Vahid Rahmani
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Vahid Rahmani has a total of 41 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nasrin Aghazadeh
Research Center for Evidence-Based Health Management, Maragheh University of Medical Sciences, Maragheh, Iran
4 shared publications - Mohammad Arabsorkhi Mishabi
Medical Education Department, Medical Education Research Center, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
3 shared publications - Arezo Elmi
Shohada Educational Hospital, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
2 shared publications Ashkan Karimi
Department of Medical Education, School of Medical Education and Learning Technologies, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 shared publications- Atiyeh Sadat Sajadi
Department of Medical Education, School of Medical Education and Learning Technologies, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 shared publications - Dorrin Nikbakht
Department of Operating Room, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 November 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
- Vol. ume 17, 1-10
Learner-Created Infographics as a Visual Active Learning Strategy: Knowledge Scores and Retention Among Undergraduate Anesthesia Students
Purpose: Active, learner-centered strategies are increasingly replacing lecture-based instruction in medical education. Infographic design has been proposed as a way to support cognitive processing and retention of complex clinical content. This study compared knowledge scores and retention between undergraduate anesthesia students who created infographics after each lecture and those who took notes. Participants and Methods: This non-randomized (quasi-experimental) two-group study used a three-phase pretest–posttest design with 70 undergraduate anesthesia students. Groups were formed by semester: third-semester students (n = 35) were the intervention group and fourth-semester students (n = 35) the control group. Both groups received identical lectures on critical care topics over six sessions. The intervention group also attended a 2-hour orientation and, after each session, individually designed an infographic; the control group took notes as usual. Knowledge was assessed at pretest, 10 days later (posttest 1), and 1 month later (posttest 2) using expert-reviewed tests. Data were analyzed with t-tests and a mixed repeated-measures ANOVA. Results: The two groups were similar in age, gender, and pretest scores. Both groups improved markedly from pretest to the first posttest, and the intervention group scored significantly higher than the control group (16.96 ± 1.31 vs 15.11 ± 1.57, P < 0.001). Scores declined in both groups by the second posttest, but the decline was smaller in the intervention group, and its mean score remained significantly higher than that of the control group (14.70 ± 1.65 vs 11.81 ± 1.40, P < 0.001). The difference between the groups therefore widened over time, and the group × time interaction was significant (P < 0.001, partial η2 = 0.319). Conclusion: In this non-randomized study, students who received an orientation and created infographics after each lecture had higher knowledge scores at 10 days and one month than those who attended the same lectures and took notes. Because the intervention group also had additional orientation, practice, and time on task, and groups were not randomized, the findings cannot be attributed to infographic design itself and should be considered preliminary. Randomized studies with a matched active control are needed.
- 1 November 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
- Vol. ume 17, 1-10
Open AccessLearner-Created Infographics as a Visual Active Learning Strategy: Knowledge Scores and Retention Among Undergraduate Anesthesia Students
Purpose: Active, learner-centered strategies are increasingly replacing lecture-based instruction in medical education. Infographic design has been proposed as a way to support cognitive processing and retention of complex clinical content. This study compared knowledge scores and retention between undergraduate anesthesia students who created infographics after each lecture and those who took notes. Participants and Methods: This non-randomized (quasi-experimental) two-group study used a three-phase pretest–posttest design with 70 undergraduate anesthesia students. Groups were formed by semester: third-semester students (n = 35) were the intervention group and fourth-semester students (n = 35) the control group. Both groups received identical lectures on critical care topics over six sessions. The intervention group also attended a 2-hour orientation and, after each session, individually designed an infographic; the control group took notes as usual. Knowledge was assessed at pretest, 10 days later (posttest 1), and 1 month later (posttest 2) using expert-reviewed tests. Data were analyzed with t-tests and a mixed repeated-measures ANOVA. Results: The two groups were similar in age, gender, and pretest scores. Both groups improved markedly from