Nadiia Horobets
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Nadiia Horobets has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Oleg Reznik
Sumy State University
8 shared publications - Olha Bondarenko
Sumy State University
2 shared publications - Yuliia Yakushchenko
Sumy State University, Ukraine
2 shared publications - Аліна Володимирівна Стеблянко
докторка філософії зі спеціальності 081 «Право», асистентка кафедри фундаментальної юриспруденції та конституційного права Навчально-наукового інституту права Сумського державного університету (м. Суми, Україна)
2 shared publications Anatoliy Kulish
Professor, Dr., Sumy State University , Academic and Research Institute of Law ( Ukraine )
1 shared publication- Andriana Kostenko
Sumy State University, Kharkivska st.116, 40007 Sumy, Ukraine
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 July 2026
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 2,p. 58-63
Digital technologies in the system of corruption prevention and counteraction in Ukraine: current state and prospects
The article examines the current state and prospects of digital technology use in the system of corruption prevention and counteraction in Ukraine. The relevance of the topic is determined by the fact that corruption remains one of the most acute systemic problems of public administration in Ukraine, as well as by the growing role of digital technologies as a tool for corruption prevention and counteraction. Empirical data confirming a strong correlation between the level of digitalization and the level of corruption are provided. At the same time, it is emphasized that the effectiveness of digital technologies in the corruption prevention and counteraction system is not unconditional. Specific digital anti-corruption instruments are examined, including ProZorro, the electronic patient cabinet in the healthcare system, the Unified Whistleblower Reporting Portal, the Diia platform, and the e-governance system. It is established that most of them are multifunctional and cannot be confined to a single conceptual approach: some gravitate towards the digital transparency approach, others towards the institutional-automated or analytical-preventive approach, while the e-declaration system combines features of several approaches simultaneously. The expediency of treating the classification of approaches as an analytical tool for evaluating digital anti-corruption solutions, rather than as a rigid division, is substantiated. Promising directions for the development of digital anti-corruption instruments are identified, including the integration of artificial intelligence and natural language processing into the whistleblower reporting system for automated analysis of submissions and detection of corruption schemes, the implementation of blockchain technologies for cryptographic data protection and transaction tracking in public finance, and the development of the civic participation approach through enhancing digital literacy of the population. It is concluded that the key condition for the development of digital technologies in the corruption prevention and counteraction system is the combination of technological solutions, institutional reforms and legal regulation.
- 24 July 2026
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 2,p. 58-63
Open AccessDigital technologies in the system of corruption prevention and counteraction in Ukraine: current state and prospects
The article examines the current state and prospects of digital technology use in the system of corruption prevention and counteraction in Ukraine. The relevance of the topic is determined by the fact that corruption remains one of the most acute systemic problems of public administration in Ukraine, as well as by the growing role of digital technologies as a tool for corruption prevention and counteraction. Empirical data confirming a strong correlation between the level of digitalization and the level of corruption are provided. At the same time, it is emphasized that the effectiveness of digital technologies in the corruption prevention and counteraction system is not unconditional. Specific digital anti-corruption instruments are examined, including ProZorro, the electronic patient cabinet in the healthcare system, the Unified Whistleblower Reporting Portal, the Diia platform, and the e-governance system. It is established that most of them are multifunctional and cannot be confined to a single conceptual approach: some gravitate towards the digital transparency approach, others towards the institutional-automated or analytical-preventive approach, while the e-declaration system combines features of several approaches simultaneously. The expediency of treating the classification of approaches as an analytical tool for evaluating digital anti-corruption solutions, rather than as a rigid division, is substantiated. Promising directions for the development of digital anti-corruption instruments are identified, including the integration of artificial intelligence and natural language processing into the whistleblower reporting system for automated analysis of submissions and detection of corruption schemes, the implementation of blockchain technologies for cryptographic data protection and transaction tracking in public finance, and the development of the civic participation approach through enhancing digital literacy of the population. It is concluded that the key condition for the development of digital technologies in the corruption prevention and counteraction system is the combination of technological solutions, institutional reforms and legal regulation.
