Juan David Millán
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Juan David Millán has a total of 37 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gonzalo Salas
Universidad Católica del Maule, Talca, Chile
9 shared publications - Jean Nikola Cudina
Leibniz University Hannover, Hannover, Germany
7 shared publications - Julio César Ossa
Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia
5 shared publications - Carmen Gloria Núñez
Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso
2 shared publications - Giuseppina Marsico
University of Salerno
2 shared publications Gonzalo Salas
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad Autonoma de Madrid in Bajo Palabra
- No. 42,p. 117-137
Pro-vacunas contra antivacunas. Desde la primera vacuna creada por Edward Jenner (1796) a la actualidad
Este artículo busca abordar el fenómeno de la epidemia de COVID-19 en relación con los debates sobre la vacunación. Se busca situar la aparición de los denominados «discursos antivacunas» y los diversos argumentos que, desde su invención a finales del siglo XVIII, buscaron oponerse a los procedimientos de inmunización. Se propone aquí la hipótesis de que la COVID-19, al igual que muchas otras pandemias que han asolado la humanidad a lo largo de su historia, ponen en tensión a las ‘máquinas de verdad’ de cada época y sus estructuras de poder. Un ejemplo de esto es el discurso de los antivacunas teniendo en cuenta que su accionar se remonta a la misma crisis que vive el capitalismo y las formas de producción discursiva tales como la postverdad.
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad Autonoma de Madrid in Bajo Palabra
- No. 42,p. 117-137
Open AccessPro-vacunas contra antivacunas. Desde la primera vacuna creada por Edward Jenner (1796) a la actualidad
Este artículo busca abordar el fenómeno de la epidemia de COVID-19 en relación con los debates sobre la vacunación. Se busca situar la aparición de los denominados «discursos antivacunas» y los diversos argumentos que, desde su invención a finales del siglo XVIII, buscaron oponerse a los procedimientos de inmunización. Se propone aquí la hipótesis de que la COVID-19, al igual que muchas otras pandemias que han asolado la humanidad a lo largo de su historia, ponen en tensión a las ‘máquinas de verdad’ de cada época y sus estructuras de poder. Un ejemplo de esto es el discurso de los antivacunas teniendo en cuenta que su accionar se remonta a la misma crisis que vive el capitalismo y las formas de producción discursiva tales como la postverdad.
- 22 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environmental Justice
The Socio-Environmental Crises Studies. An Emerging and Polycentric Field of Research (1998–2024)
Recently, some systematic reviews have been published criticizing the results of studies on socio-environmental conflicts, claiming that they are vacuous and unscientific, labeling them as deeply ideological and constituting only a genre of “scientific journalism.” In this context, this study aims to reconstruct the landscape of socio-environmental conflict studies and the academic production networks underlying the field between 1998 and 2024. It is evidently a transdisciplinary field that combines in an unprecedented way generally qualitative research and socio-environmental activist struggles. For this purpose, a sample of 274 articles in the field was analyzed from the WoS and Scopus databases. The results indicate that the academic production of socio-environmental studies is fundamentally polycentric, which is an unusual situation considering the general panorama of publications in indexed journals. On the other hand, it is noted that studies on socio-environmental conflicts lack solid collaborative networks in terms of their structure, which could mean that there is little transnational perspective on the problems addressed in each article. However, the solid and defined intellectual roots are striking, which shows a self-organization of the field around works and concepts such as ecological and political economics, radical geography, anthropology of development, and neo-Marxism, among others.
