Joshua R. Tatz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Joshua R. Tatz has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Zehra F. Peynircioğlu
Department of Psychology, https://dx.doi.org/8363American University, Washington, DC 20016, USA
5 shared publications- Jan R. Wessel
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52240
3 shared publications Madeline O. Carlson
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa, United States
2 shared publicationsMatthew A. Howard
Department of Neurosurgery, Carver College of Medicine, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA
2 shared publications- Nicholas T. Trapp
Department of Psychiatry, University of Iowa , Iowa City, IA 52242
2 shared publications - Umair Hassan
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
iTBS induces a suppression-rebound pattern in human cortical excitability
Intermittent theta burst stimulation (iTBS) is a widely used form of brain stimulation, developed on the premise that it promotes long-term potentiation (LTP) and neural excitation. However, this is not validated in higher-order neocortex, and evidence suggests its excitatory properties may have been overstated. To address this, we recruited 20 neurosurgical patients to undergo sessions of intracranial iTBS to varied targets. We probed changes in cortical reactivity with single pulse electrical stimulation, finding that iTBS resulted in approximately 1 minute of decreased cortical reactivity in the theta and high-frequency ranges in regions strongly connected to the stimulation site. However, we observed a subsequent rise in reactivity leading up to the next iTBS session with parallel changes in resting state excitation/inhibition balance. Finally, we generalized these findings to 3 neurosurgical patients who underwent iTBS delivered by transcranial magnetic stimulation, demonstrating a similar suppression-rebound pattern. Our results suggest iTBS promotes a dynamic process of cortical suppression followed by rebound increases in excitability.
Open AccessiTBS induces a suppression-rebound pattern in human cortical excitability
Intermittent theta burst stimulation (iTBS) is a widely used form of brain stimulation, developed on the premise that it promotes long-term potentiation (LTP) and neural excitation. However, this is not validated in higher-order neocortex, and evidence suggests its excitatory properties may have been overstated. To address this, we recruited 20 neurosurgical patients to undergo sessions of intracranial iTBS to varied targets. We probed changes in cortical reactivity with single pulse electrical stimulation, finding that iTBS resulted in approximately 1 minute of decreased cortical reactivity in the theta and high-frequency ranges in regions strongly connected to the stimulation site. However, we observed a subsequent rise in reactivity leading up to the next iTBS session with parallel changes in resting state excitation/inhibition balance. Finally, we generalized these findings to 3 neurosurgical patients who underwent iTBS delivered by transcranial magnetic stimulation, demonstrating a similar suppression-rebound pattern. Our results suggest iTBS promotes a dynamic process of cortical suppression followed by rebound increases in excitability.
- Open Access
Resting bilateral sensorimotor mu rhythm suppression facilitates ipsilesional M1 excitability after stroke
Objective: Stroke-related corticospinal tract (CST) disruption causes lasting hand impairments, but many stroke survivors retain some residual CST connections. In neurotypical adults, motor cortex (M1) TMS interventions can strengthen CST transmission when coupled to EEG brain states reflecting heightened M1 excitability. Because stroke alters the relationship between these brain states and cortical excitability, we aimed to identify poststroke brain states that accurately capture ipsilesional M1 excitability. We hypothesized that heightened ipsilesional M1 excitability would be represented by a common, group-level EEG pattern and a participant- specific, personalized pattern. Methods: We acquired single-pulse TMS-EEG-EMG datasets in 15 chronic stroke survivors with residual CST connections. We then identified group-level and individual-specific EEG power patterns that distinguished between high and low ipsilesional M1 excitability states. Results: At the group level, bilateral sensorimotor mu power was significantly suppressed during high versus low excitability states, but this suppression did not correlate with hand impairment severity or trait-level ipsilesional M1 excitability. At the individual level, spatiotemporally varied EEG activity patterns distinguished between excitability states, but these patterns were only present in 60% of individuals. Conclusion and Significance: This study is the first to systematically characterize poststroke EEG brain states reflecting ipsilesional M1 excitability. Findings suggest that individual-specific EEG patterns may inconsistently index ipsilesional M1 excitability and instead identify bilateral sensorimotor mu power suppression as a group-level excitability marker that is present across the full spectrum of poststroke hand impairment. Highlights: We analyzed TMS-EEG-EMG to identify group and individual level ipsilesional motor cortical excitability states in chronic stroke Bilateral sensorimotor mu suppression marked heightened ipsilesional motor cortical excitability across hand impairment severity 60% participants had individual level scalp patterns linked to motor cortical excitability states, challenging their reliability
Open AccessResting bilateral sensorimotor mu rhythm suppression facilitates ipsilesional M1 excitability after stroke
