Z. Kh. Agamov
Z. Kh. Agamov has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Eugenia Aleksandrovna Berseneva
Federal State Budgetary Institution "National Institute of Quality" of Roszdravnadzor
7 shared publications - Sergey Vladimirovich Umnov
The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
3 shared publications - Ekaterina P. Kakorina
Moscow Regional Research Clinical Institute named after M.F. Vladimirsky
2 shared publications - A. G. Rogovina
N.A. Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health
1 shared publication - A. L. Koshkakaryan
City Polyclinic No. 219 of Moscow Healthcare Department
1 shared publication A. Ye. Yakubova
City Polyclinic No. 115 of Moscow Healthcare Department
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 October 2026
- Published by Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management in City Healthcare
- Vol. 7 (3) , 172-178
Analysis of the Specifics of Doctor-Patient Interaction: Systematic Analysis Experience
Objective. To attempt a systematic analysis of the specifics of doctor-patient interaction. Materials and methods. An analysis of current research by Russian authors was performed. Results. The following constitutive features distinguishing this type of communication from other forms of social interaction are identified: ontological (existential nature), axiological (value conflict and the role of trust), communicative (immanent asymmetry), normative-ethical (dual regulation), and institutional (hybridization of models in modern conditions). Conclusion. The specifics of doctor-patient interaction are systemic in nature and cannot be reduced to the sum of individual factors. Special attention is paid to the transformation of interaction models in modern conditions, including the issue of hybridization of paternalistic, collegial, and consumerist models.
- 11 October 2026
- Published by Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management in City Healthcare
- Vol. 7 (3) , 172-178
Open AccessAnalysis of the Specifics of Doctor-Patient Interaction: Systematic Analysis Experience
Objective. To attempt a systematic analysis of the specifics of doctor-patient interaction. Materials and methods. An analysis of current research by Russian authors was performed. Results. The following constitutive features distinguishing this type of communication from other forms of social interaction are identified: ontological (existential nature), axiological (value conflict and the role of trust), communicative (immanent asymmetry), normative-ethical (dual regulation), and institutional (hybridization of models in modern conditions). Conclusion. The specifics of doctor-patient interaction are systemic in nature and cannot be reduced to the sum of individual factors. Special attention is paid to the transformation of interaction models in modern conditions, including the issue of hybridization of paternalistic, collegial, and consumerist models.
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 29 (7)
Comparative analysis of general practitiones/family doctors and therapists for their patients need in particular specialists consultation
Enhancing the accessibility of primary health care can be achieved through the development of general medical practice. The Moscow healthcare system is a notable example of this initiative, with a unique organizational model that simultaneously operates primary care physicians and general practitioners (GPs or family doctors). However, the professional status of these entities is regulated asymmetrically; a professional standard has been established for primary care physicians, while an analogous framework for GPs has remained in a project stage since 2018. This context necessitates a comparative analysis of the practical aspects of their medical roles, particularly regarding the need for patient consultations with specialist doctors, which holds both scientific and practical significance. Objective. To compare referral needs for consultations with second-level specialists among general practitioners (family doctors) and primary care physicians at a Moscow outpatient clinic. Materials and methods. A retrospective analysis was performed using data from the Unified Medical Information and Analytical System (UMIAS) for the year 2024 at a single city outpatient clinic. The study analyzed the number and structure of referrals made by 50 general practitioners and 110 primary care physicians. Analytical and statistical methods were employed to interpret the data. Results. The proportion of referrals from patient visits was 18.2% for general practitioners, compared with 16.7% for primary care physicians (p=0.018). Moreover, the average number of referrals per general practitioner was significantly higher (712 vs. 505, p<0.05). Notably, the most pronounced differences were observed in referrals to cardiologists and endocrinologists. Compared with 2019, the overall demand for specialist consultations has more than doubled across both physician groups. Conclusion. The findings indicate that the referral workload for general practitioners (family doctors) is statistically significantly higher than that of primary care physicians. The observed twofold increase in referral rates over the past five years aligns with the transition to a referral-based model for accessing specialists. These results suggest an improvement in coordination within primary care settings, despite the ongoing legal ambiguity stemming from the absence of an approved professional standard for general practitioners (family doctors). The necessity of rectifying this regulatory disparity for effective planning of primary health care resources is underscored.
