Thiemo Karwinkel
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Thiemo Karwinkel has a total of 71 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Heiko Schmaljohann
Institute of Biology and Environmental Sciences Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg Oldenburg Germany
8 shared publications - Vera Brust
Institute of Avian Research ‘Vogelwarte Helgoland’, An der Vogelwarte 21, 26386 Wilhelmshaven, Germany
7 shared publications - Franz Bairlein
Institute of Avian Research, An der Vogelwarte Wilhelmshaven Germany
5 shared publications - Michael Winklhofer
Institut für Biologie und Umweltwissenschaften, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg 2 , 26129 Oldenburg
5 shared publications - Ommo Hüppop
Institute of Avian Research ‘Vogelwarte Helgoland’, An der Vogelwarte 21, 26386 Wilhelmshaven, Germany
4 shared publications - Bo Leberecht
Department V – School of Mathematics and Science, Institute of Biology and Environmental Sciences, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg, Oldenburg 26129, Germany
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Stopover departure decisions and movement patterns of migratory bats during autumn migration
Migrating bats alternate between stopover periods and directed flights. When departing from a stopover site, bats select the night, the specific time within the night, and the flight direction to resume migration. Despite their ecological importance, the factors shaping these stopover departure decisions remain poorly understood. To identify the intrinsic and environmental factors driving departure decisions and movement patterns, we tagged Nathusius’ pipistrelles Pipistrellus nathusii at three coastal locations in the Netherlands and tracked 178 individuals during autumn migration, using the MOTUS Wildlife Tracking System. We examined movement patterns and analysed departure probability in relation to a set of individual and environmental covariates in a Bayesian capture-recapture model in state-space formulation. Additionally, we modelled within-night variation in departure timing. Seasonal patterns were strongly influenced by reproductive behaviour, with decreased migration probability during the mating period. Regardless of their seasonal timing, bats departed under moderate tailwinds and dry conditions, optimizing energy efficiency, while avoiding crosswinds and cloud cover, enhancing navigational safety. Most individuals departed shortly after sunset, whereas headwinds delayed nocturnal departure. Movement patterns were diverse, including migration towards lower latitudes, coastal barrier movements, and long-distance roundtrips, suggesting the use of multiple movement strategies. Our study demonstrates that migration patterns in bats emerge from the interaction between intrinsic factors and external conditions, and highlights the importance of both energy efficiency and safety in shaping stopover departure decisions. The presence of multiple movement strategies complicates predictions of spatiotemporal occurrence, emphasising the need to account for behavioural variability in conservation planning, for example in the context of wind energy developments.
Open AccessStopover departure decisions and movement patterns of migratory bats during autumn migration
Migrating bats alternate between stopover periods and directed flights. When departing from a stopover site, bats select the night, the specific time within the night, and the flight direction to resume migration. Despite their ecological importance, the factors shaping these stopover departure decisions remain poorly understood. To identify the intrinsic and environmental factors driving departure decisions and movement patterns, we tagged Nathusius’ pipistrelles Pipistrellus nathusii at three coastal locations in the Netherlands and tracked 178 individuals during autumn migration, using the MOTUS Wildlife Tracking System. We examined movement patterns and analysed departure probability in relation to a set of individual and environmental covariates in a Bayesian capture-recapture model in state-space formulation. Additionally, we modelled within-night variation in departure timing. Seasonal patterns were strongly influenced by reproductive behaviour, with decreased migration probability during the mating period. Regardless of their seasonal timing, bats departed under moderate tailwinds and dry conditions, optimizing energy efficiency, while avoiding crosswinds and cloud cover, enhancing navigational safety. Most individuals departed shortly after sunset, whereas headwinds delayed nocturnal departure. Movement patterns were diverse, including migration towards lower latitudes, coastal barrier movements, and long-distance roundtrips, suggesting the use of multiple movement strategies. Our study demonstrates that migration patterns in bats emerge from the interaction between intrinsic factors and external conditions, and highlights the importance of both energy efficiency and safety in shaping stopover departure decisions. The presence of multiple movement strategies complicates predictions of spatiotemporal occurrence, emphasising the need to account for behavioural variability in conservation planning, for example in the context of wind energy developments.
