Klaus Frieler
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Klaus Frieler has a total of 93 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Julia F. Christensen
Max Planck Institute for Empirical Aesthetics
4 shared publications Martin Pfleiderer
4 shared publications- Melanie Wald-Fuhrmann
Max Planck Institute for Empirical Aesthetics
4 shared publications Daniel Müllensiefen
Goldsmiths, University of London, UK
3 shared publications- Ines Schindler
Max Planck Institute for Empirical Aesthetics
3 shared publications - Meghedi Vartanian
Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Across Divides: An Online Cultural Intervention Modulating Affection for An Unfamiliar Culture
This study examined aesthetic judgment as an indicator of emotional connection with an out-group culture. A group of German female participants took part in 16 one-hour online Iranian dance classes during the SARS-CoV-19 pandemic, twice per week, over a 2-month period (October-November 2021). Sophisticated pre-intervention acculturation and expertise assessments ensured that none of the participants had prior knowledge about Iranian culture, nor had travelled to Iran, and had negligible prior dance experience. Aesthetic judgments obtained from the experimental group pre-post intervention for three categories of cultural artifacts were compared to responses of a passive, waiting-list control group (matched on sex, age, socio-economic status, Iranian-German acculturation, nationality, and dance experience). In accordance with our hypotheses, affection increased only for the experimental group, and only for (a) Iranian, but not European dance, and (b) for Iranian, but not European artworks. Conversely, for Iranian and European landscape photographs (control condition) there were no changes in either group. Thus, active, systematic engagement with an out-group cultural practice increased participants’ aesthetic judgments selectively for cultural artifacts from that culture. We discuss how aesthetic judgment may reflect increased emotional connection to the out-group culture against the backdrop of mere exposure theory and embodiment theory. Given the novelty of the paradigm, and the modest sample size (N=38), reflecting financial and logistical constraints, the study’s limitations are discussed as much as its promise. These first results elucidate the relevance of active cultural engagement in the context of current debates on acculturation in multicultural societies.
- 8 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessAcross Divides: An Online Cultural Intervention Modulating Affection for An Unfamiliar Culture
This study examined aesthetic judgment as an indicator of emotional connection with an out-group culture. A group of German female participants took part in 16 one-hour online Iranian dance classes during the SARS-CoV-19 pandemic, twice per week, over a 2-month period (October-November 2021). Sophisticated pre-intervention acculturation and expertise assessments ensured that none of the participants had prior knowledge about Iranian culture, nor had travelled to Iran, and had negligible prior dance experience. Aesthetic judgments obtained from the experimental group pre-post intervention for three categories of cultural artifacts were compared to responses of a passive, waiting-list control group (matched on sex, age, socio-economic status, Iranian-German acculturation, nationality, and dance experience). In accordance with our hypotheses, affection increased only for the experimental group, and only for (a) Iranian, but not European dance, and (b) for Iranian, but not European artworks. Conversely, for Iranian and European landscape photographs (control condition) there were no changes in either group. Thus, active, systematic engagement with an out-group cultural practice increased participants’ aesthetic judgments selectively for cultural artifacts from that culture. We discuss how aesthetic judgment may reflect increased emotional connection to the out-group culture against the backdrop of mere exposure theory and embodiment theory. Given the novelty of the paradigm, and the modest sample size (N=38), reflecting financial and logistical constraints, the study’s limitations are discussed as much as its promise. These first results elucidate the relevance of active cultural engagement in the context of current debates on acculturation in multicultural societies.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
A cross-cultural empirical investigation of aesthetic responses to an Iranian dance style
The empirical aesthetics of dance is a relatively recent field of investigation, and most research has been focused on the aesthetic experience of observers when perceiving different Western dance styles. It is well-known from other domains that prior exposure and familiarity modulate value formation and aesthetic judgment. Dance cultures vary considerably with regard to emotional expressivity and types of movements used. Therefore, we hypothesised that culturally-dependent emotional expressivities and the choice of movements within a choreography would modulate observers’ aesthetic experience. Across three experiments, with a total of 242 Iranian and English participants, we investigated cross-cultural aesthetic judgment to dance movements of an Iranian dance style. We asked how culture group, intended emotional expressivity, type of movement, motion energy and luminance interacted in aesthetic judgments of expressivity, beauty and liking. Taking advantage of a newly developed Iranian dance movement library, we found a general effect of culture and of emotion. Iranians generally rated the stimuli higher than English participants did, and joyful movements were preferred overall. Iranians found lower body and staccato movements more beautiful than English participants did – likely due to the subtle role of lower body movements, unfamiliar to English observers, in Iranian dance. While motion energy (but not luminance) had some influence on aesthetic judgment, intended emotion and movement type were stronger modulators of expressivity, beauty and liking judgments. This Iranian dance style is a largely unknown dance genre in many parts of the world and holds great promise as a subject for empirical aesthetics.
