Muhammad Abid Malik
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Muhammad Abid Malik has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Amjad Islam Amjad
Department of Education, The University of Lahore, Lahore, Pakistan
2 shared publications - Ameema Mahroof
Faculty of Education, University of the Punjab, Lahore 54590, Pakistan
1 shared publication - Ayesha Khalid
Akhuwat Department of Library and Information Services Lahore and Department of Library and Information Management, Superior University, Lahore, Pakistan
1 shared publication - Bulent Akkaya
Faculty of Applied Sciences , Banking and Finance Department, Manisa Celal Bayar University, Manisa, Türkiye
1 shared publication - Guifang Liu
Beijing International Studies University, Beijing, China
1 shared publication Habibullah Pathan
Mehran University of Engineering and Technology
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 February 2025
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 10, 1541543
AI teachers (AI-based robots as teachers): history, potential, concerns and recommendations
Although Artificial intelligence (AI) has been used in education for a long time, its popularity and spread have witnessed exponential growth since the launch of ChatGPT. It can be used as a tool, teaching assistant, or teacher. AI teacher (AI-based robot as a teacher) is not a new concept with the first teaching robots used in the 1970s; however, most of the research and usage of AI in education is focused on AI as a tool or a teaching assistant. This article looks at AI teachers’ history, some key cases, potential and benefits, and concerns and challenges associated with their use in classrooms. Overcoming teachers’ shortage, flexibility, transparency, unbiasedness, and improving students’ motivation were some of their key benefits; while being untested and unreliable, cost, need for specific infrastructure and technical expertise, resistance to change, ethical issues, and fears of dehumanizing and desensitizing students were the main concerns and challenges. We suggest co-teaching with AI teachers using four different approaches. Through them, AI teachers and human teachers can work together in classrooms to maximize the effectiveness of the teaching-learning process.
- 21 February 2025
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 10, 1541543
Open AccessAI teachers (AI-based robots as teachers): history, potential, concerns and recommendations
Although Artificial intelligence (AI) has been used in education for a long time, its popularity and spread have witnessed exponential growth since the launch of ChatGPT. It can be used as a tool, teaching assistant, or teacher. AI teacher (AI-based robot as a teacher) is not a new concept with the first teaching robots used in the 1970s; however, most of the research and usage of AI in education is focused on AI as a tool or a teaching assistant. This article looks at AI teachers’ history, some key cases, potential and benefits, and concerns and challenges associated with their use in classrooms. Overcoming teachers’ shortage, flexibility, transparency, unbiasedness, and improving students’ motivation were some of their key benefits; while being untested and unreliable, cost, need for specific infrastructure and technical expertise, resistance to change, ethical issues, and fears of dehumanizing and desensitizing students were the main concerns and challenges. We suggest co-teaching with AI teachers using four different approaches. Through them, AI teachers and human teachers can work together in classrooms to maximize the effectiveness of the teaching-learning process.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Open Access Publishing Association in Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching
- Vol. 8 (1) , 91-101
AI vs AI: How effective are Turnitin, ZeroGPT, GPTZero, and Writer AI in detecting text generated by ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini?
AI chatbots and LLMs have made a significant impact in a short time. Despite their benefits, they pose serious threats to academic integrity and ethics by generating human-like text, which is very hard to detect. Various AI-detection tools have been developed to tackle this issue. However, their effectiveness is questionable. This study investigates the performance of four AI-detection tools (Turnitin, ZeroGPT, GPTZero, and Writer AI) in detecting AI-generated text. That text was generated using three LLMs (ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini). Furthermore, three adversarial techniques (edited through Grammarly, paraphrased through Quillbot, and 10%-20% editing by a human expert) were applied to see their effects on the performance of AI-detection tools. Turnitin turned out to be the most accurate and consistent one, with a 100% AI score even with the adversarial techniques. ZeroGPT and GPTZero also reported relatively high AI scores, especially with the original files and the first and third adversarial techniques. Among the three adversarial techniques, paraphrasing through Quillbot affected the performance of three AI-detection tools (ZeroGPT, GPTZero, and Writer AI) the most. Among the three LLMs, text generated through Perplexity was more accurately detected, while Gemini-generated text showed a relatively lower AI score. What was the most note-worthy was the fact that in many cases, even when the text was generated through the same LLM, and detected through the same AI-detection tool; different files showed different AI scores, further highlighting the inconsistencies among AI-detection tools.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Open Access Publishing Association in Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching
- Vol. 8 (1) , 91-101
Open AccessAI vs AI: How effective are Turnitin, ZeroGPT, GPTZero, and Writer AI in detecting text generated by ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini?
