Allison Christians
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Allison Christians has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Samuel Singer
University of Ottawa
2 shared publications Tarcisio Diniz Magalhaes
McGill University - Faculty of Law
2 shared publicationsAlexander Ezenagu
McGill University, Faculty of Law, Students
1 shared publicationMarco Garofalo
McGill University, Faculty of Law, Students
1 shared publicationNicolas Benoît-Guay
B.C.L./LL.B., McGill University 2015 LL.M. McGill University, expected 2016
1 shared publicationTarcísio Diniz Magalhães
University of Antwerp Faculty of Law
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Policy Forum: The Role of Critical Questions in Tax Policy Analysis
This article explains what it means to ask critical tax questions, in order to show that critical tax studies are an essential component of good tax policy analysis. We demonstrate that, grounded in the three core tax policy principles of equity, neutrality, and simplicity, all tax policy analysis is critical by nature, and critical tax studies constitute no radical departure. By expressly reflecting upon whether and how a tax rule or tax regime affects people differently depending on their class, family structure, disability, race, gender, or sexual orientation, critical tax studies are instrumental in highlighting instances when these core tax policy principles are violated. Critical tax theory thus fosters rigorous tax policy analysis alongside analysis that focuses on doctrinal uncertainty, undesirable economic outcomes, and other topics. The article concludes that good tax policy discourse requires cultivating intellectual diversity, which necessitates asking critical tax questions.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessPolicy Forum: The Role of Critical Questions in Tax Policy Analysis
This article explains what it means to ask critical tax questions, in order to show that critical tax studies are an essential component of good tax policy analysis. We demonstrate that, grounded in the three core tax policy principles of equity, neutrality, and simplicity, all tax policy analysis is critical by nature, and critical tax studies constitute no radical departure. By expressly reflecting upon whether and how a tax rule or tax regime affects people differently depending on their class, family structure, disability, race, gender, or sexual orientation, critical tax studies are instrumental in highlighting instances when these core tax policy principles are violated. Critical tax theory thus fosters rigorous tax policy analysis alongside analysis that focuses on doctrinal uncertainty, undesirable economic outcomes, and other topics. The article concludes that good tax policy discourse requires cultivating intellectual diversity, which necessitates asking critical tax questions.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
The Case for Fixing the Unprincipled Residence Tax Exemption
When Canada overhauled its income tax to include capital gains in 1972, lawmakers suddenly had to decide how to deal with personal home sales. After heated debate, they opted to exclude the gains on an individual's principal residence on the grounds that the core purpose of a home is to provide "basic shelter" for its owneroccupants. This tax exemption has since become one of Canada's most significant tax shelters, and now amounts to one of Canada's largest tax subsidies to individuals. Along the way, it has created economic distortions, administrative challenges, and inequitable distributive outcomes. While lawmakers have occasionally considered how to curtail the misuse of the exemption, none have been brave enough to consider a path to unsheltering such gains, even in part. In this article we examine why Canada continues to over-subsidize home ownership through the tax system, assess the merits of that choice using tax policy criteria, and examine the alternatives that might be available to achieve the ostensible objectives.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessThe Case for Fixing the Unprincipled Residence Tax Exemption
When Canada overhauled its income tax to include capital gains in 1972, lawmakers suddenly had to decide how to deal with personal home sales. After heated debate, they opted to exclude the gains on an individual's principal residence on the grounds that the core purpose of a home is to provide "basic shelter" for its owneroccupants. This tax exemption has since become one of Canada's most significant tax shelters, and now amounts to one of Canada's largest tax subsidies to individuals. Along the way, it has created economic distortions, administrative challenges, and inequitable distributive outcomes. While lawmakers have occasionally considered how to curtail the misuse of the exemption, none have been brave enough to consider a path to unsheltering such gains, even in part. In this article we examine why Canada continues to over-subsidize home ownership through the tax system, assess the merits of that choice using tax policy criteria, and examine the alternatives that might be available to achieve the ostensible objectives.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Law Open
- Vol. 3 (4) , 939-961
Taxing data when the United States disagrees
What is the best way to tax data-driven business models without contravening the existing global quasi-constitutionalist order on tax, trade, and investment law? A number of countries in Europe and around the world have begun imposing standalone digital services taxes pending multilateral agreement on a coordinated reform of bilateral income tax treaties (aka the OECD-G20/Inclusive Framework’s ‘Pillar 1’). But if Pillar 1 fails to materialise and countries go forward with unilateral digital services taxes, the United States and U.S. firms will likely seek redress using domestic measures as well as trade and investment treaties where applicable. This Article argues that in the face of such U.S. resistance, EU member states and countries elsewhere ought to reconsider using the income tax system to achieve their goals instead. We first review the events that led countries to avoid the income tax in favour of standalone taxes only to become embroiled in domestic U.S. trade policies. We then explain how European and other source jurisdictions for business services related to data collection, mining, and commercialisation could revisit the income tax to get to the same tax base, namely by taking an ambulatory interpretation approach to provisions in existing tax treaties in a way that renders possible to accommodate withholding taxes on those services. We show that an ambulatory interpretation approach could achieve the underlying goals of taxing data-driven businesses, in some cases even without any domestic law or treaty reform, with treaty-based rules for dispute resolution a ready tool to draw upon if and when the United States disagrees.
