SPScott D. Peacor

Scott D. Peacor

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Scott D. Peacor has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Knowledge gaps and areas for synthesis in experimental studies of context‐dependent predation risk

    by Nicole E. Peckham, Scott D. Peacor, Michael J. Sheriff, Justine A. Smith, Nathan J. Dorn, Michael J. Cherry, Tanya L. Rogers, David L. Kimbro

    A growing number of experimental studies address whether the anti‐predator trait responses of prey are associated with costs to prey fitness (non‐consumptive effects) or to the fitness of other species (trait‐mediated indirect effects). Because ecologists remain keen to determine when these risk effects matter, there is a need to know how much of this literature has also evaluated the context‐dependence of risk effects. Such knowledge would identify both understudied research directions and richly investigated areas whose synthesis could advance general understanding of predation risk effects. As a guide for ecologists, we reviewed publications from 1990 to 2021 that experimentally manipulated both predation risk (presence/absence of risk) and another aspect of biotic or abiotic condition (context). We classified each experiment according to a common scheme: the manipulated context was assigned to a Focus (predator, prey, resource, or environment) and Category (community, population, or individual for biotic contexts; temperature, water, habitat, or anthropogenic disturbance for abiotic contexts). A finer categorization of Specific Context (e.g., predator identity, resource abundance) was assigned within each Focus and Category. We also identified the System (marine, freshwater, terrestrial) and Venue (laboratory or field) of each experiment. We classified 433 manipulations (339 publications) falling within 49 different Specific Contexts. Many experiments (63%) manipulated aspects of the predator and/or prey Foci, independently and factorially. Additionally, several Specific Contexts have many published papers and could be suitable for synthesis, including predator and prey identity, predator diversity, prey and resource abundance, habitat structure, and temperature. Meanwhile, manipulations of resources of the prey are relatively lacking. Because most experiments (51%) featured freshwater systems, more marine and terrestrial experiments are needed. Regardless, an imbalance between laboratory (69%) and field (31%) experiments highlights the need for more field investigations. We discuss potential contributors to biases in the literature and consider how understudied contexts should be prioritized. Consequently, our review undergirds future work on the context‐dependency of predation risk effects. As many biotic and abiotic contexts are impacted by anthropogenic activities, optimizing the integration of experimental approaches with other research efforts is crucial to furthering the development and application of predation risk theory.


  • Open Access

    Prey age modifies risk-taking behavior in a multi-predator environment

    by Brian J. Smith, Tal Avgar, Scott D. Peacor, Daniel R. Stahler, Matthew C. Metz, Jack W. Rabe, Wesley Binder, Daniel R. MacNulty

    Many species of animals undergo senescence, impacting predator-prey relationships, yet how senescing prey adjust their risk-taking behavior is poorly understood. We used integrated step selection analysis to quantify risk-taking from empirical data. A graphical framework of age-dependent adaptive risk-taking predicted – and our empirical analysis found – a reduction in female elk ( Cervus canadensis ) risk-taking with age toward wolves ( Canis lupus ) but not cougars ( Puma concolor ), underscoring the role of predator hunting mode in ecological dynamics. We estimated average risk-taking toward wolves would be 42% lower in a population with median age 10 versus 4 years, highlighting how a prey population’s age structure likely impacts risk-induced trait responses and the potential emergence of predation-risk effects. Our findings suggest that altered risk-taking may be an adaptive behavioral shift rather than a passive consequence of physical decline. Such adaptive changes to risk-taking may represent an underappreciated link between individual behavior and community-level coexistence.

  • Open Access

    Ecological meta‐analyses often produce unwarranted results

    by Scott D. Peacor, Chao Song, James R. Bence, Amy A. Briggs, Elizabeth A. Hamman, Craig W. Osenberg

    Meta‐analysis (MA), a powerful tool for synthesizing reported results, is influential in ecology. While ecologists have long been well‐informed on the potential problems associated with nonindependence in experimental work (e.g., pseudoreplication), they have, until recently, largely neglected this issue in MA. However, results used in MAs are likely much more similar when they come from the same locality, system, or laboratory. A simple and common form of nonindependence in MA arises when multiple data points, that is, observed effect sizes, come from the same paper. We obtained original data from 20 published MAs, reconstructed the published analyses, and then, for 14 that had not accounted for a paper effect, used three approaches to evaluate whether within‐paper nonindependence was a problem. First, we found that “nonsense” explanatory variables added to the original analyses were statistically significant ( p < 0.05) far more often than the expected 5% (25%–50% for four nonsense variables). For example, the number of vowels in the first author's name had a significant effect 50% of the time. Second, we found that an added dummy variable, which was randomly assigned at one of two levels, was statistically significant an average of 38% of the time, far exceeding the expected 5%. Even after including a random paper effect in the analyses, there was still an excess of significant results, suggesting that the within‐paper nonindependence was more complex than modeled with the random paper effect. Third, we repeated the original MAs that did not include random paper effects ( n = 14 MAs) but added a random paper effect to each revised analysis. In 12 out of the 14 MAs, an added random effect was statistically significant (indicating group nonindependence that was not accounted for in the original analyses), and often the original inferences were substantially altered. Further, incorporating random paper effects was not a sufficient solution to nonindependence. Thus, problems resulting from nonindependence are often substantial, and accounting for the problem will likely require careful consideration of the details of the potential dependence among observed effect sizes. MAs that do not properly account for this problem may reach unwarranted conclusions.


