Luisa-Bianca Thiele
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Luisa-Bianca Thiele has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Mohammad Sarailoo
Leibniz University Hannover, Welfengarten 1, 30167 Hannover, Germany
6 shared publications- Uwe Haberlandt
Institute of Hydrology and Water Resources Management, Leibniz University Hannover, Hanover, Germany
6 shared publications Frank Klawonn
Ostfalia University of Applied Sciences, Salzdahlumer Str. 46/48, 38302 Wolfenbuttel, Germany
5 shared publications- Markus Wallner
Ostfalia University of Applied Sciences, Herbert-Meyer-Str. 7, 29556 Suderburg, Germany
5 shared publications Regina Nogueira
Leibniz University Hannover, Welfengarten 1, 30167 Hannover, Germany
5 shared publicationsUwe Haberlandt
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Reply on RC1
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Open AccessReply on RC1
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- Open Access
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Reply on RC2
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Open AccessReply on RC2
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- Open Access
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Reply on RC1
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Open AccessReply on RC1
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- Open Access
- 4 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Comment on egusphere-2026-4177
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- 4 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-4177
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- Open Access
- 3 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Comment on egusphere-2026-4177
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- 3 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-4177
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways leading to loss of dilution capacity, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the Urban-Runoff-to-River-Flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Compound Risk Assessment of Low River Flows and High Urban Runoff: Frequency of critical drainage conditions in relation to pollutant inputs
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways of dilution failure, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the urban-runoff-to-river-flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- 22 April 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessCompound Risk Assessment of Low River Flows and High Urban Runoff: Frequency of critical drainage conditions in relation to pollutant inputs
Urbanization and climate variability increasingly intensify hydrological extremes that impair water quality. A critical compound stress arises when pollutant-rich urban runoff coincides with limited river dilution capacity. To characterize this interaction, we analyze compound events in two directional modes: (i) low river flow paired with corresponding urban runoff, and (ii) high urban runoff paired with concurrent river flow. While these modes represent distinct pathways of dilution failure, the underlying variables exhibit weak and inconsistent dependence, limiting the applicability of conventional bivariate extreme value approaches. To address this limitation, we introduce the urban-runoff-to-river-flow ratio as a direct indicator of dilution stress. A ratio-based extreme value framework is developed using both block maxima and peak-over-threshold approaches, with parameters estimated via maximum likelihood and L-moment methods. The analysis is based on more than two decades of discharge data from three catchments in Lower Saxony, Germany, representing contrasting hydrological regimes. Model performance and compound risk estimates are evaluated against two reference benchmarks: (i) a synthetic benchmark derived from marginal extremes under independence assumptions, and (ii) a conditional benchmark based on historically co-occurring events. Results show that conditional approaches systematically underestimate compound risk in weakly dependent systems, while synthetic estimates provide an upper bound by enforcing coincidence of extremes. In contrast, the ratio-based approach captures the interaction between pollutant loading and dilution capacity more consistently across sites. Overall, the proposed framework provides a robust and physically interpretable method for assessing compound dilution stress, particularly in systems where dependence between drivers is weak or unstable.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Maximisation potential of observed floods using conditional rainfall simulation and moisture maximisation
Extreme floods are caused by special meteorological conditions matching critical space-time scales of flood generation processes in a catchment. Fortunately for most of the floods these conditions do not meet. Objective of this study is to investigate how big could have historical floods become under “optimal” rainfall conditions and which are the main factors driving flood maximization. For that, observed storms are stochastically modified. First the intensities are amplified, then the spatial patterns are changed and finally both conditions are varied together. The rainfall intensities are modified with moisture maximisation considering the observed saturation deficit. The spatial patterns are changed by conditional rainfall simulation considering temporal correlation and advection. The simulated rainfall realisations are then used as input for a rainfall-runoff model to simulate corresponding floods. This case study uses data from the Mulde river basin in Germany and applies the methodology to a set of selected large flood events. The results show that observed events could have been much worse with average amplification factors of 2.9 for rainfall and of 4.6 for peak flow for the worst-case scenario of stationary storms. The developed method could also be used as alternative for the estimation of probable maximum precipitation and probable maximum floods.
