Field M. Watts
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Field M. Watts has a total of 47 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ginger V. Shultz
Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, USA
16 shared publications - Solaire A. Finkenstaedt-Quinn
Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, USA
8 shared publications - Amber J. Dood
Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, United States
6 shared publications - Jon-Marc G. Rodriguez
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Wisconsin − Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53211, United States
6 shared publications Michael N. Petterson
Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, USA
4 shared publicationsEmma P. Snyder-White
Department of Chemistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, United States
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 876
Connecting Calculus to Computing Education A Conceptual Mapping Tool to Support Disciplinary Applications
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 876
Open AccessConnecting Calculus to Computing Education A Conceptual Mapping Tool to Support Disciplinary Applications
- 27 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 507-515
AI Evaluation and Feedback to Support Middle-School Students’ Scientific Argumentation and Reasoning
- 27 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 507-515
AI Evaluation and Feedback to Support Middle-School Students’ Scientific Argumentation and Reasoning
- Open Access
- 8 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (11) , 1507
A Framework for Designing an AI Chatbot to Support Scientific Argumentation
As large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to support learning, there is a growing need for a principled framework to guide the design of LLM-based tools and resources that are pedagogically effective and contextually responsive. This study proposes a framework by examining how prompt engineering can enhance the quality of chatbot responses to support middle school students’ scientific reasoning and argumentation. Drawing on learning theories and established frameworks for scientific argumentation, we employed a design-based research approach to iteratively refine system prompts and evaluate LLM-generated responses across diverse student input scenarios. Our analysis highlights how different prompt configurations affect the relevance and explanatory depth of chatbot feedback. We report findings from the iterative refinement process, along with an analysis of the quality of responses generated by each version of the chatbot. The outcomes indicate how different prompt configurations influence the coherence, relevance, and explanatory processes of LLM responses. The study contributes a set of critical design principles for developing theory-aligned prompts that enable LLM-based chatbots to meaningfully support students in constructing and revising scientific arguments. These principles offer broader implications for designing LLM applications across varied educational domains.
- 8 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (11) , 1507
Open AccessA Framework for Designing an AI Chatbot to Support Scientific Argumentation
As large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to support learning, there is a growing need for a principled framework to guide the design of LLM-based tools and resources that are pedagogically effective and contextually responsive. This study proposes a framework by examining how prompt engineering can enhance the quality of chatbot responses to support middle school students’ scientific reasoning and argumentation. Drawing on learning theories and established frameworks for scientific argumentation, we employed a design-based research approach to iteratively refine system prompts and evaluate LLM-generated responses across diverse student input scenarios. Our analysis highlights how different prompt configurations affect the relevance and explanatory depth of chatbot feedback. We report findings from the iterative refinement process, along with an analysis of the quality of responses generated by each version of the chatbot. The outcomes indicate how different prompt configurations influence the coherence, relevance, and explanatory processes of LLM responses. The study contributes a set of critical design principles for developing theory-aligned prompts that enable LLM-based chatbots to meaningfully support students in constructing and revising scientific arguments. These principles offer broader implications for designing LLM applications across varied educational domains.
- 25 April 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (3) , 578-593
A review of research on the teaching and learning of quantum mechanics
In this work, we review research on the teaching and learning of quantum mechanics in chemistry courses. This systematic review builds on previous reviews in chemistry education research that focused on the other highly quantitative, calculation-heavy topics covered in upper-level physical chemistry courses (kinetics and thermodynamics). We aim to provide a resource for both practitioners and education researchers. Based on the topics of the research conducted in our sample ( N = 50), we grouped the articles into six categories: (1) students’ general challenges with quantum mechanics; (2) students’ conceptions of the atom; (3) students’ conceptions of bonding; (4) students’ conceptions of the quantum nature of light; (5) students’ conceptions of commonly used quantum mechanical models; (6) curricular materials and instruction. Relevant trends stemming from this work include that much of the research leans on education research in mathematics and physics to support the claim that students have difficulties with mathematics; however, these claims require further investigation within chemistry education contexts. Moreover, a suprising amount of research on quantum mechanics involved students sampled outside of upper-level chemistry courses ( i.e. , secondary-level and general chemistry contexts).