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 29 (7)
Comparative analysis of general practitiones/family doctors and therapists for their patients need in particular specialists consultation
Enhancing the accessibility of primary health care can be achieved through the development of general medical practice. The Moscow healthcare system is a notable example of this initiative, with a unique organizational model that simultaneously operates primary care physicians and general practitioners (GPs or family doctors). However, the professional status of these entities is regulated asymmetrically; a professional standard has been established for primary care physicians, while an analogous framework for GPs has remained in a project stage since 2018. This context necessitates a comparative analysis of the practical aspects of their medical roles, particularly regarding the need for patient consultations with specialist doctors, which holds both scientific and practical significance. Objective. To compare referral needs for consultations with second-level specialists among general practitioners (family doctors) and primary care physicians at a Moscow outpatient clinic. Materials and methods. A retrospective analysis was performed using data from the Unified Medical Information and Analytical System (UMIAS) for the year 2024 at a single city outpatient clinic. The study analyzed the number and structure of referrals made by 50 general practitioners and 110 primary care physicians. Analytical and statistical methods were employed to interpret the data. Results. The proportion of referrals from patient visits was 18.2% for general practitioners, compared with 16.7% for primary care physicians (p=0.018). Moreover, the average number of referrals per general practitioner was significantly higher (712 vs. 505, p<0.05). Notably, the most pronounced differences were observed in referrals to cardiologists and endocrinologists. Compared with 2019, the overall demand for specialist consultations has more than doubled across both physician groups. Conclusion. The findings indicate that the referral workload for general practitioners (family doctors) is statistically significantly higher than that of primary care physicians. The observed twofold increase in referral rates over the past five years aligns with the transition to a referral-based model for accessing specialists. These results suggest an improvement in coordination within primary care settings, despite the ongoing legal ambiguity stemming from the absence of an approved professional standard for general practitioners (family doctors). The necessity of rectifying this regulatory disparity for effective planning of primary health care resources is underscored.
- Open Access
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management in City Healthcare
- Vol. 7 (1) , 54-60
Features of Preparing Patients for Medical and Social Disability Examinations at Moscow Polyclinics
Background. As the life expectancy of citizens increases, non-communicable diseases accumulate, accompanying by persistent functional disorders. The result is a growing number of citizens referred for a medical and social disability examination (MSDE) and, therefore, an expanding workload of primary healthcare organizations in preparing patients for MSDE. In this regard, it is relevant to assess the activities of healthcare organizations in preparing patients for MSDE. Objectiv e. To estimate the volume of care provided to patients during the preparation for MSDE at Moscow polyclinics. Materials and methods . The authors analyzed the electronic health records of outpatients (471 individuals) referred for MSDE, the register of outpatients referred for MSDE, and the results of an interview survey (43 physicians and 123 patients) using analytical and sociological methods. Results . The survey confirmed that the routing of patients preparing for MSDE is characterized by a complex procedure. The average duration of preparation for MSDE was two months, compared to the established deadline of 30 days. Conclusion . The process of preparing citizens for MSDE includes redundant and duplicated doctor’s visits, tests, and examinations. Possible solutions are extending the established deadlines in the regulations, transferring some functions from doctors to nursing staff when referring patients to MSDE, and implementing electronic document management between organizations. These measures have the potential to reduce the number of visits and examinations, shorten the waiting time for care, and increase long-term patient satisfaction.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management in City Healthcare
- Vol. 7 (1) , 54-60
Open AccessFeatures of Preparing Patients for Medical and Social Disability Examinations at Moscow Polyclinics
