Volodymyr Nahnybida
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Volodymyr Nahnybida has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Academician F.H. Burchak Scientific Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship of the NALS of Ukraine
2 shared publications- Anatolii Ishchuk
Academician F. H. Burchak Scientific Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine
1 shared publication - Ievgen Boiarskyi
Academician F. H. Burchak Scientific Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship of National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine
1 shared publication - Oleksandr Krupchan
Academician F. H. Burchak Scientific-Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship
1 shared publication - Yaroslav Bliakharskyi
Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law
1 shared publication - Yurii Bilousov
Leading Scientific Researcher of the Scientific Laboratory of the Academician F. H. Burchak Scientific-Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship of National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukrain
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 May 2026
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 2 (110),p. 99
Factors Transforming the Contemporary International Legal Order
The article examines the principal factors driving the transformation of the contemporary international legal order amid profound changes in the global security, political, economic, and technological environment. It argues that the full-scale armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine has become a catalyst for reassessing the effectiveness of existing mechanisms for ensuring international legality and compliance with the fundamental principles of international law enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations and other universal international legal instruments. The authors demonstrate that the current transformation of the international legal order does not involve a revision of its normative foundations but rather the emergence of new institutional, legal, and organisational mechanisms designed to ensure the effective implementation of international legal norms. The article identifies and systematises the principal structural factors shaping the transformation of the international legal order, including changes in the global security environment, geopolitical fragmentation, climate change and the development of international environmental law, the expansion of international sanctions regimes, digitalisation and the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence, as well as the evolving role of international courts and arbitral institutions. It further demonstrates the interrelationship between these factors and their cumulative impact on the development of contemporary international legal regulation. Particular attention is devoted to the analysis of emerging international legal mechanisms developed in response to current global challenges, including international sanctions regimes, compensation mechanisms, special tribunals, international damage registers, compliance procedures, due diligence mechanisms, advisory opinions of international judicial institutions, and the practice of international commercial and investment arbitration. The article substantiates that the development of these instruments increasingly contributes to maintaining the effective ordering of international relations and strengthening the international legal order. The authors conclude that the contemporary international legal order is undergoing a process of functional and institutional transformation, the essence of which lies in adapting the mechanisms for ensuring international legality to new global challenges while preserving the fundamental principles of international law. It is established that the further development of the international legal order will depend on the international community's ability to establish effective mechanisms to ensure compliance with international legal obligations, strengthen international responsibility, and restore confidence in multilateral mechanisms of international cooperation.
- 22 May 2026
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 2 (110),p. 99
Open AccessFactors Transforming the Contemporary International Legal Order
The article examines the principal factors driving the transformation of the contemporary international legal order amid profound changes in the global security, political, economic, and technological environment. It argues that the full-scale armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine has become a catalyst for reassessing the effectiveness of existing mechanisms for ensuring international legality and compliance with the fundamental principles of international law enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations and other universal international legal instruments. The authors demonstrate that the current transformation of the international legal order does not involve a revision of its normative foundations but rather the emergence of new institutional, legal, and organisational mechanisms designed to ensure the effective implementation of international legal norms. The article identifies and systematises the principal structural factors shaping the transformation of the international legal order, including changes in the global security environment, geopolitical fragmentation, climate change and the development of international environmental law, the expansion of international sanctions regimes, digitalisation and the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence, as well as the evolving role of international courts and arbitral institutions. It further demonstrates the interrelationship between these factors and their cumulative impact on the development of contemporary international legal regulation. Particular attention is devoted to the analysis of emerging international legal mechanisms developed in response to current global challenges, including international sanctions regimes, compensation mechanisms, special tribunals, international damage registers, compliance procedures, due diligence mechanisms, advisory opinions of international judicial institutions, and the practice of international commercial and investment arbitration. The article substantiates that the development of these instruments increasingly contributes to maintaining the effective ordering of international relations and strengthening the international legal order. The authors conclude that the contemporary international legal order is undergoing a process of functional and institutional transformation, the essence of which lies in adapting the mechanisms for ensuring international legality to new global challenges while preserving the fundamental principles of international law. It is established that the further development of the international legal order will depend on the international community's ability to establish effective mechanisms to ensure compliance with international legal obligations, strengthen international responsibility, and restore confidence in multilateral mechanisms of international cooperation.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship named after Academician F.H. Burchak of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine in Private Law and Business
