MCMartine Chamberland

Martine Chamberland

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Martine Chamberland has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Wiskott-Aldrich Syndrome Mimicking Relapsing Polychondritis in a Middle-aged Woman: A Case Report

    by Samer Hussein, Martine Chamberland, Valérie Désilets, Hugues Allard-Chamard

    Background: Inborn errors of immunity pose a diagnostic challenge for rheumatologists, as they can masquerade as various autoimmune diseases. Maintaining a low threshold for investigation is crucial to prevent delays in diagnosis. Additionally, the atypical presentation of an X-linked disorder in a female patient is unlikely and leads to a late diagnosis and suboptimal treatment; thus, our case report aimed to raise awareness of these complex and often overlooked conditions. Case Presentation: Herein, we have described the rare case of Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome, an X-linked disease, presenting in a middle-aged woman who was initially diagnosed with relapsing polychondritis. By reviewing the patient’s medical and family history, we identified key clues of immunodeficiency, a low platelet count, and a son with features consistent with Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome, which could have prompted earlier testing and recognition of her condition. Conclusion: While autoimmune diseases may resemble inborn errors of immunity, a cautious examination of the patient’s familial history and atypical diagnostic odyssey may help discriminate between the diagnoses.

  • Développement d’une simulation numérique avec patients virtuels pour soutenir le raisonnement clinique des étudiants en médecine : une approche de recherche axée sur la conception

    by Martine Chamberland, Luc Lanthier, Jean Setrakian, Isabelle Boulais, Mathieu Labossière, Audrey Cloutier, Linda Bergeron, Tim Dubé

    Contexte : La formation clinique au prégradué en médecine est une période charnière pour le développement du raisonnement clinique (RC), mais les occasions d’apprentissage en contexte de supervision clinique sont soumises à plusieurs contraintes. Nous avons donc élaboré et piloté une plateforme de simulation avec patients virtuels comme activité complémentaire pour soutenir le RC à l’externat. Méthodes : Développée selon une approche de recherche axée sur la conception, la plateforme SIRACLE propose des situations cliniques authentiques, une démarche complète et explicite de RC et de multiples rétroactions. Un projet pilote utilisant un devis mixte séquentiel explicatif (questionnaire et groupe de discussion) a été réalisé auprès d’étudiants afin de décrire son utilisabilité et son utilité pour l’apprentissage du RC. Les données ont été analysées par statistiques descriptives et analyse thématique. Résultats : Quatorze étudiants ont participé au projet pilote de six semaines. Sur une échelle de cinq points, les scores moyens des items variaient de 3,3 à 4,8 pour l’utilisabilité (trois items formulés en sens inverse variaient entre 1,5 et 1,8), de 4,1 à 4,8 pour l’utilité et atteignaient 4,5 pour l’appréciation générale. L’analyse thématique a révélé quatre thèmes : 1) une activité en cohérence avec le niveau de la formation ; 2) une activité d’apprentissage différente et complémentaire ; 3) une activité qui a des effets perçus sur l’apprentissage ; 4) une activité flexible et accessible. Conclusions : La plateforme SIRACLE semble répondre à son intention pédagogique de compléter la supervision clinique afin de soutenir l’apprentissage du RC. Les résultats soutiennent son utilisabilité auprès des étudiants. La perception favorable de son utilité renforce l’importance à accorder au design pédagogique des outils technologiques avec patients virtuels.