Background. As the life expectancy of citizens increases, non-communicable diseases accumulate, accompanying by persistent functional disorders. The result is a growing number of citizens referred for a medical and social disability examination (MSDE) and, therefore, an expanding workload of primary healthcare organizations in preparing patients for MSDE. In this regard, it is relevant to assess the activities of healthcare organizations in preparing patients for MSDE. Objectiv e. To estimate the volume of care provided to patients during the preparation for MSDE at Moscow polyclinics. Materials and methods . The authors analyzed the electronic health records of outpatients (471 individuals) referred for MSDE, the register of outpatients referred for MSDE, and the results of an interview survey (43 physicians and 123 patients) using analytical and sociological methods. Results . The survey confirmed that the routing of patients preparing for MSDE is characterized by a complex procedure. The average duration of preparation for MSDE was two months, compared to the established deadline of 30 days. Conclusion . The process of preparing citizens for MSDE includes redundant and duplicated doctor’s visits, tests, and examinations. Possible solutions are extending the established deadlines in the regulations, transferring some functions from doctors to nursing staff when referring patients to MSDE, and implementing electronic document management between organizations. These measures have the potential to reduce the number of visits and examinations, shorten the waiting time for care, and increase long-term patient satisfaction.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management in City Healthcare
- Vol. 6 (2) , 18-24
Some Aspects of Ensuring Access to Health Care in Moscow Polyclinics
Background. Ensuring access to health care is a priority area of development in Russian healthcare. Introducing new organizational technologies along with eliminating medical staff shortages is important to improve access to health care. Doctors provide care at consultations, so they are the polyclinic’s most valuable resource. Therefore, doctors' working time is lost and access to health care is limited when patients fail to show up without canceling an appointment. Purpose. To ensure access to health care by eliminating the loss of doctors' working time due to patient no-shows. Materials. The authors used the results of a facility-based experiment and the data from the Unified Medical Information System (EMIAS) on the number of people who made an appointment with doctors of various specialties at a city polyclinic during one calendar year and the number of people who did not show up for an appointment later. Methods. The authors carried out a facility-based experiment and applied analytical, sociological, and statistical methods. Results. The percentage of people who pre-registered to an appointment with a doctor but subsequently failed to show up for it at a Moscow polyclinic ranged from 9% to 18.9%, depending on the medical specialty. During a facility-based experiment, the nurses of an urology office called patients who had made an appointment with a urologist to confirm their attendance. The experiment enabled to reduce the proportion of missed appointments from 13 to 3.4% (p < 0.001). Conclusion. Preliminary communication between patients who have made an appointment with doctors, and polyclinic’s healthcare workers who call patients to remind them about appointments and receive their confirmation or refusal to show up for an appointment is proved to be efficient to ensure access to health care in Moscow polyclinics.
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Research Institute for Healthcare Organization and Medical Management in City Healthcare
- Vol. 6 (2) , 18-24
Open AccessSome Aspects of Ensuring Access to Health Care in Moscow Polyclinics
Background. Ensuring access to health care is a priority area of development in Russian healthcare. Introducing new organizational technologies along with eliminating medical staff shortages is important to improve access to health care. Doctors provide care at consultations, so they are the polyclinic’s most valuable resource. Therefore, doctors' working time is lost and access to health care is limited when patients fail to show up without canceling an appointment. Purpose. To ensure access to health care by eliminating the loss of doctors' working time due to patient no-shows. Materials. The authors used the results of a facility-based experiment and the data from the Unified Medical Information System (EMIAS) on the number of people who made an appointment with doctors of various specialties at a city polyclinic during one calendar year and the number of people who did not show up for an appointment later. Methods. The authors carried out a facility-based experiment and applied analytical, sociological, and statistical methods. Results. The percentage of people who pre-registered to an appointment with a doctor but subsequently failed to show up for it at a Moscow polyclinic ranged from 9% to 18.9%, depending on the medical specialty. During a facility-based experiment, the nurses of an urology office called patients who had made an appointment with a urologist to confirm their attendance. The experiment enabled to reduce the proportion of missed appointments from 13 to 3.4% (p < 0.001). Conclusion. Preliminary communication between patients who have made an appointment with doctors, and polyclinic’s healthcare workers who call patients to remind them about appointments and receive their confirmation or refusal to show up for an appointment is proved to be efficient to ensure access to health care in Moscow polyclinics.
