Mario Haim
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Mario Haim has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Johannes Breuer
Research Data and Methods, Center for Advanced Internet Studies (CAIS), Bochum, Germany
5 shared publications - Andreas Graefe
Hochschule Macromedia München
2 shared publications - Aske Kammer
ISNI: Roskilde University
2 shared publications - Christian Wolff
Universität Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany
2 shared publications Dag Elgesem
University of Bergen, Norway
2 shared publications- Florian Arendt
University of Vienna, Austria
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 3 September 2026
- Published by Cogitatio in Media and Communication
- Vol. 14
Threat and Remedy: AI’s Technological and Normative Role in Democratic Discourse and Counter Speech
Artificial intelligence (AI) has fundamentally transformed online discourse, serving simultaneously as a source of and a potential solution to threats to democracy. This article conceptually examines AI’s multifaceted role in digital public spheres, beginning with an analysis of how AI shapes democratic processes online, ranging from information curation and political participation to dialogue facilitation and the construction of epistemic infrastructures. We identify several key risks: AI amplifies harmful content through automated content generation, coordinated manipulation, and the algorithmic mainstreaming of borderline content that often evades traditional detection systems. Within this broader democratic context, we position counter speech as a critical intervention strategy and examine both reactive measures (e.g., automated detection and content moderation) and proactive approaches (e.g., prebunking, algorithmic downranking, friction design, and AI-mediated dialogue). We argue that effective counter speech increasingly relies on human–AI collaboration, where AI supports human counter speakers with factual resources, emotional scaffolding, and scalability, while human actors preserve the authenticity and agency that make counter speech normatively meaningful. However, realizing the potential of such collaboration requires moving beyond technological fixes toward democratically legitimated governance structures. Drawing on examples from Wikipedia and decentralized platforms, we demonstrate how transparent and participatory institutional arrangements can foster more resilient discourse environments. We conclude that societies can harness AI’s democratic potential while mitigating its risks only by proactively establishing legitimate deliberative processes grounded in broadly shared discourse norms.
- 3 September 2026
- Published by Cogitatio in Media and Communication
- Vol. 14
Open AccessThreat and Remedy: AI’s Technological and Normative Role in Democratic Discourse and Counter Speech
Artificial intelligence (AI) has fundamentally transformed online discourse, serving simultaneously as a source of and a potential solution to threats to democracy. This article conceptually examines AI’s multifaceted role in digital public spheres, beginning with an analysis of how AI shapes democratic processes online, ranging from information curation and political participation to dialogue facilitation and the construction of epistemic infrastructures. We identify several key risks: AI amplifies harmful content through automated content generation, coordinated manipulation, and the algorithmic mainstreaming of borderline content that often evades traditional detection systems. Within this broader democratic context, we position counter speech as a critical intervention strategy and examine both reactive measures (e.g., automated detection and content moderation) and proactive approaches (e.g., prebunking, algorithmic downranking, friction design, and AI-mediated dialogue). We argue that effective counter speech increasingly relies on human–AI collaboration, where AI supports human counter speakers with factual resources, emotional scaffolding, and scalability, while human actors preserve the authenticity and agency that make counter speech normatively meaningful. However, realizing the potential of such collaboration requires moving beyond technological fixes toward democratically legitimated governance structures. Drawing on examples from Wikipedia and decentralized platforms, we demonstrate how transparent and participatory institutional arrangements can foster more resilient discourse environments. We conclude that societies can harness AI’s democratic potential while mitigating its risks only by proactively establishing legitimate deliberative processes grounded in broadly shared discourse norms.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Media Psychology
- p. 1-23
Contextual Changes, Credible Conclusions? A Direct and Conceptual Replication of Shen et al.'s (2019) Study on Online Image Credibility
- 4 December 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Media Psychology
- p. 1-23
Open AccessContextual Changes, Credible Conclusions? A Direct and Conceptual Replication of Shen et al.'s (2019) Study on Online Image Credibility
- Open Access
- 17 June 2025
- Published by Cogitatio in Media and Communication
- Vol. 13
Climate Communication in the Hybrid Media System: Media and Stakeholder Logics on Social Media
Climate change is a major political challenge affecting millions of people worldwide. Journalists—while following media logic—have a strong responsibility to inform the public of the scientific evidence on the causes and consequences of climate change and to explain the motivations driving the climate policies under discussion. However, within hybrid media systems, journalists increasingly compete for attention with climate stakeholders, who tend to follow a political logic in climate communication and bypass journalism to share their perspectives on climate change. Despite this dynamic, the extent to which the climate communication of media organizations and stakeholders diverges in terms of content and focus remains largely unexplored, as does whether their topics and communication styles show signs of convergence. This article addresses these gaps by comparing how journalistic media and climate stakeholders communicate about climate change on social media and by examining the user engagement their content creates. We conducted a manual quantitative content analysis of visual posts about climate change published by media organizations and climate stakeholders in Germany on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube during the 2023 UN Climate Change Conference in Dubai (N = 1,050). The results deepen our understanding of the national climate discourse in Germany and show that journalistic content in climate communication adheres strongly to media logic, presenting climate change in a more event-oriented, personalized, and negative manner. However, climate stakeholders’ communication is characterized by political logic, using strategic framing and focusing less on current climate events.