Objective: Stroke-related corticospinal tract (CST) disruption causes lasting hand impairments, but many stroke survivors retain some residual CST connections. In neurotypical adults, motor cortex (M1) TMS interventions can strengthen CST transmission when coupled to EEG brain states reflecting heightened M1 excitability. Because stroke alters the relationship between these brain states and cortical excitability, we aimed to identify poststroke brain states that accurately capture ipsilesional M1 excitability. We hypothesized that heightened ipsilesional M1 excitability would be represented by a common, group-level EEG pattern and a participant- specific, personalized pattern. Methods: We acquired single-pulse TMS-EEG-EMG datasets in 15 chronic stroke survivors with residual CST connections. We then identified group-level and individual-specific EEG power patterns that distinguished between high and low ipsilesional M1 excitability states. Results: At the group level, bilateral sensorimotor mu power was significantly suppressed during high versus low excitability states, but this suppression did not correlate with hand impairment severity or trait-level ipsilesional M1 excitability. At the individual level, spatiotemporally varied EEG activity patterns distinguished between excitability states, but these patterns were only present in 60% of individuals. Conclusion and Significance: This study is the first to systematically characterize poststroke EEG brain states reflecting ipsilesional M1 excitability. Findings suggest that individual-specific EEG patterns may inconsistently index ipsilesional M1 excitability and instead identify bilateral sensorimotor mu power suppression as a group-level excitability marker that is present across the full spectrum of poststroke hand impairment. Highlights: We analyzed TMS-EEG-EMG to identify group and individual level ipsilesional motor cortical excitability states in chronic stroke Bilateral sensorimotor mu suppression marked heightened ipsilesional motor cortical excitability across hand impairment severity 60% participants had individual level scalp patterns linked to motor cortical excitability states, challenging their reliability
- Open Access
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
One-Day Intracranial Accelerated iTBS: Antidepressant Effects and Mechanistic Insights from a Patient with Major Depression and Epilepsy
Major depression is debilitating and often resistant to pharmacological intervention. Accelerated, transcranial magnetic stimulation protocols involving intermittent theta-burst stimulation (iTBS) to dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) can produce rapid antidepressant effects, but durability is limited and repeated treatments are often necessary. In the present case study, we evaluated a novel therapeutic strategy involving a 20-session, single-day accelerated iTBS protocol delivered via invasive intracranial stimulation to DLPFC in a patient with depression undergoing intracranial monitoring for treatment-refractory epilepsy. Depression remitted, with symptom reduction persisting for at least nine weeks. Indices of modulation near the DLPFC stimulation site included enhanced theta oscillations in DLPFC, increased single unit firing rates in bilateral hippocampi, and changes in cortico-cortical evoked potentials (CCEPs) in the DLPFC, with early and late components showing different effects. Together, these findings provide proof-of-concept for intracranial iTBS as a therapeutic approach with novel insight into its local and network-level neuromodulatory effects.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessOne-Day Intracranial Accelerated iTBS: Antidepressant Effects and Mechanistic Insights from a Patient with Major Depression and Epilepsy
Major depression is debilitating and often resistant to pharmacological intervention. Accelerated, transcranial magnetic stimulation protocols involving intermittent theta-burst stimulation (iTBS) to dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) can produce rapid antidepressant effects, but durability is limited and repeated treatments are often necessary. In the present case study, we evaluated a novel therapeutic strategy involving a 20-session, single-day accelerated iTBS protocol delivered via invasive intracranial stimulation to DLPFC in a patient with depression undergoing intracranial monitoring for treatment-refractory epilepsy. Depression remitted, with symptom reduction persisting for at least nine weeks. Indices of modulation near the DLPFC stimulation site included enhanced theta oscillations in DLPFC, increased single unit firing rates in bilateral hippocampi, and changes in cortico-cortical evoked potentials (CCEPs) in the DLPFC, with early and late components showing different effects. Together, these findings provide proof-of-concept for intracranial iTBS as a therapeutic approach with novel insight into its local and network-level neuromodulatory effects.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by American Physiological Society in Journal of Neurophysiology
- Vol. 132 (5) , 1589-1607
Examining motor evidence for the pause-then-cancel model of action-stopping: insights from motor system physiology
Current debate surrounds whether single- or dual-process models better account for human action-stopping ability. We show that motor suppression of a successfully stopped muscle follows a distinct time course compared with when that same muscle is unrelated to the stopping task. Our results further suggest that distinct local inhibitory neuron populations contribute to these unique sources of suppression. Our study provides evidence from motor system physiology that multiple inhibitory processes influence action-stopping.