- Open Access
- 3 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 17 (4) , 1069-1081
movetrack: An R package to model flight paths from radio‐telemetry networks
Tracking small‐ to large‐scale movements of animals is important for studying their interactions with the environment, including how they adjust and adapt their migration in response to environmental and human‐induced changes. Despite the technical progress in tracking devices, a major challenge remains for small animals—such as songbirds, bats and insects—because GPS transmitters are still too heavy to be carried by these lightweight species. Automated radio‐telemetry offers a lightweight, scalable alternative. However, unlike GPS, radio‐telemetry does not yield precise location data—only information about receiving antennas and the strength of detected signals. Existing localisation methods either rely solely on receiver locations, offer only small‐scale, site‐specific estimates or were less user‐friendly though already integrating antenna geometry, signal strength and spatiotemporal uncertainty, limiting their ability either to reconstruct full flight paths or to be easily applied by practitioners. We fill this gap by presenting movetrack , an R package that reconstructs animal trajectories from automated radio‐telemetry data—such as that collected by the Motus Wildlife Tracking System—using a hidden Markov model (HMM) framework. Our approach combines coarse geometric position estimates—based on antenna bearing and signal strength—with an HMM that accounts for measurement error, temporal gaps, and movement dynamics. The model distinguishes behavioural states such as migratory flight, local movement and stopovers by analysing directional persistence and speed of the animal. We validate movetrack using controlled low‐altitude aircraft flights, simultaneously recorded with GPS and radiotelemetry, to simulate migratory flights of aerial species. Our results convincingly demonstrate that movetrack produces biologically realistic flight path estimates with quantifiable uncertainty, enhancing localisation in telemetry‐based movement research. movetrack provides a straightforward and practical approach, without requiring enhanced mathematical knowledge, to precisely reconstruct flight movements in a high spatiotemporal resolution. The R package enables researchers and conservationists to better study the response of aerial animals to environmental change and, ultimately, to formulate more effective conservation measures, for instance in relation to potential conflicts with anthropogenic stressors, such as artificial light at night, pesticides and human‐made structures.
- 3 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 17 (4) , 1069-1081
Open Accessmovetrack: An R package to model flight paths from radio‐telemetry networks
Tracking small‐ to large‐scale movements of animals is important for studying their interactions with the environment, including how they adjust and adapt their migration in response to environmental and human‐induced changes. Despite the technical progress in tracking devices, a major challenge remains for small animals—such as songbirds, bats and insects—because GPS transmitters are still too heavy to be carried by these lightweight species. Automated radio‐telemetry offers a lightweight, scalable alternative. However, unlike GPS, radio‐telemetry does not yield precise location data—only information about receiving antennas and the strength of detected signals. Existing localisation methods either rely solely on receiver locations, offer only small‐scale, site‐specific estimates or were less user‐friendly though already integrating antenna geometry, signal strength and spatiotemporal uncertainty, limiting their ability either to reconstruct full flight paths or to be easily applied by practitioners. We fill this gap by presenting movetrack , an R package that reconstructs animal trajectories from automated radio‐telemetry data—such as that collected by the Motus Wildlife Tracking System—using a hidden Markov model (HMM) framework. Our approach combines coarse geometric position estimates—based on antenna bearing and signal strength—with an HMM that accounts for measurement error, temporal gaps, and movement dynamics. The model distinguishes behavioural states such as migratory flight, local movement and stopovers by analysing directional persistence and speed of the animal. We validate movetrack using controlled low‐altitude aircraft flights, simultaneously recorded with GPS and radiotelemetry, to simulate migratory flights of aerial species. Our results convincingly demonstrate that movetrack produces biologically realistic flight path estimates with quantifiable uncertainty, enhancing localisation in telemetry‐based movement research. movetrack provides a straightforward and practical approach, without requiring enhanced mathematical knowledge, to precisely reconstruct flight movements in a high spatiotemporal resolution. The R package enables researchers and conservationists to better study the response of aerial animals to environmental change and, ultimately, to formulate more effective conservation measures, for instance in relation to potential conflicts with anthropogenic stressors, such as artificial light at night, pesticides and human‐made structures.
