Marjorie Gail Weber
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Marjorie Gail Weber has a total of 88 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Carolyn D. K. Graham
University of Michigan
6 shared publications - Cissy J. Ballen
Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA
3 shared publications Samantha Molino
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Michigan Ann Arbor 48109 Michigan USA
3 shared publicationsAbrianna J. Soule
Ecology and Evolutionary Biology Department, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA
2 shared publications- Abrianna J. Soule
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Michigan Ann Arbor Michigan USA
2 shared publications Addison L. Yerks
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Michigan Ann Arbor 48109 Michigan USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Divergent investment in direct versus indirect defense in Populus tremuloides across a latitudinal gradient
Theory predicts that plant defense against herbivores should be greatest towards the equator due to the strong selective pressure of more populous and diverse herbivore communities; yet recent work suggests variation in plant defense is more complex, predicting divergent patterns of investment across defense types and underlying environmental drivers. To address gaps in previous research, we measure multiple defense types in the same species and consider both biotic and abiotic variables hypothesized to underlie latitudinal gradients. Using the tree species trembling aspen ( Populus tremuloides ), we combine field surveys of biotic interactions and defense traits with climate data and metabolomic analysis of plant chemistry across a continental scale latitudinal gradient. While some metrics of defense investment were greater at lower latitudes, we found that the environmental variables underlying variation in defense traits differed across defense types, with direct defense (i.e., chemistry) decreasing along a precipitation gradient and indirect defense (i.e., extrafloral nectaries) increasing with temperature and growing season length. Incorporating proxies for predation and herbivory pressure further suggested variation in defensive traits is driven by an interplay between biotic and abiotic variables. Together, our findings reinforce that, even within a single species, different defense strategies can correlate with distinct environmental variables across latitude, consistent with complexity in the selective mechanisms shaping defense variation across space. These results illustrate the importance of considering the full scope of defense strategies and environmental pressures when testing classic hypotheses of plant defense.
Open AccessDivergent investment in direct versus indirect defense in Populus tremuloides across a latitudinal gradient
Theory predicts that plant defense against herbivores should be greatest towards the equator due to the strong selective pressure of more populous and diverse herbivore communities; yet recent work suggests variation in plant defense is more complex, predicting divergent patterns of investment across defense types and underlying environmental drivers. To address gaps in previous research, we measure multiple defense types in the same species and consider both biotic and abiotic variables hypothesized to underlie latitudinal gradients. Using the tree species trembling aspen ( Populus tremuloides ), we combine field surveys of biotic interactions and defense traits with climate data and metabolomic analysis of plant chemistry across a continental scale latitudinal gradient. While some metrics of defense investment were greater at lower latitudes, we found that the environmental variables underlying variation in defense traits differed across defense types, with direct defense (i.e., chemistry) decreasing along a precipitation gradient and indirect defense (i.e., extrafloral nectaries) increasing with temperature and growing season length. Incorporating proxies for predation and herbivory pressure further suggested variation in defensive traits is driven by an interplay between biotic and abiotic variables. Together, our findings reinforce that, even within a single species, different defense strategies can correlate with distinct environmental variables across latitude, consistent with complexity in the selective mechanisms shaping defense variation across space. These results illustrate the importance of considering the full scope of defense strategies and environmental pressures when testing classic hypotheses of plant defense.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Symbiosis
- Vol. 100 (1) , 1-11
Micromorphology and chemistry of mite domatia: mutualistic trait convergence and variation across eight sympatric north American species
