Craig Hogan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Craig Hogan has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ohkyung Kwon
University of Chicago
4 shared publications - Stephan S. Meyer
Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA
4 shared publications - Chris Stoughton
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
3 shared publications - Kristian Mackewicz
Enrico Fermi Institute Department of Physics The University of Chicago 5640 South Ellis Avenue 60637 Chicago Illinois USA
3 shared publications - Nathaniel Selub
University of California Berkeley
3 shared publications - Ray Tomlin
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL), Batavia, IL (United States)
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 August 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Dipole-independent measurements of nearly-zero CMB correlation: a possible symmetry of primordial causal quantum coherence
Anisotropy of space-time is measured on the scale of the cosmic horizon, using the angular correlation function C(Θ) of cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature at large angular separation Θ. Even-parity correlation Ceven(Θ) is introduced to obtain a direct, precise measure of horizon-scale curvature anisotropy independent of the unknown dipole, with uncertainty dominated by models of Galactic emission. In maps from WMAP and Planck, Ceven(Θ) at Θ ≃ 90○ ± 15○ is found to be much closer to zero than in previously documented measurements. Variation from zero as small as that in the Planck maps is estimated to occur by chance in a fraction ≃ 10−4.3 to ≃ 10−2.8 of standard realizations. Measurements are found to be consistent with zero correlation in a range of angles expected from quantum fluctuations during inflation whose spacelike coherence is bounded by inflationary horizons around every location at every epoch. This scale-invariant symmetry of cosmological initial conditions is incompatible with the standard quantum theory of initial conditions, but is broadly consistent with other cosmological measurements, and is subject to further tests.
- 28 August 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Open AccessDipole-independent measurements of nearly-zero CMB correlation: a possible symmetry of primordial causal quantum coherence
Anisotropy of space-time is measured on the scale of the cosmic horizon, using the angular correlation function C(Θ) of cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature at large angular separation Θ. Even-parity correlation Ceven(Θ) is introduced to obtain a direct, precise measure of horizon-scale curvature anisotropy independent of the unknown dipole, with uncertainty dominated by models of Galactic emission. In maps from WMAP and Planck, Ceven(Θ) at Θ ≃ 90○ ± 15○ is found to be much closer to zero than in previously documented measurements. Variation from zero as small as that in the Planck maps is estimated to occur by chance in a fraction ≃ 10−4.3 to ≃ 10−2.8 of standard realizations. Measurements are found to be consistent with zero correlation in a range of angles expected from quantum fluctuations during inflation whose spacelike coherence is bounded by inflationary horizons around every location at every epoch. This scale-invariant symmetry of cosmological initial conditions is incompatible with the standard quantum theory of initial conditions, but is broadly consistent with other cosmological measurements, and is subject to further tests.
- 3 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 111 (8)
Gravitational effects of null particles
- 3 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 111 (8)
Gravitational effects of null particles
- 3 June 2024
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 109 (12) , 123505
Angular spectrum of quantum fluctuations in causal structure
Scaling arguments are used to constrain the angular spectrum of distortions on boundaries of macroscopic causal diamonds, produced by Planck scale vacuum fluctuations of causally coherent quantum gravity. The small-angle spectrum of displacement is derived from a form of scale invariance: The variance and fluctuation rate of distortions normal to the surface of a causal diamond of radius at transverse physical separation should depend only on , with a normalization set by the Planck time , and should not depend on . For measurements on scale , the principle leads to universal scaling for variance on angular scale , and angular power spectrum at . This spectrum is consistent with a relational model of holographic noise based on causally coherent virtual null gravitational shocks, a general picture conjectured for all . The high scaling is contrasted with that predicted in some other quantum models, which differ by one power of angular wave number and are shown to predict excessive blurring of images from distant sources.- 3 June 2024
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 109 (12) , 123505
Angular spectrum of quantum fluctuations in causal structure
Scaling arguments are used to constrain the angular spectrum of distortions on boundaries of macroscopic causal diamonds, produced by Planck scale vacuum fluctuations of causally coherent quantum gravity. The small-angle spectrum of displacement is derived from a form of scale invariance: The variance and fluctuation rate of distortions normal to the surface of a causal diamond of radius at transverse physical separation should depend only on , with a normalization set by the Planck time , and should not depend on . For measurements on scale , the principle leads to universal scaling for variance on angular scale , and angular power spectrum at . This spectrum is consistent with a relational model of holographic noise based on causally coherent virtual null gravitational shocks, a general picture conjectured for all . The high scaling is contrasted with that predicted in some other quantum models, which differ by one power of angular wave number and are shown to predict excessive blurring of images from distant sources.- Open Access
- 19 December 2023
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 41 (1) , 015033
Gravity of gluonic fluctuations and the value of the cosmological constant
We analyze the classical linear gravitational effect of idealized pion-like dynamical systems, consisting of light quarks connected by attractive gluonic material with a stress–energy p = − ρ c 2 in one or more dimensions. In one orbit of a system of total mass M, quarks of mass m << M expand apart initially with v / c ∼ 1 , slow due to the gluonic attraction, reach a maximum size R 0 ∼ ℏ / M c , then recollapse. We solve the linearized Einstein equations and derive the effect on freely falling bodies for two systems: a gluonic bubble model where uniform gluonic stress–energy fills a spherical volume bounded by a 2D surface comprising the quarks’ rest mass, and a gluonic string model where a thin string connects two pointlike quarks. The bubble model is shown to produce a secular mean outward residual velocity of test particles that lie within its orbit. It is shown that the mean gravitational repulsion of bubble-like virtual-pion vacuum fluctuations agrees with the measured value of the cosmological constant, for a bubble with a radius equal to about twice the pion de Broglie length. These results support the view that the gravity of standard QCD vacuum fluctuations is the main source of cosmic acceleration.