pretest to the first posttest, and the intervention group scored significantly higher than the control group (16.96 ± 1.31 vs 15.11 ± 1.57, P < 0.001). Scores declined in both groups by the second posttest, but the decline was smaller in the intervention group, and its mean score remained significantly higher than that of the control group (14.70 ± 1.65 vs 11.81 ± 1.40, P < 0.001). The difference between the groups therefore widened over time, and the group × time interaction was significant (P < 0.001, partial η2 = 0.319). Conclusion: In this non-randomized study, students who received an orientation and created infographics after each lecture had higher knowledge scores at 10 days and one month than those who attended the same lectures and took notes. Because the intervention group also had additional orientation, practice, and time on task, and groups were not randomized, the findings cannot be attributed to infographic design itself and should be considered preliminary. Randomized studies with a matched active control are needed.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
- Vol. ume 17, 1-7
Hidden Talents in Medical Education: Visual Thinkers May Activate Intelligences Through Mind Mapping
This conceptual paper proposes that mind mapping may serve as a tool with the potential to transform students’ invisible clinical thinking into a tangible and assessable "clinical palette”. By visually representing data, analyses, connections, and decision-making processes, mind mapping is proposed to help unveil hidden layers of clinical reasoning while potentially engaging a wide range of intelligences, including spatial, logical, creative, fluid, intrapersonal, and interpersonal. It is hypothesized that this approach may reduce working memory load and facilitate the recognition of previously unperceived patterns, although these proposed cognitive mechanisms have not yet been empirically tested in clinical education settings. Mind mapping is thus presented not merely as a learning technique but as a candidate framework to potentially illuminate overlooked cognitive pathways and help identify latent abilities. In clinical settings, this tool could, in principle, depict the student’s cognitive journey from history-taking to diagnostic hypothesis generation and treatment planning, potentially making subtle and often overlooked aspects of clinical reasoning observable. To operationalize this proposed approach, clinical educators may consider integrating mind mapping into medical training through strategies such as brief 5– 10 minute student-generated maps, establishing mind-mapping studios, integrating mind maps with clinical assessment tools, and developing faculty programs focused on teaching the art of visual thinking. As a conceptual perspective, this framework requires empirical validation including controlled and longitudinal studies, before its educational value and comparative advantage over related constructs such as concept mapping and illness scripts can be established.
- 1 September 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Advances in Medical Education and Practice
- Vol. ume 17, 1-7
Open AccessHidden Talents in Medical Education: Visual Thinkers May Activate Intelligences Through Mind Mapping
This conceptual paper proposes that mind mapping may serve as a tool with the potential to transform students’ invisible clinical thinking into a tangible and assessable "clinical palette”. By visually representing data, analyses, connections, and decision-making processes, mind mapping is proposed to help unveil hidden layers of clinical reasoning while potentially engaging a wide range of intelligences, including spatial, logical, creative, fluid, intrapersonal, and interpersonal. It is hypothesized that this approach may reduce working memory load and facilitate the recognition of previously unperceived patterns, although these proposed cognitive mechanisms have not yet been empirically tested in clinical education settings. Mind mapping is thus presented not merely as a learning technique but as a candidate framework to potentially illuminate overlooked cognitive pathways and help identify latent abilities. In clinical settings, this tool could, in principle, depict the student’s cognitive journey from history-taking to diagnostic hypothesis generation and treatment planning, potentially making subtle and often overlooked aspects of clinical reasoning observable. To operationalize this proposed approach, clinical educators may consider integrating mind mapping into medical training through strategies such as brief 5– 10 minute student-generated maps, establishing mind-mapping studios, integrating mind maps with clinical assessment tools, and developing faculty programs focused on teaching the art of visual thinking. As a conceptual perspective, this framework requires empirical validation including controlled and longitudinal studies, before its educational value and comparative advantage over related constructs such as concept mapping and illness scripts can be established.