  • Open Access

    Embedding Clinical Reasoning into an Undergraduate Medical Curriculum: A Multi-Stakeholder Perspective

    by Martine Chamberland, Isabelle Boulais, Jean Setrakian, Linda Bergeron, Tim Dubé

    Introduction: Medical educators agree on the importance of teaching clinical reasoning (CR) at the undergraduate level with a deliberate curricular approach. Despite recent recommendations on how to reach this objective, there are limited empirical data on how it unfolds once implemented. This study advanced the understanding of how a deliberately designed CR curriculum was experienced and contributed to students’ CR development. Our study sought to add to the conversation on undergraduate CR curricula by providing data that could be relevant and applicable across other learning contexts. Methods: We conducted a qualitative descriptive study in the context of a competency-based medical program that is interdisciplinary, with spiral integration. Through nine focus groups, we sought the experience of curriculum designers, teachers, and students on how the CR curriculum embedded into the program contributes to students’ CR development. Data were analyzed using a thematic approach. Results: We identified four overarching themes: 1- Global coherence of the curriculum around the development of CR; 2- Interdisciplinary integration to enhance CR development; 3-Cognitive load of students and pervasive time constraints; 4- Active teaching methods that promote the development of CR. Discussion: From the different stakeholders’ perspectives, students acquired various knowledge types in CR domains and applied them to problem-solving. Stakeholders’ experiences with the implemented CR curriculum matched the initial intent but presented some challenges as well. These findings underscored both the feasibility and the complexity of embedding CR within an undergraduate medical curriculum. Careful attention is required to support students and teachers.

  • Open Access

    Pathways, journeys and experiences: Integrating curricular activities related to social accountability within an undergraduate medical curriculum

    by Tim V. Dubé, Annabelle Cumyn, Mariem Fourati, Martine Chamberland, Sharon Hatcher, Michel Landry

    Background: Health professions education curricula are undergoing reform towards social accountability (SA), defined as an academic institution's obligation to orient its education, service and research to respond to societal needs. However, little is known about how or which educational experiences transform learners and the processes behind such action. For example, those responsible for the development and implementation of undergraduate medical education (UGME) programs can benefit from a deeper understanding of educational approaches that foster the development of competencies related to SA. The purpose of this paper was to learn from the perspectives of the various partners involved in a program's delivery about what curricular aspects related to SA are expressed in a UGME program. Methods: We undertook a qualitative descriptive study at a francophone Canadian university. Through purposive convenience and snowball sampling, we conducted 16 focus groups (virtual) with the following partners: (a) third‐ and fourth‐year medical students, (b) medical teachers, (c) program administrators (e.g., program leadership), (d) community members (e.g., community organisations) and (e) patient partners. We used inductive thematic analysis to interpret the data. Results: The participants' perspectives organised around four key themes including (a) the definition of a future socially accountable physician, (b) socially accountable educational activities and experiences, (c) characteristics of a socially accountable MD program and (d) suggestions for curriculum improvement and implementation. Conclusions: We extend scholarship about curricular activities related to SA from the perspectives of those involved in teaching and learning. We highlight the relevance of experiential learning, engagement with community members and patient partners and collaborative approaches to curriculum development. Our study provides a snapshot of what are the sequential pathways in fostering SA among medical students and therefore addresses a gap between knowledge and practice regarding what contributes to the implementation of educational approaches related to SA. We emphasise the need for educational innovation and research to develop and align assessment methods with teaching and learning related to SA.


  • Open Access

    Exploring medical students’ use of principles of self-explanation and structured reflection during clerkship

    by Martine Chamberland, Vanessa Beaudoin, Isabelle Boulais, Linda Bergeron, Christina St-Onge, Timothy Dubé

    Background: While educators observe gaps in clerkship students’ clinical reasoning (CR) skills, students report few opportunities to develop them. This study aims at exploring how students who used self-explanation (SE) and structured reflection (SR) for CR learning during preclinical training, applied these learning strategies during clerkship. Methods: We conducted an explanatory sequential mixed-methods study involving medical students. With a questionnaire, we asked students how frequently they adopted behaviours related to SE and SR during clerkship. Next, we conducted a focus group with students to explore why they adopted these behaviours. Results: Fifty-two of 198 students answered the questionnaire and five participated in a focus group. Specific behaviours adopted varied from 50% to 98%. We identified three themes about why students used these strategies: as “just in time” learning strategies; to deepen their understanding and identify gaps in knowledge; to develop a practical approach to diagnosis. A fourth theme related to the balance between learning and assessment and its consequence on adopting SE behaviours. Conclusions: Students having experienced SE and SR regularly in preclinical training tend to transpose these strategies into the clerkship providing them with a practical way to reflect deliberately and capture learning opportunities of the unpredictable clinical context.