- 29 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perception
Open AccessA cross-cultural empirical investigation of aesthetic responses to an Iranian dance style
The empirical aesthetics of dance is a relatively recent field of investigation, and most research has been focused on the aesthetic experience of observers when perceiving different Western dance styles. It is well-known from other domains that prior exposure and familiarity modulate value formation and aesthetic judgment. Dance cultures vary considerably with regard to emotional expressivity and types of movements used. Therefore, we hypothesised that culturally-dependent emotional expressivities and the choice of movements within a choreography would modulate observers’ aesthetic experience. Across three experiments, with a total of 242 Iranian and English participants, we investigated cross-cultural aesthetic judgment to dance movements of an Iranian dance style. We asked how culture group, intended emotional expressivity, type of movement, motion energy and luminance interacted in aesthetic judgments of expressivity, beauty and liking. Taking advantage of a newly developed Iranian dance movement library, we found a general effect of culture and of emotion. Iranians generally rated the stimuli higher than English participants did, and joyful movements were preferred overall. Iranians found lower body and staccato movements more beautiful than English participants did – likely due to the subtle role of lower body movements, unfamiliar to English observers, in Iranian dance. While motion energy (but not luminance) had some influence on aesthetic judgment, intended emotion and movement type were stronger modulators of expressivity, beauty and liking judgments. This Iranian dance style is a largely unknown dance genre in many parts of the world and holds great promise as a subject for empirical aesthetics.
- Open Access
- 11 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Cultural Cognitive Science
- Vol. 10 (2) , 267-285
Enculturation modulates aesthetic judgments of dance
Seasonal and other festivities with dance and music shape individuals’ aesthetic sensitivity to their cultural heritage. Yet, there is little empirical research about the influence of culture on dance perception. To fill the gap, this paper presents a pre-registered experiment with 120 participants (Iranian, English, Southeast Asian), that investigated the influence of cultural group (categorical variable) and enculturation (continuous variables) on aesthetic judgment to emotionally expressive Iranian classical dance stimuli. We also explored how culture and enculturation modulated responses to the question ‘how important is the cultural heritage of ‘Persian dance’ for you?’. Education, age, motion energy, and aesthetic responsiveness served as covariates across all models. Our data served to explore an important question in cross-cultural empirical aesthetics: which type of variable best predicts the influence of culture on questions about a cultural heritage like dance—categorical or continuous culture variables? Surprisingly, there were no overall differences in aesthetic judgment between the groups, although Iranians and English participants were most sensitive to joyful emotional expressivity of the dancer. Aesthetic judgment was modulated by English, but not Iranian enculturation. Conversely, Iranians found Persian dance more important than did the other two groups. In all analyses, aesthetic responsiveness was a significant covariate, while education, motion energy and age were not. Effect sizes (partial η 2 s and β s) were higher for continuous enculturation measures, than for the categorical variable cultural group . We recommend using continuous enculturation variables in cross-cultural empirical aesthetics research to allow higher granularity when exploring the impact of culture on perception.