- Open Access
- 28 May 2026
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 1,p. 60-65
European (Swedish) anti-corruption model: institutional and legal framework
The aim of the work is to identify the features of the institutional and legal foundations of the European (Swedish) anti-corruption model and to assess the possibilities of its application in Ukraine. The methodological basis of the study includes general scientific and special legal methods, in particular analysis, synthesis, comparative legal method. The research is based on the study of scientific publications of domestic and foreign scholars, as well as regulatory acts of the EU and Sweden in the field of anti-corruption and whistleblower protection. Results. It has been established that the European (Swedish) anti-corruption model belongs to preventive (horizontal) models and is focused on eliminating the preconditions for corruption rather than solely combating its consequences. It combines legal, institutional, and social mechanisms to create an environment intolerant of corruption. Key features include transparency in public administration, effective public oversight, citizen participation in decision-making, high ethical standards for officials, and an independent judiciary. A central role is played by whistleblower protection, which has deep historical roots in Sweden and evolved from guarantees of freedom of expression and access to public information. Modern regulation, aligned with EU standards and Directive (EU) 2019/1937, significantly expanded protection, introduced diversified reporting channels, broadened the range of protected persons, and simplified protection through the concept of public interest. The effectiveness of this mechanism relies not only on legal guarantees but also on its interaction with public oversight, including the active role of the media. Certain shortcomings remain, such as limitations on compensation for whistleblowers and unclear sanctions for obstructing reporting or retaliation. Conclusions. The Swedish experience demonstrates that effective anti-corruption policy is based on a comprehensive approach that combines legal regulation with a high level of public trust and active societal control. Certain elements of this model, particularly in the areas of transparency, digitalization, and whistleblower protection, can be adapted in Ukraine, taking into account national specificities.
- 28 May 2026
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 1,p. 60-65
Open AccessEuropean (Swedish) anti-corruption model: institutional and legal framework
The aim of the work is to identify the features of the institutional and legal foundations of the European (Swedish) anti-corruption model and to assess the possibilities of its application in Ukraine. The methodological basis of the study includes general scientific and special legal methods, in particular analysis, synthesis, comparative legal method. The research is based on the study of scientific publications of domestic and foreign scholars, as well as regulatory acts of the EU and Sweden in the field of anti-corruption and whistleblower protection. Results. It has been established that the European (Swedish) anti-corruption model belongs to preventive (horizontal) models and is focused on eliminating the preconditions for corruption rather than solely combating its consequences. It combines legal, institutional, and social mechanisms to create an environment intolerant of corruption. Key features include transparency in public administration, effective public oversight, citizen participation in decision-making, high ethical standards for officials, and an independent judiciary. A central role is played by whistleblower protection, which has deep historical roots in Sweden and evolved from guarantees of freedom of expression and access to public information. Modern regulation, aligned with EU standards and Directive (EU) 2019/1937, significantly expanded protection, introduced diversified reporting channels, broadened the range of protected persons, and simplified protection through the concept of public interest. The effectiveness of this mechanism relies not only on legal guarantees but also on its interaction with public oversight, including the active role of the media. Certain shortcomings remain, such as limitations on compensation for whistleblowers and unclear sanctions for obstructing reporting or retaliation. Conclusions. The Swedish experience demonstrates that effective anti-corruption policy is based on a comprehensive approach that combines legal regulation with a high level of public trust and active societal control. Certain elements of this model, particularly in the areas of transparency, digitalization, and whistleblower protection, can be adapted in Ukraine, taking into account national specificities.
- Open Access
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 5 (92) , 130-135
Particularities of the European Court of Human Rights’ practice regarding social protection
The article is devoted to defining the substance, approaches, and trends in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter – the ECtHR) in the field of social protection, as well as its influence on the formation of national policy and law enforcement practices in the member states of the Council of Europe. The meaning of the category “social,” which forms the basis for understanding social rights, is clarified. It is determined that social rights are second-generation rights that encompass healthcare, housing, social security, education, and an adequate standard of living. These rights regulate key social relations, constitute the foundation of human existence, and define the essence of the functioning of a social and rule-of-law state. It has been found that, although the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter – the Convention) does not directly guarantee social rights, the practice of the ECtHR demonstrates the possibility of their protection through the interpretation of provisions on the right to life, property, non-discrimination, and effective legal remedies. Special attention is paid to the protection of property rights in the sphere of social benefits. It has been established that, according to the legal position of the ECtHR, social benefits can be regarded as «property» subject to protection. Key ECtHR decisions concerning social benefits, non-discrimination on the grounds of gender, age, social or national origin, and the practice of positive discrimination regarding pension and social benefits are presented. The article also separately examines ECtHR precedents regarding the application of Article 3 of the Convention in the context of ensuring an adequate level of medical care and decent conditions of detention as an aspect of social protection, as well as the interconnection of social rights with political freedoms and other human rights. It has been concluded that the ECtHR establishes pan-European standards for the realization of social rights, while allowing states a certain discretion in determining specific mechanisms of social policy, but at the same time monitors the impermissibility of arbitrary or discriminatory restrictions. In Ukraine, the implementation of ECtHR decisions through legislation and judicial practice contributes to harmonizing the national system with European standards and strengthening the effective protection of citizens’ social rights.
