Nataliia Martsenko
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Nataliia Martsenko has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Malvina Valeriivna Hrushko
National University "Odesa law academy
1 shared publication - Tetiana Drakokhrust
West Ukrainian National University, Ukraine
1 shared publication West Ukrainian National University
1 shared publicationWestern Ukrainian National University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 4 September 2026
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 195-222
When the Algorithm Is Wrong
This chapter examines epistemic trust, AI-generated evidence, and legal liability in judicial proceedings. The study analyses the legal nature of AI-based evidence, identifying key characteristics — algorithmic generation, data dependency, and black box opacity — which challenge traditional evidentiary standards of relevance, admissibility, and verifiability. Drawing on comparative analysis of Wisconsin v. Loomis (2016), the Dutch SyRI judgment (2020), and the Toeslagenaffaire scandal, the chapter shows that algorithmic errors are structurally diverse, systemically discriminatory, and resistant to detection through standard legal mechanisms. Legal liability is explored across multiple actors — developers, operators, and judicial users — while critically assessing traditional fault-based models. The chapter concludes that effective regulation requires risk-based approaches combining algorithmic transparency, mandatory human oversight, and procedural safeguards — as reflected in the EU AI Act 2024 — to ensure AI in justice complies with the rule of law and human rights.
- 4 September 2026
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 195-222
When the Algorithm Is Wrong
This chapter examines epistemic trust, AI-generated evidence, and legal liability in judicial proceedings. The study analyses the legal nature of AI-based evidence, identifying key characteristics — algorithmic generation, data dependency, and black box opacity — which challenge traditional evidentiary standards of relevance, admissibility, and verifiability. Drawing on comparative analysis of Wisconsin v. Loomis (2016), the Dutch SyRI judgment (2020), and the Toeslagenaffaire scandal, the chapter shows that algorithmic errors are structurally diverse, systemically discriminatory, and resistant to detection through standard legal mechanisms. Legal liability is explored across multiple actors — developers, operators, and judicial users — while critically assessing traditional fault-based models. The chapter concludes that effective regulation requires risk-based approaches combining algorithmic transparency, mandatory human oversight, and procedural safeguards — as reflected in the EU AI Act 2024 — to ensure AI in justice complies with the rule of law and human rights.
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Mariupol State University in Vìsnik Marìupolʹsʹkogo deržavnogo unìversitetu. Serìâ: Pravo
- Vol. 16 (31)
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS AND LEGAL PRACTICE: CONTRACTUAL MECHANISMS FOR REGULATING RISKS AND PROFESSIONAL TRANSPARENCY
The conducted research is relevant due to the active digitalization of legal practice and judicial proceedings, as well as the need to adapt legal regulation to the use of artificial intelligence tools. Particular importance is attached to the formation of new standards of professional transparency, the allocation of risks and the contractual delineation of the boundaries for the use of digital technologies in the provision of legal assistance. Furthermore, the analysis of current legislation, judicial practice and doctrinal approaches makes it possible to identify gaps in the regulation of generative artificial intelligence and to outline directions for its further improvement. Therefore, the aim of this study is to provide a theoretical and legal analysis of the impact of artificial intelligence on legal practice and judicial proceedings, as well as to determine its significance for the content of legal services agreements. The paper analyzes the theoretical and legal foundations of the legal services agreement, its legal nature, essential terms and specific features of its regulation under national law. It examines the role of this agreement as the primary form of exercising legal practice and as an instrument for defining the rights and obligations of the parties. Particular attention is paid to the use of generative artificial intelligence in legal practice and judicial proceedings, including the risks of «hallucinations», the abuse of procedural rights and the impact of such technologies on the quality of legal assistance. An analysis of the case law of the Supreme Court and other courts has been conducted, in which the use of artificial intelligence is assessed through the prism of the principles of good faith, procedural discipline and professional responsibility. It is determined that the absence of direct regulatory provisions leads to the development of approaches to assessing the admissibility of artificial intelligence through judicial practice and the ethical standards of legal practice. The issue of professional transparency and the need to inform the client about the use of digital technologies in the provision of legal assistance has been examined. It is emphasized that although current legislation does not require the detailed specification of technological tools used in the contract, under modern conditions of digitalization there is a growing trend toward incorporating such provisions as elements of risk allocation between the lawyer and the client. The expediency of including general clauses on the use of artificial intelligence in legal services agreements is substantiated, emphasizing its auxiliary nature and establishing the lawyer’s full professional responsibility for the final outcome. An approach is proposed whereby the regulation of artificial intelligence in legal practice should be carried out through a combination of contractual mechanisms, ethical standards and judicial practice, in order to ensure a balance between technological efficiency and the protection of clients’ rights. Keywords: artificial intelligence (AI), lawyer, advocacy (legal practice), agreement on legal assistance, judicial proceedings, procedural law, professional ethics of a lawyer, liability, digitalization of law, legal transparency, risk allocation, attorney-client privilege, court, judicial practice, good faith.
