RSRostyslav Sopilnyk

Rostyslav Sopilnyk

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Rostyslav Sopilnyk has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • FUNCTIONAL AUTONOMY OF THE HIGH COUNCIL OF JUSTICE: FROM NORMATIVE MODEL TO INSTITUTIONAL EFFECTIVENESS

    by Rostyslav Liubomyrovych Sopilnyk

    The article examines the phenomenon of the functional autonomy of the High Council of Justice (HCJ) as a key prerequisite for the independence of the judiciary in Ukraine. The author conducts a comprehensive analysis of the evolution from the normative model enshrined in the Constitution and legislation to the actual level of institutional effectiveness of this body. The paper clearly distinguishes between the concepts of "functional autonomy," "institutional independence," and "judicial self-governance," defining their interrelations within the system of judicial independence guarantees. Particular attention is paid to the normative foundations of the HCJ's autonomy, its powers, composition, and role in forming an honest and professional judiciary. Based on a comparative analysis of European standards (recommendations of the Council of Europe, the European Charter on the Statute for Judges, and the opinions of the Venice Commission), the study substantiates the compliance of the Ukrainian model with modern democratic criteria of judicial governance. The article demonstrates that despite a solid legal framework, the HCJ's autonomy between 2016 and 2021 remained largely formal due to political influence, corruption practices, and low public trust in the judiciary. A turning point was the establishment of the Ethics Council in 2021, which initiated the cleansing of the HCJ's composition with the participation of international experts. As a result of the reform and the renewal of the Council in 2023, its functionality was restored, and disciplinary practices and judicial selection processes were reactivated. The study outlines both the achievements and the remaining challenges of this stage, emphasizing the need to strengthen internal anti-corruption mechanisms and improve communication with the public. The author stresses that ensuring real functional autonomy of the HCJ is a vital condition for Ukraine's European integration, as the reform of judicial governance bodies is among the "seven requirements" set by the European Commission. It is concluded that Ukraine is making significant progress in creating an autonomous, ethical, and effective institution capable of guaranteeing judicial independence and upholding the rule of law even under wartime conditions. At the same time, the need for further strengthening the HCJ's institutional capacity, ensuring adequate financing of the judiciary, and maintaining the involvement of independent experts in selection processes is highlighted. The author asserts that only through stable functional autonomy can the High Council of Justice become a true guarantor of fair, transparent, and democratic justice in Ukraine.

  • Open Access

    FUNCTIONAL AUTONOMY OF THE HIGH COUNCIL OF JUSTICE: FROM THE NORMATIVE MODEL TO INSTITUTIONAL EFFECTIVENESS

    by Rostyslav Sopilnyk

    The article examines the phenomenon of the functional autonomy of the High Council of Justice (HCJ) as a key prerequisite for the independence of the judiciary in Ukraine. The author conducts a comprehensive analysis of the evolution from the normative model enshrined in the Constitution and legislation to the actual level of institutional effectiveness of this body. The paper clearly distinguishes between the concepts of functional autonomy, institutional independence, and judicial self-governance, defining their interrelations within the system of judicial independence guarantees. Particular attention is paid to the normative foundations of the HCJ autonomy, its powers, composition, and role in forming an honest and professional judiciary. Based on a comparative analysis of European standards (recommendations of the Council of Europe, the European Charter on the Statute for Judges, and the opinions of the Venice Commission), the study substantiates the compliance of the Ukrainian model with modern democratic criteria of judicial governance. The article demonstrates that despite a solid legal framework, the HCJ autonomy between 2016 and 2021 remained largely formal due to political influence, corruption practices, and low public trust in the judiciary. A turning point was the establishment of the Ethics Council in 2021, which initiated the cleansing of the HCJ composition with the participation of international experts. As a result of the reform and the renewal of the Council in 2023, its functionality was restored, and disciplinary practices and judicial selection processes were reactivated. The study outlines both the achievements and the remaining challenges of this stage, emphasizing the need to strengthen internal anti-corruption mechanisms and improve communication with the public. The author stresses that ensuring real functional autonomy of the HCJ is a vital condition for Ukraine European integration, as the reform of judicial governance bodies is among the seven requirements set by the European Commission. It is concluded that Ukraine is making significant progress in creating an autonomous, ethical, and effective institution capable of guaranteeing judicial independence and upholding the rule of law even under wartime conditions. At the same time, the need for further strengthening the HCJ institutional capacity, ensuring adequate financing of the judiciary, and maintaining the involvement of independent experts in selection processes is highlighted. The author asserts that only through stable functional autonomy can the High Council of Justice become a true guarantor of fair, transparent, and democratic justice in Ukraine.