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 5 (92) , 130-135
Open AccessParticularities of the European Court of Human Rights’ practice regarding social protection
The article is devoted to defining the substance, approaches, and trends in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter – the ECtHR) in the field of social protection, as well as its influence on the formation of national policy and law enforcement practices in the member states of the Council of Europe. The meaning of the category “social,” which forms the basis for understanding social rights, is clarified. It is determined that social rights are second-generation rights that encompass healthcare, housing, social security, education, and an adequate standard of living. These rights regulate key social relations, constitute the foundation of human existence, and define the essence of the functioning of a social and rule-of-law state. It has been found that, although the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter – the Convention) does not directly guarantee social rights, the practice of the ECtHR demonstrates the possibility of their protection through the interpretation of provisions on the right to life, property, non-discrimination, and effective legal remedies. Special attention is paid to the protection of property rights in the sphere of social benefits. It has been established that, according to the legal position of the ECtHR, social benefits can be regarded as «property» subject to protection. Key ECtHR decisions concerning social benefits, non-discrimination on the grounds of gender, age, social or national origin, and the practice of positive discrimination regarding pension and social benefits are presented. The article also separately examines ECtHR precedents regarding the application of Article 3 of the Convention in the context of ensuring an adequate level of medical care and decent conditions of detention as an aspect of social protection, as well as the interconnection of social rights with political freedoms and other human rights. It has been concluded that the ECtHR establishes pan-European standards for the realization of social rights, while allowing states a certain discretion in determining specific mechanisms of social policy, but at the same time monitors the impermissibility of arbitrary or discriminatory restrictions. In Ukraine, the implementation of ECtHR decisions through legislation and judicial practice contributes to harmonizing the national system with European standards and strengthening the effective protection of citizens’ social rights.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 4 (89) , 17-21
EU Law on artificial intelligence and its impact on the judicial system of Ukraine
The article is devoted to clarifying the key provisions of the EU Law on AI and its impact on the judicial system of Ukraine. It is noted that AI has significantly expanded the capabilities of information technologies in courts, and countries such as China, the USA, Japan, and the UK already have the practice of using AI in judicial proceedings. It is indicated that in most countries there is a significant gap between the level of implementation of AI in judicial systems and the legal regulation of these processes, which led to the adoption of the EU Law on AI, the provisions of which will come into force in 2026. The doctrinal understanding of the concept of “artificial intelligence” is revealed. It is found that the EU Law on AI does not define AI, but at the same time contains the concept of “AI system”, at the level of national legislation the concept of “artificial intelligence” is enshrined in the Concept of the Development of Artificial Intelligence. It is established that the adoption of the EU Law on AI should become the basis for the formation of the legal regime of AI at the international and national levels. A doctrinal understanding of the concept of “legal regime of AI” is presented. It is noted that the need to form a legal regime of AI is due to a number of advantages (automation of legal processes, analysis of large data sets, use of algorithms to predict court decisions) and potential risks of such technologies (problems with transparency and accountability, discrimination, threat to privacy and confidentiality), which requires an assessment of their impact on human rights and principles of justice. It is established that the EU Law on AI is general, but refers the judicial system to high-risk areas of application of AI and sets mandatory requirements for AI technologies in this area (transparency, non-discrimination, data quality, human control, security and cyber protection). It is concluded that the establishment of such requirements by the EU Law on AI will clearly affect the judicial system of Ukraine, as its provisions must be implemented into national legislation in order to harmonize it with European legislation. At the same time, the judicial system of Ukraine must be open to adapting the provisions of the EU Law on AI and ensure the functioning of AI technologies that meet the requirements established by it.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 4 (89) , 17-21
Open AccessEU Law on artificial intelligence and its impact on the judicial system of Ukraine
The article is devoted to clarifying the key provisions of the EU Law on AI and its impact on the judicial system of Ukraine. It is noted that AI has significantly expanded the capabilities of information technologies in courts, and countries such as China, the USA, Japan, and the UK already have the practice of using AI in judicial proceedings. It is indicated that in most countries there is a significant gap between the level of implementation of AI in judicial systems and the legal regulation of these processes, which led to the adoption of the EU Law on AI, the provisions of which will come into force in 2026. The doctrinal understanding of the concept of “artificial intelligence” is revealed. It is found that the EU Law on AI does not define AI, but at the same time contains the concept of “AI system”, at the level of national legislation the concept of “artificial intelligence” is enshrined in the Concept of the Development of Artificial Intelligence. It is established that the adoption of the EU Law on AI should become the basis for the formation of the legal regime of AI at the international and national levels. A doctrinal understanding of the concept of “legal regime of AI” is presented. It is noted that the need to form a legal regime of AI is due to a number of advantages (automation of legal processes, analysis of large data sets, use of algorithms to predict court decisions) and potential risks of such technologies (problems with transparency and accountability, discrimination, threat to privacy and confidentiality), which requires an assessment of their impact on human rights and principles of justice. It is established that the EU Law on AI is general, but refers the judicial system to high-risk areas of application of AI and sets mandatory requirements for AI technologies in this area (transparency, non-discrimination, data quality, human control, security and cyber protection). It is concluded that the establishment of such requirements by the EU Law on AI will clearly affect the judicial system of Ukraine, as its provisions must be implemented into national legislation in order to harmonize it with European legislation. At the same time, the judicial system of Ukraine must be open to adapting the provisions of the EU Law on AI and ensure the functioning of AI technologies that meet the requirements established by it.
