Timothy Paul Craig
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Timothy Paul Craig has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Joanne K. Itami
Department of Biology University of Minnesota Duluth Duluth Minnesota 55812 USA
6 shared publicationsTakayuki Ohgushi
Center for Ecological Research, Kyoto University, Otsu, Japan
3 shared publications- Joanne K. Itami
Department of Life Sciences, P.O. Box 37100, Arizona State University West, Phoenix, Arizona 85069
2 shared publications - John D. Horner
Department of Biology, Texas Christian University, Fort Worth, USA
2 shared publications - Shunsuke Utsumi
Hokkaido University
2 shared publications Annelie Livingston‐Anderson
Department of Biology University of Minnesota Duluth Duluth Minnesota 55812 USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 October 2024
- Published by Pacific Coast Entomological Society in The Pan-Pacific Entomologist
- Vol. 100 (4) , 348-360
The evolutionary implications of genetic variation among Solidago altissima L. (Asteraceae) genotype in the morphology of galls induced by Eurosta solidaginis Fitch, 1855 (Diptera: Tephritidae)
To contribute to the understanding of the coevolution of the gall-inducing tephritid fly, Eurosta solidaginis Fitch, 1855 (Diptera: Tephritidae), and its host plant, tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima L. (Asteraceae), we tested hypotheses on how plant genotypic variation influenced gall size and shape. A field survey showed that stem diameter was correlated with gall diameter, indicating that plant phenotype influences gall size. To test the hypothesis that plant genotypic variation in stem growth influenced gall diameter, length, and shape, 10 goldenrod genotypes were grown in a common garden and exposed to flies in a cage in 2019 and 2020. Plant genotype significantly influenced gall diameter and length in both years and gall shape in the second year of the experiment. Our results support those of Weis & Abrahamson (1986), who found that S. altissima gall diameter results from the interaction of plant genotype, insect genotype, and the environment. Neither stem diameter nor length significantly impacted gall diameter, length, or shape in the common garden experiments, suggesting plant genotype influences these traits through other factors uncorrelated with stem growth. Because genetic variation in gall size is weakly correlated with stem growth, this removes restraints on plant response in the evolution of gall size in response to selection by Eurosta.
- 1 October 2024
- Published by Pacific Coast Entomological Society in The Pan-Pacific Entomologist
- Vol. 100 (4) , 348-360
The evolutionary implications of genetic variation among Solidago altissima L. (Asteraceae) genotype in the morphology of galls induced by Eurosta solidaginis Fitch, 1855 (Diptera: Tephritidae)
To contribute to the understanding of the coevolution of the gall-inducing tephritid fly, Eurosta solidaginis Fitch, 1855 (Diptera: Tephritidae), and its host plant, tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima L. (Asteraceae), we tested hypotheses on how plant genotypic variation influenced gall size and shape. A field survey showed that stem diameter was correlated with gall diameter, indicating that plant phenotype influences gall size. To test the hypothesis that plant genotypic variation in stem growth influenced gall diameter, length, and shape, 10 goldenrod genotypes were grown in a common garden and exposed to flies in a cage in 2019 and 2020. Plant genotype significantly influenced gall diameter and length in both years and gall shape in the second year of the experiment. Our results support those of Weis & Abrahamson (1986), who found that S. altissima gall diameter results from the interaction of plant genotype, insect genotype, and the environment. Neither stem diameter nor length significantly impacted gall diameter, length, or shape in the common garden experiments, suggesting plant genotype influences these traits through other factors uncorrelated with stem growth. Because genetic variation in gall size is weakly correlated with stem growth, this removes restraints on plant response in the evolution of gall size in response to selection by Eurosta.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2023
- Published by Wiley
The impact of plant genetic variation, drought, and leaf nitrogen on plant-herbivore interactions
Plant genotype, drought stress, and their interaction are among the factors contributing to the susceptibility of the tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima, to herbivory by the chrysanthemum lace bug, Corythucha marmorata. The plant’s concentration of nitrogen, a critical and often limiting nutrient, differs with plant genotype and drought, but few studies have investigated the impact of the interaction of genotype and drought on herbivory and plant nitrogen. We established a common garden in Duluth, MN, of tall goldenrod collected from a local Minnesota site to analyze the effects of goldenrod genotype and drought on leaf nitrogen and lace bug preference and performance. Lace bugs had oviposition, nymph, and adult preferences among host plant genotypes, drought treatments, and among genotype and drought combinations. Nymph and adult survival and adult weight varied significantly due to plant genotype, drought treatment, the interaction of plant and drought treatment, and the interaction of treatment with lace bug density. Oviposition preference and offspring performance were significantly positively related. Leaf nitrogen increased with the increasing severity of the drought treatment in the absence of lace bugs. However, in the presence of lace bugs, there was no difference in nitrogen among drought treatments. We hypothesize that lace bugs feed on plants until nitrogen concentration reduces to a lower threshold and then move between plants until they have equalized the nitrogen concentration among all plants.