- 17 June 2025
- Published by Cogitatio in Media and Communication
- Vol. 13
Open AccessClimate Communication in the Hybrid Media System: Media and Stakeholder Logics on Social Media
Climate change is a major political challenge affecting millions of people worldwide. Journalists—while following media logic—have a strong responsibility to inform the public of the scientific evidence on the causes and consequences of climate change and to explain the motivations driving the climate policies under discussion. However, within hybrid media systems, journalists increasingly compete for attention with climate stakeholders, who tend to follow a political logic in climate communication and bypass journalism to share their perspectives on climate change. Despite this dynamic, the extent to which the climate communication of media organizations and stakeholders diverges in terms of content and focus remains largely unexplored, as does whether their topics and communication styles show signs of convergence. This article addresses these gaps by comparing how journalistic media and climate stakeholders communicate about climate change on social media and by examining the user engagement their content creates. We conducted a manual quantitative content analysis of visual posts about climate change published by media organizations and climate stakeholders in Germany on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube during the 2023 UN Climate Change Conference in Dubai (N = 1,050). The results deepen our understanding of the national climate discourse in Germany and show that journalistic content in climate communication adheres strongly to media logic, presenting climate change in a more event-oriented, personalized, and negative manner. However, climate stakeholders’ communication is characterized by political logic, using strategic framing and focusing less on current climate events.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 504-509
GPT-4o for Visual Political Communication: Toward Automated Image Type Analysis
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 504-509
Open AccessGPT-4o for Visual Political Communication: Toward Automated Image Type Analysis
- Open Access
- 8 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly
- Vol. 102 (1) , 13-36
Between Innovation and Standardization: Best Practices and Inclusive Guidelines in Computational Communication Science
Computational communication science is transitioning from an emerging to an established field within communication research, creating a need for proper guidelines and methodological standards. This forum gathers experienced computational communication science scholars to debate the merits and drawbacks of standardization and discuss the tension between innovation, rigor, and inclusion. The assembled perspectives review current standards for data collection, sharing, and documentation, offering best practices for future research. They argue that high standards and inclusive practices can coexist, enhancing creativity and accessibility. By adopting inclusive guidelines, the computational communication science community can welcome diverse scholars, foster innovation, and advance the field collectively.
- 8 December 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly
- Vol. 102 (1) , 13-36
Open AccessBetween Innovation and Standardization: Best Practices and Inclusive Guidelines in Computational Communication Science
Computational communication science is transitioning from an emerging to an established field within communication research, creating a need for proper guidelines and methodological standards. This forum gathers experienced computational communication science scholars to debate the merits and drawbacks of standardization and discuss the tension between innovation, rigor, and inclusion. The assembled perspectives review current standards for data collection, sharing, and documentation, offering best practices for future research. They argue that high standards and inclusive practices can coexist, enhancing creativity and accessibility. By adopting inclusive guidelines, the computational communication science community can welcome diverse scholars, foster innovation, and advance the field collectively.