- 25 April 2025
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (3) , 578-593
A review of research on the teaching and learning of quantum mechanics
In this work, we review research on the teaching and learning of quantum mechanics in chemistry courses. This systematic review builds on previous reviews in chemistry education research that focused on the other highly quantitative, calculation-heavy topics covered in upper-level physical chemistry courses (kinetics and thermodynamics). We aim to provide a resource for both practitioners and education researchers. Based on the topics of the research conducted in our sample ( N = 50), we grouped the articles into six categories: (1) students’ general challenges with quantum mechanics; (2) students’ conceptions of the atom; (3) students’ conceptions of bonding; (4) students’ conceptions of the quantum nature of light; (5) students’ conceptions of commonly used quantum mechanical models; (6) curricular materials and instruction. Relevant trends stemming from this work include that much of the research leans on education research in mathematics and physics to support the claim that students have difficulties with mathematics; however, these claims require further investigation within chemistry education contexts. Moreover, a suprising amount of research on quantum mechanics involved students sampled outside of upper-level chemistry courses ( i.e. , secondary-level and general chemistry contexts).
- 14 August 2024
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (1) , 112-125
“That's not a super important point”: second-semester organic chemistry students’ lines of reasoning when comparing substitution reactions
Solving organic chemistry reactions requires reasoning with multiple concepts and data (i.e., multivariate reasoning). However, studies have reported that organic chemistry students typically demonstrate univariate reasoning. Case comparisons, where students compare two or more tasks, have been reported to support students’ multivariate reasoning. Using a case-comparison task, we explored students’ multivariate reasoning. Our study was guided by the resources framework. One conceptual resource activates another conceptual resource and, successively, a set of conceptual resources. This successively activated set of resources is expressed in a line of reasoning. Pairing this framework with qualitative methods, we interviewed eleven second-semester organic chemistry students while they compared two substitution reaction mechanisms and chose the mechanism with the lower activation energy. We analysed what conceptual resources and lines of reasoning were activated and the variation to which students engaged in multivariate reasoning. Students activated multiple conceptual resources and, moreover, extended their activated resources into both developed and undeveloped lines of reasoning. When constructing their explanations, most students engaged in univariate reasoning. These students provided a developed line of reasoning selected from multiple activated resources, or they provided an undeveloped line of reasoning constructed from only one activated resource. Few students engaged in multivariate reasoning. These students provided both developed and undeveloped lines of reasoning from multiple activated resources. Our findings highlight the variation with which students engage in both univariate and multivariate reasoning. Therefore, we recommend that case-comparison activities scaffold engagement with multiple lines of reasoning in addition to activating and developing them.
- 14 August 2024
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (1) , 112-125
“That's not a super important point”: second-semester organic chemistry students’ lines of reasoning when comparing substitution reactions
Solving organic chemistry reactions requires reasoning with multiple concepts and data (i.e., multivariate reasoning). However, studies have reported that organic chemistry students typically demonstrate univariate reasoning. Case comparisons, where students compare two or more tasks, have been reported to support students’ multivariate reasoning. Using a case-comparison task, we explored students’ multivariate reasoning. Our study was guided by the resources framework. One conceptual resource activates another conceptual resource and, successively, a set of conceptual resources. This successively activated set of resources is expressed in a line of reasoning. Pairing this framework with qualitative methods, we interviewed eleven second-semester organic chemistry students while they compared two substitution reaction mechanisms and chose the mechanism with the lower activation energy. We analysed what conceptual resources and lines of reasoning were activated and the variation to which students engaged in multivariate reasoning. Students activated multiple conceptual resources and, moreover, extended their activated resources into both developed and undeveloped lines of reasoning. When constructing their explanations, most students engaged in univariate reasoning. These students provided a developed line of reasoning selected from multiple activated resources, or they provided an undeveloped line of reasoning constructed from only one activated resource. Few students engaged in multivariate reasoning. These students provided both developed and undeveloped lines of reasoning from multiple activated resources. Our findings highlight the variation with which students engage in both univariate and multivariate reasoning. Therefore, we recommend that case-comparison activities scaffold engagement with multiple lines of reasoning in addition to activating and developing them.