- 22 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environmental Justice
The Socio-Environmental Crises Studies. An Emerging and Polycentric Field of Research (1998–2024)
Recently, some systematic reviews have been published criticizing the results of studies on socio-environmental conflicts, claiming that they are vacuous and unscientific, labeling them as deeply ideological and constituting only a genre of “scientific journalism.” In this context, this study aims to reconstruct the landscape of socio-environmental conflict studies and the academic production networks underlying the field between 1998 and 2024. It is evidently a transdisciplinary field that combines in an unprecedented way generally qualitative research and socio-environmental activist struggles. For this purpose, a sample of 274 articles in the field was analyzed from the WoS and Scopus databases. The results indicate that the academic production of socio-environmental studies is fundamentally polycentric, which is an unusual situation considering the general panorama of publications in indexed journals. On the other hand, it is noted that studies on socio-environmental conflicts lack solid collaborative networks in terms of their structure, which could mean that there is little transnational perspective on the problems addressed in each article. However, the solid and defined intellectual roots are striking, which shows a self-organization of the field around works and concepts such as ecological and political economics, radical geography, anthropology of development, and neo-Marxism, among others.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Universidad Simon Bolivar in Psicogente
- Vol. 28 (54)
El primer Bandura. Un análisis panorámico de su obra
Objetivo: El presente estudio analiza el legado de Albert Bandura (1925-2021), una de las figuras más destacadas de la psicología mundial, mediante un análisis bibliométrico general de su obra, para posteriormente hacer foco en los primeros 40 años de su extensa producción. Método: Se realizó un análisis bibliométrico y una descripción histórica de las publicaciones de Albert Bandura en revistas pertenecientes a las bases de datos Scopus y WoS. Además, se examinó su producción por décadas, identificando las temáticas y publicaciones más representativas. Resultados: Se evidencia que Bandura comienza a desarrollar las bases de su teoría del aprendizaje social cognitivo en las primeras décadas de su carrera, con un enfoque centrado en la investigación experimental y el uso práctico de sus resultados, aportando una mirada novedosa a la comprensión del comportamiento humano. Más adelante continuaría desarrollando sus investigaciones en temáticas como la autoeficacia, autorregulación y agencia, buscando su aplicación a diversos contextos. Más adelante continuaría desarrollando sus investigaciones en temáticas como la autoeficacia, autorregulación y agencia, buscando su aplicación a diversos contextos. Conclusión: El estudio destaca el valor histórico y conceptual de la obra temprana de Albert Bandura, subrayando su papel central en el giro paradigmático de la psicología hacia enfoques más integradores y orientados a la aplicación práctica para el bienestar humano. Sus aportes han sido decisivos en la configuración de áreas como la psicoterapia, la psicología educacional, la salud y las políticas públicas, promoviendo una comprensión más compleja e integral del comportamiento humano. En concordancia, la obra de Bandura es un referente que ha tenido un impacto significativo en la psicología y campos afines hasta la actualidad, invitando a continuar estudiando tanto su legado como las ramificaciones derivadas de este.
- 12 December 2025
- Published by Universidad Simon Bolivar in Psicogente
- Vol. 28 (54)
Open AccessEl primer Bandura. Un análisis panorámico de su obra
Objetivo: El presente estudio analiza el legado de Albert Bandura (1925-2021), una de las figuras más destacadas de la psicología mundial, mediante un análisis bibliométrico general de su obra, para posteriormente hacer foco en los primeros 40 años de su extensa producción. Método: Se realizó un análisis bibliométrico y una descripción histórica de las publicaciones de Albert Bandura en revistas pertenecientes a las bases de datos Scopus y WoS. Además, se examinó su producción por décadas, identificando las temáticas y publicaciones más representativas. Resultados: Se evidencia que Bandura comienza a desarrollar las bases de su teoría del aprendizaje social cognitivo en las primeras décadas de su carrera, con un enfoque centrado en la investigación experimental y el uso práctico de sus resultados, aportando una mirada novedosa a la comprensión del comportamiento humano. Más adelante continuaría desarrollando sus investigaciones en temáticas como la autoeficacia, autorregulación y agencia, buscando su aplicación a diversos contextos. Más adelante continuaría desarrollando sus investigaciones en temáticas como la autoeficacia, autorregulación y agencia, buscando su aplicación a diversos contextos. Conclusión: El estudio destaca el valor histórico y conceptual de la obra temprana de Albert Bandura, subrayando su papel central en el giro paradigmático de la psicología hacia enfoques más integradores y orientados a la aplicación práctica para el bienestar humano. Sus aportes han sido decisivos en la configuración de áreas como la psicoterapia, la psicología educacional, la salud y las políticas públicas, promoviendo una comprensión más compleja e integral del comportamiento humano. En concordancia, la obra de Bandura es un referente que ha tenido un impacto significativo en la psicología y campos afines hasta la actualidad, invitando a continuar estudiando tanto su legado como las ramificaciones derivadas de este.