- 1 December 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Law Open
- Vol. 3 (4) , 939-961
Open AccessTaxing data when the United States disagrees
What is the best way to tax data-driven business models without contravening the existing global quasi-constitutionalist order on tax, trade, and investment law? A number of countries in Europe and around the world have begun imposing standalone digital services taxes pending multilateral agreement on a coordinated reform of bilateral income tax treaties (aka the OECD-G20/Inclusive Framework’s ‘Pillar 1’). But if Pillar 1 fails to materialise and countries go forward with unilateral digital services taxes, the United States and U.S. firms will likely seek redress using domestic measures as well as trade and investment treaties where applicable. This Article argues that in the face of such U.S. resistance, EU member states and countries elsewhere ought to reconsider using the income tax system to achieve their goals instead. We first review the events that led countries to avoid the income tax in favour of standalone taxes only to become embroiled in domestic U.S. trade policies. We then explain how European and other source jurisdictions for business services related to data collection, mining, and commercialisation could revisit the income tax to get to the same tax base, namely by taking an ambulatory interpretation approach to provisions in existing tax treaties in a way that renders possible to accommodate withholding taxes on those services. We show that an ambulatory interpretation approach could achieve the underlying goals of taxing data-driven businesses, in some cases even without any domestic law or treaty reform, with treaty-based rules for dispute resolution a ready tool to draw upon if and when the United States disagrees.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Global Tax Reform and Mythical International Law
Over the past several years, governments around the world have been debating how to design coordinated minimum taxes on large multinationals in a bid to end race-to-the-bottom global tax competition. The plans so far have been complex and intricate, but in virtually all respects the evolution of ideas has followed well-worn practices and approaches in tax and corporate law. Nevertheless, outspoken critics have emerged with arguments against change that are grounded in abstract and often ill-defined international law concepts—effectively, a mythology of general and/or customary norms meant to forestall forward momentum and cast doubt on the fundamental workability of global tax reform as it has been collaboratively developed to date. This Article examines the myths of international tax law and demonstrates that each purported impediment is either conceptually under-theorized or exaggerated in legal impact or both. While noting that the minimum tax initiative as it has progressed is flawed, the Article argues that the mythical international law norms offered by critics do nothing toward achieving improvements but only seek to undermine the underlying goals of the initiative as a whole. To the extent curbing base erosion and profit shifting by the largest corporations would bring about a more stable and mutually acceptable world order, the use of mythological international law to forestall reform should be abandoned in favor of cooperative problem-solving.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessGlobal Tax Reform and Mythical International Law
Over the past several years, governments around the world have been debating how to design coordinated minimum taxes on large multinationals in a bid to end race-to-the-bottom global tax competition. The plans so far have been complex and intricate, but in virtually all respects the evolution of ideas has followed well-worn practices and approaches in tax and corporate law. Nevertheless, outspoken critics have emerged with arguments against change that are grounded in abstract and often ill-defined international law concepts—effectively, a mythology of general and/or customary norms meant to forestall forward momentum and cast doubt on the fundamental workability of global tax reform as it has been collaboratively developed to date. This Article examines the myths of international tax law and demonstrates that each purported impediment is either conceptually under-theorized or exaggerated in legal impact or both. While noting that the minimum tax initiative as it has progressed is flawed, the Article argues that the mythical international law norms offered by critics do nothing toward achieving improvements but only seek to undermine the underlying goals of the initiative as a whole. To the extent curbing base erosion and profit shifting by the largest corporations would bring about a more stable and mutually acceptable world order, the use of mythological international law to forestall reform should be abandoned in favor of cooperative problem-solving.
- Open Access
- 26 June 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Rethinking Tax for the Digital Economy After COVID-19
Before COVID-19 arrived, policymakers from around the world were busy working on the makings of a new global tax consensus to reflect structural changes in the world economy as a result of the rise of digitalization. COVID-19 disrupted this process by delivering a shock that resulted in major contractions for most firms even as it created enormous windfalls for others, prompting some to call for excess profits taxes, usually associated with wartime economies, as a corrective. Yet the contemporary context for excess profits taxes is fundamentally global today, in a way that excess profit taxation during the world war period was not. As such, to effectively address the fiscal crisis brought on by COVID-19, the world needs a “global excess profits tax”—a GEP tax. This article argues that the vocabulary, the technical tools, and the political determination that were being built for the digital economy can and should be adapted to formulate a GEP tax. We examine the elements of such a tax and demonstrate its compatibility with currently evolving thinking about what creates profit and where.