AI chatbots and LLMs have made a significant impact in a short time. Despite their benefits, they pose serious threats to academic integrity and ethics by generating human-like text, which is very hard to detect. Various AI-detection tools have been developed to tackle this issue. However, their effectiveness is questionable. This study investigates the performance of four AI-detection tools (Turnitin, ZeroGPT, GPTZero, and Writer AI) in detecting AI-generated text. That text was generated using three LLMs (ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini). Furthermore, three adversarial techniques (edited through Grammarly, paraphrased through Quillbot, and 10%-20% editing by a human expert) were applied to see their effects on the performance of AI-detection tools. Turnitin turned out to be the most accurate and consistent one, with a 100% AI score even with the adversarial techniques. ZeroGPT and GPTZero also reported relatively high AI scores, especially with the original files and the first and third adversarial techniques. Among the three adversarial techniques, paraphrasing through Quillbot affected the performance of three AI-detection tools (ZeroGPT, GPTZero, and Writer AI) the most. Among the three LLMs, text generated through Perplexity was more accurately detected, while Gemini-generated text showed a relatively lower AI score. What was the most note-worthy was the fact that in many cases, even when the text was generated through the same LLM, and detected through the same AI-detection tool; different files showed different AI scores, further highlighting the inconsistencies among AI-detection tools.
- 20 September 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Education 3-13
- Vol. 54 (5) , 1236-1249
‘I thought, I believed, and I did it’: a case study about the successful implementation of twenty-first-century skills in Trinidad and Tobago
- 20 September 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Education 3-13
- Vol. 54 (5) , 1236-1249
‘I thought, I believed, and I did it’: a case study about the successful implementation of twenty-first-century skills in Trinidad and Tobago
- Open Access
- 2 September 2024
- Published by Qeios Ltd
- Vol. 6 (9)
From Isolation to Acceptance: Improving Social Acceptance and Educational Opportunities for Transgender People in Pakistan
Transgender people usually face social isolation and discrimination. Although the situation is improving in developed countries, it is still grim in more traditional and conservative societies like Pakistan. Gathering data through semi-structured interviews from eight female students, eight female teachers, and eight mothers from two girls-only schools in Lahore, this study investigated their perceptions about the social acceptance and educational opportunities for transgender people in the country. It further explored their views about transgender-inclusive education and how their social inclusion and educational opportunities could be improved. All the participants acknowledged the lack of social acceptance and educational opportunities for transgender people; however, when it came to transgender-inclusive education, opinions were more divided. Some of the participants, especially the mothers, had reservations due to social and cultural values, safety concerns, and fears of bad influence and classroom distractions. The teachers also pointed out the fact that schools, communities, students, teachers, and even the transgender people themselves were not ready for transgender-inclusive education. Although most of them believed that transgender-inclusive education was the only viable way to provide education to transgender people in Pakistan, they suggested first preparing society for it through awareness campaigns, seminars, workshops, training sessions, and school-community interactions.
