Gregory J. Gilbert
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Gregory J. Gilbert has a total of 203 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Erik A. Petigura
University of California Los Angeles
19 shared publications - Andrew W. Howard
California Institute of Technology
14 shared publications - Steven Giacalone
California Institute of Technology
13 shared publications - Judah Van Zandt
University of California Santa Barbara
12 shared publications - Fei Dai
Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawai‘i, Honolulu, USA
11 shared publications - Arpita Roy
19 Astrophysics & Space Institute, Schmidt Sciences, New York, NY 10011, USA
10 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 October 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1011 (1) , 42
The KPF SLOPE Survey: Small, Compact Multiplanet Systems Appear Spin–Orbit Aligned
The angle between stellar spin axes and planetary orbits—stellar obliquity—probes the dynamics of planetary migration and evolution. The obliquities of giant planets have been extensively studied because they are the most easily measured. Smaller planets, while more difficult to measure, have the advantage of better reflecting the dynamics of planetary systems because they trigger negligible backreactions onto the host star. This paper introduces a new observational campaign called the Small, Low-mass Oblique Planets Experiment (SLOPE) survey with the Keck Planet Finder (KPF) spectrograph and presents four new obliquity measurements. The SLOPE survey focuses on planets smaller than Saturn across a variety of system architectures. The sky-projected obliquities of the four planets measured—TOI-1386 b, TOI-480 b, TOI-4596 b, and TOI-1823 b—are all consistent with spin–orbit alignment. We validate the planetary nature of TOI-4596 b with a significant detection of the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect. Including these measurements, we conducted a statistical analysis of the obliquities of sub-Saturn-mass planets in different planetary system architectures. Compared to other architectures, those in compact multiplanet systems reside in orbits that appear preferentially aligned with the stellar equator with 6 σ confidence.
- 26 October 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 1011 (1) , 42
Open AccessThe KPF SLOPE Survey: Small, Compact Multiplanet Systems Appear Spin–Orbit Aligned
The angle between stellar spin axes and planetary orbits—stellar obliquity—probes the dynamics of planetary migration and evolution. The obliquities of giant planets have been extensively studied because they are the most easily measured. Smaller planets, while more difficult to measure, have the advantage of better reflecting the dynamics of planetary systems because they trigger negligible backreactions onto the host star. This paper introduces a new observational campaign called the Small, Low-mass Oblique Planets Experiment (SLOPE) survey with the Keck Planet Finder (KPF) spectrograph and presents four new obliquity measurements. The SLOPE survey focuses on planets smaller than Saturn across a variety of system architectures. The sky-projected obliquities of the four planets measured—TOI-1386 b, TOI-480 b, TOI-4596 b, and TOI-1823 b—are all consistent with spin–orbit alignment. We validate the planetary nature of TOI-4596 b with a significant detection of the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect. Including these measurements, we conducted a statistical analysis of the obliquities of sub-Saturn-mass planets in different planetary system architectures. Compared to other architectures, those in compact multiplanet systems reside in orbits that appear preferentially aligned with the stellar equator with 6 σ confidence.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 172 (1) , 48
The Keck Planet Finder SURFS-UP Survey. I. Transmission Spectroscopy of WASP-76 b
We introduce the Keck Planet Finder (KPF) Spectroscopy of the Upper Atmospheres and Refractory Species in Ultrahot Planets (SURFS-UP) Survey, a high-resolution survey to investigate the atmospheric composition and dynamics of a sample of ultrahot Jupiters with the KPF. Due to the unique design of KPF, we developed a publicly available pipeline for KPF that performs blaze removal, continuum normalization, order stitching, science spectra combination, telluric correction, and atmospheric detection via cross correlation. As a first demonstration, we applied this pipeline to a transit of WASP-76 b and achieved some of the highest signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) detections of refractory species in WASP-76 b to date (e.g., Fe I is detected at an SNR of 14.5). We confirm previous observations of an asymmetry in Fe I absorption, but find no measurable ingress–egress asymmetry in Na I and Ca II . Together, these results suggest variations within different layers of the atmosphere of WASP-76 b: neutral metals such as Fe I trace deeper regions with stronger asymmetries, while Na I and Ca II probe regions higher in the atmosphere where the ingress–egress asymmetries are weaker. Unlike some other ultrahot Jupiters, our results are qualitatively consistent with general circulation model predictions of decreasing velocity asymmetry with altitude and do not require a high-altitude superrotating jet that has been invoked for other planets (e.g., WASP-121 b). These results suggest that atmospheric circulation patterns in ultrahot Jupiters may be more diverse than previously thought, highlighting the need for broader surveys to study how atmospheric dynamics depend on planetary and stellar properties.
