Nico Wunderling
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Nico Wunderling has a total of 388 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jonathan Friedemann Donges
Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Member of the Leibniz Association, Telegrafenberg A 31, 14473 Potsdam, Germany
46 shared publications - Ricarda Winkelmann
Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK), Member of the Leibniz Association, Potsdam, Germany
31 shared publications - Arie Staal
Copernicus Institute of Sustainable Development, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands
17 shared publications - Annika Högner
International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA), Laxenburg, Austria
13 shared publications Johan Rockström
Earth Resilience Science Unit, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Member of the Leibniz Association, Telegrafenberg A31, D-14473 Potsdam, Germany
11 shared publicationsBoris Sakschewski
10 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics
- Vol. 33 (2) , 313-334
Quantitative comparison of causal inference methods for climate tipping points
Causal inference methods present a statistical approach to the analysis and reconstruction of dynamic systems as observed in nature or in experiments. Climate tipping points are likely present in several core components of the Earth system, such as the Greenland ice sheet or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and are characterized by an abrupt and irreversible degradation under sustained global temperatures above their corresponding thresholds. Causal inference methods may provide a promising way to study the interactions of climate tipping elements, which are currently highly uncertain due to limitations in model-based approaches. However, the data-driven analysis of climate tipping elements presents several challenges, e.g., with regard to nonlinearity, delayed effects and confoundedness. In this study, we quantify the accuracy of three commonly used multivariate causal inference methods with regard to these challenges and find unique advantages of each method: The Liang–Kleeman Information Flow (LKIF) is preferable in simple settings with limited data availability, the Peter–Clark Momentary Conditional Independence (PCMCI) provides the most control, e.g., to integrate expert knowledge, and the Granger Causality for State Space Models is advantageous for large datasets and delayed interactions. In general, data sampling intervals should be aligned with the interaction delays, and the inclusion of a confounder (like global temperatures) is crucial to deal with the nonlinear response to (climate) forcing. Based on these findings and given their data masking capabilities, we apply the LKIF and PCMCI methods to reanalysis data to detect tipping point interactions between the AMOC and Arctic summer sea ice, which imply a bidirectional stabilizing interaction, in agreement with physical mechanisms. Our results therefore contribute robust evidence to the study of interactions of the AMOC and the cryosphere.
- 19 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics
- Vol. 33 (2) , 313-334
Open AccessQuantitative comparison of causal inference methods for climate tipping points
Causal inference methods present a statistical approach to the analysis and reconstruction of dynamic systems as observed in nature or in experiments. Climate tipping points are likely present in several core components of the Earth system, such as the Greenland ice sheet or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and are characterized by an abrupt and irreversible degradation under sustained global temperatures above their corresponding thresholds. Causal inference methods may provide a promising way to study the interactions of climate tipping elements, which are currently highly uncertain due to limitations in model-based approaches. However, the data-driven analysis of climate tipping elements presents several challenges, e.g., with regard to nonlinearity, delayed effects and confoundedness. In this study, we quantify the accuracy of three commonly used multivariate causal inference methods with regard to these challenges and find unique advantages of each method: The Liang–Kleeman Information Flow (LKIF) is preferable in simple settings with limited data availability, the Peter–Clark Momentary Conditional Independence (PCMCI) provides the most control, e.g., to integrate expert knowledge, and the Granger Causality for State Space Models is advantageous for large datasets and delayed interactions. In general, data sampling intervals should be aligned with the interaction delays, and the inclusion of a confounder (like global temperatures) is crucial to deal with the nonlinear response to (climate) forcing. Based on these findings and given their data masking capabilities, we apply the LKIF and PCMCI methods to reanalysis data to detect tipping point interactions between the AMOC and Arctic summer sea ice, which imply a bidirectional stabilizing interaction, in agreement with physical mechanisms. Our results therefore contribute robust evidence to the study of interactions of the AMOC and the cryosphere.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (12) , 124008