  • Open Access

    Harnessing a knowledge translation framework to implement an undergraduate medical education intervention: A longitudinal study

    by Martine Chamberland, Jean Setrakian, Linda Bergeron, Lara Varpio, Christina St-Onge, Aliki Thomas

    Introduction Implementation of evidence-informed educational interventions (EEI) involves applying and adapting theoretical and scientific knowledge to a specific context. Knowledge translation (KT) approaches can both facilitate and structure the process. The purpose of this paper is to describe lessons learned from applying a KT approach to help implement an EEI for clinical reasoning in medical students. Methods Using the Knowledge to Action framework, we designed and implemented an EEI intended to support the development of students’ clinical reasoning skills in a renewed medical curriculum. Using mixed-methods design, we monitored students’ engagement with the EEI longitudinally through a platform log; we conducted focus groups with students and stakeholders, and observed the unfolding of the implementation and its continuation. Data are reported according to six implementation outcomes: Fidelity, Feasibility, Appropriateness, Acceptability, Adoption, and Penetration. Results Students spent a mean of 24min on the activity (fidelity outcome) with a high completion rate (between 75% and 95%; feasibility outcome) of the entire activity each time it was done. Focus group data from students and stakeholders suggest that the activity was acceptable, appropriate, feasible, adopted and well-integrated into the curriculum.


  • Implementation of three knowledge-oriented instructional strategies to teach clinical reasoning: Self-explanation, a concept mapping exercise, and deliberate reflection: AMEE Guide No. 150

    by Dario Torre, Martine Chamberland, Silvia Mamede

    The teaching of clinical reasoning is essential in medical education. This guide has been written to provide educators with practical advice on the design, development, and implementation of three knowledge-oriented instructional strategies for the teaching of clinical reasoning to medical students: Self-explanation (SE), a Clinical Reasoning Mapping Exercise (CREsME), and Deliberate Reflection (DR). We first synthesize the theoretical tenets that support the use of these strategies, including knowledge organization, and development of illness scripts. We then provide a detailed description of the key components of each strategy, emphasizing the practical applications of each one by sharing specific examples. We also explore the potential for a combined application of these strategies in a longitudinal and developmental approach to teaching clinical reasoning at the undergraduate level. Finally, we discuss enablers and barriers in the implementation and integration of these teaching strategies while taking into consideration curricular needs, context, and resources. We are aware that many strategies exist and are not arguing that SE, CReSME, and DR are the most effective ones or the only ones to be adopted. Nevertheless, we selected these strategies because of overarching theoretical principles, empirical evidence supporting their use, and our own experience with them. We are hoping to provide practical advice on the implementation of these strategies to practicing educators who aim at developing an integrated approach to the teaching of clinical reasoning to medical students at different stages of their development.


  • Open Access

    A layered analysis of self-explanation and structured reflection to support clinical reasoning in medical students

    by Martine Chamberland, Silvia Mamede, Linda Bergeron, Lara Varpio

    Self-explanation and structured reflection have been studied independently with results suggesting that both learning interventions can effectively support medical students’ clinical reasoning development. Given this evidence, medical schools may want/begin to implement these interventions in their curricula. Implementing educational interventions requires educators to maintain the core philosophy and principles of the interventions intact while adjusting implementation techniques to the specificities of individual learning contexts. Educational scholars have yet to explicitly articulate the philosophy, principles and techniques of self-explanation and structured reflection. Without such descriptions, educators risk failing to realize self-explanation’s and structured reflection’s effect to support students’ clinical reasoning skill development in their implementations. Relying on the layered analysis approach, we articulate the philosophy, principles and techniques of self-explanation and structured reflection. This description is framed within the context of an actual implementation to illustrate the philosophies underpinning self-explanation and structured reflection, the principles that realize those philosophies, and the techniques that can be used to enact those principles. Building on the similarities between self-explanation and structured reflection, while also harnessing their differences, we identify why and how these interventions can be combined in a single implementation, while preserving their philosophies and principles. The layered analysis of self-explanation and structured reflection offers essential insights into the underpinnings of these interventions. They are articulated in this manuscript in hopes that other scholars will continue to refine these descriptions thereby facilitating effective use of self-explanation and structured reflection for clinical reasoning development.