- No. 25,p. 228-232
THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS IN ESTAB-LISHING COMMON STANDARDS FOR DIGITAL ARBITRATION
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Research Institute of Private Law and Entrepreneurship named after Academician F.H. Burchak of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine in Private Law and Business
- No. 25,p. 228-232
THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS IN ESTAB-LISHING COMMON STANDARDS FOR DIGITAL ARBITRATION
- Open Access
- 25 October 2022
- Published by Universidad del Zulia in Cuestiones Políticas
- Vol. 40 (74) , 160-177
Trade agreements, digital development and international commercial arbitration
The purpose of the article was to study the problems that arise during the settlement of disputes in the order of international commercial arbitration. The article used general scientific (dialectic, analysis and synthesis) and special legal (comparative legal, formal-logical, systemic, hermeneutic, axiological) methods. In the results of the research, it was established that the characteristic features of electronic development contracts in international trade are: electronic forms of conclusion of pre-contractual and contractual communication, making amendments and additions to the contract. Taking into account the features that accompany the chosen form of contracting prevails the need to refer to the provisions of the applicable legislation on tax and customs legislation and protection of personal data, etc. The conclusions state that the main problems in the resolution of disputes arising from e-commerce contracts, in international commercial arbitration, are the issues of requirements and validity of the arbitration clauses contained in such contracts, the importance of the agreements reached in the pre-contractual stage in the subsequent resolution of disputes between the parties and the problems of proof arising from the peculiarities of entering into relevant contracts
- 25 October 2022
- Published by Universidad del Zulia in Cuestiones Políticas
- Vol. 40 (74) , 160-177
Open AccessTrade agreements, digital development and international commercial arbitration
The purpose of the article was to study the problems that arise during the settlement of disputes in the order of international commercial arbitration. The article used general scientific (dialectic, analysis and synthesis) and special legal (comparative legal, formal-logical, systemic, hermeneutic, axiological) methods. In the results of the research, it was established that the characteristic features of electronic development contracts in international trade are: electronic forms of conclusion of pre-contractual and contractual communication, making amendments and additions to the contract. Taking into account the features that accompany the chosen form of contracting prevails the need to refer to the provisions of the applicable legislation on tax and customs legislation and protection of personal data, etc. The conclusions state that the main problems in the resolution of disputes arising from e-commerce contracts, in international commercial arbitration, are the issues of requirements and validity of the arbitration clauses contained in such contracts, the importance of the agreements reached in the pre-contractual stage in the subsequent resolution of disputes between the parties and the problems of proof arising from the peculiarities of entering into relevant contracts
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 6 (84),p. 8-16
The Influence of Quarantine COVID-Restrictions Related and Policy of Digitalization on Dispute Resolution via International Commercial Arbitration
The article deals with the study of the latest challenges for the institute of international commercial arbitration in connection with the pandemic of coronavirus infection COVID-19 and to the study of the impact of the concomitant introduction of digitalization tools at different stages of arbitration. Special attention is paid to establishing the reasons for the smaller negative impact of the pandemic on the institutions of alternative dispute resolution compared to the system of state justice. The paper proves that at the level of arbitration institutions there is a coordinated and balanced response to the challenges of the pandemic, which is expressed in the assurance of business and, consequently, potential parties in the dispute, in continuing the proper functioning of the institution and its administration even in the latest conditions, and in the development of guidelines and similar documents, the implementation of virtual arbitration practices. The measures taken by the leading arbitration institution of Ukraine — ICAC at the Ukrainian CCI in response to quarantine restrictions were identified, and the prospects for further development of international commercial arbitration in Ukraine and the world in the coming years were analysed. The author summarizes that the analysis of innovations and prospects studied in scientific work regarding the further evolution of digitalization tools in the arbitration process, allows us to agree with the forecasts proposed in the report of ICAC at the Ukrainian CCI for 2020. At the same time, it is possible to add that already introduced mechanisms, such as document-only production, fast-track arbitration, Med-Arb, etc., will be more widely used in the practice of international commercial arbitration. It is further argued that even after the end of the COVID-19 pandemic, the changes it has brought and the virtualization and digitalization of the arbitration process will not lose popularity and become firmly entrenched in international commercial arbitration, reforming the institution to integrate modern technological progress realities at all stages of arbitration.