Permafrost carbon–climate feedback amplifies Earth system tipping risks
Global warming leads to widespread permafrost thaw and subsequent emissions of carbon dioxide and methane, driving the permafrost carbon–climate feedback (PCF) which amplifies climate change. Many current-generation climate models omit this feedback, limiting projections of long-term temperature outcomes and associated Earth system tipping risks. Here, we investigate how this feedback affects the risk and timing of crossing tipping points in the Earth system by integrating permafrost carbon emissions into temperature projections for idealized stabilization and overshoot scenarios. In a conceptual network model of interacting climate tipping elements—including the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, and the Amazon rainforest, we find that PCF leads to additional warming that increases the probability of exceeding one or more tipping elements by up to 50% and can substantially accelerate the timing of tipping events by hundreds of years. The effect of PCF on tipping risk and acceleration is particularly evident in overshoot scenarios with lower peak temperatures below 2–3 ∘ C or peak cumulative emissions of below 2000 PgC. Considering PCF, therefore, narrows the critical temperature space for overshoot pathways. Our results highlight that failing to account for PCF underestimates both climate risks and the urgency of mitigation, increasing the likelihood of tipping events across the Earth system.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 21 (12) , 124008
Open AccessPermafrost carbon–climate feedback amplifies Earth system tipping risks
Global warming leads to widespread permafrost thaw and subsequent emissions of carbon dioxide and methane, driving the permafrost carbon–climate feedback (PCF) which amplifies climate change. Many current-generation climate models omit this feedback, limiting projections of long-term temperature outcomes and associated Earth system tipping risks. Here, we investigate how this feedback affects the risk and timing of crossing tipping points in the Earth system by integrating permafrost carbon emissions into temperature projections for idealized stabilization and overshoot scenarios. In a conceptual network model of interacting climate tipping elements—including the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, and the Amazon rainforest, we find that PCF leads to additional warming that increases the probability of exceeding one or more tipping elements by up to 50% and can substantially accelerate the timing of tipping events by hundreds of years. The effect of PCF on tipping risk and acceleration is particularly evident in overshoot scenarios with lower peak temperatures below 2–3 ∘ C or peak cumulative emissions of below 2000 PgC. Considering PCF, therefore, narrows the critical temperature space for overshoot pathways. Our results highlight that failing to account for PCF underestimates both climate risks and the urgency of mitigation, increasing the likelihood of tipping events across the Earth system.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (3) , 673-686
Quantifying resilience in non-autonomous and stochastic Earth system dynamics with application to glacial-interglacial cycles
Understanding Earth resilience – the capacity of the Earth system to absorb and regenerate from perturbations – is key to assessing risks from anthropogenic pressures and sustaining a safe operating space for humanity within planetary boundaries. Classical resilience indicators are designed for autonomous systems with fixed attractors, but the Earth system is fundamentally non-autonomous and out of equilibrium, calling for new ways of defining and quantifying resilience. Here, we introduce a path-resilience approach that assesses how perturbations deviate from and return to a reference trajectory of a conceptual climate model replicating the glacial-interglacial cycles of the Late Pleistocene. We generate two types of perturbation ensembles: a stochastic ensemble and a pulse-perturbation ensemble, and compute two complementary metrics: the Reference Adherence Ratio, RAR(t), defined as the fraction of stochastic trajectories that remain within a narrow band around the unperturbed trajectory; and return time, defined as the time a single perturbed trajectory takes to return to the reference path. Together, these metrics reveal strong temporal variation in resilience across the glacial-interglacial cycles. We find that RAR(t) increases markedly during deglaciations and peaks in interglacial periods, while return times generally shorten as the system approaches interglacial conditions, indicating that certain phases of the cycles act as convergence zones along the forced trajectory. As the Earth system departs from such interglacial regimes under ongoing anthropogenic forcing, understanding the resilience of these trajectories, and what it may take to return to them, becomes increasingly important. These results highlight that resilience in non-autonomous systems is inherently path-dependent and illustrate a promising first step toward its quantification. Further research is needed to develop more general resilience indicators suitable for complex, forced dynamical systems.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (3) , 673-686