- 15 June 2026
- Published by Mariupol State University in Vìsnik Marìupolʹsʹkogo deržavnogo unìversitetu. Serìâ: Pravo
- Vol. 16 (31)
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS AND LEGAL PRACTICE: CONTRACTUAL MECHANISMS FOR REGULATING RISKS AND PROFESSIONAL TRANSPARENCY
The conducted research is relevant due to the active digitalization of legal practice and judicial proceedings, as well as the need to adapt legal regulation to the use of artificial intelligence tools. Particular importance is attached to the formation of new standards of professional transparency, the allocation of risks and the contractual delineation of the boundaries for the use of digital technologies in the provision of legal assistance. Furthermore, the analysis of current legislation, judicial practice and doctrinal approaches makes it possible to identify gaps in the regulation of generative artificial intelligence and to outline directions for its further improvement. Therefore, the aim of this study is to provide a theoretical and legal analysis of the impact of artificial intelligence on legal practice and judicial proceedings, as well as to determine its significance for the content of legal services agreements. The paper analyzes the theoretical and legal foundations of the legal services agreement, its legal nature, essential terms and specific features of its regulation under national law. It examines the role of this agreement as the primary form of exercising legal practice and as an instrument for defining the rights and obligations of the parties. Particular attention is paid to the use of generative artificial intelligence in legal practice and judicial proceedings, including the risks of «hallucinations», the abuse of procedural rights and the impact of such technologies on the quality of legal assistance. An analysis of the case law of the Supreme Court and other courts has been conducted, in which the use of artificial intelligence is assessed through the prism of the principles of good faith, procedural discipline and professional responsibility. It is determined that the absence of direct regulatory provisions leads to the development of approaches to assessing the admissibility of artificial intelligence through judicial practice and the ethical standards of legal practice. The issue of professional transparency and the need to inform the client about the use of digital technologies in the provision of legal assistance has been examined. It is emphasized that although current legislation does not require the detailed specification of technological tools used in the contract, under modern conditions of digitalization there is a growing trend toward incorporating such provisions as elements of risk allocation between the lawyer and the client. The expediency of including general clauses on the use of artificial intelligence in legal services agreements is substantiated, emphasizing its auxiliary nature and establishing the lawyer’s full professional responsibility for the final outcome. An approach is proposed whereby the regulation of artificial intelligence in legal practice should be carried out through a combination of contractual mechanisms, ethical standards and judicial practice, in order to ensure a balance between technological efficiency and the protection of clients’ rights. Keywords: artificial intelligence (AI), lawyer, advocacy (legal practice), agreement on legal assistance, judicial proceedings, procedural law, professional ethics of a lawyer, liability, digitalization of law, legal transparency, risk allocation, attorney-client privilege, court, judicial practice, good faith.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by West Ukrainian National University in Aktual’ni problemi pravoznavstva
- No. 3,p. 38-46
The Unity of Judicial Practice in the Light of Existing Legal Mechanisms, European Standards and Modern Technologies
The relevance of this study is determined by the fact that ensuring the unity of judicial practice is a key element of a stable legal system, as it guarantees the consistency of court decisions in similar legal situations, enhances trust in the judicial system and promotes the implementation of the rule of law. Despite the effectiveness of traditional legal mechanisms, the risk of discrepancies in the interpretation and application of norms still exists, which highlights the need for innovative approaches that, in the modern context of social and technological development, hold significant potential. The combination of traditional legal mechanisms and innovative technologies makes the study particularly relevant for shaping a unified judicial practice in Ukraine. The purpose of the study is to examine the mechanisms for ensuring the unity of judicial practice in Ukraine, taking into account national legislation, the requirements of European