  • Open Access

    Similar Conditions With Opposite Effects: Predation‐Risk Effects on Prey Abundance Are Highly Contingent

    by Scott D. Peacor, Clayton E. Cressler, Kevin L. Pangle, Alexandra V. Rafalski, Chao Song, Earl E. Werner

    Experiments have shown that predation‐risk effects on prey fitness can be highly contingent on environmental conditions, suggesting a potential difficulty in generalizing risk effects on prey abundance in natural settings. Rather than study the influence of a particular controlled factor, we examine the problem with a novel approach. We examined the influence of risk effects in multiple experiments performed under similar study conditions. Any differences in the experiments would typically be deemed incidental, that is, they would not be given attention in methodology, nor be presented as factors affecting results or inferences. Therefore, any differences in the magnitude and direction of risk effects among experiments would indicate that risk effects on prey population abundance are strongly influenced by context in natural communities. The multiple experiments were conducted under similar conditions, objectives, measurables and implementation, and captured much of the complexity of natural systems (e.g., they were performed with diverse prey assemblages (≥ 11 taxa) over multiple prey generations). Our results highlight the potentially profound context dependence of risk effects: risk effects on the density of some zooplankton species varied between a significant negative effect in one experiment to a significant positive effect in another, whereas other species showed significant negative or positive effects in one experiment and no effect in another. We review mechanisms that could underlie risk effects having opposite effects on the same prey. Our findings illustrate that risk effects observed in one study may not hold, even for the same species in the same system.


  • Measuring the benefit of a defensive trait: Vigilance and survival probability

    by William H. Ellsworth, Scott D. Peacor, Richard B. Chandler, L. Mike Conner, Elina P. Garrison, Karl V. Miller, Michael J. Cherry

    Defensive traits are hypothesized to benefit prey by reducing predation risk from a focal predator but come at a cost to the fitness of the prey. Variation in the expression of defensive traits is seen among individuals within the same population, and in the same individual in response to changes in the environment (i.e., phenotypically plastic responses). It is the relative magnitude of the cost and benefit of the defensive trait that underlies the defensive trait expression and its consequences to the community. However, whereas the cost has received much attention in ecological research, the benefit is seldom examined. Even in a defensive trait as extensively studied as vigilance, there are few studies of the purported benefit of the behavior, namely that vigilance enhances survival. We examined whether prey vigilance increased survival and quantified that benefit in a natural system, with white‐tailed deer ( Odocoileus virginianus ) experiencing unmanipulated levels of predation risk from Florida panther ( Puma concolor coryi ). Deer that spent more time vigilant (as measured by head position using camera trap data) had a higher probability of survival. Indeed, an individual deer that was vigilant 75% of the time was more than three times as likely to be killed by panthers over the course of a year than a deer that was vigilant 95% of the time. Our results therefore show that within‐population variation in the expression of a defensive trait has profound consequences for the benefit it confers. Our results provide empirical evidence supporting a long‐held but seldom‐tested hypothesis, that vigilance is a behavior that reduces the probability of predation and quantifies the benefit of this defensive trait. Our work furthers an understanding of the net effects of a trait on prey fitness and predator–prey interactions, within‐population variation in traits, and predation risk effects.


  • Open Access

    Population and community consequences of perceived risk from humans in wildlife

    by Justine A. Smith, Megan E. McDaniels, Scott D. Peacor, Ellen C. Bolas, Michael J. Cherry, Nathan J. Dorn, Olivia K. Feldman, David L. Kimbro, Emily K. Leonhardt, Nicole E. Peckham, et al.

