Kelly R. Kamnikar
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Kelly R. Kamnikar has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Heather Joy Hecht Edgar
Department of Anthropology University of New Mexico Albuquerque New Mexico USA
4 shared publications - Nicollette S. Appel
Department of Anthropology University of New Mexico Albuquerque New Mexico USA
4 shared publications Amber M. Plemons
Michigan State Univ, Dept Anthropol, 655 Auditorium Dr, E Lansing, MI 48824 USA
2 shared publications- Amber M. Plemons
Department of Anthropology, California State University, Chico, Chico, CA 95929, USA
2 shared publications - Joseph T. Hefner
Department of Anthropology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA
2 shared publications - Micayla C. Spiros
District of Columbia Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, Washington, DC 20024, USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Unprovenanced Anatomical Crania: A Stepwise Protocol Integrating Epitaphonomic Signature and Population Affinity
Unprovenanced skeletal remains housed in anatomy laboratories, medical schools, and museums present a persistent ethical challenge when the human skeletal remains potentially represent historically marginalized or legally protected populations. Reliance on a single line of evidence, like epitaphonomic indicators or population affinity estimates, may result in incomplete or misleading assessments. Herein, we present a structured, non-destructive protocol integrating epitaphonomic signatures and an estimation of population affinity (including assessing biocultural indicators of affinity) to support ethical decision-making regarding unprovenanced crania in institutional collections. Our proposed protocol was applied to 16 unprovenanced crania curated in a university anatomy collection. Epitaphonomic signatures associated with anatomical preparation were assessed using categorical scores; craniometric data were analyzed using FORDISC 3.1 following the standard approach therein and using a custom reference dataset imported into the program. Additional exploratory analyses were conducted using a Factor Analysis of Mixed Data (FAMD) to visualize concordance and discordance between epitaphonomic and craniometric variables. Results indicate most individuals exhibit epitaphonomic signatures consistent with anatomical preparation; however, when those data are integrated with craniometric analysis, we identified individuals warranting removal from teaching collections based on elevated ethical concerns. Case examples demonstrate how our protocol supports transparent ethical triage distinguishing between likely anatomically prepared human remains, human remains requiring repatriation, and indeterminate cases requiring further evaluation. This protocol provides a practical, nondestructive framework for the responsible stewardship of unprovenanced skeletal collections.
Open AccessUnprovenanced Anatomical Crania: A Stepwise Protocol Integrating Epitaphonomic Signature and Population Affinity
Unprovenanced skeletal remains housed in anatomy laboratories, medical schools, and museums present a persistent ethical challenge when the human skeletal remains potentially represent historically marginalized or legally protected populations. Reliance on a single line of evidence, like epitaphonomic indicators or population affinity estimates, may result in incomplete or misleading assessments. Herein, we present a structured, non-destructive protocol integrating epitaphonomic signatures and an estimation of population affinity (including assessing biocultural indicators of affinity) to support ethical decision-making regarding unprovenanced crania in institutional collections. Our proposed protocol was applied to 16 unprovenanced crania curated in a university anatomy collection. Epitaphonomic signatures associated with anatomical preparation were assessed using categorical scores; craniometric data were analyzed using FORDISC 3.1 following the standard approach therein and using a custom reference dataset imported into the program. Additional exploratory analyses were conducted using a Factor Analysis of Mixed Data (FAMD) to visualize concordance and discordance between epitaphonomic and craniometric variables. Results indicate most individuals exhibit epitaphonomic signatures consistent with anatomical preparation; however, when those data are integrated with craniometric analysis, we identified individuals warranting removal from teaching collections based on elevated ethical concerns. Case examples demonstrate how our protocol supports transparent ethical triage distinguishing between likely anatomically prepared human remains, human remains requiring repatriation, and indeterminate cases requiring further evaluation. This protocol provides a practical, nondestructive framework for the responsible stewardship of unprovenanced skeletal collections.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Forensic Sciences
- Vol. 5 (3) , 45
The Impact of Identity and Population History on Population Affinity Analysis in New Mexico Using Cranial Macromorphoscopic Data