- 25 June 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 172 (1) , 48
Open AccessThe Keck Planet Finder SURFS-UP Survey. I. Transmission Spectroscopy of WASP-76 b
We introduce the Keck Planet Finder (KPF) Spectroscopy of the Upper Atmospheres and Refractory Species in Ultrahot Planets (SURFS-UP) Survey, a high-resolution survey to investigate the atmospheric composition and dynamics of a sample of ultrahot Jupiters with the KPF. Due to the unique design of KPF, we developed a publicly available pipeline for KPF that performs blaze removal, continuum normalization, order stitching, science spectra combination, telluric correction, and atmospheric detection via cross correlation. As a first demonstration, we applied this pipeline to a transit of WASP-76 b and achieved some of the highest signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) detections of refractory species in WASP-76 b to date (e.g., Fe I is detected at an SNR of 14.5). We confirm previous observations of an asymmetry in Fe I absorption, but find no measurable ingress–egress asymmetry in Na I and Ca II . Together, these results suggest variations within different layers of the atmosphere of WASP-76 b: neutral metals such as Fe I trace deeper regions with stronger asymmetries, while Na I and Ca II probe regions higher in the atmosphere where the ingress–egress asymmetries are weaker. Unlike some other ultrahot Jupiters, our results are qualitatively consistent with general circulation model predictions of decreasing velocity asymmetry with altitude and do not require a high-altitude superrotating jet that has been invoked for other planets (e.g., WASP-121 b). These results suggest that atmospheric circulation patterns in ultrahot Jupiters may be more diverse than previously thought, highlighting the need for broader surveys to study how atmospheric dynamics depend on planetary and stellar properties.
- Open Access
- 23 June 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 172 (1) , 42
The Orbital Eccentricities of Planets in the Kinematic Thin and Thick Galactic Disks
The orbital eccentricity distribution of exoplanets is shaped by a combination of dynamical processes, reflecting both formation conditions and long-term evolution. Probing the orbital dynamics of planets in the kinematic thin and thick Galactic disks provides insight into the degree to which stellar and Galactic environmental factors affect planet formation and evolution pathways. The classification of host stars in Galactic kinematic terms constitutes a potentially useful axis for the interpretation of orbital eccentricity, when included together with stellar metallicity and age. Leveraging the photoeccentric effect, we constrain orbital eccentricities for the sample of Kepler planets and candidates orbiting F, G, K, and M dwarf stars. With Gaia astrometry, inferred Galactic phase space information, and kinematic disk criteria calibrated on stellar chemical abundances, we implement a machine learning approach to associate each planet host with the kinematic thin or thick Galactic disks. We then fit the underlying eccentricity distributions for the single- and multitransit populations. We find that for single-transiting planets, kinematic thick-disk planets exhibit higher eccentricities than thin-disk planets, yet we find no such difference among multitransiting planets. We determine that the difference in eccentricity is unlikely to be caused solely by the effects of host stellar metallicity or giant planet occurrence. We situate these findings in the context of known eccentricity relations, including their relationships with planet multiplicity, radius, and metallicity. We suggest comprehensive analyses to disentangle these results from the effects of poorly understood star–planet relationships, such as those between stellar age and planetary orbital dynamics.