- 18 September 2023
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessThe impact of plant genetic variation, drought, and leaf nitrogen on plant-herbivore interactions
Plant genotype, drought stress, and their interaction are among the factors contributing to the susceptibility of the tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima, to herbivory by the chrysanthemum lace bug, Corythucha marmorata. The plant’s concentration of nitrogen, a critical and often limiting nutrient, differs with plant genotype and drought, but few studies have investigated the impact of the interaction of genotype and drought on herbivory and plant nitrogen. We established a common garden in Duluth, MN, of tall goldenrod collected from a local Minnesota site to analyze the effects of goldenrod genotype and drought on leaf nitrogen and lace bug preference and performance. Lace bugs had oviposition, nymph, and adult preferences among host plant genotypes, drought treatments, and among genotype and drought combinations. Nymph and adult survival and adult weight varied significantly due to plant genotype, drought treatment, the interaction of plant and drought treatment, and the interaction of treatment with lace bug density. Oviposition preference and offspring performance were significantly positively related. Leaf nitrogen increased with the increasing severity of the drought treatment in the absence of lace bugs. However, in the presence of lace bugs, there was no difference in nitrogen among drought treatments. We hypothesize that lace bugs feed on plants until nitrogen concentration reduces to a lower threshold and then move between plants until they have equalized the nitrogen concentration among all plants.
- 2 November 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 75 (12) , 3056-3070
A geographic mosaic of coevolution between Eurosta solidaginis (Fitch) and its host plant tall goldenrod Solidago altissima (L.)
A geographic mosaic of coevolution has produced local reciprocal adaptation in tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima (L.), and the goldenrod ball-gall fly, Eurosta solidaginis (Fitch 1855). The fly is selected to induce gall diameters that minimize mortality from natural enemies, and the plant is selected to limit gall growth that reduces plant fitness. We conducted a double reciprocal transplant experiment where S. altissima and E. solidaginis from three sites were grown in gardens at each site to partition the gall morphology variation into fly genotype, plant genotype, and the environment components. The host plant gall diameter induced by each E. solidaginis population was adapted to inhibit local natural enemies from ovipositing on or consuming enclosed larvae. Reciprocally, increasing the gall size induced by the local fly population increased the resistance of the local plant host population to gall growth. Differences among sites in natural enemies produced a mosaic of hotspots of coevolutionary arms races between flies selecting for greater gall diameter and plants for smaller diameters, and coldspots where there is no selection on plant or fly for a change in gall diameter. In contrast, the geographic variations of gall length and gall shape were not due to coevolutionary interactions. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved
- 2 November 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 75 (12) , 3056-3070
A geographic mosaic of coevolution between Eurosta solidaginis (Fitch) and its host plant tall goldenrod Solidago altissima (L.)
