Gulnara Z. Karimova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Gulnara Z. Karimova has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Yevgeniya D. Kim
KIMEP University, Almaty, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications Aidana Rassilbay
Kcell Corporation
1 shared publicationAmir Shirkhanbeik
Enercom Ottawa Canada
1 shared publication- Amir Shirkhanbeik1 shared publication
- Amir Shirkhanbeik
Eastern Mediterranean University, Famagusta, Cyprus
1 shared publication Daniel A. Sauers
Winona State University, MN
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 August 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Global Marketing
- p. 1-18
AI-Facilitated Astroturfing in Medical Tourism: Evidence from YouTube Comment Sections
Medical tourism is one of the few service categories in which the consumer is geographically distant from the point of consumption at the moment of purchase. A prospective patient evaluating a dent...
- 25 August 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Global Marketing
- p. 1-18
Open AccessAI-Facilitated Astroturfing in Medical Tourism: Evidence from YouTube Comment Sections
Medical tourism is one of the few service categories in which the consumer is geographically distant from the point of consumption at the moment of purchase. A prospective patient evaluating a dent...
- Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
From Assistant to Authority: Defining and Operationalizing Authority Drift in Conversational AI
Large language models are mostly described as tools, yet their behavior in extended dialogue resembles that of interactional agents that may reshape the epistemic and relational positions of their users. Existing research on persona drift documents that model behavior is unstable across multi-turn conversation, but the construct remains analytically broad and implies shifts in tone, warmth, assertiveness, and moral framing without distinguishing between those that are governance-irrelevant and those that bear direct consequences for human autonomy and decision-making. This paper introduces authority drift as a theoretically grounded and operationalizable subdimension of personality instability, defined as the progressive, selfreinforcing conversational transition in which a language model's epistemic positioning (the right to define facts) and deontic positioning (the right to direct action) acquire increased weight relative to the advisory role co-established in early interaction, until the model's output functions in practice as a mandate rather than a suggestion. By isolating this interactional shift, the framework offers clear, accessible implications for interdisciplinary audiences regarding the erosion of human epistemic agency and the need for governance mechanisms that safeguard user autonomy in an era of increasingly persuasive conversational AI. Drawing on conversationanalytic theory, human-automation interaction research, and LLM behavioral instability literature, the paper employs a conceptual model-building methodology through interdisciplinary theory synthesis to develop a measurement framework. Authority drift provides the missing construct at their intersection, linguistically grounded, interactionally defined, and directly actionable for platform-level AI governance.
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessFrom Assistant to Authority: Defining and Operationalizing Authority Drift in Conversational AI
Large language models are mostly described as tools, yet their behavior in extended dialogue resembles that of interactional agents that may reshape the epistemic and relational positions of their users. Existing research on persona drift documents that model behavior is unstable across multi-turn conversation, but the construct remains analytically broad and implies shifts in tone, warmth, assertiveness, and moral framing without distinguishing between those that are governance-irrelevant and those that bear direct consequences for human autonomy and decision-making. This paper introduces authority drift as a theoretically grounded and operationalizable subdimension of personality instability, defined as the progressive, selfreinforcing conversational transition in which a language model's epistemic positioning (the right to define facts) and deontic positioning (the right to direct action) acquire increased weight relative to the advisory role co-established in early interaction, until the model's output functions in practice as a mandate rather than a suggestion. By isolating this interactional shift, the framework offers clear, accessible implications for interdisciplinary audiences regarding the erosion of human epistemic agency and the need for governance mechanisms that safeguard user autonomy in an era of increasingly persuasive conversational AI. Drawing on conversationanalytic theory, human-automation interaction research, and LLM behavioral instability literature, the paper employs a conceptual model-building methodology through interdisciplinary theory synthesis to develop a measurement framework. Authority drift provides the missing construct at their intersection, linguistically grounded, interactionally defined, and directly actionable for platform-level AI governance.
- Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Chronotopic Modeling: Toward a Spatiotemporal Model of Narrative Analysis
This study advances a computational framework for narrative analysis grounded in Bakhtin's concept of the chronotope-the inseparable fusion of temporal and spatial coordinates that structure storytelling. While chronotopic theory has been extensively applied in literary and media studies, its operationalisation in large-scale text analytics remains underdeveloped. Drawing on methods from narratology, computational linguistics, and cultural analytics, the study introduces chronotopic modeling, an approach that detects and classifies spatiotemporal narrative frames in social media discourse. The model integrates temporal tagging, spatial extraction, motif detection, and classification to detect narrative shifts and recurrent frames, complementing and extending topic modeling by revealing how events are positioned in time and space rather than what they are about. Using LinkedIn and Reddit commentary on virtual influencers as a illustrative case study, the analysis identifies dominant chronotopes, particularly transformation, historical, and threshold frames, and demonstrates how participants situate technological phenomena within broader socio-temporal imaginaries. The findings illustrate the potential of chronotopic modeling as a transferable tool for digital humanities, marketing research, and social media analytics for performing systematic exploration of the ideological and affective structures embedded in contemporary narratives. Managerial Implications • Chronotopic analysis helps managers see how audiences place products/services, technologies, brands or other phenomena in narrative space-time. • The method shows how public discourse assigns roles to people and technologies, revealing whether innovations are imagined as tools, partners, or sources of uncertainty. • Differences in chronotopic framing across platforms can guide managers in adjusting communication styles for professional, consumer, or mixed audiences. • Used alongside standard analytics, chronotopic insights offer early signals about shifts in how markets interpret change, agency, and responsibility around a specific phenomenon.
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessChronotopic Modeling: Toward a Spatiotemporal Model of Narrative Analysis
This study advances a computational framework for narrative analysis grounded in Bakhtin's concept of the chronotope-the inseparable fusion of temporal and spatial coordinates that structure storytelling. While chronotopic theory has been extensively applied in literary and media studies, its operationalisation in large-scale text analytics remains underdeveloped. Drawing on methods from narratology, computational linguistics, and cultural analytics, the study introduces chronotopic modeling, an approach that detects and classifies spatiotemporal narrative frames in social media discourse. The model integrates temporal tagging, spatial extraction, motif detection, and classification to detect narrative shifts and recurrent frames, complementing and extending topic modeling by revealing how events are positioned in time and space rather than what they are about. Using LinkedIn and Reddit commentary on virtual influencers as a illustrative case study, the analysis identifies dominant chronotopes, particularly transformation, historical, and threshold frames, and demonstrates how participants situate technological phenomena within broader socio-temporal imaginaries. The findings illustrate the potential of chronotopic modeling as a transferable tool for digital humanities, marketing research, and social media analytics for performing systematic exploration of the ideological and affective structures embedded in contemporary narratives. Managerial Implications • Chronotopic analysis helps managers see how audiences place products/services, technologies, brands or other phenomena in narrative space-time. • The method shows how public discourse assigns roles to people and technologies, revealing whether innovations are imagined as tools, partners, or sources of uncertainty. • Differences in chronotopic framing across platforms can guide managers in adjusting communication styles for professional, consumer, or mixed audiences. • Used alongside standard analytics, chronotopic insights offer early signals about shifts in how markets interpret change, agency, and responsibility around a specific phenomenon.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Dialogic Agent Theory for AI: A Polyphonic Framework for Branding AI Agents in Business Communication
This article presents Dialogic Agent Theory for AI (DATA), a conceptual model that redefines AI-based communicative actors as discursive agents shaped through interaction, symbolic encoding, and institutional intent. Synthesized from peer-reviewed studies, DATA departs from mechanistic views of AI by stating that such agents acquire identity through tensions between corporate authorship, user projection, visual representation, and sociotechnical settings. Informed by Bakhtinian dialogism, organizational identity theory, and research in human–computer interaction, the theory proposes that AI agents are not static carriers of scripted roles but become recognizable through polyphonic emergence, temporal shifts, and interpretive co-authorship. The study employs an illustrative case analysis of Microsoft’s Tay chatbot to demonstrate the conceptual and practical implications of DATA. It shows how communicative failures are not limited to technical breakdowns but signal a misreading of dialogic interaction. DATA contributes to the analysis of artificial communicators in business, marketing, and public-facing contexts by showing how they represent an organization, shape user perception, and gradually take part in crafting its public voice.
