Zi-Lin He
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Zi-Lin He has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Poh Kam Wong
NUS Business School, National University of Singapore, Singapore
5 shared publications - Tony W. Tong
University of Colorado Boulder
4 shared publications Wenlong He
School of Business Renmin University of China Beijing China
3 shared publications- Yuchen Zhang
The Freeman School of Business Tulane University New Orleans Louisiana USA
3 shared publications Richard A. Bettis
Kenan‐Flagler Business School, Strategy and Entrepreneurship Department University of North Carolina‐Chapel Hill Chapel Hill North Carolina U.S.A.
2 shared publicationsTony W. Tong
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited Papers
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 47 (7) , 2062-2097
Patent regime shift and firm innovation strategy: Evidence from the Second Amendment to China's Patent Law
Research Summary: While changes in intellectual property rights (IPR) protection significantly shape firm innovation, the mechanisms driving firms' responses remain poorly understood. Leveraging the Second Amendment to China's Patent Law, which strengthens appropriability particularly for state‐owned enterprises (SOEs), as a natural experiment, we show that stronger IPR has mixed effects on SOEs' innovation. While SOEs increase the rate of innovation subsequent to the Amendment, they shift the direction of innovation toward more familiar areas in which they face a lesser need to adjust existing routines. This directional change suggests a quality decline in SOEs' innovation that may be attributed to path dependence. We further show that this change varies systematically depending on different firm‐ and industry‐level characteristics that loosen or tighten the historical grip of path dependence. Managerial Summary: This study offers valuable insights for corporate leaders navigating intellectual property rights (IPR) reforms and shaping their firms' innovation strategies, particularly in emerging economies. While stronger IPR protection can increase innovation output, it may also lead firms to concentrate on familiar technologies rather than pursue more novel ideas. Thus, corporate leaders should look beyond patent volume as a performance metric and instead foster creative thinking and engage in external collaborations to access new, cutting‐edge knowledge. Such efforts can help firms move beyond established routines and strengthen their long‐term competitiveness. To promote innovation of greater novelty, policymakers must complement stronger IPR protection with broader institutional support, including enhancing economic freedom, encouraging market competition, and cultivating a culture that values breakthrough innovation.
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 47 (7) , 2062-2097
Top Cited PapersPatent regime shift and firm innovation strategy: Evidence from the Second Amendment to China's Patent Law
Research Summary: While changes in intellectual property rights (IPR) protection significantly shape firm innovation, the mechanisms driving firms' responses remain poorly understood. Leveraging the Second Amendment to China's Patent Law, which strengthens appropriability particularly for state‐owned enterprises (SOEs), as a natural experiment, we show that stronger IPR has mixed effects on SOEs' innovation. While SOEs increase the rate of innovation subsequent to the Amendment, they shift the direction of innovation toward more familiar areas in which they face a lesser need to adjust existing routines. This directional change suggests a quality decline in SOEs' innovation that may be attributed to path dependence. We further show that this change varies systematically depending on different firm‐ and industry‐level characteristics that loosen or tighten the historical grip of path dependence. Managerial Summary: This study offers valuable insights for corporate leaders navigating intellectual property rights (IPR) reforms and shaping their firms' innovation strategies, particularly in emerging economies. While stronger IPR protection can increase innovation output, it may also lead firms to concentrate on familiar technologies rather than pursue more novel ideas. Thus, corporate leaders should look beyond patent volume as a performance metric and instead foster creative thinking and engage in external collaborations to access new, cutting‐edge knowledge. Such efforts can help firms move beyond established routines and strengthen their long‐term competitiveness. To promote innovation of greater novelty, policymakers must complement stronger IPR protection with broader institutional support, including enhancing economic freedom, encouraging market competition, and cultivating a culture that values breakthrough innovation.
- 1 March 2020
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 5 (1) , 17-38
Ownership Change and Firm Innovation: The Mediating Role of Interest Alignment
Although many studies suggest a strong link between ownership and corporate strategy, little research has examined how ownership change matters for firm innovation. This paper leverages the context of privatization to study how firms’ transition from state ownership to private ownership shapes innovation. We argue that privatization helps to alleviate not only traditional principal–agent conflicts, but also principal–principal conflicts in firms of concentrated ownership, leading to greater innovation. Exploiting a major privatization reform in China, we show that privatization enhances firm innovation and that this effect is mediated by interest alignment between firm owners and managers as well as that between controlling and minority shareholders. This study contributes to a dynamic view of ownership and innovation by delineating the underlying mechanisms through which privatization affects innovation.
