Ramón S. Barthelemy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Ramón S. Barthelemy has a total of 42 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Charles Henderson
North Carolina State University
7 shared publications - Alexis Buzzell
University of Utah
6 shared publications - Madison Swirtz
University of Utah
6 shared publications - Adrienne Traxler
University of Copenhagen
5 shared publications - Timothy J. Atherton
Tufts University
5 shared publications - Alexis V. Knaub
American Association of Physics Teachers, College Park, Maryland 20740, USA
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 September 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 22 (2)
Characterizing the U.S. graduate-level quantum curriculum: Insights into doctoral programs’ coursework and comparisons with undergraduate preparation
The completion of graduate-level coursework is an important milestone on the path to a doctoral degree in physics. Yet the structure and content of the graduate curricula remain largely undocumented. Here we provide the first national-scale analysis of the graduate-level quantum curriculum, drawing on catalogs from 184 institutions, 121 core quantum course syllabi, and 91 quantum field theory (QFT) course syllabi. Our results reveal the majority of graduate programs require two quantum courses (60.3%) and most commonly use Sakurai’s textbook (41.2%). Core quantum syllabi converged on four canonical topics: kinematics, angular momentum, approximations, and dynamics. While QFT may be considered advanced coursework that is not necessary for all research fields, it remains essential for describing relativistic and multiparticle systems, yet it is nearly absent from the physics education research (PER) literature. We found that 39% of graduate programs had no formal QFT course offering. Statistical analyses revealed that smaller graduate programs with less research activity were more likely not to offer a QFT course, raising concerns about equity and access. Among institutions that did offer QFT courses, a canonical set of topics emerged: interacting fields, Feynman diagrams, quantum electrodynamics, and radiative corrections. We provide comparisons to the undergraduate quantum curriculum, as well as recommendations to instructors and programs.
- 25 September 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 22 (2)
Open AccessCharacterizing the U.S. graduate-level quantum curriculum: Insights into doctoral programs’ coursework and comparisons with undergraduate preparation
The completion of graduate-level coursework is an important milestone on the path to a doctoral degree in physics. Yet the structure and content of the graduate curricula remain largely undocumented. Here we provide the first national-scale analysis of the graduate-level quantum curriculum, drawing on catalogs from 184 institutions, 121 core quantum course syllabi, and 91 quantum field theory (QFT) course syllabi. Our results reveal the majority of graduate programs require two quantum courses (60.3%) and most commonly use Sakurai’s textbook (41.2%). Core quantum syllabi converged on four canonical topics: kinematics, angular momentum, approximations, and dynamics. While QFT may be considered advanced coursework that is not necessary for all research fields, it remains essential for describing relativistic and multiparticle systems, yet it is nearly absent from the physics education research (PER) literature. We found that 39% of graduate programs had no formal QFT course offering. Statistical analyses revealed that smaller graduate programs with less research activity were more likely not to offer a QFT course, raising concerns about equity and access. Among institutions that did offer QFT courses, a canonical set of topics emerged: interacting fields, Feynman diagrams, quantum electrodynamics, and radiative corrections. We provide comparisons to the undergraduate quantum curriculum, as well as recommendations to instructors and programs.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 22 (2)
Unique support from identity-based groups: Professional networks of women and LGBTQ+ physicists analyzed and compared by career sector
This paper presents a social network analysis of the professional support networks of 100 LGBTQ+ and/or women Ph.D. physicists, comparing the networks based on the career sectors of academia, industry, and government/nonprofit. The methods for constructing and analyzing the ego networks, which are novel in many ways, are explained in greater detail in an earlier publication (C. Hatcher ). We describe the networks of the whole group and use statistical tests of independence to explore differences between sectors in terms of whole network metrics, network composition based on alter (network member) characteristics, and support. We find that alters associated with groups (like affinity groups and personal and professional interest groups) are more likely to provide identity-based and community-building support, participants in academia have fewer personal friends in their networks, while those in industry have more; participants in government report less instrumental support, and those in academia report less material support. These results and others lead to suggestions for employers in these sectors on how to better support these physicists, including continuing to promote participation in affinity and interest groups, providing more material support and/or personal time in the academic sector, and more instrumental support in the form of professional development or training in the government sector.