  • Open Access

    Comparison of Assessment by a Virtual Patient and by Clinician-Educators of Medical Students' History-Taking Skills: Exploratory Descriptive Study

    by Jean Setrakian, Geneviève Gauthier, Linda Bergeron, Martine Chamberland, Christina St-Onge

    Background: A virtual patient (VP) can be a useful tool to foster the development of medical history–taking skills without the inherent constraints of the bedside setting. Although VPs hold the promise of contributing to the development of students’ skills, documenting and assessing skills acquired through a VP is a challenge. Objective: We propose a framework for the automated assessment of medical history taking within a VP software and then test this framework by comparing VP scores with the judgment of 10 clinician-educators (CEs). Methods: We built upon 4 domains of medical history taking to be assessed (breadth, depth, logical sequence, and interviewing technique), adapting these to be implemented into a specific VP environment. A total of 10 CEs watched the screen recordings of 3 students to assess their performance first globally and then for each of the 4 domains. Results: The scores provided by the VPs were slightly higher but comparable with those given by the CEs for global performance and for depth, logical sequence, and interviewing technique. For breadth, the VP scores were higher for 2 of the 3 students compared with the CE scores. Conclusions: Findings suggest that the VP assessment gives results akin to those that would be generated by CEs. Developing a model for what constitutes good history-taking performance in specific contexts may provide insights into how CEs generally think about assessment.


  • Open Access

    Does providing the correct diagnosis as feedback after self-explanation improve medical students diagnostic performance?

    by M. Chamberland, J. Setrakian, C. St-Onge, L. Bergeron, S. Mamede, H. G. Schmidt

    Self-explanation without feedback has been shown to improve medical students’ diagnostic reasoning. While feedback is generally seen as beneficial for learning, available evidence of the value of its combination with self-explanation is conflicting. This study investigated the effect on medical students’ diagnostic performance of adding immediate or delayed content-feedback to self-explanation while solving cases. Ninety-four 3rd-year students from a Canadian medical school were randomly assigned to three experimental conditions (immediate-feedback, delayed-feedback, control). In the learning phase, all students solved four clinical cases by giving i) the most likely diagnosis, ii) two main arguments supporting this diagnosis, and iii) two plausible alternative diagnoses, while using self-explanation. The immediate-feedback group was given the correct diagnosis after each case; delayed-feedback group received the correct diagnoses only after the four cases; control group received no feedback. One week later, all students solved four near-transfer (i.e., same final diagnosis as the learning cases but different scenarios) and four far-transfer cases (i.e., different final diagnosis from the learning cases and different scenarios) by answering the same three questions. Students’ diagnostic accuracy (score for the response to the first question only) and diagnostic performance (combined score of responses to the three questions) scores were assessed in each phase. Four one-way ANOVAs were performed on each of the two scores for near and far-transfer cases. There was a significant effect of experimental condition on diagnostic accuracy on near-transfer cases (p < .05). The immediate-feedback and delayed-feedback groups performed equally well, both better than control (respectively, mean = 90.73, standard deviation =10.69; mean = 89.92, standard deviation = 13.85; mean = 82.03, standard deviation = 17.66). The experimental conditions did not significantly differ on far-transfer cases. Providing feedback to students in the form of the correct diagnosis after using self-explanation with clinical cases is potentially beneficial to improve their diagnostic accuracy but this effect is limited to similar cases. Further studies should explore how more elaborated feedback combined with self-explanation may impact students’ diagnostic performance on different cases.