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 6 (84),p. 8-16
The Influence of Quarantine COVID-Restrictions Related and Policy of Digitalization on Dispute Resolution via International Commercial Arbitration
The article deals with the study of the latest challenges for the institute of international commercial arbitration in connection with the pandemic of coronavirus infection COVID-19 and to the study of the impact of the concomitant introduction of digitalization tools at different stages of arbitration. Special attention is paid to establishing the reasons for the smaller negative impact of the pandemic on the institutions of alternative dispute resolution compared to the system of state justice. The paper proves that at the level of arbitration institutions there is a coordinated and balanced response to the challenges of the pandemic, which is expressed in the assurance of business and, consequently, potential parties in the dispute, in continuing the proper functioning of the institution and its administration even in the latest conditions, and in the development of guidelines and similar documents, the implementation of virtual arbitration practices. The measures taken by the leading arbitration institution of Ukraine — ICAC at the Ukrainian CCI in response to quarantine restrictions were identified, and the prospects for further development of international commercial arbitration in Ukraine and the world in the coming years were analysed. The author summarizes that the analysis of innovations and prospects studied in scientific work regarding the further evolution of digitalization tools in the arbitration process, allows us to agree with the forecasts proposed in the report of ICAC at the Ukrainian CCI for 2020. At the same time, it is possible to add that already introduced mechanisms, such as document-only production, fast-track arbitration, Med-Arb, etc., will be more widely used in the practice of international commercial arbitration. It is further argued that even after the end of the COVID-19 pandemic, the changes it has brought and the virtualization and digitalization of the arbitration process will not lose popularity and become firmly entrenched in international commercial arbitration, reforming the institution to integrate modern technological progress realities at all stages of arbitration.
- 3 July 2021
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 2 (80),p. 27-34
Efficiency of Rules of Law in Regulation of Property Relations in International Commercial Turnover
The article examines the essence and criteria for the effectiveness of the mechanism of legal regulation, the effectiveness of rules of law in international commercial agreements, given the distinction between the concept of «rule of law» as a mandatory rule of conduct adopted and protected by the state, and as a category covering not only certain national legal system, but also various legal regulators of non-national and non-state, international origin. It is established that ensuring the effectiveness of the rule of law is based on the need to achieve social, political, economic and other goals of its adoption, and is guaranteed by the construction of substantively and formally consistent, holistic within the relevant institution or branch of law and logically constructed legal prescription. It is proved that the complexity and variety of sources of legal regulation of international commercial agreements, the choice of the applicable law to which is based in general, indicates the inexpediency of limiting of the understanding of the construct of «rule of law» as exclusively sanctioned and enshrined by the state. In this regard, the thesis is put forward that in law-making activity it is necessary to construct provisions of new legislation on normative-legal acts and rule-making activity with awareness of needs and realities of international business, both Ukrainian and domestically located. Two ways to achieve this goal have been proposed: either by adjusting the proposed definitions of the rule of law or by establishing the scope of meaningful dissemination of the provisions of the future law on law-making activities exclusively within national borders and in relation to the Ukrainian legal system. Also, from the point of view of the effectiveness of legal regulation of international commercial agreements, it is justified that in this regard a broader and more modern understanding of legal norms, giving the parties a guaranteed opportunity to refer to general principles of law, trade customs, lex mercatoria, unified international instruments (for example, the UNIDROIT Principles, INCOTERMS), etc. should be implemented.