Mite domatia — small structures on plant leaves that house mutualistic mites — are widespread across plants yet remain relatively understudied. Here we investigate the chemistry and micromorphology of mite domatia across sympatric species of broadleaf deciduous woody species that have convergently evolved tuft-form mite domatia. Specifically, we test whether domatia display similar micromorphological and chemical properties using metabolomics and scanning electron microscopy across multiple independent sympatric lineages. To identify domatia-specific phenotypes, we also compare tissue within domatia to that of nearby leaf tissue on each of the four domatium-bearing species, and test whether species with domatia exhibit reduced chemical defense relative to species that lack domatia using four additional species that lack prominent domatia as a control. We found that domatium-bearing species had significantly lower total phenolic concentrations and lower total defense compound abundance compared to control species, consistent with an evolutionary trade-off between chemical and mutualistic defense. However, within leaves, domatium tissue chemical defense did not differ from surrounding laminar tissue. In contrast, trichome morphology showed clear convergent modification: domatium trichomes were 24–31% longer than trichomes elsewhere on the leaf, a pattern reversed in control species. Together, our findings shed light on the degree of phenotypic convergence in a widespread, ecologically important trait.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Symbiosis
- Vol. 100 (1) , 1-11
Open AccessMicromorphology and chemistry of mite domatia: mutualistic trait convergence and variation across eight sympatric north American species
Mite domatia — small structures on plant leaves that house mutualistic mites — are widespread across plants yet remain relatively understudied. Here we investigate the chemistry and micromorphology of mite domatia across sympatric species of broadleaf deciduous woody species that have convergently evolved tuft-form mite domatia. Specifically, we test whether domatia display similar micromorphological and chemical properties using metabolomics and scanning electron microscopy across multiple independent sympatric lineages. To identify domatia-specific phenotypes, we also compare tissue within domatia to that of nearby leaf tissue on each of the four domatium-bearing species, and test whether species with domatia exhibit reduced chemical defense relative to species that lack domatia using four additional species that lack prominent domatia as a control. We found that domatium-bearing species had significantly lower total phenolic concentrations and lower total defense compound abundance compared to control species, consistent with an evolutionary trade-off between chemical and mutualistic defense. However, within leaves, domatium tissue chemical defense did not differ from surrounding laminar tissue. In contrast, trichome morphology showed clear convergent modification: domatium trichomes were 24–31% longer than trichomes elsewhere on the leaf, a pattern reversed in control species. Together, our findings shed light on the degree of phenotypic convergence in a widespread, ecologically important trait.
- Open Access
- 9 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Botany
- Vol. 113 (3) , e70173
Characterizing the causes and consequences of calcium oxalate crystal presence in Vitis riparia
Premise: Calcium oxalate biomineralization in plants is phylogenetically widespread and morphologically diverse, but the function of these inorganic crystals is an area of active debate. The variety of environmental conditions that produce the crystals, as well as the inconsistent evidence that they provide antiherbivore defense across plant and herbivore species, suggests that different crystal morphologies might have different functions. Methods: Using Vitis riparia , or riverbank grape, we experimentally investigated the environmental influence of excess calcium and simulated herbivory on the formation of calcium oxalate druse and raphide crystals in leaves. We also investigated the putative defensive function of these crystals by using a no‐choice herbivore bioassay manipulating herbivore diet composition to test for impacts of crystal shape on herbivore growth, both on its own and with plant chemistry. Results: We found that the addition of calcium to soil increased the density of both raphide and druse crystals in V. riparia leaves. Contrary to expectations, the herbivory treatment decreased the density of raphides in leaves, and V. riparia ‐derived crystals did not impact weight gain, time to pupation, or survival of moth larvae. Conclusions: Our multifaceted test of the formation and function of calcium oxalate crystals in riverbank grape demonstrates that an abiotic factor (i.e., soil calcium) is a relatively stronger determinant of crystal production and that, contrary to hundreds of years of speculation on their function, these crystals do not seem to mediate plant‐insect herbivory in all plant taxa. Instead, the alternative hypothesis of calcium regulation was supported by our experimental evidence.
