George Kinnear
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
George Kinnear has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Chris Sangwin
School of Mathematics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
7 shared publications - Anna K. Wood
School of Mathematics, University of Edinburgh - Edinburgh EH9 3FD, UK
5 shared publications - Ian Jones
Loughborough University, Loughborough, England
4 shared publications - Jill Rowan Deans MacKay
Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies, University of Edinburgh
4 shared publications Ross Galloway
4 shared publicationsBen Davies
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in EdArXiv
E-didactical contracts in students’ interactions with feedback-providing systems
Digital assessment systems offer new possibilities for providing feedback in mathematics, yet little is known about how students learn from such feedback. This study examines undergraduate students’ interactions with feedback in STACK – an interactive e-assessment environment based on example-generation tasks. Drawing on the theory of didactical contracts, we introduce the notion of e-didactical contracts to capture the approaches that students adopt when working with feedback-providing systems. Our analysis of think-aloud interviews with 17 undergraduate mathematics students in the UK and New Zealand identified three types of contracts: affirmation, guidance, and outsourcing. The contracts differ in the roles the students ascribe to the system and themselves, the anticipated use of feedback, and the locus of mathematical knowledge. Students also shifted between contracts within a session, in response to the demands of particular tasks and the affordances of the system. Our findings show that students can interact in ways that challenge task designers’ assumptions, thereby informing research on feedback and e-assessment. This manuscript is currently under consideration for publication in ZDM – Mathematics Education.
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in EdArXiv
Open AccessE-didactical contracts in students’ interactions with feedback-providing systems
Digital assessment systems offer new possibilities for providing feedback in mathematics, yet little is known about how students learn from such feedback. This study examines undergraduate students’ interactions with feedback in STACK – an interactive e-assessment environment based on example-generation tasks. Drawing on the theory of didactical contracts, we introduce the notion of e-didactical contracts to capture the approaches that students adopt when working with feedback-providing systems. Our analysis of think-aloud interviews with 17 undergraduate mathematics students in the UK and New Zealand identified three types of contracts: affirmation, guidance, and outsourcing. The contracts differ in the roles the students ascribe to the system and themselves, the anticipated use of feedback, and the locus of mathematical knowledge. Students also shifted between contracts within a session, in response to the demands of particular tasks and the affordances of the system. Our findings show that students can interact in ways that challenge task designers’ assumptions, thereby informing research on feedback and e-assessment. This manuscript is currently under consideration for publication in ZDM – Mathematics Education.
- Open Access
- 20 February 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
STEMM Teachers’ Conceptions of Teaching Large Classes
Although research into differences in how university teachers conceive of teaching has yielded valuable pedagogical insights, important questions remain about the interrelationship between conceptions and practices and the influence of contemporary teaching-learning environments. Focusing specifically on the context of large-class STEMM teaching, this study investigated the conceptions of sixteen STEMM lecturers, adopting a phenomenographic, interview-based methodology. Four conceptions were differentiated: large-class STEMM teaching as presentation; as guided learning and individual reflection; as active participation in a community of learning; and as the promotion of metacognition beyond the curriculum. These conceptions were further dissected in terms of three dimensions of variation comprising interactivity, the role of students, and aims of large STEMM classes. The findings also showed that the teachers' conceptions needed to be understood in relation both to contextual factors and to the extent to which they felt different strategies were accomplishable in particular settings.
- 20 February 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessSTEMM Teachers’ Conceptions of Teaching Large Classes
Although research into differences in how university teachers conceive of teaching has yielded valuable pedagogical insights, important questions remain about the interrelationship between conceptions and practices and the influence of contemporary teaching-learning environments. Focusing specifically on the context of large-class STEMM teaching, this study investigated the conceptions of sixteen STEMM lecturers, adopting a phenomenographic, interview-based methodology. Four conceptions were differentiated: large-class STEMM teaching as presentation; as guided learning and individual reflection; as active participation in a community of learning; and as the promotion of metacognition beyond the curriculum. These conceptions were further dissected in terms of three dimensions of variation comprising interactivity, the role of students, and aims of large STEMM classes. The findings also showed that the teachers' conceptions needed to be understood in relation both to contextual factors and to the extent to which they felt different strategies were accomplishable in particular settings.
- 4 December 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 21-36
The transfer of assessment from pen and paper to e-assessment
The use of e-assessment both at school and at university is very appealing to teachers and lecturers alike: At the very least, it allows for big time saving as the marking is automatised. However, we don’t know how the capabilities required to succeed change when transferring tasks from the traditional mode of paper-based to an e-assessment mode. Research has highlighted some differences; however, we are not yet sure how we can account for such differences. In this chapter we propose the instrumental approach as a tool to investigate such differences. We present two examples of task transfer from paper-based to e-assessment at two educational levels, and we analyse them through the lens of instrumentation. We illustrate how the mathematical capabilities assessed by the tasks depend on the modes in which the tasks are administered.