- 3 July 2021
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 2 (80),p. 27-34
Efficiency of Rules of Law in Regulation of Property Relations in International Commercial Turnover
The article examines the essence and criteria for the effectiveness of the mechanism of legal regulation, the effectiveness of rules of law in international commercial agreements, given the distinction between the concept of «rule of law» as a mandatory rule of conduct adopted and protected by the state, and as a category covering not only certain national legal system, but also various legal regulators of non-national and non-state, international origin. It is established that ensuring the effectiveness of the rule of law is based on the need to achieve social, political, economic and other goals of its adoption, and is guaranteed by the construction of substantively and formally consistent, holistic within the relevant institution or branch of law and logically constructed legal prescription. It is proved that the complexity and variety of sources of legal regulation of international commercial agreements, the choice of the applicable law to which is based in general, indicates the inexpediency of limiting of the understanding of the construct of «rule of law» as exclusively sanctioned and enshrined by the state. In this regard, the thesis is put forward that in law-making activity it is necessary to construct provisions of new legislation on normative-legal acts and rule-making activity with awareness of needs and realities of international business, both Ukrainian and domestically located. Two ways to achieve this goal have been proposed: either by adjusting the proposed definitions of the rule of law or by establishing the scope of meaningful dissemination of the provisions of the future law on law-making activities exclusively within national borders and in relation to the Ukrainian legal system. Also, from the point of view of the effectiveness of legal regulation of international commercial agreements, it is justified that in this regard a broader and more modern understanding of legal norms, giving the parties a guaranteed opportunity to refer to general principles of law, trade customs, lex mercatoria, unified international instruments (for example, the UNIDROIT Principles, INCOTERMS), etc. should be implemented.
- 31 December 2020
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 5 (77),p. 6-21
Implementation of the Principle of Party Autonomy in Determining the Law Applicable to the Substance of Dispute in International Commercial Arbitration
The article examines the essence and significance of the principle of party autonomy in international commercial arbitration when choosing the law applicable to the substance of the dispute. Terminological issues of the content of the concepts «essence of the dispute» and «applicable law» are considered separately. It is suggested that the substance of the dispute, to which the substantive law chosen by the parties or established by the arbitral tribunal applies, should cover a wide range of issues related to the rights and obligations of the parties arising from the conclusion, interpretation, enforcement, violation, termination or invalidity of the relevant foreign trade contract. It is summarized that the implementation of the party autonomy to choose the applicable substantive law by including in the foreign trade agreement the relevant provision is based on the normative permission enshrined in the lex fori, under whose jurisdiction arbitration takes place, and has its consequences in recognizing and enforcing arbitral awards. The author points out that the arbitrators have no obligation to apply the substantive law of the state of the place of arbitration to the substance of the dispute, which corresponds to the right of the parties to determine such a right independently, without imperative binding to a particular legal system. It is concluded that the delineation of the choices of substantive law before the parties is not regulated by law, leaving these issues to the discretion of the parties and the arbitration, for the analysis of which one should turn to science, arbitration and court case law. It is also necessary to consider options for establishing the substantive law applicable to the substance of the dispute: on the basis of direct or indirect choice made by the parties, or, in the absence or defect, the impossibility of realization of such a choice, the establishment of applicable law by an arbitration tribunal according to conflict of laws it considers appropriate. This logic is enshrined in all of the national arbitration laws which are analysed and is traced in the rules of arbitration institutions. The article argues that today the parties are free to choose not only national legal systems, but also non-national legal regulators (transnational principles of law, business practices, etc.), can subject various aspects of the dispute to different legal instruments with different degrees of binding power, and also to withdraw from them altogether and agree to settle the case in accordance with the equity principles or to give the arbitrator the mandate of an «amiable compositeur».
