Tomasz Zwęgliński
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Tomasz Zwęgliński has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Marcin Smolarkiewicz
Fire University
8 shared publications - Adam Widera
University of Munster
3 shared publications - Chiara Fonio3 shared publications
Aimo Taipale
VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland Ltd, Tampere, Finland
2 shared publications- Bernard Wiśniewski
Akademia WSB w Dąbrowie Górniczej
2 shared publications Hannu Salmela
VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland Ltd, Tampere, Finland
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Fire University
Szkolenia i ćwiczenia jako formy edukacji społeczeństwa w zakresie ochrony ludności i obrony cywilnej
Szkolenia i ćwiczenia z zakresu ochrony ludności i obrony cywilnej stanowią sposoby podnoszenia odporności społecznej i przygotowania struktur państwowych na wystąpienie zróżnicowanych rodzajów zagrożeń rzutujących na najważniejsze wartości utylitarne. W obu przypadkach (szkoleń i ćwiczeń) mogą być traktowane jako formy kształcenia. W odniesieniu do szkoleń jest to naturalna konsekwencja ich specyfiki. Natomiast w przypadku ćwiczeń uwidacznia możliwość wykorzystania czynności praktycznych nie tylko do weryfikacji stopnia ich opanowania, ale również do celów podnoszenia wiedzy i umiejętności, a także kształtowania kompetencji społecznych.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by Fire University
Szkolenia i ćwiczenia jako formy edukacji społeczeństwa w zakresie ochrony ludności i obrony cywilnej
Szkolenia i ćwiczenia z zakresu ochrony ludności i obrony cywilnej stanowią sposoby podnoszenia odporności społecznej i przygotowania struktur państwowych na wystąpienie zróżnicowanych rodzajów zagrożeń rzutujących na najważniejsze wartości utylitarne. W obu przypadkach (szkoleń i ćwiczeń) mogą być traktowane jako formy kształcenia. W odniesieniu do szkoleń jest to naturalna konsekwencja ich specyfiki. Natomiast w przypadku ćwiczeń uwidacznia możliwość wykorzystania czynności praktycznych nie tylko do weryfikacji stopnia ich opanowania, ale również do celów podnoszenia wiedzy i umiejętności, a także kształtowania kompetencji społecznych.
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Index Copernicus in Zeszyty Naukowe SGSP
- Vol. 2 (91) , 25-56
KEY ASPECTS THAT MAKE DECISION-MAKING TRAINING IN THE FIELD OF CRISIS MANAGEMENT TAILORED TO THE IDENTIFIED GAPS AND NEEDS
The fundamental objective of crisis management exercises is to provide participants with therequisite knowledge and skills to enable optimal responses in crisis situations. One particularlyefficacious and engaging form of exercise is decision-making training. The utilisation of virtualreality-based decision-making training, incorporating multimedia and “acting,” represents aneffective methodology for the assessment of procedures that involve multiple entities. The objectiveof this study is to present a methodology for adapting decision-making training to address theexisting gaps, needs, and decision-making issues of the entity for which the exercise is organized,thereby facilitating more effective and optimal execution. Furthermore, the paper presents datasources utilized by the authors in the organization of decision-making training. The intendedaudience for the publication is any individual, entity, and/or institution that engages in crisismanagement on a daily basis, including strategic planners, decision makers and practitioners.Consequently, the paper offers practical recommendations for the organization of an effective anddedicated decision-making training in the field of crisis management, based on a synthesis of theliterature and the authors’ experience.
