Phillip Cilli
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Phillip Cilli has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anthony Watts
University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
4 shared publications - Brian Boston
Department of Geosciences Auburn University Auburn AL USA
4 shared publications - Donna J. Shillington
School of Earth and Sustainability Northern Arizona University Flagstaff AZ USA
4 shared publications - Paul Wessel
SOEST, University of Hawaii at Manoa
4 shared publications Mark Chapman
3 shared publications- Robert Allen Dunn
Department of Earth Sciences School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology University of Hawaii at Mānoa Honolulu HI USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 June 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 130 (6)
Crustal Structure Along and Surrounding the Hawaiian Islands: Volcanic Island Construction Across Scarred Oceanic Crust
The Hawaiian Ridge is a classic example of an intraplate volcanic island chain emplaced on oceanic lithosphere. We seek to constrain both the deformation from island loading around the Hawaiian Ridge and the influence of the oceanic lithosphere, including the Molokaʻi fracture zone (MFZ), on off‐axis volcanic emplacement. To examine these processes, we conducted a marine geophysical experiment in 2018 that included the acquisition of eight multichannel seismic reflection lines and used a 6,600 in3 tuned air gun array and an ultra‐long hydrophone streamer cable towed behind R/V Marcus G. Langseth across and around the southern Hawaiian Ridge. We image both the top of igneous oceanic crust and the Moho, and we observe significant variations in regional crustal structure and thickness variations, Moho characteristics, the locations of the buried MFZ, and the flexure of the Pacific oceanic lithosphere under the Hawaiian Ridge. We observe up to ∼4.5 km of deflection of the igneous oceanic crust in response to the volcanic load with sediment thickness increasing to ∼3–3.4 km near the ridge but not correlating with the deflection. A systematic difference in igneous oceanic crustal thickness is found north (average ∼5.2 km) and south (average ∼5.9 km), of the MFZ that also correspond to changes in Moho characteristics. The MFZ itself is associated with the largest crustal thickness variations (∼3.7–7.6 km). Magma ascent through these different crustal regions may account for some variations of magmatic flux to the surface along the Hawaiian Ridge.
- 10 June 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 130 (6)
Open AccessCrustal Structure Along and Surrounding the Hawaiian Islands: Volcanic Island Construction Across Scarred Oceanic Crust
The Hawaiian Ridge is a classic example of an intraplate volcanic island chain emplaced on oceanic lithosphere. We seek to constrain both the deformation from island loading around the Hawaiian Ridge and the influence of the oceanic lithosphere, including the Molokaʻi fracture zone (MFZ), on off‐axis volcanic emplacement. To examine these processes, we conducted a marine geophysical experiment in 2018 that included the acquisition of eight multichannel seismic reflection lines and used a 6,600 in3 tuned air gun array and an ultra‐long hydrophone streamer cable towed behind R/V Marcus G. Langseth across and around the southern Hawaiian Ridge. We image both the top of igneous oceanic crust and the Moho, and we observe significant variations in regional crustal structure and thickness variations, Moho characteristics, the locations of the buried MFZ, and the flexure of the Pacific oceanic lithosphere under the Hawaiian Ridge. We observe up to ∼4.5 km of deflection of the igneous oceanic crust in response to the volcanic load with sediment thickness increasing to ∼3–3.4 km near the ridge but not correlating with the deflection. A systematic difference in igneous oceanic crustal thickness is found north (average ∼5.2 km) and south (average ∼5.9 km), of the MFZ that also correspond to changes in Moho characteristics. The MFZ itself is associated with the largest crustal thickness variations (∼3.7–7.6 km). Magma ascent through these different crustal regions may account for some variations of magmatic flux to the surface along the Hawaiian Ridge.