- 23 June 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 172 (1) , 42
Open AccessThe Orbital Eccentricities of Planets in the Kinematic Thin and Thick Galactic Disks
The orbital eccentricity distribution of exoplanets is shaped by a combination of dynamical processes, reflecting both formation conditions and long-term evolution. Probing the orbital dynamics of planets in the kinematic thin and thick Galactic disks provides insight into the degree to which stellar and Galactic environmental factors affect planet formation and evolution pathways. The classification of host stars in Galactic kinematic terms constitutes a potentially useful axis for the interpretation of orbital eccentricity, when included together with stellar metallicity and age. Leveraging the photoeccentric effect, we constrain orbital eccentricities for the sample of Kepler planets and candidates orbiting F, G, K, and M dwarf stars. With Gaia astrometry, inferred Galactic phase space information, and kinematic disk criteria calibrated on stellar chemical abundances, we implement a machine learning approach to associate each planet host with the kinematic thin or thick Galactic disks. We then fit the underlying eccentricity distributions for the single- and multitransit populations. We find that for single-transiting planets, kinematic thick-disk planets exhibit higher eccentricities than thin-disk planets, yet we find no such difference among multitransiting planets. We determine that the difference in eccentricity is unlikely to be caused solely by the effects of host stellar metallicity or giant planet occurrence. We situate these findings in the context of known eccentricity relations, including their relationships with planet multiplicity, radius, and metallicity. We suggest comprehensive analyses to disentangle these results from the effects of poorly understood star–planet relationships, such as those between stellar age and planetary orbital dynamics.
- Open Access
- 24 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (5) , 312
No Strong Associations between Eccentricity and Orbital Architecture in Kepler Compact Multis
The dynamical history of a planetary system is recorded in the present day architecture of its constituent planets’ sizes, orbital periods, and eccentricities. Studying the relationships between these quantities for large populations provides a window into the processes by which planetary systems form and evolve. Recently, G. J. Gilbert et al. performed a hierarchical Bayesian analysis of 1646 planets from the Kepler census, demonstrating a strong relationship between planet radius R p and orbital eccentricity e . Here, we build upon that work to search for correlations between eccentricity and system architecture, focusing on compact systems of small planets. We find that small planets on short orbits ( P < 4 days) show evidence of tidal circularization. This trend is well established for Jovian planets but a novel finding for super-Earths and sub-Neptunes. We reproduce the known wherein trend single-transiting systems possess elevated eccentricities relative to their multitransiting counterparts. We further show that systems with two transiting planets have higher eccentricities than those with three or more transiting planets. When compared to population synthesis models, these multiplicity–eccentricity relationships imply that Kepler singles have intrinsic multiplicity ∼3 and Kepler multis have intrinsic multiplicity ∼4−6. We detect no statistically significant associations between eccentricity and planetary period ratios, gap complexity, size inequality, or size ordering. We interpret these findings as evidence either in favor of a quiescent formation history or against dynamical processes that excite eccentricity but not inclination. Subsignificant relationships between eccentricity and architecture imply that subtle, multifactor trends may be detectable in the future using more sophisticated statistical techniques.
- 24 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (5) , 312
Open AccessNo Strong Associations between Eccentricity and Orbital Architecture in Kepler Compact Multis
The dynamical history of a planetary system is recorded in the present day architecture of its constituent planets’ sizes, orbital periods, and eccentricities. Studying the relationships between these quantities for large populations provides a window into the processes by which planetary systems form and evolve. Recently, G. J. Gilbert et al. performed a hierarchical Bayesian analysis of 1646 planets from the Kepler census, demonstrating a strong relationship between planet radius R p and orbital eccentricity e . Here, we build upon that work to search for correlations between eccentricity and system architecture, focusing on compact systems of small planets. We find that small planets on short orbits ( P < 4 days) show evidence of tidal circularization. This trend is well established for Jovian planets but a novel finding for super-Earths and sub-Neptunes. We reproduce the known wherein trend single-transiting systems possess elevated eccentricities relative to their multitransiting counterparts. We further show that systems with two transiting planets have higher eccentricities than those with three or more transiting planets. When compared to population synthesis models, these multiplicity–eccentricity relationships imply that Kepler singles have intrinsic multiplicity ∼3 and Kepler multis have intrinsic multiplicity ∼4−6. We detect no statistically significant associations between eccentricity and planetary period ratios, gap complexity, size inequality, or size ordering. We interpret these findings as evidence either in favor of a quiescent formation history or against dynamical processes that excite eccentricity but not inclination. Subsignificant relationships between eccentricity and architecture imply that subtle, multifactor trends may be detectable in the future using more sophisticated statistical techniques.