- 1 March 2020
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Strategy Science
- Vol. 5 (1) , 17-38
Ownership Change and Firm Innovation: The Mediating Role of Interest Alignment
Although many studies suggest a strong link between ownership and corporate strategy, little research has examined how ownership change matters for firm innovation. This paper leverages the context of privatization to study how firms’ transition from state ownership to private ownership shapes innovation. We argue that privatization helps to alleviate not only traditional principal–agent conflicts, but also principal–principal conflicts in firms of concentrated ownership, leading to greater innovation. Exploiting a major privatization reform in China, we show that privatization enhances firm innovation and that this effect is mediated by interest alignment between firm owners and managers as well as that between controlling and minority shareholders. This study contributes to a dynamic view of ownership and innovation by delineating the underlying mechanisms through which privatization affects innovation.
- 1 April 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Research Policy
- Vol. 47 (3) , 583-591
What determines the duration of patent examination in China? An outcome-specific duration analysis of invention patent applications at SIPO
- 1 April 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Research Policy
- Vol. 47 (3) , 583-591
What determines the duration of patent examination in China? An outcome-specific duration analysis of invention patent applications at SIPO
- Open Access
- 27 March 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Data
- Vol. 5 (1) , 180042
A database linking Chinese patents to China’s census firms
To meet researchers’ increasing interest in the fast growing innovation activities taking place in China, we match patents filed with China’s State Intellectual Property Office to firms covered in China’s Census. China has experienced a strong growth in patent filings over the past two decades, and has since 2011 become the world’s top patent filing country. China’s Census database covers about one million unique manufacturing firms from 1998–2009, representing the broad Chinese economy. We design data parsing and pre-processing routines to clean and stem firm and assignee names, create a matching algorithm that fits with our data and maintains a balance between matching accuracy and workload of manual check, and implement a systematic manual check process to filter out false positives generated from computerized matching. Our project generates 1,113,588 matches for the Census firms, among which 849,647 patents are uniquely matched. By creating the patent-firm linked dataset, we hope to reduce duplicative effort and encourage more research to better understand China’s fast changing innovation landscape.
- 27 March 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Data
- Vol. 5 (1) , 180042
Open AccessA database linking Chinese patents to China’s census firms
To meet researchers’ increasing interest in the fast growing innovation activities taking place in China, we match patents filed with China’s State Intellectual Property Office to firms covered in China’s Census. China has experienced a strong growth in patent filings over the past two decades, and has since 2011 become the world’s top patent filing country. China’s Census database covers about one million unique manufacturing firms from 1998–2009, representing the broad Chinese economy. We design data parsing and pre-processing routines to clean and stem firm and assignee names, create a matching algorithm that fits with our data and maintains a balance between matching accuracy and workload of manual check, and implement a systematic manual check process to filter out false positives generated from computerized matching. Our project generates 1,113,588 matches for the Census firms, among which 849,647 patents are uniquely matched. By creating the patent-firm linked dataset, we hope to reduce duplicative effort and encourage more research to better understand China’s fast changing innovation landscape.
- Top Cited Papers
- 2 May 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 27 (3) , 579-606
Constructing a Chinese Patent Database of listed firms in China: Descriptions, lessons, and insights
Although China is now the largest patent filing country in the world, there is little firm‐level research using Chinese patents due to difficulties in integrating Chinese patent data with firm data. To partially address this gap, we construct a Chinese Patent Database linking State Intellectual Property Office (SIPO) patents to all listed firms and their subsidiaries in China, and we are making the database publicly available to the research community. We first develop a computer program to match the assignee names of SIPO patents to the names of listed firms and subsidiaries based on a similarity score, taking into account unique challenges associated with Chinese firm‐names and Chinese characters. High‐scoring likely matches are then checked manually to determine whether they are indeed true matches. The resulting database includes 191,325 SIPO patents matched to listed firms in China from 1990 to 2010. Using this database, we find a large amount of patenting heterogeneity across firms of different geographic locations, technological foci, and ownership types. We also leverage strengths of the data to conduct a detailed analysis of the patent examination process at the SIPO. Although there is not much difference in the examination process between listed firms and their nonlisted counterparts in China, substantial differences exist between Chinese firms and foreign firms. We find that foreign firms experience substantial delay in publishing patent applications and requesting for substantive examination compared to Chinese firms. Such delay accounts for 40–60% of the longer duration from application date to decision date for foreign firms. However, after accounting for such delay, foreign firms still face much longer pendency in reaching an examination outcome (grant, withdrawal, or refusal) than Chinese firms. We hope that the public database and such analysis will encourage new streams of research on Chinese patents to improve our knowledge of China's fast‐changing innovation landscape.