- Open Access
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Movement Ecology
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-18
Stopover departure decisions in spring: pre-Saharan migrants stay longer and are more selective for favourable wind than trans-Saharan migrants
Background: Birds that breed in Europe and winter south of the Sahara, so-called trans-Saharan migrants, generally migrate longer distances than pre-Saharan migrants. The latter are expected to be less time constrained during autumn migration than the former. As such, pre-Saharan migrants are assumed to be more selective for favourable weather conditions and are more likely to minimise energy cost of migration than trans-Saharan migrants. While this pattern is supported for autumn migration, it is less well understood for spring migration. Since the optimal arrival timing at the breeding areas is generally under selection pressure to arrive ‘early’, i.e. before ‘competitors’, and since this advantage is likely to hold across migration strategies, we predict that the general differences in decision making between pre- and trans-Saharan migrants will also be manifested during spring migration. Methods: We radio-tracked three trans-Saharan (Common Redstart Phoenicurus phoenicurus , Garden Warbler Sylvia borin and Northern Wheatear Oenanthe oenanthe ) and two pre-Saharan (European Robin Erithacus rubecula and Dunnock Prunella modularis ) migrants during stopover using a regional network of Motus receiving stations. We analysed the night-to-night and within-night departure decisions in relation to weather and energy stores, and compared species’ departure direction with the location of their ring recoveries. Results: Trans-Saharan migrants stopped-over shorter and were less selective for favourable wind conditions than pre-Saharan migrants. The positive effect of high energy stores and low cloud cover on departure probability was a consistent pattern. Within-night departure times did not differ between migration strategies. Departure directions were in line with geographical mean location of ring recoveries for Common Redstart, European Robin and Dunnock. Conclusions: Our results suggest that pre-Saharan migrants are less time-constrained and follow an energy-saving strategy more strongly than trans-Saharan migrants that seem to have a stronger urge to migrate fast in spring. Since a similar pattern exists for autumn migration, we suggest that how the species-specific migration strategies and associated time constraints affect stopover decision making in both migration seasons is a general mechanism in migratory songbirds.
- 22 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Movement Ecology
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessStopover departure decisions in spring: pre-Saharan migrants stay longer and are more selective for favourable wind than trans-Saharan migrants
Background: Birds that breed in Europe and winter south of the Sahara, so-called trans-Saharan migrants, generally migrate longer distances than pre-Saharan migrants. The latter are expected to be less time constrained during autumn migration than the former. As such, pre-Saharan migrants are assumed to be more selective for favourable weather conditions and are more likely to minimise energy cost of migration than trans-Saharan migrants. While this pattern is supported for autumn migration, it is less well understood for spring migration. Since the optimal arrival timing at the breeding areas is generally under selection pressure to arrive ‘early’, i.e. before ‘competitors’, and since this advantage is likely to hold across migration strategies, we predict that the general differences in decision making between pre- and trans-Saharan migrants will also be manifested during spring migration. Methods: We radio-tracked three trans-Saharan (Common Redstart Phoenicurus phoenicurus , Garden Warbler Sylvia borin and Northern Wheatear Oenanthe oenanthe ) and two pre-Saharan (European Robin Erithacus rubecula and Dunnock Prunella modularis ) migrants during stopover using a regional network of Motus receiving stations. We analysed the night-to-night and within-night departure decisions in relation to weather and energy stores, and compared species’ departure direction with the location of their ring recoveries. Results: Trans-Saharan migrants stopped-over shorter and were less selective for favourable wind conditions than pre-Saharan migrants. The positive effect of high energy stores and low cloud cover on departure probability was a consistent pattern. Within-night departure times did not differ between migration strategies. Departure directions were in line with geographical mean location of ring recoveries for Common Redstart, European Robin and Dunnock. Conclusions: Our results suggest that pre-Saharan migrants are less time-constrained and follow an energy-saving strategy more strongly than trans-Saharan migrants that seem to have a stronger urge to migrate fast in spring. Since a similar pattern exists for autumn migration, we suggest that how the species-specific migration strategies and associated time constraints affect stopover decision making in both migration seasons is a general mechanism in migratory songbirds.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (4)