- Open Access
- 15 November 2025
- Published by Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Valparaiso in Psicoperspectivas
- Vol. 24 (3)
Conciencia ambiental en escuelas y organizaciones en territorios rurales en crisis hídrica de la Provincia de Petorca, Chile
El territorio de la provincia de Petorca en Chile, visibiliza los efectos devastadores del cambio climático agravado en las últimas décadas con la expansión de la industria agroexportadora y minera. Basados en un enfoque cualitativo, se realizaron seis entrevistas semiestructuradas sedentarias y dos entrevistas caminadas con dos escuelas y dos organizaciones locales rurales; luego se analizó temáticamente sus discursos a partir de sus dimensiones cognitivas, afectivas, disposicionales y comportamentales de la conciencia ambiental (CA). Los hallazgos dan cuenta que las experiencias autobiográficas y su dimensión afectiva, son elementos estructurales en las disposiciones adaptativas para afrontar la escasez hídrica del territorio mucho más que aspectos puramente cognitivos. Se concluye que la CA analizada en los y las entrevistados(as) manifiestan la intersección de elementos experienciales y afectivos, los cuales agregan una significación tan profunda como compleja a las disposiciones y acciones de las comunidades para poder sobrellevar la crisis socioambiental.
- 15 November 2025
- Published by Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Valparaiso in Psicoperspectivas
- Vol. 24 (3)
Open AccessConciencia ambiental en escuelas y organizaciones en territorios rurales en crisis hídrica de la Provincia de Petorca, Chile
El territorio de la provincia de Petorca en Chile, visibiliza los efectos devastadores del cambio climático agravado en las últimas décadas con la expansión de la industria agroexportadora y minera. Basados en un enfoque cualitativo, se realizaron seis entrevistas semiestructuradas sedentarias y dos entrevistas caminadas con dos escuelas y dos organizaciones locales rurales; luego se analizó temáticamente sus discursos a partir de sus dimensiones cognitivas, afectivas, disposicionales y comportamentales de la conciencia ambiental (CA). Los hallazgos dan cuenta que las experiencias autobiográficas y su dimensión afectiva, son elementos estructurales en las disposiciones adaptativas para afrontar la escasez hídrica del territorio mucho más que aspectos puramente cognitivos. Se concluye que la CA analizada en los y las entrevistados(as) manifiestan la intersección de elementos experienciales y afectivos, los cuales agregan una significación tan profunda como compleja a las disposiciones y acciones de las comunidades para poder sobrellevar la crisis socioambiental.
- 29 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 137-157
A Cultural Perspective on Psychological Training in Chile: From Undergraduate Studies to the Ph.D
- 29 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 137-157
A Cultural Perspective on Psychological Training in Chile: From Undergraduate Studies to the Ph.D
- 20 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science
- Vol. 59 (2) , 1-36
“An Emerging Science of Which I Am Aware Can Fail When Faced with the Question of Whether the Time to do it has Already Arrived”. The Publication of Wundt's Grundzüge der Physiologischen Psychologie in 1874.
The first edition of the Grundzüge der Physiologischen Psychologie of Wilhelm Wundt which celebrated its 150th anniversary of publication. The Grundzüge was a constantly updated work that from 1874 to 1911 had 6 editions which laid the philosophical and methodological foundations of Wundt's project of psychology. The first edition of 1874 is maybe the most celebrated and remembered but the least studied and subject to a great deal of misinterpretation due to the few translations and the intrinsic complexity of the book. To understand what differentiated the Grundzüge from the other published works on physiological psychology that had been published ten years earlier, it was studied how it was received by its first readers and in general an intellectual context that made the appearance of works like Wundt's conducive. Most of the reviews affirmed that the originality of Wundt's work consisted in providing a philosophical solution to physiology that had definitively abandoned the doctrine of specific energies, which had been used to explain the origin of sensations. In this sense, the philosophers' reviews of Wundt's work were complimentary and saw in it a possibility of giving scientific treatment to certain questions that had previously been dealt with by philosophy. On the other hand, many physiologists regarded the Grundzüge as a transitional work that would be overcome when anatomy and physiology provided definitive answers. The Grunzüge was also a "publishing success" that inaugurated a successful relationship between Wundt and his publisher Wilhelm Engelmann that continued until the beginning of the twentieth century. This article aimed to reconstruct the genesis of the book by analyzing published works immediately prior to its writing that dealt, for example, with research in electrophysiology where he referred to the Gründzüge as a work in progress and that would help to answer many of the unsolved problems.
