Christiana Charalambous
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Christiana Charalambous has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David M. Schultz
Centre for Atmospheric Science, Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences University of Manchester Manchester UK
6 shared publications - Nyall Jamieson
Department of Integrative Biology, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, United States of America
6 shared publications - Ian Hall
Department of Mathematics, University of Manchester
5 shared publications - Deborah Talmi
University of Cambridge
4 shared publications - Ariane Delgado-Sanchez
School of Psychology Manchester Metropolitan University Manchester UK
3 shared publications Jianxin Pan
School of Mathematics, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Spatiotemporal modelling of meteorological drivers and outbreak detection of Legionnaires’ disease in England
Legionnaires’ disease is a severe respiratory illness caused by Legionella bacteria, with most cases occurring sporadically and environmental sources often unidentified. Effective outbreak detection requires understanding the spatiotemporal dynamics of sporadic cases and their environmental drivers. We developed a mechanistically informed spatiotemporal model integrating fine-scale spatial heterogeneity, multi-week meteorological influences, and extended temporal lags. The framework combines a negative binomial generalised additive model (GAM), a Besag–York–Mollié (BYM2) spatial component, and distributed lag nonlinear models (DLNMs) to capture nonlinear, delayed effects of temperature, dewpoint depression, precipitation, and cloud cover. These outputs generate a national daily index of weather-driven vulnerability, which is combined with hierarchical clustering to identify potential outbreaks. Across 2000–2019, our model improved outbreak detection in 15 of 20 years compared with the baseline UKHSA approach; in the remaining years performance was either equivalent (two years) or only slightly worse (three years, 0.98% reduction). Mean relative improvements were 6.0%, with a maximum of 14.4% in 2013. Improvements were consistent across months, and coarser 0.25° grid evaluations likely underestimate the model’s advantage at finer spatial scales. The analysis also clarified dual-stage Legionnaires’ disease dynamics, distinguishing environmental bacterial growth from the shorter infection window, and demonstrated the necessity of extended lags for accurate risk prediction. This framework provides a robust platform for targeted surveillance and predictive modelling, supporting evidence-based interventions and enhancing preparedness for sporadic Legionnaires’ disease under observed climatic conditions.
Open AccessSpatiotemporal modelling of meteorological drivers and outbreak detection of Legionnaires’ disease in England
Legionnaires’ disease is a severe respiratory illness caused by Legionella bacteria, with most cases occurring sporadically and environmental sources often unidentified. Effective outbreak detection requires understanding the spatiotemporal dynamics of sporadic cases and their environmental drivers. We developed a mechanistically informed spatiotemporal model integrating fine-scale spatial heterogeneity, multi-week meteorological influences, and extended temporal lags. The framework combines a negative binomial generalised additive model (GAM), a Besag–York–Mollié (BYM2) spatial component, and distributed lag nonlinear models (DLNMs) to capture nonlinear, delayed effects of temperature, dewpoint depression, precipitation, and cloud cover. These outputs generate a national daily index of weather-driven vulnerability, which is combined with hierarchical clustering to identify potential outbreaks. Across 2000–2019, our model improved outbreak detection in 15 of 20 years compared with the baseline UKHSA approach; in the remaining years performance was either equivalent (two years) or only slightly worse (three years, 0.98% reduction). Mean relative improvements were 6.0%, with a maximum of 14.4% in 2013. Improvements were consistent across months, and coarser 0.25° grid evaluations likely underestimate the model’s advantage at finer spatial scales. The analysis also clarified dual-stage Legionnaires’ disease dynamics, distinguishing environmental bacterial growth from the shorter infection window, and demonstrated the necessity of extended lags for accurate risk prediction. This framework provides a robust platform for targeted surveillance and predictive modelling, supporting evidence-based interventions and enhancing preparedness for sporadic Legionnaires’ disease under observed climatic conditions.
