Alessia Gualandris
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Alessia Gualandris has a total of 193 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Simon Portegies Zwart
11 shared publications- Justin I. Read
Department of Physics, University of Surrey
9 shared publications - Simon Portegies Zwart
Astronomical Institute 'Anton Pannekoek' and Section Computational Science Amsterdam University Kruislaan 403 1098 SJ Amsterdam the Netherlands
9 shared publications - Walter Dehnen
Astronomisches Rechen-Institut, Zentrum für Astronomie der Universität Heidelberg, Mönchhofstraße 12-14, Heidelberg 69120, Germany
9 shared publications David Merritt
Rochester Institute of Technology
7 shared publications- Vasilii V. Gvaramadze
Sternberg Astronomical Institute, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Universitetskij Pr. 13, Moscow 119992, Russia
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Perturber-Driven Dynamics of Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Galaxy Mergers
The orbital eccentricity of massive black hole binaries (MBHBs) at binary formation shapes the stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) detectable by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). Previous N-body simulations show large run-to-run scatter in this quantity, dominated by Poisson noise, raising the question of whether physical substructure adds genuine astrophysical stochasticity. We test this with high-resolution re-simulations of a major merger from IllustrisTNG100-1, evolved with the Griffin N-body code. A no-perturber control is compared with two matched suites in which ftarget = 0.1 of the primary bulge mass is redistributed into equal-mass perturbers of $10^7{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ (μp ≈ 3.2 × 10−3) and $10^8{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ (μp ≈ 3.2 × 10−2), with four realisations per scenario. The control gives σe ≈ 0.11, consistent with the Poisson noise floor at this resolution. The $10^7{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case gives σe ≈ 0.115, indistinguishable from the control in its scatter, whereas the $10^8{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case gives σe ≈ 0.26, a factor of 2.4 above the floor, though statistically marginal given only four realisations. This excess scatter coincides with larger event-aligned residuals in orbital energy and angular momentum and stronger torque spikes, consistent with near-impulsive perturber–MBHB encounters. In binary–single scattering theory the transition is set by the perturber–MBHB mass ratio μp: the $10^7{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case remains diffusive while the $10^8{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case approaches the near-impulsive regime. As the expected perturber population in massive ellipticals lies mostly below this regime, perturber-driven eccentricity randomisation is unlikely to matter for GWB-relevant MBHB mergers.- 28 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Open AccessPerturber-Driven Dynamics of Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Galaxy Mergers
The orbital eccentricity of massive black hole binaries (MBHBs) at binary formation shapes the stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) detectable by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). Previous N-body simulations show large run-to-run scatter in this quantity, dominated by Poisson noise, raising the question of whether physical substructure adds genuine astrophysical stochasticity. We test this with high-resolution re-simulations of a major merger from IllustrisTNG100-1, evolved with the Griffin N-body code. A no-perturber control is compared with two matched suites in which ftarget = 0.1 of the primary bulge mass is redistributed into equal-mass perturbers of $10^7{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ (μp ≈ 3.2 × 10−3) and $10^8{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ (μp ≈ 3.2 × 10−2), with four realisations per scenario. The control gives σe ≈ 0.11, consistent with the Poisson noise floor at this resolution. The $10^7{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case gives σe ≈ 0.115, indistinguishable from the control in its scatter, whereas the $10^8{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case gives σe ≈ 0.26, a factor of 2.4 above the floor, though statistically marginal given only four realisations. This excess scatter coincides with larger event-aligned residuals in orbital energy and angular momentum and stronger torque spikes, consistent with near-impulsive perturber–MBHB encounters. In binary–single scattering theory the transition is set by the perturber–MBHB mass ratio μp: the $10^7{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case remains diffusive while the $10^8{\, \rm {M}_{\odot }}$ case approaches the near-impulsive regime. As the expected perturber population in massive ellipticals lies mostly below this regime, perturber-driven eccentricity randomisation is unlikely to matter for GWB-relevant MBHB mergers. - Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 551 (3)
Scaling relations for binary black hole merger times from cosmological initial conditions