- Open Access
- 10 June 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 130 (6)
Magma‐Assisted Flexure of Hawaiian Lithosphere Inferred From Three‐Dimensional Models of Lithospheric Flexure Constrained by Active Source Seismic Data
Reprocessed and newly acquired seismic data provide new constraints on lithospheric flexure profiles beneath the Hawaiian Islands. We use these new observations and three‐dimensional numerical models of lithospheric deformation combining elasticity, brittle failure, low‐temperature plasticity (LTP) and high‐temperature creep deformation mechanisms to constrain the thermal structure and rheology of the oceanic lithosphere. When simulating normal oceanic lithospheric conditions with experimentally‐derived LTP flow laws, the lithosphere flexes with too little amplitude and over too large a wavelength compared to observations. This result supports prior studies which call on the need to (a) adjust the LTP flow laws or, alternatively, to (b) account for magma‐assisted flexural weakening of the lithosphere. Here, models that explore reductions in the activation energy of LTP are able to explain the observations of flexure with a smaller reduction than previously suggested. Models that explore elevated temperatures attributed to hotspot magmatism localized beneath the island edifices also produce close fits to the observed flexural profiles. Although the two factors cannot be distinguished based on fits to the flexure profiles, localized magma‐assisted flexural weakening is supported by recent studies of geothermobarometry of pyroxenite xenoliths from O'ahu, seismic structure and patterns of seismicity beneath the Hawaiian chain. If magma‐assisted flexure is a common phenomenon at other ocean islands and seamounts, it could explain similarities in elastic plate thickness with subduction zones as well as differences with fracture zones globally.
- 10 June 2025
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 130 (6)
Open AccessMagma‐Assisted Flexure of Hawaiian Lithosphere Inferred From Three‐Dimensional Models of Lithospheric Flexure Constrained by Active Source Seismic Data
Reprocessed and newly acquired seismic data provide new constraints on lithospheric flexure profiles beneath the Hawaiian Islands. We use these new observations and three‐dimensional numerical models of lithospheric deformation combining elasticity, brittle failure, low‐temperature plasticity (LTP) and high‐temperature creep deformation mechanisms to constrain the thermal structure and rheology of the oceanic lithosphere. When simulating normal oceanic lithospheric conditions with experimentally‐derived LTP flow laws, the lithosphere flexes with too little amplitude and over too large a wavelength compared to observations. This result supports prior studies which call on the need to (a) adjust the LTP flow laws or, alternatively, to (b) account for magma‐assisted flexural weakening of the lithosphere. Here, models that explore reductions in the activation energy of LTP are able to explain the observations of flexure with a smaller reduction than previously suggested. Models that explore elevated temperatures attributed to hotspot magmatism localized beneath the island edifices also produce close fits to the observed flexural profiles. Although the two factors cannot be distinguished based on fits to the flexure profiles, localized magma‐assisted flexural weakening is supported by recent studies of geothermobarometry of pyroxenite xenoliths from O'ahu, seismic structure and patterns of seismicity beneath the Hawaiian chain. If magma‐assisted flexure is a common phenomenon at other ocean islands and seamounts, it could explain similarities in elastic plate thickness with subduction zones as well as differences with fracture zones globally.
- Open Access
- 28 September 2024
- Published by Wiley
Magma-Assisted Flexure of Hawaiian Lithosphere Inferred From Three-Dimensional Models of Lithospheric Flexure Constrained by Active Source Seismic Data
Reprocessed and newly acquired seismic data provide new constraints on lithospheric flexure profiles beneath the Hawaiian Islands. We use these new observations and three-dimensional numerical models of lithospheric deformation combining elasticity, brittle failure, low-temperature plasticity (LTP) and high-temperature creep deformation mechanisms to constrain the thermal structure and rheology of the oceanic lithosphere lithosphere. When simulating normal oceanic lithospheric conditions with experimentally-derived LTP flow laws, the lithosphere flexes with too little amplitude and over too large a wavelength compared to observations. This result supports prior studies which call on the need to (1) adjust the LTP flow laws or, alternatively, to (2) account for magma-assisted flexural weakening of the lithosphere. Here, models that explore reductions in the activation energy of LTP are able to explain the observations of flexure with a smaller reduction than previously suggested. Models that explore elevated temperatures attributed to hotspot magmatism localized beneath the island edifices also produce close fits to the observed flexural profiles. Although the two factors cannot be distinguished based on fits to the flexure profiles, magma-assisted flexural weakening is supported by recent studies of geothermobarometry of pyroxenite xenoliths from O‘ahu, seismic structure and patterns of seismicity beneath the Hawaiian chain. If magma-assisted flexure is a common phenomenon at other ocean islands and seamounts, it could explain global trends in effective elastic plate thickness at those settings as well as at subduction zones and fracture zones.