- 19 December 2023
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 41 (1) , 015033
Open AccessGravity of gluonic fluctuations and the value of the cosmological constant
We analyze the classical linear gravitational effect of idealized pion-like dynamical systems, consisting of light quarks connected by attractive gluonic material with a stress–energy p = − ρ c 2 in one or more dimensions. In one orbit of a system of total mass M, quarks of mass m << M expand apart initially with v / c ∼ 1 , slow due to the gluonic attraction, reach a maximum size R 0 ∼ ℏ / M c , then recollapse. We solve the linearized Einstein equations and derive the effect on freely falling bodies for two systems: a gluonic bubble model where uniform gluonic stress–energy fills a spherical volume bounded by a 2D surface comprising the quarks’ rest mass, and a gluonic string model where a thin string connects two pointlike quarks. The bubble model is shown to produce a secular mean outward residual velocity of test particles that lie within its orbit. It is shown that the mean gravitational repulsion of bubble-like virtual-pion vacuum fluctuations agrees with the measured value of the cosmological constant, for a bubble with a radius equal to about twice the pion de Broglie length. These results support the view that the gravity of standard QCD vacuum fluctuations is the main source of cosmic acceleration.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2023
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 40 (16) , 165012
Angular correlations on causally-coherent inflationary horizons
We develop a model for correlations of cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy on the largest angular scales, based on standard causal geometrical relationships in slow-roll inflation. Unlike standard models based on quantized field modes, it describes perturbations with nonlocal directional coherence on spherical boundaries of causal diamonds. Causal constraints reduce the number of independent degrees of freedom, impose new angular symmetries, and eliminate cosmic variance for purely angular 2-point correlations. Distortions of causal structure from vacuum fluctuations are modeled as gravitational memory from randomly oriented outgoing and incoming gravitational null shocks, with nonlocally coherent directional displacements on curved surfaces of causal diamonds formed by standard inflationary horizons. The angular distribution is determined by axially symmetric shock displacements on circular intersections of the comoving sphere that represents the CMB photosphere with other inflationary horizons—those centered on it, and those that pass through an observer’s world line. Displacements on thin spheres at the end of inflation have a unique angular power spectrum C ℓ that approximates the standard expectation on small angular scales, but differs substantially at large angular scales due to horizon curvature. For a thin sphere, the model predicts a universal angular correlation function C ( Θ ) with an exact ‘causal shadow’ symmetry, C ( π / 4 < Θ < 3 π / 4 ) = 0 , and significant large-angle parity violation. We apply a rank statistic to compare models with WMAP and Planck satellite data, and find that a causally-coherent model with no shape parameters or cosmic variance agrees with the measured C ( Θ ) better than a large fraction ( > 0.9999 ) of standard model realizations. Model-independent tests of holographic causal symmetries are proposed.
- 24 July 2023
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 40 (16) , 165012
Open AccessAngular correlations on causally-coherent inflationary horizons
We develop a model for correlations of cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy on the largest angular scales, based on standard causal geometrical relationships in slow-roll inflation. Unlike standard models based on quantized field modes, it describes perturbations with nonlocal directional coherence on spherical boundaries of causal diamonds. Causal constraints reduce the number of independent degrees of freedom, impose new angular symmetries, and eliminate cosmic variance for purely angular 2-point correlations. Distortions of causal structure from vacuum fluctuations are modeled as gravitational memory from randomly oriented outgoing and incoming gravitational null shocks, with nonlocally coherent directional displacements on curved surfaces of causal diamonds formed by standard inflationary horizons. The angular distribution is determined by axially symmetric shock displacements on circular intersections of the comoving sphere that represents the CMB photosphere with other inflationary horizons—those centered on it, and those that pass through an observer’s world line. Displacements on thin spheres at the end of inflation have a unique angular power spectrum C ℓ that approximates the standard expectation on small angular scales, but differs substantially at large angular scales due to horizon curvature. For a thin sphere, the model predicts a universal angular correlation function C ( Θ ) with an exact ‘causal shadow’ symmetry, C ( π / 4 < Θ < 3 π / 4 ) = 0 , and significant large-angle parity violation. We apply a rank statistic to compare models with WMAP and Planck satellite data, and find that a causally-coherent model with no shape parameters or cosmic variance agrees with the measured C ( Θ ) better than a large fraction ( > 0.9999 ) of standard model realizations. Model-independent tests of holographic causal symmetries are proposed.
