Theresa Frimberger
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Theresa Frimberger has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Michael Krautblatter
Chair of Landslide Research, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany
6 shared publications - Elisabeth Schoepfer
German Aerospace Center (DLR), German Remote Sensing Data Center (DFD), Wessling, 82234, Germany
2 shared publications - Juan Camilo Gómez Zapata
Climate Analytics Berlin Germany
2 shared publications - Massimiliano Pittore
Center for Climate Change and Transformation, Eurac Research, Bolzano, Italy
2 shared publications - Michael Langbein
German Remote Sensing Data Center (DFD), German Aerospace Center (DLR), 82234 Oberpfaffenhofen, Germany
2 shared publications - S. Daniel Andrade
Instituto Geofisico, Escuela Politecnica Nacional, Quito, Ecuador
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Secondary Lahars Impacting on Building Structures at Chimborazo Volcano: A Retrospective and Scenario-Based Modeling Approach
The intense melting of glacial ice and permafrost can increase the presence of temporarily stored liquid water in dynamic high-alpine environments. A sudden release of this water, especially in volcanic settings, might trigger a process chain of severe consequences. During a period of increased periglacial degradation between 2015 and 2017, several large-volume (> 6.0 × 105 m³), outburst-related secondary lahars damaged local infrastructure on the populated southeastern slopes of Chimborazo volcano in Ecuador. The insufficient understanding of secondary lahars associated with the sudden outburst of water complicates the identification of initiating processes and hinders the ability to decipher the governing mechanisms involved during propagation. In this study, we present how we (1) identified initiation mechanisms of past secondary lahars at Chimborazo, (2) numerically back-calculated these events, (3) developed future lahar scenarios, and (4) quantified their impact on the local population. We performed a retrospective calibration approach to simulate a secondary lahar using the physics-based model RAMMS::Debris Flow. By introducing a novel two-stage outburst scenario development concept, we were able to predict potential future lahars. Finally, applying a standards-based verification of the structural components of residential development allowed us to evaluate the physical impact of potential lahars on infrastructure. We also assessed how increasing the wall thickness affects high- and low-risk areas. Our results show that the observed secondary lahars can be numerically reproduced with a set of frictional parameters of µ = 0.028 (Coulomb-type friction) and ξ = 600 ms-2 (turbulent friction). The model shows high agreement with locally obtained data (Vasconez et al., 2021) on total lahar volume, flow distance, discharge, and flooded area (deviation from target value = 20 %). By comparing the climatic and topographical situation of similar events at other study sites with the conditions at Chimborazo, we assume that glacial/periglacial destabilization processes may have accompanied the initiation of past lahars. Through deciphering the past initiation processes, our scenarios resulted in volumes between 2.7 × 105 m³ (high probability) and 10.8 × 105 m³ (very low probability) for a climatically derived reference period of 180 years. The structural validation of the component resistance identified high risk for approximately 24 % of the entire runout area. The adjustment to 11 cm wider bricks reduces this area by 5 %. Only a precise quantification of the ice content and dynamic behavior within the source region enable to estimate the influence of destabilization processes on lahar initiation. However, this work makes an important contribution to supporting informed decision-making in land use planning by implementing an interdisciplinary methodology for analyzing the impacts of mass movements. In this study, we showed that a retrospectively calibrated numerical model enables the simulation of future outburst-triggered lahars, and we further provided a quantification of their impact on downstream communities. Vasconez, F.J., Maisincho, L., Andrade, S.D., Cáceres Correa, B.E., Bernard, B., Argoti, C., Telenchana, E., Almeida, M., Almeida, S. & Lema, V. (2021): Secondary Lahars Triggered by Periglacial Melting at Chimborazo Volcano, Ecuador. – Revista Politécnica, 48: 19–30.https://doi.org/10.33333/rp.vol48n1.02
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSecondary Lahars Impacting on Building Structures at Chimborazo Volcano: A Retrospective and Scenario-Based Modeling Approach