- 31 December 2020
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 5 (77),p. 6-21
Implementation of the Principle of Party Autonomy in Determining the Law Applicable to the Substance of Dispute in International Commercial Arbitration
The article examines the essence and significance of the principle of party autonomy in international commercial arbitration when choosing the law applicable to the substance of the dispute. Terminological issues of the content of the concepts «essence of the dispute» and «applicable law» are considered separately. It is suggested that the substance of the dispute, to which the substantive law chosen by the parties or established by the arbitral tribunal applies, should cover a wide range of issues related to the rights and obligations of the parties arising from the conclusion, interpretation, enforcement, violation, termination or invalidity of the relevant foreign trade contract. It is summarized that the implementation of the party autonomy to choose the applicable substantive law by including in the foreign trade agreement the relevant provision is based on the normative permission enshrined in the lex fori, under whose jurisdiction arbitration takes place, and has its consequences in recognizing and enforcing arbitral awards. The author points out that the arbitrators have no obligation to apply the substantive law of the state of the place of arbitration to the substance of the dispute, which corresponds to the right of the parties to determine such a right independently, without imperative binding to a particular legal system. It is concluded that the delineation of the choices of substantive law before the parties is not regulated by law, leaving these issues to the discretion of the parties and the arbitration, for the analysis of which one should turn to science, arbitration and court case law. It is also necessary to consider options for establishing the substantive law applicable to the substance of the dispute: on the basis of direct or indirect choice made by the parties, or, in the absence or defect, the impossibility of realization of such a choice, the establishment of applicable law by an arbitration tribunal according to conflict of laws it considers appropriate. This logic is enshrined in all of the national arbitration laws which are analysed and is traced in the rules of arbitration institutions. The article argues that today the parties are free to choose not only national legal systems, but also non-national legal regulators (transnational principles of law, business practices, etc.), can subject various aspects of the dispute to different legal instruments with different degrees of binding power, and also to withdraw from them altogether and agree to settle the case in accordance with the equity principles or to give the arbitrator the mandate of an «amiable compositeur».
- Open Access
- 15 April 2020
- Published by Kyiv University of Law of NAS of Ukraine in Law Review of Kyiv University of Law
- No. 1,p. 361-365
Problems of determining a foreign element in dispute resolution in international commercial arbitration
The article is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of the problems of determining the arbitrability of disputes submitted for consideration and resolution to international commercial arbitration in terms of the presence or absence of a foreign element in such disputes. The theoretical foundations of the concept of a foreign element, arbitrability, criteria for determining the competence of international commercial arbitration regarding the resolution of a dispute are analyzed in detail. Also, the article, through the prism of the provisions of the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration, substantiates the need to improve article 1 of the Law of Ukraine «On International Commercial Arbitration». Based on theoretical and regulatory sources, court practice, the author concludes that it is necessary to supplement the provisions of the Law with norms on the possibility of transferring international commercial disputes to which individual entrepreneurs, states are parties, as well as disputes in which the place of fulfillment of a significant part of the obligations and the place with which the dispute is most closely related located in a country other than the place where the parties engaged in commercial activities. The author also points out that the mechanism for determining the presence of a foreign element in assessing international commercial disputes in accordance with the provisions of the current legislation does not fully comply with international standards enshrined in UN acts. Now the provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On International Commercial Arbitration» require additions both in terms of the subject composition (individual entrepreneurs, foreign states), and by other criteria, including the place of fulfillment of a significant part of the obligations and the place with which the dispute is most closely connected. Direct work is currently underway to improve the relevant provisions, in the near future they will be submitted to parliament for consideration and adoption.
- 15 April 2020
- Published by Kyiv University of Law of NAS of Ukraine in Law Review of Kyiv University of Law
- No. 1,p. 361-365
Open AccessProblems of determining a foreign element in dispute resolution in international commercial arbitration
The article is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of the problems of determining the arbitrability of disputes submitted for consideration and resolution to international commercial arbitration in terms of the presence or absence of a foreign element in such disputes. The theoretical foundations of the concept of a foreign element, arbitrability, criteria for determining the competence of international commercial arbitration regarding the resolution of a dispute are analyzed in detail. Also, the article, through the prism of the provisions of the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration, substantiates the need to improve article 1 of the Law of Ukraine «On International Commercial Arbitration». Based on theoretical and regulatory sources, court practice, the author concludes that it is necessary to supplement the provisions of the Law with norms on the possibility of transferring international commercial disputes to which individual entrepreneurs, states are parties, as well as disputes in which the place of fulfillment of a significant part of the obligations and the place with which the dispute is most closely related located in a country other than the place where the parties engaged in commercial activities. The author also points out that the mechanism for determining the presence of a foreign element in assessing international commercial disputes in accordance with the provisions of the current legislation does not fully comply with international standards enshrined in UN acts. Now the provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On International Commercial Arbitration» require additions both in terms of the subject composition (individual entrepreneurs, foreign states), and by other criteria, including the place of fulfillment of a significant part of the obligations and the place with which the dispute is most closely connected. Direct work is currently underway to improve the relevant provisions, in the near future they will be submitted to parliament for consideration and adoption.