- Open Access
A two-scale model of Legionnaires’ disease to predict incubation periods and risk of symptomatic disease
Legionella pneumophila is an intracellular pathogen that causes Legionnaires’ disease, a severe pneumonia acquired primarily through contaminated water systems. Public health interventions rely on accurate estimates of the incubation period and dose–response (DR) relationship, yet currently used approaches in the literature underestimate incubation periods by assuming Markovian rupture times for infected macrophages. Here, we develop the first non-Markovian, two-scale within-host framework for Legionnaires’ disease, coupling stochastic intracellular replication in individual macrophages with extracellular Legionella–macrophage population dynamics. At the cellular level, we model intracellular replication using a stochastic logistic birth–death (SLBD) process, coupled with non-Markovian rupture-time distributions (Erlang and Burr). The Erlang distribution preserves tractability via the method of separation, whereas the Burr distribution captures heavy-tailed rupture times consistent with experimental data. Simulations are implemented using a renewal-based non-Markovian Gillespie algorithm. At the host level, successive infection and rupture events describe population-scale infection dynamics, enabling estimation of DR curves and incubation-period distributions. Across six model variants, DR predictions remain robust, with ID 50 estimates narrowly ranging between 8.79 and 8.94 Legionella , consistent with guinea pig challenge data. In contrast, incubation-period estimates show strong dependence on rupture-time assumptions: non-Markovian models predict median incubation periods of 5–6 days, correcting the previous 2–3 day underestimation and aligning with human outbreak data (2–10 days, up to 13 days). Sensitivity analysis identifies rupture size, phagocytosis rates, and threshold effects as key determinants of incubation-period results. By relaxing exponential assumptions, our framework provides biologically realistic within-host dynamics that improve epidemiological predictions. These results refine the quantitative basis for outbreak investigations and environmental risk assessment and are generalizable to other intracellular pathogens such as Coxiella burnetii and Francisella tularensis . Author summary: Legionella pneumophila causes Legionnaires’ disease, a serious pneumonia often linked to contaminated water systems, but key quantities such as the incubation period remain difficult to estimate accurately. Existing models assume that infected immune cells rupture at random times with no memory, an assumption that simplifies mathematics but does not reflect experimental observations. We developed a model that follows bacterial growth inside individual macrophages and connects these cellular events to infection dynamics within a host. Unlike previous approaches, our model allows rupture times to follow more realistic, non-exponential patterns that better match laboratory data. Using simulations, we show that commonly used assumptions systematically underestimate the incubation period of Legionnaires’ disease. Our results predict incubation periods of 5–6 days, consistent with human outbreak data, while leaving estimates of infectious dose largely unchanged. This work improves the biological realism of within-host infection models and provides a stronger quantitative foundation for outbreak investigation and environmental risk assessment. The modelling framework can be adapted to study other intracellular pathogens that replicate inside host immune cells.
Open AccessA two-scale model of Legionnaires’ disease to predict incubation periods and risk of symptomatic disease
Legionella pneumophila is an intracellular pathogen that causes Legionnaires’ disease, a severe pneumonia acquired primarily through contaminated water systems. Public health interventions rely on accurate estimates of the incubation period and dose–response (DR) relationship, yet currently used approaches in the literature underestimate incubation periods by assuming Markovian rupture times for infected macrophages. Here, we develop the first non-Markovian, two-scale within-host framework for Legionnaires’ disease, coupling stochastic intracellular replication in individual macrophages with extracellular Legionella–macrophage population dynamics. At the cellular level, we model intracellular replication using a stochastic logistic birth–death (SLBD) process, coupled with non-Markovian rupture-time distributions (Erlang and Burr). The Erlang distribution preserves tractability via the method of separation, whereas the Burr distribution captures heavy-tailed rupture times consistent with experimental data. Simulations are implemented using a renewal-based non-Markovian Gillespie algorithm. At the host level, successive infection and rupture events describe population-scale infection dynamics, enabling estimation of DR curves and incubation-period distributions. Across six model variants, DR predictions remain robust, with ID 50 estimates narrowly ranging between 8.79 and 8.94 Legionella , consistent with guinea pig challenge data. In contrast, incubation-period estimates show strong dependence on rupture-time assumptions: non-Markovian models predict median incubation periods of 5–6 days, correcting the previous 2–3 day underestimation and aligning with human outbreak data (2–10 days, up to 13 days). Sensitivity analysis identifies rupture size, phagocytosis rates, and threshold effects as key determinants of incubation-period results. By relaxing exponential assumptions, our framework provides biologically realistic within-host dynamics that improve epidemiological predictions. These results refine the quantitative basis for outbreak investigations and environmental risk assessment and are generalizable to other intracellular pathogens such as Coxiella burnetii and Francisella tularensis . Author summary: Legionella pneumophila causes Legionnaires’ disease, a serious pneumonia often linked to contaminated water systems, but key quantities such as the incubation period remain difficult to estimate accurately. Existing models assume that infected immune cells rupture at random times with no memory, an assumption that simplifies mathematics but does not reflect experimental observations. We developed a model that follows bacterial growth inside individual macrophages and connects these cellular events to infection dynamics within a host. Unlike previous approaches, our model allows rupture times to follow more realistic, non-exponential patterns that better match laboratory data. Using simulations, we show that commonly used assumptions systematically underestimate the incubation period of Legionnaires’ disease. Our results predict incubation periods of 5–6 days, consistent with human outbreak data, while leaving estimates of infectious dose largely unchanged. This work improves the biological realism of within-host infection models and provides a stronger quantitative foundation for outbreak investigation and environmental risk assessment. The modelling framework can be adapted to study other intracellular pathogens that replicate inside host immune cells.