- 16 December 2025
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Avicenna journal of Care and Health in Operating Room
- Vol. 3 (4) , 157-164
Investigating the Impact of Standard Physical Environment of Operating Room on Job Satisfaction Among Operating Room Staff in Maragheh Hospitals, Iran, in 2024
Introduction: Job satisfaction among operating room personnel is a key factor in improving the quality of healthcare services and enhancing the efficiency of the health system. A standard physical environment serves as an essential foundation for achieving these goals. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between the compliance of operating room physical spaces with national standards and the level of job satisfaction among operating room staff in hospitals of Maragheh County in 2024. Methods: In this descriptive-analytical study, 87 operating room personnel from hospitals in Maragheh County were examined through a census method. Data were collected using a researcher-made checklist assessing compliance with physical environment standards and the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ). Data analysis was performed using Pearson’s correlation coefficient, independent t-test, and ANOVA or its non-parametric equivalent in SPSS version 24.0. Results: Of the 87 participants, 66 were women, and 21 were men. The mean age of participants was 33.04±1.7 years. The overall compliance of the physical environment with standards was 73.23%, and the mean job satisfaction score was 71.77±13.54. Although a positive numerical correlation was observed between the two variables (r=0.540), this relationship was not statistically significant (P=0.076). Additionally, significant associations were found between job satisfaction and gender (P=0.008), age (P=0.01, r=0.334), and workplace hospital (P<0.05). Conclusion: The findings indicate that although a standard physical environment is an important prerequisite for optimal performance, it is not a strong standalone predictor of job satisfaction. Organizational and psychosocial factors play a substantial role in shaping job satisfaction among operating room staff. Therefore, adopting a systemic multidimensional approach that simultaneously improves the physical environment and strengthens motivational and organizational factors is crucial in enhancing job satisfaction in this department.
- 16 December 2025
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Avicenna journal of Care and Health in Operating Room
- Vol. 3 (4) , 157-164
Investigating the Impact of Standard Physical Environment of Operating Room on Job Satisfaction Among Operating Room Staff in Maragheh Hospitals, Iran, in 2024
Introduction: Job satisfaction among operating room personnel is a key factor in improving the quality of healthcare services and enhancing the efficiency of the health system. A standard physical environment serves as an essential foundation for achieving these goals. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between the compliance of operating room physical spaces with national standards and the level of job satisfaction among operating room staff in hospitals of Maragheh County in 2024. Methods: In this descriptive-analytical study, 87 operating room personnel from hospitals in Maragheh County were examined through a census method. Data were collected using a researcher-made checklist assessing compliance with physical environment standards and the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ). Data analysis was performed using Pearson’s correlation coefficient, independent t-test, and ANOVA or its non-parametric equivalent in SPSS version 24.0. Results: Of the 87 participants, 66 were women, and 21 were men. The mean age of participants was 33.04±1.7 years. The overall compliance of the physical environment with standards was 73.23%, and the mean job satisfaction score was 71.77±13.54. Although a positive numerical correlation was observed between the two variables (r=0.540), this relationship was not statistically significant (P=0.076). Additionally, significant associations were found between job satisfaction and gender (P=0.008), age (P=0.01, r=0.334), and workplace hospital (P<0.05). Conclusion: The findings indicate that although a standard physical environment is an important prerequisite for optimal performance, it is not a strong standalone predictor of job satisfaction. Organizational and psychosocial factors play a substantial role in shaping job satisfaction among operating room staff. Therefore, adopting a systemic multidimensional approach that simultaneously improves the physical environment and strengthens motivational and organizational factors is crucial in enhancing job satisfaction in this department.