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessDialogic Agent Theory for AI: A Polyphonic Framework for Branding AI Agents in Business Communication
This article presents Dialogic Agent Theory for AI (DATA), a conceptual model that redefines AI-based communicative actors as discursive agents shaped through interaction, symbolic encoding, and institutional intent. Synthesized from peer-reviewed studies, DATA departs from mechanistic views of AI by stating that such agents acquire identity through tensions between corporate authorship, user projection, visual representation, and sociotechnical settings. Informed by Bakhtinian dialogism, organizational identity theory, and research in human–computer interaction, the theory proposes that AI agents are not static carriers of scripted roles but become recognizable through polyphonic emergence, temporal shifts, and interpretive co-authorship. The study employs an illustrative case analysis of Microsoft’s Tay chatbot to demonstrate the conceptual and practical implications of DATA. It shows how communicative failures are not limited to technical breakdowns but signal a misreading of dialogic interaction. DATA contributes to the analysis of artificial communicators in business, marketing, and public-facing contexts by showing how they represent an organization, shape user perception, and gradually take part in crafting its public voice.
- Open Access
- 2 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
From Assistant to Authority: Defining and Operationalizing Authority Drift in Conversational AI
Large language models are mostly described as tools, yet their behavior in extended dialogue resembles that of interactional agents that may reshape the epistemic and relational positions of their users. Existing research on persona drift documents that model behavior is unstable across multi-turn conversation, but the construct remains analytically broad and implies shifts in tone, warmth, assertiveness, and moral framing without distinguishing between those that are governance-irrelevant and those that bear direct consequences for human autonomy and decision-making. This paper introduces authority drift as a theoretically grounded and operationalizable subdimension of personality instability, defined as the progressive, selfreinforcing conversational transition in which a language model's epistemic positioning (the right to define facts) and deontic positioning (the right to direct action) acquire increased weight relative to the advisory role co-established in early interaction, until the model's output functions in practice as a mandate rather than a suggestion. By isolating this interactional shift, the framework offers clear, accessible implications for interdisciplinary audiences regarding the erosion of human epistemic agency and the need for governance mechanisms that safeguard user autonomy in an era of increasingly persuasive conversational AI. Drawing on conversationanalytic theory, human-automation interaction research, and LLM behavioral instability literature, the paper employs a conceptual model-building methodology through interdisciplinary theory synthesis to develop a measurement framework. Authority drift provides the missing construct at their intersection, linguistically grounded, interactionally defined, and directly actionable for platform-level AI governance.
- 2 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessFrom Assistant to Authority: Defining and Operationalizing Authority Drift in Conversational AI
Large language models are mostly described as tools, yet their behavior in extended dialogue resembles that of interactional agents that may reshape the epistemic and relational positions of their users. Existing research on persona drift documents that model behavior is unstable across multi-turn conversation, but the construct remains analytically broad and implies shifts in tone, warmth, assertiveness, and moral framing without distinguishing between those that are governance-irrelevant and those that bear direct consequences for human autonomy and decision-making. This paper introduces authority drift as a theoretically grounded and operationalizable subdimension of personality instability, defined as the progressive, selfreinforcing conversational transition in which a language model's epistemic positioning (the right to define facts) and deontic positioning (the right to direct action) acquire increased weight relative to the advisory role co-established in early interaction, until the model's output functions in practice as a mandate rather than a suggestion. By isolating this interactional shift, the framework offers clear, accessible implications for interdisciplinary audiences regarding the erosion of human epistemic agency and the need for governance mechanisms that safeguard user autonomy in an era of increasingly persuasive conversational AI. Drawing on conversationanalytic theory, human-automation interaction research, and LLM behavioral instability literature, the paper employs a conceptual model-building methodology through interdisciplinary theory synthesis to develop a measurement framework. Authority drift provides the missing construct at their intersection, linguistically grounded, interactionally defined, and directly actionable for platform-level AI governance.
- 28 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Gender Issues
- Vol. 42 (4) , 1-29
Dialectical Frictions in Framing Femininity in YouTube Femvertising
- 28 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Gender Issues
- Vol. 42 (4) , 1-29
Dialectical Frictions in Framing Femininity in YouTube Femvertising
- Open Access
- 12 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 41 (1) , 611-628
Not in our image: rethinking anthropomorphism in expert chatbot design
This article interrogates how users interpret and respond to anthropomorphic versus minimalist chatbot designs in legal and regulatory advisory domains, contexts where ambiguity is costly and charm rarely billable. Anchored in ten in-depth interviews and supported by probabilistic simulations employing Bayesian inference and Monte Carlo simulation, the study reveals that interface preferences are far from stylistic whimsy. Instead, they reflect deep-seated expectations rooted in professional roles and interactional demands. Practitioners in law, HR, and compliance consistently gravitate toward pared-down, non-human designs and value transparency, cognitive economy, and semantic precision. In contrast, those operating in branding, UX, or emotionally expressive roles tend to welcome anthropomorphic agents, associating them with engagement and affective resonance. The findings advocate for adaptive chatbot architectures: systems that modulate their aesthetic and communicative cues in response to domain norms, user expectations, and interactional context.