- Open Access
A hybrid model of the within-host dynamics post-infection with Legionnaires’ disease
Understanding the incubation period of Legionnaires’ disease is vital for accurate source-term identification. Traditionally, researchers estimate the dose-dependent incubation period from human outbreak data, but this method suffers from the inability to estimate the exposure dose retrospectively for each case. This challenge limit the precision of incubation-period analysis using human case data. Existing within-host models, such as ordinary differential equation (ODE)-based and discrete-event stochastic approaches, estimate the dose-dependent incubation period of Legionnaires’ disease. However, discrete-event models, while useful, are so computationally costly that the within-host dynamics must be simplified to solely the Legionella and macrophage interactions. This simplification makes the computation feasible, but precludes cytokine interactions and adaptive immune response modelling. In this paper, we develop a new approach to model the within-host dynamics of Legion-naires’ disease that focuses on reducing computational cost while maintaining accuracy. Specifically, we propose a hybrid framework that integrates and improves upon existing ODE and discrete event within-host models of Legionnaires’ disease. By integrating the previously developed ODE and discrete-event stochastic models with stochastic differential equation (SDE) models, we create a unified system that adapts dynamically throughout the infection process. We quantify the points at which each model becomes the optimal tool for describing the infection, resulting in a flexible simulation of disease dynamics. Our hybrid model aligns with observed human incubation-period data and is the first framework of its kind in this context. This advancement offers a more robust platform for testing additional biological assumptions and improving our understanding of Legionnaires’ disease.
Open AccessA hybrid model of the within-host dynamics post-infection with Legionnaires’ disease
Understanding the incubation period of Legionnaires’ disease is vital for accurate source-term identification. Traditionally, researchers estimate the dose-dependent incubation period from human outbreak data, but this method suffers from the inability to estimate the exposure dose retrospectively for each case. This challenge limit the precision of incubation-period analysis using human case data. Existing within-host models, such as ordinary differential equation (ODE)-based and discrete-event stochastic approaches, estimate the dose-dependent incubation period of Legionnaires’ disease. However, discrete-event models, while useful, are so computationally costly that the within-host dynamics must be simplified to solely the Legionella and macrophage interactions. This simplification makes the computation feasible, but precludes cytokine interactions and adaptive immune response modelling. In this paper, we develop a new approach to model the within-host dynamics of Legion-naires’ disease that focuses on reducing computational cost while maintaining accuracy. Specifically, we propose a hybrid framework that integrates and improves upon existing ODE and discrete event within-host models of Legionnaires’ disease. By integrating the previously developed ODE and discrete-event stochastic models with stochastic differential equation (SDE) models, we create a unified system that adapts dynamically throughout the infection process. We quantify the points at which each model becomes the optimal tool for describing the infection, resulting in a flexible simulation of disease dynamics. Our hybrid model aligns with observed human incubation-period data and is the first framework of its kind in this context. This advancement offers a more robust platform for testing additional biological assumptions and improving our understanding of Legionnaires’ disease.
- Open Access
- 22 July 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Dynamically learning the meaning of deceptive cues about pain
Beliefs influence the intensity of felt pain. We previously applied regression models to two independent pain-cueing datasets (https://osf.io/5r6z7/) and found that pain intensity reports were a function of the error between participants’ belief, as determined by cues that informed participants about the level of forthcoming noxious stimulation, and the actual stimulation intensity, such that greater error decreased the influence of prior beliefs. Although this result appeared to present a challenge to established models of perception, our analysis did not formally compare the result against established computational models. This made it difficult to assess the validity of our results against the wider literature and we could not explain why the effect of information cues changed over the course of the task. In the current study (https://osf.io/fj27k/) we compared a model that corresponded to our original interpretation where pain ratings were considered a function of prediction error size, against Bayesian reinforcement learning models. Pain ratings were best explained by a model in which the expected value of each information cue was updated via a Bayesian reinforcement learning algorithm. These new results indicate that deception pain studies should not assume that participants’ belief about the information they are given is fixed. Rather, our results provide evidence that the meaning of cues change dynamically over the course of the session through trial-by-trial updates, even when participants are instructed otherwise.