- 28 September 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessMagma-Assisted Flexure of Hawaiian Lithosphere Inferred From Three-Dimensional Models of Lithospheric Flexure Constrained by Active Source Seismic Data
Reprocessed and newly acquired seismic data provide new constraints on lithospheric flexure profiles beneath the Hawaiian Islands. We use these new observations and three-dimensional numerical models of lithospheric deformation combining elasticity, brittle failure, low-temperature plasticity (LTP) and high-temperature creep deformation mechanisms to constrain the thermal structure and rheology of the oceanic lithosphere lithosphere. When simulating normal oceanic lithospheric conditions with experimentally-derived LTP flow laws, the lithosphere flexes with too little amplitude and over too large a wavelength compared to observations. This result supports prior studies which call on the need to (1) adjust the LTP flow laws or, alternatively, to (2) account for magma-assisted flexural weakening of the lithosphere. Here, models that explore reductions in the activation energy of LTP are able to explain the observations of flexure with a smaller reduction than previously suggested. Models that explore elevated temperatures attributed to hotspot magmatism localized beneath the island edifices also produce close fits to the observed flexural profiles. Although the two factors cannot be distinguished based on fits to the flexure profiles, magma-assisted flexural weakening is supported by recent studies of geothermobarometry of pyroxenite xenoliths from O‘ahu, seismic structure and patterns of seismicity beneath the Hawaiian chain. If magma-assisted flexure is a common phenomenon at other ocean islands and seamounts, it could explain global trends in effective elastic plate thickness at those settings as well as at subduction zones and fracture zones.
- Open Access
- 3 September 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 128 (9)
Reprocessing of Legacy Seismic Reflection Profile Data and Its Implications for Plate Flexure in the Vicinity of the Hawaiian Islands
During 1975–1988, an academic research ship, R/V Robert D. Conrad, acquired more than 150,000‐line‐km of multichannel seismic reflection profile data from each of the world's main ocean basins and their margins. This extensive legacy seismic data set, which involved both single ship and two‐ship data acquisition, has been widely used by the marine geoscience community. We report on our experience in reprocessing seismic reflection profile data acquired during Conrad cruise RC2308 to the Hawaiian Islands region in August/September 1982. We show that the application of modern, industry standard processing techniques, including filtering, de‐bubble, deconvolution, and migration, can significantly enhance 40+ year old legacy seismic reflection profile data. The reprocessed data reveals more precisely, and with much less scatter, the flexure of Cretaceous Pacific oceanic crust caused by the Pliocene‐Recent volcanic loads that comprise the Hawaiian Islands. A comparison of observed picks of top oceanic crust which has been corrected for the Hawaiian swell and the Molokai Fracture Zone with the calculations of a simple 3‐dimensional elastic plate (flexure) model reveals a best fit elastic plate thickness of the lithosphere, Te, of 26.7 km, an average infill density of 2,701 kg m−3, and a Root Mean Square difference between observations and calculations of 305 m. Tests show these results depend weakly on the load density assumed and that the average infill density is close to what would be predicted from an arithmetic average of the flanking moat infill density and the infill density that immediately underlies the volcanic edifice.