- Open Access
- 6 June 2025
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 1,p. 50-56
Legal framework for the implementation of the “green” economy policy in Ukraine
The article is devoted to the study of the regulatory framework for the implementation of the “green” economy policy in Ukraine in view of the current state of legal regulation of this area. The methodological basis of the research is the formal-logical and formal-dogmatic methods. It is determined that the development of the “green” economy in Ukraine is a strategically important task for ensuring sustainable development, preserving natural resources and improving the quality of life in the country. This task is especially relevant in the context of the post-war reconstruction of Ukraine, which must comply with the European green and digital agenda. The concept of the “green” economy and its relationship with the concept of “green” growth are studied. It is noted that the basis of the “green” economy is green technologies aimed at eliminating the causes of environmental problems. It is established that Ukraine’s international obligations to comply with global environmental standards are a crucial element in forming the principles of the “green” economy policy, which are enshrined in acts of national legislation. The main legislative acts covering various aspects of the “economy” policy, in particular environmental protection, energy efficiency, waste management and other areas, are considered. It is concluded that the above-mentioned acts adopted by 2022 emphasize the need to reduce the negative impact on the environment. Attention is draw to the updating of legislation in the field of the “green” economy during martial law in Ukraine. It is noted that an important role in consolidating the legal foundations of the implementation of the “green” economy policy belongs to strategic documents. In particular, attention is focused on the Sustainable Development Goals of Ukraine by 2030, the adoption of which was an important step in the transformation of the institutional mechanism of the “green” economy of the state. A conclusion is made about the further transformation of the legal foundations of the implementation of the “green” economy policy.
- 6 June 2025
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 1,p. 50-56
Open AccessLegal framework for the implementation of the “green” economy policy in Ukraine
The article is devoted to the study of the regulatory framework for the implementation of the “green” economy policy in Ukraine in view of the current state of legal regulation of this area. The methodological basis of the research is the formal-logical and formal-dogmatic methods. It is determined that the development of the “green” economy in Ukraine is a strategically important task for ensuring sustainable development, preserving natural resources and improving the quality of life in the country. This task is especially relevant in the context of the post-war reconstruction of Ukraine, which must comply with the European green and digital agenda. The concept of the “green” economy and its relationship with the concept of “green” growth are studied. It is noted that the basis of the “green” economy is green technologies aimed at eliminating the causes of environmental problems. It is established that Ukraine’s international obligations to comply with global environmental standards are a crucial element in forming the principles of the “green” economy policy, which are enshrined in acts of national legislation. The main legislative acts covering various aspects of the “economy” policy, in particular environmental protection, energy efficiency, waste management and other areas, are considered. It is concluded that the above-mentioned acts adopted by 2022 emphasize the need to reduce the negative impact on the environment. Attention is draw to the updating of legislation in the field of the “green” economy during martial law in Ukraine. It is noted that an important role in consolidating the legal foundations of the implementation of the “green” economy policy belongs to strategic documents. In particular, attention is focused on the Sustainable Development Goals of Ukraine by 2030, the adoption of which was an important step in the transformation of the institutional mechanism of the “green” economy of the state. A conclusion is made about the further transformation of the legal foundations of the implementation of the “green” economy policy.
- Open Access
- 26 May 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 3 (88) , 35-40
Administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy in the aspect of ensuring the economic sustainability of Ukraine: current state
The article is devoted to a comprehensive scientific study of the current state of administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy in ensuring the economic stability of Ukraine by revealing its essence and, accordingly, establishing certain features. Some scientific approaches to defining the concept of the «green» economy of the state are considered, and based on their analysis, one’s own opinion is expressed regarding the interpretation of this concept. It is stated that as of today, administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy in Ukraine is carried out in accordance with the provisions of a set of certain documents aimed at ensuring environmentally balanced economic development of the state. The author’s vision is expressed regarding the disclosure of the essence of the concept of administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy of the state, under which it is proposed to consider a set of administrative and legal norms and mechanisms aimed at integrating the principles of sustainable development and environmental protection into the economic policy of the country. The main characteristics of the administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy of the state are highlighted, namely: integration of environmental standards into the national legal system by including environmental requirements and standards in regulatory legal acts regulating economic processes; stimulation of «green» investments and innovations, which requires the development and implementation of relevant legal norms in order to stimulate investment in environmentally friendly technologies and the development of «green» sectors of the economy; coordination between public and private institutions, which involves interaction between public authorities and the private sector to ensure the effective implementation of «green» initiatives; development of legal infrastructure in order to build legal mechanisms that contribute to the development of the «green» economy; provision of control and supervision mechanisms, which is achieved by creating effective mechanisms of state control and supervision over the implementation of environmental norms and standards, etc.