Individual Variation in Migration and Wintering Patterns of Long‐Tailed Ducks Clangula hyemalis From a Population in Decline
The population of long‐tailed ducks Clangula hyemalis has declined dramatically since the 1990s at the species' most important wintering area, the Baltic Sea. It is unclear if this represents a real population decline at the flyway level or merely a northward shift in the wintering range, with part of the population moving from the Baltic Sea to rarelysurveyed ice‐free Arctic waters. To investigate wintering area choice and individual repeatability, we deployed light‐level loggers on female long‐tailed ducks at three breeding sites in the Western Russian Arctic across two annual cycles, from 2017 to 2019. We obtained data from 94 year‐round migration tracks (78, 14 and 2 from each breeding site) from 65 females. Females moved from freshwater breeding sites to mostly marine post‐breeding sites after wing moult. For wintering, the majority of the birds (94%) migrated to the Baltic Sea, while the rest overwintered in the White and Barents Seas. Spring migration involved staging at marine sites in the Arctic Ocean for most birds. Individual repeatability scores were high for longitudes of wintering sites, departure dates from breeding and wintering sites, and low for arrival dates at breeding and wintering sites. Therefore, our results suggest that the observed decline in the long‐tailed duck wintering population in the Baltic Sea is unlikely the result of a shift in wintering range within individuals, so that a real decline in the population size remains the most parsimonious explanation. High repeatability values indicate that the substantial variation in wintering sites throughout the Baltic Sea is clearly attributable to between‐individual variation rather than within‐individual variation across years. Still, addressing the underlying causes of population decline remains a challenge for this Arctic‐breeding species.
- 1 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (4)
Open AccessIndividual Variation in Migration and Wintering Patterns of Long‐Tailed Ducks Clangula hyemalis From a Population in Decline
The population of long‐tailed ducks Clangula hyemalis has declined dramatically since the 1990s at the species' most important wintering area, the Baltic Sea. It is unclear if this represents a real population decline at the flyway level or merely a northward shift in the wintering range, with part of the population moving from the Baltic Sea to rarelysurveyed ice‐free Arctic waters. To investigate wintering area choice and individual repeatability, we deployed light‐level loggers on female long‐tailed ducks at three breeding sites in the Western Russian Arctic across two annual cycles, from 2017 to 2019. We obtained data from 94 year‐round migration tracks (78, 14 and 2 from each breeding site) from 65 females. Females moved from freshwater breeding sites to mostly marine post‐breeding sites after wing moult. For wintering, the majority of the birds (94%) migrated to the Baltic Sea, while the rest overwintered in the White and Barents Seas. Spring migration involved staging at marine sites in the Arctic Ocean for most birds. Individual repeatability scores were high for longitudes of wintering sites, departure dates from breeding and wintering sites, and low for arrival dates at breeding and wintering sites. Therefore, our results suggest that the observed decline in the long‐tailed duck wintering population in the Baltic Sea is unlikely the result of a shift in wintering range within individuals, so that a real decline in the population size remains the most parsimonious explanation. High repeatability values indicate that the substantial variation in wintering sites throughout the Baltic Sea is clearly attributable to between‐individual variation rather than within‐individual variation across years. Still, addressing the underlying causes of population decline remains a challenge for this Arctic‐breeding species.