Background/Objectives: This paper presents cranial MMS data for an American Indian (AI) sample from New Mexico. We compare these data to other population reference samples to understand biological distance and classification patterns. Methods: Cranial MMS data was collected from CT scans of AI individuals (n = 839) in the New Mexico Decedent Image Database. We used 12 traits following a published protocol for CT data and excluded nasal bone contour. The AI sample is compared to other samples of African American or Black, Asian, Hispanic, and White individuals to assess biological distance and classification accuracy. Results: Biological distance analysis indicated similarity among the AI, Hispanic, and Black samples, but dissimilarity among the Asian and White samples to the AI sample. Classification accuracy was low for the overall model, with Hispanic and Black individuals frequently misclassifying as AI. Conclusions: As is true everywhere, ideas about identity are complex in New Mexico. AI and Hispanic individuals in NM self-ascribe to one or both social groups. We found that biological data cannot meaningfully differentiate between these social groups, as crania are morphologically similar when examining cranial MMS traits. These results, coupled with New Mexican identity and genetics, contributes to the difficulty in group attribution in forensic casework. Nevertheless, the reference data for AI presented here can provide more robust statistics that support the likelihood of AI and Hispanic affinity in population affinity analysis. We underscore the need for an understanding of regional population history and structure and reference samples while assessing population affinity in forensic casework.
- 15 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Forensic Sciences
- Vol. 5 (3) , 45
Open AccessThe Impact of Identity and Population History on Population Affinity Analysis in New Mexico Using Cranial Macromorphoscopic Data
Background/Objectives: This paper presents cranial MMS data for an American Indian (AI) sample from New Mexico. We compare these data to other population reference samples to understand biological distance and classification patterns. Methods: Cranial MMS data was collected from CT scans of AI individuals (n = 839) in the New Mexico Decedent Image Database. We used 12 traits following a published protocol for CT data and excluded nasal bone contour. The AI sample is compared to other samples of African American or Black, Asian, Hispanic, and White individuals to assess biological distance and classification accuracy. Results: Biological distance analysis indicated similarity among the AI, Hispanic, and Black samples, but dissimilarity among the Asian and White samples to the AI sample. Classification accuracy was low for the overall model, with Hispanic and Black individuals frequently misclassifying as AI. Conclusions: As is true everywhere, ideas about identity are complex in New Mexico. AI and Hispanic individuals in NM self-ascribe to one or both social groups. We found that biological data cannot meaningfully differentiate between these social groups, as crania are morphologically similar when examining cranial MMS traits. These results, coupled with New Mexican identity and genetics, contributes to the difficulty in group attribution in forensic casework. Nevertheless, the reference data for AI presented here can provide more robust statistics that support the likelihood of AI and Hispanic affinity in population affinity analysis. We underscore the need for an understanding of regional population history and structure and reference samples while assessing population affinity in forensic casework.
- 7 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 187 (4) , e70106
A Newly Developed AI‐Assisted Tool for the Collection of Cranial Landmark Data
Virtual anthropology databases provide substantial benefits for research, offering large‐scale, diverse samples that facilitate methodological advancements in research and allow for testing of theoretical models that may otherwise not be possible. As technology evolves, it is crucial to develop methods that can effectively be utilized in new forms of imaging and visualization. Here, we introduce a craniometric data collection module within the medical imaging software, Amira, developed to enhance, improve, and expedite large‐scale data collection in virtual anthropology. This module's capabilities include 3D visualization of computed tomography (CT) scans and AI‐driven assistance in landmark plotting. An output file contains x, y, and z coordinate data of all plotted landmarks and interlandmark distances. Additionally, researchers can plot floating and endocranial landmarks, enhancing the flexibility and comprehensiveness of data collection. A key advantage of this module is its complete customizability. Researchers can tailor the module to fit their objectives. The module's efficiency represents a marked improvement over previous virtual craniometrics data collection methods. In its current form, the module allows researchers to load input files, register the sample skull, and plot 104 cranial landmarks (both ectocranial and endocranial) in approximately 40 min. This is considerably faster than prior approaches. The module demonstrates the potential of leveraging AI and CT scans for the advancement of biological and forensic anthropology. Its integration with Amira's powerful tools provides researchers with a new and valuable resource that sets a new standard for data collection in virtual anthropology.
