JGJane Goudge

Jane Goudge

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Jane Goudge has a total of 215 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Exploring Factors Associated With the Stalled Implementation of a Ground-Up Electronic Health Record System in South Africa: Qualitative Insights From the E-Tick Case Study Using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR)

    by Campion Zharima, Frances Griffiths, Jane Goudge

    Background: Electronic health records (EHRs) have the potential to improve service delivery through record keeping and monitoring health outcomes. As countries move toward universal health coverage, digital health tools such as EHRs are essential for achieving this goal. However, EHR implementation in middle-income countries like South Africa faces obstacles. Objective: This study explores the reasons behind a stalled implementation of the electronic tick register (E-tick) system (an electronic version of a paper primary health care register to record services provided), using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research. Methods: Using a qualitative design, in-depth interviews were conducted with 38 participants to explore their perceptions and experiences, and the factors surrounding the success and stalling of E-ticks. Participants included managers, stakeholders, implementers, and end users from the 3 implementation clinics. Data was collected using semistructured interview guides. The Thematic and Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research framework analysis (innovation, inner setting, individual characteristics, implementation process, and outer setting) was applied. Results: The E-tick system was designed to improve data quality in paper health registers, addressing inaccuracies in reporting to district and provincial health departments (Innovation domain). Implementers iteratively developed the system through user input from managers and clinicians, and stakeholder engagement of software developers, funders, health managers, and decision-makers from the provincial health department (individual characteristics). Although the system was initially well adopted by end users, it stalled primarily due to outer setting factors, which included a change of developers, funding cuts, and limited support at the provincial health department level due to capacity gaps, political appointments, and mistrust stemming from corruption and abuse of the tender system. Moreover, resistance to leveraging lessons from locally developed small-scale systems further constrained institutional support for the E-tick. Conclusions: Although successful implementation of EHRs can be facilitated by strong user engagement and co-design, outer setting factors such as governance, funding, and policy alignment can pose significant threats to sustainability. This underscores the importance of effective synergy between top-down and bottom-up processes for successful implementation.


  • Open Access

    “ They need to feel at home not in a home. ” Experiences of residents and carers in mental health residential facilities: In-depth case studies from the Sedibeng district, South Africa

    by Samantha Mhlanga, Frances Griffiths, Lesley Robertson, Jane Goudge

    Background: Since the 1990s, the relocation of psychiatric patients from long-stay institutions to community-based supported living has increased globally. However, most evidence on suitable residential services comes from high-income countries, with little from low- and middle-income contexts. This study explored the experiences of residents and carers in three residential care homes for people living with serious mental illness in Sedibeng District, South Africa. Methods: Three organisations were purposefully selected as in-depth case studies. Ninety-one face-to-face qualitative interviews were conducted with service providers, residents, and family members between October 2022 and June 2023. Findings: Residents described severe psychosocial disability when living with families, but improved functioning in residential homes. Organisations 1 and 3 operated small 3–4-roomed houses in township areas, accommodating 21 and 40 residents respectively, who had community access and social interaction. In Organisation 3, residents formed romantic relationships, undertook paid work, and lived semi-independently. Organisation 2, a repurposed school-like building with four large dormitories for 86 residents, imposed strict movement controls; medication was used to manage behaviour, and caregivers reported safety concerns. Conclusions: Smaller residential homes offer more autonomy and integration than large dormitory-style facilities. Policies and funding should support smaller, community-based supported accommodation for people with serious mental illness.


  • Open Access

    Healthcare providers’ experiences of community-based collaborative care for serious mental illness: a qualitative study in two integrated clinics in South Africa

    by Saira Abdulla, Lesley Robertson, Sherianne Kramer, Jane Goudge

    Community-based collaborative care (CBCC) is an internationally recognised model of integrated care that emphasises multidisciplinary teamwork and care coordination. In South Africa, community psychiatry has been integrated into some primary healthcare (PHC) facilities. This study examines healthcare providers’ perceptions of collaboration and its challenges in various integrated care settings. Three main components of CBCC (multidisciplinary teams, communication and case management) were explored through qualitative interviews with 29 staff members in 2 clinics. In Clinic-1, community psychiatry services operate independently in an outbuilding behind the main PHC clinic (“co-located”). In Clinic-2, these services are fully integrated within the PHC clinic (“physically integrated”). Both clinics had multidisciplinary teams, with various staff members conducting case management functions on an ad hoc basis. The physically integrated clinic (due to shared files, physical proximity and a facility manager with mental health experience) had greater levels of communication between the multidisciplinary team. In contrast, the co-located clinic struggled with poor management, unclear reporting structures and reinforced traditional hierarchies, limiting collaboration between the staff members. Integration does not guarantee collaboration. Improving collaboration between mental health and PHC staff requires clear roles, competent managers, CBCC endorsement from PHC clinicians, sufficient human resources and systematic communication channels, such as case review meetings.