- 8 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 55-74
Politicians' Self-depiction and Their News Portrayal: Evidence from 28 Countries Using Visual Computational Analysis
Visual content plays a crucial role in today’s online political communication, especially during election campaigns. Prior research on candidate imagery has shown particular effects from non-verbal behavior (e.g., smiling), contextual features (e.g., the depiction of other people), and structural characteristics (e.g., camera angle and proximity). Importantly, this study argues to look at candidate imagery as institutionalized means of political communication online. In the realm of the European Parliamentary Election 2019, self-promoted candidate imagery on social networking sites (SNS) is expected to align cross-nationally along party-family structures vis-à-vis respective imagery in the news, which is anticipated to align along national borders. We analyze and describe respective candidate imagery in both news and SNS from 13,811 unique candidates across all 28 European member states by means of a computational content analysis of 79,500 images. After a manual two-step validation, which raises concerns about the validity of the computationally assigned camera angle, logistic regression models are used to estimate non-verbal behavior, contextual features, and structural characteristics. Findings show that while self-depiction on SNS includes more smiling, news imagery employs broader variation in camera angles and close-up photography. Differences are almost independent from structural influences with the exception of country alignment, which is a minor yet consistent predictor of all outcome variables. Visual computational content analysis has proven to be a useful and reliable utility for all but one variable – a call for its employment along strong validation also in future studies to allow visual content analyses also on a large and quantitative scale.
- 8 October 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 55-74
Politicians' Self-depiction and Their News Portrayal: Evidence from 28 Countries Using Visual Computational Analysis
Visual content plays a crucial role in today’s online political communication, especially during election campaigns. Prior research on candidate imagery has shown particular effects from non-verbal behavior (e.g., smiling), contextual features (e.g., the depiction of other people), and structural characteristics (e.g., camera angle and proximity). Importantly, this study argues to look at candidate imagery as institutionalized means of political communication online. In the realm of the European Parliamentary Election 2019, self-promoted candidate imagery on social networking sites (SNS) is expected to align cross-nationally along party-family structures vis-à-vis respective imagery in the news, which is anticipated to align along national borders. We analyze and describe respective candidate imagery in both news and SNS from 13,811 unique candidates across all 28 European member states by means of a computational content analysis of 79,500 images. After a manual two-step validation, which raises concerns about the validity of the computationally assigned camera angle, logistic regression models are used to estimate non-verbal behavior, contextual features, and structural characteristics. Findings show that while self-depiction on SNS includes more smiling, news imagery employs broader variation in camera angles and close-up photography. Differences are almost independent from structural influences with the exception of country alignment, which is a minor yet consistent predictor of all outcome variables. Visual computational content analysis has proven to be a useful and reliable utility for all but one variable – a call for its employment along strong validation also in future studies to allow visual content analyses also on a large and quantitative scale.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2024
- Published by Internet Policy Review, Alexander von Humboldt Institute for Internet and Society in Internet Policy Review
- Vol. 13 (3)
Fulfilling data access obligations: How could (and should) platforms facilitate data donation studies?
Research into digital platforms has become increasingly difficult. One way to overcome these difficulties is to build on data access rights in EU data protection law, which requires platforms to offer users a copy of their data. In data donation studies, researchers ask study participants to exercise this right and donate their data to science. However, there is increasing evidence that platforms do not comply with designated laws. We first discuss the obligations of data access from a legal perspective (with accessible, transparent, and complete data as key requirements). Next, we compile experiences from social scientists engaging in data donation projects as well as a study on data request/access. We identify 14 key challenges, most of which are a consequence of non-compliance by platforms. They include platforms’ insufficient adherence to (a) providing data in a concise and easily accessible form (e.g. the lack of information on when and how subjects can access their data); (b) being transparent about the content of their data (e.g. the lack of information on measures); and (c) providing complete data (e.g. the lack of all available information platforms process related to platform users). Finally, we formulate four central recommendations for improving the right to access.
- 16 September 2024
- Published by Internet Policy Review, Alexander von Humboldt Institute for Internet and Society in Internet Policy Review
- Vol. 13 (3)
Open AccessFulfilling data access obligations: How could (and should) platforms facilitate data donation studies?
Research into digital platforms has become increasingly difficult. One way to overcome these difficulties is to build on data access rights in EU data protection law, which requires platforms to offer users a copy of their data. In data donation studies, researchers ask study participants to exercise this right and donate their data to science. However, there is increasing evidence that platforms do not comply with designated laws. We first discuss the obligations of data access from a legal perspective (with accessible, transparent, and complete data as key requirements). Next, we compile experiences from social scientists engaging in data donation projects as well as a study on data request/access. We identify 14 key challenges, most of which are a consequence of non-compliance by platforms. They include platforms’ insufficient adherence to (a) providing data in a concise and easily accessible form (e.g. the lack of information on when and how subjects can access their data); (b) being transparent about the content of their data (e.g. the lack of information on measures); and (c) providing complete data (e.g. the lack of all available information platforms process related to platform users). Finally, we formulate four central recommendations for improving the right to access.