- Open Access
- 12 July 2024
- Published by Reaviz Medical University in Bulletin of the Medical Institute "REAVIZ" (REHABILITATION, DOCTOR AND HEALTH)
- Vol. 14 (3) , 151-155
Main trends in providing medical personnel to the state healthcare system of the Russian Federation
The purpose of this study is to analyze trends in the provision of medical personnel to the state health care system during the implementation of state programs and national projects in the field of health care. Materials and methods. Statistical collections of the Ministry of Health of Russia for 2012–2023, regulatory legal acts, passport of national project. Methods of descriptive statistics and analytical were used. Results. A reduction in indicators of the supply of doctors, paramedical personnel and the ratio of doctor/nursing medical personnel and a discrepancy between their target values established in state programs and national projects for the development of healthcare was revealed. Differences in the values of target indicators of state programs and national projects have been identified. Conclusion. The need to take urgent measures to eliminate the reduction in the supply of medical personnel has been identified. Differences in the dynamics of staffing indicators indicate the heterogeneity of the level of development of regions and their preparedness for events within the framework of state programs and national projects to achieve target indicators. Measures are needed to eliminate territorial imbalances, as well as to search for mechanisms to equalize differences between the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. Differences in the values of indicators for achieving the goals of state programs and national projects complicate their assessment and determine the need to form a hierarchy of state programs and national projects, as well as the development of scientifically based target indicators, taking into account regional characteristics and the needs of the population for medical care.
- 12 July 2024
- Published by Reaviz Medical University in Bulletin of the Medical Institute "REAVIZ" (REHABILITATION, DOCTOR AND HEALTH)
- Vol. 14 (3) , 151-155
Open AccessMain trends in providing medical personnel to the state healthcare system of the Russian Federation
The purpose of this study is to analyze trends in the provision of medical personnel to the state health care system during the implementation of state programs and national projects in the field of health care. Materials and methods. Statistical collections of the Ministry of Health of Russia for 2012–2023, regulatory legal acts, passport of national project. Methods of descriptive statistics and analytical were used. Results. A reduction in indicators of the supply of doctors, paramedical personnel and the ratio of doctor/nursing medical personnel and a discrepancy between their target values established in state programs and national projects for the development of healthcare was revealed. Differences in the values of target indicators of state programs and national projects have been identified. Conclusion. The need to take urgent measures to eliminate the reduction in the supply of medical personnel has been identified. Differences in the dynamics of staffing indicators indicate the heterogeneity of the level of development of regions and their preparedness for events within the framework of state programs and national projects to achieve target indicators. Measures are needed to eliminate territorial imbalances, as well as to search for mechanisms to equalize differences between the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. Differences in the values of indicators for achieving the goals of state programs and national projects complicate their assessment and determine the need to form a hierarchy of state programs and national projects, as well as the development of scientifically based target indicators, taking into account regional characteristics and the needs of the population for medical care.
- 22 February 2024
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 27 (2)
Morbidity of the HIV infection in the Kursk region public from 2011 to 2022 years
One of the most important ways of HIV infection early diagnosis is population screening. During the pandemic of novel coronavirus infection, carrying out of medical check-ups and annual preventive medical examinations were suspended. OBJECTIVE To analyze the dynamics of morbidity and HIV infection incidence in the Kursk region before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. MATERIAL AND METHODS The analysis of newsletters data of Central Research Institute of Epidemiology, Center for AIDS Prevention and Control «Kursk Regional Multidisciplinary Clinical Hospital» has been carried out. Methods of descriptive and analytical statistics were used for statistical data processing. The differences were considered statistically significant at pppp<0.001). In 2020 yr., during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people examined for antibodies to HIV infection in the Kursk region decreased sharply, as the medical check-ups and annual preventive medical examinations were suspended. The number of new cases of HIV antibody detection per 100.000 tested population decreased steadily. CONCLUSION The detection of new HIV infection cases was complicated during the COVID-19 pandemic. These data are confirmed by the decline in the number of surveyed population, which may have contributed to a decline in HIV infection rates. However, the number of new HIV antibody detection cases per 100.000 of the examined population in the Kursk region has been decreasing steadily. This indicates a true decrease in the number of new HIV infection cases.
