ABAntony Butcher

Antony Butcher

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Antony Butcher has a total of 31 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Evaluating the performance of distributed acoustic sensing for crosswell seismic imaging of abandoned mine geothermal systems

    by Joanna M. Holmgren, Antony Butcher, Maximilian J. Werner, Sacha Lapins, Jonathan Chambers, J-Michael Kendall, Germán Rodríguez, James Verdon, Vanessa Starcher

    We explore the performance of distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) for crosswell seismic imaging at a shallow geothermal project in an abandoned mine. The UK Geoenergy Observatory (UKGEOS) research facility in Glasgow has repurposed an abandoned coal mine below the city with the goal to investigate the heat storage and heat recovery potential of flooded mines. Originally for distributed temperature sensing purposes, UKGEOS installed fiber-optic cables in boreholes less than 100 m deep passing through the mined coal seams now targeted for heat production. We first conduct a crosswell active-source seismic survey prior to heat pump installation to obtain a baseline velocity structure of the coal seams and surrounding lithologies. We acquire data simultaneously with DAS and a colocated hydrophone array to facilitate a comparison with conventional crosswell methods. We find that the noise levels are significantly higher for DAS, making first arrivals discernible only within a 30 m vertical offset between shot and channel depths, which limits the DAS monitoring depth range along the borehole. However, the DAS coda provides much greater spatial resolution that can capture refracted arrivals, allowing for accurate and precise identification of discrete layers. Future repeated surveys with DAS can thus shed important light on any changes within the seismic velocity structure between the boreholes, indicating potential changes in fracture zones and fluid pathways. Just as repurposing abandoned coal mines for geothermal energy has been shown to be a promising alterative geoenergy source, DAS could be an inexpensive and simpler alternative to drilling monitoring wells and deploying conventional seismic arrays.


  • Distributed acoustic sensing, transfer functions, and moment magnitude determination: Application to high-frequency downhole data

    by Boris Boullenger, Antony Butcher, Bob Paap, Vincent Vandeweijer, Anna L. Stork

    Distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) enables sampling seismic wavefields along optical fibers at a spatial resolution of less than 1 m, over distances beyond several tens of kilometers. This makes DAS a powerful tool to record seismic events densely along 2D directions, whether horizontally along the earth’s surface or vertically in boreholes. Compared with traditional seismic sensors measuring ground motion units, DAS provides uniaxial strain measurements along the fiber with often imperfectly known transfer functions between the measurements and true ground motion. This can generate uncertainties in the derivation of seismic source parameters, such as the magnitude, that require an absolute measurement of the ground motion and a known instrument response. In this study, we examine the DAS transfer function, mapping DAS data to reference velocity records obtained from multiple colocated accelerometers. Our investigation makes use of downhole recordings from the Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy field site situated in Utah, USA. Overall, we find that the DAS response estimated at different depth positions follows a consistent trend and deviates significantly from a flat response only below 80 Hz. An average site-specific DAS system response is then used to convert microseismic event recordings into calibrated velocity records with improved amplitude accuracies. Subsequently, moment magnitudes MW are derived from the P-wave records with results matching the independent accelerometer-based estimations with high fidelity for events with MW>−1.0.


  • Open Access

    Seismic Noise Interferometry and Distributed Acoustic Sensing (DAS): Inverting for the Firn Layer S‐Velocity Structure on Rutford Ice Stream, Antarctica

    by Wen Zhou, Antony Butcher, Alex M. Brisbourne, Sofia‐Katerina Kufner, J‐Michael Kendall, Anna L. Stork

    Firn densification profiles are an important parameter for ice‐sheet mass balance and palaeoclimate studies. One conventional method of investigating firn profiles is using seismic refraction surveys, but these are difficult to upscale to large‐area measurements. Distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) presents an opportunity for large‐scale seismic measurements of firn with dense spatial sampling and easy deployment, especially when seismic noise is used. We study the feasibility of seismic noise interferometry (SI) on DAS data for characterizing the firn layer at the Rutford Ice Stream, West Antarctica. Dominant seismic energy appears to come from anthropogenic noise and shear‐margin crevasses. The DAS cross‐correlation interferometry yields noisy Rayleigh wave signals. To overcome this, we present two strategies for cross‐correlations: (a) hybrid instruments—correlating a geophone with DAS, and (b) stacking of selected cross‐correlation panels picked in the tau‐p domain. These approaches are validated with results derived from an active survey. Using the retrieved Rayleigh wave dispersion curve, we inverted for a high‐resolution 1D S‐wave velocity profile down to a depth of 100 m. The profile shows a “kink” (velocity gradient inflection) at ∼12 m depth, resulting from a change of compaction mechanism. A triangular DAS array is used to investigate directional variation in velocity, which shows no evident variations thus suggesting a lack of azimuthal anisotropy in the firn. Our results demonstrate the potential of using DAS and SI to image the near‐surface and present a new approach to derive S‐velocity profiles from surface wave inversion in firn studies.