  • Open Access

    The ICC jurisdiction in Ukraine: challenges and opportunities in the fight against impunity

    by Andrii Lankevych, Oleh Zaverukha, Rostyslav Sopilnyk, Oleksandr Havrylenko, Olha Podilchak

    This article examines the legal relationship between the International Criminal Court (ICC) and Ukraine, a non-party to the Rome Statute, focusing on the scope of the Court's jurisdiction to consider Ukraine's referrals regarding serious crimes committed on its territory since 2014. Discussions regarding the extension of the ICC's jurisdiction over Ukraine commenced in 2014-2015 following Ukraine's two requests for recognition of the ICC's ad hoc jurisdiction. Following the full-scale invasion in 2022, the ICC consolidated these proceedings with the ongoing investigation of crimes committed in Ukraine since 2014. This article analyzes how the ICC's jurisdiction applies to Ukraine, the challenges and prospects for cooperation between the ICC and Ukraine in investigating crimes committed by Russian forces, and the broader implications for the international criminal justice system. The authors analyze arguments for and against Ukraine's ratification of the Rome Statute, concluding that the ICC's jurisdictional framework, particularly concerning the crime of aggression, requires refinement.


  • LEGAL MECHANISMS OF INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC COOPERATION UNDER CONDITIONS OF WAR

    by R.L. Sopilnyk

    The article examines the legal mechanisms for ensuring international scientific cooperation under conditions of armed conflict, taking into account Ukraine's experience during the full-scale armed aggression of the Russian Federation. The regulatory framework for international scientific cooperation is analyzed, in particular the provisions of Articles 45 and 66 of the Law of Ukraine "On Scientific and Scientific-Technical Activity" of November 26, 2015, concerning state support for international scientific relations and integration into the European Research Area. The impact of the martial law regime, introduced in Ukraine pursuant to the Decree of the President of Ukraine of February 24, 2022, on the conditions for conducting scientific activities and the freedom of scientific contacts is examined. The sanctions mechanisms in the scientific sphere provided by the Law of Ukraine "On Sanctions" of August 14, 2014, are analyzed, and the necessity of individualizing sanctions against scientific institutions of the aggressor state is substantiated. The legal framework for Ukraine's participation in the EU Horizon Europe framework programme as an associated participant is considered, and its significance for preserving scientific potential under wartime conditions is determined. The export control system provided by the Law of Ukraine "On State Control over International Transfers of Military Goods and Dual-Use Items" of February 20, 2003, is examined, and directions for its improvement with regard to scientific cooperation are identified, in particular concerning the criteria for assessing risks associated with the transfer of fundamental research results. Proposals for forming a comprehensive legal model of international scientific cooperation that combines sanctions restrictions with active development of partnership relations are formulated.

  • Open Access

    Socio-political discourses on war-related damage to ukrainian citizens: Analysis of public policy in the context of court cases

    by Mariana Khmyz, Rostyslav Sopilnyk, Vitaliy Hudyma, Yurii Semchuk, Liubomyr Sopilnyk

    The purpose of this study is to identify mechanisms based on effective political decisions that will fully impose material damage caused by military actions on the aggressor country. The methodological basis of the work was formed by general theoretical and special scientific methods, which ensured the formation of reliable conclusions and the solution of the tasks. In the course of this study, the author identified the main procedural problems faced by citizens in the process of ensuring the right to compensation for damage caused to them as a result of hostilities. The analysis of the Supreme Court's case law shows that after the start of the full-scale invasion of the Russian Federation, the courts began to take a radically different approach to resolving the issue of compensation in favor of citizens, and in fact deny the immunity of the aggressor state. Authors identify the main political decisions that will be useful in the future for the actual resolution of the issue of compensation for damages. The author analyzes certain legal acts that define the mechanism of compensation for damage. The author assesses the international achievements of Ukraine that will further simplify the procedure for compensation for damages, in particular, international legal acts. In general, the study assessed the real state of affairs in Ukraine regarding compensation for damage to citizens as a result of armed aggression and concluded that effective mechanisms for such compensation have not yet been implemented.


  • NEUROTECHNOLOGIES AND THE RIGHT TO MENTAL PRIVACY

    by R.L. Sopilnyk

    The article examines the legal problems arising from the development of neurotechnologies and their impact on the right to mental privacy as a component of the right to respect for private life. The concepts of neurotechnologies and neurorights are analyzed through the prism of contemporary scientific research in the field of neurosciences and neuroethics, and the main categories of neurorights proposed in the scientific literature are identified: cognitive liberty, mental privacy, mental integrity and psychological continuity. The provisions of Article 8 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of November 4, 1950, and Article 32 of the Constitution of Ukraine regarding guarantees of the right to non-interference in private life in the context of neurotechnological reading and influence on human cognitive processes are examined. The experience of Chile as the first state in the world to enshrine neurorights at the constitutional level through amendments to the Constitution and the adoption of a special Neurorights Law in October 2021 is considered, and the OECD Council Recommendation on Responsible Innovation in Neurotechnology of 2019 is analyzed. The problems of legal regulation of brain-computer interfaces in the context of personal data protection are identified, and the insufficiency of existing legal mechanisms, including the Law of Ukraine "On Personal Data Protection" and EU Regulation 2016/679 (GDPR), for adequate protection of neural data as a special category of sensitive data is analyzed. The necessity of forming a regulatory framework that will ensure the protection of mental privacy in the conditions of rapid neurotechnological development and the definition of neural data as a separate legal category requiring an enhanced protection regime is substantiated.