- 4 December 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 21-36
The transfer of assessment from pen and paper to e-assessment
The use of e-assessment both at school and at university is very appealing to teachers and lecturers alike: At the very least, it allows for big time saving as the marking is automatised. However, we don’t know how the capabilities required to succeed change when transferring tasks from the traditional mode of paper-based to an e-assessment mode. Research has highlighted some differences; however, we are not yet sure how we can account for such differences. In this chapter we propose the instrumental approach as a tool to investigate such differences. We present two examples of task transfer from paper-based to e-assessment at two educational levels, and we analyse them through the lens of instrumentation. We illustrate how the mathematical capabilities assessed by the tasks depend on the modes in which the tasks are administered.
- Open Access
- 30 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
- Vol. 12 (2) , 295-324
Question Design for Classroom Voting in Undergraduate Mathematics: A Systematic Review of the Literature
Classroom voting is an active learning approach based around posing questions for students to answer during a class. We synthesise existing advice about the design of multiple-choice questions (MCQs) for classroom voting, and suggest directions for future research. Our findings highlight the importance of considering the context in which questions will be asked and the intended purpose of the voting. Our synthesis of the existing literature provides a basis for mathematics educators and mathematicians working to further develop and evaluate the use of classroom voting in undergraduate mathematics. We suggest three directions for future research: empirical work to compare different classroom voting approaches, developing principles to guide the design of questions for classroom voting, and the collaborative development of question banks.
- 30 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
- Vol. 12 (2) , 295-324
Open AccessQuestion Design for Classroom Voting in Undergraduate Mathematics: A Systematic Review of the Literature
Classroom voting is an active learning approach based around posing questions for students to answer during a class. We synthesise existing advice about the design of multiple-choice questions (MCQs) for classroom voting, and suggest directions for future research. Our findings highlight the importance of considering the context in which questions will be asked and the intended purpose of the voting. Our synthesis of the existing literature provides a basis for mathematics educators and mathematicians working to further develop and evaluate the use of classroom voting in undergraduate mathematics. We suggest three directions for future research: empirical work to compare different classroom voting approaches, developing principles to guide the design of questions for classroom voting, and the collaborative development of question banks.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Elsevier in The Journal of Mathematical Behavior
- Vol. 81
Does understanding moderate aesthetic appraisals of proofs?
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Elsevier in The Journal of Mathematical Behavior
- Vol. 81
Open AccessDoes understanding moderate aesthetic appraisals of proofs?
- Open Access
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavior Research Methods
- Vol. 57 (8) , 1-16
Comparative judgement as a research tool: A meta-analysis of application and reliability
Comparative judgement (CJ) provides methods for constructing measurement scales, by asking assessors to make a series of pairwise comparisons of the artefacts or representations to be scored. Researchers using CJ need to decide how many assessors to recruit and how many comparisons to collect. They also need to gauge the reliability of the resulting measurement scale, with two different estimates in widespread use: scale separation reliability (SSR) and split-halves reliability (SHR). Previous research has offered guidance on these issues, but with either limited empirical support or focused only on education research. In this paper, we offer guidance based on our analysis of 101 CJ datasets that we collated from previous research across a range of disciplines. We present two novel findings, with substantive implications for future CJ research. First, we find that collecting ten comparisons for every representation is generally sufficient; a more lenient guideline than previously published. Second, we conclude that SSR can serve as a reliable proxy for inter-rater reliability, but recommend that researchers use a higher threshold of .8, rather than the current standard of .7.
- 10 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavior Research Methods
- Vol. 57 (8) , 1-16
Open AccessComparative judgement as a research tool: A meta-analysis of application and reliability
Comparative judgement (CJ) provides methods for constructing measurement scales, by asking assessors to make a series of pairwise comparisons of the artefacts or representations to be scored. Researchers using CJ need to decide how many assessors to recruit and how many comparisons to collect. They also need to gauge the reliability of the resulting measurement scale, with two different estimates in widespread use: scale separation reliability (SSR) and split-halves reliability (SHR). Previous research has offered guidance on these issues, but with either limited empirical support or focused only on education research. In this paper, we offer guidance based on our analysis of 101 CJ datasets that we collated from previous research across a range of disciplines. We present two novel findings, with substantive implications for future CJ research. First, we find that collecting ten comparisons for every representation is generally sufficient; a more lenient guideline than previously published. Second, we conclude that SSR can serve as a reliable proxy for inter-rater reliability, but recommend that researchers use a higher threshold of .8, rather than the current standard of .7.
- Open Access
- 23 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
STEM Teachers’ Conceptions of Teaching Large Classes
Teachers’ beliefs are an important factor affecting teaching practice and understanding them is critical for planning successful professional development support. However, relatively little research on conceptions has focussed on the teaching of large classes, despite the fact that large classes are central to STEM teaching provision in higher education. There has also been a lack of research investigating the nature of those beliefs, such as how they change and how context dependent they are. This study explores teachers’ conceptions of teaching large STEM classes from two perspectives. Firstly, sixteen STEM lecturers were interviewed about their experiences of teaching a large class using a phenomenographic approach through which four conceptions of teaching were identified: 1) Teaching as presentation 2) Teaching as guided learning and individual reflection 3) Teaching as active participation in the learning community 4) Teaching as promoting metacognition beyond the curriculum. Three dimensions of variation describe the differences between these conceptions: interactivity, the role of students, and the aim of the class. A secondary analysis of the interview data showed that teachers’ conceptions are context dependent, that they may hold multiple conceptions at the same time, and they can be aware of higher conceptions without adhering to them themselves.