  • Open Access

    Using a cash transfer plus SMS nudge package to improve the wellbeing among caregivers of adolescents living with HIV during the COVID-19 epidemic in South Africa: A pilot randomised controlled trial

    by Stanley Carries, Zibuyisile Mkhwanazi, Nokwanda Sithole, Lovemore Sigwadhi, Mosa Moshabela, Makandwe Nyirenda, Jane Goudge, Eugene Lee Davids, Darshini Govindasamy

    Caregivers of adolescents living with HIV encounter multiple economic and psycho-social challenges which impair their wellbeing and provision of optimal care. Cash transfers combined with short message service (SMS) nudges may address the financial and mental barriers to caregiver wellbeing in sub-Saharan Africa. We examined the preliminary effectiveness and feasibility outcomes of this multipronged approach for improving caregiver wellbeing. We piloted the Caregiver Wellbeing intervention in the eThekwini municipality, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Participants were randomly assigned to one of the following groups: (i) the intervention arm (n = 50) received three cash payments (of ZAR 350, approximately 21 USD), coupled with behaviourally-informed mobile SMS nudges over a 3-month period; (ii) the control arm (n = 50) received a standard SMS encouraging linkage to health services. The primary outcome was change in psychological wellbeing at four-months follow-up. Secondary outcomes were changes in depressive symptoms and caregiver burden scores, recruitment pace, retention, uptake, acceptability and costs. Trial Registraion Number: PACTR202203585402090. The n = 100 caregivers (mean age = 42.3 years, 87% female) enrolled at baseline were recruited within six weeks. Compared to controls, there was a non-significant increase in psychological wellbeing (β = 3.14, p = 0.319). There was a 1.32 unit (p = 0.085) decrease in depressive symptoms and a reduction in caregiver burden (β = -1.28, p = 0.020) in the intervention arm. Participant retention was 85%, with high intervention uptake (95%). Caregivers expressed appreciation for the intervention as the cash component allowed them to fulfil their carer responsibilities and the SMS brought a sense of belonging and self-acceptance. Total societal cost of the intervention was US$13,549, and the incremental cost per increase in wellbeing score was US$1,080. Results suggest a cash transfer plus SMS nudge package, whilst feasible and acceptable, may require longer duration and an economic empowerment component to enhance caregiver wellbeing as part of post-pandemic recovery efforts.


  • Open Access

    Licensing and regulation of the mental health residential care facilities: A case study from the Sedibeng district, South Africa

    by Samantha Mhlanga, Frances Griffiths, Lesley Robertson, Jane Goudge

    The World Health Organization advocates for the regulating of mental health accommodation services to ensure that they use a person-centered approach and promote human rights. However, many low-middle-income countries still face challenges that prevent them from delivering services according to such regulations. In this study, we explore the experiences of regulating mental health residential facilities in one district of South Africa. We conducted a qualitative study using in-depth interviews and observations from October 2022 to June 2023. Our participants were district governance and compliance team members, and managers, staff, residents and their families of three residential facilities. The governance team tried to ensure facilities complied with regulatory standards, assisting them where possible to meet those standards. Managers and family members understood that enforcing regulation will help improve service delivery. However, managers reported that some regulatory standards were more appropriate for hospitals than residential facilities. Facility staff felt neglected and undervalued by the governance team. Residents found the inspection process intrusive. Managers reported that their experience of providing residential services was undervalued in the regulatory process and that the funding for their facilities was insufficient for them to meet current standards. The governance team were aware there was a shortage of residential care facilities so had to decide which facilities to license even when they did not meet current standards. Current inspection, licensing and regulation of mental health residential facilities in South Africa is not yet fit for purpose and may hinder residents to achieve independency and quality of life. Involvement of service users and providers in mental health care planning may help align the licensing regulations to residential care services that are truly community-based.