- 9 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Botany
- Vol. 113 (3) , e70173
Open AccessCharacterizing the causes and consequences of calcium oxalate crystal presence in Vitis riparia
Premise: Calcium oxalate biomineralization in plants is phylogenetically widespread and morphologically diverse, but the function of these inorganic crystals is an area of active debate. The variety of environmental conditions that produce the crystals, as well as the inconsistent evidence that they provide antiherbivore defense across plant and herbivore species, suggests that different crystal morphologies might have different functions. Methods: Using Vitis riparia , or riverbank grape, we experimentally investigated the environmental influence of excess calcium and simulated herbivory on the formation of calcium oxalate druse and raphide crystals in leaves. We also investigated the putative defensive function of these crystals by using a no‐choice herbivore bioassay manipulating herbivore diet composition to test for impacts of crystal shape on herbivore growth, both on its own and with plant chemistry. Results: We found that the addition of calcium to soil increased the density of both raphide and druse crystals in V. riparia leaves. Contrary to expectations, the herbivory treatment decreased the density of raphides in leaves, and V. riparia ‐derived crystals did not impact weight gain, time to pupation, or survival of moth larvae. Conclusions: Our multifaceted test of the formation and function of calcium oxalate crystals in riverbank grape demonstrates that an abiotic factor (i.e., soil calcium) is a relatively stronger determinant of crystal production and that, contrary to hundreds of years of speculation on their function, these crystals do not seem to mediate plant‐insect herbivory in all plant taxa. Instead, the alternative hypothesis of calcium regulation was supported by our experimental evidence.
- Open Access
Convergent evolution of red pigmentation in extrafloral nectaries: global patterns and mechanisms
Convergent traits are a signature of adaptation, where shared selective pressures may lead to the replicated evolution of traits with similar function. Here, we present an integrative investigation of a widespread yet understudied feature of an iconic, convergent mutualistic plant trait - red pigmentation in extrafloral nectaries (EFNs). We surveyed 625 species to describe the distribution of red coloration in EFNs across plant morphology, biogeography, and phylogeny for the first time and propose several adaptive hypotheses for the drivers of their convergence across plants. We then test several of these hypotheses by integrating our global-scale biogeographic and phylogenetic analysis with phylogenetically paired common garden bioassays and a museum collections survey. We find that across the plant phylogeny, cold wet regions and deserts are hotspots of red EFN coloration, and multiple lines of evidence point to a fungal defense role of red pigments in EFNs. Ultimately, our findings highlight red EFNs as a highly convergent phenotype across plants and point to distinct selective pressures underlying the distribution of EFN coloration and EFNs themselves.
Open AccessConvergent evolution of red pigmentation in extrafloral nectaries: global patterns and mechanisms
Convergent traits are a signature of adaptation, where shared selective pressures may lead to the replicated evolution of traits with similar function. Here, we present an integrative investigation of a widespread yet understudied feature of an iconic, convergent mutualistic plant trait - red pigmentation in extrafloral nectaries (EFNs). We surveyed 625 species to describe the distribution of red coloration in EFNs across plant morphology, biogeography, and phylogeny for the first time and propose several adaptive hypotheses for the drivers of their convergence across plants. We then test several of these hypotheses by integrating our global-scale biogeographic and phylogenetic analysis with phylogenetically paired common garden bioassays and a museum collections survey. We find that across the plant phylogeny, cold wet regions and deserts are hotspots of red EFN coloration, and multiple lines of evidence point to a fungal defense role of red pigments in EFNs. Ultimately, our findings highlight red EFNs as a highly convergent phenotype across plants and point to distinct selective pressures underlying the distribution of EFN coloration and EFNs themselves.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Functional Ecology
- Vol. 40 (3) , 736-749
Separate and synergistic anti‐herbivore effects of non‐glandular trichomes and leaf chemistry in a desert plant