- Open Access
Detecting Calls to Action in Multimodal Content: Analysis of the 2021 German Federal Election Campaign on Instagram
This study investigates the automated classification of Calls to Action (CTAs) within the 2021 German Instagram election campaign to advance the understanding of mobilization in social media contexts. We analyzed over 2,208 Instagram stories and 712 posts using fine-tuned BERT models and OpenAI's GPT-4 models. The fine-tuned BERT model incorporating synthetic training data achieved a macro F1 score of 0.93, demonstrating a robust classification performance. Our analysis revealed that 49.58% of Instagram posts and 10.64% of stories contained CTAs, highlighting significant differences in mobilization strategies between these content types. Additionally, we found that FDP and the Greens had the highest prevalence of CTAs in posts, whereas CDU and CSU led in story CTAs.
Open AccessDetecting Calls to Action in Multimodal Content: Analysis of the 2021 German Federal Election Campaign on Instagram
This study investigates the automated classification of Calls to Action (CTAs) within the 2021 German Instagram election campaign to advance the understanding of mobilization in social media contexts. We analyzed over 2,208 Instagram stories and 712 posts using fine-tuned BERT models and OpenAI's GPT-4 models. The fine-tuned BERT model incorporating synthetic training data achieved a macro F1 score of 0.93, demonstrating a robust classification performance. Our analysis revealed that 49.58% of Instagram posts and 10.64% of stories contained CTAs, highlighting significant differences in mobilization strategies between these content types. Additionally, we found that FDP and the Greens had the highest prevalence of CTAs in posts, whereas CDU and CSU led in story CTAs.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Publizistik
- Vol. 69 (3) , 333-356
Key topic or bare necessity? How Research Ethics are Addressed and Discussed in Computational Communication Science
In Computational Communication Science (CCS) researchers grapple with intricate ethical challenges arising from the collection and analysis of complex data sets, often including sensitive or copyrighted data. Taking into consideration differences between the two main lines of philosophical reasoning in the realm of (research) ethics—deontology and consequentialism—we argue that ethical challenges faced in CCS are multidimensional and, hence, require multiple perspectives and approaches. Our general considerations are complemented by an empirical study that aims to assess the nature, prevalence, and discussion of ethical issues in CCS literature. Through a manual content analysis of 476 CCS publications, we shed light on ethical challenges as well as reflections thereof by CCS researchers. Notably, we find that only 5.88% of studies explicitly address general ethical considerations. Ethical review processes are also only mentioned in 6.51% of the considered studies, with the majority focusing on specific ethical procedures, such as obtaining informed consent, data anonymization measures, or debriefing. This suggests that, in the absence of consensus and field-specific standards, researchers in CCS prioritize context-specific ethical procedures, emphasizing the importance of flexibility in addressing ethical considerations.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Publizistik
- Vol. 69 (3) , 333-356
Open AccessKey topic or bare necessity? How Research Ethics are Addressed and Discussed in Computational Communication Science
In Computational Communication Science (CCS) researchers grapple with intricate ethical challenges arising from the collection and analysis of complex data sets, often including sensitive or copyrighted data. Taking into consideration differences between the two main lines of philosophical reasoning in the realm of (research) ethics—deontology and consequentialism—we argue that ethical challenges faced in CCS are multidimensional and, hence, require multiple perspectives and approaches. Our general considerations are complemented by an empirical study that aims to assess the nature, prevalence, and discussion of ethical issues in CCS literature. Through a manual content analysis of 476 CCS publications, we shed light on ethical challenges as well as reflections thereof by CCS researchers. Notably, we find that only 5.88% of studies explicitly address general ethical considerations. Ethical review processes are also only mentioned in 6.51% of the considered studies, with the majority focusing on specific ethical procedures, such as obtaining informed consent, data anonymization measures, or debriefing. This suggests that, in the absence of consensus and field-specific standards, researchers in CCS prioritize context-specific ethical procedures, emphasizing the importance of flexibility in addressing ethical considerations.