  • Open Access

    Community-based Collaborative Care for Serious Mental Illness: A Rapid Qualitative Evidence Synthesis of Health Care Providers’ Experiences and Perspectives

    by Saira Abdulla, Sherianne Kramer, Lesley Robertson, Samantha Mhlanga, Campion Zharima, Jane Goudge

    Community-based collaborative care (CBCC) is an effective approach for addressing the needs of people with mental health conditions. However, even with the established components of CBCC in place, CBCCs effectiveness for serious mental illnesses (SMIs) remains unknown. This review aims to synthesize qualitative evidence of health care providers’ experiences of CBCC in order to identify key factors that facilitate or hinder collaboration in the specific context of SMIs. We searched databases to identify 3368 studies. The eligibility criteria included qualitative studies focusing on health care providers’ experiences in delivering a CBCC intervention for people with SMIs. Studies were included if they had at least 2 of 3 CBCC components: a multidisciplinary team, case management, and structured communication. Thematic analysis was used to synthesise the findings, and the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research framework was used to assess the quality of included studies. The protocol is registered on Prospero. Of the 19 studies included in our review, 5 had achieved collaboration, which was driven by several key ingredients: the availability of on-site case managers and psychiatrists, or the psychiatrists’ willingness to travel to the site; the psychiatrists’ efforts in actively engaging and supporting the CBCC team; the primary care clinicians’ willingness to collaborate with the team and reduce traditional hierarchical engagement; the team’s understanding of CBCC; and case managers with strong interpersonal and professional skills. The inclusion of CBCC components do not guarantee collaboration. The findings emphasise the importance of on-site mental health specialists, clearly defined roles, and proactive providers in achieving collaboration.


  • Open Access

    Do Integrated Community Psychiatry Services in Primary Health Care Settings Improve Continuity of Care? A Mixed-methods Study of Health Care Users’ Experiences in South Africa

    by Saira Abdulla, Lesley Robertson, Sherianne Kramer, Jane Goudge

    Background: A community psychiatry service is provided from selected primary health care (PHC) clinics in Gauteng, South Africa. This study described the demographic and clinical characteristics of health care users (HCUs), and explored HCUs’ experiences of these services in order to shed light on the challenges of integrating psychiatric services into PHC. Methods: A mixed-methods study was conducted at two PHC clinics, where 384 clinical records were reviewed and 23 HCUs were interviewed. In Clinic-1, community psychiatry services were co-located, while in Clinic-2, these services were physically integrated into the PHC clinic. Results: HCUs from both clinics were generally female (55%), had not completed secondary level education (65%), and were unemployed (80%). Both clinics struggled with medication stock-outs and had the same number of community psychiatry health care providers. Compared to the co-located clinic, the physically integrated clinic had insufficient consultation rooms (compromising confidentiality), higher caseloads (910 compared to 580), more HCUs with psychotic disorders (61% compared to 44%) and a history of missed medication (58% compared to 40%). In both clinics, overall care coordination was limited, although some nurses coordinated care for HCUs. While organisational integration approaches improved the proximity of mental health services, there were challenges in continuity of care within and across health care sites. Conclusion: Coordination and continuity of care were constrained in both clinics, regardless of the organisational integration approaches used. As low- and middle-income countries work towards integrating mental health care into PHC, the implementation of organisational integration approaches should consider physical space, caseload, HCU need, and the inclusion of dedicated providers to coordinate care.


  • Open Access

    Managing under austerity: a qualitative study of management–union relations during attempts to cut labour costs in three South African public hospitals

    by Thanduxolo Elford Fana, Jane Goudge

    Purpose: In this paper, the authors examine the strategies used to reduce labour costs in three public hospitals in South Africa, which were effective and why. In the democratic era, after the revelations of large-scale corruption, the authors ask whether their case studies provide lessons for how public service institutions might re-make themselves, under circumstances of austerity.Design/methodology/approach: A comparative qualitative case study approach, collecting data using a combination of interviews with managers, focus group discussions and interviews with shop stewards and staff was used.Findings: Management in two hospitals relied on their financial power, divisions between unions and employees' loyalty. They lacked the insight to manage different actors, and their efforts to outsource services and draw on the Extended Public Works Program failed. They failed to support staff when working beyond their scope of practice, reducing employees' willingness to take on extra responsibilities. In the remaining hospital, while previous management had been removed due to protests by the unions, the new CEO provided stability and union–management relations were collaborative. Her legitimate power enabled unions and management to agree on appropriate cost cutting strategies.Originality/value: Finding an appropriate balance between the new reality of reduced financial resources and the needs of staff and patients, requires competent unions and management, transparency and trust to develop legitimate power; managing in an authoritarian manner, without legitimate power, reduces organisational capacity. Ensuring a fair and orderly process to replace ineffective management is key, while South Africa grows cohorts of competent managers and builds managerial experience.