A geographic mosaic of coevolution has produced local reciprocal adaptation in tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima (L.), and the goldenrod ball-gall fly, Eurosta solidaginis (Fitch 1855). The fly is selected to induce gall diameters that minimize mortality from natural enemies, and the plant is selected to limit gall growth that reduces plant fitness. We conducted a double reciprocal transplant experiment where S. altissima and E. solidaginis from three sites were grown in gardens at each site to partition the gall morphology variation into fly genotype, plant genotype, and the environment components. The host plant gall diameter induced by each E. solidaginis population was adapted to inhibit local natural enemies from ovipositing on or consuming enclosed larvae. Reciprocally, increasing the gall size induced by the local fly population increased the resistance of the local plant host population to gall growth. Differences among sites in natural enemies produced a mosaic of hotspots of coevolutionary arms races between flies selecting for greater gall diameter and plants for smaller diameters, and coldspots where there is no selection on plant or fly for a change in gall diameter. In contrast, the geographic variations of gall length and gall shape were not due to coevolutionary interactions. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved
- Open Access
A small‐tiled geographic mosaic of coevolution between Eurosta solidaginis and its natural enemies and host plant
We identified a geographic mosaic of Eurosta solidaginis fly traits produced by coevolution of the stem gall‐forming fly with both its natural enemies and its host plants at small geographic scales in the presence of gene flow. These tritrophic interactions between the fly with its natural enemies and with its host‐plant Solidago altissima produced what has been termed a small‐tiled geographic mosaic of coevolution. Selection on gall diameter and length varies between prairie and forest habitats due to differences in host plants and natural‐enemy communities. At the prairie–forest ecotone where prairie and forest habitats are intermixed, we found that geographic selection mosaics on gall diameter and length varied on a scale of a few kilometers. Gall diameter variation among sites correlated with selection on gall diameters, indicating local adaptation. In contrast, gall lengths did not correlate with selection, indicating that gene flow may have prevented local adaptation of this trait. Eastern (forest) and western (prairie) subspecies of E. solidaginis have been proposed based on fly wing patterns, and these had intermediate forms in the ecotone indicating gene flow between these subspecies. Variation in wing patterns correlated with gall diameter, indicating that gene flow between prairie and forest fly populations may influence the distribution of gall traits. The ratio of forest to prairie vegetation increases with latitude, but there was no indication of latitudinal clines in gall or wing traits. Our results indicate that selection for differentiation in coevolved traits is strong enough to overcome gene flow in small tiles of habitat. The result is that ecological forces produce a dynamic mosaic of genetically differentiated locally adapted populations. It also indicates that prairie and forest host races of E. solidaginis form a mosaic hybrid zone in this region.
Open AccessA small‐tiled geographic mosaic of coevolution between Eurosta solidaginis and its natural enemies and host plant
We identified a geographic mosaic of Eurosta solidaginis fly traits produced by coevolution of the stem gall‐forming fly with both its natural enemies and its host plants at small geographic scales in the presence of gene flow. These tritrophic interactions between the fly with its natural enemies and with its host‐plant Solidago altissima produced what has been termed a small‐tiled geographic mosaic of coevolution. Selection on gall diameter and length varies between prairie and forest habitats due to differences in host plants and natural‐enemy communities. At the prairie–forest ecotone where prairie and forest habitats are intermixed, we found that geographic selection mosaics on gall diameter and length varied on a scale of a few kilometers. Gall diameter variation among sites correlated with selection on gall diameters, indicating local adaptation. In contrast, gall lengths did not correlate with selection, indicating that gene flow may have prevented local adaptation of this trait. Eastern (forest) and western (prairie) subspecies of E. solidaginis have been proposed based on fly wing patterns, and these had intermediate forms in the ecotone indicating gene flow between these subspecies. Variation in wing patterns correlated with gall diameter, indicating that gene flow between prairie and forest fly populations may influence the distribution of gall traits. The ratio of forest to prairie vegetation increases with latitude, but there was no indication of latitudinal clines in gall or wing traits. Our results indicate that selection for differentiation in coevolved traits is strong enough to overcome gene flow in small tiles of habitat. The result is that ecological forces produce a dynamic mosaic of genetically differentiated locally adapted populations. It also indicates that prairie and forest host races of E. solidaginis form a mosaic hybrid zone in this region.