- 17 June 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 22 (2)
Open AccessUnique support from identity-based groups: Professional networks of women and LGBTQ+ physicists analyzed and compared by career sector
This paper presents a social network analysis of the professional support networks of 100 LGBTQ+ and/or women Ph.D. physicists, comparing the networks based on the career sectors of academia, industry, and government/nonprofit. The methods for constructing and analyzing the ego networks, which are novel in many ways, are explained in greater detail in an earlier publication (C. Hatcher ). We describe the networks of the whole group and use statistical tests of independence to explore differences between sectors in terms of whole network metrics, network composition based on alter (network member) characteristics, and support. We find that alters associated with groups (like affinity groups and personal and professional interest groups) are more likely to provide identity-based and community-building support, participants in academia have fewer personal friends in their networks, while those in industry have more; participants in government report less instrumental support, and those in academia report less material support. These results and others lead to suggestions for employers in these sectors on how to better support these physicists, including continuing to promote participation in affinity and interest groups, providing more material support and/or personal time in the academic sector, and more instrumental support in the form of professional development or training in the government sector.
- Open Access
- 19 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Survey of physics faculty insights on the US quantum curriculum and research need
Quantum mechanics forms the conceptual core of graduate physics training, yet little empirical work has examined how well coursework prepares students to conduct dissertation-level research. Using a national survey of 551 physics faculty across 194 US doctoral-granting institutions, we investigate faculty perspectives on which quantum topics are essential for research and whether coursework adequately prepared students for research. Participants rated the importance of 14 quantum concepts identified in prior curriculum studies and reported how frequently they apply these concepts in their own research. $\chi^2$ analyzes reveal faculty who have taught graduate quantum mechanics rate the majority of topics as essential compared with undergraduate-only instructors, indicating that research practice and conceptual instruction intersect primarily in graduate courses. 72\% of faculty report that students are not prepared for dissertation-level work after coursework alone. Qualitative analysis shows that faculty most often provide supplemental instruction in computation, mathematics, and authentic research practices--skills central to contemporary quantum research but rarely integrated systematically into the curriculum. These findings suggest that preparedness depends heavily on advisor-mediated apprenticeship, creating a hidden curriculum in which access to essential practices varies by research group. We argue that aligning coursework with research practice will require earlier integration of authentic computational and methodological reasoning, greater coherence between undergraduate and graduate instruction, and the identification of shared competencies that transcend subfield specialization.- 19 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessSurvey of physics faculty insights on the US quantum curriculum and research need
Quantum mechanics forms the conceptual core of graduate physics training, yet little empirical work has examined how well coursework prepares students to conduct dissertation-level research. Using a national survey of 551 physics faculty across 194 US doctoral-granting institutions, we investigate faculty perspectives on which quantum topics are essential for research and whether coursework adequately prepared students for research. Participants rated the importance of 14 quantum concepts identified in prior curriculum studies and reported how frequently they apply these concepts in their own research. $\chi^2$ analyzes reveal faculty who have taught graduate quantum mechanics rate the majority of topics as essential compared with undergraduate-only instructors, indicating that research practice and conceptual instruction intersect primarily in graduate courses. 72\% of faculty report that students are not prepared for dissertation-level work after coursework alone. Qualitative analysis shows that faculty most often provide supplemental instruction in computation, mathematics, and authentic research practices--skills central to contemporary quantum research but rarely integrated systematically into the curriculum. These findings suggest that preparedness depends heavily on advisor-mediated apprenticeship, creating a hidden curriculum in which access to essential practices varies by research group. We argue that aligning coursework with research practice will require earlier integration of authentic computational and methodological reasoning, greater coherence between undergraduate and graduate instruction, and the identification of shared competencies that transcend subfield specialization. - Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT)
- p. 112-117
Assessing a combined human coding and natural language processing method for qualitative analysis in physics education research