- 11 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Cultural Cognitive Science
- Vol. 10 (2) , 267-285
Open AccessEnculturation modulates aesthetic judgments of dance
Seasonal and other festivities with dance and music shape individuals’ aesthetic sensitivity to their cultural heritage. Yet, there is little empirical research about the influence of culture on dance perception. To fill the gap, this paper presents a pre-registered experiment with 120 participants (Iranian, English, Southeast Asian), that investigated the influence of cultural group (categorical variable) and enculturation (continuous variables) on aesthetic judgment to emotionally expressive Iranian classical dance stimuli. We also explored how culture and enculturation modulated responses to the question ‘how important is the cultural heritage of ‘Persian dance’ for you?’. Education, age, motion energy, and aesthetic responsiveness served as covariates across all models. Our data served to explore an important question in cross-cultural empirical aesthetics: which type of variable best predicts the influence of culture on questions about a cultural heritage like dance—categorical or continuous culture variables? Surprisingly, there were no overall differences in aesthetic judgment between the groups, although Iranians and English participants were most sensitive to joyful emotional expressivity of the dancer. Aesthetic judgment was modulated by English, but not Iranian enculturation. Conversely, Iranians found Persian dance more important than did the other two groups. In all analyses, aesthetic responsiveness was a significant covariate, while education, motion energy and age were not. Effect sizes (partial η 2 s and β s) were higher for continuous enculturation measures, than for the categorical variable cultural group . We recommend using continuous enculturation variables in cross-cultural empirical aesthetics research to allow higher granularity when exploring the impact of culture on perception.
- Open Access
- 29 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Music & Science
- Vol. 9
Listener Perception and Musical Structure: A Study of Segmentation in Sonata Form
This study aims to create a dialogue between music psychology and music-theoretical discourse on the perception of musical form. In a lab and online study, we investigated how listeners segment Western classical music in real time, focusing on (1) inter-rater agreement, (2) alignment with music-theoretical analyses of sonata form, (3) subjective qualities of segment boundaries (beginnings, endings, importance ratings), and (4) the effects of repeated listening. Participants listened to two stylistically contrasting orchestral movements—one classicist, early romantic and one romantic work—and marked perceived segment boundaries during two exposures. In line with previous research, results reveal consistent above-chance agreement among listeners, particularly at structurally prominent moments with clear surface cues. While most boundaries aligned with music-theoretical segmentations, others did not, especially when formal boundaries were not reinforced by salient acoustic features. Listeners frequently identified boundaries based on perceived beginnings, but higher agreement was associated with strong endings and higher importance ratings. Exploratory categorization of boundary types revealed a tendency to emphasize transitional moments, suggesting a processual, forward-directed mode of engagement. Repeated listening reduced the number of segmentation responses, but its effect on agreement varied by piece, suggesting that structural clarity and ambiguity modulate how listeners integrate musical form. Findings underscore the importance of both surface salience and formal function in shaping real-time segmentation. We argue for a listener-centered approach to musical form that integrates perceptual and analytical perspectives, and we propose that perceptually salient yet analytically unmarked moments merit greater attention in theories of musical form.
- 29 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Music & Science
- Vol. 9
Open AccessListener Perception and Musical Structure: A Study of Segmentation in Sonata Form
This study aims to create a dialogue between music psychology and music-theoretical discourse on the perception of musical form. In a lab and online study, we investigated how listeners segment Western classical music in real time, focusing on (1) inter-rater agreement, (2) alignment with music-theoretical analyses of sonata form, (3) subjective qualities of segment boundaries (beginnings, endings, importance ratings), and (4) the effects of repeated listening. Participants listened to two stylistically contrasting orchestral movements—one classicist, early romantic and one romantic work—and marked perceived segment boundaries during two exposures. In line with previous research, results reveal consistent above-chance agreement among listeners, particularly at structurally prominent moments with clear surface cues. While most boundaries aligned with music-theoretical segmentations, others did not, especially when formal boundaries were not reinforced by salient acoustic features. Listeners frequently identified boundaries based on perceived beginnings, but higher agreement was associated with strong endings and higher importance ratings. Exploratory categorization of boundary types revealed a tendency to emphasize transitional moments, suggesting a processual, forward-directed mode of engagement. Repeated listening reduced the number of segmentation responses, but its effect on agreement varied by piece, suggesting that structural clarity and ambiguity modulate how listeners integrate musical form. Findings underscore the importance of both surface salience and formal function in shaping real-time segmentation. We argue for a listener-centered approach to musical form that integrates perceptual and analytical perspectives, and we propose that perceptually salient yet analytically unmarked moments merit greater attention in theories of musical form.