Plant defence phenotypes commonly integrate physical and chemical traits that may act synergistically against herbivores, but empirical evidence for synergy as a defence strategy remains limited. We experimentally tested the separate and combined effects of two common plant defences, non‐glandular trichomes and leaf metabolites, on the feeding, behaviour and performance of a generalist herbivore. We conducted choice and no‐choice assays that exposed beet armyworm caterpillars ( Spodoptera exigua , Noctuidae) to desert stingbush ( Eucnide urens , Loasaceae) leaves with manipulated trichome cover and raised caterpillars on a diet containing factorial combinations of E. urens trichomes and leaf extracts. We assessed differences in caterpillar behaviour, performance, and survival across treatments. We found a significant interactive effect of trichomes and leaf metabolites that markedly decreased caterpillar growth, providing evidence for a defence synergism. Both defences also reduced caterpillar performance individually. Leaf extracts contained a high proportion of putatively defensive compounds, including iridoid glycosides, which were associated with reduced caterpillar growth and high mortality before pupation. Barbed trichomes impeded caterpillar movement and, when consumed, caused mandible damage and reduced eclosion rates compared to controls. Our results indicate that two commonly co‐expressed plant defences can synergistically reduce herbivore performance. These findings provide a rare example of trait synergy as a defence strategy and represent a step forward in the effort to study plant defence holistically, as suites or syndromes of defences, rather than isolated traits. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- 20 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Functional Ecology
- Vol. 40 (3) , 736-749
Open AccessSeparate and synergistic anti‐herbivore effects of non‐glandular trichomes and leaf chemistry in a desert plant
Plant defence phenotypes commonly integrate physical and chemical traits that may act synergistically against herbivores, but empirical evidence for synergy as a defence strategy remains limited. We experimentally tested the separate and combined effects of two common plant defences, non‐glandular trichomes and leaf metabolites, on the feeding, behaviour and performance of a generalist herbivore. We conducted choice and no‐choice assays that exposed beet armyworm caterpillars ( Spodoptera exigua , Noctuidae) to desert stingbush ( Eucnide urens , Loasaceae) leaves with manipulated trichome cover and raised caterpillars on a diet containing factorial combinations of E. urens trichomes and leaf extracts. We assessed differences in caterpillar behaviour, performance, and survival across treatments. We found a significant interactive effect of trichomes and leaf metabolites that markedly decreased caterpillar growth, providing evidence for a defence synergism. Both defences also reduced caterpillar performance individually. Leaf extracts contained a high proportion of putatively defensive compounds, including iridoid glycosides, which were associated with reduced caterpillar growth and high mortality before pupation. Barbed trichomes impeded caterpillar movement and, when consumed, caused mandible damage and reduced eclosion rates compared to controls. Our results indicate that two commonly co‐expressed plant defences can synergistically reduce herbivore performance. These findings provide a rare example of trait synergy as a defence strategy and represent a step forward in the effort to study plant defence holistically, as suites or syndromes of defences, rather than isolated traits. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Open Access
Opposing seasonal dynamics in phylogenetic and flower color diversity of co-flowering wildflower assemblages
Flower color is a key trait mediating plant-pollinator interactions, yet the ecological rules governing its distribution across co-flowering assemblages remain poorly understood. We examined spatiotemporal patterns of flower color and phylogenetic diversity in Eastern North American wildflowers to test for non-random community structure, seasonal shifts, and associations between flower color similarity and phylogenetic relatedness. Using occurrence, phenology, and color data from community science datasets, we reconstructed communities of co-flowering assemblages and calculated standardized effect sizes of mean pairwise distances for both flower color and phylogenetic relatedness. We analyzed seasonal trends using mixed models and assessed whether closely related species co-flowered non-randomly with respect to color similarity using bootstrap correlations. We found that, on average, co-flowering assemblages were overdispersed for both flower color and phylogeny. However, flower color dispersion significantly decreased over the growing season, while phylogenetic dispersion significantly increased, reflecting a pattern in which co-flowering assemblages shifted to more distantly related but similarly colored assemblages. Finally, color and phylogenetic dispersion were negatively correlated across communities, indicating that communities composed of more closely related species tended to exhibit more dissimilar flowers. Together, our results suggest that wildflower assemblages in Eastern North America show detectable, non-random structure across space and time with respect to color and relatedness at the broad scale, and that mechanisms underlying the structure of co-flowering groups may shift throughout the growing season.