Open AccessQuantifying resilience in non-autonomous and stochastic Earth system dynamics with application to glacial-interglacial cycles
Understanding Earth resilience – the capacity of the Earth system to absorb and regenerate from perturbations – is key to assessing risks from anthropogenic pressures and sustaining a safe operating space for humanity within planetary boundaries. Classical resilience indicators are designed for autonomous systems with fixed attractors, but the Earth system is fundamentally non-autonomous and out of equilibrium, calling for new ways of defining and quantifying resilience. Here, we introduce a path-resilience approach that assesses how perturbations deviate from and return to a reference trajectory of a conceptual climate model replicating the glacial-interglacial cycles of the Late Pleistocene. We generate two types of perturbation ensembles: a stochastic ensemble and a pulse-perturbation ensemble, and compute two complementary metrics: the Reference Adherence Ratio, RAR(t), defined as the fraction of stochastic trajectories that remain within a narrow band around the unperturbed trajectory; and return time, defined as the time a single perturbed trajectory takes to return to the reference path. Together, these metrics reveal strong temporal variation in resilience across the glacial-interglacial cycles. We find that RAR(t) increases markedly during deglaciations and peaks in interglacial periods, while return times generally shorten as the system approaches interglacial conditions, indicating that certain phases of the cycles act as convergence zones along the forced trajectory. As the Earth system departs from such interglacial regimes under ongoing anthropogenic forcing, understanding the resilience of these trajectories, and what it may take to return to them, becomes increasingly important. These results highlight that resilience in non-autonomous systems is inherently path-dependent and illustrate a promising first step toward its quantification. Further research is needed to develop more general resilience indicators suitable for complex, forced dynamical systems.
- Open Access
- 18 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Comment on egusphere-2025-6345
In order to address the emerging global polycrisis, it is essential to develop quantitative indicators for estimating resilience of essential bio-geophysical and social drivers of change. Such indicators are required to navigate the Anthropocene and to assess which actions increase the likelihood of achieving a safe and just operating space (SAJOS). In this paper, we propose a novel information-based resilience metric. We define it as the conditional probability of a system reaching a desired system state, e.g. a SAJOS, given initial conditions and an information set. This information set reflects knowledge about relevant ranges of bio-physical and socio-cultural system dynamics, boundaries and perturbations. The resulting resilience index is highly dependent on the available information about the system and its intrinsic action capacities. An increase in epistemic knowledge about the system does not necessarily result in enhanced resilience. It is still possible to envisage scenarios in which one could find oneself in a world that is capable of attaining a SAJOS in only a limited number of circumstances. Our proposed approach facilitates the operationalization and quantification of resilience in complex World-Earth system (WES) models. Resilience should be understood as being constrained by available information about the system, its internal processes, boundaries, and the capacity of the system to act in an uncertain future. This further implies the importance of making informed investment decisions that balance improving system understanding (i.e. gaining information), increasing (anticipatory) capacities of action, and taking common-sense action to enhance resilience. Our information-based index can be applied to any kind of system. Since it answers the classical question of "resilience of what, to what" on a meta level, it allows moving beyond a highly specified and static notion of resilience, allowing for a wide range of application cases.