- 2 May 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
- Vol. 27 (3) , 579-606
Top Cited PapersConstructing a Chinese Patent Database of listed firms in China: Descriptions, lessons, and insights
Although China is now the largest patent filing country in the world, there is little firm‐level research using Chinese patents due to difficulties in integrating Chinese patent data with firm data. To partially address this gap, we construct a Chinese Patent Database linking State Intellectual Property Office (SIPO) patents to all listed firms and their subsidiaries in China, and we are making the database publicly available to the research community. We first develop a computer program to match the assignee names of SIPO patents to the names of listed firms and subsidiaries based on a similarity score, taking into account unique challenges associated with Chinese firm‐names and Chinese characters. High‐scoring likely matches are then checked manually to determine whether they are indeed true matches. The resulting database includes 191,325 SIPO patents matched to listed firms in China from 1990 to 2010. Using this database, we find a large amount of patenting heterogeneity across firms of different geographic locations, technological foci, and ownership types. We also leverage strengths of the data to conduct a detailed analysis of the patent examination process at the SIPO. Although there is not much difference in the examination process between listed firms and their nonlisted counterparts in China, substantial differences exist between Chinese firms and foreign firms. We find that foreign firms experience substantial delay in publishing patent applications and requesting for substantive examination compared to Chinese firms. Such delay accounts for 40–60% of the longer duration from application date to decision date for foreign firms. However, after accounting for such delay, foreign firms still face much longer pendency in reaching an examination outcome (grant, withdrawal, or refusal) than Chinese firms. We hope that the public database and such analysis will encourage new streams of research on Chinese patents to improve our knowledge of China's fast‐changing innovation landscape.
- 13 July 2016
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 38 (7) , 1435-1454
Conflict inside and outside: Social comparisons and attention shifts in multidivisional firms
Research summary: Behavioral Theory highlights the crucial role of social comparisons in attention allocation in adaptive aspirations. Yet, both the specification of social reference points and the dynamics of attention allocation have received little scholarly examination. We address performance feedback from two social reference points relative to divisions in multidivisional firms: economic reference point and political reference point. Comparing divisional performance with the two reference points can give consistent or inconsistent feedback, which has important consequences for the dynamics of attention allocation in adaptive aspirations. We find consistent feedback leads to more attention to own experience, while inconsistent feedback results in more attention to the social reference point the focal division underperforms. Results reveal that political reference point plays an important role in determining managerial attention allocation . Managerial summary: This article is based on how goal‐based performance of divisions relative to both their relevant external market rivals and sister divisions in multidivisional firms influences corporate resource allocation. As a result, various combinations of performance against the two groups of peers drive the reallocation of divisional management attention. We show that specific attention shifts occur on average as a function of the focal division's performance relative to the marketplace performance and that of sister divisions . Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 13 July 2016
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 38 (7) , 1435-1454
Conflict inside and outside: Social comparisons and attention shifts in multidivisional firms
Research summary: Behavioral Theory highlights the crucial role of social comparisons in attention allocation in adaptive aspirations. Yet, both the specification of social reference points and the dynamics of attention allocation have received little scholarly examination. We address performance feedback from two social reference points relative to divisions in multidivisional firms: economic reference point and political reference point. Comparing divisional performance with the two reference points can give consistent or inconsistent feedback, which has important consequences for the dynamics of attention allocation in adaptive aspirations. We find consistent feedback leads to more attention to own experience, while inconsistent feedback results in more attention to the social reference point the focal division underperforms. Results reveal that political reference point plays an important role in determining managerial attention allocation . Managerial summary: This article is based on how goal‐based performance of divisions relative to both their relevant external market rivals and sister divisions in multidivisional firms influences corporate resource allocation. As a result, various combinations of performance against the two groups of peers drive the reallocation of divisional management attention. We show that specific attention shifts occur on average as a function of the focal division's performance relative to the marketplace performance and that of sister divisions . Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 1 January 2016
- Published by Academy of Management in Academy of Management Proceedings
- Vol. 2016 (1) , 12774
What Determines the Duration of Patent Examination in China?