standards and the potential use of artificial intelligence. To study the unity of judicial practice, such methods as the formal-logical, comparative-legal, systemic and analysis and synthesis methods were employed, allowing for a comprehensive assessment of the role of legal norms and technological tools in ensuring the consistency of court decisions. It is concluded that the unity of judicial practice is a fundamental element of the rule of law and a guarantee of society’s trust in the judicial system. In this context, the consistency of court decisions serves not only as a tool of legal certainty but also as a necessary condition for the realization of the right to a fair trial. Ensuring the unity of judicial practice is based both on historically established legal principles, beginning with Roman law and on modern European standards. It is argued that the mechanisms for ensuring the unity of judicial practice require constant improvement, particularly through the development of both legal and innovative tools. Therefore, under modern conditions, the possibility of integrating innovative technologies, especially artificial intelligence, into the processes of analyzing and systematizing judicial practice acquires special significance. The current level of artificial intelligence development demonstrates that it is capable not only of enhancing the efficiency of judicial proceedings but also of contributing to unified approaches in law enforcement. At the same time, its use must strictly comply with European ethical standards, ensure transparency, preserve judicial responsibility for final decisions and uphold the principles of confidentiality and judicial independence. A harmonious combination of traditional mechanisms of legal regulation with the potential of modern technologies creates promising conditions for strengthening the unity of judicial practice and increasing citizens’ trust in the justice system.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by West Ukrainian National University in Aktual’ni problemi pravoznavstva
- No. 3,p. 38-46
Open AccessThe Unity of Judicial Practice in the Light of Existing Legal Mechanisms, European Standards and Modern Technologies
The relevance of this study is determined by the fact that ensuring the unity of judicial practice is a key element of a stable legal system, as it guarantees the consistency of court decisions in similar legal situations, enhances trust in the judicial system and promotes the implementation of the rule of law. Despite the effectiveness of traditional legal mechanisms, the risk of discrepancies in the interpretation and application of norms still exists, which highlights the need for innovative approaches that, in the modern context of social and technological development, hold significant potential. The combination of traditional legal mechanisms and innovative technologies makes the study particularly relevant for shaping a unified judicial practice in Ukraine. The purpose of the study is to examine the mechanisms for ensuring the unity of judicial practice in Ukraine, taking into account national legislation, the requirements of European standards and the potential use of artificial intelligence. To study the unity of judicial practice, such methods as the formal-logical, comparative-legal, systemic and analysis and synthesis methods were employed, allowing for a comprehensive assessment of the role of legal norms and technological tools in ensuring the consistency of court decisions. It is concluded that the unity of judicial practice is a fundamental element of the rule of law and a guarantee of society’s trust in the judicial system. In this context, the consistency of court decisions serves not only as a tool of legal certainty but also as a necessary condition for the realization of the right to a fair trial. Ensuring the unity of judicial practice is based both on historically established legal principles, beginning with Roman law and on modern European standards. It is argued that the mechanisms for ensuring the unity of judicial practice require constant improvement, particularly through the development of both legal and innovative tools. Therefore, under modern conditions, the possibility of integrating innovative technologies, especially artificial intelligence, into the processes of analyzing and systematizing judicial practice acquires special significance. The current level of artificial intelligence development demonstrates that it is capable not only of enhancing the efficiency of judicial proceedings but also of contributing to unified approaches in law enforcement. At the same time, its use must strictly comply with European ethical standards, ensure transparency, preserve judicial responsibility for final decisions and uphold the principles of confidentiality and judicial independence. A harmonious combination of traditional mechanisms of legal regulation with the potential of modern technologies creates promising conditions for strengthening the unity of judicial practice and increasing citizens’ trust in the justice system.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Scientific Notes Series Law