- 22 February 2024
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 27 (2)
Morbidity of the HIV infection in the Kursk region public from 2011 to 2022 years
One of the most important ways of HIV infection early diagnosis is population screening. During the pandemic of novel coronavirus infection, carrying out of medical check-ups and annual preventive medical examinations were suspended. OBJECTIVE To analyze the dynamics of morbidity and HIV infection incidence in the Kursk region before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. MATERIAL AND METHODS The analysis of newsletters data of Central Research Institute of Epidemiology, Center for AIDS Prevention and Control «Kursk Regional Multidisciplinary Clinical Hospital» has been carried out. Methods of descriptive and analytical statistics were used for statistical data processing. The differences were considered statistically significant at pppp<0.001). In 2020 yr., during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people examined for antibodies to HIV infection in the Kursk region decreased sharply, as the medical check-ups and annual preventive medical examinations were suspended. The number of new cases of HIV antibody detection per 100.000 tested population decreased steadily. CONCLUSION The detection of new HIV infection cases was complicated during the COVID-19 pandemic. These data are confirmed by the decline in the number of surveyed population, which may have contributed to a decline in HIV infection rates. However, the number of new HIV antibody detection cases per 100.000 of the examined population in the Kursk region has been decreasing steadily. This indicates a true decrease in the number of new HIV infection cases.
- 28 December 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 26 (12)
Assessment of medical organizations managers in personnel management literacy
Effective personnel management is a key professional attribute of managers in the healthcare system. Despite the specifics of management in medical organizations, basic management knowledge remains relevant for all managers, regardless of the economic sector. However, the basic competence of medical organizations’ managers is given undeservedly little attention. We developed a basic competence assessment tool and used it to test the managers of medical organizations. Objective. To assess managers for competence in personnel management and conduct a comparative analysis of the performance of managers depending on various characteristics (gender, age, work experience, etc.). Material and methods. The test «Competence of managers in personnel management» (CMPM-test) has been developed, which identifies areas of development of the manager and highlights topics for further training on personnel management. The test includes 79 questions divided into 6 groups. One hundred eighty-six volunteers were surveyed online using the test. Results. The results indicate different competence levels of managers, although in general it scored low in all respondents. Female respondents performed better than male ones. Similarly, respondents with secondary education performed better than those with university degrees. Respondents who received additional training were more competent. Depending on the work experience, the following patterns were observed: a higher competence among managers with 11-15 years of experience (the highest results) compared to young professionals (total work experience up to 10 years), a lower percentage of correct answers and the lowest level of competence among managers with a total work experience of 31-35 years and more than 36 years. Conclusions. Differences in the competence level of managers in personnel management were revealed depending on gender, education, additional training, and work experience. To explain these differences, more research is needed accounting for other factors that might have affected the results obtained.
- 28 December 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 26 (12)
Assessment of medical organizations managers in personnel management literacy
Effective personnel management is a key professional attribute of managers in the healthcare system. Despite the specifics of management in medical organizations, basic management knowledge remains relevant for all managers, regardless of the economic sector. However, the basic competence of medical organizations’ managers is given undeservedly little attention. We developed a basic competence assessment tool and used it to test the managers of medical organizations. Objective. To assess managers for competence in personnel management and conduct a comparative analysis of the performance of managers depending on various characteristics (gender, age, work experience, etc.). Material and methods. The test «Competence of managers in personnel management» (CMPM-test) has been developed, which identifies areas of development of the manager and highlights topics for further training on personnel management. The test includes 79 questions divided into 6 groups. One hundred eighty-six volunteers were surveyed online using the test. Results. The results indicate different competence levels of managers, although in general it scored low in all respondents. Female respondents performed better than male ones. Similarly, respondents with secondary education performed better than those with university degrees. Respondents who received additional training were more competent. Depending on the work experience, the following patterns were observed: a higher competence among managers with 11-15 years of experience (the highest results) compared to young professionals (total work experience up to 10 years), a lower percentage of correct answers and the lowest level of competence among managers with a total work experience of 31-35 years and more than 36 years. Conclusions. Differences in the competence level of managers in personnel management were revealed depending on gender, education, additional training, and work experience. To explain these differences, more research is needed accounting for other factors that might have affected the results obtained.