  • Open Access

    Seismic noise interferometry and Distributed Acoustic Sensing (DAS): measuring the firn layer S-velocity structure on Rutford Ice Stream, Antarctica

    by Wen Zhou, Antony Butcher, Alex Mark Brisbourne, Sofia-Katerina Kufner, John-Michael Kendall, Anna Stork

    Firn densification profiles are an important parameter for ice-sheet mass balance and palaeoclimate studies. One conventional method of investigating firn profiles is using seismic refraction surveys, but these are limited to point measurements. Distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) presents an opportunity for large-scale seismic measurements of firn with dense spatial sampling and easy deployment, especially when seismic noise is used. We study the feasibility of seismic noise interferometry on DAS data for characterizing the firn layer at the Rutford Ice Stream, West Antarctica. Dominant seismic energy appears to come from anthropogenic noise and shear-margin crevasses. The DAS cross-correlation interferometry yields a noisy Green’s function (Rayleigh waves). To overcome this, we present two strategies for cross-correlations: (1) hybrid instruments – correlating a geophone with DAS, and (2) selected stacking where the cross-correlation panels are picked in the tau-p domain. These approaches are validated with results derived from an active survey. Using the retrieved Rayleigh wave dispersion curve, we inverted for a high-resolution 1D S-wave velocity profile down to a depth of 100 m. The inversion spontaneously retrieves a “kink” (velocity gradient inflection) at ~12 m depth, resulting from a change of compaction mechanism. A triangular DAS array is used to investigate directional variation in velocity, which shows no evident variations thus suggesting a lack of deformation in the firn. Our results demonstrate the potential of using DAS and seismic noise interferometry to image the near-surface and present a new approach to derive S-velocity profiles from surface wave inversion in firn studies.

  • Open Access

    Ambient Seismic Recordings and Distributed Acoustic Sensing (DAS): Imaging the firn layer on Rutford Ice Stream, Antarctica

    by Wen Zhou, Antony Butcher, Alex Mark Brisbourne, Sofia-Katerina Kufner, John-Michael Kendall, Anna Stork

    Distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) is a rapidly growing seismic technology, which provides near-continuous spatial sampling, low maintenance, long-term deployments, can exploit extensive cable networks already deployed in many environments. Here, we present a case study from the Rutford Ice Stream, Antarctica, showing how the ice-sheet firn layer can be imaged with DAS and seismic interferometry, exploiting noise from a power generator and fracturing at the ice stream margin. Conventional cross-correlation interferometry between DAS channels yields an unstable seismic response. Instead, we present two strategies to improve interferograms: (1) combining signals from conventional seismic instruments with DAS; (2) selective-stacking cross-correlation. These steps yield high-quality Rayleigh wave responses. We validate our approach with a dataset acquired using a sledgehammer-and-plate source, and show an excellent agreement between the dispersion curves. The passive results display a lower frequency content (~3Hz) than the active datasets (~10Hz). A 1D S-wave velocity profile is inverted for the top 100m of the glacier, which contains inflections as predicted by firn densification models. Using a triangular DAS array, we repeat the noise interferometry analysis and find no visible effect of seismic anisotropy in the uppermost 80 meters of our study site. Results presented here highlight the potential of DAS and surface wave inversions to complement conventional refraction surveys, which are often used for imaging firn layer, and the potential in near-surface imaging applications in general.