As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly integrated into education research, it is critical to assess the capabilities and limitations of such tools in complex disciplinary contexts. This study explores the effectiveness of natural language processing (NLP) for topic identification using the BERTopic package to analyze undergraduate quantum mechanics syllabi. By comparing AI-generated topics with human-coded themes from a corpus of syllabi from 50 US institutions, we find that while NLP reliably identifies broad and structural elements of syllabi (e.g., policies, textbook references), it is limited in its ability to capture the nuanced and context-dependent content typical of upper-level physics instruction. The AI-derived topics were often underrepresented and diverged from expert human interpretation, particularly in areas requiring deep disciplinary knowledge. Our findings support the use of NLP as a complementary tool for theme generation and cross-validation, but emphasize the continued necessity of expert human analysis for rigorous and meaningful educational research.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT)
- p. 112-117
Open AccessAssessing a combined human coding and natural language processing method for qualitative analysis in physics education research
As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly integrated into education research, it is critical to assess the capabilities and limitations of such tools in complex disciplinary contexts. This study explores the effectiveness of natural language processing (NLP) for topic identification using the BERTopic package to analyze undergraduate quantum mechanics syllabi. By comparing AI-generated topics with human-coded themes from a corpus of syllabi from 50 US institutions, we find that while NLP reliably identifies broad and structural elements of syllabi (e.g., policies, textbook references), it is limited in its ability to capture the nuanced and context-dependent content typical of upper-level physics instruction. The AI-derived topics were often underrepresented and diverged from expert human interpretation, particularly in areas requiring deep disciplinary knowledge. Our findings support the use of NLP as a complementary tool for theme generation and cross-validation, but emphasize the continued necessity of expert human analysis for rigorous and meaningful educational research.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (2)
Egocentric mixed-methods social network analysis: Analyzing interviews with women and/or queer Ph.D. physicists
Social network analysis (SNA) has been widely used in physics education research (PER) in recent years, but mostly in a limited range of the available modalities. This paper describes a unique approach to egocentric, mixed-methods SNA applied to qualitative network data obtained from 100 interviews with women and/or queer professional physicists. We focus on our methods for obtaining quantitative network data from these qualitative sources and present novel techniques for the analysis of the networks. We also examine the ways in which egocentric and mixed-methods SNA techniques are aligned with critical methods and well suited to the study of difference, non-normativity, and experiences of marginalization in physics spaces and communities. We explore the limitations and potential applications of these methods and situate this work in the larger context of our study of these interviews. This work bridges a methodological gap between SNA and qualitative work on identity in PER and begins to develop our understanding of the way gender and sexual minority physicists experience support.
- 29 September 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (2)
Open AccessEgocentric mixed-methods social network analysis: Analyzing interviews with women and/or queer Ph.D. physicists
Social network analysis (SNA) has been widely used in physics education research (PER) in recent years, but mostly in a limited range of the available modalities. This paper describes a unique approach to egocentric, mixed-methods SNA applied to qualitative network data obtained from 100 interviews with women and/or queer professional physicists. We focus on our methods for obtaining quantitative network data from these qualitative sources and present novel techniques for the analysis of the networks. We also examine the ways in which egocentric and mixed-methods SNA techniques are aligned with critical methods and well suited to the study of difference, non-normativity, and experiences of marginalization in physics spaces and communities. We explore the limitations and potential applications of these methods and situate this work in the larger context of our study of these interviews. This work bridges a methodological gap between SNA and qualitative work on identity in PER and begins to develop our understanding of the way gender and sexual minority physicists experience support.
- Open Access
- 12 May 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Graduate program reform in one department of physics and astronomy: A case study of students’ experiences with early new policy
In 2017, the University of Utah experienced a tragedy that accelerated already proposed changes to the physics and astronomy graduate program. This article outlines the changes made to the graduate program and discusses students’ experiences with the early implementation of the new policies. In-depth, open-ended interviews were conducted with students over 2 years to understand their experiences under or with the new graduate program. Findings suggest that student interviews and direct recruitment aided in students’ decisions to attend a graduate program, and a weeklong orientation helped build community among the cohorts. A centralized Advising Day, dictated by the department, facilitated enrolled students meeting with department members to ensure they were on track in their program and taking courses geared toward research interests favored by students. Findings suggest that qualifying or comprehensive exams need more instruction and study materials, and that students still face issues of financial insecurities, healthcare concerns, and sexism that need addressing. Further research should examine how these reforms have impacted students at the end of their time in the program. Content Warning: This paper discusses the death by suicide of a graduate student.
