Amedee Marchand Martella
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Amedee Marchand Martella has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alyssa P. Lawson
University of California Santa Barbara Santa Barbara California USA
3 shared publications - Daniel H. Robinson
The University of Texas at Arlington
2 shared publications - Darryl W. Schneider
Purdue University
2 shared publications - Jane Kinkus Yatcilla
Libraries and School of Information Studies Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USA
2 shared publications Jeffrey D. Karpicke
2 shared publications- Josef Buchner
Institute of Digital and Computer Science Education, St. Gallen University of Teacher Education
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Color Me Confounded: A Critical Analysis of Media Comparisons on ChatGPT in Education
Research on the use of artificial intelligence in education is rapidly accumulating. In the ChatGPT literature, two recent meta-analyses were published (Deng et al., 2025 and Wang & Fan, 2025) that examined media comparisons between ChatGPT and more traditional forms of instruction; both reviews found ChatGPT to improve learning. However, as researchers have found in media comparisons studies (e.g., Clark, 1983; Lawson et al., 2024), instructional methods are often not controlled between conditions, making it difficult to attribute any learning differences to affordances of the medium itself. Therefore, the purpose of our critical review was to examine those media comparisons studies included in Deng et al. (2025) and Wang and Fan (2025) to understand whether the ChatGPT and control conditions were comparable on their instructional features (i.e., matched on instructional methods, practice with the dependent measure, and time spent learning the content). Results indicated a lack of control in the ChatGPT studies that were reviewed, with many studies conflating the use of ChatGPT with other instructional features. Further, across the various direct learning outcomes, studies often did not include enough information to determine the comparability of conditions. For the most common learning outcome (i.e., ChatGPT > Control), comparisons often involved a confound between conditions as well as missing information about instructional features. Therefore, the benefits of ChatGPT must be interpreted with caution at the present time, and more research is needed to determine how, for whom, and under what pedagogical conditions ChatGPT can improve learning.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessColor Me Confounded: A Critical Analysis of Media Comparisons on ChatGPT in Education
Research on the use of artificial intelligence in education is rapidly accumulating. In the ChatGPT literature, two recent meta-analyses were published (Deng et al., 2025 and Wang & Fan, 2025) that examined media comparisons between ChatGPT and more traditional forms of instruction; both reviews found ChatGPT to improve learning. However, as researchers have found in media comparisons studies (e.g., Clark, 1983; Lawson et al., 2024), instructional methods are often not controlled between conditions, making it difficult to attribute any learning differences to affordances of the medium itself. Therefore, the purpose of our critical review was to examine those media comparisons studies included in Deng et al. (2025) and Wang and Fan (2025) to understand whether the ChatGPT and control conditions were comparable on their instructional features (i.e., matched on instructional methods, practice with the dependent measure, and time spent learning the content). Results indicated a lack of control in the ChatGPT studies that were reviewed, with many studies conflating the use of ChatGPT with other instructional features. Further, across the various direct learning outcomes, studies often did not include enough information to determine the comparability of conditions. For the most common learning outcome (i.e., ChatGPT > Control), comparisons often involved a confound between conditions as well as missing information about instructional features. Therefore, the benefits of ChatGPT must be interpreted with caution at the present time, and more research is needed to determine how, for whom, and under what pedagogical conditions ChatGPT can improve learning.