- Open Access
- 17 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (5) , 299
Planetary Architectures of Kepler Compact Multiplanet Systems with Binary-star Companions
Planets in binary-star systems exhibit demographic differences compared to planets in single-star systems. In particular, planets with binary-star hosts have a lower overall occurrence rate compared to their single-star counterparts, as well as a suppressed relative occurrence rate for sub-Neptunes ( R p = 2–4 R ⊕ ) compared to super-Earths ( R p = 1.0–1.5 R ⊕ ). These differences are most pronounced in close-separation binaries ( ρ < 100 au), which have been interpreted as resulting from binary stars disrupting the protoplanetary disks of their stellar companions. The architectures of planetary systems—i.e., the arrangements of planet sizes and orbits—provide additional information about system formation and evolution. While the architectures of single-star planetary systems are well studied, those of binary-star planetary systems have not been investigated in detail. In this work, we analyzed a large sample of Kepler planetary systems (162 planets in 118 binary-star systems and 880 planets in 544 single-star systems) to compare their architectures as a function of stellar multiplicity. We found that planets with binary star hosts follow a similar “peas-in-a-pod” tendency toward uniformity in planet radii and log-uniformity in period spacing as those in single-star systems. However, we also detected modest (2.5 σ –3 σ ) differences in period spacing and planet multiplicity, with binary-star systems having higher typical gap complexities (indicating more uneven spacing) and a greater prevalence of single planets. We interpret these results as evidence that binary stars primarily influence the planetary architectures of their stellar companions by shaping the protoplanetary disk during formation, with subsequent dynamical processing more gently altering the system architectures over secular timescales.
- 17 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (5) , 299
Open AccessPlanetary Architectures of Kepler Compact Multiplanet Systems with Binary-star Companions
Planets in binary-star systems exhibit demographic differences compared to planets in single-star systems. In particular, planets with binary-star hosts have a lower overall occurrence rate compared to their single-star counterparts, as well as a suppressed relative occurrence rate for sub-Neptunes ( R p = 2–4 R ⊕ ) compared to super-Earths ( R p = 1.0–1.5 R ⊕ ). These differences are most pronounced in close-separation binaries ( ρ < 100 au), which have been interpreted as resulting from binary stars disrupting the protoplanetary disks of their stellar companions. The architectures of planetary systems—i.e., the arrangements of planet sizes and orbits—provide additional information about system formation and evolution. While the architectures of single-star planetary systems are well studied, those of binary-star planetary systems have not been investigated in detail. In this work, we analyzed a large sample of Kepler planetary systems (162 planets in 118 binary-star systems and 880 planets in 544 single-star systems) to compare their architectures as a function of stellar multiplicity. We found that planets with binary star hosts follow a similar “peas-in-a-pod” tendency toward uniformity in planet radii and log-uniformity in period spacing as those in single-star systems. However, we also detected modest (2.5 σ –3 σ ) differences in period spacing and planet multiplicity, with binary-star systems having higher typical gap complexities (indicating more uneven spacing) and a greater prevalence of single planets. We interpret these results as evidence that binary stars primarily influence the planetary architectures of their stellar companions by shaping the protoplanetary disk during formation, with subsequent dynamical processing more gently altering the system architectures over secular timescales.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (5) , 267
A Smooth Transition from Giant Planets to Brown Dwarfs from the Radial Occurrence Distribution
Measuring the occurrence rates of celestial objects is a valuable way to study their origins and evolution. Giant planets and brown dwarfs produce large Doppler signatures that are easily detectable by modern instrumentation, and legacy radial velocity (RV) surveys have now achieved full orbital coverage for periods ≲30 yr. However, the Doppler method’s sensitivity to companion minimum mass M c sin i —as opposed to true mass M c —prevents unambiguous characterization using RVs alone because purported giant planets may be brown dwarfs or stars on inclined orbits. Here, we combined legacy RVs with absolute astrometry to refit the orbits of 194 companions from the California Legacy Survey. Around 40% (7/18) of the “brown dwarfs” ( M c sin i =13–80 M Jup ) we refit had true masses above 80 M Jup . We incorporated our orbital posteriors and target sensitivity maps into a Poisson likelihood model to calculate occurrence as a function of true companion mass M c (0.8–80 M Jup ) and separation a (0.3–30 au). The semimajor axis distributions of objects in this range vary smoothly with mass, with Jupiter analogs favoring an abrupt increase in occurrence near 1 au and brown dwarfs exhibiting a gradual enhancement at wider separations. Marginalized companion occurrence between 1 and 10 au decreases smoothly with mass, with brown dwarfs having the lowest occurrence rate: 1 . 1 − 0.4 + 0.5 % . Jupiter analogs are 10 times as common as brown dwarfs per mass interval in this range, demonstrating that the brown dwarf desert extends to 10 au. The smooth variation in these distributions disfavors a sharp transition mass between “bottom-up” core accretion and “top-down” gravitational instability formation mechanisms and rather suggests that these processes may produce companions in overlapping mass ranges.