- 12 May 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Open AccessGraduate program reform in one department of physics and astronomy: A case study of students’ experiences with early new policy
In 2017, the University of Utah experienced a tragedy that accelerated already proposed changes to the physics and astronomy graduate program. This article outlines the changes made to the graduate program and discusses students’ experiences with the early implementation of the new policies. In-depth, open-ended interviews were conducted with students over 2 years to understand their experiences under or with the new graduate program. Findings suggest that student interviews and direct recruitment aided in students’ decisions to attend a graduate program, and a weeklong orientation helped build community among the cohorts. A centralized Advising Day, dictated by the department, facilitated enrolled students meeting with department members to ensure they were on track in their program and taking courses geared toward research interests favored by students. Findings suggest that qualifying or comprehensive exams need more instruction and study materials, and that students still face issues of financial insecurities, healthcare concerns, and sexism that need addressing. Further research should examine how these reforms have impacted students at the end of their time in the program. Content Warning: This paper discusses the death by suicide of a graduate student.
- Open Access
- 17 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Modern physics courses: Understanding the content taught in the U.S.
[This paper is part of the Focused Collection in Investigating and Improving Quantum Education through Research.] The modern physics course is a crucial gateway for physics majors as it provides an introduction to concepts beyond the scope of the K-12 education. This study collected 167 modern physics syllabi from 127 U.S. research-intensive institutions using publicly available syllabi (51.5%) and private correspondence (48.5%). Due to the size of the corpus being large enough for natural language processing (NLP) to provide significant insight into the curricular content of a course, but still being small enough for human analysis to remain feasible, both NLP and human-analysis methods were utilized. The use of both methods provided a way to test the newly introduced method of NLP in physics education research and offered a novel tool for cross-validation. Public course catalogs were consulted to identify prerequisites and corequisites with 89.3% of students having completed a course in calculus II or higher. Foundational topics like Newtonian mechanics (94%), electricity and magnetism (84.4%), and waves or optics (77.2%) were frequently required. Most institutions consistently taught quantum physics (94%), atomic physics (83%), and relativity (70%), but there was variability in the inclusion of other topics alongside these three main topics. The study highlights the current modern physics curricula at U.S. research-intensive institutions, emphasizing the importance of a consistent and comprehensive education for physics majors across universities. This insight contributes to the ongoing discourse on optimizing physics education in higher education.
- 17 April 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Open AccessModern physics courses: Understanding the content taught in the U.S.
[This paper is part of the Focused Collection in Investigating and Improving Quantum Education through Research.] The modern physics course is a crucial gateway for physics majors as it provides an introduction to concepts beyond the scope of the K-12 education. This study collected 167 modern physics syllabi from 127 U.S. research-intensive institutions using publicly available syllabi (51.5%) and private correspondence (48.5%). Due to the size of the corpus being large enough for natural language processing (NLP) to provide significant insight into the curricular content of a course, but still being small enough for human analysis to remain feasible, both NLP and human-analysis methods were utilized. The use of both methods provided a way to test the newly introduced method of NLP in physics education research and offered a novel tool for cross-validation. Public course catalogs were consulted to identify prerequisites and corequisites with 89.3% of students having completed a course in calculus II or higher. Foundational topics like Newtonian mechanics (94%), electricity and magnetism (84.4%), and waves or optics (77.2%) were frequently required. Most institutions consistently taught quantum physics (94%), atomic physics (83%), and relativity (70%), but there was variability in the inclusion of other topics alongside these three main topics. The study highlights the current modern physics curricula at U.S. research-intensive institutions, emphasizing the importance of a consistent and comprehensive education for physics majors across universities. This insight contributes to the ongoing discourse on optimizing physics education in higher education.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 16 January 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Quantum mechanics curriculum in the U.S.: Quantifying the instructional time, content taught, and paradigms used
[This paper is part of the Focused Collection in Investigating and Improving Quantum Education through Research.] Quantum mechanics is an integral course for physics students. An understanding of quantum concepts is imperative for enrollment in physics graduate programs, participating in research within physics fields, and employment with companies developing quantum technologies. This study analyzes 188 U.S. research-intensive institutions’ course catalogs to determine the role and extent of quantum mechanics in their undergraduate physics programs. All of the institutions required one course on quantum concepts, 92% required two courses, and half required three. Among institutions with complete class data ( n = 56 ), the quantum curriculum was analyzed using course syllabi. The mean number of classroom hours spent on quantum concepts was 63.5 h with a standard deviation of 28.1 h. The most commonly taught themes in the quantum curriculum were the equation and three-dimensional quantum mechanics. However, the Stern-Gerlach experiment was only included in 28% of the course outlines. Despite current efforts to promote a spin-first approach, this study found the traditional position-first approaches were still more common as they were used by 73.7% of instructors.