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Index Copernicus in Zeszyty Naukowe SGSP
- Vol. 2 (91) , 25-56
KEY ASPECTS THAT MAKE DECISION-MAKING TRAINING IN THE FIELD OF CRISIS MANAGEMENT TAILORED TO THE IDENTIFIED GAPS AND NEEDS
The fundamental objective of crisis management exercises is to provide participants with therequisite knowledge and skills to enable optimal responses in crisis situations. One particularlyefficacious and engaging form of exercise is decision-making training. The utilisation of virtualreality-based decision-making training, incorporating multimedia and “acting,” represents aneffective methodology for the assessment of procedures that involve multiple entities. The objectiveof this study is to present a methodology for adapting decision-making training to address theexisting gaps, needs, and decision-making issues of the entity for which the exercise is organized,thereby facilitating more effective and optimal execution. Furthermore, the paper presents datasources utilized by the authors in the organization of decision-making training. The intendedaudience for the publication is any individual, entity, and/or institution that engages in crisismanagement on a daily basis, including strategic planners, decision makers and practitioners.Consequently, the paper offers practical recommendations for the organization of an effective anddedicated decision-making training in the field of crisis management, based on a synthesis of theliterature and the authors’ experience.
- 24 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 90-114
The Union Civil Protection Mechanism and Disaster Risk Reduction in Shaping National Security
The aim of this chapter is to present the Union Civil Protection Mechanism (UCPM) as a system operating within a defined operational framework, which has significant potential for short-term disaster responses in the international environment. The overall objective of the UCPM is to strengthen cooperation between participating states in the field of civil protection. Currently, 35 countries are directly involved in downloading and sharing resources through the system. This is intended to improve the effectiveness of disaster prevention, preparedness and response structures that strengthen national efforts in shaping and maintaining effective national security systems. The UCPM mobilises support at the request of any country in the world affected by a disaster, including circumstances related to acts of terrorism. By combining the capabilities to protect the populations of participating countries, the UCPM can provide better protection primarily for people, but also for the natural and cultural environment and property. The chapter presents the principles of the UCPM, how it is activated, and its current potential to shape national security through disaster risk reduction in a good practice perspective.
- 24 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 90-114
The Union Civil Protection Mechanism and Disaster Risk Reduction in Shaping National Security
The aim of this chapter is to present the Union Civil Protection Mechanism (UCPM) as a system operating within a defined operational framework, which has significant potential for short-term disaster responses in the international environment. The overall objective of the UCPM is to strengthen cooperation between participating states in the field of civil protection. Currently, 35 countries are directly involved in downloading and sharing resources through the system. This is intended to improve the effectiveness of disaster prevention, preparedness and response structures that strengthen national efforts in shaping and maintaining effective national security systems. The UCPM mobilises support at the request of any country in the world affected by a disaster, including circumstances related to acts of terrorism. By combining the capabilities to protect the populations of participating countries, the UCPM can provide better protection primarily for people, but also for the natural and cultural environment and property. The chapter presents the principles of the UCPM, how it is activated, and its current potential to shape national security through disaster risk reduction in a good practice perspective.
- Open Access
- 22 December 2022
- Published by Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawla II in Archiwa, Biblioteki i Muzea Kościelne
- Vol. 119, 395-416
Wybrane problemy bezpieczeństwa archiwów kościelnych