- 22 July 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessDynamically learning the meaning of deceptive cues about pain
Beliefs influence the intensity of felt pain. We previously applied regression models to two independent pain-cueing datasets (https://osf.io/5r6z7/) and found that pain intensity reports were a function of the error between participants’ belief, as determined by cues that informed participants about the level of forthcoming noxious stimulation, and the actual stimulation intensity, such that greater error decreased the influence of prior beliefs. Although this result appeared to present a challenge to established models of perception, our analysis did not formally compare the result against established computational models. This made it difficult to assess the validity of our results against the wider literature and we could not explain why the effect of information cues changed over the course of the task. In the current study (https://osf.io/fj27k/) we compared a model that corresponded to our original interpretation where pain ratings were considered a function of prediction error size, against Bayesian reinforcement learning models. Pain ratings were best explained by a model in which the expected value of each information cue was updated via a Bayesian reinforcement learning algorithm. These new results indicate that deception pain studies should not assume that participants’ belief about the information they are given is fixed. Rather, our results provide evidence that the meaning of cues change dynamically over the course of the session through trial-by-trial updates, even when participants are instructed otherwise.
- Open Access
- 16 July 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (7) , 250226
A within-host birth–death and time–dose–response model for Legionnaires’ disease
Understanding the dose–response (DR) relationship for infectious diseases is important for quantitative microbial risk assessment studies to mitigate risk. To capture the DR dynamics, understanding the pathogenesis of the infectious agent is desirable. Typically, attempting to understand the DR dynamics would involve within-host mathematical modelling and fitting DR curves to experimental data. No mathematical model exists that describes the within-host dynamics that occur within an individual infected with Legionnaires’ disease. Further, most DR models are based either on a single-hit or threshold hypothesis for the cause of illness. Here, we derive a model to explain within-host dynamics post-infection with Legionnaires’ disease that incorporates heterogeneity at the cellular and population levels. We develop a new DR model that allows for either of two hypotheses for the cause of illness, adding a new level of flexibility not currently seen in the literature. We extend the DR model to incorporate time as we develop a dose-dependent incubation-period model that is based on biological mechanisms. Our within-host models provide an ID50 of between eight and nine Legionella and median incubation periods close to 4 days, which is consistent with evidence obtained from animal experiments and human outbreaks in the literature.
- 16 July 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 12 (7) , 250226
Open AccessA within-host birth–death and time–dose–response model for Legionnaires’ disease
Understanding the dose–response (DR) relationship for infectious diseases is important for quantitative microbial risk assessment studies to mitigate risk. To capture the DR dynamics, understanding the pathogenesis of the infectious agent is desirable. Typically, attempting to understand the DR dynamics would involve within-host mathematical modelling and fitting DR curves to experimental data. No mathematical model exists that describes the within-host dynamics that occur within an individual infected with Legionnaires’ disease. Further, most DR models are based either on a single-hit or threshold hypothesis for the cause of illness. Here, we derive a model to explain within-host dynamics post-infection with Legionnaires’ disease that incorporates heterogeneity at the cellular and population levels. We develop a new DR model that allows for either of two hypotheses for the cause of illness, adding a new level of flexibility not currently seen in the literature. We extend the DR model to incorporate time as we develop a dose-dependent incubation-period model that is based on biological mechanisms. Our within-host models provide an ID50 of between eight and nine Legionella and median incubation periods close to 4 days, which is consistent with evidence obtained from animal experiments and human outbreaks in the literature.