- Open Access
- 22 March 2023
- Published by Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)
The Fermilab Holometer: A program to measure Planck scale indeterminacy
The U.S. Department of Energy's Office of Scientific and Technical Information
- 22 March 2023
- Published by Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)
Open AccessThe Fermilab Holometer: A program to measure Planck scale indeterminacy
The U.S. Department of Energy's Office of Scientific and Technical Information
- Open Access
Vacuum Energy Density Measured from Cosmological Data
Within the $\Lambda$CDM cosmological model, the absolute value of Einstein's cosmological constant $\Lambda$, sometimes expressed as the gravitating mass-energy density $\rho_\Lambda$ of the physical vacuum, is a fundamental constant of nature, whose accurate measurement plays a central role in testing some proposed theories of quantum gravity. Several combinations of currently public cosmological data and an assumed flat $\Lambda$CDM cosmological model are used here to make a joint Bayesian inference on the combination of conventional parameters $\Omega_\Lambda h^2$ that corresponds to the absolute physical density $\rho_\Lambda$. In physical units, we obtain $\rho_\Lambda = \left(60.3\pm{1.3}\right)\times 10^{-31}{\rm g/cm^3}$, the most accurate constraint to date, with an absolute calibration of cosmological measurements based on CMB temperature. Significantly different values are obtained with calibrations that use a local distance scale, mainly connected to systematic differences in the value of the Hubble constant. It is suggested that future comprehensive cosmological parameter studies assuming the $\Lambda$CDM model include constraints on the vacuum density.Open AccessVacuum Energy Density Measured from Cosmological Data
Within the $\Lambda$CDM cosmological model, the absolute value of Einstein's cosmological constant $\Lambda$, sometimes expressed as the gravitating mass-energy density $\rho_\Lambda$ of the physical vacuum, is a fundamental constant of nature, whose accurate measurement plays a central role in testing some proposed theories of quantum gravity. Several combinations of currently public cosmological data and an assumed flat $\Lambda$CDM cosmological model are used here to make a joint Bayesian inference on the combination of conventional parameters $\Omega_\Lambda h^2$ that corresponds to the absolute physical density $\rho_\Lambda$. In physical units, we obtain $\rho_\Lambda = \left(60.3\pm{1.3}\right)\times 10^{-31}{\rm g/cm^3}$, the most accurate constraint to date, with an absolute calibration of cosmological measurements based on CMB temperature. Significantly different values are obtained with calibrations that use a local distance scale, mainly connected to systematic differences in the value of the Hubble constant. It is suggested that future comprehensive cosmological parameter studies assuming the $\Lambda$CDM model include constraints on the vacuum density. - 1 June 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics
- Vol. 2022 (06) , 015
Vacuum energy density measured from cosmological data
Within the ΛCDM cosmological model, the absolute value of Einstein's cosmological constant Λ, sometimes expressed as the gravitating mass-energy densityρΛof the physical vacuum, is a fundamental constant of nature, whose accurate measurement plays a central role in testing some proposed theories of quantum gravity. Several combinations of currently public cosmological data and an assumed flat ΛCDM cosmological model are used here to make a joint Bayesian inference on the combination of conventional parameters ΩΛh2that corresponds to the absolute physical densityρΛ. In physical units, we obtainρΛ= (60.3 ± 1.3)× 10-31g/cm3, the most accurate constraint to date, with an absolute calibration of cosmological measurements based on CMB temperature. Significantly different values are obtained with calibrations that use a local distance scale, mainly connected to systematic differences in the value of the Hubble constant. It is suggested that future comprehensive cosmological parameter studies assuming the ΛCDM model include constraints on the vacuum density.
- 1 June 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics
- Vol. 2022 (06) , 015
Vacuum energy density measured from cosmological data
Within the ΛCDM cosmological model, the absolute value of Einstein's cosmological constant Λ, sometimes expressed as the gravitating mass-energy densityρΛof the physical vacuum, is a fundamental constant of nature, whose accurate measurement plays a central role in testing some proposed theories of quantum gravity. Several combinations of currently public cosmological data and an assumed flat ΛCDM cosmological model are used here to make a joint Bayesian inference on the combination of conventional parameters ΩΛh2that corresponds to the absolute physical densityρΛ. In physical units, we obtainρΛ= (60.3 ± 1.3)× 10-31g/cm3, the most accurate constraint to date, with an absolute calibration of cosmological measurements based on CMB temperature. Significantly different values are obtained with calibrations that use a local distance scale, mainly connected to systematic differences in the value of the Hubble constant. It is suggested that future comprehensive cosmological parameter studies assuming the ΛCDM model include constraints on the vacuum density.