- 26 May 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 3 (88) , 35-40
Open AccessAdministrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy in the aspect of ensuring the economic sustainability of Ukraine: current state
The article is devoted to a comprehensive scientific study of the current state of administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy in ensuring the economic stability of Ukraine by revealing its essence and, accordingly, establishing certain features. Some scientific approaches to defining the concept of the «green» economy of the state are considered, and based on their analysis, one’s own opinion is expressed regarding the interpretation of this concept. It is stated that as of today, administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy in Ukraine is carried out in accordance with the provisions of a set of certain documents aimed at ensuring environmentally balanced economic development of the state. The author’s vision is expressed regarding the disclosure of the essence of the concept of administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy of the state, under which it is proposed to consider a set of administrative and legal norms and mechanisms aimed at integrating the principles of sustainable development and environmental protection into the economic policy of the country. The main characteristics of the administrative and legal regulation of the «green» economy of the state are highlighted, namely: integration of environmental standards into the national legal system by including environmental requirements and standards in regulatory legal acts regulating economic processes; stimulation of «green» investments and innovations, which requires the development and implementation of relevant legal norms in order to stimulate investment in environmentally friendly technologies and the development of «green» sectors of the economy; coordination between public and private institutions, which involves interaction between public authorities and the private sector to ensure the effective implementation of «green» initiatives; development of legal infrastructure in order to build legal mechanisms that contribute to the development of the «green» economy; provision of control and supervision mechanisms, which is achieved by creating effective mechanisms of state control and supervision over the implementation of environmental norms and standards, etc.
- Open Access
- 18 November 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 2 (85) , 299-304
Peculiarities of receiving, distributing and accounting of international military aid for the security forces and defense forces of Ukraine
The article is devoted to the study of the peculiarities of receiving, distributing and accounting for international military aid for the security and defense forces of Ukraine, taking into account the changes made to the legislation. The meaning of the terms «military property», «property of the Armed Forces of Ukraine», «international military aid» enshrined in the current legislation of Ukraine is disclosed. It is emphasized that despite the definition of the concept of «international military aid» at the sub-legal level, the indication in its content of «other resources not prohibited by law» does not provide a comprehensive answer to the question of what is included in international military aid. It was determined that the military management bodies of the Armed Forces of Ukraine are key entities that organize the receipt and transfer of international military aid by the security and defense forces, while the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine ensures its distribution among military units that are responsible for accounting for such property. It was found that the issue of accounting for international military aid is regulated by an act that regulates the issue of accounting for military property in general. Attention has been drawn to the fact that in the case of receiving international military aid, which cannot be classified as military property in the sense of the legislator, the question of which regulatory act to perform its accounting should be recommended. The expediency of using digital technologies to ensure effective, rational and transparent use of international military aid was emphasized. It was established that three levels of accounting for the supply and use of weapons have actually been launched in Ukraine: the LOGFAS program, the new program for accounting and logistics of military equipment «Korovai» and a module based on the «SOTA» program, and the state of accounting for international military aid with the help of digital technologies is still being improved. It is noted that the LOGFAS program is becoming one of the main tools for digitizing the list of resources available in the Armed Forces of Ukraine, in particular those provided as international military aid, which contributes to effective logistics planning. It was concluded that further analysis of the legal aspects of receiving, distributing and accounting for international military aid to ensure the effectiveness of the processes of providing and using international military aid to Ukraine is an actual direction of scientific research.
- 18 November 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 2 (85) , 299-304
Open AccessPeculiarities of receiving, distributing and accounting of international military aid for the security forces and defense forces of Ukraine
The article is devoted to the study of the peculiarities of receiving, distributing and accounting for international military aid for the security and defense forces of Ukraine, taking into account the changes made to the legislation. The meaning of the terms «military property», «property of the Armed Forces of Ukraine», «international military aid» enshrined in the current legislation of Ukraine is disclosed. It is emphasized that despite the definition of the concept of «international military aid» at the sub-legal level, the indication in its content of «other resources not prohibited by law» does not provide a comprehensive answer to the question of what is included in international military aid. It was determined that the military management bodies of the Armed Forces of Ukraine are key entities that organize the receipt and transfer of international military aid by the security and defense forces, while the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine ensures its distribution among military units that are responsible for accounting for such property. It was found that the issue of accounting for international military aid is regulated by an act that regulates the issue of accounting for military property in general. Attention has been drawn to the fact that in the case of receiving international military aid, which cannot be classified as military property in the sense of the legislator, the question of which regulatory act to perform its accounting should be recommended. The expediency of using digital technologies to ensure effective, rational and transparent use of international military aid was emphasized. It was established that three levels of accounting for the supply and use of weapons have actually been launched in Ukraine: the LOGFAS program, the new program for accounting and logistics of military equipment «Korovai» and a module based on the «SOTA» program, and the state of accounting for international military aid with the help of digital technologies is still being improved. It is noted that the LOGFAS program is becoming one of the main tools for digitizing the list of resources available in the Armed Forces of Ukraine, in particular those provided as international military aid, which contributes to effective logistics planning. It was concluded that further analysis of the legal aspects of receiving, distributing and accounting for international military aid to ensure the effectiveness of the processes of providing and using international military aid to Ukraine is an actual direction of scientific research.