Open AccessOpposing seasonal dynamics in phylogenetic and flower color diversity of co-flowering wildflower assemblages
Flower color is a key trait mediating plant-pollinator interactions, yet the ecological rules governing its distribution across co-flowering assemblages remain poorly understood. We examined spatiotemporal patterns of flower color and phylogenetic diversity in Eastern North American wildflowers to test for non-random community structure, seasonal shifts, and associations between flower color similarity and phylogenetic relatedness. Using occurrence, phenology, and color data from community science datasets, we reconstructed communities of co-flowering assemblages and calculated standardized effect sizes of mean pairwise distances for both flower color and phylogenetic relatedness. We analyzed seasonal trends using mixed models and assessed whether closely related species co-flowered non-randomly with respect to color similarity using bootstrap correlations. We found that, on average, co-flowering assemblages were overdispersed for both flower color and phylogeny. However, flower color dispersion significantly decreased over the growing season, while phylogenetic dispersion significantly increased, reflecting a pattern in which co-flowering assemblages shifted to more distantly related but similarly colored assemblages. Finally, color and phylogenetic dispersion were negatively correlated across communities, indicating that communities composed of more closely related species tended to exhibit more dissimilar flowers. Together, our results suggest that wildflower assemblages in Eastern North America show detectable, non-random structure across space and time with respect to color and relatedness at the broad scale, and that mechanisms underlying the structure of co-flowering groups may shift throughout the growing season.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (9) , e72151
Temperature‐Dependent Shifts in Multiple Indirect Defensive Interactions on Black Cherry
Many plants engage in indirect defense via tri‐trophic interactions whereby plants provide resources such as food or shelter to mutualists in exchange for protection against herbivores and pathogens, increasing plant fitness. As temperature regimes shift under climate change, understanding the influence of temperature on tri‐trophic defensive interactions is increasingly important. However, where plant species host multiple tri‐trophic defensive interactions, we still lack an understanding of if each interaction, even within the same system, responds in the same way to temperature. In this study, we monitored black cherry (Prunus serotina) seedlings for 10 weeks under ambient and increased temperatures to explore the effects of temperature on two different tri‐trophic defensive interactions between black cherry and: (1) mutualistic leaf domatia‐dwelling mites and leaf fungi; and (2) arthropod predators and herbivores. We found that the positive association between mite abundance and domatia size increased by 8.7% on warmed plants, while warming weakened the positive relationship between mite abundance and the abundance of foliar fungi by 14%, though warmer conditions alone did not affect the abundances of any of these groups. Further, warming increased the abundance of arthropod predators by 116% and decreased the amount of herbivory plants experienced by 42%, but did not modify the impact predators had on herbivory. Ultimately, the differences among interacting species with warming did not translate to differences in plant growth, indicating black cherry can be robust to at least some of the variation in species interactions caused by changing temperatures in the short term. These findings illustrate that warming can modify the abundance of, and relationships between, some but not all tri‐trophic defensive interactions in a given system, further confirming that temperature does not impact plant interactions uniformly.
- 18 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (9) , e72151
Open AccessTemperature‐Dependent Shifts in Multiple Indirect Defensive Interactions on Black Cherry
Many plants engage in indirect defense via tri‐trophic interactions whereby plants provide resources such as food or shelter to mutualists in exchange for protection against herbivores and pathogens, increasing plant fitness. As temperature regimes shift under climate change, understanding the influence of temperature on tri‐trophic defensive interactions is increasingly important. However, where plant species host multiple tri‐trophic defensive interactions, we still lack an understanding of if each interaction, even within the same system, responds in the same way to temperature. In this study, we monitored black cherry (Prunus serotina) seedlings for 10 weeks under ambient and increased temperatures to explore the effects of temperature on two different tri‐trophic defensive interactions between black cherry and: (1) mutualistic leaf domatia‐dwelling mites and leaf fungi; and (2) arthropod predators and herbivores. We found that the positive association between mite abundance and domatia size increased by 8.7% on warmed plants, while warming weakened the positive relationship between mite abundance and the abundance of foliar fungi by 14%, though warmer conditions alone did not affect the abundances of any of these groups. Further, warming increased the abundance of arthropod predators by 116% and decreased the amount of herbivory plants experienced by 42%, but did not modify the impact predators had on herbivory. Ultimately, the differences among interacting species with warming did not translate to differences in plant growth, indicating black cherry can be robust to at least some of the variation in species interactions caused by changing temperatures in the short term. These findings illustrate that warming can modify the abundance of, and relationships between, some but not all tri‐trophic defensive interactions in a given system, further confirming that temperature does not impact plant interactions uniformly.