  • Open Access

    Service Users’ and Providers’ Experiences and Perceptions of Mental Health Accommodation Services: A Rapid Qualitative Synthesis of International Evidence

    by Samantha Mhlanga, Frances Griffiths, Campion Zharima, Lesley Robertson, Saira Abdulla, Jane Goudge

    Background. There is a high prevalence of homeless people with psychotic disorders and supported housing is often required. However, there is little evidence about supported housing services, especially in low‐middle income countries. This rapid review synthesizes evidence about the experiences of users and providers of community‐based accommodation services for people living with serious mental illness internationally to understand priorities for policy and practice. Methods. PubMed, PsycINFO, Google Scholar, and reference lists were searched to identify 1344 studies. The inclusion criteria specified qualitative studies about users’ and/or providers’ views of the accommodation services for adults aged 18+ years with serious mental illness. Title, abstract, and full‐text screening were conducted in duplicate, and quality appraisal was conducted using the standard for reporting qualitative research tool. Data extraction was conducted using both Excel and Word documents, and we used thematic analysis to report findings. Results. Only 43 studies were identified for inclusion. Service users’ and providers’ experiences of accommodation services from high income countries and low‐middle income countries were similar. Both the service providers and users appreciated housing, and service providers mentioned it was not a sufficient step towards independent living. Shortage of resources in low‐middle income countries made it challenging for some service providers to provide care because they had to choose between buying medicine or food. While service users needed greater availability of service providers, providers were at risk of burnout. Although some service providers were trained to respond to stigmatizing events, some users continued to experience stigma from their family members, society, and service providers. Conclusions. People living with serious mental illness and service providers value the housing provision but globally their experience of this provision is relatively poor compared to mainstream society, suggesting people living with serious mental illness remain disadvantaged. Further research should explore low‐cost housing options that will provide quality person‐centered care for people living with serious mental illness.


  • Open Access

    The Experiences of Strategic Purchasing of Healthcare in Nine Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Qualitative Review

    by Joshua Sumankuuro, Frances Griffiths, Adam D. Koon, Witness Mapanga, Beryl Maritim, Atiya Mosam, Jane Goudge

    Background: Efforts to move towards universal health coverage (UHC) aim to rebalance health financing in ways that increase efficiency, equity, and quality. Resource constraints require a shift from passive to strategic purchasing (SP). In this paper, we report on the experiences of SP in public sector health insurance schemes in nine middle-income countries to understand what extent SP has been established, the challenges and facilitators, and how it is helping countries achieve their UHC goals. Methods: We conducted a systematic search to identify papers on SP. Nine countries were selected for case study analysis. We extracted data from 129 articles. We used a common framework to compare the purchasing arrangements and key features in the different schemes. The evidence was synthesised qualitatively. Results: Five countries had health technology assessment (HTA) units to research what services to buy. Most schemes had reimbursement mechanisms that enabled some degree of cost control. However, we found evidenced-based changes to the reimbursement mechanisms only in Thailand and China. All countries have some form of mechanism for accreditation of health facilities, although there was considerable variation in what is done. All countries had some strategy for monitoring claims, but they vary in complexity and the extent of implementation; three countries have implemented e-claim processing enabling a greater level of monitoring. Only four countries had independent governance structures to provide oversight. We found delayed reimbursement (six countries), failure to provide services in the benefits package (four countries), and high out-of-pocket (OOP) payments in all countries except Thailand and Indonesia, suggesting the schemes were failing their members. Conclusion: We recommend investment in purchaser and research capacity and a focus on strong governance, including regular engagement between the purchaser, provider and citizens, to build trusting relationships to leverage the potential of SP more fully, and expand financial protection and progress towards UHC.