- Open Access
A within-host birth–death and time–dose–response model for Legionnaires’ disease
Understanding the dose–response relationship for infectious diseases is important for quantitative microbial risk assessment studies to mitigate risk. To capture the dose–response dynamics, understanding the pathogenesis of the infectious agent is desirable. Typically, attempting to understand the dose–response dynamics would involve within-host mathematical modelling and fitting dose–response curves to experimental data. No mathematical model exists that describes the within-host dynamics that occur within an individual infected with Legionnaires’ disease. Further, most dose–response models are based either on a single-hit or threshold hypothesis for the cause of illness. Here, we derive a model to explain within-host dynamics post-infection with Legionnaires’ disease that incorporates heterogeneity at the cellular and population levels. We develop a new dose–response model that allows for either of two hypotheses for the cause of illness, adding a new level of flexibility not currently seen in the literature. We extend the dose–response model to incorporate time as we develop a dose-dependent incubation-period model that is based on biological mechanisms. Our within-host models provide an ID50 of between eight and nine Legionella and median incubation periods close to four days, which is consistent with evidence obtained from animal experiments and human outbreaks in the literature.
Open AccessA within-host birth–death and time–dose–response model for Legionnaires’ disease
Understanding the dose–response relationship for infectious diseases is important for quantitative microbial risk assessment studies to mitigate risk. To capture the dose–response dynamics, understanding the pathogenesis of the infectious agent is desirable. Typically, attempting to understand the dose–response dynamics would involve within-host mathematical modelling and fitting dose–response curves to experimental data. No mathematical model exists that describes the within-host dynamics that occur within an individual infected with Legionnaires’ disease. Further, most dose–response models are based either on a single-hit or threshold hypothesis for the cause of illness. Here, we derive a model to explain within-host dynamics post-infection with Legionnaires’ disease that incorporates heterogeneity at the cellular and population levels. We develop a new dose–response model that allows for either of two hypotheses for the cause of illness, adding a new level of flexibility not currently seen in the literature. We extend the dose–response model to incorporate time as we develop a dose-dependent incubation-period model that is based on biological mechanisms. Our within-host models provide an ID50 of between eight and nine Legionella and median incubation periods close to four days, which is consistent with evidence obtained from animal experiments and human outbreaks in the literature.
- Open Access
- 27 December 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 20 (12) , e1012041
The Burr distribution as a model for the delay between key events in an individual’s infection history
Understanding the temporal relationship between key events in an individual’s infection history is crucial for disease control. Delay data between events, such as infection and symptom onset times, is doubly censored because the exact time at which these key events occur is generally unknown. Current mathematical models for delay distributions are derived from heuristic justifications. Here, we derive a new model for delay distributions, specifically for incubation periods, motivated by bacterial-growth dynamics that lead to the Burr family of distributions being a valid modelling choice. We also incorporate methods within these models to account for the doubly censored data. Our approach provides biological justification in the derivation of our delay distribution model, the results of fitting to data highlighting the superiority of the Burr model compared to currently used models when the mode of the distribution is clearly defined or when the distribution tapers off. Under these conditions, our results indicate that the derived Burr distribution is a better-performing model for incubation-period data than currently used methods, with the derived Burr distribution being 13 times more likely to be a better-performing model than the gamma distribution for Legionnaires’ disease based on data from a known outbreak.
- 27 December 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Computational Biology
- Vol. 20 (12) , e1012041
Open AccessThe Burr distribution as a model for the delay between key events in an individual’s infection history
Understanding the temporal relationship between key events in an individual’s infection history is crucial for disease control. Delay data between events, such as infection and symptom onset times, is doubly censored because the exact time at which these key events occur is generally unknown. Current mathematical models for delay distributions are derived from heuristic justifications. Here, we derive a new model for delay distributions, specifically for incubation periods, motivated by bacterial-growth dynamics that lead to the Burr family of distributions being a valid modelling choice. We also incorporate methods within these models to account for the doubly censored data. Our approach provides biological justification in the derivation of our delay distribution model, the results of fitting to data highlighting the superiority of the Burr model compared to currently used models when the mode of the distribution is clearly defined or when the distribution tapers off. Under these conditions, our results indicate that the derived Burr distribution is a better-performing model for incubation-period data than currently used methods, with the derived Burr distribution being 13 times more likely to be a better-performing model than the gamma distribution for Legionnaires’ disease based on data from a known outbreak.
