JOJames A. Orr

James A. Orr

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


James A. Orr has a total of 159 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Growth-density inversion in Escherichia coli reveals superlinear, not sublinear, density dependence

    by James A. Orr, Kaleigh E. Davis, Alicia H. Williams, Jan Engelstädter, Daniel B. Stouffer, Andrew D. Letten

    Density dependence is a core principle in ecology and evolution, and yet the shape of the relationship between per capita growth and population size remains contentious. Sublinear (decelerating) density dependence has been widely reported in empirical studies, but the apparent ubiquity of sublinearity is at odds with resource competition theory. Moreover, most estimates of density dependence suffer from underappreciated statistical biases and weak inference. Using a microbial, continuous-culture approach that bypasses the limitations of conventional methods by inverting the direction of causality, we report robust evidence for superlinear (accelerating) density dependence, in agreement with theory. These results underscore the need for concerted efforts to reconcile a widening disconnect between mechanistic and phenomenological approaches to inference on the shape of density dependence. Resolving this debate has wide implications for past and future research into species coexistence and ecosystem stability, and in conservation and natural resource modelling.


  • Open Access

    Gene‐to‐Population Level Responses to Multiple Stressors on the Rocky Shore

    by Ramesh Wilson, Katie Driver, James Orr, Manuela Truebano, Michael Collins, Michelle Jackson

    Coastal ecosystems are exposed to both global and local stressors operating across multiple scales. However, research rarely considers how their combined effects propagate over time and across levels of biological organisation. Here, we employ an in situ warming experiment across two rocky shore sites with contrasting sewage pollution to quantify independent and interactive effects of warming and nutrient pollution from genes to populations. Passively warmed and control settlement plates were deployed at polluted and non‐polluted sites and surveyed across a summer to quantify temporal dynamics in the responses of key intertidal taxa. Barnacles were further employed as a model for comparing responses across biological levels, including body size, stable isotope analysis and RNA sequencing. Pollution consistently increased invertebrate abundance and macroalgal cover, alongside transient positive effects on barnacle size, whereas warming reduced barnacle abundance and suppressed macroalgal cover late in the season. Warming and pollution interacted synergistically on barnacle abundance, with pollution remaining the dominant stressor. Microphytobenthos groups similarly showed distinct pollution‐driven increases with warming primarily modifying temporal trajectories; cyanobacteria showed both date‐specific and season‐wide synergistic interactions, against a backdrop of temporal variability across stressor treatments. Consistent with these patterns, pollution shifted barnacle δ 13 C and δ 15 N towards values indicative of greater assimilation of sewage‐derived material, while warming increased elemental C:N ratios, consistent with altered nutritional stress. Barnacle transcriptomic responses mirrored this dominance of pollution, broadly regulating gene expression linked to protein turnover, DNA repair and protein folding; combined warming and pollution further intensified proteostasis‐related changes and produced predominantly reversal and antagonistic interaction types. Our results show that sewage pollution can overwhelm and reshape warming effects over time and across biological levels, linking group‐level responses with parallel shifts in trophic biomarkers and gene regulation. Our scalable field approach provides a template for in situ marine multiple stressor experiments across wider spatiotemporal scales.

  • Open Access

    Gene-to-population level responses to multiple stressors on the rocky shore

    by Ramesh Wilson, Katie Driver, James Orr, Manuela Truebano, Michael Collins, Michelle Jackson

    Coastal ecosystems are exposed to both global and local stressors operating across multiple scales. However, research rarely considers how their combined effects propagate over time and across levels of biological organisation. Here, we employ an in situ warming experiment across two rocky shore sites with contrasting sewage pollution to quantify independent and interactive effects of warming and nutrient pollution from genes to communities. Passively warmed and control settlement plates were deployed at polluted and non-polluted sites and surveyed across a summer to quantify temporal dynamics in the responses of key intertidal taxa. Barnacles were further employed as a model for comparing responses across biological levels, including body size, stable isotope analysis, and RNA sequencing. Pollution consistently increased invertebrate abundance and macroalgal cover, alongside transient positive effects on barnacle size, whereas warming reduced barnacle abundance and suppressed macroalgal cover late in the season. Warming and pollution interacted synergistically on barnacle abundance, with pollution remaining the dominant stressor. Microphytobenthos groups similarly showed distinct pollution-driven increases with warming primarily modifying temporal trajectories; cyanobacteria showed both date-specific and season-wide synergistic interactions, against a backdrop of temporal variability across stressor treatments. Consistent with these patterns, pollution shifted barnacle δ13C and δ15N toward values indicative of greater assimilation of sewage-derived material, while warming increased elemental C:N ratios, consistent with altered nutritional stress. Transcriptomic responses mirrored this dominance of pollution, broadly regulating gene expression linked to protein turnover, DNA repair, and protein folding; combined warming and pollution further intensified proteostasis-related changes and produced predominantly reversal and antagonistic interaction types. Our results show that sewage pollution can overwhelm and reshape warming effects over time and across biological levels, linking group-level responses with parallel shifts in trophic biomarkers and gene regulation. Our scalable field approach provides a template for in situ marine multiple stressor experiments across wider spatiotemporal scales.