- 5 June 2024
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Education
- Vol. 101 (7) , 2602-2607
Self-Reported Limitations in Chemistry Education Research: Providing Specific and Contextualized Limitations Supports Researchers and Practitioners
- 5 June 2024
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Education
- Vol. 101 (7) , 2602-2607
Self-Reported Limitations in Chemistry Education Research: Providing Specific and Contextualized Limitations Supports Researchers and Practitioners
- Open Access
- 30 April 2024
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in JACS Au
- Vol. 4 (5) , 2029-2040
Using Hypothetical Scenarios to Address Social Desirability Bias: Investigating Student Perceptions, Evaluations, and Motivations of Cheating and Academic Integrity in the General Chemistry Laboratory
Supporting students with upholding the principles of academic integrity is an important aspect of teaching. Academic integrity is especially important in chemistry laboratory classrooms, where students gain hands-on experience related to research and scientific practices. Prior literature on academic integrity largely focuses on catching and preventing cheating, describing various factors commonly associated with cheating behaviors. This body of literature assumes that students neutralize their feelings about cheating to engage in unethical behavior. In contrast, for this study, we began with the assumption that students intend to act ethically; to this end, we sought to investigate students' perceptions, evaluations, and motivations related to cheating and academic integrity. We interviewed 24 students enrolled in general chemistry laboratories and asked questions related to cheating and academic integrity. Additionally, to address concerns about social desirability bias affecting students' responses, we asked students questions involving hypothetical scenarios related to academic integrity that were contextualized within the chemistry laboratory classroom. In our analysis, we found that students held common views about cheating and academic integrity in general but diverged in their responses to the hypothetical scenarios. Our findings suggest the importance of providing clearer, more direct instruction regarding what counts as cheating and how to engage in academically honest behavior within the chemistry laboratory classroom.
- 30 April 2024
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in JACS Au
- Vol. 4 (5) , 2029-2040
Open AccessUsing Hypothetical Scenarios to Address Social Desirability Bias: Investigating Student Perceptions, Evaluations, and Motivations of Cheating and Academic Integrity in the General Chemistry Laboratory
Supporting students with upholding the principles of academic integrity is an important aspect of teaching. Academic integrity is especially important in chemistry laboratory classrooms, where students gain hands-on experience related to research and scientific practices. Prior literature on academic integrity largely focuses on catching and preventing cheating, describing various factors commonly associated with cheating behaviors. This body of literature assumes that students neutralize their feelings about cheating to engage in unethical behavior. In contrast, for this study, we began with the assumption that students intend to act ethically; to this end, we sought to investigate students' perceptions, evaluations, and motivations related to cheating and academic integrity. We interviewed 24 students enrolled in general chemistry laboratories and asked questions related to cheating and academic integrity. Additionally, to address concerns about social desirability bias affecting students' responses, we asked students questions involving hypothetical scenarios related to academic integrity that were contextualized within the chemistry laboratory classroom. In our analysis, we found that students held common views about cheating and academic integrity in general but diverged in their responses to the hypothetical scenarios. Our findings suggest the importance of providing clearer, more direct instruction regarding what counts as cheating and how to engage in academically honest behavior within the chemistry laboratory classroom.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 25 (3) , 742-759
Analysis of organic chemistry students’ developing reasoning elicited by a scaffolded case comparison activity
Recent efforts in organic chemistry education research focus on investigating activities and strategies designed to elicit students’ mechanistic reasoning. This study investigates how a scaffolded case comparison activity implemented in an introductory organic chemistry course elicits and supports students’ mechanistic reasoning in an authentic classroom setting. The activity included an adaptation of a previously reported reasoning scaffold to support small-group student discussions comparing organic reactions. We analyzed students’ written responses to the in-class activity using Hammer's resources framework and Toulmin's argumentation model, interwoven to create an anti-deficit approach to exploring students’ developing reasoning. The analysis of students’ written artifacts sought to identify ways in which a scaffolded case comparison implemented in a collaborative class setting may support students’ engagement in complex reasoning and argumentation development. We found that the in-class activity elicited students’ writing about various aspects of mechanistic reasoning, including identifying explicit and implicit properties, dynamic reasoning, and multivariate reasoning. These findings indicate that the activity can engage students in complex mechanistic reasoning aspects in the classroom setting. Furthermore, this study extends the literature by detailing the nuances of students’ developing causal reasoning with energetic and electrostatic accounts as shown in their writing. The results highlight students’ emerging causal reasoning with varying levels of complexity and conceptual integration. This study provides direct implications for instructors seeking to implement similar classroom activities. The findings indicate directions for future research on the development of instructional activities and tools that further support students’ developing causal reasoning, such as adapting existing scaffolding structures to support argumentation development and the integration of challenging concepts such as energetics.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 25 (3) , 742-759
Analysis of organic chemistry students’ developing reasoning elicited by a scaffolded case comparison activity
Recent efforts in organic chemistry education research focus on investigating activities and strategies designed to elicit students’ mechanistic reasoning. This study investigates how a scaffolded case comparison activity implemented in an introductory organic chemistry course elicits and supports students’ mechanistic reasoning in an authentic classroom setting. The activity included an adaptation of a previously reported reasoning scaffold to support small-group student discussions comparing organic reactions. We analyzed students’ written responses to the in-class activity using Hammer's resources framework and Toulmin's argumentation model, interwoven to create an anti-deficit approach to exploring students’ developing reasoning. The analysis of students’ written artifacts sought to identify ways in which a scaffolded case comparison implemented in a collaborative class setting may support students’ engagement in complex reasoning and argumentation development. We found that the in-class activity elicited students’ writing about various aspects of mechanistic reasoning, including identifying explicit and implicit properties, dynamic reasoning, and multivariate reasoning. These findings indicate that the activity can engage students in complex mechanistic reasoning aspects in the classroom setting. Furthermore, this study extends the literature by detailing the nuances of students’ developing causal reasoning with energetic and electrostatic accounts as shown in their writing. The results highlight students’ emerging causal reasoning with varying levels of complexity and conceptual integration. This study provides direct implications for instructors seeking to implement similar classroom activities. The findings indicate directions for future research on the development of instructional activities and tools that further support students’ developing causal reasoning, such as adapting existing scaffolding structures to support argumentation development and the integration of challenging concepts such as energetics.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 25 (3) , 721-741
Examining the role of assignment design and peer review on student responses and revisions to an organic chemistry writing-to-learn assignment
Research on student learning in organic chemistry indicates that students tend to focus on surface level features of molecules with less consideration of implicit properties when engaging in mechanistic reasoning. Writing-to-learn (WTL) is one approach for supporting students’ mechanistic reasoning. A variation of WTL incorporates peer review and revision to provide opportunities for students to interact with and learn from their peers, as well as revisit and reflect on their own knowledge and reasoning. However, research indicates that the rhetorical features included in WTL assignments may influence the language students use in their responses. This study utilizes machine learning to characterize the mechanistic features present in second-semester undergraduate organic chemistry students’ responses to two versions of a WTL assignment with different rhetorical features. Furthermore, we examine the role of peer review on the mechanistic reasoning captured in students’ revised drafts. Our analysis indicates that students include both surface level and implicit features of mechanistic reasoning in their drafts and in the feedback to their peers, with slight differences depending on the rhetorical features present in the assignment. However, students’ revisions appeared to be primarily connected to the peer review process via the presence of surface features in the drafts students read (as opposed to the feedback received). These findings indicate that further scaffolding focused on how to utilize information gained from the peer review process ( i.e. , both feedback received and drafts read) and emphasizing implicit properties could help support the utility of WTL for developing students’ mechanistic reasoning in organic chemistry.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 25 (3) , 721-741
Examining the role of assignment design and peer review on student responses and revisions to an organic chemistry writing-to-learn assignment
