Laura Tesler Waldman

Introduction For patients with autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD), the only approved treatment is tolvaptan, a twice-daily medication that works to slow kidney function decline. Patients on tolvaptan report a considerable burden related to the drug’s aquaretic effects which can intensify immediately following a dose of the medication. Methods A targeted literature review and individual concept elicitation (CE) interviews with nephrologists and adult patients with ADPKD taking tolvaptan were conducted to inform the development of a hybrid diary, programmed as a smartphone application. A sample of adults with ADPKD taking tolvaptan tested the diary for 7 days; a subset also participated in cognitive debriefing (CD) interviews. The diary was then revised and finalized. Results CE interviews confirmed the importance of tracking urinary frequency and urgency and timing of tolvaptan doses in real time. Results from the usability/feasibility test and CD interviews confirmed the understandability and relevance of the diary and provided critical insights to improve its content and functionality. The resulting PKD Daily includes two daily entries to report dose timing, overnight urination, and daily impacts of frequent/urgent urination; real-time entries to capture frequency/urgency of daytime urination; and reminders to encourage regular data entry. Conclusion Originally developed for use in a clinical trial, the PKD Daily can also provide valuable information to clinicians and patients to support treatment decisions and inform dose selection in clinical practice, becoming a valuable part of a clinician’s toolbox. Further, the development of the PKD Daily can serve as a case study for the successful creation of a hybrid diary.

Purpose: Congenital cytomegalovirus (cCMV) is the most common congenital infection worldwide. cCMV can result in long-term impairments such as hearing loss and developmental delay. The study objective was to understand the caregiver experience of cCMV and caregiver-reported perceptions of the experience for cCMV patients. Methods: This non-interventional, cross-sectional study interviewed 25 caregivers of patients (aged 4 months to 17 years) with confirmed cCMV in the United States. Semi-structured qualitative interviewing methods were used to elicit descriptions of cCMV symptoms and their impact on the patient as perceived by the caregiver. Separate questions assessed the caregiver burden of a patient with cCMV. Transcripts were analyzed using an iterative coding process to identify key concepts. Results: All caregivers reported increased healthcare needs for their child with cCMV. Other caregiver-reported patient impacts spanned multiple domains including emotional, physical and social functioning, education and communication. For example, a child with cCMV-related communication/hearing difficulties experiencing sadness or social isolation, or with cCMV-related seizures resulting in worry or apprehension. The caregiver impacts of caring for a child with cCMV also covered multiple domains including emotional, role and social functioning, work, sleep, and family planning. Emotional functioning was considered the greatest impact by approximately half of caregivers. Conclusion: These results advance understanding of experiences related to cCMV for caregivers and caregiver-reported perceptions of the patient experience. This may help healthcare professionals improve routine clinical practice for families affected by cCMV. The results and conceptual model may also support the development of a disease-specific clinical outcome assessment tool.