  • Open Access

    Hypothesis‐Driven Research on Multiple Stressors: An Analytical Framework for Stressor Interactions

    by Iris Madge Pimentel, Dania Albini, Arne J. Beermann, Florian Leese, Samuel J. Macaulay, Christoph D. Matthaei, James A. Orr, Jeremy J. Piggott, Ralf B. Schäfer

    Identifying and characterizing stressor interactions is central to multiple stressor research. Such interactions refer to stronger (synergism) or weaker (antagonism) joint effects of co‐occurring stressors on biological entities, when compared to the predictions of a theoretical null model. Various null models have been developed, and the selection of the most appropriate null model for a specific research question is ideally based on assumptions on co‐tolerance patterns in communities and mechanisms of stressor effects. Statistical models are commonly used to evaluate the statistical significance of interaction terms. However, they introduce constraints by imposing a specific null hypothesis on stressor combinations that cannot be flexibly changed. This can introduce a mismatch between the null model that the analyst wants to test and the one imposed by the statistical model. Here, we show under which conditions the statistical null hypothesis for interaction terms misaligns with a multiple‐stressor null model and propose to resolve such misalignments using post‐estimation inference. Null‐model specific interaction estimates can be calculated from adjusted predictions of a fitted regression model, and associated standard errors are derived using the delta method, posterior simulations, or bootstrapping. We illustrate the suggested approach with three case studies and validate statistical conclusions through data simulations. Post‐estimation inference has the potential to advance hypothesis‐driven research on stressor interactions by flexibly testing any a priori defined null model independent from regression model structure.


  • Open Access

    Density dependence revisited: strong evidence for superlinear population growth

    by James Orr, Kaleigh Davis, Alicia H Williams, Jan Engelstädter, Daniel B Stouffer, Andrew D Letten

    Density dependence is a core principle in ecological and evolutionary theory, and yet the precise nature of the relationship between per capita growth and population size continues to ignite debate. While sublinear (convex/decelerating) density dependence is frequently observed in empirical studies, standard techniques for estimating density dependence are prone to unreliable inference. At the same time, the putative ubiquity of sublinearity in nature is at odds with the predictions of mechanistic models of resource competition. We used a continuous-culture approach, which bypasses the inferential challenges hindering conventional methods, in order to investigate the shape of density dependence in Escherichia coli. In agreement with the predictions of a model of resource competition empirically parameterised from independent growth assays, we found strong evidence for superlinear (concave/accelerating) density dependence. Despite the simplicity of our experimental system, we hypothesise that the evidence for sublinearity as a widespread phenomenon is less robust than widely assumed. Resolving this debate has significant implications for our fundamental understanding of ecosystem stability and the development of reliable models informing conservation and resource management.


  • Open Access

    Hypothesis-Driven Research on Multiple Stressors: An Analytical Framework for Stressor Interactions

    by Iris Madge Pimentel, Dania Albini, Arne Beermann, Florian Leese, Sam Macaulay, Christoph Matthaei, James Orr, Jeremy Piggott, Ralf Schäfer

    1. Identifying and characterizing stressor interactions is central to multiple-stressor research. Such interactions refer to stronger (synergism) or weaker (antagonism) joint effects of co-occurring stressors on biological entities, when compared to the predictions of a theoretical null model. Various null models have been developed and selection of the most appropriate null model for a specific research question is ideally based on assumptions on co-tolerance patterns in communities, and mechanisms of stressor effects. 2. Statistical models are commonly used to evaluate the statistical significance of interaction terms. However, they introduce constraints by imposing a specific null hypothesis on stressor combinations that cannot be flexibly changed. This can introduce a mismatch between the null model that the analyst wants to test, and the one imposed by the statistical model. 3. Here, we show under which conditions the statistical null hypothesis for interaction terms misaligns with a multiple-stressor null model and propose to resolve such misalignments using post-estimation inference. Null-model specific interaction estimates can be calculated from adjusted predictions of a fitted regression model, and associated standard errors are derived using the delta method, posterior simulations or bootstrapping. We illustrate the suggested approach with three case studies and validate statistical conclusions through data simulations. 4. Post-estimation inference has the potential to advance hypothesis-driven research on stressor interactions by flexibly testing any a priori defined null model independent from regression model structure.