- 26 June 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessRethinking Tax for the Digital Economy After COVID-19
Before COVID-19 arrived, policymakers from around the world were busy working on the makings of a new global tax consensus to reflect structural changes in the world economy as a result of the rise of digitalization. COVID-19 disrupted this process by delivering a shock that resulted in major contractions for most firms even as it created enormous windfalls for others, prompting some to call for excess profits taxes, usually associated with wartime economies, as a corrective. Yet the contemporary context for excess profits taxes is fundamentally global today, in a way that excess profit taxation during the world war period was not. As such, to effectively address the fiscal crisis brought on by COVID-19, the world needs a “global excess profits tax”—a GEP tax. This article argues that the vocabulary, the technical tools, and the political determination that were being built for the digital economy can and should be adapted to formulate a GEP tax. We examine the elements of such a tax and demonstrate its compatibility with currently evolving thinking about what creates profit and where.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Canada’s Experience with the ICAP
As tax administrations around the world continue to reform international tax rules to promote transparency and address the challenges of aggressive tax avoidance, base erosion and profit shifting, and the digitalisation of the economy, multinational taxpayers are increasingly expressing concerns about a rise in compliance costs and risks of double taxation. To tackle these issues, Canada has, in the past years, implemented a series of administrative policies and initiatives of voluntary co-operation, aimed at increasing disclosure by large corporations for better compliance, while reducing risks. This chapter, developed by consultation with competent authorities from Canada Revenue Agency’s International and Large Business Directorate, focuses on Canada's involvement in the OECD’s new pilot project for co-operative compliance: the International Compliance Assurance Programme (ICAP). It concludes that one of the ICAP's impacts will be to allow states to gain insight into the approaches, and anticipate the likely revenue positions, of their peers.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessCanada’s Experience with the ICAP
As tax administrations around the world continue to reform international tax rules to promote transparency and address the challenges of aggressive tax avoidance, base erosion and profit shifting, and the digitalisation of the economy, multinational taxpayers are increasingly expressing concerns about a rise in compliance costs and risks of double taxation. To tackle these issues, Canada has, in the past years, implemented a series of administrative policies and initiatives of voluntary co-operation, aimed at increasing disclosure by large corporations for better compliance, while reducing risks. This chapter, developed by consultation with competent authorities from Canada Revenue Agency’s International and Large Business Directorate, focuses on Canada's involvement in the OECD’s new pilot project for co-operative compliance: the International Compliance Assurance Programme (ICAP). It concludes that one of the ICAP's impacts will be to allow states to gain insight into the approaches, and anticipate the likely revenue positions, of their peers.
- 30 November 2018
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Tax justice as social licence: the Fair Tax Mark
Tax justice advocates have spent the past decade building public consciousness about the tax planning practices of financial elites and large MNCs. An important recent development in this campaign was the establishment, in the UK in 2014, of the Fair Tax Mark. The Fair Tax Mark, modelled on the success of the ‘fair trade’ initiative, is a rules-based ethical consumption standard designed to influence firm and consumer behaviour and promote increased corporate transparency. This makes the Fair Tax Mark an emergent quasi-legal regime that has the potential to reach well beyond the UK, with repercussions for consumers, firms and governments around the world. It is thus important to understand not only what the Fair Tax Mark is in terms of the ‘rules’ that make it a quasi-legal regime, but also how it might function as both a quasi-legal tax regime and a strategy for influencing consumer and corporate behaviour. This chapter argues that the creators of the Fair Tax Mark have taken an important step beyond straightforward issue advocacy, developing an alternative tax standard based on their own conceptions of justice. They have done this by creating an independent set of acceptable parameters for tax planning and compliance, defined and measured by a point system that reduces taxpayer behaviour to an observable, quantitative measure.
- 30 November 2018
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Tax justice as social licence: the Fair Tax Mark
Tax justice advocates have spent the past decade building public consciousness about the tax planning practices of financial elites and large MNCs. An important recent development in this campaign was the establishment, in the UK in 2014, of the Fair Tax Mark. The Fair Tax Mark, modelled on the success of the ‘fair trade’ initiative, is a rules-based ethical consumption standard designed to influence firm and consumer behaviour and promote increased corporate transparency. This makes the Fair Tax Mark an emergent quasi-legal regime that has the potential to reach well beyond the UK, with repercussions for consumers, firms and governments around the world. It is thus important to understand not only what the Fair Tax Mark is in terms of the ‘rules’ that make it a quasi-legal regime, but also how it might function as both a quasi-legal tax regime and a strategy for influencing consumer and corporate behaviour. This chapter argues that the creators of the Fair Tax Mark have taken an important step beyond straightforward issue advocacy, developing an alternative tax standard based on their own conceptions of justice. They have done this by creating an independent set of acceptable parameters for tax planning and compliance, defined and measured by a point system that reduces taxpayer behaviour to an observable, quantitative measure.
- 1 November 2017
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 506-507
III.69 The Importance of Tax in International Economic Law
- 1 November 2017
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 506-507
III.69 The Importance of Tax in International Economic Law
- 1 November 2017
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 112
I.50 International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) Commission on Taxation
- 1 November 2017
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 112
I.50 International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) Commission on Taxation
- 1 November 2017
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
- p. 111-112
I.49 Group of Twenty (Rolein Tax)