  • Access to a genuinely independent and impartial trial: a review of the sixteenth sustainability goal completeness

    by Rostyslav Sopilnyk, Juliusz Piwowarski

    The sixteenth sustainability goal is about equality in access to justice. However, according to some events in Eastern Europe, access is insufficient. The court must be genuinely independent and impartial. In this regard, we decided to find arguments in favour of expanding the sixteenth sustainability goal. A review of the sources and a theoretical study indicated a clear link between judicial independence and sustainable development. We used the method of doctrinal research. ECtHR cases have become our data for qualitative analysis. We have reaffirmed that judicial independence is the condition of the rule of law. It means conduction of proceedings without any pressure or interference on a judge, particularly from other branches of government. We argue that the entire independence of the judiciary appears on the background of the subjective and objective independence of the judge. In addition, this study demonstrates that judicial independence is a condition for sustainable development. It is associated with public trust and public confidence in the reality of such independence. In the example of equality of parties, we pointed out that there is no need to detail the sixteenth goal further. With our study, we wish to breathe new energy into the sixteenth goal of sustainable development


  • Problems and prospects of Ukrainian Advocacy development: Euro-integration discourse

    by Rostyslav Sopilnyk, Yurii Semchuk

    European integration is now one of the central issues of politics, economics, law, and sociology. Changes in the legal consciousness of citizens, the turn of the political and legal situation that occurred as a result of the Revolution of Dignity led to the actualisation of fundamentally new requirements for the functioning of legal institutions. In this article, we explored the legal profession of Ukraine in the framework of European integration transformations. We have explored the theoretical basis of the processes of globalisation and European integration, which have a significant impact on legal reform in Ukraine. In particular, we have established the main models of European integration and the features of the European integration paradigm. We compared the current development goals of the Bar of Ukraine and the requirements that arise in connection with the Euro-integration discourse. This article can help elaborate a Ukrainian Advocacy development strategy in the Euro-integration discourse

  • ADMINISTRATIVE AND LEGAL ASPECTS OF THE ACTIVITY OF THE HIGH ANTI-CORRUPTION COURT AND OTHER ANTI-CORRUPTION BODIES OF UKRAINE IN THE CONTEXT OF EUROPEANIZATION

    by Mykhailo Kosiuta, Lyubomyr Sopilnyk, Solomiya Denys, Rostyslav Sopilnyk, Roman Zayats

    The establishment of the High Anti-Corruption Court in Ukraine was a radical step for Ukraine in the fight against corruption. This fact has led to many discussions and debates in scientific circles. The purpose of the article is to administrative and legal characteristics of the legal status of the High Anti-Corruption Court and other Anti-Corruption Bodies of Ukraine and prospects it’s activity in the context of Europeanization. The chosen methodology helpedto identify the historical origins of corruption; to outline the main features and establish the concept of “corruption”; to analyze the experience of European countries in establishing a system of anti-corruption bodies; to make proposals for reforming the current system of anti-corruption bodies of Ukraine in the context of Europeanization of administrative law. We believe that a key point in the process of improving the effectiveness of the fight against corruption in Ukraine is the need to implement the experience of European countries also in terms of informing and training civil servants professional ethics, awareness and legal culture. The high authority of anti-corruption bodies, as evidenced by the analyzed practice of EU countries (including Denmark), determines the effectiveness of the fight against corruption. Such a system of anti-corruption institutions will help to clearly establish powers, avoid conflicts of interest and bureaucratic schemes, increase the targeted use of budget funds, facilitate citizens' access to relevant bodies with complaints about corruption offenses, and eliminate the privileged status of corrupt officials in the administration of justice.

  • Open Access

    Principles of Legal Regulation of the Use of Cloud Technologies for Personal Data Processing

    by Ruslan Skrynkovskyy, Rostyslav Sopilnyk, Oleksandr Malashko, Vasyl Vikonskyi, Myroslav Kovaliv, Tetiana Protsiuk, Serhii Yesimov, Roman Zayats

    Principles of Legal Regulation of the Use of Cloud Technologies for Personal Data Processing Principles of Legal Regulation of the Use of Cloud Technologies for Personal Data Processing