The aim of this article is to present the basic issues related to the preservation of church archives, which are by their nature valuable resources in the context of history and information. The research conducted for the purpose of this article was interdisciplinary, as it utilises research methods typical of a scientific discipline, namely security science, whereby disciplines classified as social sciences and technical sciences were interlinked, resulting in a coherent whole. Theoretical research methods were used, as the authors were keen to capture the correct picture of the surrounding reality related to the security of church archives. Inductive, deductive, and especially collection and ordering methods proved useful, as through the latter the results of the authors’ creative inquiries were presented in an orderly form by systematizing them. The article assumes that the security of church archives is characterized by the introduction of successive and causally related specific changes, resulting in an acceptable level of protection of these archives from threats originating in forces of nature, technical failures, as well as acts in violation of the norms of social life and the law. Thus, we are addressing those threats that, in the security sciences, are referred to as threats to public safety and common security. The authors focus their considerations on a particular type of threats, rarely analysed in the context of protecting the Church’s archival resources. They are not due to the passage of time or unfavourable environmental conditions for the storage of archival resources, but to threats that cannot be circumvented in terms of their impact. The considerations are presented comprehensively on both cognitive and utilitarian levels. The authors refer to the legal conditions for the security of church archives in the context of ecclesiastical law, in order to conduct an analysis of threats from the mentioned areas, to demonstrate their specificity and unique destructive potential against archival resources. The article is a voice in the discussion regarding the development, on a larger scale, of a unified and structured concept for identifying threats to church archives, while providing an opportunity to define their scope. Celem artykułu jest przedstawienie podstawowych zagadnień związanych z ochroną archiwów kościelnych, które w kontekście nie tylko historycznym, ale także informacyjnym stanowią ze swej natury cenne zasoby. Przeprowadzone na potrzeby niniejszego artykułu badania miały charakter interdyscyplinarny, zastosowano w nich bowiem metody badawcze typowe dla dyscypliny naukowej – nauki o bezpieczeństwie; tym samym powiązano dyscypliny zaliczane do nauk społecznych i technicznych, co doprowadziło do powstania spójnej całości. Zastosowano teoretyczne metody badań, ponieważ autorom zależało na uchwyceniu prawidłowego obrazu otaczającej rzeczywistości związanej z bezpieczeństwem archiwów kościelnych. Przydatne okazały się metody indukcyjne, dedukcyjne, a szczególnie metody zbierania i porządkowania, ponieważ dzięki tym ostatnim przedstawiono wyniki twórczych dociekań autorów w formie uporządkowanej poprzez ich systematyzację. W artykule przyjęto, że bezpieczeństwo archiwów kościelnych charakteryzuje się wprowadzaniem następujących po sobie i powiązanych przyczynowo określonych zmian, skutkujących akceptowalnym poziomem ochrony tychże archiwów przed zagrożeniami mającymi swoje źródło w siłach natury, awariach technicznych, a także czynach stojących w sprzeczności z normami życia społecznego i prawem. Mowa zatem o tych zagrożeniach, które na gruncie nauk o bezpieczeństwie określane są mianem zagrożeń godzących w bezpieczeństwo publiczne oraz bezpieczeństwo powszechne. Autorzy swoje rozważania koncentrują na szczególnym rodzaju zagrożeń, raczej rzadko analizowanym w kontekście ochrony zasobów archiwalnych Kościoła. Nie wynikają one z upływu czasu czy też niekorzystnych dla przechowywania zasobów archiwalnych warunków otoczenia, lecz z zagrożeń w swej sile oddziaływania nie do okiełznania. Rozważania prezentowane są kompleksowo na płaszczyźnie zarówno poznawczej, jak i utylitarnej. Autorzy odnoszą się do prawnych uwarunkowań bezpieczeństwa archiwów kościelnych w kontekście prawa kościelnego, by prowadząc analizę zagrożeń ze wspomnianych obszarów, wykazać ich specyfikę i wyjątkowy potencjał destrukcyjny wobec zasobów archiwalnych. Artykuł stanowi głos w dyskusji dotyczącej wypracowania w szerszej skali jednolitej i uporządkowanej koncepcji identyfikacji zagrożeń archiwów kościelnych, dając jednocześnie możliwość określenia ich zakresów.