- 2 September 2024
- Published by Qeios Ltd
- Vol. 6 (9)
Open AccessFrom Isolation to Acceptance: Improving Social Acceptance and Educational Opportunities for Transgender People in Pakistan
Transgender people usually face social isolation and discrimination. Although the situation is improving in developed countries, it is still grim in more traditional and conservative societies like Pakistan. Gathering data through semi-structured interviews from eight female students, eight female teachers, and eight mothers from two girls-only schools in Lahore, this study investigated their perceptions about the social acceptance and educational opportunities for transgender people in the country. It further explored their views about transgender-inclusive education and how their social inclusion and educational opportunities could be improved. All the participants acknowledged the lack of social acceptance and educational opportunities for transgender people; however, when it came to transgender-inclusive education, opinions were more divided. Some of the participants, especially the mothers, had reservations due to social and cultural values, safety concerns, and fears of bad influence and classroom distractions. The teachers also pointed out the fact that schools, communities, students, teachers, and even the transgender people themselves were not ready for transgender-inclusive education. Although most of them believed that transgender-inclusive education was the only viable way to provide education to transgender people in Pakistan, they suggested first preparing society for it through awareness campaigns, seminars, workshops, training sessions, and school-community interactions.
- 11 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs
- Vol. 24 (4) , 1161-1174
Interviewing students with special needs: Developing ethical considerations and interviewing protocols
Interviewing students with special needs (SSNs) comes with a unique set of ethical and practical challenges that require highly specialised skills and interviewing protocols. Our objectives were to identify the most appropriate tools for collecting data from SSNs, key differences in interviewing students with and without special needs, and ethical and practical challenges during it. The ultimate goal was to develop ethical considerations and interviewing protocols for SSNs (ECIP4SSN). It was done through a two‐step Delphi method, collecting data from 11 special education experts from 11 different countries. The experts believed the tools should be selected based on the study's nature; however, many of them preferred the interviews. They believed that interviewing special students is challenging due to their special needs. Challenges pertaining to consent, hyperactivity, emotional distress, and wrong and irrelevant answers were among the top challenges mentioned by them. Final ECIP4SSN consisted of the key ethical considerations and interviewing protocols i.e. obtaining the background information and support, training and preparations, consent, data collection, building rapport, emotional support, confidentiality, and anonymity, using supporting tools, language, methods of asking questions and validating responses. The ECIP4SSN will guide the university teachers, students and researchers in interviewing special students.
- 11 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs
- Vol. 24 (4) , 1161-1174
Interviewing students with special needs: Developing ethical considerations and interviewing protocols
Interviewing students with special needs (SSNs) comes with a unique set of ethical and practical challenges that require highly specialised skills and interviewing protocols. Our objectives were to identify the most appropriate tools for collecting data from SSNs, key differences in interviewing students with and without special needs, and ethical and practical challenges during it. The ultimate goal was to develop ethical considerations and interviewing protocols for SSNs (ECIP4SSN). It was done through a two‐step Delphi method, collecting data from 11 special education experts from 11 different countries. The experts believed the tools should be selected based on the study's nature; however, many of them preferred the interviews. They believed that interviewing special students is challenging due to their special needs. Challenges pertaining to consent, hyperactivity, emotional distress, and wrong and irrelevant answers were among the top challenges mentioned by them. Final ECIP4SSN consisted of the key ethical considerations and interviewing protocols i.e. obtaining the background information and support, training and preparations, consent, data collection, building rapport, emotional support, confidentiality, and anonymity, using supporting tools, language, methods of asking questions and validating responses. The ECIP4SSN will guide the university teachers, students and researchers in interviewing special students.
- Open Access
- 15 August 2022
- Published by Nova Southeastern University in The Qualitative Report
- Vol. 28 (8) , 2343-2362
Time to Transform: Challenges and Opportunities for Teaching Practice During COVID-19 and Beyond
Teaching practice is one of the most significant components of a teacher education program that prepares prospective teachers for a fast-changing and technology-infused world. However, in many developing countries like Pakistan, it has remained stuck in the traditional methods (face-to-face, without proper utilization of technology) which made it vulnerable during COVID-19. This study explores teaching practice methods and strategies used by Pakistani universities before and during COVID-19. It further identifies the causes behind its deficiencies to prepare prospective teachers for the challenges of the current era. Using semi-structured interviews, data was gathered from nine teaching practice supervisors from nine different universities. The study found that before COVID-19, eight universities used traditional methods and strategies for teaching practice. During COVID-19, the universities used four different approaches (online teaching practice in mock classes, online teaching practice with real students, microteaching 2.0, and teaching practice through emails and WhatsApp groups) for its continuation. Ignoring modern tools and technologies, lack of focus and attention, and a clerical approach were reported to be the main reasons behind its deficiencies to prepare prospective teachers for the challenges of the current world. The study highlights the importance of using blended modes for teaching practice, allocating some credit hours/modules for purely online teaching practice, giving more importance to it, and providing specialized training to teaching practice supervisors and cooperating teachers so that they can supervise and assess prospective teachers more effectively.