- 20 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science
- Vol. 59 (2) , 1-36
“An Emerging Science of Which I Am Aware Can Fail When Faced with the Question of Whether the Time to do it has Already Arrived”. The Publication of Wundt's Grundzüge der Physiologischen Psychologie in 1874.
The first edition of the Grundzüge der Physiologischen Psychologie of Wilhelm Wundt which celebrated its 150th anniversary of publication. The Grundzüge was a constantly updated work that from 1874 to 1911 had 6 editions which laid the philosophical and methodological foundations of Wundt's project of psychology. The first edition of 1874 is maybe the most celebrated and remembered but the least studied and subject to a great deal of misinterpretation due to the few translations and the intrinsic complexity of the book. To understand what differentiated the Grundzüge from the other published works on physiological psychology that had been published ten years earlier, it was studied how it was received by its first readers and in general an intellectual context that made the appearance of works like Wundt's conducive. Most of the reviews affirmed that the originality of Wundt's work consisted in providing a philosophical solution to physiology that had definitively abandoned the doctrine of specific energies, which had been used to explain the origin of sensations. In this sense, the philosophers' reviews of Wundt's work were complimentary and saw in it a possibility of giving scientific treatment to certain questions that had previously been dealt with by philosophy. On the other hand, many physiologists regarded the Grundzüge as a transitional work that would be overcome when anatomy and physiology provided definitive answers. The Grunzüge was also a "publishing success" that inaugurated a successful relationship between Wundt and his publisher Wilhelm Engelmann that continued until the beginning of the twentieth century. This article aimed to reconstruct the genesis of the book by analyzing published works immediately prior to its writing that dealt, for example, with research in electrophysiology where he referred to the Gründzüge as a work in progress and that would help to answer many of the unsolved problems.
- 10 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in History of the Human Sciences
- Vol. 38 (1) , 99-128
‘Wundt's work is merely an incident in one of the challenging scholarly careers on recent history’: The media and academic reception of Völkerpsychologie , 1900–1920
Wundt's Völkerpsychologie (VP) is an exceptional case in the history of psychology. Outlined in 1863 in the second volume of Vorlesungen über Menschen- und Thierseele (Lectures on the Human and Animal Soul), VP was finally published 37 years later in 10 volumes during the last 20 years of the author's life. The work was characterized by an ambitious program of multimethod and transdisciplinary research. This article explores the intellectual and contextual reasons for the early successes and failures of VP. We analyzed n = 264 articles published in the German press and n = 220 books, reviews, and articles published in scientific journals that explicitly cited the 10 volumes between 1900 and 1920. VP received considerable criticism from linguists and philologists, who claimed that its results were of little practical use for their research. The first volumes of VP were criticized for their abstract character and psychological indifferentism; on the other hand, positive reviews emphasized their attempt to systematize and give a philosophical order to the individual investigations of philology, linguistics, comparative history, religious studies, and so on. The normative-methodological role that VP tried to play in relation to the other historical sciences was significantly criticized, and this was a determining factor in its diminishing impact over time. Some of Wundt's hypotheses were philosophically at odds with the project of German cultural imperialism that was being developed at the time and with which most of his intellectual enemies agreed.