- Vol. 1 (18) , 41-47
PECULIARITIES OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS IN ADOPTION CASES
Актуальність теми зумовлена значущістю інституту усиновлення як ключового механізму захисту прав дитини та забезпечення її права на сімейне виховання. Попри законодавче визначення усиновлення як юридичного акту, спрямованого на реалізацію принципу найкращих інтересів дитини, на практиці спостерігаються проблеми щодо ефективності здійснення судового провадження у цій сфері. Особлива увага приділяється необхідності гармонізації національного законодавства з міжнародними стандартами, зокрема практикою Європейського суду з прав людини, що актуалізує питання удосконалення процесуальних механізмів і забезпечення балансу між правами дитини та інших учасників справи. Метою дослідження є всебічний аналіз особливостей окремого провадження у справах про усиновлення в Україні з урахуванням принципу найкращих інтересів дитини, норм національного та міжнародного права, а також судової практики. У результаті проведеного дослідження встановлено, що окреме провадження у справах про усиновлення вимагає від суду ретельного та всебічного дослідження обставин справи, активної участі органів опіки та піклування, а також пріоритетного врахування найкращих інтересів дитини. Водночас наголошено на необхідності подолання формалізму та удосконалення процесуальних гарантій, що сприятиме забезпеченню балансу між правами дитини і інших учасників процесу. У проведеному дослідженні підкреслено, що суди мають враховувати не лише юридичну чинність актів, а й їх вплив на емоційне, психологічне та соціальне благополуччя дитини. Будь-яке рішення у справах про усиновлення має базуватися на принципі правової визначеності та непорушності сімейних відносин, що сформувалися на законних підставах, забезпечуючи тим самим ефективний захист прав дитини та реалізацію конституційних і міжнародних стандартів. The relevance of the topic is determined by the importance of the adoption institute as a key mechanism for protecting the rights of the child and ensuring their right to family upbringing. Despite the legislative definition of adoption as a legal act aimed at realizing the principle of the best interests of the child, in practice, there are problems concerning the effectiveness of judicial proceedings in this area. Particular attention is paid to the need to harmonize national legislation with international standards, especially the case law of the European Court of Human Rights, which actualizes the issue of improving procedural mechanisms and ensuring a balance between the rights of the child and other parties to the case. A comparative analysis of scholarly literature, current national and international legislation, and judicial practice reveals a number of problematic aspects related to ensuring an effective procedural mechanism for adoption. In particular, these include the formalism of judicial procedures, insufficient standardization of the involvement of guardianship and custody authorities, as well as the need to harmonize the national approach with European standards and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. In this context, the need for further improvement of judicial consideration of adoption cases becomes especially relevant in order to ensure adequate protection of the child's rights in accordance with Ukraine’s international legal obligations. The purpose of the study is a comprehensive analysis of the specific features of separate proceedings in adoption cases in Ukraine, taking into account the principle of the best interests of the child, the norms of national and international law, as well as judicial practice. The results of the study show that separate proceedings in adoption cases require the court to conduct a thorough and comprehensive examination of the circumstances of the case, active involvement of guardianship and custody authorities, as well as the priority consideration of the best interests of the child. At the same time, emphasis is placed on the need to overcome formalism and improve procedural guarantees, which will contribute to ensuring a balance between the rights of the child and other participants in the process. The study emphasizes that courts must consider not only the legal validity of certain acts but also their impact on the emotional, psychological, and social well-being of the child. Any decision in adoption cases must be based on the principle of legal certainty and the inviolability of family relationships established on legal grounds,...