The intense melting of glacial ice and permafrost can increase the presence of temporarily stored liquid water in dynamic high-alpine environments. A sudden release of this water, especially in volcanic settings, might trigger a process chain of severe consequences. During a period of increased periglacial degradation between 2015 and 2017, several large-volume (> 6.0 × 105 m³), outburst-related secondary lahars damaged local infrastructure on the populated southeastern slopes of Chimborazo volcano in Ecuador. The insufficient understanding of secondary lahars associated with the sudden outburst of water complicates the identification of initiating processes and hinders the ability to decipher the governing mechanisms involved during propagation. In this study, we present how we (1) identified initiation mechanisms of past secondary lahars at Chimborazo, (2) numerically back-calculated these events, (3) developed future lahar scenarios, and (4) quantified their impact on the local population. We performed a retrospective calibration approach to simulate a secondary lahar using the physics-based model RAMMS::Debris Flow. By introducing a novel two-stage outburst scenario development concept, we were able to predict potential future lahars. Finally, applying a standards-based verification of the structural components of residential development allowed us to evaluate the physical impact of potential lahars on infrastructure. We also assessed how increasing the wall thickness affects high- and low-risk areas. Our results show that the observed secondary lahars can be numerically reproduced with a set of frictional parameters of µ = 0.028 (Coulomb-type friction) and ξ = 600 ms-2 (turbulent friction). The model shows high agreement with locally obtained data (Vasconez et al., 2021) on total lahar volume, flow distance, discharge, and flooded area (deviation from target value = 20 %). By comparing the climatic and topographical situation of similar events at other study sites with the conditions at Chimborazo, we assume that glacial/periglacial destabilization processes may have accompanied the initiation of past lahars. Through deciphering the past initiation processes, our scenarios resulted in volumes between 2.7 × 105 m³ (high probability) and 10.8 × 105 m³ (very low probability) for a climatically derived reference period of 180 years. The structural validation of the component resistance identified high risk for approximately 24 % of the entire runout area. The adjustment to 11 cm wider bricks reduces this area by 5 %. Only a precise quantification of the ice content and dynamic behavior within the source region enable to estimate the influence of destabilization processes on lahar initiation. However, this work makes an important contribution to supporting informed decision-making in land use planning by implementing an interdisciplinary methodology for analyzing the impacts of mass movements. In this study, we showed that a retrospectively calibrated numerical model enables the simulation of future outburst-triggered lahars, and we further provided a quantification of their impact on downstream communities. Vasconez, F.J., Maisincho, L., Andrade, S.D., Cáceres Correa, B.E., Bernard, B., Argoti, C., Telenchana, E., Almeida, M., Almeida, S. & Lema, V. (2021): Secondary Lahars Triggered by Periglacial Melting at Chimborazo Volcano, Ecuador. – Revista Politécnica, 48: 19–30.https://doi.org/10.33333/rp.vol48n1.02
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Developing a practical approach to assessing the drivers of multi-hazard risk in the Alpine space
Unprecedented weather extremes have affected the Alpine space in recent years, significantly impacting human populations, the economy, and the environment. Extreme weather events can trigger a multitude of alpine hazards that, due to the distinct characteristics of the Alpine natural and built environment, have the potential to induce severe compound and cascading impacts. Despite recent scientific evidence that climate change will contribute to more intense and more frequent weather extremes, our understanding of local implications on multi-hazards, compound and cascading effects, and future risks remains insufficient. Consequently, risk managers and decision-makers lack a systematic approach to assess future changes in multi-hazard risk.We are developing a practical approach that aims to help local risk managers answer fundamental questions about the drivers of multi-hazard risk in their respective Alpine regions. To that end, we combine a questionnaire about the current risk situation with a systematic basis for propagating the effects of future changes, covering all aspects of the risk chain, namely hazard, exposure, vulnerability, and capacity. Ultimately, the method aims to help (1) identify important drivers of (future) risk, (2) assess their contribution to the (future) risk landscape, and (3) identify relevant risk pathways for targeting (future) risk management practice.The approach relies on detailed knowledge of local conditions that can only be provided by local stakeholders as well as more general input on the future trends in climate and anthropogenic developments that must be provided by higher authorities and the scientific community. This work is part of the X-RISK-CC project, funded by the Interreg Alpine Space Program 2021-27. The approach will be applied to some of the project's pilot regions to help generate insights that will assist risk managers in the evaluation and management of newly emerging risks associated with weather extremes in their respective regions.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessDeveloping a practical approach to assessing the drivers of multi-hazard risk in the Alpine space