- 10 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in History of the Human Sciences
- Vol. 38 (1) , 99-128
‘Wundt's work is merely an incident in one of the challenging scholarly careers on recent history’: The media and academic reception of Völkerpsychologie , 1900–1920
Wundt's Völkerpsychologie (VP) is an exceptional case in the history of psychology. Outlined in 1863 in the second volume of Vorlesungen über Menschen- und Thierseele (Lectures on the Human and Animal Soul), VP was finally published 37 years later in 10 volumes during the last 20 years of the author's life. The work was characterized by an ambitious program of multimethod and transdisciplinary research. This article explores the intellectual and contextual reasons for the early successes and failures of VP. We analyzed n = 264 articles published in the German press and n = 220 books, reviews, and articles published in scientific journals that explicitly cited the 10 volumes between 1900 and 1920. VP received considerable criticism from linguists and philologists, who claimed that its results were of little practical use for their research. The first volumes of VP were criticized for their abstract character and psychological indifferentism; on the other hand, positive reviews emphasized their attempt to systematize and give a philosophical order to the individual investigations of philology, linguistics, comparative history, religious studies, and so on. The normative-methodological role that VP tried to play in relation to the other historical sciences was significantly criticized, and this was a determining factor in its diminishing impact over time. Some of Wundt's hypotheses were philosophically at odds with the project of German cultural imperialism that was being developed at the time and with which most of his intellectual enemies agreed.
- 1 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Prevention & Intervention in the Community
- Vol. 52 (3-4) , 379-399
Rural territories in socio-environmental crisis: Challenges and opportunities for building sustainable schools and communities in Chile
The Chilean model of economic development, based on the extraction of natural resources, has had significant environmental and social impacts on the country, especially in rural areas. The research project "Towards the construction of sustainable schools and communities in rural areas in socio-environmental crises" studies the interaction between the unregulated exploitation of natural resources, the resulting socio-environmental crises and the responses of schools and communities in the affected rural areas. Based on a documentary and socio-bibliometric approach, identifying the main issues and research gaps related to the socio-environmental crises in the selected territories. The research showed that there are few studies on the role of rural schools and community organizations in the addressing of the socio-environmental crises of the territories and the fostering of long-term educational and community resilience. This reflects the low visibility that these communities are receiving, despite their significant potential on the matter.
- 1 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Prevention & Intervention in the Community
- Vol. 52 (3-4) , 379-399
Rural territories in socio-environmental crisis: Challenges and opportunities for building sustainable schools and communities in Chile
The Chilean model of economic development, based on the extraction of natural resources, has had significant environmental and social impacts on the country, especially in rural areas. The research project "Towards the construction of sustainable schools and communities in rural areas in socio-environmental crises" studies the interaction between the unregulated exploitation of natural resources, the resulting socio-environmental crises and the responses of schools and communities in the affected rural areas. Based on a documentary and socio-bibliometric approach, identifying the main issues and research gaps related to the socio-environmental crises in the selected territories. The research showed that there are few studies on the role of rural schools and community organizations in the addressing of the socio-environmental crises of the territories and the fostering of long-term educational and community resilience. This reflects the low visibility that these communities are receiving, despite their significant potential on the matter.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 60 (4) , e70000
“Psychoanalysts are always at the same time doctors and patients and can be cured as doctors.” An analysis of Karl Kraus's antipsychoanalytic aphorisms (1905–1930)
Karl Kraus was one of the most important and influential personalities in Vienna at the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century; he was the founder and life director of the magazine Die Fackel, famous for leading important debates with writers, poets, journalists, and psychoanalysts. At the beginning of the 20th century, Freud wanted to win Kraus's sympathy because he believed that having him on his side was essential for psychoanalysis to penetrate the artistic and cultural circle of Vienna. As will be shown in this article, the alliance between the two was never consummated and, on the contrary, they became antagonists, with Ernst Jones naming Kraus “Freud's greatest enemy.” In this paper, mentions of Freud and psychoanalysis in Die Fackel between 1905 and 1930 were identified and subsequently, 26 aphorisms written by Kraus through the post‐structural linguistic approach were analyzed. A sample from the digital collection AAC‐FACKEL of the Austrian Academy Corpus was used. Early writings reveal that Kraus came to regard psychoanalysis as an ally in his struggle against Austrian sexual morality, yet he was always wary of its invasion of the intimate lives of individuals. Kraus criticized Freud's explanation of female hysteria and instead considered that the root of female suffering was due to their inability to give themselves individuality. It can be concluded that although Kraus was a severe critic of psychoanalysis, at many times he viewed some of its postulates with sympathy, to the point that he considered his aphorisms to be a kind of attenuated psychoanalysis; that is, without the exaggerated presence of sexual elements or interpretations.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 60 (4) , e70000