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Scientific Notes Series Law
- Vol. 1 (18) , 41-47
Open AccessPECULIARITIES OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS IN ADOPTION CASES
Актуальність теми зумовлена значущістю інституту усиновлення як ключового механізму захисту прав дитини та забезпечення її права на сімейне виховання. Попри законодавче визначення усиновлення як юридичного акту, спрямованого на реалізацію принципу найкращих інтересів дитини, на практиці спостерігаються проблеми щодо ефективності здійснення судового провадження у цій сфері. Особлива увага приділяється необхідності гармонізації національного законодавства з міжнародними стандартами, зокрема практикою Європейського суду з прав людини, що актуалізує питання удосконалення процесуальних механізмів і забезпечення балансу між правами дитини та інших учасників справи. Метою дослідження є всебічний аналіз особливостей окремого провадження у справах про усиновлення в Україні з урахуванням принципу найкращих інтересів дитини, норм національного та міжнародного права, а також судової практики. У результаті проведеного дослідження встановлено, що окреме провадження у справах про усиновлення вимагає від суду ретельного та всебічного дослідження обставин справи, активної участі органів опіки та піклування, а також пріоритетного врахування найкращих інтересів дитини. Водночас наголошено на необхідності подолання формалізму та удосконалення процесуальних гарантій, що сприятиме забезпеченню балансу між правами дитини і інших учасників процесу. У проведеному дослідженні підкреслено, що суди мають враховувати не лише юридичну чинність актів, а й їх вплив на емоційне, психологічне та соціальне благополуччя дитини. Будь-яке рішення у справах про усиновлення має базуватися на принципі правової визначеності та непорушності сімейних відносин, що сформувалися на законних підставах, забезпечуючи тим самим ефективний захист прав дитини та реалізацію конституційних і міжнародних стандартів. The relevance of the topic is determined by the importance of the adoption institute as a key mechanism for protecting the rights of the child and ensuring their right to family upbringing. Despite the legislative definition of adoption as a legal act aimed at realizing the principle of the best interests of the child, in practice, there are problems concerning the effectiveness of judicial proceedings in this area. Particular attention is paid to the need to harmonize national legislation with international standards, especially the case law of the European Court of Human Rights, which actualizes the issue of improving procedural mechanisms and ensuring a balance between the rights of the child and other parties to the case. A comparative analysis of scholarly literature, current national and international legislation, and judicial practice reveals a number of problematic aspects related to ensuring an effective procedural mechanism for adoption. In particular, these include the formalism of judicial procedures, insufficient standardization of the involvement of guardianship and custody authorities, as well as the need to harmonize the national approach with European standards and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. In this context, the need for further improvement of judicial consideration of adoption cases becomes especially relevant in order to ensure adequate protection of the child's rights in accordance with Ukraine’s international legal obligations. The purpose of the study is a comprehensive analysis of the specific features of separate proceedings in adoption cases in Ukraine, taking into account the principle of the best interests of the child, the norms of national and international law, as well as judicial practice. The results of the study show that separate proceedings in adoption cases require the court to conduct a thorough and comprehensive examination of the circumstances of the case, active involvement of guardianship and custody authorities, as well as the priority consideration of the best interests of the child. At the same time, emphasis is placed on the need to overcome formalism and improve procedural guarantees, which will contribute to ensuring a balance between the rights of the child and other participants in the process. The study emphasizes that courts must consider not only the legal validity of certain acts but also their impact on the emotional, psychological, and social well-being of the child. Any decision in adoption cases must be based on the principle of legal certainty and the inviolability of family relationships established on legal grounds,...
