BKBryan Klapes

Bryan Klapes

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Bryan Klapes has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • A contemporary quantitative model for continuous choice under reinforcing and punishing contingencies

    by Bryan Klapes, J. J McDowell

    We developed five novel quantitative models of punishment based on the generalized matching law (GML). Two of the new models were based on Deluty's additive theory of punishment, two were based on de Villiers's subtractive theory of punishment, and the last was based on the concatenated GML (cGML). Using information criteria, we compared the descriptive accuracies of these models against each other and against the GML. To obtain a data set that fairly compared these complex models, we exposed 30 human participants to 36 concurrent random‐interval random‐interval reinforcement schedules via a recently developed rapid‐acquisition operant procedure (procedure for rapidly establishing steady‐state behavior). This experimental design allowed us to fit the models to 30 data sets ranging from 22 to 36 data points each, comparing the models' descriptive accuracy using Akaike information criteria, corrected for small samples (AICc). The punishment model based on the cGML had the lowest AICc value of the set, with an Akaike weight of 0.99. Thus, this cGML‐based punishment model is presumed to be the best contemporary quantitative model of punishment. We discuss the theoretical strengths and weaknesses of these models and future directions of GML‐based punishment model development.


  • A test of the evolutionary theory's account of punishment superimposed on single‐alternative schedules

    by J. J McDowell, Bryan Klapes, Shubhang Arashanapalli

    A test of the evolutionary theory was conducted by replicating Bradshaw et al.'s (1977, 1978, 1979) experiments in which human participants worked on single‐alternative variable‐interval (VI) schedules of reinforcement under three punishment conditions: no punishment, superimposed VI punishment, and superimposed variable‐ratio (VR) punishment. Artificial organisms (AOs) animated by the theory worked in the same environments. Four principal findings were reported for the human participants: (1) their behavior was well described by an hyperbola in all conditions, (2) the asymptote of the hyperbola under VI punishment was equal to the asymptote in the absence of punishment, but the asymptote under VR punishment was lower than the asymptote in the absence of punishment, (3) the parameter in the denominator of the hyperbola was larger under both VI and VR punishment than in the absence of punishment, and (4) response suppression under punishment was greater at lower than at higher reinforcement frequencies. These four outcomes were also observed in the behavior of the AOs working in the same environments, thereby confirming the theory's first‐order predictions about the effects of punishment on single‐alternative responding.


  • Scaling N from 1 to 1,000,000: Application of the Generalized Matching Law to Big Data Contexts

    by David J. Cox, Bryan Klapes, John Michael Falligant

    The generalized matching law (GML) has been used to describe the behavior of individual organisms in operant chambers, artificial environments, and nonlaboratory human settings. Most of these analyses have used a handful of participants to determine how well the GML describes choice in the experimental arrangement or how some experimental manipulation influences estimated matching parameters. Though the GML accounts very well for choice in a variety of contexts, the generality of the GML to all individuals in a population is unknown. That is, no known studies have used the GML to describe the individual behavior of all individuals in a population. This is likely because the data from every individual in the population has not historically been available or because time and computational constraints made population-level analyses prohibitive. In this study, we use open data on baseball pitches to provide an example of how big data methods can be combined with the GML to: (1) scale within-subjects designs to the population level; (2) track individual members of a population over time; (3) easily segment the population into subgroups for further analyses within and between groups; and (4) compare GML fits and estimated parameters to performance. These were accomplished for each of 2,374 individuals in a population using 8,467,473 observations of behavior-environment relationships spanning 11 years. In total, this study is a proof of concept for how behavior analysts can use data-science techniques to extend individual-level quantitative analyses of behavior to the population-level focused on domains of social relevance.


  • Methodological improvements to a Procedure for Rapidly Establishing Steady‐State Behavior

    by Bryan Klapes, Christine L. Ginalis, J. J McDowell

    We performed three experiments to improve the quality and retention of data obtained from a Procedure for Rapidly Establishing Steady‐State Behavior (PRESS‐B; Klapes et al., 2020). In Experiment 1, 120 participants worked on nine concurrent random‐interval random‐interval (conc RI RI) schedules and were assigned to four conditions of varying changeover delay (COD) length. The 0.5‐s COD condition group exhibited the fewest instances of exclusive reinforcer acquisition. Importantly, this group did not differ in generalized matching law (GML) fit quality from the other groups. In Experiment 2, 60 participants worked on nine conc RI RI schedules with a wider range of scheduled reinforcement rate ratios than was used in Experiment 1. Participants showed dramatic reductions in exclusive reinforcer acquisition. Experiment 3 entailed a replication of Experiment 2 wherein blackout periods were implemented between the schedule presentations and each schedule remained in operation until at least one reinforcer was acquired on each alternative. GML fit quality was slightly more consistent in Experiment 3 than in the previous experiments. Thus, these results suggest that future PRESS‐B studies should implement a shorter COD, a wider and richer scheduled reinforcement rate ratio range, and brief blackouts between schedule presentations for optimal data quality and retention.


  • All Behavior is choice: Revisiting an evolutionary theory's account of behavior on single schedules

    by J. J McDowell, Bryan Klapes

    The axiomatic principle that all behavior is choice was incorporated into a revised implementation of an evolutionary theory's account of behavior on single schedules. According to this implementation, target responding occurs in the context of background responding and reinforcement. In Phase 1 of the research, the target responding of artificial organisms (AOs) animated by the revised theory was found to be well described by an exponentiated hyperbola, the parameters of which varied as a function of the background reinforcement rate. In Phase 2, the effect of reinforcer magnitude on the target behavior of the AOs was studied. As in Phase 1, the AOs' behavior was well described by an exponentiated hyperbola, the parameters of which varied with both the target reinforcer magnitude and the background reinforcement rate. Evidence from experiments with live organisms was found to be consistent with the Phase‐1 predictions of the revised theory. The Phase‐2 predictions have not been tested. The revised implementation of the theory can be used to study the effects of superimposing punishment on single‐schedule responding, and it may lead to the discovery of a function that relates response rate to both the rate and magnitude of reinforcement on single schedules.


  • A discriminated rapid‐acquisition laboratory procedure for human continuous choice

    by Bryan Klapes, Olivia L. Calvin, J. J McDowell

    Previous continuous choice laboratory procedures for human participants are either prohibitively time‐intensive or result in inadequate fits of the generalized matching law (GML). We developed a rapid‐acquisition laboratory procedure (Procedure for Rapidly Establishing Steady‐State Behavior, or PRESS‐B) for studying human continuous choice that reduces participant burden and produces data that is well‐described by the GML. To test the procedure, 27 human participants were exposed to 9 independent concurrent random‐interval random‐interval reinforcement schedules over the course of a single, 37‐min session. Fits of the GML to the participants' data accounted for large proportions of variance (median R2: 0.94), with parameter estimates that were similar to those previously found in human continuous choice studies [median a: 0.67; median log(b): ‐0.02]. In summary, PRESS‐B generates human continuous choice behavior in the laboratory that conforms to the GML with limited experimental duration.