- 14 September 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Evolutionary Ecology
- Vol. 32 (5) , 547-559
Evolutionary and environmental effects on the geographical adaptation of herbivory resistance in native and introduced Solidago altissima populations
- 14 September 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Evolutionary Ecology
- Vol. 32 (5) , 547-559
Evolutionary and environmental effects on the geographical adaptation of herbivory resistance in native and introduced Solidago altissima populations
- Open Access
- 11 March 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Plant Interactions
- Vol. 6 (2-3) , 141-145
Bridges and barriers to host shifts resulting from host plant genotypic variation
Host-associated differentiation is hypothesized to be one of the primary means by which new species of herbivorous insects evolve. Divergent selection for host plant use following a host shift is a critical assumption of host-associated differentiation. Host shifts are more likely to occur between closely related host species, and the probability of a host shift and of the evolution of reproductive isolation depends on the genetic variation within both the host plant population and the herbivorous insect. We have been studying the evolution of reproductive isolation in populations of Eurosta solidaginis that form galls on Solidago altissima altissima and Solidago altissima gilvocanescens. Each of the Eurosta populations is a host race that is partially but incompletely isolated from the other host races by its adaptation to its host plants. The Solidago sp. populations show high intraspecific variation within and among populations in their resistance to attack by the host races which are adapted to them. There is also evidence that they vary in their susceptibility to host races adapted to other Solidago species. We examine the hypothesis that the intraspecific Solidago variation determines the degree of gene flow among Eurosta populations and that this can create barriers or bridges to gene flow and therefore determine the course of speciation in these insects. The intraspecific host plant variation can influence the interactions with herbivores when it is an invasive species. The restricted range of genetic variation introduced into a new region may be a good or poor match with populations of herbivores that are also introduced into the new area.
- 11 March 2011
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Plant Interactions
- Vol. 6 (2-3) , 141-145
Open AccessBridges and barriers to host shifts resulting from host plant genotypic variation
Host-associated differentiation is hypothesized to be one of the primary means by which new species of herbivorous insects evolve. Divergent selection for host plant use following a host shift is a critical assumption of host-associated differentiation. Host shifts are more likely to occur between closely related host species, and the probability of a host shift and of the evolution of reproductive isolation depends on the genetic variation within both the host plant population and the herbivorous insect. We have been studying the evolution of reproductive isolation in populations of Eurosta solidaginis that form galls on Solidago altissima altissima and Solidago altissima gilvocanescens. Each of the Eurosta populations is a host race that is partially but incompletely isolated from the other host races by its adaptation to its host plants. The Solidago sp. populations show high intraspecific variation within and among populations in their resistance to attack by the host races which are adapted to them. There is also evidence that they vary in their susceptibility to host races adapted to other Solidago species. We examine the hypothesis that the intraspecific Solidago variation determines the degree of gene flow among Eurosta populations and that this can create barriers or bridges to gene flow and therefore determine the course of speciation in these insects. The intraspecific host plant variation can influence the interactions with herbivores when it is an invasive species. The restricted range of genetic variation introduced into a new region may be a good or poor match with populations of herbivores that are also introduced into the new area.
- 10 November 2010
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 65 (3) , 802-817
DIVERGENCE OF EUROSTA SOLIDAGINIS IN RESPONSE TO HOST PLANT VARIATION AND NATURAL ENEMIES
We tested the hypothesis that forest and prairie populations of the gall-inducing fly, Eurosta solidaginis, have diverged in response to variation in selection by its host plant Solidago altissima, and its natural enemies. A reciprocal cross infection design experiment demonstrated that fly populations from the prairie and forest biomes had higher survival on local biome plants compared to foreign biome host plants. Flies from each biome also had an oviposition preference for their local plants. Each fly population induced galls of the size and shape found in their local biome on host plants from both biomes indicating a genetic basis to the differences in gall morphology. Solidago altissima from the prairie and forest biomes retained significant morphological differences in the common garden indicating that they are genetically differentiated, possibly at the subspecies level. The populations are partially reproductively isolated as a result of a combination of prezygotic isolation due to host-associated assortative mating, and postzygotic isolation due to low hybrid survival. We conclude that E. solidaginis is undergoing diversifying selection to adapt to differences between prairie and forest habitats.
- 10 November 2010
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 65 (3) , 802-817
DIVERGENCE OF EUROSTA SOLIDAGINIS IN RESPONSE TO HOST PLANT VARIATION AND NATURAL ENEMIES
We tested the hypothesis that forest and prairie populations of the gall-inducing fly, Eurosta solidaginis, have diverged in response to variation in selection by its host plant Solidago altissima, and its natural enemies. A reciprocal cross infection design experiment demonstrated that fly populations from the prairie and forest biomes had higher survival on local biome plants compared to foreign biome host plants. Flies from each biome also had an oviposition preference for their local plants. Each fly population induced galls of the size and shape found in their local biome on host plants from both biomes indicating a genetic basis to the differences in gall morphology. Solidago altissima from the prairie and forest biomes retained significant morphological differences in the common garden indicating that they are genetically differentiated, possibly at the subspecies level. The populations are partially reproductively isolated as a result of a combination of prezygotic isolation due to host-associated assortative mating, and postzygotic isolation due to low hybrid survival. We conclude that E. solidaginis is undergoing diversifying selection to adapt to differences between prairie and forest habitats.