- 16 January 2025
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 21 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessQuantum mechanics curriculum in the U.S.: Quantifying the instructional time, content taught, and paradigms used
[This paper is part of the Focused Collection in Investigating and Improving Quantum Education through Research.] Quantum mechanics is an integral course for physics students. An understanding of quantum concepts is imperative for enrollment in physics graduate programs, participating in research within physics fields, and employment with companies developing quantum technologies. This study analyzes 188 U.S. research-intensive institutions’ course catalogs to determine the role and extent of quantum mechanics in their undergraduate physics programs. All of the institutions required one course on quantum concepts, 92% required two courses, and half required three. Among institutions with complete class data ( n = 56 ), the quantum curriculum was analyzed using course syllabi. The mean number of classroom hours spent on quantum concepts was 63.5 h with a standard deviation of 28.1 h. The most commonly taught themes in the quantum curriculum were the equation and three-dimensional quantum mechanics. However, the Stern-Gerlach experiment was only included in 28% of the course outlines. Despite current efforts to promote a spin-first approach, this study found the traditional position-first approaches were still more common as they were used by 73.7% of instructors.
- Open Access
- 5 January 2025
- Published by STAR Scholars Network in Journal of International Students
- Vol. 15 (1) , 189-214
The impact of politics and COVID-19 on graduate STEM international students of color
Political factors and the COVID-19 pandemic have had profound impacts on international students in the U.S. These factors include anti-immigration rhetoric, the policies of the executive branch, and the additional COVID-19 restrictions placed on international students in 2020. In this study, we interviewed international students in graduate STEM programs and asked them about their political opinions and experiences during the pandemic. This article also provides a brief historical overview of immigration policy and how these policies relate to and impact international students. Many of our participants expressed negative emotions regarding President Trump for reasons ranging from his racist rhetoric to his administration’s policies before and during the pandemic.
- 5 January 2025
- Published by STAR Scholars Network in Journal of International Students
- Vol. 15 (1) , 189-214
Open AccessThe impact of politics and COVID-19 on graduate STEM international students of color
Political factors and the COVID-19 pandemic have had profound impacts on international students in the U.S. These factors include anti-immigration rhetoric, the policies of the executive branch, and the additional COVID-19 restrictions placed on international students in 2020. In this study, we interviewed international students in graduate STEM programs and asked them about their political opinions and experiences during the pandemic. This article also provides a brief historical overview of immigration policy and how these policies relate to and impact international students. Many of our participants expressed negative emotions regarding President Trump for reasons ranging from his racist rhetoric to his administration’s policies before and during the pandemic.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2024
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 20 (2)
Person-centered and qualitative approaches to network analysis in physics education research
Network analysis has become a well-recognized methodology in physics education research (PER), with study topics including student performance and persistence, faculty change, and the structure of conceptual networks. The social network analysis side of this work has focused on quantitative analysis of whole-network cases, such as the structure of networks in single classrooms. Egocentric or personal network approaches are largely unexplored, and qualitative methods are underdeveloped. In this paper, we outline theoretical and practical differences between two major network paradigms—whole-network and egocentric—and introduce theoretical frameworks and methodological considerations for egocentric studies. We also describe qualitative and mixed-methods approaches that are currently missing from the PER literature. We identify areas where these additional network methods may be of particular interest to physics education researchers and end by discussing example cases and implications for new PER studies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
- 21 October 2024
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 20 (2)
Open AccessPerson-centered and qualitative approaches to network analysis in physics education research
Network analysis has become a well-recognized methodology in physics education research (PER), with study topics including student performance and persistence, faculty change, and the structure of conceptual networks. The social network analysis side of this work has focused on quantitative analysis of whole-network cases, such as the structure of networks in single classrooms. Egocentric or personal network approaches are largely unexplored, and qualitative methods are underdeveloped. In this paper, we outline theoretical and practical differences between two major network paradigms—whole-network and egocentric—and introduce theoretical frameworks and methodological considerations for egocentric studies. We also describe qualitative and mixed-methods approaches that are currently missing from the PER literature. We identify areas where these additional network methods may be of particular interest to physics education researchers and end by discussing example cases and implications for new PER studies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024