Purpose Mapping or matching the items in a clinical outcome assessment (COA) to concepts that define a condition is a common method for evaluating a COA’s concept coverage. The purpose of this research was to address the lack of formal guidance for conducting this task by developing a framework for best practices in COA concept mapping and applying it to a case study. Methods To develop the framework, we examined the literature and created a draft set of best practices which was then reviewed by experienced researchers through focus groups before being finalized. To conduct the case study, we extracted data from a systematic review of knee osteoarthritis (KO) symptoms and impacts and used the framework to map relevant concepts to items in the SF-36v2^® Health Survey (SF-36v2). Results The framework guides researchers in defining the purpose of and data sources for the mapping, establishing guiding principles and decision-making thresholds, and conducting the mapping exercise. The results of the case study demonstrate the usefulness of the framework in identifying 27/36 items (75%) in the SF-36v2 that addressed concepts that define KO. Conclusion This case study illustrates how the framework for best practices in COA concept mapping may be used, highlighting how establishing clear concept definitions and guiding principles and following a structured process throughout can help produce consistent, reliable, and reproducible results. The results from this rigorous approach can provide valuable evidence to support decisions about the appropriateness of a COA for the intended patient population.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to conduct cognitive debriefing (CD) interviews with adults diagnosed with chronic hypoparathyroidism (HP) to assess the content validity of the SF-36v2® Health Survey Acute (SF-36v2) measure in this population. Methods: CD interviews were conducted with adults with HP in the United States (US). Interviews were conducted by a trained moderator using a semi-structured interview guide, employing a think-aloud method in conjunction with verbal probing. Participants were asked whether each item was understandable, relevant, important, and sensitive to change in relation to HP. Additionally, comprehension of instructions, response options, and the appropriateness of a 1-week recall period was assessed. Results: Sixteen adults with HP participated in individual CD telephone interviews. All items in the SF-36v2 were reported to be understood, relevant, important, and sensitive to change by at least half, and in most cases, by a strong majority of study participants. Most of the study sample confirmed comprehension of the instructions and the entire sample understood all response options. Conclusion: The study findings show that the items in the SF-36v2® are applicable to adults with HP. The overall high levels of endorsement of items provide strong evidence of the measure’s content validity for this population. The SF-36v2 is therefore recommended for usage in clinical trials examining adults with HP, although it is recommended that this generic measure be supplemented with disease-specific instruments such as the recently developed Hypoparathyroidism Patient Experience Scale—Symptom (HPES-Symptom) and Hypoparathyroidism Patient Experience Scale—Impact (HPES-Impact) measures.

Purpose: Hypoparathyroidism (HP) is a rare endocrine disorder characterized by absent or inappropriately low levels of circulating parathyroid hormone (PTH). Research indicates that HP patients on conventional therapy may have a reduced quality of life. The study’s purpose was to develop a new disease-specific measure of the impacts of hypoparathyroidism on functioning and well-being and provide evidence for its content validity based on rigorous qualitative research methodologies for patient-reported outcomes development.Methods: Semi-structured, individual concept elicitation (CE) interviews were conducted with 5 clinical experts and 42 adults in the USA with HP to identify impacts of relevance and importance to the target population. Transcripts were coded and analyzed using an adapted grounded theory approach common to qualitative research. Following item generation, the draft measure was cognitive debriefed in an independent sample of 16 adults with HP.Results: Analyses identified four impact domains: physical functioning, including ability to exercise (n = 32, 76%) and mobility (n = 21, 50%); daily life, including ability to do things around the home (n = 33, 79%), and interference with work productivity (n = 18, 43%); psychological well-being, including feeling anxious/anxiety (n = 34, 81%) and frustrated (n = 27, 64%); and social, including ability to participate in social activities (n = 33, 79%) and relationships (n = 32, 76%). Twenty-seven impacts were identified and included in the preliminary measure. After the cognitive debriefing, a validation-ready, 26-item Hypoparathyroidism Patient Experience Scale-Impact (HPES-Impact) was generated.Conclusion: Findings provide substantial evidence of content validity for the validation-ready HPES-Impact in adults with HP.

Background: Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is associated with excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS), which may go undiagnosed and can significantly impair a patient’s health-related quality of life (HRQOL). This qualitative research examined timing and reasons patients sought medical care for their EDS and OSA symptoms, and the impact of EDS on HRQOL. Methods: Focus groups were conducted in 3 US cities with 42 participants currently experiencing EDS with OSA. Transcripts were coded and analyzed using an adapted grounded theory approach common to qualitative research. Results: Over three-fifths of study participants (n = 26, 62%) were currently using a positive airway pressure (PAP) or dental device; one-third (n = 14, 33%) had previously used a positive airway pressure (PAP) or dental device, and the remainder had either used another treatment (n = 1, 2%) or were treatment naïve (n = 1, 2%). Twenty-two participants (52%) reported experiencing OSA symptoms for ≥1 year, with an average duration of 11.4 (median 8.0, range 1–37) years before seeking medical attention. Several (n = 7, 32%) considered their symptoms to be “normal,” rather than signaling a serious medical condition. Thirty participants (71%) discussed their reasons for ultimately seeking medical attention, which included: input from spouse/partner, another family member, or friend (n = 20, 67%); their own concern about particular symptoms (n = 7, 23%); and/or falling asleep while driving (n = 5, 17%). For all 42 participants, HRQOL domains impacted by EDS included: physical health and functioning (n = 40, 95%); work productivity (n = 38, 90%); daily life functioning (n = 39, 93%); cognition (n = 38, 90%); social life/relationships (n = 37, 88%); and emotions (n = 30, 71%). Conclusions: Findings suggest that patients may be unaware that their symptoms could indicate OSA requiring evaluation and treatment. Even following diagnosis, EDS associated with OSA can continue to substantially affect HRQOL and daily functioning. Further research is needed to address diagnostic delays and unmet treatment needs for patients with EDS associated with OSA.