- 18 May 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-6345
In order to address the emerging global polycrisis, it is essential to develop quantitative indicators for estimating resilience of essential bio-geophysical and social drivers of change. Such indicators are required to navigate the Anthropocene and to assess which actions increase the likelihood of achieving a safe and just operating space (SAJOS). In this paper, we propose a novel information-based resilience metric. We define it as the conditional probability of a system reaching a desired system state, e.g. a SAJOS, given initial conditions and an information set. This information set reflects knowledge about relevant ranges of bio-physical and socio-cultural system dynamics, boundaries and perturbations. The resulting resilience index is highly dependent on the available information about the system and its intrinsic action capacities. An increase in epistemic knowledge about the system does not necessarily result in enhanced resilience. It is still possible to envisage scenarios in which one could find oneself in a world that is capable of attaining a SAJOS in only a limited number of circumstances. Our proposed approach facilitates the operationalization and quantification of resilience in complex World-Earth system (WES) models. Resilience should be understood as being constrained by available information about the system, its internal processes, boundaries, and the capacity of the system to act in an uncertain future. This further implies the importance of making informed investment decisions that balance improving system understanding (i.e. gaining information), increasing (anticipatory) capacities of action, and taking common-sense action to enhance resilience. Our information-based index can be applied to any kind of system. Since it answers the classical question of "resilience of what, to what" on a meta level, it allows moving beyond a highly specified and static notion of resilience, allowing for a wide range of application cases.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 6 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 654 (8117) , 114-120
Deforestation-induced drying lowers Amazon climate threshold
Humanity is putting unprecedented pressures on the Amazon forest system through global warming and land use changes 1,2 . As the Amazon forest may undergo self-reinforcing transitions, these pressures could lead to system-wide changes across major parts of Amazonian ecosystems 1–4 . Here we apply a dynamical systems model to assess the local and far-reaching cascading transition risks towards degraded ecosystems in the Amazon biome under different Shared Socioeconomic Pathways. For these emission scenarios, we constructed how moisture is transported through the atmosphere within the Amazon basin using an established atmospheric moisture-tracking model 5 . Without accounting for deforestation, we find a critical global warming threshold of 3.7–4.0 °C, beyond which up to a third of the Amazon forest risks losing stability. However, when considering deforestation, we find a near system-wide transition of the Amazon forest (62−77% of the area) under the combination of a lower threshold range of global warming of 1.5–1.9 °C and deforestation of 22–28%. The large majority of the simulated transitions is caused by spatial knock-on effects from increasing drought intensities, leading to long-ranging and self-propelling cascades on scales of hundreds to thousands of kilometres. Overall, our results reinforce the need to keep global warming levels below 1.5 °C and halt deforestation, as well as ecologically restore degraded forests to avoid high transition risks across the Amazon forest system.
- 6 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature
- Vol. 654 (8117) , 114-120
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessDeforestation-induced drying lowers Amazon climate threshold
Humanity is putting unprecedented pressures on the Amazon forest system through global warming and land use changes 1,2 . As the Amazon forest may undergo self-reinforcing transitions, these pressures could lead to system-wide changes across major parts of Amazonian ecosystems 1–4 . Here we apply a dynamical systems model to assess the local and far-reaching cascading transition risks towards degraded ecosystems in the Amazon biome under different Shared Socioeconomic Pathways. For these emission scenarios, we constructed how moisture is transported through the atmosphere within the Amazon basin using an established atmospheric moisture-tracking model 5 . Without accounting for deforestation, we find a critical global warming threshold of 3.7–4.0 °C, beyond which up to a third of the Amazon forest risks losing stability. However, when considering deforestation, we find a near system-wide transition of the Amazon forest (62−77% of the area) under the combination of a lower threshold range of global warming of 1.5–1.9 °C and deforestation of 22–28%. The large majority of the simulated transitions is caused by spatial knock-on effects from increasing drought intensities, leading to long-ranging and self-propelling cascades on scales of hundreds to thousands of kilometres. Overall, our results reinforce the need to keep global warming levels below 1.5 °C and halt deforestation, as well as ecologically restore degraded forests to avoid high transition risks across the Amazon forest system.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (2) , 333-352
A risk assessment framework for interacting tipping elements
Tipping elements, such as the Greenland Ice Sheet, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) or the Amazon rainforest, interact with one another and with other non-linear systems such as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO). In doing so, the risk of any one element being degraded can be drastically affected, typically increasing due to the interactions. Therefore, in this work we propose a fully probabilistic network model for risk assessment of interacting tipping elements that coherently incorporates literature-based expert assessments of inter-element interactions. For fixed levels of global warming, we provide analytic results for the risk of being degraded for 8 interacting tipping elements and ENSO at equilibrium, including the stability of and convergence times to this equilibrium solution. Moreover we simulate their tipping risks until 2350 using emission pathways from the Shared Socio-economic Pathways (SSP 1-1.9, 1-2.6, 2-4.5, 3-7.0, and 5-8.5). Compared to the interaction-free baseline, we find that interactions tend to destabilise the climate system. For instance the coral reefs are likely to have collapsed by 2100 even under the most optimistic scenario (SSP1-1.9). The effects of interactions, however, are most noticeable after 2100, especially for the SSP scenarios with the strongest greenhouse gas emissions (SSP3-7.0 and SSP5-8.5). In summary, our risk assessment framework for tipping elements and ENSO indicates that rapid mitigation is essential to keep temperatures as close as possible to 1.5 °C in the short term and below 1 °C in the longer run.