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Scientific Notes Series Law
- Vol. 1 (12) , 34-39
CIVIL LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES, CAUSED BY ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
A study of the peculiarities of civil liability for damage caused by artificial intelligence was conducted. The special relevance of the chosen topic is emphasized, given the significant positive potential of artificial intelligence technologies and the feasibility of minimizing the negative risks of artificial intelligence use and related compensation. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to determine the specifics of civil liability for damage caused by artificial intelligence, based on the rules of law currently enshrined in the Civil Code of Ukraine and taking into account the experience of foreign countries law enforcement. The understanding, types and grounds for the application of civil liability are analyzed. In particular, the rules of law relating to tort liability are analyzed in detail. Tort liability includes liability for culpable human conduct and for other types of torts caused by things or animals. The obligation to compensate for the damage caused is related to the actions or inaction of the person or other phenomenon, if it was the cause of the damage. The possibility of applying the norms of the Civil Code of Ukraine to compensate for damage caused by artificial intelligence is considered. It is argued that the legal rules on liability for damage caused by a dangerous product are currently the only ones that can be applied to things equipped with artificial intelligence, although liability under this principle also has certain limitations that should be taken into account. The norms of European tort law that can be used to compensate for damage caused by artificial intelligence are analyzed. Ways to improve the current civil legislation of Ukraine in terms of liability for damage caused by artificial intelligence, to minimize the negative consequences of the use of these technologies in various spheres of society and the state was suggested.
- 1 October 2022
- Published by Volodymyr Vynnychenko Central Ukrainian State Pedagogical University in Scientific Notes Series Law
- Vol. 1 (12) , 34-39
CIVIL LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES, CAUSED BY ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
A study of the peculiarities of civil liability for damage caused by artificial intelligence was conducted. The special relevance of the chosen topic is emphasized, given the significant positive potential of artificial intelligence technologies and the feasibility of minimizing the negative risks of artificial intelligence use and related compensation. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to determine the specifics of civil liability for damage caused by artificial intelligence, based on the rules of law currently enshrined in the Civil Code of Ukraine and taking into account the experience of foreign countries law enforcement. The understanding, types and grounds for the application of civil liability are analyzed. In particular, the rules of law relating to tort liability are analyzed in detail. Tort liability includes liability for culpable human conduct and for other types of torts caused by things or animals. The obligation to compensate for the damage caused is related to the actions or inaction of the person or other phenomenon, if it was the cause of the damage. The possibility of applying the norms of the Civil Code of Ukraine to compensate for damage caused by artificial intelligence is considered. It is argued that the legal rules on liability for damage caused by a dangerous product are currently the only ones that can be applied to things equipped with artificial intelligence, although liability under this principle also has certain limitations that should be taken into account. The norms of European tort law that can be used to compensate for damage caused by artificial intelligence are analyzed. Ways to improve the current civil legislation of Ukraine in terms of liability for damage caused by artificial intelligence, to minimize the negative consequences of the use of these technologies in various spheres of society and the state was suggested.
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 6 (84),p. 102-110
Humanitarian Access during Armed Conflicts
The article analyses the right to humanitarian access, which finds its expression in humanitarian aid and protection during armed conflicts in accordance with the norms of International Humanitarian Law. The basics of humanitarian access activities are determined. Mechanisms for ensuring and supporting effective humanitarian access as a result of collective action and efforts of humanitarian actors are considered. The article reaffirms that the provision of humanitarian assistance is the responsibility of all parties to an armed conflict in accordance with International Humanitarian Law. International Humanitarian Law is a constant of legal norms that must be applied by all parties to an armed conflict. Determinant in this definition is the presence of armed conflict, not the «humanitarian» component. Authors of the article emphasize that the axiom of International Humanitarian Law is the protection of war victims, which corresponds to the key principle of humanity. Access standards are reflected in the four Geneva Conventions for the Protection of Victims of War of 1949 and the two Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions of 1977. Unless a State or other party to an armed conflict is a party to a treaty, customary International Humanitarian Law operate in parallel with contractual rules. Humanitarian protection is designed to protect and restore human rights, which is based on the provisions of international human rights law and forms the basis of fundamental human rights and freedoms. The provisions of international criminal law, in particular the 1998 Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court are strengthens humanitarian access. The article argues that addressing issues such as the accreditation of humanitarian missions, the humanitarian aid coordination system and overcoming regulatory gaps will address the current challenges of humanitarian access in armed conflict mainly due to the difficulties of interaction of international humanitarian missions with the warring parties. The authors of the article confirmed that the violation of the right to humanitarian access poses a threat to peace and security in the world.