- Open Access
- 10 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Affective Science
- Vol. 6 (4) , 647-655
Do Children’s Attachment Security and Empathy Facilitate Story Appreciation?
In a sample of 295 native Farsi speaking children between 6 and 10 years, we investigated to what extent children experienced aesthetic emotions during story listening. Since previous research has shown that aesthetic evaluation has dispositional components, we also investigated the influence of child-reported attachment security and mother-reported child empathy on the experience of aesthetic emotions and story liking. By means of a multiple mediator model, we tested how aesthetic emotions acted as mediators of the relationship of attachment security and empathy with story liking. Results showed that attachment security was related to more pleasing and captivating emotions (with a trend for less negative emotions), and thereby, increased story liking. Empathy was linked to emotions of affinity, but these did not predict story liking, resulting in a nonsignificant effect of empathy on story liking.
- 10 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Affective Science
- Vol. 6 (4) , 647-655
Open AccessDo Children’s Attachment Security and Empathy Facilitate Story Appreciation?
In a sample of 295 native Farsi speaking children between 6 and 10 years, we investigated to what extent children experienced aesthetic emotions during story listening. Since previous research has shown that aesthetic evaluation has dispositional components, we also investigated the influence of child-reported attachment security and mother-reported child empathy on the experience of aesthetic emotions and story liking. By means of a multiple mediator model, we tested how aesthetic emotions acted as mediators of the relationship of attachment security and empathy with story liking. Results showed that attachment security was related to more pleasing and captivating emotions (with a trend for less negative emotions), and thereby, increased story liking. Empathy was linked to emotions of affinity, but these did not predict story liking, resulting in a nonsignificant effect of empathy on story liking.
- 1 August 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts
- Vol. 19 (4) , 597-607
The structure of musical dislikes.
- 1 August 2025
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts
- Vol. 19 (4) , 597-607
The structure of musical dislikes.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2025
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Transactions of the International Society for Music Information Retrieval
- Vol. 8 (1) , 121-139
Interacting with Annotated and Synchronized Music Corpora on the Dezrann Web Platform
Open datasets with annotated corpora are crucial to foster research in music information retrieval (MIR) studies and to disseminate knowledge towards musicians and the general public. Many groups have published corpora, at times accompanied by specific visualization interfaces. However, achieving a cohesive access to such a diverse range of data poses a significant challenge. Dezrann is an open-source web platform to interact with corpora while sharing music and music analysis in the form of scores, images, audio files (waveforms), video files, and annotations. We present how we render through this platform ten curated corpora published in the last years in the MIR community, gathering 1500+ pieces and 35000+ annotations. These corpora include works by Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, and Schubert, lieder from the 19th century by female composers (OpenScore Lieder), jazz solo transcriptions (Weimar Jazz Database), piano rolls (SUPRA), Georgian sacred songs (Erkomaishvili dataset), and Slovenian folk song ballads. Showing these corpora with the cross-modal synchronization enabled by the platform improves the way to hear, study, and annotate music. This opens up new possibilities for corpus annotation and analysis in musicology and computer music research, enhances music education, fosters the promotion of music diversity, and facilitates collaborative score editing and correction.
