CMCalil Makhoul

Calil Makhoul

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Calil Makhoul has a total of 42 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Distinguishing thermally altered bones from debris using imaging and fluorescence spectrometry

    by Maria Beatriz Barreiro, Maria Teresa Ferreira, Calil Makhoul, Miguel Morgado


  • Chemosteometric regression models of heat exposed human bones to determine their pre‐burnt metric dimensions

    by David Gonçalves, Ana R. Vassalo, Calil Makhoul, Giampaolo Piga, Adriana P. Mamede, Stewart F. Parker, Maria T. Ferreira, Eugenia Cunha, Maria P. M. Marques, Luís A. E. Batista de Carvalho

    Objectives: Heat exposure can lead to apparently random osteometric changes that hinder the application of metric methods used for biological profiling. The impracticality of using objective and burn‐specific osteometric methods reduces the chances of establishing the biological profiles of unknown individuals based on their skeletal remains. We investigated the potential of chemometry analysis based on infrared spectroscopy to predict the amount of heat‐induced osteometric changes and how this reflected into sex estimation. Material and methods: Bones from 41 identified adult skeletons (24 females and 17 males with ages between 62 and 90 years old) were experimentally burnt to maximum temperatures ranging from 450°C to 1,100°C (attained after 65 to 240 min). Measurements were taken both before and after each experiment and powder samples were analyzed through FTIR‐ATR. Correlations among heat‐induced metric changes and chemometric indices (crystallinity index; B‐type carbonates; carbonate [A + B] to carbonate B ratio; hydroxyl to phosphate ratio; 630 cm −1 , 1450 cm −1 , 3572 cm −1 , and 3642 cm −1 ) were tested. Significant variables were used to build regression models to predict heat‐induced metric change which were then tested on an independent set of samples. Agreement in sex estimation between the pre‐ and post‐burnt samples was also evaluated. Results: All indices were significantly correlated to heat‐induced metric changes ( α = .01) and the highest correlations were obtained for the 630 cm −1 , 3572 cm −1 , and crystallinity index. We confirmed that regression models based on chemometrics obtained from infrared spectra through FTIR‐ATR are better at estimating heat‐induced metric changes affecting bone and at sexing remains than other osteometric methods such as those based on correction factors or on metric references specific to calcined bones. Discussion: Regression models avoid the subjectivity associated with the application of other methods. While the latter can be applied only to calcined bones, which is difficult to assess sometimes, regression models can be applied to all bones regardless of their condition. Also, regression models have the advantage of allowing to infer about heat‐induced metric change on a case‐by‐case basis.


  • Preliminary results of an investigation on postmortem variations in human skeletal mass of buried bones

    by Ana Amarante, Maria Teresa Ferreira, Calil Makhoul, Ana Rita Vassalo, Eugénia Cunha, David Gonçalves


  • Open Access

    Heat-induced Bone Diagenesis Probed by Vibrational Spectroscopy

    by M. P. M. Marques, A. P. Mamede, A. R. Vassalo, C. Makhoul, E. Cunha, D. Gonçalves, S. F. Parker, L. A. E. Batista de Carvalho

    Complementary vibrational spectroscopic techniques – infrared, Raman and inelastic neutron scattering (INS) – were applied to the study of human bone burned under controlled conditions (400 to 1000 °C). This is an innovative way of tackling bone diagenesis upon burning, aiming at a quantitative evaluation of heat-induced dimensional changes allowing a reliable estimation of pre-burning skeletal dimensions. INS results allowed the concomitant observation of the hydroxyl libration (OHlibration), hydroxyl stretching (ν(OH)) and (OHlibration + ν(OH)) combination modes, leading to an unambiguous assignment of these INS features to bioapatite and confirming hydroxylation of bone’s inorganic matrix. The OHlib, ν(OH) and ν4(PO43−) bands were identified as spectral biomarkers, which displayed clear quantitative relationships with temperature revealing heat-induced changes in bone’s H-bonding pattern during the burning process. These results will enable the routine use of FTIR-ATR (Fourier Transform Infrared-Attenuated Total Reflectance) for the analysis of burned skeletal remains, which will be of the utmost significance in forensic, bioanthropological and archaeological contexts.