“Psychoanalysts are always at the same time doctors and patients and can be cured as doctors.” An analysis of Karl Kraus's antipsychoanalytic aphorisms (1905–1930)
Karl Kraus was one of the most important and influential personalities in Vienna at the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century; he was the founder and life director of the magazine Die Fackel, famous for leading important debates with writers, poets, journalists, and psychoanalysts. At the beginning of the 20th century, Freud wanted to win Kraus's sympathy because he believed that having him on his side was essential for psychoanalysis to penetrate the artistic and cultural circle of Vienna. As will be shown in this article, the alliance between the two was never consummated and, on the contrary, they became antagonists, with Ernst Jones naming Kraus “Freud's greatest enemy.” In this paper, mentions of Freud and psychoanalysis in Die Fackel between 1905 and 1930 were identified and subsequently, 26 aphorisms written by Kraus through the post‐structural linguistic approach were analyzed. A sample from the digital collection AAC‐FACKEL of the Austrian Academy Corpus was used. Early writings reveal that Kraus came to regard psychoanalysis as an ally in his struggle against Austrian sexual morality, yet he was always wary of its invasion of the intimate lives of individuals. Kraus criticized Freud's explanation of female hysteria and instead considered that the root of female suffering was due to their inability to give themselves individuality. It can be concluded that although Kraus was a severe critic of psychoanalysis, at many times he viewed some of its postulates with sympathy, to the point that he considered his aphorisms to be a kind of attenuated psychoanalysis; that is, without the exaggerated presence of sexual elements or interpretations.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in History of Psychology
- Vol. 27 (1) , 24-53
“My Opponent Prof. W.”: The debate between Wilhelm Wundt and Adolf Horwicz in the beginning of physiological psychology (1872–1879).
Adolf Horwicz (1831-1894) was the main public critic of Wilhelm Wundt's election for the chair of philosophy at the Universität Leipzig in 1875. Horwicz's book titled Psychologische Analysen auf physiologischer Grundlage published in 1872 had a great impact on his contemporaries. Two years later, Wundt published Grundzüge der physiologischen Psychologie (1874) and with Horwicz's books were recognized as the most representative books of the emerging physiological psychology. Finally, Horwicz and Wundt had a debate published in Vierteljahrsschrift für wissenschaftliche Philosophie during 1879-1880 in where Wundt affirmed that many of Horwicz's research results were deduced from preconceived ideas without using a clear method. For that reason, Horwicz considered that Wundt's criticisms were aimed at destroying his scientific reputation. The debate is the materialization of a long professional struggle that took place between professional philosophers and physiologists who began to occupy chairs of philosophy in the early 1870s. The debate can be summarized in the following questions: (a) Should psychology have as its main objective the search for a single physical-biological process to which all other psychical processes are reduced? (b) Should psychological research use an inductivist reasoning? (c) What should be the relationship between philosophy and the psychological psychology? (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 February 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in History of Psychology
- Vol. 27 (1) , 24-53
“My Opponent Prof. W.”: The debate between Wilhelm Wundt and Adolf Horwicz in the beginning of physiological psychology (1872–1879).
Adolf Horwicz (1831-1894) was the main public critic of Wilhelm Wundt's election for the chair of philosophy at the Universität Leipzig in 1875. Horwicz's book titled Psychologische Analysen auf physiologischer Grundlage published in 1872 had a great impact on his contemporaries. Two years later, Wundt published Grundzüge der physiologischen Psychologie (1874) and with Horwicz's books were recognized as the most representative books of the emerging physiological psychology. Finally, Horwicz and Wundt had a debate published in Vierteljahrsschrift für wissenschaftliche Philosophie during 1879-1880 in where Wundt affirmed that many of Horwicz's research results were deduced from preconceived ideas without using a clear method. For that reason, Horwicz considered that Wundt's criticisms were aimed at destroying his scientific reputation. The debate is the materialization of a long professional struggle that took place between professional philosophers and physiologists who began to occupy chairs of philosophy in the early 1870s. The debate can be summarized in the following questions: (a) Should psychology have as its main objective the search for a single physical-biological process to which all other psychical processes are reduced? (b) Should psychological research use an inductivist reasoning? (c) What should be the relationship between philosophy and the psychological psychology? (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).