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 17 (2) , 333-352
Open AccessA risk assessment framework for interacting tipping elements
Tipping elements, such as the Greenland Ice Sheet, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) or the Amazon rainforest, interact with one another and with other non-linear systems such as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO). In doing so, the risk of any one element being degraded can be drastically affected, typically increasing due to the interactions. Therefore, in this work we propose a fully probabilistic network model for risk assessment of interacting tipping elements that coherently incorporates literature-based expert assessments of inter-element interactions. For fixed levels of global warming, we provide analytic results for the risk of being degraded for 8 interacting tipping elements and ENSO at equilibrium, including the stability of and convergence times to this equilibrium solution. Moreover we simulate their tipping risks until 2350 using emission pathways from the Shared Socio-economic Pathways (SSP 1-1.9, 1-2.6, 2-4.5, 3-7.0, and 5-8.5). Compared to the interaction-free baseline, we find that interactions tend to destabilise the climate system. For instance the coral reefs are likely to have collapsed by 2100 even under the most optimistic scenario (SSP1-1.9). The effects of interactions, however, are most noticeable after 2100, especially for the SSP scenarios with the strongest greenhouse gas emissions (SSP3-7.0 and SSP5-8.5). In summary, our risk assessment framework for tipping elements and ENSO indicates that rapid mitigation is essential to keep temperatures as close as possible to 1.5 °C in the short term and below 1 °C in the longer run.
- Open Access
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-35
Comment on egusphere-2026-614
Crossing climate tipping points poses a rising risk under continued global warming. Yet quantitative tipping risk assessments often rely on idealised system dynamics and do not take into account Earth system model (ESM) processes. Here, we present a process-informed, updatable framework that links systematic stability assessments from comprehensive models to transparent low-order dynamical systems for three high-impact climate tipping elements (TEs): the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS), the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) and the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). We assemble TE experiments from Earth system and Earth system component models, fit element-specific dynamical systems with saddle-node bifurcations that map external forcing to state transitions, and run idealised instantaneous-forcing experiments to show the application of our framework. A simple, modular update protocol allows tipping thresholds and timescales to be revised as new simulations from ESMs become available without refitting the full framework. Applied to current ESM simulations, our emulators reproduce multistability of the GrIS and WAIS and a freshwater-forced weakening of the AMOC, yielding decision-relevant transient and equilibrium behaviour consistent with the underlying ESMs. Our approach provides a transparent bridge between comprehensive simulations and simple dynamical systems, and can be extended to additional climate tipping elements as suitable experiments become available.
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-35
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-614
Crossing climate tipping points poses a rising risk under continued global warming. Yet quantitative tipping risk assessments often rely on idealised system dynamics and do not take into account Earth system model (ESM) processes. Here, we present a process-informed, updatable framework that links systematic stability assessments from comprehensive models to transparent low-order dynamical systems for three high-impact climate tipping elements (TEs): the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS), the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) and the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). We assemble TE experiments from Earth system and Earth system component models, fit element-specific dynamical systems with saddle-node bifurcations that map external forcing to state transitions, and run idealised instantaneous-forcing experiments to show the application of our framework. A simple, modular update protocol allows tipping thresholds and timescales to be revised as new simulations from ESMs become available without refitting the full framework. Applied to current ESM simulations, our emulators reproduce multistability of the GrIS and WAIS and a freshwater-forced weakening of the AMOC, yielding decision-relevant transient and equilibrium behaviour consistent with the underlying ESMs. Our approach provides a transparent bridge between comprehensive simulations and simple dynamical systems, and can be extended to additional climate tipping elements as suitable experiments become available.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-35
Comment on egusphere-2026-614
Crossing climate tipping points poses a rising risk under continued global warming. Yet quantitative tipping risk assessments often rely on idealised system dynamics and do not take into account Earth system model (ESM) processes. Here, we present a process-informed, updatable framework that links systematic stability assessments from comprehensive models to transparent low-order dynamical systems for three high-impact climate tipping elements (TEs): the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS), the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) and the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). We assemble TE experiments from Earth system and Earth system component models, fit element-specific dynamical systems with saddle-node bifurcations that map external forcing to state transitions, and run idealised instantaneous-forcing experiments to show the application of our framework. A simple, modular update protocol allows tipping thresholds and timescales to be revised as new simulations from ESMs become available without refitting the full framework. Applied to current ESM simulations, our emulators reproduce multistability of the GrIS and WAIS and a freshwater-forced weakening of the AMOC, yielding decision-relevant transient and equilibrium behaviour consistent with the underlying ESMs. Our approach provides a transparent bridge between comprehensive simulations and simple dynamical systems, and can be extended to additional climate tipping elements as suitable experiments become available.