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Computers & Education
- Vol. 254
Color me confounded: A critical analysis of media comparisons on ChatGPT in education
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Computers & Education
- Vol. 254
Color me confounded: A critical analysis of media comparisons on ChatGPT in education
- Open Access
- 23 July 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (8) , 945
First-Year STEM College Students’ Study Strategies: Perceived Effectiveness and Use
Effective studying is important to learn better and increase academic achievement in postsecondary education, which also holds true for the challenging content of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Informed by previous research, this study mainly aimed to investigate first-year STEM college students’ study habits and perceptions of the effectiveness of different study strategies, and the frequency of use of these strategies. To this end, this study employed a cross-sectional survey using the Prolific platform. The results revealed that participants use various study strategies, including more and less effective ones, generally do not study in a planned way nor believe that learning takes hard work, and also prioritize approaching deadlines. The results also showed that the participants (a) frequently use the study strategies that they think are effective, suggesting that perceived effectiveness can have an important role in students’ strategy choice, and (b) mostly use study strategies for studying only or for both studying and while learning for fun. However, the frequency of the use of strategies partially aligned with the perceived effectiveness of the strategies. Overall, these results suggest the need to further investigate the conditions under which college students find study strategies effective, which can affect their choices.
- 23 July 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (8) , 945
Open AccessFirst-Year STEM College Students’ Study Strategies: Perceived Effectiveness and Use
Effective studying is important to learn better and increase academic achievement in postsecondary education, which also holds true for the challenging content of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Informed by previous research, this study mainly aimed to investigate first-year STEM college students’ study habits and perceptions of the effectiveness of different study strategies, and the frequency of use of these strategies. To this end, this study employed a cross-sectional survey using the Prolific platform. The results revealed that participants use various study strategies, including more and less effective ones, generally do not study in a planned way nor believe that learning takes hard work, and also prioritize approaching deadlines. The results also showed that the participants (a) frequently use the study strategies that they think are effective, suggesting that perceived effectiveness can have an important role in students’ strategy choice, and (b) mostly use study strategies for studying only or for both studying and while learning for fun. However, the frequency of the use of strategies partially aligned with the perceived effectiveness of the strategies. Overall, these results suggest the need to further investigate the conditions under which college students find study strategies effective, which can affect their choices.
- Open Access
- 26 September 2024
- Published by IUScholarWorks in Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 24 (3)
A Reflection on the Current State of Active Learning Research
Interest in active learning continues to grow worldwide. Although the large volume of active learning research has provided a myriad of ways to implement active learning in the classroom, the construct remains underdeveloped and difficult to operationalize because of three main issues in the research literature: (a) the variation in active learning activities in research and in practice; (b) the dichotomy between active learning and lecture; and (c) whether “active” in active learning refers to behavioral activity, cognitive activity, or both. The purpose of this reflection article is to articulate these issues so that active learning can move beyond its current status as a “curious construct.” By discussing avenues for future research that address those issues, our goal is to move the field forward by helping researchers focus on why active learning is effective, which forms of it are the most effective, how it should be implemented to maximize learning, and for whom different active learning interventions are the most effective. Just as active learning is easy to prescribe, it should also be easy to implement.
- 26 September 2024
- Published by IUScholarWorks in Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
- Vol. 24 (3)
Open AccessA Reflection on the Current State of Active Learning Research
Interest in active learning continues to grow worldwide. Although the large volume of active learning research has provided a myriad of ways to implement active learning in the classroom, the construct remains underdeveloped and difficult to operationalize because of three main issues in the research literature: (a) the variation in active learning activities in research and in practice; (b) the dichotomy between active learning and lecture; and (c) whether “active” in active learning refers to behavioral activity, cognitive activity, or both. The purpose of this reflection article is to articulate these issues so that active learning can move beyond its current status as a “curious construct.” By discussing avenues for future research that address those issues, our goal is to move the field forward by helping researchers focus on why active learning is effective, which forms of it are the most effective, how it should be implemented to maximize learning, and for whom different active learning interventions are the most effective. Just as active learning is easy to prescribe, it should also be easy to implement.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition
- Vol. 13 (3) , 354-369
Investigating the intensity and integration of active learning and lecture.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition
- Vol. 13 (3) , 354-369
Investigating the intensity and integration of active learning and lecture.
- Open Access
- 22 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 14 (8) , 920
How Scientific Is Cognitive Load Theory Research Compared to the Rest of Educational Psychology?