- 7 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 187 (4) , e70106
A Newly Developed AI‐Assisted Tool for the Collection of Cranial Landmark Data
Virtual anthropology databases provide substantial benefits for research, offering large‐scale, diverse samples that facilitate methodological advancements in research and allow for testing of theoretical models that may otherwise not be possible. As technology evolves, it is crucial to develop methods that can effectively be utilized in new forms of imaging and visualization. Here, we introduce a craniometric data collection module within the medical imaging software, Amira, developed to enhance, improve, and expedite large‐scale data collection in virtual anthropology. This module's capabilities include 3D visualization of computed tomography (CT) scans and AI‐driven assistance in landmark plotting. An output file contains x, y, and z coordinate data of all plotted landmarks and interlandmark distances. Additionally, researchers can plot floating and endocranial landmarks, enhancing the flexibility and comprehensiveness of data collection. A key advantage of this module is its complete customizability. Researchers can tailor the module to fit their objectives. The module's efficiency represents a marked improvement over previous virtual craniometrics data collection methods. In its current form, the module allows researchers to load input files, register the sample skull, and plot 104 cranial landmarks (both ectocranial and endocranial) in approximately 40 min. This is considerably faster than prior approaches. The module demonstrates the potential of leveraging AI and CT scans for the advancement of biological and forensic anthropology. Its integration with Amira's powerful tools provides researchers with a new and valuable resource that sets a new standard for data collection in virtual anthropology.
- 7 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 185 (4) , e25032
Technical note: Measuring bicondylar length in computed tomography data
Objectives: With the increased use of 3D‐generated images in biological research, there is a critical need to adapt classical anatomical measurements, traditionally conducted with calipers, to a virtual environment. We present detailed protocols for measuring bicondylar length, a critical dimension of the femur, using three different imaging software programs—3D Slicer™, Amira™, and Simpleware™. These protocols provide researchers and practitioners in radiology, orthopedics, biomechanics, and biological anthropology with accurate and reproducible measurement techniques. The objective is to standardize and support virtual osteology in biomechanical research, stature estimation, and related medical and anthropological studies.Materials and Methods: Adhering to standardized protocols, we adapted femoral bicondylar length measurements for computed tomography images from a New Mexican collection (n = 10). The method was designed for applicability and reproducibility across three software platforms. By comparing measurements from the same sample across different observers and different platforms, this study validates the accuracy and consistency of the adapted protocol, demonstrating its utility for research and clinical assessments.Results: We present a step‐by‐step guide for each program, detailing bone alignment and measurement. We illustrate each step and provide video tutorials via links for an enhanced understanding of the process.Discussion: Bicondylar length can be measured effectively in each software program following the provided instructions. However, ease of measurement varied among the programs, with some offering a more straightforward process. This variability underscores the importance of choosing appropriate software for the user's needs and proficiency. It also suggests areas for improvement and standardization in software design and instructional clarity.
- 7 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 185 (4) , e25032
Technical note: Measuring bicondylar length in computed tomography data
Objectives: With the increased use of 3D‐generated images in biological research, there is a critical need to adapt classical anatomical measurements, traditionally conducted with calipers, to a virtual environment. We present detailed protocols for measuring bicondylar length, a critical dimension of the femur, using three different imaging software programs—3D Slicer™, Amira™, and Simpleware™. These protocols provide researchers and practitioners in radiology, orthopedics, biomechanics, and biological anthropology with accurate and reproducible measurement techniques. The objective is to standardize and support virtual osteology in biomechanical research, stature estimation, and related medical and anthropological studies.Materials and Methods: Adhering to standardized protocols, we adapted femoral bicondylar length measurements for computed tomography images from a New Mexican collection (n = 10). The method was designed for applicability and reproducibility across three software platforms. By comparing measurements from the same sample across different observers and different platforms, this study validates the accuracy and consistency of the adapted protocol, demonstrating its utility for research and clinical assessments.Results: We present a step‐by‐step guide for each program, detailing bone alignment and measurement. We illustrate each step and provide video tutorials via links for an enhanced understanding of the process.Discussion: Bicondylar length can be measured effectively in each software program following the provided instructions. However, ease of measurement varied among the programs, with some offering a more straightforward process. This variability underscores the importance of choosing appropriate software for the user's needs and proficiency. It also suggests areas for improvement and standardization in software design and instructional clarity.