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-35
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-614
Crossing climate tipping points poses a rising risk under continued global warming. Yet quantitative tipping risk assessments often rely on idealised system dynamics and do not take into account Earth system model (ESM) processes. Here, we present a process-informed, updatable framework that links systematic stability assessments from comprehensive models to transparent low-order dynamical systems for three high-impact climate tipping elements (TEs): the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS), the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) and the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). We assemble TE experiments from Earth system and Earth system component models, fit element-specific dynamical systems with saddle-node bifurcations that map external forcing to state transitions, and run idealised instantaneous-forcing experiments to show the application of our framework. A simple, modular update protocol allows tipping thresholds and timescales to be revised as new simulations from ESMs become available without refitting the full framework. Applied to current ESM simulations, our emulators reproduce multistability of the GrIS and WAIS and a freshwater-forced weakening of the AMOC, yielding decision-relevant transient and equilibrium behaviour consistent with the underlying ESMs. Our approach provides a transparent bridge between comprehensive simulations and simple dynamical systems, and can be extended to additional climate tipping elements as suitable experiments become available.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-32
Reply on RC2
Causal inference methods present a statistical approach to the analysis and reconstruction of dynamic systems as observed in nature or in experiments. Climate tipping points are likely present in several core components of the Earth system, such as the Greenland ice sheet or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and are characterized by an abrupt and irreversible degradation under sustained global temperatures above their corresponding thresholds. Causal inference methods may provide a promising way to study the interactions of climate tipping elements, which are currently highly uncertain due to limitations in model-based approaches. However, the data-driven analysis of climate tipping elements presents several challenges, e.g., with regard to nonlinearity, delayed effects and confoundedness. In this study, we quantify the accuracy of three commonly used multivariate causal inference methods with regard to these challenges and find unique advantages of each method: The Liang–Kleeman Information Flow is preferable in simple settings with limited data availability, the Peter–Clark Momentary Conditional Independence (PCMCI) provides the most control, e.g., to integrate expert knowledge, and the Granger Causality for State Space Models is advantageous for large datasets and delayed interactions. In general, data sampling intervals should be aligned with the interaction delays, and the inclusion of a confounder (like global temperatures) is crucial to deal with the nonlinear response to (climate) forcing. Based on these findings and given their data masking capabilities, we apply the LKIF and PCMCI methods to reanalysis data to detect tipping point interactions between the AMOC and Arctic summer sea ice, which imply a bidirectional stabilizing interaction, in agreement with physical mechanisms. Our results therefore contribute robust evidence to the study of interactions of the AMOC and the cryosphere.