  • Open Access

    Evaluating rock mass disturbance within open-pit excavations using seismic methods: A case study from the Hinkley Point C nuclear power station

    by Antony Butcher, Anna L. Stork, James P. Verdon, J-Michael Kendall, Katrin Plenkers, Finlay Booth, Marcus Boneham, Adrian Koe


  • Open Access

    Distributed Acoustic Sensing (DAS) for natural microseismicity studies: A case study from Antarctica

    by Thomas Samuel Hudson, Alan F Baird, John-Michael Kendall, Sofia-Katerina Kufner, Alex Mark Brisbourne, Andrew Mark Smith, Antony Butcher, Athena Chalari, Andy Clarke

    Icequakes, microseismic earthquakes at glaciers, offer critical insights into the dynamics of ice sheets. For the first time in the Antarctic, we explore the use of fibre optic cables as Distributed Acoustic Sensors (DAS) as a new approach for monitoring basal icequakes. Fibre was deployed on the ice surface at Rutford Ice Stream, in two different configurations. We compare the performance of DAS with a conventional geophone network for: microseismic detection and location; resolving source and noise spectra; source mechanism inversion; and measuring anisotropic shear-wave splitting parameters. The DAS arrays detect fewer events than the geophone array. However, DAS is superior to geophones for recording the microseism signal, suggesting the applicability of DAS for ambient noise interferometry. We also present the first full-waveform source mechanism inversions using DAS anywhere, successfully constraining the horizontal stick-slip nature of the icequakes. In addition, we develop an approach to use a 2D DAS array geometry as an effective multi-component sensor capable of accurately characterising shear-wave splitting due to anisotropy of the ice fabric. Although our observations originate from a glacial environment, the methodology and implications of this work are relevant for employing DAS in other microseismic environments.


  • Seismic Magnitudes, Corner Frequencies, and Microseismicity: Using Ambient Noise to Correct for High-Frequency Attenuation

    by Antony Butcher, Richard Luckett, J.-Michael Kendall, Brian Baptie

    Over recent years, a greater importance has been attached to low‐magnitude events, with increasing use of the subsurface for industrial activities such as hydraulic fracturing and enhanced geothermal schemes. Magnitude distributions and earthquake source properties are critical inputs when managing the associated seismic risk of these activities, yet inconsistencies and discrepancies are commonly observed with microseismic activity (⁠ M<2⁠). This, in part, is due to their impulse response being controlled by the medium, as opposed to the source. Here, an approach for estimating the high‐frequency amplitude decay parameter from the spectral decay of ambient seismic noise (⁠ κ0_noise⁠) is developed. The estimate does not require a pre‐existing seismic catalog and is independent of the source properties, so avoids some of the main limitations of earthquake‐based methods. We then incorporate κ0_noise into the Brune (1970) source model and calculate source properties and magnitude relationships for coal‐mining‐related microseismic events, recorded near New Ollerton, United Kingdom. This generates rupture radii ranging approximately between 10 and 100 m, which agrees with the findings of Verdon et al. (2018), and results in stress‐drop values between 0.1 and 10 MPa. Calculating these properties without κ0_noise produces much higher rupture radii of between 100 and 500 m and significantly lower stress drops (⁠ ∼1×10−2  MPa⁠). Finally, we find that the combined κ0‐Brune model parameterized with these source property estimates accurately capture the ML–Mw relationship at New Ollerton, and that stress drop heavily influences the gradient of this relationship.


  • Open Access

    Local Magnitude Discrepancies for Near‐Event Receivers: Implications for the U.K. Traffic‐Light Scheme

    by Antony Butcher, Richard Luckett, James P. Verdon, J.‐Michael Kendall, Brian Baptie, James Wookey

    Local seismic magnitudes provide a practical and efficient scale for the implementation of regulation designed to manage the risk of induced seismicity, such as Traffic‐Light Schemes (TLS). We demonstrate that significant magnitude discrepancies (up to a unit higher) occur between seismic events recorded on nearby stations (<5 km) compared with those at greater distances. This is due to the influence of sedimentary layers, which are generally lower in velocity and more attenuating than the underlying crystalline basement rocks, and requires a change in the attenuation term of the ML scale. This has a significant impact on the United Kingdom’s (U.K.) hydraulic fracturing TLS, whose red light is set at ML 0.5. Because the nominal detectability of the U.K. network is ML 2, this scheme will require the deployment of monitoring stations in close proximity to well sites. Using data collected from mining events near New Ollerton, Nottinghamshire, we illustrate the effects that proximity has on travel path velocities and attenuation, then perform a damped least‐squares inversion to determine appropriate constants within the ML scale. We show that the attenuation term needs to increase from 0.00183 to 0.0514 and demonstrate that this higher value is representative of a ray path within a slower more attenuating sedimentary layer compared with the continental crust. We therefore recommend that the magnitude scale ML=log(A)+1.17log(r)+0.0514r−3.0 should be used when local monitoring networks are within 5 km of the event epicenters