- 3 September 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 128 (9)
Open AccessReprocessing of Legacy Seismic Reflection Profile Data and Its Implications for Plate Flexure in the Vicinity of the Hawaiian Islands
During 1975–1988, an academic research ship, R/V Robert D. Conrad, acquired more than 150,000‐line‐km of multichannel seismic reflection profile data from each of the world's main ocean basins and their margins. This extensive legacy seismic data set, which involved both single ship and two‐ship data acquisition, has been widely used by the marine geoscience community. We report on our experience in reprocessing seismic reflection profile data acquired during Conrad cruise RC2308 to the Hawaiian Islands region in August/September 1982. We show that the application of modern, industry standard processing techniques, including filtering, de‐bubble, deconvolution, and migration, can significantly enhance 40+ year old legacy seismic reflection profile data. The reprocessed data reveals more precisely, and with much less scatter, the flexure of Cretaceous Pacific oceanic crust caused by the Pliocene‐Recent volcanic loads that comprise the Hawaiian Islands. A comparison of observed picks of top oceanic crust which has been corrected for the Hawaiian swell and the Molokai Fracture Zone with the calculations of a simple 3‐dimensional elastic plate (flexure) model reveals a best fit elastic plate thickness of the lithosphere, Te, of 26.7 km, an average infill density of 2,701 kg m−3, and a Root Mean Square difference between observations and calculations of 305 m. Tests show these results depend weakly on the load density assumed and that the average infill density is close to what would be predicted from an arithmetic average of the flanking moat infill density and the infill density that immediately underlies the volcanic edifice.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Variation in Elastic Thickness along the Emperor Seamount Chain
The Hawaii-Emperor seamount chain stretches westward from the “Big Island” of Hawaii for over 6000 km until the oldest part of the Emperor chain is subducted at the Kuril and Aleutian trenches. Still regarded as the iconic hotspot-generated seamount chain it has been sampled, mapped, and studied to give insights into numerous oceanic phenomena, such as seamount and volcano formation and associated intraplate magma budgets, the past absolute motions of the Pacific plate and the drift of the Hawaiian plume, and the thermal and mechanical properties of oceanic lithosphere. Much early work on determining the flexural rigidity and equivalent elastic plate thickness that supports the large volcano loads that comprise the chain was focussed on the Hawaiian Ridge, with a major multichannel seismic expedition to the Hawaiian Islands in 1982 providing clear and direct evidence of plate flexure, as well as the indirect effect this deformation has on Earth’s gravity field. Numerous studies have since followed. However, the older part of the chain, beyond the ~50 Ma “bend”, has been much less well studied due to its remoteness, but recent expeditions have provided new marine seismic data to allow an estimation of elastic thickness along the Emperor chain and how they compare to the information we have along the Hawaiian Ridge. Here, we present preliminary work on determining the elastic thickness beneath the Emperor Seamounts. Unlike the Hawaiian Ridge, where the age of the lithosphere at the time of loading (i.e., the difference in age between the underlying seafloor and the formation age of a seamount or oceanic island) is remarkably constant, along the Emperor chain there are major variations in the age of loading, compounded by higher uncertainty due to limited seamount age sampling and the chain’s location within the Cretaceous Quiet Zone. Thus, models with variable elastic thickness as a function of location along the Emperor chain are required. In this presentation, we discuss several models that seek to account for the new seismic imaging of the top and base of flexed oceanic crust (i.e. Moho) at Jimmu guyot while at the same time honouring the characteristic gravimetric signature of the Emperor seamount edifices and their flanking moats. The Optimal Regional Separation (ORS) method is used to isolate the flexural loads, while seismic tomography and different velocity/density relations are explored for assigning suitable load and infill densities that vary spatially, and we search for optimal density and elastic parameters which minimize the misfit to both the residual gravity as well as the seismically observed flexure in the vicinity of Jimmu guyot. The first-order result is a clear thinning of the elastic thickness as we move from south to north: the implications of which we examine here for the tectonic evolution of the northwest Pacific Ocean and the long-term (>106 a) mechanical properties of oceanic lithosphere.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessVariation in Elastic Thickness along the Emperor Seamount Chain