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Forensic Science International
- Vol. 361, 112151
Stature estimation equations for modern American Indians in the American Southwest
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Forensic Science International
- Vol. 361, 112151
Stature estimation equations for modern American Indians in the American Southwest
- 3 February 2020
- Published by Wiley in WIREs Forensic Science
- Vol. 2 (4)
Ancestry estimation in forensic anthropology: A review
Forensic anthropologists assist law enforcement agencies and medical examiner's offices with investigations involving human remains, providing insight into trauma analysis, the establishment of postmortem interval, and the estimation of biological profile data. Ancestry is considered one of the more difficult aspects of the biological profile, due in large part to the complicated relationship between skeletal morphology and social constructs. The methods used to estimate ancestry rely on the correlation between skeletal morphology, geographic origin, and an individual's social race. While there is a well‐documented contemptible history associated with the development of ancestry estimation methods in biological anthropology, many of the more traditional, now antiquated, methods are still used in some laboratories. The push to improve the framework within which ancestry data are analyzed requires validation and reassessment for each method in addition to the development of novel approaches utilizing modern technological advances. An array of software programs designed to aid in ancestry estimation is available. These advances do not signal the end of ancestry‐related research. Indeed, several areas seemingly stagnated by tradition and time require further study through more than simply review and rarefaction. The future of ancestry estimation research centers on: (a) abandoning the trait list approach, (b) rejecting the three‐group model, (c) establishing larger and more representative reference data, (d) assessing the utility of mixed method models, and (e) developing new statistical approaches and updating current software tools.This article is categorized under:Forensic Anthropology > Ancestry DeterminationForensic Medicine > Historical PerspectivesForensic Anthropology > Anthropology in Mass Disaster & War Crime Contexts
- 3 February 2020
- Published by Wiley in WIREs Forensic Science
- Vol. 2 (4)
Ancestry estimation in forensic anthropology: A review
Forensic anthropologists assist law enforcement agencies and medical examiner's offices with investigations involving human remains, providing insight into trauma analysis, the establishment of postmortem interval, and the estimation of biological profile data. Ancestry is considered one of the more difficult aspects of the biological profile, due in large part to the complicated relationship between skeletal morphology and social constructs. The methods used to estimate ancestry rely on the correlation between skeletal morphology, geographic origin, and an individual's social race. While there is a well‐documented contemptible history associated with the development of ancestry estimation methods in biological anthropology, many of the more traditional, now antiquated, methods are still used in some laboratories. The push to improve the framework within which ancestry data are analyzed requires validation and reassessment for each method in addition to the development of novel approaches utilizing modern technological advances. An array of software programs designed to aid in ancestry estimation is available. These advances do not signal the end of ancestry‐related research. Indeed, several areas seemingly stagnated by tradition and time require further study through more than simply review and rarefaction. The future of ancestry estimation research centers on: (a) abandoning the trait list approach, (b) rejecting the three‐group model, (c) establishing larger and more representative reference data, (d) assessing the utility of mixed method models, and (e) developing new statistical approaches and updating current software tools.This article is categorized under:Forensic Anthropology > Ancestry DeterminationForensic Medicine > Historical PerspectivesForensic Anthropology > Anthropology in Mass Disaster & War Crime Contexts
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Project MUSE in Human Biology
- Vol. 90 (1) , 11-30
New Approaches to Juvenile Age Estimation in Forensics: Application of Transition Analysis via the Shackelford et al. Method to a Diverse Modern Subadult Sample
- 1 January 2018
- Published by Project MUSE in Human Biology
- Vol. 90 (1) , 11-30
New Approaches to Juvenile Age Estimation in Forensics: Application of Transition Analysis via the Shackelford et al. Method to a Diverse Modern Subadult Sample
- 24 May 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Forensic Sciences
- Vol. 63 (2) , 361-370
Intraobserver Error in Macromorphoscopic Trait Data, ,
As part of a much larger investigation into the use of macromorphoscopic trait data by forensic anthropologists to estimate ancestry from unidentified skeletal remains, we conducted a fourteen-year (2002–2016) intraobserver error study. Motivated by the development of a large macromorphoscopic database―which will potentially utilize data collected in 2002―quantification of observer error, the impact of technological improvements in macromorphoscopic trait data collection and observer experience is necessary. To maximize comparisons between the two samples, ten macromorphoscopic traits were assessed. Results revealed three patterns of error relating to observer experience, the introduction of new technologies, and error inherent in the method. Overall, this study found the effect of error on macromorphoscopic trait analysis could be predicted and did not significantly impact their utility.