  • Open Access

    Coexistence Theory for Microbial Ecology, and Vice Versa

    by James A. Orr, David W. Armitage, Andrew D. Letten

    Classical models from theoretical ecology are seeing increasing uptake in microbial ecology, but there remains rich potential for closer cross‐pollination. Here we explore opportunities for stronger integration of ecological theory into microbial research (and vice versa) through the lens of so‐called “modern” coexistence theory. Coexistence theory can be used to disentangle the contributions different mechanisms (e.g., resource partitioning, environmental variability) make to species coexistence. We begin with a short primer on the fundamental concepts of coexistence theory, with an emphasis on the relevance to microbial communities. We next present a systematic review, which highlights the paucity of empirical applications of coexistence theory in microbial systems. In light of this gap, we then identify and discuss ways in which: (i) coexistence theory can help to answer fundamental and applied questions in microbial ecology, particularly in spatio‐temporally heterogeneous environments, and (ii) experimental microbial systems can be leveraged to validate and advance coexistence theory. Finally, we address several unique but often surmountable empirical challenges posed by microbial systems, as well as some conceptual limitations. Nevertheless, thoughtful integration of coexistence theory into microbial ecology presents a wealth of opportunities for the advancement of both theoretical and microbial ecology.


  • Open Access

    Priced out of belonging? Insufficient concessions on membership fees across international societies in ecology and evolution

    by Malgorzata Lagisz, Kevin R. Bairos-Novak, April Robin Martinig, Michael G. Bertram, Ayumi Mizuno, Saeed Shafiei Sabet, Matthieu Paquet, Manuela S. Santana, Eli S. J. Thoré, Nina Trubanová, et al.

    Learned societies, as professional bodies for scientists, are an integral part of the scientific system. However, their membership fees have the potential to be prohibitive to the most vulnerable members of the scientific community. To shed light on how membership fees are structured, we conducted a survey of 182 international learned societies relevant to researchers in ecology and evolution. We found that 83% of these societies offered fee concessions to students, but only 26% to postdoctoral researchers. An average regular membership fee—US$67.8, student fee—US$27.4 (42.7% of the regular fee) and postdoctoral fee—US$42.7 (52.9%). Other types of individual concessions, such as for emeritus, family or unemployed, were rare (2–20%). Of the surveyed societies, 43% had discounts for members from developing countries (Global South). Such discounts were more common among societies located in high-income countries. Societies with a publicly visible commitment to equity, diversity and inclusion were more likely to offer different types of concessions. Currently, fees may prevent researchers from vulnerable and underprivileged groups from accessing multiple professional benefits offered by learned societies in ecology and evolution. This includes postdoctoral researchers, who should receive more support. We recommend tangible actions towards making learned societies more affordable and accessible.


  • The promise of community-driven preprints in ecology and evolution

    by Daniel W. A. Noble, Zoe A. Xirocostas, Nicholas C. Wu, April Robin Martinig, Rafaela A. Almeida, Kevin R. Bairos-Novak, Heikel Balti, Michael G. Bertram, Louis Bliard, Jack A. Brand, et al.

    Publishing preprints is quickly becoming commonplace in ecology and evolutionary biology. Preprints can facilitate the rapid sharing of scientific knowledge establishing precedence and enabling feedback from the research community before peer review. Yet, significant barriers to preprint use exist, including language barriers, a lack of understanding about the benefits of preprints and a lack of diversity in the types of research outputs accepted (e.g. reports). Community-driven preprint initiatives can allow a research community to come together to break down these barriers to improve equity and coverage of global knowledge. Here, we explore the first preprints uploaded to EcoEvoRxiv ( n = 1216), a community-driven preprint server for ecologists and evolutionary biologists, to characterize preprint use in ecology, evolution and conservation. Our perspective piece highlights some of the unique initiatives that EcoEvoRxiv has taken to break down barriers to scientific publishing by exploring the composition of articles, how gender and career stage influence preprint use, whether preprints are associated with greater open science practices (e.g. code and data sharing) and tracking preprint publication outcomes. Our analysis identifies areas that we still need to improve upon but highlights how community-driven initiatives, such as EcoEvoRxiv , can play a crucial role in shaping publishing practices in biology.


  • Open Access

    Variability of functional and biodiversity responses to perturbations is predictable and informative

    by James A. Orr, Jeremy J. Piggott, Andrew L. Jackson, Michelle C. Jackson, Jean-François Arnoldi

    Perturbations such as climate change, invasive species and pollution, impact the functioning and diversity of ecosystems. However diversity has many meanings, and ecosystems provide a plethora of functions. Thus, on top of the various perturbations that global change represents, there are also many ways to measure a perturbation’s ecological impact. This leads to an overwhelming response variability, which undermines hopes of prediction. Here, we show that this variability can instead provide insights into hidden features of functions and of species responses to perturbations. By analysing a dataset of global change experiments in microbial soil systems we first show that the variability of functional and diversity responses to perturbations is not random; functions that are mechanistically similar tend to respond coherently. Furthermore, diversity metrics and broad functions (e.g. total biomass) systematically respond in opposite ways. We then formalise these observations to demonstrate, using geometrical arguments, simulations, and a theory-driven analysis of the empirical data, that the response variability of ecosystems is not only predictable, but can also be used to access useful information about species contributions to functions and population-level responses to perturbations. Our research offers a powerful framework for understanding the complexity of ecological responses to global change.