- 23 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessSTEM Teachers’ Conceptions of Teaching Large Classes
Teachers’ beliefs are an important factor affecting teaching practice and understanding them is critical for planning successful professional development support. However, relatively little research on conceptions has focussed on the teaching of large classes, despite the fact that large classes are central to STEM teaching provision in higher education. There has also been a lack of research investigating the nature of those beliefs, such as how they change and how context dependent they are. This study explores teachers’ conceptions of teaching large STEM classes from two perspectives. Firstly, sixteen STEM lecturers were interviewed about their experiences of teaching a large class using a phenomenographic approach through which four conceptions of teaching were identified: 1) Teaching as presentation 2) Teaching as guided learning and individual reflection 3) Teaching as active participation in the learning community 4) Teaching as promoting metacognition beyond the curriculum. Three dimensions of variation describe the differences between these conceptions: interactivity, the role of students, and the aim of the class. A secondary analysis of the interview data showed that teachers’ conceptions are context dependent, that they may hold multiple conceptions at the same time, and they can be aware of higher conceptions without adhering to them themselves.
- Open Access
- 6 February 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Comparative judgement as a research tool: a meta-analysis of application and reliability
Comparative judgement (CJ) provides methods for constructing measurement scales, by asking assessors to make a series of pairwise comparisons of the artefacts or representations to be scored. Researchers using CJ need to decide how many assessors to recruit and how many comparisons to collect. They also need to gauge the reliability of the resulting measurement scale, with two different estimates in widespread use: Scale Separation Reliability (SSR) and Split-Halves Reliability (SHR). Previous research has offered guidance on these issues, but with either limited empirical support or focused only on education research. In this paper, we offer guidance based on our analysis of 101 CJ datasets that we collated from previous research across a range of disciplines. We present two novel findings, with substantive implications for future CJ research. First, we find that collecting 10 comparisons for every representation is generally sufficient; a more lenient guideline than previously published. Second, we conclude that SSR can serve as a reliable proxy for inter-rater reliability, but recommend that researchers use a higher threshold of .8, rather than the current standard of .7.
- 6 February 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessComparative judgement as a research tool: a meta-analysis of application and reliability
Comparative judgement (CJ) provides methods for constructing measurement scales, by asking assessors to make a series of pairwise comparisons of the artefacts or representations to be scored. Researchers using CJ need to decide how many assessors to recruit and how many comparisons to collect. They also need to gauge the reliability of the resulting measurement scale, with two different estimates in widespread use: Scale Separation Reliability (SSR) and Split-Halves Reliability (SHR). Previous research has offered guidance on these issues, but with either limited empirical support or focused only on education research. In this paper, we offer guidance based on our analysis of 101 CJ datasets that we collated from previous research across a range of disciplines. We present two novel findings, with substantive implications for future CJ research. First, we find that collecting 10 comparisons for every representation is generally sufficient; a more lenient guideline than previously published. Second, we conclude that SSR can serve as a reliable proxy for inter-rater reliability, but recommend that researchers use a higher threshold of .8, rather than the current standard of .7.
- Open Access
- 27 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Studies in Mathematics
- Vol. 119 (2) , 179-201
Student approaches to generating mathematical examples: comparing e-assessment and paper-based tasks
Example-generation tasks have been suggested as an effective way to both promote students’ learning of mathematics and assess students’ understanding of concepts. E-assessment offers the potential to use example-generation tasks with large groups of students, but there has been little research on this approach so far. Across two studies, we investigate students’ responses to a particular sequence of example-generation tasks, posed either on paper or through e-assessment. We identify a striking difference in students’ example-generation strategies and success, for e-assessment and paper-based versions of the same tasks. This suggests the use of example-generation tasks in e-assessment may not be straightforward, and we conclude by discussing the implications for teaching and research.
- 27 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Studies in Mathematics
- Vol. 119 (2) , 179-201
Open AccessStudent approaches to generating mathematical examples: comparing e-assessment and paper-based tasks
Example-generation tasks have been suggested as an effective way to both promote students’ learning of mathematics and assess students’ understanding of concepts. E-assessment offers the potential to use example-generation tasks with large groups of students, but there has been little research on this approach so far. Across two studies, we investigate students’ responses to a particular sequence of example-generation tasks, posed either on paper or through e-assessment. We identify a striking difference in students’ example-generation strategies and success, for e-assessment and paper-based versions of the same tasks. This suggests the use of example-generation tasks in e-assessment may not be straightforward, and we conclude by discussing the implications for teaching and research.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2024
- Published by Elsevier in The Journal of Mathematical Behavior
- Vol. 76
Lecturers' use of questions in undergraduate mathematics lectures
- 18 September 2024
- Published by Elsevier in The Journal of Mathematical Behavior
- Vol. 76
Open AccessLecturers' use of questions in undergraduate mathematics lectures