- Open Access
- 12 October 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 5,p. 887-891
International and European standards of regulation of the institute of whistleblowers
The article is devoted to clarifying the peculiarities of the international and European standards of regulation of the institute of whistleblowers. It was found that whistleblowers play an important role in detecting violations that can cause significant damage to society, accordingly, international and European standards protect not only the right of every person to disclose information of public interest, but also the rights of persons who report such information ( whistleblowers). It has been established that the concept of «whistleblower» is most widely interpreted by Directive 2019/1937 of the EU and the Council of the EU on the protection of persons who report violations of Union legislation. It was determined that the standards for the protection of the rights of whistleblowers, but only in the field of corruption, are contained in the UN Convention against Corruption, the Criminal Convention on the Fight against Corruption, the Civil Convention on the Fight against Corruption, among them, in particular, the duty of the states that have joined them to determine the competent authority(ies) for reporting whistleblowers and the ability to provide them with the protection they need. At the same time, attention is focused on the fact that EU Directive 2019/1937, in contrast to the mentioned acts, more broadly defines the standards for the protection of whistleblower rights, in particular: it extends its effect simultaneously to the private and public sectors, provides for the protection of not only persons who report violations, but also of persons who contributed to such a report, relatives, colleagues of whistleblowers, etc., as well as persons who suffered from false reports of whistleblowers, which minimizes abuse of the latter’s status (protection). The essential role of the ECtHR’s practice in establishing standards for the regulation of the whistleblower institute is emphasized. It was found out that the ECtHR determines the very concept of «exposure» as one of the manifestations of freedom of expression, which is guaranteed by Article 10 of the Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms and provides for adequate protection for whistleblowers from arbitrary interference in the exercise of this freedom and retaliation for the consequences of its exercise . Analysis of the practice of the ECtHR shows that the court is gradually expanding the standards of protection of whistleblowers, emphasizing their role in exposing violations in various areas and protecting public interests.
- 12 October 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 5,p. 887-891
Open AccessInternational and European standards of regulation of the institute of whistleblowers
The article is devoted to clarifying the peculiarities of the international and European standards of regulation of the institute of whistleblowers. It was found that whistleblowers play an important role in detecting violations that can cause significant damage to society, accordingly, international and European standards protect not only the right of every person to disclose information of public interest, but also the rights of persons who report such information ( whistleblowers). It has been established that the concept of «whistleblower» is most widely interpreted by Directive 2019/1937 of the EU and the Council of the EU on the protection of persons who report violations of Union legislation. It was determined that the standards for the protection of the rights of whistleblowers, but only in the field of corruption, are contained in the UN Convention against Corruption, the Criminal Convention on the Fight against Corruption, the Civil Convention on the Fight against Corruption, among them, in particular, the duty of the states that have joined them to determine the competent authority(ies) for reporting whistleblowers and the ability to provide them with the protection they need. At the same time, attention is focused on the fact that EU Directive 2019/1937, in contrast to the mentioned acts, more broadly defines the standards for the protection of whistleblower rights, in particular: it extends its effect simultaneously to the private and public sectors, provides for the protection of not only persons who report violations, but also of persons who contributed to such a report, relatives, colleagues of whistleblowers, etc., as well as persons who suffered from false reports of whistleblowers, which minimizes abuse of the latter’s status (protection). The essential role of the ECtHR’s practice in establishing standards for the regulation of the whistleblower institute is emphasized. It was found out that the ECtHR determines the very concept of «exposure» as one of the manifestations of freedom of expression, which is guaranteed by Article 10 of the Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms and provides for adequate protection for whistleblowers from arbitrary interference in the exercise of this freedom and retaliation for the consequences of its exercise . Analysis of the practice of the ECtHR shows that the court is gradually expanding the standards of protection of whistleblowers, emphasizing their role in exposing violations in various areas and protecting public interests.