- 30 December 2021
- Published by Leonid Yuzkov Khmelnytskyi University of Management and Law in University Scientific Notes
- No. 6 (84),p. 102-110
Humanitarian Access during Armed Conflicts
The article analyses the right to humanitarian access, which finds its expression in humanitarian aid and protection during armed conflicts in accordance with the norms of International Humanitarian Law. The basics of humanitarian access activities are determined. Mechanisms for ensuring and supporting effective humanitarian access as a result of collective action and efforts of humanitarian actors are considered. The article reaffirms that the provision of humanitarian assistance is the responsibility of all parties to an armed conflict in accordance with International Humanitarian Law. International Humanitarian Law is a constant of legal norms that must be applied by all parties to an armed conflict. Determinant in this definition is the presence of armed conflict, not the «humanitarian» component. Authors of the article emphasize that the axiom of International Humanitarian Law is the protection of war victims, which corresponds to the key principle of humanity. Access standards are reflected in the four Geneva Conventions for the Protection of Victims of War of 1949 and the two Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions of 1977. Unless a State or other party to an armed conflict is a party to a treaty, customary International Humanitarian Law operate in parallel with contractual rules. Humanitarian protection is designed to protect and restore human rights, which is based on the provisions of international human rights law and forms the basis of fundamental human rights and freedoms. The provisions of international criminal law, in particular the 1998 Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court are strengthens humanitarian access. The article argues that addressing issues such as the accreditation of humanitarian missions, the humanitarian aid coordination system and overcoming regulatory gaps will address the current challenges of humanitarian access in armed conflict mainly due to the difficulties of interaction of international humanitarian missions with the warring parties. The authors of the article confirmed that the violation of the right to humanitarian access poses a threat to peace and security in the world.
- 20 March 2020
- Published by Uniwersytet Warminsko-Mazurski in Studia Prawnoustrojowe
- No. 47
Determining the place of artificial intelligence in civil law
W artykule przeanalizowano cywilno-prawne aspekty systemu prawnego dotyczącego sztucznej inteligencji. Autor uważa, że postrzeganie robota i sztucznej inteligencji jako podmiotów stosunków cywilnoprawnych jest niewłaściwe i może prowadzić do sytuacji niepewności prawnej. Stosowanie pojęcia “osoba elektroniczna” w aktach normatywnych UE wydaje się nierozsądne i przedwczesne, gdyż rozszerzenie tego pojęcia na całe prawo nie zapewnia całościowego zastępstwa prawnego w sprawach dotyczących ich statusu prawnego, odpowiedzialności cywilnej, ochrony praw użytkowników czy ochrony danych. Uważa się, że wskazane jest postrzeganie robotyki i sztucznej inteligencji jako przedmiotów praw obywatelskich. Proponuje się zastosowanie w odniesieniu do sztucznej inteligencji systemu prawnego dotyczącego źródeł wysokiego ryzyka, który stosuje się w dziedzinach takich jak medycyna czy administracja publiczna w celu skuteczniejszej ochrony praw użytkowników technologii sztucznej inteligencji. W przypadku odpowiedzialności cywilnej należy przestrzegać zasady proporcjonalności: im wyższe ryzyko szkody, tym wyższy wymiar odpowiedzialności.