Cognitive load theory (CLT) has driven numerous empirical studies for over 30 years and is a major theme in many of the most cited articles published between 1988 and 2023. However, CLT articles have not been compared to other educational psychology research in terms of the research designs used and the extent to which recommendations for practice are justified. As Brady and colleagues found, a large percentage of the educational psychology articles reviewed were not experimental and yet frequently made specific recommendations from observational/correlational data. Therefore, in this review, CLT articles were examined with regard to the types of research methodology employed and whether recommendations for practice were justified. Across several educational psychology journals in 2020 and 2023, 16 articles were determined to directly test CLT. In contrast to other articles, which employed mostly observational methods, all but two of the CLT articles employed experimental or intervention designs. For the two CLT articles that were observational, recommendations for practice were not made. Reasons for the importance of experimental work are discussed.
- 22 August 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 14 (8) , 920
Open AccessHow Scientific Is Cognitive Load Theory Research Compared to the Rest of Educational Psychology?
Cognitive load theory (CLT) has driven numerous empirical studies for over 30 years and is a major theme in many of the most cited articles published between 1988 and 2023. However, CLT articles have not been compared to other educational psychology research in terms of the research designs used and the extent to which recommendations for practice are justified. As Brady and colleagues found, a large percentage of the educational psychology articles reviewed were not experimental and yet frequently made specific recommendations from observational/correlational data. Therefore, in this review, CLT articles were examined with regard to the types of research methodology employed and whether recommendations for practice were justified. Across several educational psychology journals in 2020 and 2023, 16 articles were determined to directly test CLT. In contrast to other articles, which employed mostly observational methods, all but two of the CLT articles employed experimental or intervention designs. For the two CLT articles that were observational, recommendations for practice were not made. Reasons for the importance of experimental work are discussed.
- 21 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Psychology Review
- Vol. 36 (3) , 1-25
Identifying the Most Cited Articles and Authors in Educational Psychology Journals from 1988 to 2023
- 21 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Psychology Review
- Vol. 36 (3) , 1-25
Identifying the Most Cited Articles and Authors in Educational Psychology Journals from 1988 to 2023
- Open Access
- 4 November 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Psychology Review
- Vol. 35 (4) , 1-48
How Rigorous is Active Learning Research in STEM Education? An Examination of Key Internal Validity Controls in Intervention Studies
Active learning is a popular approach to teaching and learning that has gained traction through research on STEM educational improvement. There have been numerous university- and national/international-level efforts focused on transitioning courses from the lecture method to active learning. However, despite these large-scale changes, the active learning literature has not been assessed on its methodological rigor to ensure instructional recommendations are rooted in rigorous research studies. The purpose of the present review was to determine areas of strengths and areas in need of improvement and to provide specific recommendations on how to continue or improve active learning research to strengthen the respective literature base and increase confidence in results. We assessed the articles included in the Freeman et al. (PNAS, 111:8410–8415, 2014) meta-analysis as well as a random sample of more recent active learning articles (2015–2022) on 12 internal validity controls (i.e., control procedure used to prevent a threat to the internal validity of a study). Results indicated that there were high percentages of articles that did not meet each internal validity control. In fact, no articles from the Freeman et al. meta-analysis and no sampled 2015–2022 articles met each of the 12 internal validity controls. Therefore, the active learning literature contains numerous internal validity control issues that need to be addressed if we are to determine the extent to which active learning interventions are effective and if there are any boundary conditions for when particular active learning interventions are or are not effective.
