-based feedback, and upholding high ethical and open-science standards for transparent processes and accountability. A reviewer checklist is also provided to help structure the assessment process. The aim of this short paper is to assist both novice and experienced reviewers in delivering fair, thorough, and constructive reviews that enhance manuscript quality, reduce unnecessary revision cycles, and ultimately strengthen the reliability and progress of ecological and zoological research.

  • Open Access

    Nest architecture and male aggression drive sexual isolation between three-spined stickleback ecotypes

    by Carl Smith, Rowena Spence, Eliza Szczerkowska-Majchrzak, Dawid Żegota, Grzegorz ZięBa

    To understand how sexual isolation contributes to the evolution of reproductive barriers, we examined the pre- and post-zygotic reproductive barriers between ecotypes of the three-spined stickleback ( Gasterosteus aculeatus ) from North Uist, where the species has undergone an adaptive radiation. Using an experimental design that separated the effects of ecotype, population of origin, and body size, we identified a pre-zygotic barrier attributed solely to ecotype; pairings within ecotypes were more likely to result in mating than those between ecotypes, regardless of population origin or relative body size of males and females. This effect was associated with reproductive incompatibilities linked to the failure of armoured females to enter the unusually small nests of armourless males, along with high levels of aggression from armoured males directed at armourless females. In vitro crosses did not reveal post-zygotic reproductive barriers associated with ecotype or population of origin. These findings indicate that sexual isolation, linked primarily to male traits and involving the coupling of barrier effects, is a significant obstacle to gene flow among the ecotypes, supporting an emerging view that pre-zygotic sexual isolation tends to evolve rapidly and at an early stage during ecological divergence.


  • Open Access

    Distribution of parasitic larvae of non-native Sinanodonta woodiana on fish hosts across an invasion gradient

    by Dariusz Halabowski, Kacper Pyrzanowski, Grzegorz Zięba, Joanna Grabowska, Mirosław Przybylski, Carl Smith, Martin Reichard

    The Chinese pond mussel (Sinanodonta woodiana) is a highly invasive freshwater bivalve, recognised for its broad host range and ecological plasticity. Its obligate parasitic larvae (glochidia) must attach to fish hosts to complete development, potentially disrupting native host-parasite interactions. We investigated patterns of natural infection by glochidia of S. woodiana and native unionid species across six sites in Poland that differ in habitat type and invasion history. Using whole-body dissections of 601 wild fish belonging to eight species, we quantified glochidia prevalence, intensity of infection and attachment site preferences. Glochidia of S. woodiana were widespread and present on all fish species, with the greatest loads on Carassius gibelio and Rhodeus amarus. In contrast, native mussels (primarily Unio spp.) infected only a subset of hosts and at lower prevalence. Habitat type strongly influenced parasite loads, with higher infection levels observed in lentic compared to lotic habitats. Glochidia of S. woodiana attached both to gills and fins, whereas native unionids predominantly targeted the gills. This spatial disparity may reflect differences in infection strategies or host immune responses. Although previous studies have shown that prior infection by S. woodiana can reduce the success of subsequent native mussel infections, our study found simultaneous infections and no significant association between native and invasive glochidia under natural conditions. Our findings underscore the generalist nature and potential ecological dominance of S. woodiana, while highlighting risks posed to native mussel reproduction. Understanding these interactions is crucial for developing effective conservation strategies for native unionid populations in freshwater ecosystems under pressure from biological invasions.


  • Open Access

    Rapid evolution in response to biological invasion: variation in resistance and survival of the European bitterling fish across a gradient of Sinanodonta woodiana expansion

    by Abhishek Nair Anil, Dariusz Halabowski, Kacper Pyrzanowski, Grzegorz Zięba, Joanna Grabowska, Carl Smith, Karel Douda, Martin Reichard

    Biological invasions impose new selective pressures on native species, prompting rapid evolutionary responses. We examined how the parasitic larvae (glochidia) of the invasive East Asian mussel Sinanodonta woodiana affect European bitterling fish ( Rhodeus amarus ) populations with different histories of exposure to the parasite (none, 15 years, or 40+ years). Glochidia parasitise fish fins and gills, and bitterling are especially vulnerable to parasitism due to their spawning association with mussels. We found the lowest glochidia load in bitterling from populations with the longest association with S. woodiana . While infection reduced swimming capacity proportionally to parasite load, this effect was not population-specific. However, post-infection mortality was highest in naïve and lowest in long-associated populations, indicating evolved tolerance. No long-term effects on survival, growth, condition, or reproduction were observed, suggesting fitness costs are concentrated shortly after infection. These results show that novel host–parasite interactions during invasions can drive rapid adaptive change, emphasising the need to consider evolutionary dynamics in invasion management.


  • Open Access

    Female mate choice in zebrafish is based on male compatibility

    by Rowena Spence, Carl Smith

    Female mate choice decisions are a key aspect of many mating systems. Using data from a previously published study, we fitted a zero-adjusted generalised Poisson model to data to identify the basis of female mate choice decisions in the zebrafish (Danio rerio, Cyprinidae), a widely used vertebrate model species. Mate choice decisions were based on the propensity to spawn with particular males and the number of eggs laid in the presence of particular males. After controlling for the day of the experiment as a fixed effect, both in the count and logistic parts of the model, we showed that specific male-female crosses were significant predictors of female mate choice, while male and female identity was not. These results support a model of mate choice based on genetic compatibility while contradicting predictions based on ‘good genes’, Fisherian selection and sensory bias. Female mate choice in zebrafish may use olfactory cues associated with MHC dissimilarity.


  • Open Access

    The depressed river mussel Pseudanodonta complanata as an occasional host for the European bitterling Rhodeus amarus

    by Dariusz Halabowski, Martin Reichard, Kacper Pyrzanowski, Grzegorz Zięba, Joanna Grabowska, Carl Smith, Mirosław Przybylski

    This study explores the utilisation of European freshwater mussels as hosts by the European bitterling (Rhodeus amarus) at their current sympatric occurrence range. Our study confirms Pseudanodonta complanata as a suitable, occasional host for bitterling. The spawning relationship of R. amarus with freshwater mussels has physiological costs for the hosts, leading to resource competition and potential negative effects on host fertility. Further research is needed to assess the dynamics of host-parasite interactions, mussel adaptations to prevent parasitism, and the consequences of the bitterling recent and possible future expansion in Europe for mussel populations.