- 1 November 2024
- Published by American Physiological Society in Journal of Neurophysiology
- Vol. 132 (5) , 1589-1607
Examining motor evidence for the pause-then-cancel model of action-stopping: insights from motor system physiology
Current debate surrounds whether single- or dual-process models better account for human action-stopping ability. We show that motor suppression of a successfully stopped muscle follows a distinct time course compared with when that same muscle is unrelated to the stopping task. Our results further suggest that distinct local inhibitory neuron populations contribute to these unique sources of suppression. Our study provides evidence from motor system physiology that multiple inhibitory processes influence action-stopping.
- Open Access
Examining motor evidence for the pause-then-cancel model of action-stopping: Insights from motor system physiology
Stopping initiated actions is fundamental to adaptive behavior. Longstanding, single-process accounts of action-stopping have been challenged by recent, two-process, ‘pause-then-cancel’ models. These models propose that action-stopping involves two inhibitory processes: 1) a fast Pause process, which broadly suppresses the motor system as the result of detecting any salient event, and 2) a slower Cancel process, which involves motor suppression specific to the cancelled action. A purported signature of the Pause process is global suppression, or the reduced corticospinal excitability (CSE) of task-unrelated effectors early on in action-stopping. However, unlike the Pause process, few (if any) motor system signatures of a Cancel process have been identified. Here, we used single- and paired-pulse TMS methods to comprehensively measure the local physiological excitation and inhibition of both responding and task-unrelated motor effector systems during action-stopping. Specifically, we measured CSE, short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI), and the duration of the cortical silent period (CSP). Consistent with key predictions from the pause-then-cancel model, CSE measurements at the responding effector indicated that additional suppression was necessary to counteract Go-related increases in CSE during-action-stopping, particularly at later timepoints. Increases in SICI on Stop-signal trials did not differ across responding and non-responding effectors, or across timepoints. This suggests SICI as a potential source of global suppression. Increases in CSP duration on Stop- signal trials were more prominent at later timepoints. SICI and CSP duration therefore appeared most consistent with the Pause and Cancel processes, respectively. Our study provides further evidence from motor system physiology that multiple inhibitory processes influence action-stopping.
Open AccessExamining motor evidence for the pause-then-cancel model of action-stopping: Insights from motor system physiology
Stopping initiated actions is fundamental to adaptive behavior. Longstanding, single-process accounts of action-stopping have been challenged by recent, two-process, ‘pause-then-cancel’ models. These models propose that action-stopping involves two inhibitory processes: 1) a fast Pause process, which broadly suppresses the motor system as the result of detecting any salient event, and 2) a slower Cancel process, which involves motor suppression specific to the cancelled action. A purported signature of the Pause process is global suppression, or the reduced corticospinal excitability (CSE) of task-unrelated effectors early on in action-stopping. However, unlike the Pause process, few (if any) motor system signatures of a Cancel process have been identified. Here, we used single- and paired-pulse TMS methods to comprehensively measure the local physiological excitation and inhibition of both responding and task-unrelated motor effector systems during action-stopping. Specifically, we measured CSE, short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI), and the duration of the cortical silent period (CSP). Consistent with key predictions from the pause-then-cancel model, CSE measurements at the responding effector indicated that additional suppression was necessary to counteract Go-related increases in CSE during-action-stopping, particularly at later timepoints. Increases in SICI on Stop-signal trials did not differ across responding and non-responding effectors, or across timepoints. This suggests SICI as a potential source of global suppression. Increases in CSP duration on Stop- signal trials were more prominent at later timepoints. SICI and CSP duration therefore appeared most consistent with the Pause and Cancel processes, respectively. Our study provides further evidence from motor system physiology that multiple inhibitory processes influence action-stopping.