The Hawaii-Emperor seamount chain stretches westward from the “Big Island” of Hawaii for over 6000 km until the oldest part of the Emperor chain is subducted at the Kuril and Aleutian trenches. Still regarded as the iconic hotspot-generated seamount chain it has been sampled, mapped, and studied to give insights into numerous oceanic phenomena, such as seamount and volcano formation and associated intraplate magma budgets, the past absolute motions of the Pacific plate and the drift of the Hawaiian plume, and the thermal and mechanical properties of oceanic lithosphere. Much early work on determining the flexural rigidity and equivalent elastic plate thickness that supports the large volcano loads that comprise the chain was focussed on the Hawaiian Ridge, with a major multichannel seismic expedition to the Hawaiian Islands in 1982 providing clear and direct evidence of plate flexure, as well as the indirect effect this deformation has on Earth’s gravity field. Numerous studies have since followed. However, the older part of the chain, beyond the ~50 Ma “bend”, has been much less well studied due to its remoteness, but recent expeditions have provided new marine seismic data to allow an estimation of elastic thickness along the Emperor chain and how they compare to the information we have along the Hawaiian Ridge. Here, we present preliminary work on determining the elastic thickness beneath the Emperor Seamounts. Unlike the Hawaiian Ridge, where the age of the lithosphere at the time of loading (i.e., the difference in age between the underlying seafloor and the formation age of a seamount or oceanic island) is remarkably constant, along the Emperor chain there are major variations in the age of loading, compounded by higher uncertainty due to limited seamount age sampling and the chain’s location within the Cretaceous Quiet Zone. Thus, models with variable elastic thickness as a function of location along the Emperor chain are required. In this presentation, we discuss several models that seek to account for the new seismic imaging of the top and base of flexed oceanic crust (i.e. Moho) at Jimmu guyot while at the same time honouring the characteristic gravimetric signature of the Emperor seamount edifices and their flanking moats. The Optimal Regional Separation (ORS) method is used to isolate the flexural loads, while seismic tomography and different velocity/density relations are explored for assigning suitable load and infill densities that vary spatially, and we search for optimal density and elastic parameters which minimize the misfit to both the residual gravity as well as the seismically observed flexure in the vicinity of Jimmu guyot. The first-order result is a clear thinning of the elastic thickness as we move from south to north: the implications of which we examine here for the tectonic evolution of the northwest Pacific Ocean and the long-term (>106 a) mechanical properties of oceanic lithosphere.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Assessing the pressure (in)dependence of cross-property relations
It is known that geological reservoir characterisation can be improved by the joint modelling and inversion of both electrical and elastic data, however the relationship between a rock’s electrical and elastic properties, which is intrinsic to these methods, is relatively uncertain. On top of this, estimating reservoir pressure from geophysical measurements is an essential part of the 3D and 4D monitoring of CO2 injection and hydrocarbon production, and while electrical and elastic properties are affected by pressure, the effect of pressure on electrical-elastic relations is less obvious.Here we use the Cross-Property Differential Effective Medium approximation to model public-domain electrical-elastic laboratory measurements made on brine-saturated clean and mixed sandstones cores at 6 effective pressures ranging from 8 MPa to 60 MPa. Although the approximation is able to realise a large proportion of the electrical-elastic space bounded by the Hashin-Shtrikman bounds using a range of permissible parameter values, we find the model parameter, equivalent pore aspect ratio, varies very little as a function of pressure when modelling the measured data. Interestingly, we see equivalent pore aspect ratio changes exponentially as a function of pressure with an R2 value of over 0.99 when modelling clean sandstones, a trend which has been observed previously in single-property inclusion modelling. This small variance in the model parameter as a function of pressure corresponds to an observably small change in the samples’ electrical-elastic measurements with pressure.We conclude the electrical-elastic properties of the examined clean and mixed brine-saturated sandstones are only weakly dependent on pressure and we demonstrate how a single, pressure-independent model parameter is able to model the electrical-elastic measurements of both the clean and mixed sandstones with reasonable accuracy over the full range of experimental pressures.