- Open Access
- 15 July 2024
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 2,p. 42-47
Subjects of attracting and using international military aid in Ukraine
The article is devoted to clarifying the subject composition of the involvement and use of international military aid in Ukraine. It was determined that the relevance of studying this issue is due to the need to minimize corruption risks during the involvement and use of international military aid, as well as to ensure the transparency of these processes in order to build trusting legal relations between Ukraine and the countries that provide such aid. Given the lack of comprehensive research on this issue, the basis of the study is the legislative and by- laws of Ukraine, which define the powers of the entities that participate in the involvement and use of international military aid. It was found that until 2024, despite 2 years of war, the concept of “international military aid” was absent in the legislation of Ukraine, which made it possible and complicated to develop and approve the procedure for attracting and using international military aid. It was emphasized that with the adoption by the government of Resolution No. 168 on February 13, 2024, the powers and limits of responsibility of the subjects of the general (the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, the President of Ukraine, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine) and special (the National Security and Defense Council, the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, the Armed Forces Forces of Ukraine) competence in the field of attraction and use of international military aid. It was concluded that, in practice, the above-mentioned subjects’ implementation of their powers will contribute to the transparent receipt, distribution of such aid, its targeted use, and the preparation of appropriate reporting for partner countries.
- 15 July 2024
- Published by Association of International Educational ミーnd Scientific Cooperation in Visegrad Journal on Human Rights
- No. 2,p. 42-47
Open AccessSubjects of attracting and using international military aid in Ukraine
The article is devoted to clarifying the subject composition of the involvement and use of international military aid in Ukraine. It was determined that the relevance of studying this issue is due to the need to minimize corruption risks during the involvement and use of international military aid, as well as to ensure the transparency of these processes in order to build trusting legal relations between Ukraine and the countries that provide such aid. Given the lack of comprehensive research on this issue, the basis of the study is the legislative and by- laws of Ukraine, which define the powers of the entities that participate in the involvement and use of international military aid. It was found that until 2024, despite 2 years of war, the concept of “international military aid” was absent in the legislation of Ukraine, which made it possible and complicated to develop and approve the procedure for attracting and using international military aid. It was emphasized that with the adoption by the government of Resolution No. 168 on February 13, 2024, the powers and limits of responsibility of the subjects of the general (the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, the President of Ukraine, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine) and special (the National Security and Defense Council, the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, the Armed Forces Forces of Ukraine) competence in the field of attraction and use of international military aid. It was concluded that, in practice, the above-mentioned subjects’ implementation of their powers will contribute to the transparent receipt, distribution of such aid, its targeted use, and the preparation of appropriate reporting for partner countries.
- Open Access
- 11 May 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 507-512
Сorruption risks of attracting and using international aid in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine
The article is devoted to the definition of corruption risks of attracting and using international aid in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine, as well as possible directions for their minimization. The meaning of the concept of «corruption» in the understanding of international institutions (UN, OECD). Emphasis is placed on the institutional, systemic and latent nature of modern corruption, as well as its influence on the development of the military sphere of the state. The types of corruption that take place in the sphere of state security and defense have been clarified: petty, elite, pyramidal. It is emphasized that counteraction to corruption manifestations and risks in the security and defense sector at the departmental level is multifaceted and requires the presence of departmental anti-corruption rule-making, which corresponds to the strategic anti-corruption documents of the state, as well as the activities of special units (departments, services) authorized to detect facts of corruption in the activities of personnel composition and management links of the security and defense sector. It was determined that countering corruption in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine has appropriate institutional and regulatory support. It was noted that one of the issues that hinders the full implementation of the anti-corruption strategy in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine is the lack of a legally defined procedure and channels for whistleblowers to report information with limited access. The classification of corruption risks of attracting and using international aid in the field of security and defense, proposed by NAKO, was considered. It is noted that it is the corruption risks of control over the targeted use of international aid that affect its volume for Ukraine. It was concluded that one of the directions for minimizing corruption risks at all stages of attracting and using international aid in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine is the regulatory support of this area, the development and introduction of appropriate software for proper accounting and monitoring of the use of international aid and transparent reporting for partner countries . The implementation of the mentioned areas will likely affect the amount of international assistance in the field of security and defense received from partner countries. Стаття присвячена визначенню корупційних ризиків залучення та використання міжнародної допомоги у сфері безпеки й оборони України, а також можливих напрямків їх мінімізації. Розкрито зміст поняття «корупція» у розумінні міжнародних інституцій (ООН, ОЕСР). Наголошено на інституціональному, системному та латентному характері сучасної корупції, а також її впливі на розвиток військової сфери держави. З'ясовано типи корупції, які мають місце в сфері безпеки й оборони держави: дрібна, елітна, пірамідальна. Акцентовано, що протидія корупційним проявам і ризикам у секторі безпеки й оборони на відомчому рівні є багатоаспектною та передбачає наявність відомчої нормотворчості антикоруп- ційної діяльності, що відповідає стратегічним антикорупційним документам держави, а також діяльність спеціальних підрозділів (відділів, служб) уповноважених виявляти факти корупції в діяльності особового складу та управлінських ланок сектору безпеки й оборони. Визначено, що протидія корупції в сфері безпеки й оборони України має відповідне інституційне та нормативне забезпечення. Зауважено, що одним із питань, що стримує повноцінну реалізацію ан- тикорупційної стратегії в сфері безпеки й оборони України є відсутність визначеного законом порядку та каналів повідомлення викривачами інформації з обмеженим доступом. Розглянуто запропоновану НАКО класифікацію корупційних ризиків залучення та використання міжнародної допомоги у сфері безпеки та оборони. Зазначено, що саме корупційні ризики контролю за цільовим використанням міжнародної допомоги впливають на її обсяг для України. Зроблено висновок, що одними із напрямків мінімізації корупційних ризиків на всіх етапах залучення та використання міжнародної допомоги у сфері безпеки й оборони України є нормативне забезпечення цієї сфери, розроблення та запровадження відповідного програмного забезпечення для належного обліку і моніторингу використання міжнародної допомоги та...