- 1 May 2010
- Published by Wiley in Population Ecology
- Vol. 52 (4) , 461-473
The resource regulation hypothesis and positive feedback loops in plant–herbivore interactions
Resource regulation occurs when herbivory maintains or increases plant susceptibility to further herbivory by the same species. A review of the literature indicates it is a widespread plant–animal interaction involving a diverse array of herbivores. At least three mechanisms can produce this positive feedback cycle. First, phytophagous insect and mammalian herbivore damage can stimulate dormant buds to produce vigorous juvenile growth, which is preferred for further attack. Juvenilization cycles may have repeatedly evolved because herbivores are able to take advantage of a generalized plant compensatory response to any type of damage. Second, herbivores can manipulate plant source–sink relationships to attain more resources, and this alteration of plant growth may benefit subsequent herbivore generations. Third, herbivory can alter plant nutrition or defensive chemistry in a way that makes a plant susceptible to more herbivory. Resource regulation probably occurs because damage to resources preferred by the herbivores induces a generalized plant response that produces more preferred resources. Alternatively, manipulation of plant resources to induce resource regulation may have evolved in herbivores with a high degree of philopatry due to selection to alter plant resources to benefit their offspring. Resource regulation can stabilize insect population dynamics by maintaining a supply of high‐quality plant resources. It can also increase the heterogeneity of host‐plant resources for herbivores by altering the physiological age structure and the distribution of resources within plants. Resource regulation may have strong plant‐mediated effects on other organisms that use that host plant, but these effects have not yet been explored.
- 1 May 2010
- Published by Wiley in Population Ecology
- Vol. 52 (4) , 461-473
The resource regulation hypothesis and positive feedback loops in plant–herbivore interactions
Resource regulation occurs when herbivory maintains or increases plant susceptibility to further herbivory by the same species. A review of the literature indicates it is a widespread plant–animal interaction involving a diverse array of herbivores. At least three mechanisms can produce this positive feedback cycle. First, phytophagous insect and mammalian herbivore damage can stimulate dormant buds to produce vigorous juvenile growth, which is preferred for further attack. Juvenilization cycles may have repeatedly evolved because herbivores are able to take advantage of a generalized plant compensatory response to any type of damage. Second, herbivores can manipulate plant source–sink relationships to attain more resources, and this alteration of plant growth may benefit subsequent herbivore generations. Third, herbivory can alter plant nutrition or defensive chemistry in a way that makes a plant susceptible to more herbivory. Resource regulation probably occurs because damage to resources preferred by the herbivores induces a generalized plant response that produces more preferred resources. Alternatively, manipulation of plant resources to induce resource regulation may have evolved in herbivores with a high degree of philopatry due to selection to alter plant resources to benefit their offspring. Resource regulation can stabilize insect population dynamics by maintaining a supply of high‐quality plant resources. It can also increase the heterogeneity of host‐plant resources for herbivores by altering the physiological age structure and the distribution of resources within plants. Resource regulation may have strong plant‐mediated effects on other organisms that use that host plant, but these effects have not yet been explored.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2008
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Systematic Biology
- Vol. 57 (1) , 182-183
Evolutionary Ecology of Parasites, second edition.—Robert Poulin. 2006. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. 342 pp. ISBN 978-0-691-12085-0. $US39.50 £23.95 (paperback). ISBN 978-0-691-12084-3. $US99.50 £59.95 (hardback)
Because of the independent origins of evolutionary ecology and many areas of applied biology, they initially evolved in isolation from each other, with each developing its own terminology, research approaches, societies, and publications. Such fields as economic entomology, plant pathology, parasitology, microbiology, and even medicine have a wealth of information that could aid in theory development in evolutionary ecology; but for a long time this has largely been ignored by evolutionary ecologists. Recently, however, there has been an increase in cross-pollination among fields. For example, coevolutionary biologists initially learned about gene-gene interactions by examining older studies by plant pathologists (Flor, 1956), and evolutionary concepts are finally being applied to the study of medicine (Ewald, 1994).