- 22 April 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 26 (4)
Blockchain technology in healthcare digitalization
In recent years, digitalization has become one of the key areas for the healthcare system development. Blockchain technology is one of the most promising for meeting the challenge. It allows for improving the protection of patients’ personal data and significantly changes the very structure of the healthcare system, simplifying the interaction of individual doctors and organizations with each other and patients. Objective. To study individual cases and prospects for introducing blockchain technology into the healthcare system for digitalization in the Russian Federation. Material and methods. According to the study’s objective, a search for publications was carried out using the following electronic resources: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov and https://elibrary.ru. We found 1.435 and 4.615 sources, respectively. In addition, a search was conducted in various media. Results. We found many cases of blockchain use in healthcare, both in the commercial and public sectors. We identified three areas: interaction with patients, interaction within the healthcare system, and research. Blockchain technology is now considered a potential tool for encrypting data and protecting patient privacy. In addition, blockchain technology can simplify the work with morbidity statistics, increase the reliability of medical databases, and make scientific research more open. Conclusions. The potential of blockchain technology in healthcare is significant. It can protect patients’ personal data and improve the reliability of databases, simplify communication between doctors of different specialties and doctors with patients, maintain morbidity statistics, improve the reproducibility of scientific research, and much more. In some countries, blockchain technology is integrated into national healthcare systems; in Russia, startups and technology companies are actively developing this technology. However, the true potential of blockchain technology can be shown when it is implemented throughout the country, which requires a digital infrastructure currently absent in Russia.
- 22 April 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 26 (4)
Blockchain technology in healthcare digitalization
In recent years, digitalization has become one of the key areas for the healthcare system development. Blockchain technology is one of the most promising for meeting the challenge. It allows for improving the protection of patients’ personal data and significantly changes the very structure of the healthcare system, simplifying the interaction of individual doctors and organizations with each other and patients. Objective. To study individual cases and prospects for introducing blockchain technology into the healthcare system for digitalization in the Russian Federation. Material and methods. According to the study’s objective, a search for publications was carried out using the following electronic resources: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov and https://elibrary.ru. We found 1.435 and 4.615 sources, respectively. In addition, a search was conducted in various media. Results. We found many cases of blockchain use in healthcare, both in the commercial and public sectors. We identified three areas: interaction with patients, interaction within the healthcare system, and research. Blockchain technology is now considered a potential tool for encrypting data and protecting patient privacy. In addition, blockchain technology can simplify the work with morbidity statistics, increase the reliability of medical databases, and make scientific research more open. Conclusions. The potential of blockchain technology in healthcare is significant. It can protect patients’ personal data and improve the reliability of databases, simplify communication between doctors of different specialties and doctors with patients, maintain morbidity statistics, improve the reproducibility of scientific research, and much more. In some countries, blockchain technology is integrated into national healthcare systems; in Russia, startups and technology companies are actively developing this technology. However, the true potential of blockchain technology can be shown when it is implemented throughout the country, which requires a digital infrastructure currently absent in Russia.
- 12 April 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 26 (3)
Development of a process algorithm for providing specialized neurosurgical care to patients with spinal cord injury in a multidisciplinary hospital
Methods of process management as elements of informatization and digitalization are now increasingly being introduced into the management system of medical organizations. The advantage of process management is its continuity due to the combination and interaction of individual processes in the general information system. The peculiarity of the health care system is its extension and versatility, leading to specific difficulties in solving the problems of ensuring the quality and safety of medical activities and requiring the availability of a scientifically based methodology of process management and methods adapted to the features of Russian medical organizations. Theoretical and methodological aspects of process management are widely described in domestic and foreign studies. However, in the scientific literature, there are no studies on organizing the provision of certain types of medical care, particularly neurosurgery. Therefore, developing organizational methods for neurosurgical care based on the process approach is relevant.
