JKJudith Künneke

Judith Künneke

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Judith Künneke has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Promotion Decisions and the Adoption of Explicit Potential Assessment

    by Isabella Grabner, Judith Künneke, Frank Moers

    In this study, we leverage the transformation of a performance management system that shifts from only providing a performance rating to also providing an explicit assessment of potential. Although performance measures enable organizations to evaluate an employee’s past performance, they provide limited information regarding the employee’s potential to perform in a prospective job that requires a different skill set. Consequently, firms are gradually moving toward the incorporation of explicit potential assessments in their annual appraisal process to evaluate the employee’s promotability to a different task environment. Our data access allows us to provide evidence on the consequences of implementing a performance management system that adopted the explicit assessment of potential. We find that, on average, the performance of promoted employees is lower after implementation, suggesting that the potential assessment system is less effective in identifying candidates suitable for promotion. Additional analyses lead us to conclude that the difficulty of evaluating employee potential reduces performance upon promotion because of inaccurate recommendations of supervisors who do not sufficiently differentiate in their ratings. We thus identify variation in supervisors’ evaluation quality as an important source of the Peter Principle. This paper was accepted by Ranjani Krishnan, accounting. Supplemental Material: The online appendices and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.02199 .


  • Supervisor Impact on Employee Careers: The Role of Rating Differentiation

    by Judith Künneke

    Organizations invest heavily in supervision to increase the competitive advantage of their human capital. Although recent studies show that supervisors add value in general, it is not well understood what specific supervisory behaviors are relevant for employee career outcomes. To that end, this study explores the performance evaluation process and focuses on supervisors’ evaluation behavior. Interpreting a supervisor’s tendency to differentiate as a way of advancing employee development, I provide theory-consistent evidence revealing the relevance of differentiation for employee career outcomes. Using proprietary archival data, I demonstrate that differentiation relates positively to employees (1) performing more successfully in a new position upon promotion, (2) receiving a promotion to the next position, and (3) remaining in the organization. Therefore, this study presents novel and relevant evidence on the importance of specific supervisory behaviors in establishing effective human capital management practices.


  • Open Access

    Tacit Knowledge, Audit Quality, and Talent Identification

    by Isabella Grabner, Judith Künneke, Frank Moers

    The accounting literature has recently transitioned from the focus on client- or audit firm-level characteristics and their relation with audit quality to the inclusion of audit partner and team effects in audit quality. We extend this literature by studying whether tacit knowledge is a relevant factor in achieving high audit quality. Using survey measures and unique proprietary data of a Big 4 firm, we find evidence that the engagement partners’ level of tacit knowledge explains variation in audit quality as defined by the firm’s internal assessment of audit quality. Given its value-creating character, we subsequently examine whether tacit knowledge is a criterion that is incorporated in the talent identification process. We find that tacit knowledge is largely ignored or even negatively correlated with the firm’s assessment of potential, which likely provides an explanation for the loss of talent in professional audit firms.


  • Open Access

    How Calibration Committees Can Mitigate Performance Evaluation Bias: An Analysis of Implicit Incentives

    by Isabella Grabner, Judith Künneke, Frank Moers

    While prior research on performance evaluation bias has mainly focused on the determinants and consequences of rating errors, we investigate how a firm can provide implicit incentives to supervisors to mitigate these errors via its calibration committee. We empirically examine the extent to which a calibration committee incorporates supervisors' evaluation behavior with respect to their subordinates in the performance evaluation outcomes, i.e., performance ratings and promotion decisions, for these supervisors. In our study, we distinguish between lack of skills and opportunism as two important facets of evaluation behavior, which we expect the calibration committee to address differently. Using panel data of a professional service firm, we show that supervisors' opportunistic behavior to strategically inflate subordinates' performance ratings is disciplined through a decrease in the supervisors' own performance rating, while the supervisors' skills to provide less compressed and, thus, more informative performance ratings is rewarded through a higher likelihood of promotion.


  • Open Access

    Nourishing the Potential Pipeline: The Role of Supervisors’ Performance Management Skills in Career Outcomes of Future Leaders

    by Judith Künneke

    Supervisors are the linking pin between the organization and its employees, and therefore play an important role for organizational performance and success. Prior literature often considers the link between supervisors and employee performance in their current job. However, the attention is shifting towards potential management, and supervisors are increasingly responsible for the development of their employees’ potential and the guidance to a successful future career in the organization. Hence, this study provides the first empirical evidence on the role of the supervisor in employee potential development and retention. Using a theory-based measure of performance management skills, I demonstrate that employees of supervisors who are high in performance management skills have (1) a higher likelihood of promotion, (2) better performance in their new job upon promotion, and (3) are more likely to stay with the organization.

  • Open Access

    FAR Research Project: The loss of talent: a threat for audit quality?

    by Isabella Grabner, Judith Künneke, Frank Moers

    The main priority of the audit industry is to maintain and improve audit quality. While audit quality has been an important topic in both accounting academia and practice, there is still a lack of understanding of what drives audit quality. Given that people are the most valuable asset an audit firm has, we focus on examining the labor inputs as a driver of audit quality. Specifically, we argue that a key threat for audit quality that so far has been largely neglected is the loss of talent across the hierarchy. A well-known problem for audit firms is that they invest enormous resources in new professionals only to have many with talent leave (Patten, 1995; Vera-Muñoz, Ho & Chow, 2006; ACCA & ACRA, 2012). A recent survey by the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants finds that only about 38% are satisfied with their career and only 35% plan to stay beyond three years, with no significant differences across Big 4 and midtier firms (ACCA & ACRA, 2012).


  • Open Access

    The Roles of Supervisors within the Organization: Evidence on Supervisor Responsibilities and Effectiveness from a Management Control Perspective

    by Judith Künneke

    This paper investigates the role of the supervisor from a performance management and control perspective. This investigation has two parts: (1) who to select as supervisor and (2) does the supervisor actually have an impact on subordinate performance. As many organizations have a structured supervision program in place that aims at developing employees, it is important to understand the determinants of the eligibility to act as supervisor. Therefore, I examine which competencies influence the likelihood of receiving the responsibilities and tasks that come with the supervisory role. I hypothesize that soft skills increase the employee’s likelihood of becoming a supervisor as these are necessary to effectively communicate and transfer knowledge to subordinates. Next, I investigate if and to what extent the expected benefits from supervision are actually realized by the subordinates. The effectiveness of such supervision programs are especially important as knowledge and skills have to be passed on to the next generation of employees. Hence, I predict that the supervisors’ ability and effort is a crucial factor that positively influences the performance of their subordinates. In addition, I identify a measure specifically capturing supervisor counselling ability, which enhance the transfer of the supervisor’s general knowledge and skills. Using proprietary data from an international professional service provider, I find evidence confirming my predictions.