- 2 April 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (5) , 267
Open AccessA Smooth Transition from Giant Planets to Brown Dwarfs from the Radial Occurrence Distribution
Measuring the occurrence rates of celestial objects is a valuable way to study their origins and evolution. Giant planets and brown dwarfs produce large Doppler signatures that are easily detectable by modern instrumentation, and legacy radial velocity (RV) surveys have now achieved full orbital coverage for periods ≲30 yr. However, the Doppler method’s sensitivity to companion minimum mass M c sin i —as opposed to true mass M c —prevents unambiguous characterization using RVs alone because purported giant planets may be brown dwarfs or stars on inclined orbits. Here, we combined legacy RVs with absolute astrometry to refit the orbits of 194 companions from the California Legacy Survey. Around 40% (7/18) of the “brown dwarfs” ( M c sin i =13–80 M Jup ) we refit had true masses above 80 M Jup . We incorporated our orbital posteriors and target sensitivity maps into a Poisson likelihood model to calculate occurrence as a function of true companion mass M c (0.8–80 M Jup ) and separation a (0.3–30 au). The semimajor axis distributions of objects in this range vary smoothly with mass, with Jupiter analogs favoring an abrupt increase in occurrence near 1 au and brown dwarfs exhibiting a gradual enhancement at wider separations. Marginalized companion occurrence between 1 and 10 au decreases smoothly with mass, with brown dwarfs having the lowest occurrence rate: 1 . 1 − 0.4 + 0.5 % . Jupiter analogs are 10 times as common as brown dwarfs per mass interval in this range, demonstrating that the brown dwarf desert extends to 10 au. The smooth variation in these distributions disfavors a sharp transition mass between “bottom-up” core accretion and “top-down” gravitational instability formation mechanisms and rather suggests that these processes may produce companions in overlapping mass ranges.
- Open Access
- 30 January 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (2) , 115
The Orbital Eccentricity–Radius Relation for Planets Orbiting M Dwarfs
The orbital eccentricity–radius relation for small planets is indicative of the predominant dynamical sculpting processes during late-stage orbital evolution. Previous studies have shown that planets orbiting Sun-like stars exhibit an eccentricity–radius trend such that larger planets have higher orbital eccentricities, and that radius gap planets may have modestly higher orbital eccentricities than planets on either side of the radius gap. In this work, we investigate the trend for a sample of smaller M dwarf stars. For a sample of 236 single- and multitransit confirmed planets or candidates discovered by the TESS and Kepler missions, we constrain orbital eccentricity for each planet from the transit photometry together with a stellar density prior. We investigate the binned eccentricity–planet radius relation for the combined planet sample and present evidence for a positive eccentricity–radius relationship with elevated eccentricities for planets larger than 3.5 R ⊕ , similar to the trend for planets orbiting Sun-like stars. We find modest evidence that single-transit M dwarf planets near the radius gap exhibit higher eccentricity, consistent with trends for Sun-like stars. However, we see no evidence for an increased eccentricity near the radius gap among multitransit M dwarf planets. We discuss implications for these results in the context of predominant atmospheric loss mechanisms: namely, supporting evidence for photoevaporation in M dwarf planets versus planet–planet collisions or giant impacts in FGK dwarf planets.