- Open Access
- 24 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 39 (4) , e70017
Conservation‐focused mapping of avian migratory routes using a pan‐European automated telemetry network
Accelerated biodiversity loss has destabilized functional links within and between ecosystems. Species that cross different ecosystems during migration between breeding and nonbreeding sites are particularly sensitive to global change because they are exposed to various, often ecosystem‐specific, threats. Because these threats have lethal and nonlethal effects on populations, many migratory species are declining, making this group especially vulnerable to global change. To mitigate their decline, research at a continental and flyway scale is required to adequately monitor changes in the migratory and demographic processes of populations during all parts of the annual cycle. The Motus Wildlife Tracking System (Motus) could provide a solution to data gaps that exist for small, migratory species. Motus is an automated telemetry system for animal tracking that uses a single very‐high‐frequency radio signal to track tagged individuals. Motus can provide information on movements made by individuals of small migrant species, thereby aiding the understanding of aspects of their migration that could affect demographic parameters. Conservation‐focused research opportunities related to Motus include identification of critical stopover sites that support and connect multiple species and insight into migratory decisions in small migrant birds related to environmental stressors, such as artificial light at night. Examples of stopover studies from the existing network that demonstrate its utility include identification of a high‐conservation‐value stopover area for the blackpoll warbler ( Setophaga striata ) in the eastern United States. Geographical gaps in the network across the Mediterranean region and across eastern Europe need to be filled to track continent‐wide movements. Motus can provide individual‐level migration information for a variety of small‐bodied taxa, and a drive to expand the network will improve its ability to direct conservation plans for such species.
- 24 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 39 (4) , e70017
Open AccessConservation‐focused mapping of avian migratory routes using a pan‐European automated telemetry network
Accelerated biodiversity loss has destabilized functional links within and between ecosystems. Species that cross different ecosystems during migration between breeding and nonbreeding sites are particularly sensitive to global change because they are exposed to various, often ecosystem‐specific, threats. Because these threats have lethal and nonlethal effects on populations, many migratory species are declining, making this group especially vulnerable to global change. To mitigate their decline, research at a continental and flyway scale is required to adequately monitor changes in the migratory and demographic processes of populations during all parts of the annual cycle. The Motus Wildlife Tracking System (Motus) could provide a solution to data gaps that exist for small, migratory species. Motus is an automated telemetry system for animal tracking that uses a single very‐high‐frequency radio signal to track tagged individuals. Motus can provide information on movements made by individuals of small migrant species, thereby aiding the understanding of aspects of their migration that could affect demographic parameters. Conservation‐focused research opportunities related to Motus include identification of critical stopover sites that support and connect multiple species and insight into migratory decisions in small migrant birds related to environmental stressors, such as artificial light at night. Examples of stopover studies from the existing network that demonstrate its utility include identification of a high‐conservation‐value stopover area for the blackpoll warbler ( Setophaga striata ) in the eastern United States. Geographical gaps in the network across the Mediterranean region and across eastern Europe need to be filled to track continent‐wide movements. Motus can provide individual‐level migration information for a variety of small‐bodied taxa, and a drive to expand the network will improve its ability to direct conservation plans for such species.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Journal of The Royal Society Interface
- Vol. 21 (214) , 20230745
A refined magnetic pulse treatment method for magnetic navigation experiments with adequate sham control: a case study on free-flying songbirds
Migratory songbirds may navigate by extracting positional information from the geomagnetic field, potentially with a magnetic-particle-based receptor. Previous studies assessed this hypothesis experimentally by exposing birds to a strong but brief magnetic pulse aimed at remagnetizing the particles and evoking an altered behaviour. Critically, such studies were not ideally designed because they lacked an adequate sham treatment controlling for the induced electric field that is fundamentally associated with a magnetic pulse. Consequently, we designed a sham-controlled magnetic-pulse experiment, with sham and treatment pulse producing a similar induced electric field, while limiting the sham magnetic field to a value that is deemed insufficient to remagnetize particles. We tested this novel approach by pulsing more than 250 wild, migrating European robins ( Erithacus rubecula ) during two autumn seasons. After pulsing them, five traits of free-flight migratory behaviour were observed, but no effect of the pulse could be found. Notably, one of the traits, the migratory motivation of adults, was significantly affected in only one of the two study years. Considering the problem of reproducing experiments with wild animals, we recommend a multi-year approach encompassing large sample size, blinded design and built-in sham control to obtain future insights into the role of magnetic-particle-based magnetoreception in bird navigation.