Recent evidence from pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) for a nanohertz gravitational wave background is broadly consistent with theoretical expectations from a population of massive black hole binaries (MBHBs), although the inferred amplitude appears somewhat higher than predicted by standard models. Interpreting these observations requires a robust understanding of the merger time-scales of MBHBs, and of their connection to host galaxy properties. In this work, we investigate the evolution of MBHBs selected from cosmological galaxy mergers in the IllustrisTNG simulation. We re-simulate these systems at high resolution using the N-body code griffin to accurately resolve the dynamical friction and stellar hardening phases, and follow their evolution to coalescence with a semi-analytical model. We find that cosmological galaxy encounters and the resulting MBHBs are typically highly eccentric. We characterize the distribution of binary eccentricities at formation and at entry into the PTA band, and quantify the corresponding residence times. We identify the key parameters governing the duration of the different stages of MBHB evolution, and derive scaling relations linking galaxy and orbital properties to dynamical friction, hardening, and total coalescence times. These relations provide a framework for subgrid prescriptions in cosmological simulations. Applying these scaling relations to the full IllustrisTNG merger population, we infer the probability distributions of galaxy merger and black hole coalescence times. We find that galaxy mergers typically complete within $\sim 0.7$ Gyr, while the total black hole coalescence time is $\sim 1.0$ Gyr. These short time-scales imply efficient binary evolution, consistent with current PTA constraints.- 9 July 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 551 (3)
Open AccessScaling relations for binary black hole merger times from cosmological initial conditions
Recent evidence from pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) for a nanohertz gravitational wave background is broadly consistent with theoretical expectations from a population of massive black hole binaries (MBHBs), although the inferred amplitude appears somewhat higher than predicted by standard models. Interpreting these observations requires a robust understanding of the merger time-scales of MBHBs, and of their connection to host galaxy properties. In this work, we investigate the evolution of MBHBs selected from cosmological galaxy mergers in the IllustrisTNG simulation. We re-simulate these systems at high resolution using the N-body code griffin to accurately resolve the dynamical friction and stellar hardening phases, and follow their evolution to coalescence with a semi-analytical model. We find that cosmological galaxy encounters and the resulting MBHBs are typically highly eccentric. We characterize the distribution of binary eccentricities at formation and at entry into the PTA band, and quantify the corresponding residence times. We identify the key parameters governing the duration of the different stages of MBHB evolution, and derive scaling relations linking galaxy and orbital properties to dynamical friction, hardening, and total coalescence times. These relations provide a framework for subgrid prescriptions in cosmological simulations. Applying these scaling relations to the full IllustrisTNG merger population, we infer the probability distributions of galaxy merger and black hole coalescence times. We find that galaxy mergers typically complete within $\sim 0.7$ Gyr, while the total black hole coalescence time is $\sim 1.0$ Gyr. These short time-scales imply efficient binary evolution, consistent with current PTA constraints. - Open Access
- 6 February 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Continuous-Time Modelling of Black Hole Binary Evolution with Neural ODEs
Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) can detect the low-frequency stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) generated by an ensemble of supermassive black hole binaries (BHBs). Accurate determination of BHB merger timescales is essential for interpreting GWBs and constraining key astrophysical quantities such as black hole (BH) occupation fractions and galaxy coalescence rates. High-accuracy N-body codes such as Griffin can resolve sub-pc BHB dynamics but are too costly to explore a wide range of initial conditions, motivating the need for surrogate models that emulate their long-term evolution at much lower computational cost. We investigate neural ordinary differential equations (NODEs) as surrogates for the secular orbital evolution of BHBs. Our primary contribution is a parameterised NODE (PNODE) trained on an ensemble of N-body simulations of galaxy mergers spanning a two-dimensional parameter space defined by the initial orbital eccentricity and particle resolution (ei, N), with the learned vector field explicitly conditioned on these parameters. A single PNODE thereby learns a simulation-parameter-conditioned dynamical model for the coupled evolution of the BH pair’s orbital state across the ensemble, yielding smooth trajectories from which stable hardening and eccentricity growth rates can be extracted. The PNODE accurately reproduces the secular evolution of the specific orbital energy and angular momentum, and the corresponding Keplerian orbital elements, for held-out trajectories, with modest generalisation to a partially unseen high-resolution case. Combining PNODE predictions with semi-analytical prescriptions for stellar hardening and gravitational-wave emission yields BHB merger timescales consistent with those obtained from direct N-body inputs within current theoretical uncertainties.