- 22 December 2022
- Published by Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawla II in Archiwa, Biblioteki i Muzea Kościelne
- Vol. 119, 395-416
Open AccessWybrane problemy bezpieczeństwa archiwów kościelnych
The aim of this article is to present the basic issues related to the preservation of church archives, which are by their nature valuable resources in the context of history and information. The research conducted for the purpose of this article was interdisciplinary, as it utilises research methods typical of a scientific discipline, namely security science, whereby disciplines classified as social sciences and technical sciences were interlinked, resulting in a coherent whole. Theoretical research methods were used, as the authors were keen to capture the correct picture of the surrounding reality related to the security of church archives. Inductive, deductive, and especially collection and ordering methods proved useful, as through the latter the results of the authors’ creative inquiries were presented in an orderly form by systematizing them. The article assumes that the security of church archives is characterized by the introduction of successive and causally related specific changes, resulting in an acceptable level of protection of these archives from threats originating in forces of nature, technical failures, as well as acts in violation of the norms of social life and the law. Thus, we are addressing those threats that, in the security sciences, are referred to as threats to public safety and common security. The authors focus their considerations on a particular type of threats, rarely analysed in the context of protecting the Church’s archival resources. They are not due to the passage of time or unfavourable environmental conditions for the storage of archival resources, but to threats that cannot be circumvented in terms of their impact. The considerations are presented comprehensively on both cognitive and utilitarian levels. The authors refer to the legal conditions for the security of church archives in the context of ecclesiastical law, in order to conduct an analysis of threats from the mentioned areas, to demonstrate their specificity and unique destructive potential against archival resources. The article is a voice in the discussion regarding the development, on a larger scale, of a unified and structured concept for identifying threats to church archives, while providing an opportunity to define their scope. Celem artykułu jest przedstawienie podstawowych zagadnień związanych z ochroną archiwów kościelnych, które w kontekście nie tylko historycznym, ale także informacyjnym stanowią ze swej natury cenne zasoby. Przeprowadzone na potrzeby niniejszego artykułu badania miały charakter interdyscyplinarny, zastosowano w nich bowiem metody badawcze typowe dla dyscypliny naukowej – nauki o bezpieczeństwie; tym samym powiązano dyscypliny zaliczane do nauk społecznych i technicznych, co doprowadziło do powstania spójnej całości. Zastosowano teoretyczne metody badań, ponieważ autorom zależało na uchwyceniu prawidłowego obrazu otaczającej rzeczywistości związanej z bezpieczeństwem archiwów kościelnych. Przydatne okazały się metody indukcyjne, dedukcyjne, a szczególnie metody zbierania i porządkowania, ponieważ dzięki tym ostatnim przedstawiono wyniki twórczych dociekań autorów w formie uporządkowanej poprzez ich systematyzację. W artykule przyjęto, że bezpieczeństwo archiwów kościelnych charakteryzuje się wprowadzaniem następujących po sobie i powiązanych przyczynowo określonych zmian, skutkujących akceptowalnym poziomem ochrony tychże archiwów przed zagrożeniami mającymi swoje źródło w siłach natury, awariach technicznych, a także czynach stojących w sprzeczności z normami życia społecznego i prawem. Mowa zatem o tych zagrożeniach, które na gruncie nauk o bezpieczeństwie określane są mianem zagrożeń godzących w bezpieczeństwo publiczne oraz bezpieczeństwo powszechne. Autorzy swoje rozważania koncentrują na szczególnym rodzaju zagrożeń, raczej rzadko analizowanym w kontekście ochrony zasobów archiwalnych Kościoła. Nie wynikają one z upływu czasu czy też niekorzystnych dla przechowywania zasobów archiwalnych warunków otoczenia, lecz z zagrożeń w swej sile oddziaływania nie do okiełznania. Rozważania prezentowane są kompleksowo na płaszczyźnie zarówno poznawczej, jak i utylitarnej. Autorzy odnoszą się do prawnych uwarunkowań bezpieczeństwa archiwów kościelnych w kontekście prawa kościelnego, by prowadząc analizę zagrożeń ze wspomnianych obszarów, wykazać ich specyfikę i wyjątkowy potencjał destrukcyjny wobec zasobów archiwalnych. Artykuł stanowi głos w dyskusji dotyczącej wypracowania w szerszej skali jednolitej i uporządkowanej koncepcji identyfikacji zagrożeń archiwów kościelnych, dając jednocześnie możliwość określenia ich zakresów.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 215-233
Three-Dimensional Model and Orthophotomap's Quality Evaluation Towards Facilitating Aerial Reconnaissance of Flood Response Needs