- 20 December 2023
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Multisensory Research
- Vol. 37 (1) , 47-74
Cross-Modal Contributions to Episodic Memory for Voices
Multisensory context often facilitates perception and memory. In fact, encoding items within a multisensory context can improve memory even on strictly unisensory tests (i.e., when the multisensory context is absent). Prior studies that have consistently found these multisensory facilitation effects have largely employed multisensory contexts in which the stimuli were meaningfully related to the items targeting for remembering (e.g., pairing canonical sounds and images). Other studies have used unrelated stimuli as multisensory context. A third possible type of multisensory context is one that is environmentally related simply because the stimuli are often encountered together in the real world. We predicted that encountering such a multisensory context would also enhance memory through cross-modal associations, or representations relating to one’s prior multisensory experience with that sort of stimuli in general. In two memory experiments, we used faces and voices of unfamiliar people as everyday stimuli individuals have substantial experience integrating the perceptual features of. We assigned participants to face- or voice-recognition groups and ensured that, during the study phase, half of the face or voice targets were encountered also with information in the other modality. Voices initially encoded along with faces were consistently remembered better, providing evidence that cross-modal associations could explain the observed multisensory facilitation.
- 20 December 2023
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Multisensory Research
- Vol. 37 (1) , 47-74
Cross-Modal Contributions to Episodic Memory for Voices
Multisensory context often facilitates perception and memory. In fact, encoding items within a multisensory context can improve memory even on strictly unisensory tests (i.e., when the multisensory context is absent). Prior studies that have consistently found these multisensory facilitation effects have largely employed multisensory contexts in which the stimuli were meaningfully related to the items targeting for remembering (e.g., pairing canonical sounds and images). Other studies have used unrelated stimuli as multisensory context. A third possible type of multisensory context is one that is environmentally related simply because the stimuli are often encountered together in the real world. We predicted that encountering such a multisensory context would also enhance memory through cross-modal associations, or representations relating to one’s prior multisensory experience with that sort of stimuli in general. In two memory experiments, we used faces and voices of unfamiliar people as everyday stimuli individuals have substantial experience integrating the perceptual features of. We assigned participants to face- or voice-recognition groups and ensured that, during the study phase, half of the face or voice targets were encountered also with information in the other modality. Voices initially encoded along with faces were consistently remembered better, providing evidence that cross-modal associations could explain the observed multisensory facilitation.
- Open Access
β-bursts over frontal cortex track the surprise of unexpected events in auditory, visual, and tactile modalities
One of the fundamental ways in which the brain regulates and monitors behavior is by making predictions about the sensory environment and adjusting behavior when those expectations are violated. As such, surprise is one of the fundamental computations performed by the human brain. In recent years, it has been well-established that one key aspect by which behavior is adjusted during surprise is inhibitory control of the motor system. Moreover, since surprise automatically triggers inhibitory control without much proactive influence, it can provide unique insights into largely reactive control processes. Recent years have seen tremendous interest in burst-like β frequency events in the human (and non-human) local field potential – especially over (pre)frontal cortex) – as a potential signature of inhibitory control. To date, β-bursts have only been studied in paradigms involving a substantial amount of proactive control (such as the stop-signal task). Here, we used two cross-modal oddball tasks to investigate whether surprise processing is accompanied by increases in scalp-recorded β-bursts. Indeed, we found that unexpected events in all tested sensory domains (haptic, auditory, visual) were followed by low-latency increases in β-bursting over frontal cortex. Across experiments, β-burst rates were positively correlated with estimates of surprise derived from Shannon’s information theory, a type of surprise that represents the degree to which a given stimulus violates prior expectations. As such, the current work clearly implicates frontal β-bursts as a signature of surprise processing. We discuss these findings in the context of common frameworks of inhibitory and cognitive control after unexpected events.