Introduction: Scant research has examined the work impact of excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) associated with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), beyond increased accident risk among commercial drivers. Aims and Objectives: To assess the impact of OSA with EDS on productivity across diverse work settings in the United States (US). Methods: Focus groups in 3 US cities with 42 patients experiencing OSA with EDS; coded transcripts qualitatively analysed using adapted grounded theory approach. Results: Most patients either currently (n=29, 69%) or previously (n=9, 21%) experienced EDS-related work impacts (difficulty staying awake at work [n=29, 69%], difficulty completing detail-oriented tasks [n=22, 52%], decreased overall productivity [n=15, 36%]). Ten (24%) reported that their symptoms had been noticed by a boss or coworkers; 5 (12%) experienced disciplinary action, including employment termination (n=3, 7%). Notably, of those currently experiencing EDS-related work impacts (n=29), the majority used a CPAP/BiPAP (n=16, 55%) or oral device (n=5, 17%) and 71% (15/21) of these device users reported that their device was effective for managing OSA symptoms such as snoring, cessation of breathing, and waking up during the night. Physician advice to those with current EDS-related work impacts for managing their EDS (n=8) included weight loss (n=5, 63%), prescription medication (n=2, 25%), and lifestyle changes (n=2, 25%). Conclusion: Findings suggest that OSA with EDS may affect work productivity. Future research should quantitatively assess this further, and explore how treatments and interventions may help patients manage EDS in their work lives. Support: Jazz Pharmaceuticals.

Background and Objective Hypoparathyroidism is a rare endocrine disorder characterized by absent or inappropriately low levels of circulating parathyroid hormone. Patients with hypoparathyroidism receiving standard-of-care therapy report debilitating physical and cognitive symptoms, which may indicate a reduced health-related quality of life. The purpose of this study was to develop a new disease-specific measure of the signs and symptoms of hypoparathyroidism, the Hypoparathyroidism Patient Experience Scale-Symptom (HPES-Symptom), and provide evidence for the content validity of items in the measure based on rigorous qualitative research methodologies for patient-reported outcome development. Methods Semi-structured, individual concept elicitation interviews were conducted with five clinical experts and 42 adults with hypoparathyroidism in the USA to identify the signs and symptoms of relevance and importance to those with the condition. Transcripts were coded and analyzed using an adapted grounded theory approach. Following item generation, cognitive debriefing interviews of the draft measure were conducted in an independent sample of 16 adults with hypoparathyroidism. Results One hundred percent of the concept elicitation patient sample reported experiencing physical symptoms that were attributed to hypoparathyroidism, including tingling/numbness/paresthesia (n = 37, 88%), muscle cramping (n = 36, 86%), and physical fatigue (n = 35, 83%). The majority of patients (n = 36, 86%) further reported experiencing cognitive dysfunction, including impaired memory (n = 24, 57%), impaired ability to have a conversation (n = 21, 50%), and lack of concentration/focus (n = 18, 43%). Seventeen major signs and symptoms were identified during item generation and included in the preliminary measure. After the cognitive debriefing, the 17-item HPES-Symptom was generated. Conclusions The findings provided evidence of content validity for the HPES-Symptom in US adults with hypoparathyroidism. Additional research is needed to validate the measure in patients with hypoparathyroidism to assess its psychometric properties.