Searching for and trialling innovative solutions in disaster management is a must. This process challenges certain efforts and requires specific methods since disaster response is a very complex, dynamic, and uncertain environment. Furthermore, the spectrum of solutions that are claimed to have potential to facilitate disaster response is broad enough and constantly increasing. Hence, there is an urgent need for searching and utilisation of new testing methods which are thoroughly tailored to provide possibly utmost reliable, valid, and complete knowledge to disaster management practitioners. The aim of the study is defining whether 3D modelling and orthophotomapping might provide an added value in aerial flood reconnaissance. Thus, an evaluation of a classification model based on 3D modelling and orthophotomapping generated from a UAV flight has been conducted. The analysis was based on results of a full-scale trial with disaster managers’ participation. As explored, the proposed innovation line, only to a certain extent, facilitates decision-making by an increase of decision efficacy. This improvement is impacted by a relative reduction of the efficiency as well as decision time extension in the overall reconnaissance process. Disaster managers are to benefit from the research findings.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 215-233
Three-Dimensional Model and Orthophotomap's Quality Evaluation Towards Facilitating Aerial Reconnaissance of Flood Response Needs
Searching for and trialling innovative solutions in disaster management is a must. This process challenges certain efforts and requires specific methods since disaster response is a very complex, dynamic, and uncertain environment. Furthermore, the spectrum of solutions that are claimed to have potential to facilitate disaster response is broad enough and constantly increasing. Hence, there is an urgent need for searching and utilisation of new testing methods which are thoroughly tailored to provide possibly utmost reliable, valid, and complete knowledge to disaster management practitioners. The aim of the study is defining whether 3D modelling and orthophotomapping might provide an added value in aerial flood reconnaissance. Thus, an evaluation of a classification model based on 3D modelling and orthophotomapping generated from a UAV flight has been conducted. The analysis was based on results of a full-scale trial with disaster managers’ participation. As explored, the proposed innovation line, only to a certain extent, facilitates decision-making by an increase of decision efficacy. This improvement is impacted by a relative reduction of the efficiency as well as decision time extension in the overall reconnaissance process. Disaster managers are to benefit from the research findings.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 173-197
Dynamic Flood Modelling in Disaster Response
The incidence of floods, which are globally recognised as the most hazardous phenomena, increases in dimensions of space, time, and intensity. Therefore, disaster managers seek solutions to facilitate their decision-making process in this respect. Although there is a broad spectrum of potentially appropriate technologies, finding the most suitable solution to address specific needs is a challenge. The research is based on trialling a dynamic flood modelling software towards its efficiency and efficacy in facilitating disaster response decision-making. The solution was trialled by disaster managers from several EU and non-EU countries during tabletop trials organised in Poland and in the Netherlands. The aim was to search for added value the solution might provide to disaster management in early stages of a major flood. The research questions of the trial were built upon the assumption that the proposed innovation line implementing the dynamic flood modelling solution will improve decision-making above the currently used legacy system, depicted as a baseline. The trial evaluation was based on a comparison of the performance of two approaches to decision-making called the innovation line and the baseline. The first one was facilitated with the trialled solution, while the other one was not. Both lines were run by two comparable, independent disaster management teams. In the trial setup, the efficiency of the lines being compared was measured with a key performance indicator (KPI) related to time consumption, while efficacy was measured in terms of the decision adequacy. The key results show that the solution implementation leads to shortening the decision-making time as well as making the decisions easier to be operationalized for disaster response purposes.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 173-197
Dynamic Flood Modelling in Disaster Response
The incidence of floods, which are globally recognised as the most hazardous phenomena, increases in dimensions of space, time, and intensity. Therefore, disaster managers seek solutions to facilitate their decision-making process in this respect. Although there is a broad spectrum of potentially appropriate technologies, finding the most suitable solution to address specific needs is a challenge. The research is based on trialling a dynamic flood modelling software towards its efficiency and efficacy in facilitating disaster response decision-making. The solution was trialled by disaster managers from several EU and non-EU countries during tabletop trials organised in Poland and in the Netherlands. The aim was to search for added value the solution might provide to disaster management in early stages of a major flood. The research questions of the trial were built upon the assumption that the proposed innovation line implementing the dynamic flood modelling solution will improve decision-making above the currently used legacy system, depicted as a baseline. The trial evaluation was based on a comparison of the performance of two approaches to decision-making called the innovation line and the baseline. The first one was facilitated with the trialled solution, while the other one was not. Both lines were run by two comparable, independent disaster management teams. In the trial setup, the efficiency of the lines being compared was measured with a key performance indicator (KPI) related to time consumption, while efficacy was measured in terms of the decision adequacy. The key results show that the solution implementation leads to shortening the decision-making time as well as making the decisions easier to be operationalized for disaster response purposes.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Innovation in Crisis Management