  • Open Access

    β-Tricalcium Phosphate Interferes with the Assessment of Crystallinity in Burned Skeletal Remains

    by Giampaolo Piga, Ana Amarante, Calil Makhoul, Eugénia Cunha, Assumpció Malgosa, Stefano Enzo, David Gonçalves

    The analysis of burned remains is a highly complex process, and a better insight can be gained with advanced technologies. The main goal of this paper is to apply X-ray diffraction, partially supported by infrared attenuated total reflectance spectroscopy to determine changes in burned human bones and teeth in terms of mineral phase transformations. Samples of 36 bones and 12 teeth were heated at 1050°C and afterwards subjected to XRD and ATR-IR. The crystallinity index was calculated for every sample. A quantitative evaluation of phases was documented by using the Rietveld approach. In addition to bioapatite, the following mineralogical phases were found in the bone: β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) (Ca3(PO4)2), lime (CaO), portlandite (Ca(OH)2), calcite (CaCO3), and buchwaldite (NaCaPO4). In the case of bone, besides bioapatite, only the first two mineralogical phases and magnesium oxide were present. We also observed that the formation of β-TCP affects the phosphate peaks used for CI calculation. Therefore, caution is needed when its occurrence and evaluation are carried out. This is an important warning for tracking heat-induced changes in human bone, in terms of physicochemical properties related to structure, which is expected to impact in forensic, bioanthropological, and archaeological contexts.


  • Crystal clear: Vibrational spectroscopy reveals intrabone, intraskeleton, and interskeleton variation in human bones

    by D. Gonçalves, A. R. Vassalo, A. P. Mamede, C. Makhoul, G. Piga, E. Cunha, M. P. M. Marques, L. A. E. Batista de Carvalho

    Objectives: Vibrational spectroscopy is a valuable tool for the study of burned skeletal remains. Nonetheless, most investigations have been focused on a limited number of samples as well as on faunal bones rather than human bones. Conclusions based on those investigations may lack representativeness, namely about the intrabone, intra‐ and interskeleton variability of several chemometric indices. We aimed to investigate this issue on a large sample of human bones.Material and Methods: Powder samples were collected from 168 bones from four human skeletons. The sampling targeted 47 long bones, 72 short bones, and 49 tarsal bones as well as different bone regions in a total of 638 powder samples. Bones were experimentally burned in an electric muffle furnace for two hours to maximum temperatures ranging from 400°C to 1000°C. Another 623 burned samples were then collected totaling 1261 samples subjected to FTIR‐ATR analysis. The CI, BPI, C/C, and OH/P indices were calculated.Results: An important intrabone, intra‐ and interskeleton variation was observed, especially for the BPI. The CI, C/C, and OH/P indices revealed much less variation so site‐specific sampling may not be as critical in these cases. Clear differences between our results and those from previous investigations were observed, namely on the temperature increment evolution of the CI and C/C indices.Discussion: The relatively large heterogeneity, especially at the intrabone level, is possibly the consequence of microstructural bone differences. The dissimilarities observed between our investigation and other published studies are probably due to the fact that the samples used here came from human rather than faunal bones. Also, our samples were buried previously to the experimental burning so this may also partly explain our contrasting results, since previous research was mostly performed on fresh bone. Future inferences based on vibrational spectroscopy analyses should take into account the possible effect of all these sources.


  • Dead weight: Validation of mass regression equations on experimentally burned skeletal remains to assess skeleton completeness

    by D. Gonçalves, J. D'OLiveira Coelho, A. Amarante, C. Makhoul, I. Oliveira-Santos, D. Navega, E. Cunha


  • Open Access

    Experimental burning and real fire scenarios: Are they comparable in terms of chemical anthropology?

    by Calil Makhoul, Ana Amarante, João D’oLiveira Coelho, David Navega, Miguel Almeida, Stewart F. Parker, Maria Teresa Ferreira, Domingos X. Viegas, M.P.M. Marques, Luís Batista de Carvalho, et al.


  • A structural approach in the study of bones: fossil and burnt bones at nanosize scale

    by Giampaolo Piga, Maria Dolors Baró, Irati Golvano Escobal, David Gonçalves, Calil Makhoul, Ana Amarante, Assumpció Malgosa, Stefano Enzo, Sebastiano Garroni