- 15 May 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Journal of The Royal Society Interface
- Vol. 21 (214) , 20230745
Open AccessA refined magnetic pulse treatment method for magnetic navigation experiments with adequate sham control: a case study on free-flying songbirds
Migratory songbirds may navigate by extracting positional information from the geomagnetic field, potentially with a magnetic-particle-based receptor. Previous studies assessed this hypothesis experimentally by exposing birds to a strong but brief magnetic pulse aimed at remagnetizing the particles and evoking an altered behaviour. Critically, such studies were not ideally designed because they lacked an adequate sham treatment controlling for the induced electric field that is fundamentally associated with a magnetic pulse. Consequently, we designed a sham-controlled magnetic-pulse experiment, with sham and treatment pulse producing a similar induced electric field, while limiting the sham magnetic field to a value that is deemed insufficient to remagnetize particles. We tested this novel approach by pulsing more than 250 wild, migrating European robins ( Erithacus rubecula ) during two autumn seasons. After pulsing them, five traits of free-flight migratory behaviour were observed, but no effect of the pulse could be found. Notably, one of the traits, the migratory motivation of adults, was significantly affected in only one of the two study years. Considering the problem of reproducing experiments with wild animals, we recommend a multi-year approach encompassing large sample size, blinded design and built-in sham control to obtain future insights into the role of magnetic-particle-based magnetoreception in bird navigation.
- Open Access
- 17 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Biological Reviews
- Vol. 99 (4) , 1576-1593
A conceptual framework on the role of magnetic cues in songbird migration ecology
Migrating animals perform astonishing seasonal movements by orienting and navigating over thousands of kilometres with great precision. Many migratory species use cues from the sun, stars, landmarks, olfaction and the Earth's magnetic field for this task. Among vertebrates, songbirds are the most studied taxon in magnetic‐cue‐related research. Despite multiple studies, we still lack a clear understanding of when, where and how magnetic cues affect the decision‐making process of birds and hence, their realised migratory behaviour in the wild. This understanding is especially important to interpret the results of laboratory experiments in an ecologically appropriate way. In this review, we summarise the current findings about the role of magnetic cues for migratory decisions in songbirds. First, we review the methodological principles for orientation and navigation research, specifically by comparing experiments on caged birds with experiments on free‐flying birds. While cage experiments can show the sensory abilities of birds, studies with free‐flying birds can characterise the ecological roles of magnetic cues. Second, we review the migratory stages, from stopover to endurance flight, in which songbirds use magnetic cues for their migratory decisions and incorporate this into a novel conceptual framework. While we lack studies examining whether and when magnetic cues affect orientation or navigation decisions during flight, the role of magnetic cues during stopover is relatively well studied, but mostly in the laboratory. Notably, many such studies have produced contradictory results so that understanding the biological importance of magnetic cues for decisions in free‐flying songbirds is not straightforward. One potential explanation is that reproducibility of magnetic‐cue experiments is low, probably because variability in the behavioural responses of birds among experiments is high. We are convinced that parts of this variability can be explained by species‐specific and context‐dependent reactions of birds to the study conditions and by the bird's high flexibility in whether they include magnetic cues in a decision or not. Ultimately, this review should help researchers in the challenging field of magnetoreception to design experiments meticulously and interpret results of such studies carefully by considering the migration ecology of their focal species.