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-32
Open AccessReply on RC2
Causal inference methods present a statistical approach to the analysis and reconstruction of dynamic systems as observed in nature or in experiments. Climate tipping points are likely present in several core components of the Earth system, such as the Greenland ice sheet or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and are characterized by an abrupt and irreversible degradation under sustained global temperatures above their corresponding thresholds. Causal inference methods may provide a promising way to study the interactions of climate tipping elements, which are currently highly uncertain due to limitations in model-based approaches. However, the data-driven analysis of climate tipping elements presents several challenges, e.g., with regard to nonlinearity, delayed effects and confoundedness. In this study, we quantify the accuracy of three commonly used multivariate causal inference methods with regard to these challenges and find unique advantages of each method: The Liang–Kleeman Information Flow is preferable in simple settings with limited data availability, the Peter–Clark Momentary Conditional Independence (PCMCI) provides the most control, e.g., to integrate expert knowledge, and the Granger Causality for State Space Models is advantageous for large datasets and delayed interactions. In general, data sampling intervals should be aligned with the interaction delays, and the inclusion of a confounder (like global temperatures) is crucial to deal with the nonlinear response to (climate) forcing. Based on these findings and given their data masking capabilities, we apply the LKIF and PCMCI methods to reanalysis data to detect tipping point interactions between the AMOC and Arctic summer sea ice, which imply a bidirectional stabilizing interaction, in agreement with physical mechanisms. Our results therefore contribute robust evidence to the study of interactions of the AMOC and the cryosphere.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-32
Reply on CC1
Causal inference methods present a statistical approach to the analysis and reconstruction of dynamic systems as observed in nature or in experiments. Climate tipping points are likely present in several core components of the Earth system, such as the Greenland ice sheet or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and are characterized by an abrupt and irreversible degradation under sustained global temperatures above their corresponding thresholds. Causal inference methods may provide a promising way to study the interactions of climate tipping elements, which are currently highly uncertain due to limitations in model-based approaches. However, the data-driven analysis of climate tipping elements presents several challenges, e.g., with regard to nonlinearity, delayed effects and confoundedness. In this study, we quantify the accuracy of three commonly used multivariate causal inference methods with regard to these challenges and find unique advantages of each method: The Liang–Kleeman Information Flow is preferable in simple settings with limited data availability, the Peter–Clark Momentary Conditional Independence (PCMCI) provides the most control, e.g., to integrate expert knowledge, and the Granger Causality for State Space Models is advantageous for large datasets and delayed interactions. In general, data sampling intervals should be aligned with the interaction delays, and the inclusion of a confounder (like global temperatures) is crucial to deal with the nonlinear response to (climate) forcing. Based on these findings and given their data masking capabilities, we apply the LKIF and PCMCI methods to reanalysis data to detect tipping point interactions between the AMOC and Arctic summer sea ice, which imply a bidirectional stabilizing interaction, in agreement with physical mechanisms. Our results therefore contribute robust evidence to the study of interactions of the AMOC and the cryosphere.
- 25 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-32
Open AccessReply on CC1
Causal inference methods present a statistical approach to the analysis and reconstruction of dynamic systems as observed in nature or in experiments. Climate tipping points are likely present in several core components of the Earth system, such as the Greenland ice sheet or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), and are characterized by an abrupt and irreversible degradation under sustained global temperatures above their corresponding thresholds. Causal inference methods may provide a promising way to study the interactions of climate tipping elements, which are currently highly uncertain due to limitations in model-based approaches. However, the data-driven analysis of climate tipping elements presents several challenges, e.g., with regard to nonlinearity, delayed effects and confoundedness. In this study, we quantify the accuracy of three commonly used multivariate causal inference methods with regard to these challenges and find unique advantages of each method: The Liang–Kleeman Information Flow is preferable in simple settings with limited data availability, the Peter–Clark Momentary Conditional Independence (PCMCI) provides the most control, e.g., to integrate expert knowledge, and the Granger Causality for State Space Models is advantageous for large datasets and delayed interactions. In general, data sampling intervals should be aligned with the interaction delays, and the inclusion of a confounder (like global temperatures) is crucial to deal with the nonlinear response to (climate) forcing. Based on these findings and given their data masking capabilities, we apply the LKIF and PCMCI methods to reanalysis data to detect tipping point interactions between the AMOC and Arctic summer sea ice, which imply a bidirectional stabilizing interaction, in agreement with physical mechanisms. Our results therefore contribute robust evidence to the study of interactions of the AMOC and the cryosphere.