Research on student learning in organic chemistry indicates that students tend to focus on surface level features of molecules with less consideration of implicit properties when engaging in mechanistic reasoning. Writing-to-learn (WTL) is one approach for supporting students’ mechanistic reasoning. A variation of WTL incorporates peer review and revision to provide opportunities for students to interact with and learn from their peers, as well as revisit and reflect on their own knowledge and reasoning. However, research indicates that the rhetorical features included in WTL assignments may influence the language students use in their responses. This study utilizes machine learning to characterize the mechanistic features present in second-semester undergraduate organic chemistry students’ responses to two versions of a WTL assignment with different rhetorical features. Furthermore, we examine the role of peer review on the mechanistic reasoning captured in students’ revised drafts. Our analysis indicates that students include both surface level and implicit features of mechanistic reasoning in their drafts and in the feedback to their peers, with slight differences depending on the rhetorical features present in the assignment. However, students’ revisions appeared to be primarily connected to the peer review process via the presence of surface features in the drafts students read (as opposed to the feedback received). These findings indicate that further scaffolding focused on how to utilize information gained from the peer review process ( i.e. , both feedback received and drafts read) and emphasizing implicit properties could help support the utility of WTL for developing students’ mechanistic reasoning in organic chemistry.
- 15 February 2024
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Education
- Vol. 101 (3) , 807-818
Automated Text Analysis of Organic Chemistry Students’ Written Hypotheses
Generating a testable hypothesis is a necessary skill for engaging in science, requiring both general reasoning skills and specific content knowledge of the phenomenon being investigated. While many students have the reasoning skills necessary for developing testable hypotheses in a general science context, it can be challenging for students to apply these skills to content areas where the phenomena being studied are unobservable, such as problems in organic chemistry. Generating hypotheses for experiments is a skill that students are expected to apply in chemistry teaching laboratories. Students can benefit from receiving real-time feedback to support developing this ability. However, providing feedback on writing can be challenging for instructors, especially in large-enrollment courses. For this study, we explored and compared the performance of several machine learning algorithms to classify organic chemistry students’ written hypotheses for a science-general scenario and an organic chemistry-specific scenario. These models were trained to analyze students’ written hypotheses for the presence of five features: (1) a testable prediction in a given situation; (2) a predicted change in the independent variable that is related to the dependent variable; (3) scientific content addressing the research question provided in the prompt; (4) a correct and completely defined independent variable; and (5) a correct and completely defined dependent variable. This work has implications for guiding future research on the feasibility of providing instructors with information about students’ hypothesis-generating abilities that can support the delivery of real-time feedback.
- 15 February 2024
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Education
- Vol. 101 (3) , 807-818
Automated Text Analysis of Organic Chemistry Students’ Written Hypotheses
Generating a testable hypothesis is a necessary skill for engaging in science, requiring both general reasoning skills and specific content knowledge of the phenomenon being investigated. While many students have the reasoning skills necessary for developing testable hypotheses in a general science context, it can be challenging for students to apply these skills to content areas where the phenomena being studied are unobservable, such as problems in organic chemistry. Generating hypotheses for experiments is a skill that students are expected to apply in chemistry teaching laboratories. Students can benefit from receiving real-time feedback to support developing this ability. However, providing feedback on writing can be challenging for instructors, especially in large-enrollment courses. For this study, we explored and compared the performance of several machine learning algorithms to classify organic chemistry students’ written hypotheses for a science-general scenario and an organic chemistry-specific scenario. These models were trained to analyze students’ written hypotheses for the presence of five features: (1) a testable prediction in a given situation; (2) a predicted change in the independent variable that is related to the dependent variable; (3) scientific content addressing the research question provided in the prompt; (4) a correct and completely defined independent variable; and (5) a correct and completely defined dependent variable. This work has implications for guiding future research on the feasibility of providing instructors with information about students’ hypothesis-generating abilities that can support the delivery of real-time feedback.