- 30 January 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (2) , 115
Open AccessThe Orbital Eccentricity–Radius Relation for Planets Orbiting M Dwarfs
The orbital eccentricity–radius relation for small planets is indicative of the predominant dynamical sculpting processes during late-stage orbital evolution. Previous studies have shown that planets orbiting Sun-like stars exhibit an eccentricity–radius trend such that larger planets have higher orbital eccentricities, and that radius gap planets may have modestly higher orbital eccentricities than planets on either side of the radius gap. In this work, we investigate the trend for a sample of smaller M dwarf stars. For a sample of 236 single- and multitransit confirmed planets or candidates discovered by the TESS and Kepler missions, we constrain orbital eccentricity for each planet from the transit photometry together with a stellar density prior. We investigate the binned eccentricity–planet radius relation for the combined planet sample and present evidence for a positive eccentricity–radius relationship with elevated eccentricities for planets larger than 3.5 R ⊕ , similar to the trend for planets orbiting Sun-like stars. We find modest evidence that single-transit M dwarf planets near the radius gap exhibit higher eccentricity, consistent with trends for Sun-like stars. However, we see no evidence for an increased eccentricity near the radius gap among multitransit M dwarf planets. We discuss implications for these results in the context of predominant atmospheric loss mechanisms: namely, supporting evidence for photoevaporation in M dwarf planets versus planet–planet collisions or giant impacts in FGK dwarf planets.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (2) , 75
The Transition from Giant Planets to Brown Dwarfs Beyond 1 au from the Stellar Metallicity Distribution
Giant planets and brown dwarfs are thought to form via a combination of pathways, including bottom-up mechanisms in which gas is accreted onto a solid core and top-down mechanisms in which gas collapses directly into a gravitationally bound object. One can distinguish the prevalence of these mechanisms using host star metallicities. Bottom-up formation thrives in metal-rich environments, whereas top-down formation is weakly dependent on ambient metal content. Using a hierarchical Bayesian model and the results of the California Legacy Survey (CLS), a low-bias and homogeneously analyzed radial velocity survey, we find evidence for a transition in the stellar metallicity distribution at a companion mass of γ = 2 7 − 8 + 12 M Jup for companions with orbital separations between 1 and 50 au. Companions below and above this threshold tend to orbit stars with higher ([Fe/H] = 0.17 ± 0.12 dex) and lower ([Fe/H] = −0.03 ± 0.10 dex) metallicities, respectively. Previous studies of relatively close-in companions reported evidence of a lower transition mass of ≤10 M Jup . When applied to the CLS sample, our model predicts the probability of a transition in the stellar metallicity distribution at or below 10 M Jup to be γ gleaned from other observational metrics and discuss implications for planet-formation theory.
- 8 January 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (2) , 75
Open AccessThe Transition from Giant Planets to Brown Dwarfs Beyond 1 au from the Stellar Metallicity Distribution
Giant planets and brown dwarfs are thought to form via a combination of pathways, including bottom-up mechanisms in which gas is accreted onto a solid core and top-down mechanisms in which gas collapses directly into a gravitationally bound object. One can distinguish the prevalence of these mechanisms using host star metallicities. Bottom-up formation thrives in metal-rich environments, whereas top-down formation is weakly dependent on ambient metal content. Using a hierarchical Bayesian model and the results of the California Legacy Survey (CLS), a low-bias and homogeneously analyzed radial velocity survey, we find evidence for a transition in the stellar metallicity distribution at a companion mass of γ = 2 7 − 8 + 12 M Jup for companions with orbital separations between 1 and 50 au. Companions below and above this threshold tend to orbit stars with higher ([Fe/H] = 0.17 ± 0.12 dex) and lower ([Fe/H] = −0.03 ± 0.10 dex) metallicities, respectively. Previous studies of relatively close-in companions reported evidence of a lower transition mass of ≤10 M Jup . When applied to the CLS sample, our model predicts the probability of a transition in the stellar metallicity distribution at or below 10 M Jup to be γ gleaned from other observational metrics and discuss implications for planet-formation theory.