- 6 February 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Open AccessContinuous-Time Modelling of Black Hole Binary Evolution with Neural ODEs
Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) can detect the low-frequency stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) generated by an ensemble of supermassive black hole binaries (BHBs). Accurate determination of BHB merger timescales is essential for interpreting GWBs and constraining key astrophysical quantities such as black hole (BH) occupation fractions and galaxy coalescence rates. High-accuracy N-body codes such as Griffin can resolve sub-pc BHB dynamics but are too costly to explore a wide range of initial conditions, motivating the need for surrogate models that emulate their long-term evolution at much lower computational cost. We investigate neural ordinary differential equations (NODEs) as surrogates for the secular orbital evolution of BHBs. Our primary contribution is a parameterised NODE (PNODE) trained on an ensemble of N-body simulations of galaxy mergers spanning a two-dimensional parameter space defined by the initial orbital eccentricity and particle resolution (ei, N), with the learned vector field explicitly conditioned on these parameters. A single PNODE thereby learns a simulation-parameter-conditioned dynamical model for the coupled evolution of the BH pair’s orbital state across the ensemble, yielding smooth trajectories from which stable hardening and eccentricity growth rates can be extracted. The PNODE accurately reproduces the secular evolution of the specific orbital energy and angular momentum, and the corresponding Keplerian orbital elements, for held-out trajectories, with modest generalisation to a partially unseen high-resolution case. Combining PNODE predictions with semi-analytical prescriptions for stellar hardening and gravitational-wave emission yields BHB merger timescales consistent with those obtained from direct N-body inputs within current theoretical uncertainties.
- Open Access
- 13 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 546 (1)
Converging on the eccentricity of massive black hole binaries in Galactic mergers
Binaries of supermassive black holes [massive black hole binaries (MBHBs)] represent the primary sources of the gravitational wave background (GWB) detectable by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). The eccentricity with which binaries form in galactic mergers is the key parameter determining their evolutionary time-scale from pairing to coalescence. However, accurately determining the binary eccentricity at formation is difficult in simulations due to stochastic effects. We present a numerical study of the formation and evolution of MBHBs that are potential PTA sources. We simulate mergers of equal-mass galaxies on different initial orbits and follow the dynamics of the MBHBs through the hardening phase. We find that low-resolution simulations are affected by stochasticity due to torques from the stellar distribution acting at pericentre passages. The dispersion in binary eccentricity decreases with increasing central resolution, as expected for a Poisson process. We provide a fitting formula for the resolution requirement of an N-body simulation of MBHB formation and evolution as a function of the initial eccentricity of the merger, $e_0$, and the required accuracy in the binary eccentricity, $e_{\mathrm{b}}$. We find that binaries experience a torque at first pericentre that is approximately independent of initial eccentricity, producing a general trend in which the binary eccentricity decreases above sufficiently large initial orbital eccentricities. While this behaviour is generic, the precise cross-over eccentricity ($e_0 \sim 0.97$ in our models) and the sharpness of the drop-off depend on the galaxy initial conditions. We provide a fitting formula for $e_{\mathrm{b}}(e_0)$ that can be used in semi-analytical models to determine the merger time-scales of MBHBs as well as the amplitude and slope of the GWB.- 13 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 546 (1)
Open AccessConverging on the eccentricity of massive black hole binaries in Galactic mergers
Binaries of supermassive black holes [massive black hole binaries (MBHBs)] represent the primary sources of the gravitational wave background (GWB) detectable by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). The eccentricity with which binaries form in galactic mergers is the key parameter determining their evolutionary time-scale from pairing to coalescence. However, accurately determining the binary eccentricity at formation is difficult in simulations due to stochastic effects. We present a numerical study of the formation and evolution of MBHBs that are potential PTA sources. We simulate mergers of equal-mass galaxies on different initial orbits and follow the dynamics of the MBHBs through the hardening phase. We find that low-resolution simulations are affected by stochasticity due to torques from the stellar distribution acting at pericentre passages. The dispersion in binary eccentricity decreases with increasing central resolution, as expected for a Poisson process. We provide a fitting formula for the resolution requirement of an N-body simulation of MBHB formation and evolution as a function of the initial eccentricity of the merger, $e_0$, and the required accuracy in the binary eccentricity, $e_{\mathrm{b}}$. We find that binaries experience a torque at first pericentre that is approximately independent of initial eccentricity, producing a general trend in which the binary eccentricity decreases above sufficiently large initial orbital eccentricities. While this behaviour is generic, the precise cross-over eccentricity ($e_0 \sim 0.97$ in our models) and the sharpness of the drop-off depend on the galaxy initial conditions. We provide a fitting formula for $e_{\mathrm{b}}(e_0)$ that can be used in semi-analytical models to determine the merger time-scales of MBHBs as well as the amplitude and slope of the GWB. - Open Access