- 11 May 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 507-512
Open AccessСorruption risks of attracting and using international aid in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine
The article is devoted to the definition of corruption risks of attracting and using international aid in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine, as well as possible directions for their minimization. The meaning of the concept of «corruption» in the understanding of international institutions (UN, OECD). Emphasis is placed on the institutional, systemic and latent nature of modern corruption, as well as its influence on the development of the military sphere of the state. The types of corruption that take place in the sphere of state security and defense have been clarified: petty, elite, pyramidal. It is emphasized that counteraction to corruption manifestations and risks in the security and defense sector at the departmental level is multifaceted and requires the presence of departmental anti-corruption rule-making, which corresponds to the strategic anti-corruption documents of the state, as well as the activities of special units (departments, services) authorized to detect facts of corruption in the activities of personnel composition and management links of the security and defense sector. It was determined that countering corruption in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine has appropriate institutional and regulatory support. It was noted that one of the issues that hinders the full implementation of the anti-corruption strategy in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine is the lack of a legally defined procedure and channels for whistleblowers to report information with limited access. The classification of corruption risks of attracting and using international aid in the field of security and defense, proposed by NAKO, was considered. It is noted that it is the corruption risks of control over the targeted use of international aid that affect its volume for Ukraine. It was concluded that one of the directions for minimizing corruption risks at all stages of attracting and using international aid in the sphere of security and defense of Ukraine is the regulatory support of this area, the development and introduction of appropriate software for proper accounting and monitoring of the use of international aid and transparent reporting for partner countries . The implementation of the mentioned areas will likely affect the amount of international assistance in the field of security and defense received from partner countries. Стаття присвячена визначенню корупційних ризиків залучення та використання міжнародної допомоги у сфері безпеки й оборони України, а також можливих напрямків їх мінімізації. Розкрито зміст поняття «корупція» у розумінні міжнародних інституцій (ООН, ОЕСР). Наголошено на інституціональному, системному та латентному характері сучасної корупції, а також її впливі на розвиток військової сфери держави. З'ясовано типи корупції, які мають місце в сфері безпеки й оборони держави: дрібна, елітна, пірамідальна. Акцентовано, що протидія корупційним проявам і ризикам у секторі безпеки й оборони на відомчому рівні є багатоаспектною та передбачає наявність відомчої нормотворчості антикоруп- ційної діяльності, що відповідає стратегічним антикорупційним документам держави, а також діяльність спеціальних підрозділів (відділів, служб) уповноважених виявляти факти корупції в діяльності особового складу та управлінських ланок сектору безпеки й оборони. Визначено, що протидія корупції в сфері безпеки й оборони України має відповідне інституційне та нормативне забезпечення. Зауважено, що одним із питань, що стримує повноцінну реалізацію ан- тикорупційної стратегії в сфері безпеки й оборони України є відсутність визначеного законом порядку та каналів повідомлення викривачами інформації з обмеженим доступом. Розглянуто запропоновану НАКО класифікацію корупційних ризиків залучення та використання міжнародної допомоги у сфері безпеки та оборони. Зазначено, що саме корупційні ризики контролю за цільовим використанням міжнародної допомоги впливають на її обсяг для України. Зроблено висновок, що одними із напрямків мінімізації корупційних ризиків на всіх етапах залучення та використання міжнародної допомоги у сфері безпеки й оборони України є нормативне забезпечення цієї сфери, розроблення та запровадження відповідного програмного забезпечення для належного обліку і моніторингу використання міжнародної допомоги та...