- Open Access
- 24 March 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Letters
- Vol. 128 (12) , 121101
Constraints on Scalar Field Dark Matter from Colocated Michelson Interferometers
Low-mass (sub-eV) scalar field dark matter may induce apparent oscillations of fundamental constants, resulting in corresponding oscillations of the size and the index of refraction of solids. Laser interferometers are highly sensitive to changes in the size and index of refraction of the main beam splitter. Using cross-correlated data of the Fermilab Holometer instrument, which consists of twin colocated 40-m arm length power-recycled interferometers, we investigate the possible existence of scalar field dark matter candidates in the mass range between and . We set new upper limits for the coupling parameters of scalar field dark matter, improving on limits from previous direct searches by up to 3 orders of magnitude.- 24 March 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Letters
- Vol. 128 (12) , 121101
Open AccessConstraints on Scalar Field Dark Matter from Colocated Michelson Interferometers
Low-mass (sub-eV) scalar field dark matter may induce apparent oscillations of fundamental constants, resulting in corresponding oscillations of the size and the index of refraction of solids. Laser interferometers are highly sensitive to changes in the size and index of refraction of the main beam splitter. Using cross-correlated data of the Fermilab Holometer instrument, which consists of twin colocated 40-m arm length power-recycled interferometers, we investigate the possible existence of scalar field dark matter candidates in the mass range between and . We set new upper limits for the coupling parameters of scalar field dark matter, improving on limits from previous direct searches by up to 3 orders of magnitude. - 10 March 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 39 (7) , 075016
Anomalies of cosmic anisotropy from holographic universality of great-circle variance
We examine all-sky cosmic microwave background temperature maps on large angular scales to compare their consistency with two scenarios: the standard inflationary quantum picture, and a distribution constrained to have a universal variance of primordial curvature perturbations on great circles. The latter symmetry is not a property of standard quantum inflation, but may be a symmetry of holographic models with causal quantum coherence on null surfaces. Since the variation of great-circle variance is dominated by the largest angular scale modes, in the latter case the amplitude and direction of the unobserved intrinsic dipole (that is, the ℓ = 1 harmonics) can be estimated from measured ℓ = 2, 3 harmonics by minimizing the variance of great-circle variances including only ℓ = 1, 2, 3 modes. It is found that including the estimated intrinsic dipole leads to a nearly-null angular correlation function over a wide range of angles, in agreement with a null anti-hemispherical symmetry independently motivated by holographic causal arguments, but highly anomalous in standard cosmology. Simulations are used here to show that simultaneously imposing the constraints of universal great-circle variance and the vanishing of the angular correlation function over a wide range of angles tends to require patterns that are unusual in the standard picture, such as anomalously high sectorality of the ℓ = 3 components, and a close alignment of principal axes of ℓ = 2 and ℓ = 3 components, that have been previously noted on the actual sky. The precision of these results appears to be primarily limited by errors introduced by models of Galactic foregrounds.
- 10 March 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Vol. 39 (7) , 075016
Anomalies of cosmic anisotropy from holographic universality of great-circle variance
We examine all-sky cosmic microwave background temperature maps on large angular scales to compare their consistency with two scenarios: the standard inflationary quantum picture, and a distribution constrained to have a universal variance of primordial curvature perturbations on great circles. The latter symmetry is not a property of standard quantum inflation, but may be a symmetry of holographic models with causal quantum coherence on null surfaces. Since the variation of great-circle variance is dominated by the largest angular scale modes, in the latter case the amplitude and direction of the unobserved intrinsic dipole (that is, the ℓ = 1 harmonics) can be estimated from measured ℓ = 2, 3 harmonics by minimizing the variance of great-circle variances including only ℓ = 1, 2, 3 modes. It is found that including the estimated intrinsic dipole leads to a nearly-null angular correlation function over a wide range of angles, in agreement with a null anti-hemispherical symmetry independently motivated by holographic causal arguments, but highly anomalous in standard cosmology. Simulations are used here to show that simultaneously imposing the constraints of universal great-circle variance and the vanishing of the angular correlation function over a wide range of angles tends to require patterns that are unusual in the standard picture, such as anomalously high sectorality of the ℓ = 3 components, and a close alignment of principal axes of ℓ = 2 and ℓ = 3 components, that have been previously noted on the actual sky. The precision of these results appears to be primarily limited by errors introduced by models of Galactic foregrounds.