Unprecedented weather extremes have affected the Alpine space in recent years, significantly impacting human populations, the economy, and the environment. Extreme weather events can trigger a multitude of alpine hazards that, due to the distinct characteristics of the Alpine natural and built environment, have the potential to induce severe compound and cascading impacts. Despite recent scientific evidence that climate change will contribute to more intense and more frequent weather extremes, our understanding of local implications on multi-hazards, compound and cascading effects, and future risks remains insufficient. Consequently, risk managers and decision-makers lack a systematic approach to assess future changes in multi-hazard risk.We are developing a practical approach that aims to help local risk managers answer fundamental questions about the drivers of multi-hazard risk in their respective Alpine regions. To that end, we combine a questionnaire about the current risk situation with a systematic basis for propagating the effects of future changes, covering all aspects of the risk chain, namely hazard, exposure, vulnerability, and capacity. Ultimately, the method aims to help (1) identify important drivers of (future) risk, (2) assess their contribution to the (future) risk landscape, and (3) identify relevant risk pathways for targeting (future) risk management practice.The approach relies on detailed knowledge of local conditions that can only be provided by local stakeholders as well as more general input on the future trends in climate and anthropogenic developments that must be provided by higher authorities and the scientific community. This work is part of the X-RISK-CC project, funded by the Interreg Alpine Space Program 2021-27. The approach will be applied to some of the project's pilot regions to help generate insights that will assist risk managers in the evaluation and management of newly emerging risks associated with weather extremes in their respective regions.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Investigating subsurface conditions favouring the formation of secondary lahars in the glacier forefields of Cotopaxi volcano, Ecuador
Recently deglaciated terrain is highly active and subject to enhanced geomorphological change. The tropical glaciers on Cotopaxi volcano (5897 masl) in Ecuador are rapidly declining and have lost more than 50% of their surface area within the last five decades, and climate models predict a future rise of the Equilibrium Line Altitude of at least 200 m within the next 50 years (Vuille et al., 2018). The retreat of the presumably polythermal glaciers exposes unconsolidated, previously frozen pyroclastic material and moraine deposits on the steep volcano flanks. In recent years, secondary lahars unrelated to obvious trigger mechanisms occurred at Cotopaxi. As these lahars originated in proglacial areas, we aim to explore a potential connection between glacier retreat and lahar formation.Here, we provide first insights into scarcely investigated subsurface conditions in periglacial areas of tropical glaciers. In order to gain knowledge on the presence of permafrost and ground ice, which can act as an aquiclude and potential detachment plane, we installed temperature loggers at 5-10 cm depth and performed electrical resistivity and seismic refraction surveys in the glacier forefields between 5000 and 5300 masl. The 1.5-year temperature record shows positive mean annual ground temperatures at all six logger sites. However, the temperature-calibrated electrical resistivity tomogram indicates partly frozen ground at depths of 10-20 m, where high electrical resistivities correspond to calibrated rock temperatures of -1.3 °C. We apply a 1-D thermal model to reproduce temperature changes at the surface with depth due to the retreat of cold-based glaciers. It allows to estimate the effect of the pyroclastic cover with high ice contents, which dampens thermal changes by uptake of latent heat during thawing, and can contribute to maintain ice bodies or relict permafrost lenses for years after deglaciation. In this study, we explore the relevance of degrading permafrost and ice lenses for preconditioning periglacial secondary lahars on rapidly deglaciating tropical volcanoes.Vuille, M., Carey, M., Huggel, C., Buytaert, W., Rabatel, A., Jacobsen, D., Soruco, A., Villacis, M., Yarleque, C. and Timm, O. E. 2018. Rapid decline of snow and ice in the tropical Andes–Impacts, uncertainties and challenges ahead. Earth-Science Reviews, 176, 195-213.