- Open Access
- 5 January 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (2) , 67
Orbital Eccentricities Suggest a Gradual Transition from Giant Planets to Brown Dwarfs
To date, hundreds of substellar objects with masses between 1 and 80 M Jup have been detected orbiting main-sequence stars. The current convention uses the deuterium-burning limit, M c ≈ 13 M Jup to divide this population between giant planets and brown dwarfs. However, this classification heuristic is largely divorced from any formation physics and may not accurately reflect the astrophysical nature of these objects. Previous work has suggested that a transition from “planet-like” to “brown-dwarf-like” characteristics occurs somewhere in the range 1–10 M Jup , but precise the crossover mass and whether the transition is gradual or abrupt remains unknown. Here, we explore how the occurrence rate, host star metallicity, and orbital eccentricities vary as a function of mass in a sample of 70 Doppler-detected substellar objects (0.8 < M c / M Jup < 80) from the California Legacy Survey. Our population consists of objects near and beyond the water ice line (1 < a /AU < 10), providing valuable clues to the details of giant planet formation physics at a location in the protostellar disk where planet formation efficiency is thought to be enhanced. We find that occurrence rate, host star metallicity, and orbital eccentricity all change gradually across the mass range under consideration, suggesting that “bottom-up” core accretion mechanisms and “top-down” gravitational instability mechanisms produce objects that overlap in mass. The observed eccentricity distributions could arise either from different formation channels or from postformation dynamical interactions between massive substellar objects.
- 5 January 2026
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (2) , 67
Open AccessOrbital Eccentricities Suggest a Gradual Transition from Giant Planets to Brown Dwarfs
To date, hundreds of substellar objects with masses between 1 and 80 M Jup have been detected orbiting main-sequence stars. The current convention uses the deuterium-burning limit, M c ≈ 13 M Jup to divide this population between giant planets and brown dwarfs. However, this classification heuristic is largely divorced from any formation physics and may not accurately reflect the astrophysical nature of these objects. Previous work has suggested that a transition from “planet-like” to “brown-dwarf-like” characteristics occurs somewhere in the range 1–10 M Jup , but precise the crossover mass and whether the transition is gradual or abrupt remains unknown. Here, we explore how the occurrence rate, host star metallicity, and orbital eccentricities vary as a function of mass in a sample of 70 Doppler-detected substellar objects (0.8 < M c / M Jup < 80) from the California Legacy Survey. Our population consists of objects near and beyond the water ice line (1 < a /AU < 10), providing valuable clues to the details of giant planet formation physics at a location in the protostellar disk where planet formation efficiency is thought to be enhanced. We find that occurrence rate, host star metallicity, and orbital eccentricity all change gradually across the mass range under consideration, suggesting that “bottom-up” core accretion mechanisms and “top-down” gravitational instability mechanisms produce objects that overlap in mass. The observed eccentricity distributions could arise either from different formation channels or from postformation dynamical interactions between massive substellar objects.
- Open Access
- 18 December 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (1) , 46
A Decade of Transit-timing Measurements Confirm Resonance in the K2-19 System
K2-19 is a star, slightly smaller than the Sun, that hosts three transiting planets. Two of these, K2-19 b and c, are between the size of Neptune and Saturn and have orbital periods near a 3:2 commensurability, and exhibit strong transit-timing variations (TTVs). A previous TTV analysis reported moderate eccentricities of ≈0.20 ± 0.03 for the two planets, but such high values would imply rapid orbital decay for the innermost planet d. Here, we present an updated analysis that includes eight new transit times from TESS, which extends the time baseline from three years to a decade, and employ a gradient-aware TTV modeling code. We confirm that the system resides in resonance with a small libration amplitude, but find a broader constraints on eccentricity that range from a few percent up to 0.2. These revised eccentricities alleviate previous concerns regarding rapid tidal circularization and support the long-term dynamical stability of the system.
- 18 December 2025
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astronomical Journal
- Vol. 171 (1) , 46
Open AccessA Decade of Transit-timing Measurements Confirm Resonance in the K2-19 System
K2-19 is a star, slightly smaller than the Sun, that hosts three transiting planets. Two of these, K2-19 b and c, are between the size of Neptune and Saturn and have orbital periods near a 3:2 commensurability, and exhibit strong transit-timing variations (TTVs). A previous TTV analysis reported moderate eccentricities of ≈0.20 ± 0.03 for the two planets, but such high values would imply rapid orbital decay for the innermost planet d. Here, we present an updated analysis that includes eight new transit times from TESS, which extends the time baseline from three years to a decade, and employ a gradient-aware TTV modeling code. We confirm that the system resides in resonance with a small libration amplitude, but find a broader constraints on eccentricity that range from a few percent up to 0.2. These revised eccentricities alleviate previous concerns regarding rapid tidal circularization and support the long-term dynamical stability of the system.