- 15 August 2022
- Published by Nova Southeastern University in The Qualitative Report
- Vol. 28 (8) , 2343-2362
Open AccessTime to Transform: Challenges and Opportunities for Teaching Practice During COVID-19 and Beyond
Teaching practice is one of the most significant components of a teacher education program that prepares prospective teachers for a fast-changing and technology-infused world. However, in many developing countries like Pakistan, it has remained stuck in the traditional methods (face-to-face, without proper utilization of technology) which made it vulnerable during COVID-19. This study explores teaching practice methods and strategies used by Pakistani universities before and during COVID-19. It further identifies the causes behind its deficiencies to prepare prospective teachers for the challenges of the current era. Using semi-structured interviews, data was gathered from nine teaching practice supervisors from nine different universities. The study found that before COVID-19, eight universities used traditional methods and strategies for teaching practice. During COVID-19, the universities used four different approaches (online teaching practice in mock classes, online teaching practice with real students, microteaching 2.0, and teaching practice through emails and WhatsApp groups) for its continuation. Ignoring modern tools and technologies, lack of focus and attention, and a clerical approach were reported to be the main reasons behind its deficiencies to prepare prospective teachers for the challenges of the current world. The study highlights the importance of using blended modes for teaching practice, allocating some credit hours/modules for purely online teaching practice, giving more importance to it, and providing specialized training to teaching practice supervisors and cooperating teachers so that they can supervise and assess prospective teachers more effectively.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Humanity Only - HO in Global Sociological Review
- Vol. VII (II) , 26-36
Construction of Femininity and Consumer Culture in American Women's Magazines: A Qualitative Study about Good Housekeeping
Good housekeeping is one of the mainstream American women's magazines. Targeting primarily the middle-class married women, it gives guidance and suggestions on beautifying appearance, latest fashions,housekeeping, cooking, and child-rearing. Using 24 issues of Good Housekeeping published in 2016-2017, this study explores what kind of femininity is constructed in this magazine. The study uses thematic analysis and interpretive textual analysis as the key methodologies. Furthermore, it explores the overlapping relationships between the magazine, femininity, and consumer culture. The article finds that femininity constructed in those two years of Good Housekeeping tends to be conservative, which is idealized and perfected in the magazine.The magazine has maintained its long-established and conservative style. It is established on a commercialized base and advocates that ideal femininity is to be gained through
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Humanity Only - HO in Global Sociological Review
- Vol. VII (II) , 26-36
Open AccessConstruction of Femininity and Consumer Culture in American Women's Magazines: A Qualitative Study about Good Housekeeping
Good housekeeping is one of the mainstream American women's magazines. Targeting primarily the middle-class married women, it gives guidance and suggestions on beautifying appearance, latest fashions,housekeeping, cooking, and child-rearing. Using 24 issues of Good Housekeeping published in 2016-2017, this study explores what kind of femininity is constructed in this magazine. The study uses thematic analysis and interpretive textual analysis as the key methodologies. Furthermore, it explores the overlapping relationships between the magazine, femininity, and consumer culture. The article finds that femininity constructed in those two years of Good Housekeeping tends to be conservative, which is idealized and perfected in the magazine.The magazine has maintained its long-established and conservative style. It is established on a commercialized base and advocates that ideal femininity is to be gained through
- 29 June 2022
- Published by Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM Press) in 3l the Southeast Asian Journal of English Language Studies
- Vol. 28 (2) , 83-95
Influence of Mother Tongue on English Writing: An Error-analysis Study about Grade 9 Students in Pakistan
Influence of Mother Tongue on English Writing: An Error-analysis Study about Grade 9 Students in Pakistan
- 29 June 2022
- Published by Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM Press) in 3l the Southeast Asian Journal of English Language Studies
- Vol. 28 (2) , 83-95
Influence of Mother Tongue on English Writing: An Error-analysis Study about Grade 9 Students in Pakistan
Influence of Mother Tongue on English Writing: An Error-analysis Study about Grade 9 Students in Pakistan
- 24 June 2022
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 1-16
Combating COVID
This study investigates Pakistani universities' responses during COVID-19. Permanent faculty members from eight different universities were interviewed for data collection. The participants reported six different strategies that were employed to continue the teaching-learning process during COVID-19: from well-developed LMS to virtually no classes. They also pointed out five main issues and challenges during COVID-19 (i.e., infrastructure and internet-related issues, students' participation and engagement issues, teachers' training and attitudinal issues, quality assurance issues, and lack of uniform policy by HEC). They also feared increased educational disparities due to the digital divide. Although this pandemic has adversely affected the higher education sector in Pakistan, if the policymakers and institutions are willing to learn and innovate, this crisis can be turned into an opportunity.