Converging on the eccentricity of massive black hole binaries in galactic mergers
Binaries of supermassive black holes (MBHBs) represent the primary sources of the gravitational wave background (GWB) detectable by Pulsar Timing Arrays (PTAs). The eccentricity with which binaries form in galactic mergers is the key parameter determining their evolutionary timescale from pairing to coalescence. However, accurately determining the binary eccentricity at formation is difficult in simulations due to stochastic effects. We present a numerical study of the formation and evolution of MBHBs that are potential PTA sources. We simulate mergers of equal-mass galaxies on different initial orbits and follow the dynamics of the MBHBs through the hardening phase. We find that low-resolution simulations are affected by stochasticity due to torques from the stellar distribution acting at pericentre passages. The dispersion in binary eccentricity decreases with increasing central resolution, as expected for a Poisson process. We provide a fitting formula for the resolution requirement of an N-body simulation of MBHB formation and evolution as a function of the initial eccentricity of the merger, e0, and the required accuracy in the binary eccentricity, eb. We find that binaries experience a torque at first pericentre that is approximately independent of initial eccentricity, producing a general trend in which the binary eccentricity decreases above sufficiently large initial orbital eccentricities. While this behaviour is generic, the precise cross-over eccentricity (e0~0.97 in our models) and the sharpness of the drop-off depend on the galaxy initial conditions. We provide a fitting formula for eb(e0) that can be used in semi-analytical models to determine the merger timescales of MBHBs as well as the amplitude and slope of the GWB.
Open AccessConverging on the eccentricity of massive black hole binaries in galactic mergers
Binaries of supermassive black holes (MBHBs) represent the primary sources of the gravitational wave background (GWB) detectable by Pulsar Timing Arrays (PTAs). The eccentricity with which binaries form in galactic mergers is the key parameter determining their evolutionary timescale from pairing to coalescence. However, accurately determining the binary eccentricity at formation is difficult in simulations due to stochastic effects. We present a numerical study of the formation and evolution of MBHBs that are potential PTA sources. We simulate mergers of equal-mass galaxies on different initial orbits and follow the dynamics of the MBHBs through the hardening phase. We find that low-resolution simulations are affected by stochasticity due to torques from the stellar distribution acting at pericentre passages. The dispersion in binary eccentricity decreases with increasing central resolution, as expected for a Poisson process. We provide a fitting formula for the resolution requirement of an N-body simulation of MBHB formation and evolution as a function of the initial eccentricity of the merger, e0, and the required accuracy in the binary eccentricity, eb. We find that binaries experience a torque at first pericentre that is approximately independent of initial eccentricity, producing a general trend in which the binary eccentricity decreases above sufficiently large initial orbital eccentricities. While this behaviour is generic, the precise cross-over eccentricity (e0~0.97 in our models) and the sharpness of the drop-off depend on the galaxy initial conditions. We provide a fitting formula for eb(e0) that can be used in semi-analytical models to determine the merger timescales of MBHBs as well as the amplitude and slope of the GWB.
- Open Access
- 25 November 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 994 (2) , 177
Black Hole Dragging: A New Mechanism for Forming Nuclear Star Clusters in Giant Elliptical Galaxies
It has long been thought that nuclear star clusters (NSCs) cannot coexist with the most massive supermassive black holes (SMBHs), since SMBH mergers—unavoidable for the most massive systems—would scatter away NSC stars. However, central concentrations of light have now been reported in up to one-third of all massive ellipticals. We present a new mechanism for forming NSCs in giant elliptical galaxies, arising naturally from SMBH mergers, which could explain these observations. We call this “black hole dragging.” After a major merger of two galaxies and their SMBHs, the newly merged SMBH can receive a gravitational-wave recoil kick. We show that recoiling SMBHs induce two competing effects on the galaxy’s background stars. First, some stars become bound to the SMBH and comove with it, an effect strongest at low recoil velocities. Second, background stars are ejected as the recoiling SMBH falls back due to dynamical friction, an effect strongest at high recoil velocities. At intermediate recoil velocities (500–1000 km s −1 ), both effects become important, and the density of bound stars can exceed that of the background stellar core. This yields a central dense NSC that is clearly visible in the galaxy’s surface brightness profile. We show that NSCs formed in this way have realistic sizes, masses, and velocity dispersions when measured similarly to observed systems. This provides a route for even giant ellipticals containing SMBHs to host an NSC. We predict such NSCs should have indistinguishable colors, ages, and chemistry from non-NSC central stars, combined with low ellipticities.