- 13 March 2020
- Published by Legislation Institute of The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine in Scientific Papers of the Legislation Institute of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine
- No. 2,p. 78-86
Арбітраж як суб’єкт правозастосування при вирішенні міжнародних комерційних спорів
Метою статті є дослідження механізму встановлення юрисдикції арбітражного суду на вирішення комерційних спорів, аналіз поняття та змісту концепції арбітрабільності. Наукова новизна полягає у дослідженні особливостей делегування міжнародному комерційному арбітражу правозастосовчих функцій державними судами. Так, стверджується, що, делегуючи такі функції, держава автоматично не виключає вказані категорії спорів з-під юрисдикції судів. Лише при наявності письмової арбітражної угоди, яка відповідатиме вимогам чинності, дійсності та виконуваності, дотримання вимог арбітрабільності спору, а також реалізації однією зі сторін наміру вирішити спір саме в порядку арбітражу шляхом подання звернення в арбітраж (позовної заяви) такий спір виключається з юрисдикції державних судів та розглядається арбітражем. Висновки. Беручи до уваги договірні передумови передачі спору на вирішення міжнародних комерційних арбітражів, арбітрабільність спорів дійсно є критерієм, що окреслює сферу правомочностей сторін спору щодо вибору й передачі на вирішення арбітражу певних, визначених категорій спорів (визначає межі договірної свободи сторін), а з іншого боку – на етапі виникнення спору дозволяє складу арбітражу виявити належність конкретного спору до тих, які можуть бути вирішені арбітражем, відмежовуючи таким чином сферу підвідомчості спорів державним судам. Положення проаналізованих норм свідчать, що на рівні українського законодавства створено відповідний механізм реалізації положень Нью-Йоркської конвенції 1958 р. й учасники, які уклали угоду про передачу спору на вирішення міжнародного комерційного арбітражу, дійсно мають право скористатися саме таким способом альтернативного вирішення спору з його одночасним вилученням з юрисдикції державних судів, що забезпечується положеннями процесуального кодексу про залишення позову без розгляду та закриття провадження у справі.
- 13 March 2020
- Published by Legislation Institute of The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine in Scientific Papers of the Legislation Institute of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine
- No. 2,p. 78-86
Арбітраж як суб’єкт правозастосування при вирішенні міжнародних комерційних спорів
Метою статті є дослідження механізму встановлення юрисдикції арбітражного суду на вирішення комерційних спорів, аналіз поняття та змісту концепції арбітрабільності. Наукова новизна полягає у дослідженні особливостей делегування міжнародному комерційному арбітражу правозастосовчих функцій державними судами. Так, стверджується, що, делегуючи такі функції, держава автоматично не виключає вказані категорії спорів з-під юрисдикції судів. Лише при наявності письмової арбітражної угоди, яка відповідатиме вимогам чинності, дійсності та виконуваності, дотримання вимог арбітрабільності спору, а також реалізації однією зі сторін наміру вирішити спір саме в порядку арбітражу шляхом подання звернення в арбітраж (позовної заяви) такий спір виключається з юрисдикції державних судів та розглядається арбітражем. Висновки. Беручи до уваги договірні передумови передачі спору на вирішення міжнародних комерційних арбітражів, арбітрабільність спорів дійсно є критерієм, що окреслює сферу правомочностей сторін спору щодо вибору й передачі на вирішення арбітражу певних, визначених категорій спорів (визначає межі договірної свободи сторін), а з іншого боку – на етапі виникнення спору дозволяє складу арбітражу виявити належність конкретного спору до тих, які можуть бути вирішені арбітражем, відмежовуючи таким чином сферу підвідомчості спорів державним судам. Положення проаналізованих норм свідчать, що на рівні українського законодавства створено відповідний механізм реалізації положень Нью-Йоркської конвенції 1958 р. й учасники, які уклали угоду про передачу спору на вирішення міжнародного комерційного арбітражу, дійсно мають право скористатися саме таким способом альтернативного вирішення спору з його одночасним вилученням з юрисдикції державних судів, що забезпечується положеннями процесуального кодексу про залишення позову без розгляду та закриття провадження у справі.