- 4 November 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Psychology Review
- Vol. 35 (4) , 1-48
Open AccessHow Rigorous is Active Learning Research in STEM Education? An Examination of Key Internal Validity Controls in Intervention Studies
Active learning is a popular approach to teaching and learning that has gained traction through research on STEM educational improvement. There have been numerous university- and national/international-level efforts focused on transitioning courses from the lecture method to active learning. However, despite these large-scale changes, the active learning literature has not been assessed on its methodological rigor to ensure instructional recommendations are rooted in rigorous research studies. The purpose of the present review was to determine areas of strengths and areas in need of improvement and to provide specific recommendations on how to continue or improve active learning research to strengthen the respective literature base and increase confidence in results. We assessed the articles included in the Freeman et al. (PNAS, 111:8410–8415, 2014) meta-analysis as well as a random sample of more recent active learning articles (2015–2022) on 12 internal validity controls (i.e., control procedure used to prevent a threat to the internal validity of a study). Results indicated that there were high percentages of articles that did not meet each internal validity control. In fact, no articles from the Freeman et al. meta-analysis and no sampled 2015–2022 articles met each of the 12 internal validity controls. Therefore, the active learning literature contains numerous internal validity control issues that need to be addressed if we are to determine the extent to which active learning interventions are effective and if there are any boundary conditions for when particular active learning interventions are or are not effective.
- 6 February 2021
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA) in Review of Educational Research
- Vol. 91 (2) , 272-308
Quotation Accuracy Matters: An Examination of How an Influential Meta-Analysis on Active Learning Has Been Cited
When previous research is cited incorrectly, misinformation can infiltrate scientific discourse and undermine scholarly knowledge. One of the more damaging citation issues involves incorrectly citing article content (called quotation errors); therefore, investigating quotation accuracy is an important research endeavor. One field where quotation accuracy is needed is in the learning sciences given its impact on pedagogy. An integral article in pedagogical discussions surrounding how to teach at the college level is the meta-analysis on active learning by Freeman et al. The Freeman et al. meta-analysis compared active learning to traditional lecture in terms of its effects on student learning and has been important in national initiatives on STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) reform. Given its influence coupled with the impact quotation errors could have in scientific discourse, we used citation context analysis to analyze whether assertions in the citing text that related to the efficacy of lecture and active learning were supported by what was explicitly stated in the cited meta-analysis. Assertions were analyzed under supported, unsupported, or irrelevant for purposes of study categories. The most prevalent supported category related to active learning being more effective than lecture; the most prevalent unsupported category related to the effectiveness of specific activities/approaches other than the general approach of active learning. Overall, the percentage of supported assertions was 47.67%, and the percentage of unsupported assertions was 26.01%. Furthermore, the percentage of articles containing at least one unsupported assertion was 34.77%. Proactive measures are needed to reduce the incidence of quotation errors to ensure robust scientific integrity.
- 6 February 2021
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA) in Review of Educational Research
- Vol. 91 (2) , 272-308
Quotation Accuracy Matters: An Examination of How an Influential Meta-Analysis on Active Learning Has Been Cited
When previous research is cited incorrectly, misinformation can infiltrate scientific discourse and undermine scholarly knowledge. One of the more damaging citation issues involves incorrectly citing article content (called quotation errors); therefore, investigating quotation accuracy is an important research endeavor. One field where quotation accuracy is needed is in the learning sciences given its impact on pedagogy. An integral article in pedagogical discussions surrounding how to teach at the college level is the meta-analysis on active learning by Freeman et al. The Freeman et al. meta-analysis compared active learning to traditional lecture in terms of its effects on student learning and has been important in national initiatives on STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) reform. Given its influence coupled with the impact quotation errors could have in scientific discourse, we used citation context analysis to analyze whether assertions in the citing text that related to the efficacy of lecture and active learning were supported by what was explicitly stated in the cited meta-analysis. Assertions were analyzed under supported, unsupported, or irrelevant for purposes of study categories. The most prevalent supported category related to active learning being more effective than lecture; the most prevalent unsupported category related to the effectiveness of specific activities/approaches other than the general approach of active learning. Overall, the percentage of supported assertions was 47.67%, and the percentage of unsupported assertions was 26.01%. Furthermore, the percentage of articles containing at least one unsupported assertion was 34.77%. Proactive measures are needed to reduce the incidence of quotation errors to ensure robust scientific integrity.