- 25 November 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 994 (2) , 177
Open AccessBlack Hole Dragging: A New Mechanism for Forming Nuclear Star Clusters in Giant Elliptical Galaxies
It has long been thought that nuclear star clusters (NSCs) cannot coexist with the most massive supermassive black holes (SMBHs), since SMBH mergers—unavoidable for the most massive systems—would scatter away NSC stars. However, central concentrations of light have now been reported in up to one-third of all massive ellipticals. We present a new mechanism for forming NSCs in giant elliptical galaxies, arising naturally from SMBH mergers, which could explain these observations. We call this “black hole dragging.” After a major merger of two galaxies and their SMBHs, the newly merged SMBH can receive a gravitational-wave recoil kick. We show that recoiling SMBHs induce two competing effects on the galaxy’s background stars. First, some stars become bound to the SMBH and comove with it, an effect strongest at low recoil velocities. Second, background stars are ejected as the recoiling SMBH falls back due to dynamical friction, an effect strongest at high recoil velocities. At intermediate recoil velocities (500–1000 km s −1 ), both effects become important, and the density of bound stars can exceed that of the background stellar core. This yields a central dense NSC that is clearly visible in the galaxy’s surface brightness profile. We show that NSCs formed in this way have realistic sizes, masses, and velocity dispersions when measured similarly to observed systems. This provides a route for even giant ellipticals containing SMBHs to host an NSC. We predict such NSCs should have indistinguishable colors, ages, and chemistry from non-NSC central stars, combined with low ellipticities.
- Open Access
- 7 November 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 703, A86
Realistic consecutive galaxy mergers form eccentric pulsar timing array sources
Results from pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) show evidence of a gravitational wave background (GWB) consistent with a population of unresolved supermassive black hole binaries (BHBs). The observed spectrum shows a flattening at lower frequencies that can be explained by a population of eccentric BHBs. This study aims to determine the dynamical evolution and merger timescales of the most massive BHBs, which are potential sources of the GWB. We selected successive galactic major mergers from the IllustrisTNG100-1 cosmological simulation and re-simulated them at high resolution with the N -body code Griffin , down to binary separations of the order of a parsec. Coalescence timescales were estimated using a semi-analytical model that incorporates gravitational wave emission and stellar hardening. Throughout our investigation, we considered the impact of prior mergers on the remnant galaxy in the form of core scouring and anisotropy, which can influence the subsequent formation and evolution of BHBs. We find that all the binaries in our sample enter the PTA band with an eccentricity of e > 0.85: such a large eccentricity can impact the shape of the PTA observed GWB spectrum, and it highlights the importance of including the eccentricity of binaries when interpreting the PTA signal. Furthermore, we find that: (i) starting from initial separations of a few tens of kiloparsecs, the dynamical friction phase lasts for a few hundred million years; (ii) the binary formation time is not resolution-dependent; (iii) the scatter on the eccentricity at binary formation decreases with increasing resolution; and (iv) triple systems form whenever a third galaxy interacts with a binary that has not yet reached coalescence.
- 7 November 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 703, A86
Open AccessRealistic consecutive galaxy mergers form eccentric pulsar timing array sources
Results from pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) show evidence of a gravitational wave background (GWB) consistent with a population of unresolved supermassive black hole binaries (BHBs). The observed spectrum shows a flattening at lower frequencies that can be explained by a population of eccentric BHBs. This study aims to determine the dynamical evolution and merger timescales of the most massive BHBs, which are potential sources of the GWB. We selected successive galactic major mergers from the IllustrisTNG100-1 cosmological simulation and re-simulated them at high resolution with the N -body code Griffin , down to binary separations of the order of a parsec. Coalescence timescales were estimated using a semi-analytical model that incorporates gravitational wave emission and stellar hardening. Throughout our investigation, we considered the impact of prior mergers on the remnant galaxy in the form of core scouring and anisotropy, which can influence the subsequent formation and evolution of BHBs. We find that all the binaries in our sample enter the PTA band with an eccentricity of e > 0.85: such a large eccentricity can impact the shape of the PTA observed GWB spectrum, and it highlights the importance of including the eccentricity of binaries when interpreting the PTA signal. Furthermore, we find that: (i) starting from initial separations of a few tens of kiloparsecs, the dynamical friction phase lasts for a few hundred million years; (ii) the binary formation time is not resolution-dependent; (iii) the scatter on the eccentricity at binary formation decreases with increasing resolution; and (iv) triple systems form whenever a third galaxy interacts with a binary that has not yet reached coalescence.