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAssessing the pressure (in)dependence of cross-property relations
It is known that geological reservoir characterisation can be improved by the joint modelling and inversion of both electrical and elastic data, however the relationship between a rock’s electrical and elastic properties, which is intrinsic to these methods, is relatively uncertain. On top of this, estimating reservoir pressure from geophysical measurements is an essential part of the 3D and 4D monitoring of CO2 injection and hydrocarbon production, and while electrical and elastic properties are affected by pressure, the effect of pressure on electrical-elastic relations is less obvious.Here we use the Cross-Property Differential Effective Medium approximation to model public-domain electrical-elastic laboratory measurements made on brine-saturated clean and mixed sandstones cores at 6 effective pressures ranging from 8 MPa to 60 MPa. Although the approximation is able to realise a large proportion of the electrical-elastic space bounded by the Hashin-Shtrikman bounds using a range of permissible parameter values, we find the model parameter, equivalent pore aspect ratio, varies very little as a function of pressure when modelling the measured data. Interestingly, we see equivalent pore aspect ratio changes exponentially as a function of pressure with an R2 value of over 0.99 when modelling clean sandstones, a trend which has been observed previously in single-property inclusion modelling. This small variance in the model parameter as a function of pressure corresponds to an observably small change in the samples’ electrical-elastic measurements with pressure.We conclude the electrical-elastic properties of the examined clean and mixed brine-saturated sandstones are only weakly dependent on pressure and we demonstrate how a single, pressure-independent model parameter is able to model the electrical-elastic measurements of both the clean and mixed sandstones with reasonable accuracy over the full range of experimental pressures.
- Open Access
- 13 April 2021
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Machine learning based prediction of channelisation during dissolution of carbonate rocks
Evolving preferential dissolution channels are common features formed during reactive fluid flow in carbonate rocks. Understanding these is of particular importance in applications involving subsurface engineered reservoirs but predicting their progression is currently challenging and poorly understood. Here, we propose a new approach to predict both the spatial distribution and extent of dissolution using a combination of experimental work, X-ray microtomography (μCT) and machine learning. We have conducted experiments, under reservoir conditions of temperature and pressure, involving pre- and post-flooding μCT characterisations, and coupled the outputs with a neural network to predict locations where carbonate was most likely to be dissolved. Our simulations demonstrate that our new solution can identify the key geometrical features that are important during dissolution, and can accurately predict the location and spread of dissolution. An important benefit of this approach is that it can accurately predict dissolution channels through forward prediction, while it does not require further chemical parameters, using instead common and accessible variables.
- 13 April 2021
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Open AccessMachine learning based prediction of channelisation during dissolution of carbonate rocks
Evolving preferential dissolution channels are common features formed during reactive fluid flow in carbonate rocks. Understanding these is of particular importance in applications involving subsurface engineered reservoirs but predicting their progression is currently challenging and poorly understood. Here, we propose a new approach to predict both the spatial distribution and extent of dissolution using a combination of experimental work, X-ray microtomography (μCT) and machine learning. We have conducted experiments, under reservoir conditions of temperature and pressure, involving pre- and post-flooding μCT characterisations, and coupled the outputs with a neural network to predict locations where carbonate was most likely to be dissolved. Our simulations demonstrate that our new solution can identify the key geometrical features that are important during dissolution, and can accurately predict the location and spread of dissolution. An important benefit of this approach is that it can accurately predict dissolution channels through forward prediction, while it does not require further chemical parameters, using instead common and accessible variables.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Electrical-elastic modelling of rocks using cross-property DEM
The combination of electrical and elastic measurements can be useful in lowering subsurface characterisation uncertainty. The majority of rock physics relations which relate a rock’s electrical and elastic properties, however, rely on the estimation of porosity as an intermediate step. By combining differential effective medium schemes which relate a rock’s electrical and elastic properties to porosity and pore shape, we obtain cross-property expressions which are independent of porosity, depending only on pore aspect ratio. Analysing published joint electrical-elastic measurements shows the cross-property model works well for clean sandstones, and models Vp/Vs ratios as a function of resistivity without porosity. Although clay-bearing sandstones are more complex, our model can still identify the correct trends. On theoretical grounds, it seems our approach has the potential to produce additional cross-property relations; a topic upon which we speculate.