- 12 April 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 26 (3)
Development of a process algorithm for providing specialized neurosurgical care to patients with spinal cord injury in a multidisciplinary hospital
Methods of process management as elements of informatization and digitalization are now increasingly being introduced into the management system of medical organizations. The advantage of process management is its continuity due to the combination and interaction of individual processes in the general information system. The peculiarity of the health care system is its extension and versatility, leading to specific difficulties in solving the problems of ensuring the quality and safety of medical activities and requiring the availability of a scientifically based methodology of process management and methods adapted to the features of Russian medical organizations. Theoretical and methodological aspects of process management are widely described in domestic and foreign studies. However, in the scientific literature, there are no studies on organizing the provision of certain types of medical care, particularly neurosurgery. Therefore, developing organizational methods for neurosurgical care based on the process approach is relevant.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 25 (10)
Expertise of managers of medical organizations in personnel management
Повышение эффективности управления персоналом особенно актуально для сферы здравоохранения, в которой главный ресурс — это люди. В то же время необходимо учитывать, что медицинские организации обладают своей спецификой. В связи с этим сложно оценить компетентность руководителей в сфере управления персоналом, подход к которой отличается в разных странах. Эту проблему усугубляет отсутствие общепринятого набора компетенций, которыми должны обладать руководители, единой интерпретации и способов их оценки. ЦЕЛЬ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЯ Проанализировать существующие перечни компетенций руководителей медицинских организаций в области управления персоналом и сформировать предложения для дополнения и уточнения единого перечня с учетом мировой и отечественной практики в качестве основы для разработки программ подготовки менеджеров в здравоохранении. МАТЕРИАЛ И МЕТОДЫ В соответствии с целью исследования проведен поиск публикаций в электронных ресурсах https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov и https://elibrary.ru. РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ Различные организации предлагают свои варианты общих перечней компетенций, на основе которых возможна разработка инструментов с учетом проблем и запросов конкретных медицинских учреждений. Часто перечни компетенций отличаются на уровне не только национальных систем здравоохранения, но даже отдельных организаций. С одной стороны, это приводит к разнообразию методов оценки, позволяя подобрать наиболее подходящий под задачи вариант. С другой стороны, в отсутствие общепринятого и универсального подхода не представляется возможным сравнить и оценить компетентность руководителей различных организаций в разных странах, предложить способы улучшения сложившихся методов управления. ВЫВОДЫ Для построения эффективной системы управления кадровыми ресурсами необходимо сформировать четкий перечень компетенций руководителей. Важно выделить в отдельный блок те компетенции, которые связаны со сферой управления персоналом. Наиболее понятной и подходящей структурой этого блока может быть структура кадрового цикла, которая связана непосредственно с практической деятельностью руководителя. Необходимо разработать и улучшить существующие методы оценки компетенций, в том числе в сфере управления персоналом.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Preventive Medicine
- Vol. 25 (10)
Expertise of managers of medical organizations in personnel management
Повышение эффективности управления персоналом особенно актуально для сферы здравоохранения, в которой главный ресурс — это люди. В то же время необходимо учитывать, что медицинские организации обладают своей спецификой. В связи с этим сложно оценить компетентность руководителей в сфере управления персоналом, подход к которой отличается в разных странах. Эту проблему усугубляет отсутствие общепринятого набора компетенций, которыми должны обладать руководители, единой интерпретации и способов их оценки. ЦЕЛЬ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЯ Проанализировать существующие перечни компетенций руководителей медицинских организаций в области управления персоналом и сформировать предложения для дополнения и уточнения единого перечня с учетом мировой и отечественной практики в качестве основы для разработки программ подготовки менеджеров в здравоохранении. МАТЕРИАЛ И МЕТОДЫ В соответствии с целью исследования проведен поиск публикаций в электронных ресурсах https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov и https://elibrary.ru. РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ Различные организации предлагают свои варианты общих перечней компетенций, на основе которых возможна разработка инструментов с учетом проблем и запросов конкретных медицинских учреждений. Часто перечни компетенций отличаются на уровне не только национальных систем здравоохранения, но даже отдельных организаций. С одной стороны, это приводит к разнообразию методов оценки, позволяя подобрать наиболее подходящий под задачи вариант. С другой стороны, в отсутствие общепринятого и универсального подхода не представляется возможным сравнить и оценить компетентность руководителей различных организаций в разных странах, предложить способы улучшения сложившихся методов управления. ВЫВОДЫ Для построения эффективной системы управления кадровыми ресурсами необходимо сформировать четкий перечень компетенций руководителей. Важно выделить в отдельный блок те компетенции, которые связаны со сферой управления персоналом. Наиболее понятной и подходящей структурой этого блока может быть структура кадрового цикла, которая связана непосредственно с практической деятельностью руководителя. Необходимо разработать и улучшить существующие методы оценки компетенций, в том числе в сфере управления персоналом.