Open Accessβ-bursts over frontal cortex track the surprise of unexpected events in auditory, visual, and tactile modalities
One of the fundamental ways in which the brain regulates and monitors behavior is by making predictions about the sensory environment and adjusting behavior when those expectations are violated. As such, surprise is one of the fundamental computations performed by the human brain. In recent years, it has been well-established that one key aspect by which behavior is adjusted during surprise is inhibitory control of the motor system. Moreover, since surprise automatically triggers inhibitory control without much proactive influence, it can provide unique insights into largely reactive control processes. Recent years have seen tremendous interest in burst-like β frequency events in the human (and non-human) local field potential – especially over (pre)frontal cortex) – as a potential signature of inhibitory control. To date, β-bursts have only been studied in paradigms involving a substantial amount of proactive control (such as the stop-signal task). Here, we used two cross-modal oddball tasks to investigate whether surprise processing is accompanied by increases in scalp-recorded β-bursts. Indeed, we found that unexpected events in all tested sensory domains (haptic, auditory, visual) were followed by low-latency increases in β-bursting over frontal cortex. Across experiments, β-burst rates were positively correlated with estimates of surprise derived from Shannon’s information theory, a type of surprise that represents the degree to which a given stimulus violates prior expectations. As such, the current work clearly implicates frontal β-bursts as a signature of surprise processing. We discuss these findings in the context of common frameworks of inhibitory and cognitive control after unexpected events.
- Open Access
- 7 September 2021
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 41 (42) , 8826-8838
Common and Unique Inhibitory Control Signatures of Action-Stopping and Attentional Capture Suggest That Actions Are Stopped in Two Stages
The ability to stop an already initiated action is paramount to adaptive behavior. Much scientific debate in the field of human action-stopping currently focuses on two interrelated questions. (1) Which cognitive and neural processes uniquely underpin the implementation of inhibitory control when actions are stopped after explicit stop signals, and which processes are instead commonly evoked by all salient signals, even those that do not require stopping? (2) Why do purported (neuro)physiological signatures of inhibition occur at two different latencies after stop signals? Here, we address both questions via two preregistered experiments that combined measurements of corticospinal excitability, EMG, and whole-scalp EEG. Adult human subjects performed a stop signal task that also contained “ignore” signals: equally salient signals that did not require stopping but rather completion of the Go response. We found that both stop- and ignore signals produced equal amounts of early-latency inhibition of corticospinal excitability and EMG, which took place ∼150 ms following either signal. Multivariate pattern analysis of the whole-scalp EEG data further corroborated that this early processing stage was shared between stop- and ignore signals, as neural activity following the two signals could not be decoded from each other until a later time period. In this later period, unique activity related to stop signals emerged at frontocentral scalp sites, reflecting an increased stop signal P3. These findings suggest a two-step model of action-stopping, according to which an initial, universal inhibitory response to the saliency of the stop signal is followed by a slower process that is unique to outright stopping.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENTHumans often have to stop their ongoing actions when indicated by environmental stimuli (stop signals). Successful action-stopping requires both the ability to detect these salient stop signals and to subsequently inhibit ongoing motor programs. Because of this tight entanglement of attentional control and motor inhibition, identifying unique neurophysiological signatures of action-stopping is difficult. Indeed, we report that recently proposed early-latency signatures of motor inhibition during action-stopping are also found after salient signals that do not require stopping. However, using multivariate pattern analysis of scalp-recorded neural data, we also identified subsequent neural activity that uniquely distinguished action-stopping from saliency detection. These results suggest that actions are stopped in two stages: the first common to all salient events and the second unique to action-stopping.
- 7 September 2021
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 41 (42) , 8826-8838
Open AccessCommon and Unique Inhibitory Control Signatures of Action-Stopping and Attentional Capture Suggest That Actions Are Stopped in Two Stages
The ability to stop an already initiated action is paramount to adaptive behavior. Much scientific debate in the field of human action-stopping currently focuses on two interrelated questions. (1) Which cognitive and neural processes uniquely underpin the implementation of inhibitory control when actions are stopped after explicit stop signals, and which processes are instead commonly evoked by all salient signals, even those that do not require stopping? (2) Why do purported (neuro)physiological signatures of inhibition occur at two different latencies after stop signals? Here, we address both questions via two preregistered experiments that combined measurements of corticospinal excitability, EMG, and whole-scalp EEG. Adult human subjects performed a stop signal task that also contained “ignore” signals: equally salient signals that did not require stopping but rather completion of the Go response. We found that both stop- and ignore signals produced equal amounts of early-latency inhibition of corticospinal excitability and EMG, which took place ∼150 ms following either signal. Multivariate pattern analysis of the whole-scalp EEG data further corroborated that this early processing stage was shared between stop- and ignore signals, as neural activity following the two signals could not be decoded from each other until a later time period. In this later period, unique activity related to stop signals emerged at frontocentral scalp sites, reflecting an increased stop signal P3. These findings suggest a two-step model of action-stopping, according to which an initial, universal inhibitory response to the saliency of the stop signal is followed by a slower process that is unique to outright stopping.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENTHumans often have to stop their ongoing actions when indicated by environmental stimuli (stop signals). Successful action-stopping requires both the ability to detect these salient stop signals and to subsequently inhibit ongoing motor programs. Because of this tight entanglement of attentional control and motor inhibition, identifying unique neurophysiological signatures of action-stopping is difficult. Indeed, we report that recently proposed early-latency signatures of motor inhibition during action-stopping are also found after salient signals that do not require stopping. However, using multivariate pattern analysis of scalp-recorded neural data, we also identified subsequent neural activity that uniquely distinguished action-stopping from saliency detection. These results suggest that actions are stopped in two stages: the first common to all salient events and the second unique to action-stopping.