- 4 March 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessElectrical-elastic modelling of rocks using cross-property DEM
The combination of electrical and elastic measurements can be useful in lowering subsurface characterisation uncertainty. The majority of rock physics relations which relate a rock’s electrical and elastic properties, however, rely on the estimation of porosity as an intermediate step. By combining differential effective medium schemes which relate a rock’s electrical and elastic properties to porosity and pore shape, we obtain cross-property expressions which are independent of porosity, depending only on pore aspect ratio. Analysing published joint electrical-elastic measurements shows the cross-property model works well for clean sandstones, and models Vp/Vs ratios as a function of resistivity without porosity. Although clay-bearing sandstones are more complex, our model can still identify the correct trends. On theoretical grounds, it seems our approach has the potential to produce additional cross-property relations; a topic upon which we speculate.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 225 (3) , 1812-1823
Linking elastic and electrical properties of rocks using cross-property DEM
Combining electrical and elastic measurements can be instrumental in lowering the uncertainty of subsurface characterization. Many commonly used rock physics relations for joint electrical–elastic properties are at least partly empirical and often rely on the estimation of porosity as an intermediate step. We combine differential effective medium schemes that relate, respectively, elastic and electrical properties to porosity and pore shape. The resulting expressions are independent of porosity, depending only on pore aspect ratio. Analysis of published joint electrical–elastic data shows that a single aspect ratio model performs well for clean sandstones, allowing us to model Vp/Vs ratios as a function of resistivity. Clay-bearing sandstones are more complex, but our modelling can still identify the correct trends. We speculate about the potential to extend our approach to produce additional cross-property relations.
- 3 February 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 225 (3) , 1812-1823
Open AccessLinking elastic and electrical properties of rocks using cross-property DEM
Combining electrical and elastic measurements can be instrumental in lowering the uncertainty of subsurface characterization. Many commonly used rock physics relations for joint electrical–elastic properties are at least partly empirical and often rely on the estimation of porosity as an intermediate step. We combine differential effective medium schemes that relate, respectively, elastic and electrical properties to porosity and pore shape. The resulting expressions are independent of porosity, depending only on pore aspect ratio. Analysis of published joint electrical–elastic data shows that a single aspect ratio model performs well for clean sandstones, allowing us to model Vp/Vs ratios as a function of resistivity. Clay-bearing sandstones are more complex, but our modelling can still identify the correct trends. We speculate about the potential to extend our approach to produce additional cross-property relations.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2020
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EarthArXiv
Linking elastic and electrical properties of rocks using cross-property DEM
Joint electrical-elastic rock physics modelling can be instrumental in lowering uncertainty in subsurface reservoir characterisation. Typical electrical-elastic cross-property models, however, are empirical or require an intermediate step of porosity estimation to link a rock's electrical and elastic moduli, which can be error-prone away from well controls. Another outstanding issue in electrical-elastic modelling is the challenge of predicting a rock's shear modulus and ultimately Vp/Vs ratio from electrical measurements. By reformulating an existing electrical differential effective medium (DEM) theory to embed ellipsoidal pores into a background of matrix material, rather than the typical method of embedding ellipsoidal grains into a background of fluid, we express the model in terms of the geometrical function R, which is present in other electrical ellipsoidal inclusion models. This reformulation is consistent with two other effective conductivity models and shares its geometrical function R with the electrical self-consistent approximation (SCA) model, providing a new mathematical link between electrical DEM and SCA models. Combining this reformulated electrical DEM model and a