- Open Access
- 23 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (4) , e71379
Mite Domatia and Associated Mite Density in a North American Eastern Deciduous Forest in Michigan
Mite–plant defense mutualisms are among the most common defense mutualisms in the world—yet studies providing basic information on their prevalence in plant communities remain rare. Here, we systematically surveyed common woody plants in a North American deciduous forest for the presence of plant–mite mutualistic interactions. We scored 16 common woody species in a wooded natural area for the presence and number of mite domatia—small structures on the underside of plant leaves that are known to house mutualistic mites. We found that 80% of common woody species in the forest had mite domatia, the highest reported percentage of mite domatia in any survey conducted thus far. We paired our survey with a quantification of the number of mites found on each leaf and investigated the relationship between mite domatia and mite abundance within and across species. We found that plants with mite domatia had significantly more mites on their leaves than species that lacked mite domatia, and that plants with more domatia had more mites. Together, our study provides much needed systematic survey data on plant–mite mutualism prevalence in an important plant community and points to northern temperate forests as a promising system to study plant–mite mutualisms in high densities in the future.
- 23 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (4) , e71379
Open AccessMite Domatia and Associated Mite Density in a North American Eastern Deciduous Forest in Michigan
Mite–plant defense mutualisms are among the most common defense mutualisms in the world—yet studies providing basic information on their prevalence in plant communities remain rare. Here, we systematically surveyed common woody plants in a North American deciduous forest for the presence of plant–mite mutualistic interactions. We scored 16 common woody species in a wooded natural area for the presence and number of mite domatia—small structures on the underside of plant leaves that are known to house mutualistic mites. We found that 80% of common woody species in the forest had mite domatia, the highest reported percentage of mite domatia in any survey conducted thus far. We paired our survey with a quantification of the number of mites found on each leaf and investigated the relationship between mite domatia and mite abundance within and across species. We found that plants with mite domatia had significantly more mites on their leaves than species that lacked mite domatia, and that plants with more domatia had more mites. Together, our study provides much needed systematic survey data on plant–mite mutualism prevalence in an important plant community and points to northern temperate forests as a promising system to study plant–mite mutualisms in high densities in the future.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 79 (6) , 1056-1072
Multiple metrics of trichome diversity support independent evolutionary hypotheses in blazingstars ( Mentzelia : Loasaceae)
Trichomes are diverse and functionally important plant structures that vary in response to selection pressures across ecological gradients and evolutionary timescales. Classic hypotheses predict higher investment in trichomes in arid environments, at lower latitudes, and in long-lived species, as well as shifts in trichome production to reduce conflict between defense traits and mutualisms. However, tests of these hypotheses often rely on aggregate trichome metrics and neglect the rich diversity of trichome phenotypes. Here, we collected data on fine-scale patterns of trichome length, density, and type in 52 species of blazingstars (Mentzelia: Loasaceae) and tested whether individual trichome traits were consistent with existing adaptive hypotheses. Contrary to longstanding hypotheses, we found that Mentzelia species tend to display greater trichome investment in less arid environments and at higher latitudes. Barbed trichomes are significantly less common on the upper surface of the leaf, possibly reducing defense–pollination conflict. Species with larger petals (a proxy for reliance on insect pollinators) also shift investment away from insect-trapping hairs on the underside of the leaf. Examining trichome types separately revealed that different morphologies show distinct responses to abiotic and biotic factors, demonstrating the need to consider multiple axes of diversity when testing adaptive hypotheses for complex traits.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 79 (6) , 1056-1072
Multiple metrics of trichome diversity support independent evolutionary hypotheses in blazingstars ( Mentzelia : Loasaceae)
Trichomes are diverse and functionally important plant structures that vary in response to selection pressures across ecological gradients and evolutionary timescales. Classic hypotheses predict higher investment in trichomes in arid environments, at lower latitudes, and in long-lived species, as well as shifts in trichome production to reduce conflict between defense traits and mutualisms. However, tests of these hypotheses often rely on aggregate trichome metrics and neglect the rich diversity of trichome phenotypes. Here, we collected data on fine-scale patterns of trichome length, density, and type in 52 species of blazingstars (Mentzelia: Loasaceae) and tested whether individual trichome traits were consistent with existing adaptive hypotheses. Contrary to longstanding hypotheses, we found that Mentzelia species tend to display greater trichome investment in less arid environments and at higher latitudes. Barbed trichomes are significantly less common on the upper surface of the leaf, possibly reducing defense–pollination conflict. Species with larger petals (a proxy for reliance on insect pollinators) also shift investment away from insect-trapping hairs on the underside of the leaf. Examining trichome types separately revealed that different morphologies show distinct responses to abiotic and biotic factors, demonstrating the need to consider multiple axes of diversity when testing adaptive hypotheses for complex traits.