Although China is now the largest patent filing country in the world, research on the patent examination process and factors affecting examination durations has been scarce. This paper conducts the first outcome-specific duration analysis of the population of invention patent applications to the SIPO from 1993 to 2006 by considering all three competing examination outcomes (grant, withdrawal, and refusal) simultaneously. In addition to controlling a rich set of variables, we also test a behavioral view that an applicant’s “serious” attitude toward an application will be associated with longer time to withdrawal and refusal it experiences. We show that several applicant- and application-level characteristics have differential effects on examination durations depending on different examination outcomes. We further find that several proxies for an applicant’s seriousness are related to slower withdrawal and refusal, though their effects on grant pendency are ambiguous as predicted, suggesting that behavioral factors can matter importantly to examination durations for different outcomes at the patent office.
- 1 January 2016
- Published by Academy of Management in Academy of Management Proceedings
- Vol. 2016 (1) , 12774
What Determines the Duration of Patent Examination in China?
Although China is now the largest patent filing country in the world, research on the patent examination process and factors affecting examination durations has been scarce. This paper conducts the first outcome-specific duration analysis of the population of invention patent applications to the SIPO from 1993 to 2006 by considering all three competing examination outcomes (grant, withdrawal, and refusal) simultaneously. In addition to controlling a rich set of variables, we also test a behavioral view that an applicant’s “serious” attitude toward an application will be associated with longer time to withdrawal and refusal it experiences. We show that several applicant- and application-level characteristics have differential effects on examination durations depending on different examination outcomes. We further find that several proxies for an applicant’s seriousness are related to slower withdrawal and refusal, though their effects on grant pendency are ambiguous as predicted, suggesting that behavioral factors can matter importantly to examination durations for different outcomes at the patent office.
- Top Cited Papers
- 18 May 2015
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 37 (7) , 1177-1195
Thinking about U : Theorizing and testing U ‐ and inverted U ‐shaped relationships in strategy research
Research summary : U ‐ and inverted U ‐shaped relationships are increasingly explored in strategy research, with 11 percent of all articles published in S trategic M anagement J ournal ( SMJ ) in 2008–2012 investigating such quadratic relationships. Moreover, a movement towards introducing moderation to quadratic relationships has emerged. By reviewing 110 articles published in SMJ from 1980 to 2012, we identify several critical issues in theorizing and testing of these relationships for which current practice falls short. These include insufficient causal argumentation, incorrect testing, mixing up two different types of moderation, and not realizing that the curve can flip completely. For these and other issues, a guideline is provided which, when followed, may bring clarity to theoretical motivation and rigor to empirical testing . Managerial summary : Too much can be as bad as too little. Many relationships in strategic management follow an inverted U ‐shaped pattern, where moderate levels of a strategy lead to optimal performance. To gain deeper insights into the conventional wisdom that too much of a good thing can be harmful to performance, we discuss how such relationships can be better theorized and tested based on a review of articles exploring U ‐shaped relationships in S trategic M anagement J ournal during 1980–2012. We identify several critical issues that require close attention and provide a guideline to further develop and validate this important managerial intuition . Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 18 May 2015
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 37 (7) , 1177-1195
Top Cited PapersThinking about U : Theorizing and testing U ‐ and inverted U ‐shaped relationships in strategy research
Research summary : U ‐ and inverted U ‐shaped relationships are increasingly explored in strategy research, with 11 percent of all articles published in S trategic M anagement J ournal ( SMJ ) in 2008–2012 investigating such quadratic relationships. Moreover, a movement towards introducing moderation to quadratic relationships has emerged. By reviewing 110 articles published in SMJ from 1980 to 2012, we identify several critical issues in theorizing and testing of these relationships for which current practice falls short. These include insufficient causal argumentation, incorrect testing, mixing up two different types of moderation, and not realizing that the curve can flip completely. For these and other issues, a guideline is provided which, when followed, may bring clarity to theoretical motivation and rigor to empirical testing . Managerial summary : Too much can be as bad as too little. Many relationships in strategic management follow an inverted U ‐shaped pattern, where moderate levels of a strategy lead to optimal performance. To gain deeper insights into the conventional wisdom that too much of a good thing can be harmful to performance, we discuss how such relationships can be better theorized and tested based on a review of articles exploring U ‐shaped relationships in S trategic M anagement J ournal during 1980–2012. We identify several critical issues that require close attention and provide a guideline to further develop and validate this important managerial intuition . Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 14 March 2014