- 20 March 2020
- Published by Uniwersytet Warminsko-Mazurski in Studia Prawnoustrojowe
- No. 47
Determining the place of artificial intelligence in civil law
W artykule przeanalizowano cywilno-prawne aspekty systemu prawnego dotyczącego sztucznej inteligencji. Autor uważa, że postrzeganie robota i sztucznej inteligencji jako podmiotów stosunków cywilnoprawnych jest niewłaściwe i może prowadzić do sytuacji niepewności prawnej. Stosowanie pojęcia “osoba elektroniczna” w aktach normatywnych UE wydaje się nierozsądne i przedwczesne, gdyż rozszerzenie tego pojęcia na całe prawo nie zapewnia całościowego zastępstwa prawnego w sprawach dotyczących ich statusu prawnego, odpowiedzialności cywilnej, ochrony praw użytkowników czy ochrony danych. Uważa się, że wskazane jest postrzeganie robotyki i sztucznej inteligencji jako przedmiotów praw obywatelskich. Proponuje się zastosowanie w odniesieniu do sztucznej inteligencji systemu prawnego dotyczącego źródeł wysokiego ryzyka, który stosuje się w dziedzinach takich jak medycyna czy administracja publiczna w celu skuteczniejszej ochrony praw użytkowników technologii sztucznej inteligencji. W przypadku odpowiedzialności cywilnej należy przestrzegać zasady proporcjonalności: im wyższe ryzyko szkody, tym wyższy wymiar odpowiedzialności.
- 1 January 2019
- Published by Nomos Verlag in osteuropa recht
- Vol. 65 (2) , 223-237
Peculiarities of Recognition of Judgments and other Acts Issued by Unrecognized Authorities – The Example of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, and Luhansk and Donetsk Oblasts (“LNR” and “DNR”)
The military annexation of Crimea of February 2014 and the establishment of the socalled “Donetsk National Republic” and “Luhansk National Republic” under the control of the Russian Federation have led to a complicated situation with regard to the recognition of court judgements and other acts on these territories. This article analyses the connection between the rules of private and public law, since the question of recognition or non-recognition of the territory in public law has certain legal consequences for individuals living on unrecognized territories in private law. It continues with a discussion of the recognition of judgments in the occupied territories: in Crimea, Luhansk and Donetsk oblasts (so-called “LNR” and “DNR”) with a particular focus on the question which law is applied by the courts in these territories. In the next chapter, other decisions of the occupied territories authorities (recognition of civil status acts, recognition of contracts with real estate, etc.) are thoroughly discussed. The Recognition of occupied territories authorities’ decisions is further analyzed from an international perspective. In conclusion, the article closes with a summary of the findings, as well as recommendations regarding private law in order to protect the rights of Ukrainian citizens who virtually became hostages of occupation.
- 1 January 2019
- Published by Nomos Verlag in osteuropa recht
- Vol. 65 (2) , 223-237
Peculiarities of Recognition of Judgments and other Acts Issued by Unrecognized Authorities – The Example of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, and Luhansk and Donetsk Oblasts (“LNR” and “DNR”)
The military annexation of Crimea of February 2014 and the establishment of the socalled “Donetsk National Republic” and “Luhansk National Republic” under the control of the Russian Federation have led to a complicated situation with regard to the recognition of court judgements and other acts on these territories. This article analyses the connection between the rules of private and public law, since the question of recognition or non-recognition of the territory in public law has certain legal consequences for individuals living on unrecognized territories in private law. It continues with a discussion of the recognition of judgments in the occupied territories: in Crimea, Luhansk and Donetsk oblasts (so-called “LNR” and “DNR”) with a particular focus on the question which law is applied by the courts in these territories. In the next chapter, other decisions of the occupied territories authorities (recognition of civil status acts, recognition of contracts with real estate, etc.) are thoroughly discussed. The Recognition of occupied territories authorities’ decisions is further analyzed from an international perspective. In conclusion, the article closes with a summary of the findings, as well as recommendations regarding private law in order to protect the rights of Ukrainian citizens who virtually became hostages of occupation.