- Open Access
Black hole dragging: a new mechanism for forming nuclear star clusters in giant elliptical galaxies
It has long been thought that nuclear star clusters (NSCs) cannot co-exist with the most massive supermassive black holes (SMBHs), since SMBH mergers - unavoidable for the most massive systems - would scatter away NSC stars. However, central concentrations of light have now been reported in up to a third of all massive ellipticals. We present a new mechanism for forming NSCs in giant elliptical galaxies, arising naturally from SMBH mergers, which could explain these observations. We call this ''black hole dragging''. After a major merger of two galaxies and their SMBHs, the newly-merged SMBH can receive a gravitational wave recoil kick. We show that recoiling SMBHs induce two competing effects on the galaxy's background stars. Firstly, some stars become bound to the SMBH and co-move with it, an effect strongest at low recoil velocities. Secondly, background stars are ejected as the recoiling SMBH falls back due to dynamical friction, an effect strongest at high recoil velocities. At intermediate recoil velocities (500-1000 km/s), both effects become important, and the density of bound stars can exceed that of the background stellar core. This yields a central dense NSC that is clearly visible in the galaxy's surface brightness profile. We show that NSCs formed in this way have realistic sizes, masses and velocity dispersions when measured similarly to observed systems. This provides a route for even giant ellipticals containing SMBHs to host an NSC. We predict such NSCs should have indistinguishable colors, ages and chemistry from non-NSC central stars, combined with low ellipticities.
Open AccessBlack hole dragging: a new mechanism for forming nuclear star clusters in giant elliptical galaxies
It has long been thought that nuclear star clusters (NSCs) cannot co-exist with the most massive supermassive black holes (SMBHs), since SMBH mergers - unavoidable for the most massive systems - would scatter away NSC stars. However, central concentrations of light have now been reported in up to a third of all massive ellipticals. We present a new mechanism for forming NSCs in giant elliptical galaxies, arising naturally from SMBH mergers, which could explain these observations. We call this ''black hole dragging''. After a major merger of two galaxies and their SMBHs, the newly-merged SMBH can receive a gravitational wave recoil kick. We show that recoiling SMBHs induce two competing effects on the galaxy's background stars. Firstly, some stars become bound to the SMBH and co-move with it, an effect strongest at low recoil velocities. Secondly, background stars are ejected as the recoiling SMBH falls back due to dynamical friction, an effect strongest at high recoil velocities. At intermediate recoil velocities (500-1000 km/s), both effects become important, and the density of bound stars can exceed that of the background stellar core. This yields a central dense NSC that is clearly visible in the galaxy's surface brightness profile. We show that NSCs formed in this way have realistic sizes, masses and velocity dispersions when measured similarly to observed systems. This provides a route for even giant ellipticals containing SMBHs to host an NSC. We predict such NSCs should have indistinguishable colors, ages and chemistry from non-NSC central stars, combined with low ellipticities.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 974 (2) , 204
Core Formation by Binary Scouring and Gravitational Wave Recoil in Massive Elliptical Galaxies
Scouring by supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries is the most accepted mechanism for the formation of the cores seen in giant elliptical galaxies. However, an additional mechanism is required to explain the largest observed cores. Gravitational-wave (GW) recoil is expected to trigger further growth of the core, as subsequent heating from dynamical friction of the merged SMBH removes stars from the central regions. We model core formation in massive elliptical galaxies from both binary scouring and heating by GW recoil and examine their unique signatures. We aim to determine whether the nature of cores in 3D space density can be attributed uniquely to either process and whether the magnitude of the kick can be inferred. We perform N-body simulations of galactic mergers of multicomponent galaxies, based on the observed parameters of four massive elliptical galaxies with cores >0.5 kpc. After binary scouring and hardening, the merged SMBH remnant is given a range of GW recoil kicks with 0.5–0.9 of the escape speed of the galaxy. We find that binary scouring alone can form the cores of NGC 1600 and A2147-BCG, which are 2 kpc cores in NGC 6166 and A2261-BCG require heating from GW recoil kicks of <0.5 of the galaxy escape speed. A unique feature of GW recoil heating is flatter cores in surface brightness, corresponding to truly flat cores in 3D space density. It also preferentially removes stars on low angular momentum orbits from the galactic nucleus.