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMaximisation potential of observed floods using conditional rainfall simulation and moisture maximisation
Extreme floods are caused by special meteorological conditions matching critical space-time scales of flood generation processes in a catchment. Fortunately for most of the floods these conditions do not meet. Objective of this study is to investigate how big could have historical floods become under “optimal” rainfall conditions and which are the main factors driving flood maximization. For that, observed storms are stochastically modified. First the intensities are amplified, then the spatial patterns are changed and finally both conditions are varied together. The rainfall intensities are modified with moisture maximisation considering the observed saturation deficit. The spatial patterns are changed by conditional rainfall simulation considering temporal correlation and advection. The simulated rainfall realisations are then used as input for a rainfall-runoff model to simulate corresponding floods. This case study uses data from the Mulde river basin in Germany and applies the methodology to a set of selected large flood events. The results show that observed events could have been much worse with average amplification factors of 2.9 for rainfall and of 4.6 for peak flow for the worst-case scenario of stationary storms. The developed method could also be used as alternative for the estimation of probable maximum precipitation and probable maximum floods.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Efficient drainage network control: from hydrodynamic modelling to AI-supported decision-making
Climate change is causing an increase in extreme, high-intensity rainfall events, which are locally and temporally limited and pose a significant risk potential for urban stormwater drainage. Particularly affected are densely populated and urban hardscapes, where substantial damage potential is expected. The hydraulics of the drainage network can be calculated with a high degree of accuracy using spatially and temporally high-resolution rainfall data. Numerical stormwater models are used for this purpose. However, such models have the disadvantage of long computation times, which can exceed the time scale of a forecast depending on the application. Our aim is to improve the forecasting and early warning systems for the operational optimisation of drainage network control and hazard prevention in the stormwater drainage system using artificial neural networks (ANN).The study area is a part of the city of Osnabrück in Germany. To quantify the risk of overflow, a hydrodynamic stormwater model with 1896 real and synthetic rainfall events with a temporal resolution of 5 minutes, durations between 15 and 60 minutes and return periods between 1 and 100 years is operated. The catchment area is divided into 1x1km pixels and one of four risk categories is defined for each pixel based on the sum of the overflow for each time step. In order to check whether the risk categories can be reduced by controlling the drainage network, three different control scenarios of the drainage network are calculated hydrodynamically in addition to the uncontrolled state, so that 7584 (4 x 1896) simulations are available for training the ANN. Finally, the ANN will be evaluated for its suitability to support decision-making for an optimised control scenario in real time. A particular challenge here is the evaluation of the AI model in the comparison of the risk categories in neighbouring pixels.
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessEfficient drainage network control: from hydrodynamic modelling to AI-supported decision-making
Climate change is causing an increase in extreme, high-intensity rainfall events, which are locally and temporally limited and pose a significant risk potential for urban stormwater drainage. Particularly affected are densely populated and urban hardscapes, where substantial damage potential is expected. The hydraulics of the drainage network can be calculated with a high degree of accuracy using spatially and temporally high-resolution rainfall data. Numerical stormwater models are used for this purpose. However, such models have the disadvantage of long computation times, which can exceed the time scale of a forecast depending on the application. Our aim is to improve the forecasting and early warning systems for the operational optimisation of drainage network control and hazard prevention in the stormwater drainage system using artificial neural networks (ANN).The study area is a part of the city of Osnabrück in Germany. To quantify the risk of overflow, a hydrodynamic stormwater model with 1896 real and synthetic rainfall events with a temporal resolution of 5 minutes, durations between 15 and 60 minutes and return periods between 1 and 100 years is operated. The catchment area is divided into 1x1km pixels and one of four risk categories is defined for each pixel based on the sum of the overflow for each time step. In order to check whether the risk categories can be reduced by controlling the drainage network, three different control scenarios of the drainage network are calculated hydrodynamically in addition to the uncontrolled state, so that 7584 (4 x 1896) simulations are available for training the ANN. Finally, the ANN will be evaluated for its suitability to support decision-making for an optimised control scenario in real time. A particular challenge here is the evaluation of the AI model in the comparison of the risk categories in neighbouring pixels.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Representation of different flood types in rainfall-runoff modelling