- Open Access
- 12 March 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Validating a measure of the precision of ascending noxious signals
Pain perception can be described as a process of Bayesian inference, which generates sensory estimates based on prior expectations and afferent information. The inference is inherently affected by the precision (inverse variance) of the distribution of centrally-predicted ascending noxious signals. In this study, we examined the measurement validity of Bayesian likelihood precision in pain perception. Using a 2x2 fully factorial within-subject design, we measured and compared the precision of the distribution of centrally-predicted noxious stimuli in four tasks administered to 57 healthy adults: the cued-pain task (CPT) and the Focused Analgesia Test (FAST), in two noxious modalities, thermal and electrical. A hierarchical Bayesian model was applied to the CPT, and the FAST was employed as a validation criterion, given that it is known to correlate with clinical pain reports and the placebo response. We found that individuals with a more precise representation of ascending sensory signals in the cued-pain task produced less variable pain reports in the FAST. We validated the result by replicating this correlation across thermal and electrical pain. These results support the validity of our approach to the measurement of precision of ascending noxious signals. Their correlation with FAST scores supports their criterion validity and their correlation across noxious sub-modalities support the concurrent validity of this measurement. In the future, the precision of noxious inputs could be used to quantify individual placebo susceptibility, and thereby optimise the assay sensitivity of randomised clinical trials of new pain medication.
- 12 March 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessValidating a measure of the precision of ascending noxious signals
Pain perception can be described as a process of Bayesian inference, which generates sensory estimates based on prior expectations and afferent information. The inference is inherently affected by the precision (inverse variance) of the distribution of centrally-predicted ascending noxious signals. In this study, we examined the measurement validity of Bayesian likelihood precision in pain perception. Using a 2x2 fully factorial within-subject design, we measured and compared the precision of the distribution of centrally-predicted noxious stimuli in four tasks administered to 57 healthy adults: the cued-pain task (CPT) and the Focused Analgesia Test (FAST), in two noxious modalities, thermal and electrical. A hierarchical Bayesian model was applied to the CPT, and the FAST was employed as a validation criterion, given that it is known to correlate with clinical pain reports and the placebo response. We found that individuals with a more precise representation of ascending sensory signals in the cued-pain task produced less variable pain reports in the FAST. We validated the result by replicating this correlation across thermal and electrical pain. These results support the validity of our approach to the measurement of precision of ascending noxious signals. Their correlation with FAST scores supports their criterion validity and their correlation across noxious sub-modalities support the concurrent validity of this measurement. In the future, the precision of noxious inputs could be used to quantify individual placebo susceptibility, and thereby optimise the assay sensitivity of randomised clinical trials of new pain medication.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pain Research
- Vol. ume 16, 3145-3166
Are We Any Closer to Understanding How Chronic Pain Develops? A Systematic Search and Critical Narrative Review of Existing Chronic Pain Vulnerability Models
Identifying biopsychosocial factors underlying chronic pain vulnerability is essential for the design of preventative efforts. Multiple chronic pain vulnerability models exist, however, there is a lack of comprehensive evaluation of these models in the literature, potentially due to the lack of guidelines that specify the criteria by which these types of work should be assessed. In this work, we created evaluation criteria (based on the general goals of conceptual models), and we then used them to critically review the chronic pain vulnerability models available in the current peer-reviewed literature (identified through a systematic search). Particularly, we evaluated the models on the basis of conceptual clarity/specificity of measures, depth of description of aetiological and mechanistic factors, use of a whole system approach, and quality of the evidence associated with the models. We found nine conceptual models that have been explored in detail (eg, fear avoidance model, diathesis-stress model). These models excel at clarity and are supported mostly by self-report evidence of a psychological nature (anxiety sensitivity, pain catastrophizing, etc.), but provide little explanation of mechanistic and aetiological factors. In the future, models could be improved by complementing them with proposals from other models and exploring potential causal factors and mechanisms maintaining the condition. This task could be carried out through prospective cohort studies, and computational approaches, amongst others. Plain Language Summary: Several theories explain why some people are more vulnerable to develop chronic pain; however, there is no previous work that compares these theories or evaluates their quality. After evaluating these theories, we concluded that they are very good at identifying what psychological characteristics make someone vulnerable to develop chronic pain. However, they lack an explanation regarding what makes people develop those characteristics or how they lead to pain. We propose ways in which the different theories could be complemented.