- 24 June 2022
- Published by IGI Global Scientific Publishing
- p. 1-16
Combating COVID
This study investigates Pakistani universities' responses during COVID-19. Permanent faculty members from eight different universities were interviewed for data collection. The participants reported six different strategies that were employed to continue the teaching-learning process during COVID-19: from well-developed LMS to virtually no classes. They also pointed out five main issues and challenges during COVID-19 (i.e., infrastructure and internet-related issues, students' participation and engagement issues, teachers' training and attitudinal issues, quality assurance issues, and lack of uniform policy by HEC). They also feared increased educational disparities due to the digital divide. Although this pandemic has adversely affected the higher education sector in Pakistan, if the policymakers and institutions are willing to learn and innovate, this crisis can be turned into an opportunity.
- Open Access
- 17 December 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (24) , 12055
Online University Students’ Perceptions on the Awareness of, Reasons for, and Solutions to Plagiarism in Higher Education: The Development of the AS&P Model to Combat Plagiarism
Academic plagiarism has remained a major concern for higher education institutions, as it hampers not only the quality of the teaching-learning process and research, but also the overall educational institution. This issue appears to be even more serious in online and distance education institutions. As a result, a qualitative study was conducted on an online university in Pakistan to investigate the determinants of academic plagiarism and to find ways to address this issue. The students were given an open-ended questionnaire to reflect their opinions on the awareness and understanding of plagiarism, its determinants, and ways to address it. The findings revealed that most of the 267 online university students had a poor awareness and understanding of plagiarism. Major reasons for students’ plagiarism turned out to be a lack of a proactive approach to create awareness, an omission of citation conventions from course content, untrained teachers, a lack of strict penalties and their proper implementation, poor time management, a fear of failure, a lack of confidence, laziness, and a culture of plagiarism. The study proposes the Awareness, Support, and Prevention model (AS&P model) to address this issue in higher education institutions.
- 17 December 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 11 (24) , 12055
Open AccessOnline University Students’ Perceptions on the Awareness of, Reasons for, and Solutions to Plagiarism in Higher Education: The Development of the AS&P Model to Combat Plagiarism
Academic plagiarism has remained a major concern for higher education institutions, as it hampers not only the quality of the teaching-learning process and research, but also the overall educational institution. This issue appears to be even more serious in online and distance education institutions. As a result, a qualitative study was conducted on an online university in Pakistan to investigate the determinants of academic plagiarism and to find ways to address this issue. The students were given an open-ended questionnaire to reflect their opinions on the awareness and understanding of plagiarism, its determinants, and ways to address it. The findings revealed that most of the 267 online university students had a poor awareness and understanding of plagiarism. Major reasons for students’ plagiarism turned out to be a lack of a proactive approach to create awareness, an omission of citation conventions from course content, untrained teachers, a lack of strict penalties and their proper implementation, poor time management, a fear of failure, a lack of confidence, laziness, and a culture of plagiarism. The study proposes the Awareness, Support, and Prevention model (AS&P model) to address this issue in higher education institutions.