Gunnar Behrens
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Gunnar Behrens has a total of 30 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Axel Lauer
Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt (DLR), Institut für Physik der Atmosphäre, Oberpfaffenhofen, Germany
13 shared publications - Veronika Eyring
Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt, Oberpfaffenhofen, Wessling, D-82234, Germany [DE
9 shared publications - Adrià Amell
Chalmers University of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden
7 shared publications - Lara Leko
Chalmers University of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden
7 shared publications - Nils Müller
Chalmers University of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden
7 shared publications - Patrick Eriksson
Chalmers University of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Reply on RC2
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- 2 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Open AccessReply on RC2
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- Open Access
- 2 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Reply on RC1
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- 2 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Open AccessReply on RC1
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- Open Access
- 21 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Comment on egusphere-2026-3869
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- 21 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3869
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (18) , 8731-8754
An ESMValTool-based framework for sanity checks, physical consistency and climate fidelity during model development – ICONEval v1.0
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components, i.e. atmosphere, ocean, and land. Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench. While ICONEval is focused on the ICON model, the underlying ESMValTool diagnostics can also be used for different models as long as the model output is following the CMOR (Climate Model Output Rewriter) standard or the model is supported directly by ESMValTool.
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (18) , 8731-8754
Open AccessAn ESMValTool-based framework for sanity checks, physical consistency and climate fidelity during model development – ICONEval v1.0
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components, i.e. atmosphere, ocean, and land. Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench. While ICONEval is focused on the ICON model, the underlying ESMValTool diagnostics can also be used for different models as long as the model output is following the CMOR (Climate Model Output Rewriter) standard or the model is supported directly by ESMValTool.
- Open Access
- 20 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Comment on egusphere-2026-3869
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- 20 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-29
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-3869
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-38
Reply on RC2
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components (atmosphere, ocean, and land). Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-38
Open AccessReply on RC2
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components (atmosphere, ocean, and land). Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-38
Reply on CEC1
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components (atmosphere, ocean, and land). Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-38
Open AccessReply on CEC1
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components (atmosphere, ocean, and land). Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-38
Reply on RC1
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components (atmosphere, ocean, and land). Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-38
Open AccessReply on RC1
Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring during the development of Earth System Models (ESMs) are essential to identify potential problems early, such as unrealistic behavior of climate-relevant quantities, insufficient skill in reproducing the observed basic climate state, or violations of physical laws. The latter is particularly important for the emerging class of hybrid machine learning (ML) enhanced ESMs, where data-driven components are integrated with physics-based model formulations. ESMs used for projections of future climate continue to increase in complexity and resolution. Efficient and user-friendly tools such as the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) can therefore greatly support the assessment of a model. So far, ESMValTool focused primarily on providing a broad collection of community-developed evaluation diagnostics and recipes, allowing users to perform a large variety of rather detailed assessments across different domains. A main application of the tool was the assessment of multiple ESMs, in particular those participating in the coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Here, we introduce ICONEval, an open-source evaluation framework using ESMValTool that complements existing capabilities by enabling rapid, reproducible, and physically informed assessments of model performance, also during development. ICONEval provides efficient parallel processing of ESMValTool recipes and can generate HTML summary reports allowing to easily automatize and visualize evaluation and monitoring of performance during model development. The new capabilities are grouped into three complementary categories: (1) sanity checks, (2) physical consistency checks, and (3) climate fidelity diagnostics. The sanity checks assess whether global mean values of climate-relevant variables are within the bounds derived from observational and reanalysis datasets. The physical consistency checks aim to identify potential violations of constraints imposed by fundamental physics such as conservation of total air mass, realistic variability of atmospheric water vapor with temperature or the temperature dependence of the cloud ice fraction. The climate fidelity diagnostics assess important climate variables from different ESM components (atmosphere, ocean, and land). Here, we demonstrate this extension of the ESMValTool capabilities by applying the new diagnostics to a historical simulation performed with the ICON-XPP model as an illustrative example. The three-step assessment presented here can be efficiently used to compare different model configurations or versions, for example when testing new or updated parameterizations, including hybrid ML-enhanced (MLe) ESMs, also supporting emerging community benchmarking standards such as ClimateBench.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- p. 1-29
Diurnal cycles of deep convective processes: Biases of ERA5 and DYAMOND km-scale models revealed by satellite observations of frozen water path and precipitation
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.
- 31 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- p. 1-29
Open AccessDiurnal cycles of deep convective processes: Biases of ERA5 and DYAMOND km-scale models revealed by satellite observations of frozen water path and precipitation
Tropical convective processes show pronounced diurnal variability with strong land and ocean contrasts. Here, we compare their diurnal cycles from satellite observations, ERA5 and km-scale models. As observational base, we use the Chalmers Cloud Ice Climatology (CCIC), a machine-learning satellite product, for frozen water path (FWP) and high cloud cover, and IMERG for precipitation. CCIC captures the full diurnal cycle of FWP in contrast to older satellite FWP products. The satellite observations show late-night or early-morning peaks over the oceans, and afternoon peaks over tropical land areas for FWP and precipitation. The diurnal cycle of tropical FWP and precipitation has a general synchronicity in satellite observations. High cloud cover over tropical land lags behind FWP and precipitation by several hours and peaks during the night in the warm, wet season. ERA5 shows a smaller diurnal amplitude of FWP over tropical land with local phase shifts of more than ± 6 hours compared to CCIC. In contrast, the diurnal amplitude of ERA5 precipitation exceeds that of IMERG over land areas and lacks night-time peaks related to mesoscale convective systems and topography. Km-scale models have smaller diurnal phase shifts; however, regional biases exist over the South Pacific Convergence Zone, as well as systematic differences in diurnal amplitudes over tropical land areas, which can be quantified with satellite observations like CCIC. Our analysis illustrates the power of combining different satellite products to better understand the diurnal cycles of tropical convective processes when evaluating reanalyses or models.