- 1 September 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Pain Research
- Vol. ume 16, 3145-3166
Open AccessAre We Any Closer to Understanding How Chronic Pain Develops? A Systematic Search and Critical Narrative Review of Existing Chronic Pain Vulnerability Models
Identifying biopsychosocial factors underlying chronic pain vulnerability is essential for the design of preventative efforts. Multiple chronic pain vulnerability models exist, however, there is a lack of comprehensive evaluation of these models in the literature, potentially due to the lack of guidelines that specify the criteria by which these types of work should be assessed. In this work, we created evaluation criteria (based on the general goals of conceptual models), and we then used them to critically review the chronic pain vulnerability models available in the current peer-reviewed literature (identified through a systematic search). Particularly, we evaluated the models on the basis of conceptual clarity/specificity of measures, depth of description of aetiological and mechanistic factors, use of a whole system approach, and quality of the evidence associated with the models. We found nine conceptual models that have been explored in detail (eg, fear avoidance model, diathesis-stress model). These models excel at clarity and are supported mostly by self-report evidence of a psychological nature (anxiety sensitivity, pain catastrophizing, etc.), but provide little explanation of mechanistic and aetiological factors. In the future, models could be improved by complementing them with proposals from other models and exploring potential causal factors and mechanisms maintaining the condition. This task could be carried out through prospective cohort studies, and computational approaches, amongst others. Plain Language Summary: Several theories explain why some people are more vulnerable to develop chronic pain; however, there is no previous work that compares these theories or evaluates their quality. After evaluating these theories, we concluded that they are very good at identifying what psychological characteristics make someone vulnerable to develop chronic pain. However, they lack an explanation regarding what makes people develop those characteristics or how they lead to pain. We propose ways in which the different theories could be complemented.
- Open Access
- 27 June 2023
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Pain Reports
- Vol. 8 (4) , e1083
Trauma in childhood is associated with greater pain catastrophizing but not anxiety sensitivity: a cross-sectional study
Introduction: Adverse life experiences have been identified as a possible vulnerability factor for chronic pain. This association could result from the effect of trauma on the psychological state of individuals. Previous studies found childhood trauma to be associated with pain catastrophizing and anxiety sensitivity, both of which have been associated with an increased risk of chronic pain. However, it is unknown whether trauma in adulthood affects these variables and whether the effect on pain catastrophizing is independent of confounds such as depression and anxiety. Objectives: To test the effect of childhood and adulthood trauma on pain catastrophizing and anxiety sensitivity whilst controlling for depression and anxiety. Methods: In the current study, we conducted an online survey in the United Kingdom in a chronic pain sample (N = 138; 123 women; age range 19–78). We analysed whether there is an association between different types of trauma (both in childhood and through the lifespan), pain catastrophizing, and anxiety sensitivity while controlling for anxiety and depression. Results: We found that childhood trauma (particularly emotional abuse) significantly predicts pain catastrophizing, even when controlling for depression and anxiety, whereas it did not have a significant effect on anxiety sensitivity. Trauma through the lifespan (not childhood) did not have a significant effect on anxiety sensitivity nor did it have a significant effect on pain catastrophizing. Conclusions: Our results show that the life stage in which trauma occurs is key in its psychological effects on patients with chronic pain. Furthermore, it shows that trauma affects some psychological variables but not others.
- 27 June 2023
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Pain Reports
- Vol. 8 (4) , e1083
Open AccessTrauma in childhood is associated with greater pain catastrophizing but not anxiety sensitivity: a cross-sectional study
Introduction: Adverse life experiences have been identified as a possible vulnerability factor for chronic pain. This association could result from the effect of trauma on the psychological state of individuals. Previous studies found childhood trauma to be associated with pain catastrophizing and anxiety sensitivity, both of which have been associated with an increased risk of chronic pain. However, it is unknown whether trauma in adulthood affects these variables and whether the effect on pain catastrophizing is independent of confounds such as depression and anxiety. Objectives: To test the effect of childhood and adulthood trauma on pain catastrophizing and anxiety sensitivity whilst controlling for depression and anxiety. Methods: In the current study, we conducted an online survey in the United Kingdom in a chronic pain sample (N = 138; 123 women; age range 19–78). We analysed whether there is an association between different types of trauma (both in childhood and through the lifespan), pain catastrophizing, and anxiety sensitivity while controlling for anxiety and depression. Results: We found that childhood trauma (particularly emotional abuse) significantly predicts pain catastrophizing, even when controlling for depression and anxiety, whereas it did not have a significant effect on anxiety sensitivity. Trauma through the lifespan (not childhood) did not have a significant effect on anxiety sensitivity nor did it have a significant effect on pain catastrophizing. Conclusions: Our results show that the life stage in which trauma occurs is key in its psychological effects on patients with chronic pain. Furthermore, it shows that trauma affects some psychological variables but not others.