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessInvestigating subsurface conditions favouring the formation of secondary lahars in the glacier forefields of Cotopaxi volcano, Ecuador
Recently deglaciated terrain is highly active and subject to enhanced geomorphological change. The tropical glaciers on Cotopaxi volcano (5897 masl) in Ecuador are rapidly declining and have lost more than 50% of their surface area within the last five decades, and climate models predict a future rise of the Equilibrium Line Altitude of at least 200 m within the next 50 years (Vuille et al., 2018). The retreat of the presumably polythermal glaciers exposes unconsolidated, previously frozen pyroclastic material and moraine deposits on the steep volcano flanks. In recent years, secondary lahars unrelated to obvious trigger mechanisms occurred at Cotopaxi. As these lahars originated in proglacial areas, we aim to explore a potential connection between glacier retreat and lahar formation.Here, we provide first insights into scarcely investigated subsurface conditions in periglacial areas of tropical glaciers. In order to gain knowledge on the presence of permafrost and ground ice, which can act as an aquiclude and potential detachment plane, we installed temperature loggers at 5-10 cm depth and performed electrical resistivity and seismic refraction surveys in the glacier forefields between 5000 and 5300 masl. The 1.5-year temperature record shows positive mean annual ground temperatures at all six logger sites. However, the temperature-calibrated electrical resistivity tomogram indicates partly frozen ground at depths of 10-20 m, where high electrical resistivities correspond to calibrated rock temperatures of -1.3 °C. We apply a 1-D thermal model to reproduce temperature changes at the surface with depth due to the retreat of cold-based glaciers. It allows to estimate the effect of the pyroclastic cover with high ice contents, which dampens thermal changes by uptake of latent heat during thawing, and can contribute to maintain ice bodies or relict permafrost lenses for years after deglaciation. In this study, we explore the relevance of degrading permafrost and ice lenses for preconditioning periglacial secondary lahars on rapidly deglaciating tropical volcanoes.Vuille, M., Carey, M., Huggel, C., Buytaert, W., Rabatel, A., Jacobsen, D., Soruco, A., Villacis, M., Yarleque, C. and Timm, O. E. 2018. Rapid decline of snow and ice in the tropical Andes–Impacts, uncertainties and challenges ahead. Earth-Science Reviews, 176, 195-213.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Towards a better understanding of the role of glacier retreat and permafrost degradation in triggering secondary lahars
As everywhere in the Andes, tropical glaciers have been rapidly retreating since several decades. The glaciers of Cotopaxi volcano, Ecuador, have been reduced in area by about 50% since 1976 (Cáceres, 2017). The Cotopaxi is mostly famous for its capacity to produce massive lahars during volcanic eruptions, but comparably smaller, secondary lahars generated in post-eruptive periods by heavy rainfall occur more frequently on the volcano’s flanks. However, since a few years, secondary lahars that originate in proglacial areas without any clear trigger mechanism are recorded at Cotopaxi. This raises the question of whether there exists a process-based link between the occurrence of secondary lahars and the retreat of cold-based glaciers with accompanied permafrost degradation in the former subglacial frozen pyroclastic material over the following years and decades.Here, we present the data obtained from laboratory-calibrated Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Seismic Refraction Tomography (SRT) conducted near the glacier margin between 5000 and 5300 m asl, which provide a better understanding of frozen/unfrozen conditions and the structure of the subsurface. In addition, data loggers have been recording surface air temperatures close to the glacier since May 2018. Our measurements show that permafrost cannot develop under current thermal conditions, but high electrical resistivities at depths of 10-20 m correspond to calibrated rock temperatures below 0 °C. The detected frozen lenses may act as detachment planes of periglacial secondary lahars in pyroclastic material recently exposed by glacier retreat. Cáceres, B. (2017). Goal workshop 2017 Mexico 135 Evolución de los glaciares del Ecuador durante los últimos 60 años y su relación con el cambio climático. Conference paper: The role of Geosciences to societal development: A German-Latin American Perspective. GOAL Geo-Network of Latin American-German Alumini. P. 149. México: UANL-Monterrey-México.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessTowards a better understanding of the role of glacier retreat and permafrost degradation in triggering secondary lahars
As everywhere in the Andes, tropical glaciers have been rapidly retreating since several decades. The glaciers of Cotopaxi volcano, Ecuador, have been reduced in area by about 50% since 1976 (Cáceres, 2017). The Cotopaxi is mostly famous for its capacity to produce massive lahars during volcanic eruptions, but comparably smaller, secondary lahars generated in post-eruptive periods by heavy rainfall occur more frequently on the volcano’s flanks. However, since a few years, secondary lahars that originate in proglacial areas without any clear trigger mechanism are recorded at Cotopaxi. This raises the question of whether there exists a process-based link between the occurrence of secondary lahars and the retreat of cold-based glaciers with accompanied permafrost degradation in the former subglacial frozen pyroclastic material over the following years and decades.Here, we present the data obtained from laboratory-calibrated Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Seismic Refraction Tomography (SRT) conducted near the glacier margin between 5000 and 5300 m asl, which provide a better understanding of frozen/unfrozen conditions and the structure of the subsurface. In addition, data loggers have been recording surface air temperatures close to the glacier since May 2018. Our measurements show that permafrost cannot develop under current thermal conditions, but high electrical resistivities at depths of 10-20 m correspond to calibrated rock temperatures below 0 °C. The detected frozen lenses may act as detachment planes of periglacial secondary lahars in pyroclastic material recently exposed by glacier retreat. Cáceres, B. (2017). Goal workshop 2017 Mexico 135 Evolución de los glaciares del Ecuador durante los últimos 60 años y su relación con el cambio climático. Conference paper: The role of Geosciences to societal development: A German-Latin American Perspective. GOAL Geo-Network of Latin American-German Alumini. P. 149. México: UANL-Monterrey-México.