- Open Access
- 19 March 2025
- Published by Journal of Pollination Ecology (ASBL) in Journal of Pollination Ecology
- Vol. 38, 58-75
Increased reliance on diurnal pollination in a geographically and morphologically atypical sand verbena
Premise—Pollinator-mediated selection drives floral morphologies to converge on sets of traits deemed “pollination syndromes”. As a result of similarity due to common descent, pollination syndromes can be shared among closely related plants in cases where pollinators remain relatively constant over evolutionary time. In these cases, species that display trait deviations away from their ancestral states may indicate hidden pollinator shifts. Identifying when and where trait deviations reflect reproductive contributions from unexpected pollinators is important for understanding the boundaries and cohesion of pollination syndrome phenotypes. Methods—The floral morphology of heart’s delight, Abronia ameliae, unites a collection of traditional moth-pollination syndrome traits, typical for the genus, with several characters odd for moth pollination, including diurnally open, pink flowers and large, tall inflorescences. We predicted that the evolution of this combination of traits reflects a change in pollinators from other Abronia, specifically that this species is primarily diurnally-pollinated. We conducted pollinator-exclusion experiments in a natural population and a common garden to determine the independent reproductive contributions of diurnal and nocturnal pollinators to A. ameliae and characterized its volatile profile. Results—We found that A. ameliae is indeed primarily diurnally pollinated: visitation by day-active butterflies and moths contributed to higher seed set than visitation by nocturnal moths. However, A. ameliae also emits nocturnal moth-associated volatile compounds and receives considerable nocturnal pollination. Conclusions—We suggest that the unusual phenotypes found in A. ameliae flowers relative to the genus reflect a shift in reproductive contributions to incorporate mostly diurnal pollination and transition to a mixed pollination strategy that blends diurnal and nocturnal pollination phenotypes.
- 19 March 2025
- Published by Journal of Pollination Ecology (ASBL) in Journal of Pollination Ecology
- Vol. 38, 58-75
Open AccessIncreased reliance on diurnal pollination in a geographically and morphologically atypical sand verbena
Premise—Pollinator-mediated selection drives floral morphologies to converge on sets of traits deemed “pollination syndromes”. As a result of similarity due to common descent, pollination syndromes can be shared among closely related plants in cases where pollinators remain relatively constant over evolutionary time. In these cases, species that display trait deviations away from their ancestral states may indicate hidden pollinator shifts. Identifying when and where trait deviations reflect reproductive contributions from unexpected pollinators is important for understanding the boundaries and cohesion of pollination syndrome phenotypes. Methods—The floral morphology of heart’s delight, Abronia ameliae, unites a collection of traditional moth-pollination syndrome traits, typical for the genus, with several characters odd for moth pollination, including diurnally open, pink flowers and large, tall inflorescences. We predicted that the evolution of this combination of traits reflects a change in pollinators from other Abronia, specifically that this species is primarily diurnally-pollinated. We conducted pollinator-exclusion experiments in a natural population and a common garden to determine the independent reproductive contributions of diurnal and nocturnal pollinators to A. ameliae and characterized its volatile profile. Results—We found that A. ameliae is indeed primarily diurnally pollinated: visitation by day-active butterflies and moths contributed to higher seed set than visitation by nocturnal moths. However, A. ameliae also emits nocturnal moth-associated volatile compounds and receives considerable nocturnal pollination. Conclusions—We suggest that the unusual phenotypes found in A. ameliae flowers relative to the genus reflect a shift in reproductive contributions to incorporate mostly diurnal pollination and transition to a mixed pollination strategy that blends diurnal and nocturnal pollination phenotypes.