- 1 February 2008
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Systematic Biology
- Vol. 57 (1) , 182-183
Open AccessEvolutionary Ecology of Parasites, second edition.—Robert Poulin. 2006. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. 342 pp. ISBN 978-0-691-12085-0. $US39.50 £23.95 (paperback). ISBN 978-0-691-12084-3. $US99.50 £59.95 (hardback)
Because of the independent origins of evolutionary ecology and many areas of applied biology, they initially evolved in isolation from each other, with each developing its own terminology, research approaches, societies, and publications. Such fields as economic entomology, plant pathology, parasitology, microbiology, and even medicine have a wealth of information that could aid in theory development in evolutionary ecology; but for a long time this has largely been ignored by evolutionary ecologists. Recently, however, there has been an increase in cross-pollination among fields. For example, coevolutionary biologists initially learned about gene-gene interactions by examining older studies by plant pathologists (Flor, 1956), and evolutionary concepts are finally being applied to the study of medicine (Ewald, 1994).
- 1 November 2007
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 61 (11) , 2607-2613
HOST PLANT GENOTYPE INFLUENCES SURVIVAL OF HYBRIDS BETWEEN EUROSTA SOLIDAGINIS HOST RACES
Extrinsic, host-associated environmental factors may influence postmating isolation between herbivorous insect populations and represent a fundamentally ecological cause of speciation. We investigated this issue in experiments on hybrids between the host races of Eurosta solidaginis, a fly that induces galls on the goldenrods Solidago altissima and S. gigantea. To do so, we measured the performance of parental host races and their hybrids on five genotypes of S. gigantea and nine genotypes of S. altissima to test hypotheses about how variation in plant genotype affects performance (i.e., fitness) and potentially influences gene flow between these host races. We found that rates of gall induction and of survival to adult emergence by hybrid larvae were significantly lower than those of both parental host races on both host species, adding support to the hypothesis that there is partial postmating isolation between the host races. Hybrid flies significantly varied in their performance across plant genotypes of both host species. A significant interaction between the effects of plant genotype and mating treatment (parental vs. hybrid crosses) on larval performance indicated that the relative suitability of particular plant genotypes differed between the parental host races and their hybrids. These patterns illustrate a poor correspondence between optimal parental and hybrid environments, consistent with the hypothesis that these host races are partially isolated due to extrinsic (ecological) factors. Based on these findings, we discuss the possibility that plant genotypes in which hybrid performance is high can facilitate hybridization and gene flow between partially reproductively isolated populations of herbivorous insects, thus affecting the dynamics of ecological speciation.
- 1 November 2007
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 61 (11) , 2607-2613
HOST PLANT GENOTYPE INFLUENCES SURVIVAL OF HYBRIDS BETWEEN EUROSTA SOLIDAGINIS HOST RACES
Extrinsic, host-associated environmental factors may influence postmating isolation between herbivorous insect populations and represent a fundamentally ecological cause of speciation. We investigated this issue in experiments on hybrids between the host races of Eurosta solidaginis, a fly that induces galls on the goldenrods Solidago altissima and S. gigantea. To do so, we measured the performance of parental host races and their hybrids on five genotypes of S. gigantea and nine genotypes of S. altissima to test hypotheses about how variation in plant genotype affects performance (i.e., fitness) and potentially influences gene flow between these host races. We found that rates of gall induction and of survival to adult emergence by hybrid larvae were significantly lower than those of both parental host races on both host species, adding support to the hypothesis that there is partial postmating isolation between the host races. Hybrid flies significantly varied in their performance across plant genotypes of both host species. A significant interaction between the effects of plant genotype and mating treatment (parental vs. hybrid crosses) on larval performance indicated that the relative suitability of particular plant genotypes differed between the parental host races and their hybrids. These patterns illustrate a poor correspondence between optimal parental and hybrid environments, consistent with the hypothesis that these host races are partially isolated due to extrinsic (ecological) factors. Based on these findings, we discuss the possibility that plant genotypes in which hybrid performance is high can facilitate hybridization and gene flow between partially reproductively isolated populations of herbivorous insects, thus affecting the dynamics of ecological speciation.