- Open Access
- 5 February 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (4) , 1714
Community Perception and Communication of Volcanic Risk from the Cotopaxi Volcano in Latacunga, Ecuador
The inhabitants of Latacunga living in the surrounding of the Cotopaxi volcano (Ecuador) are exposed to several hazards and related disasters. After the last 2015 volcanic eruption, it became evident once again how important it is for the exposed population to understand their own social, physical, and systemic vulnerability. Effective risk communication is essential before the occurrence of a volcanic crisis. This study integrates quantitative risk and semi-quantitative social risk perceptions, aiming for risk-informed communities. We present the use of the RIESGOS demonstrator for interactive exploration and visualisation of risk scenarios. The development of this demonstrator through an iterative process with the local experts and potential end-users increases both the quality of the technical tool as well as its practical applicability. Moreover, the community risk perception in a focused area was investigated through online and field surveys. Geo-located interviews are used to map the social perception of volcanic risk factors. Scenario-based outcomes from quantitative risk assessment obtained by the RIESGOS demonstrator are compared with the semi-quantitative risk perceptions. We have found that further efforts are required to provide the exposed communities with a better understanding of the concepts of hazard scenario and intensity.
- 5 February 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (4) , 1714
Open AccessCommunity Perception and Communication of Volcanic Risk from the Cotopaxi Volcano in Latacunga, Ecuador
The inhabitants of Latacunga living in the surrounding of the Cotopaxi volcano (Ecuador) are exposed to several hazards and related disasters. After the last 2015 volcanic eruption, it became evident once again how important it is for the exposed population to understand their own social, physical, and systemic vulnerability. Effective risk communication is essential before the occurrence of a volcanic crisis. This study integrates quantitative risk and semi-quantitative social risk perceptions, aiming for risk-informed communities. We present the use of the RIESGOS demonstrator for interactive exploration and visualisation of risk scenarios. The development of this demonstrator through an iterative process with the local experts and potential end-users increases both the quality of the technical tool as well as its practical applicability. Moreover, the community risk perception in a focused area was investigated through online and field surveys. Geo-located interviews are used to map the social perception of volcanic risk factors. Scenario-based outcomes from quantitative risk assessment obtained by the RIESGOS demonstrator are compared with the semi-quantitative risk perceptions. We have found that further efforts are required to provide the exposed communities with a better understanding of the concepts of hazard scenario and intensity.
- Open Access
- 22 December 2020
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 46 (3) , 680-700
Modelling future lahars controlled by different volcanic eruption scenarios at Cotopaxi (Ecuador) calibrated with the massively destructive 1877 lahar
Lahars are among the most hazardous mass flow processes on earth and have caused up to 23 000 casualties in single events in the recent past. The Cotopaxi volcano, 60 km southeast of Quito, has a well‐documented history of massively destructive lahars and is a hotspot for future lahars due to (i) its ~10 km2 glacier cap, (ii) its 117–147‐year return period of (Sub)‐Plinian eruptions, and (iii) the densely populated potential inundation zones (300 000 inhabitants). Previous mechanical lahar models often do not (i) capture the steep initial lahar trajectory, (ii) reproduce multiple flow paths including bifurcation and confluence, and (iii) generate appropriate key parameters like flow speed and pressure at the base as a measure of erosion capacity. Here, we back‐calculate the well‐documented 1877 lahar using the RAMMS debris flow model with an implemented entrainment algorithm, covering the entire lahar path from the volcano edifice to an extent of ~70 km from the source. To evaluate the sensitivity and to constrain the model input range, we systematically explore input parameter values, especially the Voellmy–Salm friction coefficients μ and ξ. Objective selection of the most likely parameter combinations enables a realistic and robust lahar hazard representation. Detailed historic records for flow height, flow velocity, peak discharge, travel time and inundation limits match best with a very low Coulomb‐type friction μ (0.0025–0.005) and a high turbulent friction ξ (1000–1400 m/s2). Finally, we apply the calibrated model to future eruption scenarios (Volcanic Explosivity Index = 2–3, 3–4, >4) at Cotopaxi and accordingly scaled lahars. For the first time, we anticipate a potential volume growth of 50–400% due to lahar erosivity on steep volcano flanks. Here we develop a generic Voellmy–Salm approach across different scales of high‐magnitude lahars and show how it can be used to anticipate future syneruptive lahars.