- 24 May 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Forensic Sciences
- Vol. 63 (2) , 361-370
Intraobserver Error in Macromorphoscopic Trait Data, ,
As part of a much larger investigation into the use of macromorphoscopic trait data by forensic anthropologists to estimate ancestry from unidentified skeletal remains, we conducted a fourteen-year (2002–2016) intraobserver error study. Motivated by the development of a large macromorphoscopic database―which will potentially utilize data collected in 2002―quantification of observer error, the impact of technological improvements in macromorphoscopic trait data collection and observer experience is necessary. To maximize comparisons between the two samples, ten macromorphoscopic traits were assessed. Results revealed three patterns of error relating to observer experience, the introduction of new technologies, and error inherent in the method. Overall, this study found the effect of error on macromorphoscopic trait analysis could be predicted and did not significantly impact their utility.
- 1 October 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Archaeological Journal
- Vol. 24 (3) , 513-522
Recovering the ‘Body Politic’: a Relational Ethics of Meaning for Bioarchaeology
Bioarchaeology is fraught with profound ethical quandaries, yet it has lagged behind the larger discipline of anthropology in the development of ethical principles and a professional code of ethics. Here, we propose an additional ethical justification for bioarchaeology based on relational ethics, theoretical work on embodiment, and the produced and constituted nature of human bodies, and on deriving meaning from skeletal remains: highly contextualized skeletal data analyzed in a relational, contingent interpretive space can generate otherwise inaccessible, direct information about the constitutive, productive effects of processes like power and oppression on human bodies. This enables recovery and recognition of the agency, singularity, and meaning of past peoples through giving voice to their narratives. This justification is not universally applicable; it is best suited to skeletal remains from marginalized, disenfranchised, and impoverished individuals and communities. We conclude with a case study applying the approach to a skeletal sample from the 18th-19th century Mississippi State Asylum to demonstrate that the approach complements more traditional bioarchaeological research while providing an additional foundation for ethical discourses and debates in the field.
- 1 October 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Cambridge Archaeological Journal
- Vol. 24 (3) , 513-522
Recovering the ‘Body Politic’: a Relational Ethics of Meaning for Bioarchaeology
Bioarchaeology is fraught with profound ethical quandaries, yet it has lagged behind the larger discipline of anthropology in the development of ethical principles and a professional code of ethics. Here, we propose an additional ethical justification for bioarchaeology based on relational ethics, theoretical work on embodiment, and the produced and constituted nature of human bodies, and on deriving meaning from skeletal remains: highly contextualized skeletal data analyzed in a relational, contingent interpretive space can generate otherwise inaccessible, direct information about the constitutive, productive effects of processes like power and oppression on human bodies. This enables recovery and recognition of the agency, singularity, and meaning of past peoples through giving voice to their narratives. This justification is not universally applicable; it is best suited to skeletal remains from marginalized, disenfranchised, and impoverished individuals and communities. We conclude with a case study applying the approach to a skeletal sample from the 18th-19th century Mississippi State Asylum to demonstrate that the approach complements more traditional bioarchaeological research while providing an additional foundation for ethical discourses and debates in the field.