- Open Access
- 16 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Research Notes
- Vol. 18 (1) , 302
Mental fatigue of operating room nurses and its relationship with missed perioperative nursing care: a descriptive-analytical study
Mental fatigue is a psychological condition characterised by diminished alertness, impaired cognitive functioning, heightened error rates, and overall decreased performance. missed perioperative nursing care diminishes patient safety and increases the likelihood of adverse incidents. The correlation between mental fatigue among operating room nurses and missed perioperative care, despite its critical role in ensuring high-quality care, has been insufficiently investigated, particularly in Iranian hospitals where nurses face chronic understaffing, excessive workloads, and limited institutional support. A cross-sectional research was undertaken in 2023, including 385 operating room nurses working in Hospitals affiliated with Universities of Medical Sciences and Health Services in East Azarbaijan, Iran. Inclusion criteria were a minimum of six months’ work experience, holding an associate degree or higher in nursing or operating room disciplines, and currently having an active scrub or circulating role in the operating room. Exclusion criteria included unwillingness to participate, inactivity in scrub or circulating roles during the past month, diagnosed mental illness, or use of antidepressant medication. Stratified random sampling was used to select the participants. A demographic questionnaire, Johansson’s mental fatigue questionnaire, and Kalisch’s MISSCARE Survey-Operating Room questionnaire were used to collect data. The validity and reliability of both instruments were confirmed, with Cronbach’s alpha values of 0.85 for the mental fatigue questionnaire and 0.78 for the MISSCARE scale. Data were analyzed using SPSS version 16, employing descriptive statistics, non-parametric tests (Mann–Whitney, Kruskal–Wallis), correlation analyses (Spearman, Kendall), and quantile regression. The results of the present study showed that 77.9% of the participants experienced varying levels of mental fatigue, ranging from mild to severe. Operating room nurses scored an average of 102.03 (out of 132) on the missed perioperative nursing care scale, indicating a moderate level of missed care. The correlation analysis revealed a positive and statistically significant association between the mental fatigue of operating room nurses and the missed perioperative nursing care (p = 0.001; r = 0.319). Our operating room nurses reported a mild level of mental fatigue and a moderate level of missed perioperative nursing care. Given the implications of fatigue in operating room nurses, this likely impacts the standard of care provided prior to, during, and after surgery. Nursing authorities should regularly evaluate the mental fatigue experienced by operating room nurses, along with the reasons that contribute to it, and the frequency of missed perioperative nursing care in clinical environments. Implementing targeted interventions such as resilience training programs, improving nurse-to-patient ratios, and optimizing shift schedules may help reduce fatigue and enhance care quality.
- 16 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Research Notes
- Vol. 18 (1) , 302
Open AccessMental fatigue of operating room nurses and its relationship with missed perioperative nursing care: a descriptive-analytical study
Mental fatigue is a psychological condition characterised by diminished alertness, impaired cognitive functioning, heightened error rates, and overall decreased performance. missed perioperative nursing care diminishes patient safety and increases the likelihood of adverse incidents. The correlation between mental fatigue among operating room nurses and missed perioperative care, despite its critical role in ensuring high-quality care, has been insufficiently investigated, particularly in Iranian hospitals where nurses face chronic understaffing, excessive workloads, and limited institutional support. A cross-sectional research was undertaken in 2023, including 385 operating room nurses working in Hospitals affiliated with Universities of Medical Sciences and Health Services in East Azarbaijan, Iran. Inclusion criteria were a minimum of six months’ work experience, holding an associate degree or higher in nursing or operating room disciplines, and currently having an active scrub or circulating role in the operating room. Exclusion criteria included unwillingness to participate, inactivity in scrub or circulating roles during the past month, diagnosed mental illness, or use of antidepressant medication. Stratified random sampling was used to select the participants. A demographic questionnaire, Johansson’s mental fatigue questionnaire, and Kalisch’s MISSCARE Survey-Operating Room questionnaire were used to collect data. The validity and reliability of both instruments were confirmed, with Cronbach’s alpha values of 0.85 for the mental fatigue questionnaire and 0.78 for the MISSCARE scale. Data were analyzed using SPSS version 16, employing descriptive statistics, non-parametric tests (Mann–Whitney, Kruskal–Wallis), correlation analyses (Spearman, Kendall), and quantile regression. The results of the present study showed that 77.9% of the participants experienced varying levels of mental fatigue, ranging from mild to severe. Operating room nurses scored an average of 102.03 (out of 132) on the missed perioperative nursing care scale, indicating a moderate level of missed care. The correlation analysis revealed a positive and statistically significant association between the mental fatigue of operating room nurses and the missed perioperative nursing care (p = 0.001; r = 0.319). Our operating room nurses reported a mild level of mental fatigue and a moderate level of missed perioperative nursing care. Given the implications of fatigue in operating room nurses, this likely impacts the standard of care provided prior to, during, and after surgery. Nursing authorities should regularly evaluate the mental fatigue experienced by operating room nurses, along with the reasons that contribute to it, and the frequency of missed perioperative nursing care in clinical environments. Implementing targeted interventions such as resilience training programs, improving nurse-to-patient ratios, and optimizing shift schedules may help reduce fatigue and enhance care quality.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2023
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Journal of Preventive Epidemiology
- Vol. 9 (1) , e35226
What special precautions are required while anesthetizing COVID-19 patients in the operation room?