- 22 December 2020
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 46 (3) , 680-700
Open AccessModelling future lahars controlled by different volcanic eruption scenarios at Cotopaxi (Ecuador) calibrated with the massively destructive 1877 lahar
Lahars are among the most hazardous mass flow processes on earth and have caused up to 23 000 casualties in single events in the recent past. The Cotopaxi volcano, 60 km southeast of Quito, has a well‐documented history of massively destructive lahars and is a hotspot for future lahars due to (i) its ~10 km2 glacier cap, (ii) its 117–147‐year return period of (Sub)‐Plinian eruptions, and (iii) the densely populated potential inundation zones (300 000 inhabitants). Previous mechanical lahar models often do not (i) capture the steep initial lahar trajectory, (ii) reproduce multiple flow paths including bifurcation and confluence, and (iii) generate appropriate key parameters like flow speed and pressure at the base as a measure of erosion capacity. Here, we back‐calculate the well‐documented 1877 lahar using the RAMMS debris flow model with an implemented entrainment algorithm, covering the entire lahar path from the volcano edifice to an extent of ~70 km from the source. To evaluate the sensitivity and to constrain the model input range, we systematically explore input parameter values, especially the Voellmy–Salm friction coefficients μ and ξ. Objective selection of the most likely parameter combinations enables a realistic and robust lahar hazard representation. Detailed historic records for flow height, flow velocity, peak discharge, travel time and inundation limits match best with a very low Coulomb‐type friction μ (0.0025–0.005) and a high turbulent friction ξ (1000–1400 m/s2). Finally, we apply the calibrated model to future eruption scenarios (Volcanic Explosivity Index = 2–3, 3–4, >4) at Cotopaxi and accordingly scaled lahars. For the first time, we anticipate a potential volume growth of 50–400% due to lahar erosivity on steep volcano flanks. Here we develop a generic Voellmy–Salm approach across different scales of high‐magnitude lahars and show how it can be used to anticipate future syneruptive lahars.
- Open Access
- 23 March 2020
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Assessing lahar hazards at Cotopaxi volcano (Ecuador) controlled by volcanic eruptions and glacier retreat
Lahars rank as one of the most destructive hazards at Cotopaxi volcano (5897 m asl) due to the presence of a massive glacier cap, the frequency of eruptions and the high population density in the surrounding, potentially inundated valleys. In 1877, Cotopaxi experienced the last major VEI 3-4 eruption, producing syneruptive lahars of 60-100 million m3 that travelled hundreds of km downstream. Few lahar simulations based on empirical or fluid dynamic approaches exist for Cotopaxi, but here we introduce a calibrated numerical debris flow model capable of reproducing confluence and erosivity of flows.In this study, we back-calculate the well documented 1877 lahar event using the 2D debris flow model RAMMS, which is based on the Voellmy-Salm friction approach and includes an entrainment algorithm. We first evaluate the sensitivity and range of possible model input parameters by systematically varying model inputs for release volume, density and frictional resistance (Coulomb type friction μ [-] and turbulent friction ξ [ms-2]). Supported by a probabilistic analysis, we find that a choice of historical and field-derived calibration metrics of the 1877 lahar event along the northern lahar trajectory can well constrain most likely input parameters for frictional resistance. Our results show that modelling large-scale primary lahars at Cotopaxi is strongly controlled by very small values for Coulomb friction μ (0.005-0.015). Finally, we apply the calibrated model to typical eruption scenarios of Cotopaxi (VEI 1 to >4) in order to enable a realistic lahar hazard representation.Considering the rapid rise of the equilibrium-line altitude of tropical Andean glaciers together with reports on secondary lahars at the eastern flank of Cotopaxi without any clear trigger, we hypothesize a process-based link between the two phenomena. Geoelectrical and refraction seismic field surveys near the glacier margin (5000- 5300 m asl) have been conducted in order to gain a better understanding of the structure, conditions and degree of freezing of the subsurface, which is dominated by loose pyroclastic material and interbedded lava layers. The tomography results are highlighted within the concept of permafrost degradation and accompanied material weakening as potential triggering mechanism for secondary lahars.Here we show 1) a carefully calibrated numerical lahar model at Cotopaxi capable of reproducing previously non-respected effects such as confluence, erosion reach and propagation speed, and 2) first measurements addressing the role of glacier retreat on the formation of secondary lahars. Our results contribute to the multi-hazard risk assessment in the RIESGOS project funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research.