- 25 February 2020
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- p. 86-97
The Influence of the Law of the Country of the Place of Enforcement of the Arbitral Award on the Settlement of Disputes in the International Commercial Arbitration
The article examines the key aspects of the impact of the law of the place of enforcement of the arbitral award on arbitration and directly on the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, given the study of doctrinal positions, regulations and relevant case law. It was found out that the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards of 1958 refers to the procedural rules of the country of enforcement to settle matters inherent to the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards not governed by the Convention, establishing only basic and fairly simple formal requirements for the said procedure, which is one of the strong characteristics of the conventional regime of recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards. In light of this, it is concluded that such an approach is moderate and takes into account the impossibility and lack of practical necessity of unification at the international treaty level of procedural features of recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, establishing only basic principles and requirements. It is substantiated that there are two components of the law of the place of enforcement of the arbitral award, which regulate the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards within the relevant jurisdiction, namely substantive and procedural, which, however, are contained in single legal acts — mostly national arbitration laws. The author emphasizes the crucial role of the law of the place of enforcement of the arbitral award in the material and procedural aspects for the procedure of recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards within the relevant jurisdiction. It is concluded that the unification of material grounds for refusal of recognition and enforcement (in particular, non-arbitrability of the subject matter of the dispute and contradiction of the award to public policy as grounds that can be raised by the competent judicial authority at the place of enforcement ex officio, regardless of reference to them by opposing party), as well as the consolidation of basic procedural requirements and principles is carried out by the New York Convention of 1958, which leaves to the discretion of the national legislature, on the one hand, the settlement of minor aspects of the procedure, but, on the other hand, recognizes its full discretion in determining the limits of objective arbitrability, the content and specific filling of the category of international public policy applicable in the relevant jurisdiction. Keywords: arbitral award, international commercial arbitration, applicable law, arbitration process, public policy.
- 25 February 2020
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- p. 86-97
The Influence of the Law of the Country of the Place of Enforcement of the Arbitral Award on the Settlement of Disputes in the International Commercial Arbitration
The article examines the key aspects of the impact of the law of the place of enforcement of the arbitral award on arbitration and directly on the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, given the study of doctrinal positions, regulations and relevant case law. It was found out that the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards of 1958 refers to the procedural rules of the country of enforcement to settle matters inherent to the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards not governed by the Convention, establishing only basic and fairly simple formal requirements for the said procedure, which is one of the strong characteristics of the conventional regime of recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards. In light of this, it is concluded that such an approach is moderate and takes into account the impossibility and lack of practical necessity of unification at the international treaty level of procedural features of recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, establishing only basic principles and requirements. It is substantiated that there are two components of the law of the place of enforcement of the arbitral award, which regulate the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards within the relevant jurisdiction, namely substantive and procedural, which, however, are contained in single legal acts — mostly national arbitration laws. The author emphasizes the crucial role of the law of the place of enforcement of the arbitral award in the material and procedural aspects for the procedure of recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards within the relevant jurisdiction. It is concluded that the unification of material grounds for refusal of recognition and enforcement (in particular, non-arbitrability of the subject matter of the dispute and contradiction of the award to public policy as grounds that can be raised by the competent judicial authority at the place of enforcement ex officio, regardless of reference to them by opposing party), as well as the consolidation of basic procedural requirements and principles is carried out by the New York Convention of 1958, which leaves to the discretion of the national legislature, on the one hand, the settlement of minor aspects of the procedure, but, on the other hand, recognizes its full discretion in determining the limits of objective arbitrability, the content and specific filling of the category of international public policy applicable in the relevant jurisdiction. Keywords: arbitral award, international commercial arbitration, applicable law, arbitration process, public policy.