pre-existing elastic DEM model, we obtain expressions for a rock's effective elastic moduli with respect to effective conductivity. This method is analogous to the more common electrical-elastic modelling stratagem where an electrical model is substituted into an elastic model or vice versa through their shared independent variable, porosity, which is rendered a dummy variable in the process. Modelling the elastic moduli of clay-bearing sandstones using public domain laboratory measurements, there seems to be a weak sensitivity of the model's single parameter, equivalent pore aspect ratio, to clay volume fraction. Furthermore, the uncertainty in shear modulus modelling from conductivity measurements seems weakly sensitive to clay content. By employing the Gardner empirical velocity-density relation for sandstones, we forward model Vp and Vs from electrical measurements in the absence of porosity and density measurements, with accuracy comparable to the Han (1986) empirical Vp/Vs model for mixed sandstones. Our proposed cross-property DEM method generalises mathematically to relate any two of a composite's elastic moduli, electrical conductivity, electrical permittivity, thermal conductivity, magnetic permeability, and diffusion constant due to the equivalence of these properties in inclusion modelling by the universality of the Laplace equation, which underpins the models' constructions. This generalisation of the cross-property DEM model to numerous physical properties leads to a testable hypothesis: the cross-property DEM parameter, aspect ratio, is (or is not) universal when linking a given rock's various physical properties.
- 22 October 2020
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EarthArXiv
Open AccessLinking elastic and electrical properties of rocks using cross-property DEM
Joint electrical-elastic rock physics modelling can be instrumental in lowering uncertainty in subsurface reservoir characterisation. Typical electrical-elastic cross-property models, however, are empirical or require an intermediate step of porosity estimation to link a rock's electrical and elastic moduli, which can be error-prone away from well controls. Another outstanding issue in electrical-elastic modelling is the challenge of predicting a rock's shear modulus and ultimately Vp/Vs ratio from electrical measurements. By reformulating an existing electrical differential effective medium (DEM) theory to embed ellipsoidal pores into a background of matrix material, rather than the typical method of embedding ellipsoidal grains into a background of fluid, we express the model in terms of the geometrical function R, which is present in other electrical ellipsoidal inclusion models. This reformulation is consistent with two other effective conductivity models and shares its geometrical function R with the electrical self-consistent approximation (SCA) model, providing a new mathematical link between electrical DEM and SCA models. Combining this reformulated electrical DEM model and a pre-existing elastic DEM model, we obtain expressions for a rock's effective elastic moduli with respect to effective conductivity. This method is analogous to the more common electrical-elastic modelling stratagem where an electrical model is substituted into an elastic model or vice versa through their shared independent variable, porosity, which is rendered a dummy variable in the process. Modelling the elastic moduli of clay-bearing sandstones using public domain laboratory measurements, there seems to be a weak sensitivity of the model's single parameter, equivalent pore aspect ratio, to clay volume fraction. Furthermore, the uncertainty in shear modulus modelling from conductivity measurements seems weakly sensitive to clay content. By employing the Gardner empirical velocity-density relation for sandstones, we forward model Vp and Vs from electrical measurements in the absence of porosity and density measurements, with accuracy comparable to the Han (1986) empirical Vp/Vs model for mixed sandstones. Our proposed cross-property DEM method generalises mathematically to relate any two of a composite's elastic moduli, electrical conductivity, electrical permittivity, thermal conductivity, magnetic permeability, and diffusion constant due to the equivalence of these properties in inclusion modelling by the universality of the Laplace equation, which underpins the models' constructions. This generalisation of the cross-property DEM model to numerous physical properties leads to a testable hypothesis: the cross-property DEM parameter, aspect ratio, is (or is not) universal when linking a given rock's various physical properties.