- 23 March 2020
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAssessing lahar hazards at Cotopaxi volcano (Ecuador) controlled by volcanic eruptions and glacier retreat
Lahars rank as one of the most destructive hazards at Cotopaxi volcano (5897 m asl) due to the presence of a massive glacier cap, the frequency of eruptions and the high population density in the surrounding, potentially inundated valleys. In 1877, Cotopaxi experienced the last major VEI 3-4 eruption, producing syneruptive lahars of 60-100 million m3 that travelled hundreds of km downstream. Few lahar simulations based on empirical or fluid dynamic approaches exist for Cotopaxi, but here we introduce a calibrated numerical debris flow model capable of reproducing confluence and erosivity of flows.In this study, we back-calculate the well documented 1877 lahar event using the 2D debris flow model RAMMS, which is based on the Voellmy-Salm friction approach and includes an entrainment algorithm. We first evaluate the sensitivity and range of possible model input parameters by systematically varying model inputs for release volume, density and frictional resistance (Coulomb type friction μ [-] and turbulent friction ξ [ms-2]). Supported by a probabilistic analysis, we find that a choice of historical and field-derived calibration metrics of the 1877 lahar event along the northern lahar trajectory can well constrain most likely input parameters for frictional resistance. Our results show that modelling large-scale primary lahars at Cotopaxi is strongly controlled by very small values for Coulomb friction μ (0.005-0.015). Finally, we apply the calibrated model to typical eruption scenarios of Cotopaxi (VEI 1 to >4) in order to enable a realistic lahar hazard representation.Considering the rapid rise of the equilibrium-line altitude of tropical Andean glaciers together with reports on secondary lahars at the eastern flank of Cotopaxi without any clear trigger, we hypothesize a process-based link between the two phenomena. Geoelectrical and refraction seismic field surveys near the glacier margin (5000- 5300 m asl) have been conducted in order to gain a better understanding of the structure, conditions and degree of freezing of the subsurface, which is dominated by loose pyroclastic material and interbedded lava layers. The tomography results are highlighted within the concept of permafrost degradation and accompanied material weakening as potential triggering mechanism for secondary lahars.Here we show 1) a carefully calibrated numerical lahar model at Cotopaxi capable of reproducing previously non-respected effects such as confluence, erosion reach and propagation speed, and 2) first measurements addressing the role of glacier retreat on the formation of secondary lahars. Our results contribute to the multi-hazard risk assessment in the RIESGOS project funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research.