- 17 April 2024
- Published by Wiley in Biological Reviews
- Vol. 99 (4) , 1576-1593
Open AccessA conceptual framework on the role of magnetic cues in songbird migration ecology
Migrating animals perform astonishing seasonal movements by orienting and navigating over thousands of kilometres with great precision. Many migratory species use cues from the sun, stars, landmarks, olfaction and the Earth's magnetic field for this task. Among vertebrates, songbirds are the most studied taxon in magnetic‐cue‐related research. Despite multiple studies, we still lack a clear understanding of when, where and how magnetic cues affect the decision‐making process of birds and hence, their realised migratory behaviour in the wild. This understanding is especially important to interpret the results of laboratory experiments in an ecologically appropriate way. In this review, we summarise the current findings about the role of magnetic cues for migratory decisions in songbirds. First, we review the methodological principles for orientation and navigation research, specifically by comparing experiments on caged birds with experiments on free‐flying birds. While cage experiments can show the sensory abilities of birds, studies with free‐flying birds can characterise the ecological roles of magnetic cues. Second, we review the migratory stages, from stopover to endurance flight, in which songbirds use magnetic cues for their migratory decisions and incorporate this into a novel conceptual framework. While we lack studies examining whether and when magnetic cues affect orientation or navigation decisions during flight, the role of magnetic cues during stopover is relatively well studied, but mostly in the laboratory. Notably, many such studies have produced contradictory results so that understanding the biological importance of magnetic cues for decisions in free‐flying songbirds is not straightforward. One potential explanation is that reproducibility of magnetic‐cue experiments is low, probably because variability in the behavioural responses of birds among experiments is high. We are convinced that parts of this variability can be explained by species‐specific and context‐dependent reactions of birds to the study conditions and by the bird's high flexibility in whether they include magnetic cues in a decision or not. Ultimately, this review should help researchers in the challenging field of magnetoreception to design experiments meticulously and interpret results of such studies carefully by considering the migration ecology of their focal species.
- Open Access
- 22 February 2023
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 19 (2)
Naive songbirds show seasonally appropriate spring orientation in the laboratory despite having never completed first migration
The role of inherited orientation programmes in determining the outbound migratory routes of birds is increasingly well understood, though less is known about the influence of inherited information on return migration. Previous studies suggest that spatial gradient cues learnt through experience could be of considerable importance when relocating the natal site, though such cues could, in principle, augment rather than replace inherited migratory information. Here, we show that juvenile Eurasian blackcaps ( Sylvia atricapilla ) that have never left northwest Europe (i.e. never had the opportunity to learn navigational information on a continental scale) show significant spring orientation in a direction near-identical to that expected based on ringing recoveries from free-flying individuals. We suggest that this is probably indicative of birds inheriting an orientation programme for spring as well as autumn migration and speculate that, as long as the birds are not displaced far from their normal migration route, the use of inherited spring migratory trajectories might make uni-coordinate ‘stop signs’ sufficiently accurate for the long-distance targeting of their breeding sites.
- 22 February 2023
- Published by The Royal Society in Biology Letters
- Vol. 19 (2)
Open AccessNaive songbirds show seasonally appropriate spring orientation in the laboratory despite having never completed first migration
The role of inherited orientation programmes in determining the outbound migratory routes of birds is increasingly well understood, though less is known about the influence of inherited information on return migration. Previous studies suggest that spatial gradient cues learnt through experience could be of considerable importance when relocating the natal site, though such cues could, in principle, augment rather than replace inherited migratory information. Here, we show that juvenile Eurasian blackcaps ( Sylvia atricapilla ) that have never left northwest Europe (i.e. never had the opportunity to learn navigational information on a continental scale) show significant spring orientation in a direction near-identical to that expected based on ringing recoveries from free-flying individuals. We suggest that this is probably indicative of birds inheriting an orientation programme for spring as well as autumn migration and speculate that, as long as the birds are not displaced far from their normal migration route, the use of inherited spring migratory trajectories might make uni-coordinate ‘stop signs’ sufficiently accurate for the long-distance targeting of their breeding sites.