- 30 May 2025
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Transactions of the International Society for Music Information Retrieval
- Vol. 8 (1) , 121-139
Open AccessInteracting with Annotated and Synchronized Music Corpora on the Dezrann Web Platform
Open datasets with annotated corpora are crucial to foster research in music information retrieval (MIR) studies and to disseminate knowledge towards musicians and the general public. Many groups have published corpora, at times accompanied by specific visualization interfaces. However, achieving a cohesive access to such a diverse range of data poses a significant challenge. Dezrann is an open-source web platform to interact with corpora while sharing music and music analysis in the form of scores, images, audio files (waveforms), video files, and annotations. We present how we render through this platform ten curated corpora published in the last years in the MIR community, gathering 1500+ pieces and 35000+ annotations. These corpora include works by Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, and Schubert, lieder from the 19th century by female composers (OpenScore Lieder), jazz solo transcriptions (Weimar Jazz Database), piano rolls (SUPRA), Georgian sacred songs (Erkomaishvili dataset), and Slovenian folk song ballads. Showing these corpora with the cross-modal synchronization enabled by the platform improves the way to hear, study, and annotate music. This opens up new possibilities for corpus annotation and analysis in musicology and computer music research, enhances music education, fosters the promotion of music diversity, and facilitates collaborative score editing and correction.
- Open Access
- 6 November 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 11 (11) , 241623
Appreciation of singing and speaking voices is highly idiosyncratic
Voice preferences are an integral part of interpersonal interactions and shape how people connect with each other. While a large number of studies have investigated the mechanisms behind (speaking) voice attractiveness, very little research was dedicated to other types of vocalizations. In this Registered Report, we proposed to investigate voice preferences with an integrative approach. To this end, we used a newly recorded and validated stimulus set of contrasting vocalizations by 22 highly trained female singers speaking and singing the same material (in Brazilian Portuguese) in contrasting styles (sung as a lullaby, as a pop song or as an opera aria; and spoken aloud as if directed to an adult audience and as if directed to an infant). We asked 62 participants to rate these vocalizations in terms of how much they liked them; and we compared the amount of shared taste (that is, how much participants agreed in their preferences) across styles. We found highly idiosyncratic preferences across all styles. Our predictions concerning shared taste were not confirmed: although shared taste was higher for lullaby than for pop singing, it was unexpectedly higher for operatic than pop singing, and higher for infant-directed than adult-directed speech. Conversely, our prediction of limited consistency in average preferences for some singers across styles was confirmed, contradicting sexual selection-based ideas of singing and speaking as ‘backup’ signals of individual fitness. Our findings draw attention to the role of individual differences in voice preferences and highlight the need for a broader approach to understanding the underlying mechanisms of voice preferences. Stage 1 recommendation and review history: https://rr.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=357 . Stage 2 recommendation and review history: https://rr.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=802 .
- 6 November 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 11 (11) , 241623
Open AccessAppreciation of singing and speaking voices is highly idiosyncratic
Voice preferences are an integral part of interpersonal interactions and shape how people connect with each other. While a large number of studies have investigated the mechanisms behind (speaking) voice attractiveness, very little research was dedicated to other types of vocalizations. In this Registered Report, we proposed to investigate voice preferences with an integrative approach. To this end, we used a newly recorded and validated stimulus set of contrasting vocalizations by 22 highly trained female singers speaking and singing the same material (in Brazilian Portuguese) in contrasting styles (sung as a lullaby, as a pop song or as an opera aria; and spoken aloud as if directed to an adult audience and as if directed to an infant). We asked 62 participants to rate these vocalizations in terms of how much they liked them; and we compared the amount of shared taste (that is, how much participants agreed in their preferences) across styles. We found highly idiosyncratic preferences across all styles. Our predictions concerning shared taste were not confirmed: although shared taste was higher for lullaby than for pop singing, it was unexpectedly higher for operatic than pop singing, and higher for infant-directed than adult-directed speech. Conversely, our prediction of limited consistency in average preferences for some singers across styles was confirmed, contradicting sexual selection-based ideas of singing and speaking as ‘backup’ signals of individual fitness. Our findings draw attention to the role of individual differences in voice preferences and highlight the need for a broader approach to understanding the underlying mechanisms of voice preferences. Stage 1 recommendation and review history: https://rr.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=357 . Stage 2 recommendation and review history: https://rr.peercommunityin.org/articles/rec?id=802 .