- 12 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in AI & SOCIETY
- Vol. 41 (1) , 611-628
Open AccessNot in our image: rethinking anthropomorphism in expert chatbot design
This article interrogates how users interpret and respond to anthropomorphic versus minimalist chatbot designs in legal and regulatory advisory domains, contexts where ambiguity is costly and charm rarely billable. Anchored in ten in-depth interviews and supported by probabilistic simulations employing Bayesian inference and Monte Carlo simulation, the study reveals that interface preferences are far from stylistic whimsy. Instead, they reflect deep-seated expectations rooted in professional roles and interactional demands. Practitioners in law, HR, and compliance consistently gravitate toward pared-down, non-human designs and value transparency, cognitive economy, and semantic precision. In contrast, those operating in branding, UX, or emotionally expressive roles tend to welcome anthropomorphic agents, associating them with engagement and affective resonance. The findings advocate for adaptive chatbot architectures: systems that modulate their aesthetic and communicative cues in response to domain norms, user expectations, and interactional context.
- 20 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Interactive Learning Environments
- p. 1-15
Latent motivations in educational technology: projective techniques for AI-driven learning tools
- 20 March 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Interactive Learning Environments
- p. 1-15
Latent motivations in educational technology: projective techniques for AI-driven learning tools
- Open Access
- 13 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Education and Information Technologies
- Vol. 30 (2) , 2185-2209
Poietic symbiosis or algorithmic subjugation: generative AI technology in marketing communications education
This exploratory study investigates the convergence of marketing communications and AI-powered technology in higher education, adopting a perspective on student interactions with generative AI tools. Through a comprehensive content analysis of learners’ responses, we employed a blend of manual scrutiny, Python-generated Word Cloud, and Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) to expose the nature of interaction between learners and AI tools. Our findings indicate that learners predominantly adhere to the perception of AI as a tool resembling a ‘brush’ in the creative process, rather than as an active co-creator – the percaption that is aligned with the conventional tool-user dynamic. Students articulated a dual narrative regarding AI: they acknowledged its utility in enhancing creativity, yet expressed concerns about overreliance potentially eroding their own creative skills. Heidegger’s exploration of different modes of ‘revealing’ and Deleuze and Guattari’s notions of desiring machines and machinic enslavement suggest an alternative perspective where technology, and by extension AI-empowered technology, can contribute to a deeper existential understanding. This study points out the possibility of moving beyond a simple tool-user model, suggesting the emergence of more complex plausible scenarios of interaction: poietic symbiosis or algorithmic subjugation.
- 13 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Education and Information Technologies
- Vol. 30 (2) , 2185-2209
Open AccessPoietic symbiosis or algorithmic subjugation: generative AI technology in marketing communications education
This exploratory study investigates the convergence of marketing communications and AI-powered technology in higher education, adopting a perspective on student interactions with generative AI tools. Through a comprehensive content analysis of learners’ responses, we employed a blend of manual scrutiny, Python-generated Word Cloud, and Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) to expose the nature of interaction between learners and AI tools. Our findings indicate that learners predominantly adhere to the perception of AI as a tool resembling a ‘brush’ in the creative process, rather than as an active co-creator – the percaption that is aligned with the conventional tool-user dynamic. Students articulated a dual narrative regarding AI: they acknowledged its utility in enhancing creativity, yet expressed concerns about overreliance potentially eroding their own creative skills. Heidegger’s exploration of different modes of ‘revealing’ and Deleuze and Guattari’s notions of desiring machines and machinic enslavement suggest an alternative perspective where technology, and by extension AI-empowered technology, can contribute to a deeper existential understanding. This study points out the possibility of moving beyond a simple tool-user model, suggesting the emergence of more complex plausible scenarios of interaction: poietic symbiosis or algorithmic subjugation.
- Open Access
- 25 April 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction
- p. 1-14
The Dialogic Evolution of AI-Based Products: A Polyphonic Analysis of Temporal Transformations
- 25 April 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction
- p. 1-14
Open AccessThe Dialogic Evolution of AI-Based Products: A Polyphonic Analysis of Temporal Transformations