- 16 June 2021
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 41 (24) , 5135-5137
Unexpected Events Activate a Frontal-Basal-Ganglia Inhibitory Network: What Is the Role of the Pre-Supplementary Motor Area?
- 16 June 2021
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 41 (24) , 5135-5137
Unexpected Events Activate a Frontal-Basal-Ganglia Inhibitory Network: What Is the Role of the Pre-Supplementary Motor Area?
- 1 March 2021
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition
- Vol. 47 (3) , 481-497
Effect of impoverished information on multisensory integration in judgments of learning.
According to the principle of inverse effectiveness (PIE), weaker responses to information in one modality (i.e., unisensory) benefit more from additional information in a second modality (i.e., multisensory; Meredith & Stein, 1986). We suggest that the PIE may also inform whether perceptual fluency affects judgments of learning (JOLs). If JOLs follow the PIE, the differences in JOLs for multisensory and unisensory items should increase as the unisensory study items become harder to perceive. That is, an influence of perceptual fluency should prompt a similar, interactive pattern across perceptual responses and JOLs. In 3 experiments, we systematically varied the signal intensity or noise in 1 modality to examine how responses might change with the inclusion of information in a second modality. In Experiment 1, written words in several font sizes were sometimes accompanied by spoken equivalents. In Experiments 2 and 3, spoken words in various background noise levels were sometimes accompanied by visual speech articulations. Consistent with the PIE, the multisensory benefits in response time and/or correct identification increased as responses to unisensory information decreased. Also, the multisensory formats received higher JOLs than the unisensory formats; however, unlike the predictions from PIE, this difference did not increase as study items became harder to perceive. Experiment 3 extended this finding to participants' explicit beliefs. In multisensory settings, JOLs may rely more on theory- than data-driven processes. We suggest that broadly defined processing fluency may always contribute to JOLs, but, regarding perceptual information, JOLs appear to track perceptual attributes rather than perceptual fluency.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition
- Vol. 47 (3) , 481-497
Effect of impoverished information on multisensory integration in judgments of learning.
According to the principle of inverse effectiveness (PIE), weaker responses to information in one modality (i.e., unisensory) benefit more from additional information in a second modality (i.e., multisensory; Meredith & Stein, 1986). We suggest that the PIE may also inform whether perceptual fluency affects judgments of learning (JOLs). If JOLs follow the PIE, the differences in JOLs for multisensory and unisensory items should increase as the unisensory study items become harder to perceive. That is, an influence of perceptual fluency should prompt a similar, interactive pattern across perceptual responses and JOLs. In 3 experiments, we systematically varied the signal intensity or noise in 1 modality to examine how responses might change with the inclusion of information in a second modality. In Experiment 1, written words in several font sizes were sometimes accompanied by spoken equivalents. In Experiments 2 and 3, spoken words in various background noise levels were sometimes accompanied by visual speech articulations. Consistent with the PIE, the multisensory benefits in response time and/or correct identification increased as responses to unisensory information decreased. Also, the multisensory formats received higher JOLs than the unisensory formats; however, unlike the predictions from PIE, this difference did not increase as study items became harder to perceive. Experiment 3 extended this finding to participants' explicit beliefs. In multisensory settings, JOLs may rely more on theory- than data-driven processes. We suggest that broadly defined processing fluency may always contribute to JOLs, but, regarding perceptual information, JOLs appear to track perceptual attributes rather than perceptual fluency.