- 1 October 2024
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 974 (2) , 204
Open AccessCore Formation by Binary Scouring and Gravitational Wave Recoil in Massive Elliptical Galaxies
Scouring by supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries is the most accepted mechanism for the formation of the cores seen in giant elliptical galaxies. However, an additional mechanism is required to explain the largest observed cores. Gravitational-wave (GW) recoil is expected to trigger further growth of the core, as subsequent heating from dynamical friction of the merged SMBH removes stars from the central regions. We model core formation in massive elliptical galaxies from both binary scouring and heating by GW recoil and examine their unique signatures. We aim to determine whether the nature of cores in 3D space density can be attributed uniquely to either process and whether the magnitude of the kick can be inferred. We perform N-body simulations of galactic mergers of multicomponent galaxies, based on the observed parameters of four massive elliptical galaxies with cores >0.5 kpc. After binary scouring and hardening, the merged SMBH remnant is given a range of GW recoil kicks with 0.5–0.9 of the escape speed of the galaxy. We find that binary scouring alone can form the cores of NGC 1600 and A2147-BCG, which are 2 kpc cores in NGC 6166 and A2261-BCG require heating from GW recoil kicks of <0.5 of the galaxy escape speed. A unique feature of GW recoil heating is flatter cores in surface brightness, corresponding to truly flat cores in 3D space density. It also preferentially removes stars on low angular momentum orbits from the galactic nucleus.
- Open Access
Core formation by binary scouring and gravitational wave recoil in massive elliptical galaxies
Scouring by supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries is the most accepted mechanism for the formation of the cores seen in giant elliptical galaxies. However, an additional mechanism is required to explain the largest observed cores. Gravitational wave (GW) recoil is expected to trigger further growth of the core, as subsequent heating from dynamical friction of the merged SMBH removes stars from the central regions. We model core formation in massive elliptical galaxies from both binary scouring and heating by GW recoil and examine their unique signatures. We aim to determine if the nature of cores in 3D space density can be attributed uniquely to either process and if the magnitude of the kick can be inferred. We perform $N$-body simulations of galactic mergers of multicomponent galaxies, based on the observed parameters of four massive elliptical galaxies with cores $> 0.5$ kpc. After binary scouring and hardening, the merged SMBH remnant is given a range of GW recoil kicks with $0.5$-$0.9$ of the escape speed of the galaxy. We find that binary scouring alone can form the cores of NGC 1600 and A2147-BCG, which are $< 1.3$ kpc in size. However, the $> 2$ kpc cores in NGC 6166 and A2261-BCG require heating from GW recoil kicks of $< 0.5$ of the galaxy escape speed. A unique feature of GW recoil heating is flatter cores in surface brightness, corresponding to truly flat cores in 3D space density. It also preferentially removes stars on low angular momentum orbits from the galactic nucleus.Open AccessCore formation by binary scouring and gravitational wave recoil in massive elliptical galaxies
Scouring by supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries is the most accepted mechanism for the formation of the cores seen in giant elliptical galaxies. However, an additional mechanism is required to explain the largest observed cores. Gravitational wave (GW) recoil is expected to trigger further growth of the core, as subsequent heating from dynamical friction of the merged SMBH removes stars from the central regions. We model core formation in massive elliptical galaxies from both binary scouring and heating by GW recoil and examine their unique signatures. We aim to determine if the nature of cores in 3D space density can be attributed uniquely to either process and if the magnitude of the kick can be inferred. We perform $N$-body simulations of galactic mergers of multicomponent galaxies, based on the observed parameters of four massive elliptical galaxies with cores $> 0.5$ kpc. After binary scouring and hardening, the merged SMBH remnant is given a range of GW recoil kicks with $0.5$-$0.9$ of the escape speed of the galaxy. We find that binary scouring alone can form the cores of NGC 1600 and A2147-BCG, which are $< 1.3$ kpc in size. However, the $> 2$ kpc cores in NGC 6166 and A2261-BCG require heating from GW recoil kicks of $< 0.5$ of the galaxy escape speed. A unique feature of GW recoil heating is flatter cores in surface brightness, corresponding to truly flat cores in 3D space density. It also preferentially removes stars on low angular momentum orbits from the galactic nucleus.