- Open Access
- 3 October 2022
- Published by The Company of Biologists in Journal of Experimental Biology
- Vol. 225 (19)
A magnetic pulse does not affect free-flight navigation behaviour of a medium-distance songbird migrant in spring
Current evidence suggests that migratory animals extract map information from the geomagnetic field for true navigation. The sensory basis underlying this feat is elusive, but presumably involves magnetic particles. A common experimental manipulation procedure consists of pre-treating animals with a magnetic pulse, with the aim of re-magnetising particles to alter the internal representation of the external field prior to a navigation task. Although pulsing provoked deflected bearings in caged songbirds, analogous studies with free-flying songbirds yielded inconsistent results. Here, we pulsed European robins (Erithacus rubecula) at an offshore stopover site during spring migration and monitored their free-flight behaviour with a regional-scale network of radio-receiving stations. We found no pulse effect on departure probability, nocturnal departure timing departure direction or consistency of flight direction. This suggests either no use of the geomagnetic map by our birds, or that magnetic pulses do not affect the sensory system underlying geomagnetic map detection.
- 3 October 2022
- Published by The Company of Biologists in Journal of Experimental Biology
- Vol. 225 (19)
Open AccessA magnetic pulse does not affect free-flight navigation behaviour of a medium-distance songbird migrant in spring
Current evidence suggests that migratory animals extract map information from the geomagnetic field for true navigation. The sensory basis underlying this feat is elusive, but presumably involves magnetic particles. A common experimental manipulation procedure consists of pre-treating animals with a magnetic pulse, with the aim of re-magnetising particles to alter the internal representation of the external field prior to a navigation task. Although pulsing provoked deflected bearings in caged songbirds, analogous studies with free-flying songbirds yielded inconsistent results. Here, we pulsed European robins (Erithacus rubecula) at an offshore stopover site during spring migration and monitored their free-flight behaviour with a regional-scale network of radio-receiving stations. We found no pulse effect on departure probability, nocturnal departure timing departure direction or consistency of flight direction. This suggests either no use of the geomagnetic map by our birds, or that magnetic pulses do not affect the sensory system underlying geomagnetic map detection.
- Open Access
A magnetic pulse does not affect free-flight navigation behaviour of a medium-distance songbird migrant in spring
Current evidence suggests that migratory animals extract map information from the geomagnetic field for true navigation. The sensory basis underlying this feat is elusive, but presumably involves magnetic particles. A common experimental manipulation procedure consists of pre-treating animals with a magnetic pulse. This aims at re-magnetising particles to alter the internal representation of the external field prior to a navigation task. While pulsing provoked deflected bearings in laboratory experiments, analogous studies with free-flying songbirds yielded inconsistent results. Here, we pulsed European robins ( Erithacus rubecula ), being medium-distance migrants, at an offshore stopover site during spring migration and monitored their free-flight behaviour with a regional-scale tracking system. We found no pulse effect on departure probability, nocturnal departure timing, or departure direction, in agreement with results on a long-distance migrant released at the same site in autumn. This necessitates a reassessment of the importance of geomagnetic maps for migratory decisions for free-flying birds. Summary statement: Magnetic pulse pre-treatment disturbs geomagnetic map usage of birds in lab environments. However, our free-flying birds show no effect, suggesting geomagnetic map information is less important in the natural environment.
Open AccessA magnetic pulse does not affect free-flight navigation behaviour of a medium-distance songbird migrant in spring
Current evidence suggests that migratory animals extract map information from the geomagnetic field for true navigation. The sensory basis underlying this feat is elusive, but presumably involves magnetic particles. A common experimental manipulation procedure consists of pre-treating animals with a magnetic pulse. This aims at re-magnetising particles to alter the internal representation of the external field prior to a navigation task. While pulsing provoked deflected bearings in laboratory experiments, analogous studies with free-flying songbirds yielded inconsistent results. Here, we pulsed European robins ( Erithacus rubecula ), being medium-distance migrants, at an offshore stopover site during spring migration and monitored their free-flight behaviour with a regional-scale tracking system. We found no pulse effect on departure probability, nocturnal departure timing, or departure direction, in agreement with results on a long-distance migrant released at the same site in autumn. This necessitates a reassessment of the importance of geomagnetic maps for migratory decisions for free-flying birds. Summary statement: Magnetic pulse pre-treatment disturbs geomagnetic map usage of birds in lab environments. However, our free-flying birds show no effect, suggesting geomagnetic map information is less important in the natural environment.