On The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted not only the daily routines of individuals, but also the procedural approaches of medical and anesthesia experts, encompassing surgical procedures, operating room administration, patient welfare, and healthcare personnel. One of the most susceptible direct contact groups with COVID-19 patients is the operating room staff. The primary objective of this investigation is to conduct a literature review of specific articles pertaining to the requisite precautions during anesthesia administration for patients afflicted with COVID-19. The literature was carried out in PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus were used to search for English-language articles. All type of articles was included. Keywords were COVID-19, novel coronavirus, 2019- nCoV, coronavirus disease 2019, operating room, theatre, measures, medical staff, health providers, and anesthesia. In this study, we aimed to identify essential information needed by operating room staff, especially anesthesiologists, to manage the entire anesthesia process in COVID-19 patients in a relatively safe manner. We found that necessary points included avoiding the airway and other biologic secretions such as cerebrospinal fluid and blood, using fiber-optic or video laryngoscopy, adequate pre-oxygenation with a well-fitted mask, avoiding awake intubation, selecting a rapid sequence approach, using disposable equipment, delaying elective surgery, and wearing a N95 mask, eye shield, gown, and gloves.
- 4 December 2023
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Journal of Preventive Epidemiology
- Vol. 9 (1) , e35226
Open AccessWhat special precautions are required while anesthetizing COVID-19 patients in the operation room?
On The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted not only the daily routines of individuals, but also the procedural approaches of medical and anesthesia experts, encompassing surgical procedures, operating room administration, patient welfare, and healthcare personnel. One of the most susceptible direct contact groups with COVID-19 patients is the operating room staff. The primary objective of this investigation is to conduct a literature review of specific articles pertaining to the requisite precautions during anesthesia administration for patients afflicted with COVID-19. The literature was carried out in PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus were used to search for English-language articles. All type of articles was included. Keywords were COVID-19, novel coronavirus, 2019- nCoV, coronavirus disease 2019, operating room, theatre, measures, medical staff, health providers, and anesthesia. In this study, we aimed to identify essential information needed by operating room staff, especially anesthesiologists, to manage the entire anesthesia process in COVID-19 patients in a relatively safe manner. We found that necessary points included avoiding the airway and other biologic secretions such as cerebrospinal fluid and blood, using fiber-optic or video laryngoscopy, adequate pre-oxygenation with a well-fitted mask, avoiding awake intubation, selecting a rapid sequence approach, using disposable equipment, delaying elective surgery, and wearing a N95 mask, eye shield, gown, and gloves.
- Open Access
- 13 August 2020
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Journal of Renal Injury Prevention
- Vol. 10 (3) , e18
A systematic review of the relationship between acute tubular necrosis and kidney transplantation
Introduction: Acute tubular necrosis (ATN) is a common syndrome following kidney transplantation. In this study, we reviewed systematically the relationship between ATN and kidney transplantation. Materials and Methods: International databases including PubMed, Web of Science and Scopus were considered for search of English articles by Aug 2019. Seven published articles were finally entered into the study. Keywords were ATN, acute kidney injury, kidney transplantation and renal transplantation or a combination of them in the title/abstracts. Results: There were seven published articles (conducted on 2,534 individuals) reviewed in this systematic review consisted of two retrospective, three prospective studies and two clinical trial studies. Conclusion: The administration of cyclosporine immediately following kidney transplantation is a predicting factor for development of ATN. According to the results, ATN can be associated with kidney transplantation, especially transplanted from deceased donors.