    Human activities catalyse risk avoidance behaviours in wildlife across taxa and systems. However, the broader ecological significance of human‐induced risk perception remains unclear, with a limited understanding of how phenotypic responses scale up to affect population or community dynamics. We present a framework informed by predator–prey ecology to predict the occurrence of non‐consumptive effects (NCE) and trait‐mediated indirect effects (TMIE) of anthropogenic disturbances. We report evidence from a comprehensive review of the different types of human‐induced behavioural and physiological phenotypic changes and their influence on vital rates and population parameters in wildlife. Evidence for human‐induced NCEs and TMIEs is mixed, with half of published studies finding a relationship between human activities, phenotypic change and population outcomes. The net effects of anthropogenic NCEs and TMIEs depend on the mismatch between the phenotypic response and the lethality of human activity. However, strong research biases in taxa, systems, human disturbance types and demographic measures prevent unified inference about the prevalence of population responses to human activities. Coexistence with and conservation of wildlife requires additional research linking human‐induced phenotypic change to population and community outcomes.


  • Open Access

    Higher predation rate need not and did not lead to higher risk‐induced trait responses in related zooplankton species

    by Alexandra V. Rafalski, Kevin L. Pangle, Scott D. Peacor

    Predators can directly affect prey populations both through predation (consumption of prey) and risk‐induced trait responses (RITRs) that reduce predation risk but are often associated with a fitness cost. Thousands of studies make clear that RITRs (also termed anti‐predator or defensive traits) including changes in behavior, morphology, and life history, are employed by numerous taxa across diverse ecological systems, and there is large variation in their magnitude. A natural goal is to elucidate the species and circumstances for which and to what magnitude RITRs are expected. A candidate hypothesis is that prey species that experience higher mortality from a predator will exhibit a higher RITR. This hypothesis is an intuitive extension of the fact that invulnerable animals are not expected to exhibit an RITR, while vulnerable species are. We present an example that clarifies why this relationship is not always expected and when it is expected. Other factors may influence the level of the RITR leading to the possibility that a positive relationship is not expected. We elucidate this problem using a mesocosm experiment with a fish–cladoceran system in which there is large variability in the predation rate on different cladoceran species. Results not only did not show a positive relationship, but rather a negative trend between predation rate and the RITR. In fact, highly preyed upon taxa did not respond, while the least preyed upon taxa had the largest responses. These results clarify how the level of predation risk interacts with many factors to determine the RITR of prey.


  • Open Access

    A skewed literature: Few studies evaluate the contribution of predation‐risk effects to natural field patterns

    by Scott D. Peacor, Nathan J. Dorn, Justine A. Smith, Nicole E. Peckham, Michael J. Cherry, Michael J. Sheriff, David L. Kimbro

    A narrative in ecology is that prey modify traits to reduce predation risk, and the trait modification has costs large enough to cause ensuing demographic, trophic and ecosystem consequences, with implications for conservation, management and agriculture. But ecology has a long history of emphasising that quantifying the importance of an ecological process ultimately requires evidence linking a process to unmanipulated field patterns. We suspected that such process‐linked‐to‐pattern (PLP) studies were poorly represented in the predation risk literature, which conflicts with the confidence often given to the importance of risk effects. We reviewed 29 years of the ecological literature which revealed that there are well over 4000 articles on risk effects. Of those, 349 studies examined risk effects on prey fitness measures or abundance (i.e., non‐consumptive effects) of which only 26 were PLP studies, while 275 studies examined effects on other interacting species (i.e., trait‐mediated indirect effects) of which only 35 were PLP studies. PLP studies were narrowly focused taxonomically and included only three that examined unmanipulated patterns of prey abundance. Before concluding a widespread and influential role of predation‐risk effects, more attention must be given to linking the process of risk effects to unmanipulated patterns observed across diverse ecosystems.


  • Open Access

    An assessment of statistical methods for non‐independent data in ecological meta‐analyses: Reply

    by Chao Song, Scott D. Peacor, Craig W. Osenberg, James R. Bence


  • Open Access

    An assessment of statistical methods for nonindependent data in ecological meta‐analyses

    by Chao Song, Scott D. Peacor, Craig W. Osenberg, James R. Bence

    In ecological meta‐analyses, nonindependence among observed effect sizes from the same source paper is common. If not accounted for, nonindependence can seriously undermine inferences. We compared the performance of four meta‐analysis methods that attempt to address such nonindependence and the standard random‐effect model that ignores nonindependence. We simulated data with various types of within‐paper nonindependence, and assessed the standard deviation of the estimated mean effect size and Type I error rate of each method. Although all four methods performed substantially better than the standard random‐effects model that assumes independence, there were differences in performance among the methods. A two‐step method that first summarizes the multiple observed effect sizes per paper using a weighted mean and then analyzes the reduced data in a standard random‐effects model, and a robust variance estimation method performed consistently well. A hierarchical model with both random paper and study effects gave precise estimates but had a higher Type I error rates, possibly reflecting limitations of currently available meta‐analysis software. Overall, we advocate the use of the two‐step method with a weighted paper mean and the robust variance estimation method as reliable ways to handle within‐paper nonindependence in ecological meta‐analyses.