This book deals with how to measure innovation in crisis management, drawing on data, case studies, and lessons learnt from different European countries. The aim of this book is to tackle innovation in crisis management through lessons learnt and experiences gained from the implementation of mixed methods through a practitioner-driven approach in a large-scale demonstration project (DRIVER+). It explores innovation from the perspective of the end-users by focusing on the needs and problems they are trying to address through a tool (be it an app, a drone, or a training program) and takes a deep dive into what is needed to understand if and to what extent the tool they have in mind can really bring innovation. This book is a toolkit for readers interested in understanding what needs to be in place to measure innovation: it provides the know-how through examples and best practices. The book will be a valuable source of knowledge for scientists, practitioners, researchers, and postgraduate students studying safety, crisis management, and innovation.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Innovation in Crisis Management
This book deals with how to measure innovation in crisis management, drawing on data, case studies, and lessons learnt from different European countries. The aim of this book is to tackle innovation in crisis management through lessons learnt and experiences gained from the implementation of mixed methods through a practitioner-driven approach in a large-scale demonstration project (DRIVER+). It explores innovation from the perspective of the end-users by focusing on the needs and problems they are trying to address through a tool (be it an app, a drone, or a training program) and takes a deep dive into what is needed to understand if and to what extent the tool they have in mind can really bring innovation. This book is a toolkit for readers interested in understanding what needs to be in place to measure innovation: it provides the know-how through examples and best practices. The book will be a valuable source of knowledge for scientists, practitioners, researchers, and postgraduate students studying safety, crisis management, and innovation.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-4
Introduction
This book provides key insights into how potentially innovative solutions can be assessed by crisis management organisations before committing resources. This edited collection, drawing on the rich experiences and data collected in one of biggest and most ambitious crisis management project ever funded in Europe (DRIVER+, Driving Innovation in Crisis Management for European Resilience, 2014-2020), offers multiple perspectives. Part 1 takes a deep dive into the trial guidance methodology and describes the background knowledge needed to understand the rest of the book. Part 2 revolves around the technical infrastructure and the toolset to connect solutions and simulate crisis environments in a realistic way. Part 3 outlines the DRIVER+ trials by providing examples, analyses, results of the trials and considerations on simulation, and situational awareness tools and methods. Part 4 describes how the DRIVER+ outputs have been applied in other projects and hence provides the basis for a paradigm shift in assessing innovation in the CM domain. Additional resources are provided in Part 5.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-4
Introduction
This book provides key insights into how potentially innovative solutions can be assessed by crisis management organisations before committing resources. This edited collection, drawing on the rich experiences and data collected in one of biggest and most ambitious crisis management project ever funded in Europe (DRIVER+, Driving Innovation in Crisis Management for European Resilience, 2014-2020), offers multiple perspectives. Part 1 takes a deep dive into the trial guidance methodology and describes the background knowledge needed to understand the rest of the book. Part 2 revolves around the technical infrastructure and the toolset to connect solutions and simulate crisis environments in a realistic way. Part 3 outlines the DRIVER+ trials by providing examples, analyses, results of the trials and considerations on simulation, and situational awareness tools and methods. Part 4 describes how the DRIVER+ outputs have been applied in other projects and hence provides the basis for a paradigm shift in assessing innovation in the CM domain. Additional resources are provided in Part 5.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 304-305
Conclusions