Flood characteristics vary due to different processes causing the floods. Classifying flood events according to their causative processes can help to improve the estimation accuracy of flood probabilities. Hydrological models can be used for derived flood frequency analyses when the length of observed climate and runoff data is insufficient. This also allows the estimation of uncertainties due to variable catchment characteristics, climate conditions, and runoff regimes. The aim of this work is to investigate whether rainfall-runoff models are capable of reproducing different flood types. Observed flood events of the period 1980 - 2020 are classified according to the approaches of Fischer et al. (2019) and Tarasova et al. (2020). The conceptual rainfall-runoff model HBV-IWW is operated for 120 meso- and macroscale (30km² - 1500km²) catchments in Germany. Observed and simulated flood events are compared to assess the model performance separately for different flood types. In addition, the model performance is evaluated for the pre-event phase to determine whether the preconditions of the flood event are met. The results indicate that the model reproduces certain flood types better than others. The model performance is in particular poor for snow dominated flood events both for the pre-event phase and during the flood event. The outcome of these investigations should help to find and improve the deficits of the hydrological modelling.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessRepresentation of different flood types in rainfall-runoff modelling
Flood characteristics vary due to different processes causing the floods. Classifying flood events according to their causative processes can help to improve the estimation accuracy of flood probabilities. Hydrological models can be used for derived flood frequency analyses when the length of observed climate and runoff data is insufficient. This also allows the estimation of uncertainties due to variable catchment characteristics, climate conditions, and runoff regimes. The aim of this work is to investigate whether rainfall-runoff models are capable of reproducing different flood types. Observed flood events of the period 1980 - 2020 are classified according to the approaches of Fischer et al. (2019) and Tarasova et al. (2020). The conceptual rainfall-runoff model HBV-IWW is operated for 120 meso- and macroscale (30km² - 1500km²) catchments in Germany. Observed and simulated flood events are compared to assess the model performance separately for different flood types. In addition, the model performance is evaluated for the pre-event phase to determine whether the preconditions of the flood event are met. The results indicate that the model reproduces certain flood types better than others. The model performance is in particular poor for snow dominated flood events both for the pre-event phase and during the flood event. The outcome of these investigations should help to find and improve the deficits of the hydrological modelling.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 27 (5) , 1109-1132
Regionalisation of rainfall depth–duration–frequency curves with different data types in Germany
Rainfall depth–duration–frequency (DDF) curves are required for the design of several water systems and protection works. For the reliable estimation of such curves, long and dense observation networks are necessary, which in practice is seldom the case. Usually observations with different accuracy, temporal resolution and density are present. In this study, we investigate the integration of different observation datasets under different methods for the local and regional estimation of DDF curves in Germany. For this purpose, two competitive DDF procedures for local estimation (Koutsoyiannis et al., 1998; Fischer and Schumann, 2018) and two for regional estimation (kriging theory vs. index based) are implemented and compared. Available station data from the German Weather Service (DWD) for Germany are employed, which includes 5000 daily stations with more than 10 years available, 1261 high-resolution (1 min) recordings with an observation period between 10 and 20 years, and finally 133 high-resolution (1 min) recordings with 60–70 years of observations. The performance of the selected approaches is evaluated by cross-validation, where the local DDFs from the long sub-hourly time series are considered the true reference. The results reveal that the best approach for the estimation of the DDF curves in Germany is by first deriving the local extreme value statistics based on Koutsoyiannis et al.'s (1998) framework and later using the kriging regionalisation of long sub-hourly time series with the short sub-hourly time series acting as an external drift. The integration of the daily stations proved to be useful only for DDF values of a low return period (T[a] < 10 years) but does not introduce any improvement for higher return periods (T[a] ≥ 10 years).
- 14 March 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
- Vol. 27 (5) , 1109-1132
Open AccessRegionalisation of rainfall depth–duration–frequency curves with different data types in Germany
Rainfall depth–duration–frequency (DDF) curves are required for the design of several water systems and protection works. For the reliable estimation of such curves, long and dense observation networks are necessary, which in practice is seldom the case. Usually observations with different accuracy, temporal resolution and density are present. In this study, we investigate the integration of different observation datasets under different methods for the local and regional estimation of DDF curves in Germany. For this purpose, two competitive DDF procedures for local estimation (Koutsoyiannis et al., 1998; Fischer and Schumann, 2018) and two for regional estimation (kriging theory vs. index based) are implemented and compared. Available station data from the German Weather Service (DWD) for Germany are employed, which includes 5000 daily stations with more than 10 years available, 1261 high-resolution (1 min) recordings with an observation period between 10 and 20 years, and finally 133 high-resolution (1 min) recordings with 60–70 years of observations. The performance of the selected approaches is evaluated by cross-validation, where the local DDFs from the long sub-hourly time series are considered the true reference. The results reveal that the best approach for the estimation of the DDF curves in Germany is by first deriving the local extreme value statistics based on Koutsoyiannis et al.'s (1998) framework and later using the kriging regionalisation of long sub-hourly time series with the short sub-hourly time series acting as an external drift. The integration of the daily stations proved to be useful only for DDF values of a low return period (T[a] < 10 years) but does not introduce any improvement for higher return periods (T[a] ≥ 10 years).