- Open Access
- 23 March 2020
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Scenario- based multi- risk assessment on exposed buildings to volcanic cascading hazards
In order to assess the building portfolio composition for a particular natural hazard risk assessment application, it is necessary to classify the built environment into schemas containing building classes. The building classes should also address the attributes which may control their vulnerability towards the different hazards associated with their failure mechanisms, which along with their respective fragility functions are representative of a particular study area. In the case of volcanic risk, former efforts have been carried out in developing volcanic related fragility functions, this has been done mostly for European, Atlantic islands and South Asian building types (SEDIMER, MIA VITA, VOLDIES, EXPLORIS, SAFELAND projects). However, in other parts of the globe, particular construction practices, materials, and even occupancies may describe very diverse building types with different degrees of vulnerability which may or not be compatible with the existing schemas and fragility functions (Spence et al. 2005, Zuccaro et al. 2013, Mavrouli et al. 2013, Jenkins et al. 2014, Torres-Corredor et al. 2017).As highlighted by Zuccaro et al. 2018, since in the case of volcanic active areas, the built environment will not only be exposed to a single hazard but to several compound or cascading hazards (e.g. tephra fall, pyroclastic flows, lahars), with different time intervals between them, a dynamic vulnerability with cumulated damage on the physical assets would be the baseline upon a multi-risk- volcanic framework should be described. In this similar context, single- hazard but still multi-state fragility functions have been very recently used in order to set up damage descriptions independently on the reference building schema. We propose to generalize this novel approach and further extend it in the volcanic risk assessment context. To do so, the very first step was to generate a multi-hazard- building- taxonomy containing a set of exhaustive mutually exclusive building attributes. Upon that framework, a probabilistic mapping across single- hazards- building- schemas and damage states has been achieved.This methodological approach has been tested under the RIESGOS project over a selected study area of the Latin American Andes Region. In this region, cities close to active volcanos have been experienced a non-structured grow, which is translated into a significantly vulnerable population living in non- engineering buildings that are highly exposed to volcanic hazards. The Cotopaxi region in Ecuador has been chosen in order to explore the ash falls and lahars damage contributions with several scenarios in terms of volcanic explosivity index (VEI). Local lahars simulations have been obtained at different resolutions. Moreover, probabilistic ash- fall maps have been recently obtained after exhaustive ash fall and wind direction measurements. Lahar flow- velocity and ash- fall load pressure were respectively used as intensity measures. Furthermore, local and foreign building schemas that define the building exposure models have been constrained through ancillary data, cadastral information, and remote individual building inspections, to then been associated with a multi-state fragility function. These ingredients have been integrated into this novel methodological scenario-based- multi-risk- volcanic assessment.
- 23 March 2020
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessScenario- based multi- risk assessment on exposed buildings to volcanic cascading hazards
In order to assess the building portfolio composition for a particular natural hazard risk assessment application, it is necessary to classify the built environment into schemas containing building classes. The building classes should also address the attributes which may control their vulnerability towards the different hazards associated with their failure mechanisms, which along with their respective fragility functions are representative of a particular study area. In the case of volcanic risk, former efforts have been carried out in developing volcanic related fragility functions, this has been done mostly for European, Atlantic islands and South Asian building types (SEDIMER, MIA VITA, VOLDIES, EXPLORIS, SAFELAND projects). However, in other parts of the globe, particular construction practices, materials, and even occupancies may describe very diverse building types with different degrees of vulnerability which may or not be compatible with the existing schemas and fragility functions (Spence et al. 2005, Zuccaro et al. 2013, Mavrouli et al. 2013, Jenkins et al. 2014, Torres-Corredor et al. 2017).As highlighted by Zuccaro et al. 2018, since in the case of volcanic active areas, the built environment will not only be exposed to a single hazard but to several compound or cascading hazards (e.g. tephra fall, pyroclastic flows, lahars), with different time intervals between them, a dynamic vulnerability with cumulated damage on the physical assets would be the baseline upon a multi-risk- volcanic framework should be described. In this similar context, single- hazard but still multi-state fragility functions have been very recently used in order to set up damage descriptions independently on the reference building schema. We propose to generalize this novel approach and further extend it in the volcanic risk assessment context. To do so, the very first step was to generate a multi-hazard- building- taxonomy containing a set of exhaustive mutually exclusive building attributes. Upon that framework, a probabilistic mapping across single- hazards- building- schemas and damage states has been achieved.This methodological approach has been tested under the RIESGOS project over a selected study area of the Latin American Andes Region. In this region, cities close to active volcanos have been experienced a non-structured grow, which is translated into a significantly vulnerable population living in non- engineering buildings that are highly exposed to volcanic hazards. The Cotopaxi region in Ecuador has been chosen in order to explore the ash falls and lahars damage contributions with several scenarios in terms of volcanic explosivity index (VEI). Local lahars simulations have been obtained at different resolutions. Moreover, probabilistic ash- fall maps have been recently obtained after exhaustive ash fall and wind direction measurements. Lahar flow- velocity and ash- fall load pressure were respectively used as intensity measures. Furthermore, local and foreign building schemas that define the building exposure models have been constrained through ancillary data, cadastral information, and remote individual building inspections, to then been associated with a multi-state fragility function. These ingredients have been integrated into this novel methodological scenario-based- multi-risk- volcanic assessment.