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Brill in Journal of Cognition and Culture
- Vol. 24 (3-4) , 325-372
Enculturation-Acculturation Screening Tools for Empirical Aesthetics Research: a Proof of Principle Study
Grouping research participants by culture or language proficiency may no longer suffice to investigate cognitive universals and differences cross-culturally, due to the interconnectedness of our multicultural world. Based on immigration psychology research, we provide a ‘proof of principle’ for three culture screening tools. Across five online experiments (total N = 440), we developed (1) The Cultural Traditions Questionnaire (CTQ), (2) the Arts Engagement in Childhood Questionnaire (AECQ), and (3) the Enculturation and Acculturation Quiz (EAQ). While these screening tools are tailored to Iranian and English cultures, the procedures provided here are expandable to other cultures. The screening scores predicted emotional attachment to a culture better than traditional variables used in cross-cultural research (self-ascribed culture group, country of residence during formative years, mother tongue). Continuous measures of enculturation and acculturation are potentially better predictors for downstream variables of interest, due to their finer granularity and capability to capture multifaceted cultural identities.
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Brill in Journal of Cognition and Culture
- Vol. 24 (3-4) , 325-372
Enculturation-Acculturation Screening Tools for Empirical Aesthetics Research: a Proof of Principle Study
Grouping research participants by culture or language proficiency may no longer suffice to investigate cognitive universals and differences cross-culturally, due to the interconnectedness of our multicultural world. Based on immigration psychology research, we provide a ‘proof of principle’ for three culture screening tools. Across five online experiments (total N = 440), we developed (1) The Cultural Traditions Questionnaire (CTQ), (2) the Arts Engagement in Childhood Questionnaire (AECQ), and (3) the Enculturation and Acculturation Quiz (EAQ). While these screening tools are tailored to Iranian and English cultures, the procedures provided here are expandable to other cultures. The screening scores predicted emotional attachment to a culture better than traditional variables used in cross-cultural research (self-ascribed culture group, country of residence during formative years, mother tongue). Continuous measures of enculturation and acculturation are potentially better predictors for downstream variables of interest, due to their finer granularity and capability to capture multifaceted cultural identities.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 18 December 2023
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 379 (1895) , 20220424
Parallelisms and deviations: two fundamentals of an aesthetics of poetic diction
Poetic diction routinely involves two complementary classes of features: (i) parallelisms, i.e. repetitive patterns (rhyme, metre, alliteration, etc.) that enhance the predictability of upcoming words, and (ii) poetic deviations that challenge standard expectations/predictions regarding regular word form and order. The present study investigated how these two prediction-modulating fundamentals of poetic diction affect the cognitive processing and aesthetic evaluation of poems, humoristic couplets and proverbs. We developed quantitative measures of these two groups of text features. Across the three text genres, higher deviation scores reduced both comprehensibility and aesthetic liking whereas higher parallelism scores enhanced these. The positive effects of parallelism are significantly stronger than the concurrent negative effects of the features of deviation. These results are in accord with the hypothesis that art reception involves an interplay of prediction errors and prediction error minimization, with the latter paving the way for processing fluency and aesthetic liking. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Art, aesthetics and predictive processing: theoretical and empirical perspectives’.
- 18 December 2023
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 379 (1895) , 20220424
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessParallelisms and deviations: two fundamentals of an aesthetics of poetic diction
Poetic diction routinely involves two complementary classes of features: (i) parallelisms, i.e. repetitive patterns (rhyme, metre, alliteration, etc.) that enhance the predictability of upcoming words, and (ii) poetic deviations that challenge standard expectations/predictions regarding regular word form and order. The present study investigated how these two prediction-modulating fundamentals of poetic diction affect the cognitive processing and aesthetic evaluation of poems, humoristic couplets and proverbs. We developed quantitative measures of these two groups of text features. Across the three text genres, higher deviation scores reduced both comprehensibility and aesthetic liking whereas higher parallelism scores enhanced these. The positive effects of parallelism are significantly stronger than the concurrent negative effects of the features of deviation. These results are in accord with the hypothesis that art reception involves an interplay of prediction errors and prediction error minimization, with the latter paving the way for processing fluency and aesthetic liking. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Art, aesthetics and predictive processing: theoretical and empirical perspectives’.