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 36 (7) , 987-1005
Adaptive aspirations and performance heterogeneity: Attention allocation among multiple reference points
Organizations learn and adapt their aspiration levels based on reference points (prior aspiration, prior performance, and prior performance of reference groups). The relative attention that organizations allocate to these reference points impacts organizational search and strategic decisions. However, very little research has explored this. Therefore, we build a recursive feedback model of learning from organizational experience that explains heterogeneity of attention allocation to the reference points in adaptive aspirations. In a sample of the German magazine industry (1972–2010), we find when early in their life cycle and as they or their parent company age, organizations tend to focus more on their own aspirations; however, when at the verge of bankruptcy, they increase their attention to competitors' performance . Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 14 March 2014
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 36 (7) , 987-1005
Adaptive aspirations and performance heterogeneity: Attention allocation among multiple reference points
Organizations learn and adapt their aspiration levels based on reference points (prior aspiration, prior performance, and prior performance of reference groups). The relative attention that organizations allocate to these reference points impacts organizational search and strategic decisions. However, very little research has explored this. Therefore, we build a recursive feedback model of learning from organizational experience that explains heterogeneity of attention allocation to the reference points in adaptive aspirations. In a sample of the German magazine industry (1972–2010), we find when early in their life cycle and as they or their parent company age, organizations tend to focus more on their own aspirations; however, when at the verge of bankruptcy, they increase their attention to competitors' performance . Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
- 25 October 2012
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Industry and Innovation
- Vol. 19 (7) , 539-561
Reaching Out and Reaching Within: A Study of the Relationship between Innovation Collaboration and Innovation Performance
A large body of research has thoroughly discussed and examined agglomeration advantages for innovation of geographically concentrated firms. However, there is an increasing awareness that this intellectual tradition tends to overemphasize the role of geographic proximity in the transfer of knowledge between firms and to under-theorize the contribution of nonlocal knowledge flows. With a sample of 143 manufacturing firms from Singapore, this research attempts to answer three interrelated questions: (1) Does local networking effort provide firms with added value above and beyond what is available to them by just “being there?” (2) Does local collaboration contribute more to innovation performance than nonlocal collaboration? (3) What is the joint impact of local and nonlocal collaborations on innovation performance? We find that while local and nonlocal collaborations are statistically indistinguishable from each other in terms of their relative importance, they represent complementary spurs to innovation. Despite the unique research setting of Singapore as a city state, we argue that our findings may be generalizable to geographic systems in other parts of the world.
- 25 October 2012
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Industry and Innovation
- Vol. 19 (7) , 539-561
Reaching Out and Reaching Within: A Study of the Relationship between Innovation Collaboration and Innovation Performance
A large body of research has thoroughly discussed and examined agglomeration advantages for innovation of geographically concentrated firms. However, there is an increasing awareness that this intellectual tradition tends to overemphasize the role of geographic proximity in the transfer of knowledge between firms and to under-theorize the contribution of nonlocal knowledge flows. With a sample of 143 manufacturing firms from Singapore, this research attempts to answer three interrelated questions: (1) Does local networking effort provide firms with added value above and beyond what is available to them by just “being there?” (2) Does local collaboration contribute more to innovation performance than nonlocal collaboration? (3) What is the joint impact of local and nonlocal collaborations on innovation performance? We find that while local and nonlocal collaborations are statistically indistinguishable from each other in terms of their relative importance, they represent complementary spurs to innovation. Despite the unique research setting of Singapore as a city state, we argue that our findings may be generalizable to geographic systems in other parts of the world.