- 13 August 2020
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Journal of Renal Injury Prevention
- Vol. 10 (3) , e18
Open AccessA systematic review of the relationship between acute tubular necrosis and kidney transplantation
Introduction: Acute tubular necrosis (ATN) is a common syndrome following kidney transplantation. In this study, we reviewed systematically the relationship between ATN and kidney transplantation. Materials and Methods: International databases including PubMed, Web of Science and Scopus were considered for search of English articles by Aug 2019. Seven published articles were finally entered into the study. Keywords were ATN, acute kidney injury, kidney transplantation and renal transplantation or a combination of them in the title/abstracts. Results: There were seven published articles (conducted on 2,534 individuals) reviewed in this systematic review consisted of two retrospective, three prospective studies and two clinical trial studies. Conclusion: The administration of cyclosporine immediately following kidney transplantation is a predicting factor for development of ATN. According to the results, ATN can be associated with kidney transplantation, especially transplanted from deceased donors.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2020
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Journal of Nephropharmacology
- Vol. 10 (1) , e06
Lessons of mortality following COVID-19 epidemic in the United States especially in the geriatrics
COVID-19 is spreading all around the world, and is considered as the most widespread infectious disease of the century. Coronavirus transmits through respiratory droplets when in close contact with the infected person. Therefore, populous places are more likely to be the source of the novel coronavirus that is threatening the health of everyone especially the geriatric population. This study aimed to compare the transmission of coronavirus between metropolitan and non- metropolitan counties as lessons of mortality (especially in geriatric) following COVID-19 epidemic. The USAFact.org public website (https://usafacts.org/visualizations) was used to determine the transmission between metro and non- metropolitan counties. In this study, four different time periods were considered for the COVID-19 incremental trend (April 1, May 1, June 1, and July 1, 2020). The number of cases was determined per each 10,000 population. Yellow color means no case in the metropolitan county (metro). Orange color means less than 10 cases/10,000 of the population in metro. Figure and maps were used to show the objectives of the study. In metropolitan counties, the spread of COVID-19 is very fast, which is significantly different from the non-metro counties (P<0.001). The results show the sharp increasing trend of infected people in metropolitan counties. In metropolitan counties the number of infected people reached 2 420 316 cases per 10 000 populations but the number of infected people reached 231 459 cases per 10 000 populations. Over the four months period, the frequency of the light colors was decreased. According to the results, susceptible people especially the elderly should move to non- metropolitan counties during the COVID-19 pandemic to be less likely at risk.
- 24 July 2020
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in Journal of Nephropharmacology
- Vol. 10 (1) , e06
Open AccessLessons of mortality following COVID-19 epidemic in the United States especially in the geriatrics
COVID-19 is spreading all around the world, and is considered as the most widespread infectious disease of the century. Coronavirus transmits through respiratory droplets when in close contact with the infected person. Therefore, populous places are more likely to be the source of the novel coronavirus that is threatening the health of everyone especially the geriatric population. This study aimed to compare the transmission of coronavirus between metropolitan and non- metropolitan counties as lessons of mortality (especially in geriatric) following COVID-19 epidemic. The USAFact.org public website (https://usafacts.org/visualizations) was used to determine the transmission between metro and non- metropolitan counties. In this study, four different time periods were considered for the COVID-19 incremental trend (April 1, May 1, June 1, and July 1, 2020). The number of cases was determined per each 10,000 population. Yellow color means no case in the metropolitan county (metro). Orange color means less than 10 cases/10,000 of the population in metro. Figure and maps were used to show the objectives of the study. In metropolitan counties, the spread of COVID-19 is very fast, which is significantly different from the non-metro counties (P<0.001). The results show the sharp increasing trend of infected people in metropolitan counties. In metropolitan counties the number of infected people reached 2 420 316 cases per 10 000 populations but the number of infected people reached 231 459 cases per 10 000 populations. Over the four months period, the frequency of the light colors was decreased. According to the results, susceptible people especially the elderly should move to non- metropolitan counties during the COVID-19 pandemic to be less likely at risk.