It is legitimate to raise the question on whether it is realistic to be prepared in such an uncertain world as it is today. We have clear evidence that high-impact, low-probability events, such as pandemics and wars, suddenly materialise in a short period of time, if not in parallel, pushing individuals and entire nations into crises. While, on the one hand, we cannot prepare for such events, on the other, we can decrease the level of uncertainty. One way for doing this is to assess if we have “what we need” - namely, solutions that can help deal with a wide variety of crises. In this book, rich and evidence-based methodological, technical, and practical perspectives are provided to understand how potentially innovative solutions can be assessed by crisis management organisations. Ultimately, this edited collection offers the basis for a paradigm shift in assessing innovation in the crisis management domain.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 304-305
Conclusions
It is legitimate to raise the question on whether it is realistic to be prepared in such an uncertain world as it is today. We have clear evidence that high-impact, low-probability events, such as pandemics and wars, suddenly materialise in a short period of time, if not in parallel, pushing individuals and entire nations into crises. While, on the one hand, we cannot prepare for such events, on the other, we can decrease the level of uncertainty. One way for doing this is to assess if we have “what we need” - namely, solutions that can help deal with a wide variety of crises. In this book, rich and evidence-based methodological, technical, and practical perspectives are provided to understand how potentially innovative solutions can be assessed by crisis management organisations. Ultimately, this edited collection offers the basis for a paradigm shift in assessing innovation in the crisis management domain.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 151-169
New Approach to Selection of Innovative Solutions Tailored to the Practitioners' Needs
Due to the trial guidance methodology the new approach to finding an added value of a solution or a set of solutions which they might bring to crisis management is called trialling. The approach allows the collection of valid and reliable information, rooted from evidence-based data generated by practitioners using a solution or a set of solutions during a trial. As such, it provides a fundament for formulating conclusions on a trialled solution/s, for example, towards its usefulness for crisis management purposes. So far, some of the results, revealed in trials, have already been published. However, these results have not considered the statistical uncertainty yet, mainly analysing the pure values of key indicators. Therefore, the purpose of this chapter is to present a way of potential extension of the evaluation phase with a method of initial estimation of the results of uncertainty. This method might be applicable in a number of cases depending on the type of data collected during a trial. For this purpose, data generated during a trial has been used as an input. The trial was based on a forest fire simulated scenario. It aimed at trailing a set of new solutions juxtaposed towards facilitating the decision-making process run by disaster managers. The data generated during the innovation line run has been compared with the data reflecting the baseline, so the data that have been figured out with the use of the legacy system in the respective domain. The results show that applying the newly proposed Performance Indicators Uncertainty Estimation Method for comparison purposes may increase the reliability of the formulated conclusions out of the trial results.
- 19 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 151-169
New Approach to Selection of Innovative Solutions Tailored to the Practitioners' Needs
Due to the trial guidance methodology the new approach to finding an added value of a solution or a set of solutions which they might bring to crisis management is called trialling. The approach allows the collection of valid and reliable information, rooted from evidence-based data generated by practitioners using a solution or a set of solutions during a trial. As such, it provides a fundament for formulating conclusions on a trialled solution/s, for example, towards its usefulness for crisis management purposes. So far, some of the results, revealed in trials, have already been published. However, these results have not considered the statistical uncertainty yet, mainly analysing the pure values of key indicators. Therefore, the purpose of this chapter is to present a way of potential extension of the evaluation phase with a method of initial estimation of the results of uncertainty. This method might be applicable in a number of cases depending on the type of data collected during a trial. For this purpose, data generated during a trial has been used as an input. The trial was based on a forest fire simulated scenario. It aimed at trailing a set of new solutions juxtaposed towards facilitating the decision-making process run by disaster managers. The data generated during the innovation line run has been compared with the data reflecting the baseline, so the data that have been figured out with the use of the legacy system in the respective domain. The results show that applying the newly proposed Performance Indicators Uncertainty Estimation Method for comparison purposes may increase the reliability of the formulated conclusions out of the trial results.