Naven Narayanan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Naven Narayanan has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Allison K. Shaw
University of Minnesota
7 shared publications Peter Lutz
Department of Ecology, Evolution, Behavior University of Minnesota Twin Cities Saint Paul Minnesota USA
3 shared publicationsAllison K Shaw
University of Minnesota
2 shared publications- Chris Wojan
University of Minnesota
2 shared publications - Dongmin Kim
Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Behavior University of Minnesota St. Paul Minnesota USA
2 shared publications - Martha Torstenson
Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Behavior University of Minnesota St. Paul Minnesota USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Adaptive benefits of motility in cross-feeding mutualisms
Cross-feeding mutualisms, in which partner species exchange essential metabolites, are ubiquitous in microbial communities. In spatially structured environments, motility can improve access to partner-produced resources but also impose metabolic costs and displace cells from nutrient-rich regions, so its net benefit depends on the spatial dynamics of the interaction. Here, we combine competition experiments in a cross-feeding mutualism between Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica with a spatially explicit consumer-resource model to determine what drives selection on motility. Spatial structure imposes asymmetric selection between partners i.e. S. enterica benefits from motility regardless of partner motility, whereas selection on \textit{E. coli} switches from favourable to unfavourable depending on whether its partner can move. Competition in well-mixed culture suggests that this reversal reflects the loss of a spatial benefit rather than an increased cost. Our model attributes the asymmetry to three interacting factors: the ratio of metabolite production to consumption which sets whether the cross-fed resource is scarce or abundant; the number of growth-limiting resources which determines whether an alternative gradient can rescue the benefit of motility; and partner motility and growth rate, which shape where metabolites are produced. When a metabolite is scarce, motile cells gain by dispersing into regions it has reached but not yet been depleted from. When it accumulates, this gradient is eroded, and the motility costs offset any benefit it provides. Selection on motility therefore depends on the metabolic structure of the interaction and the spatial behaviour of partners.
Open AccessAdaptive benefits of motility in cross-feeding mutualisms
Cross-feeding mutualisms, in which partner species exchange essential metabolites, are ubiquitous in microbial communities. In spatially structured environments, motility can improve access to partner-produced resources but also impose metabolic costs and displace cells from nutrient-rich regions, so its net benefit depends on the spatial dynamics of the interaction. Here, we combine competition experiments in a cross-feeding mutualism between Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica with a spatially explicit consumer-resource model to determine what drives selection on motility. Spatial structure imposes asymmetric selection between partners i.e. S. enterica benefits from motility regardless of partner motility, whereas selection on \textit{E. coli} switches from favourable to unfavourable depending on whether its partner can move. Competition in well-mixed culture suggests that this reversal reflects the loss of a spatial benefit rather than an increased cost. Our model attributes the asymmetry to three interacting factors: the ratio of metabolite production to consumption which sets whether the cross-fed resource is scarce or abundant; the number of growth-limiting resources which determines whether an alternative gradient can rescue the benefit of motility; and partner motility and growth rate, which shape where metabolites are produced. When a metabolite is scarce, motile cells gain by dispersing into regions it has reached but not yet been depleted from. When it accumulates, this gradient is eroded, and the motility costs offset any benefit it provides. Selection on motility therefore depends on the metabolic structure of the interaction and the spatial behaviour of partners.
- Open Access
Diverse communities promote the coexistence of closely-related strains through emergent equalization and stabilization
Microbial communities harbor extensive fine-scale diversity: closely-related strains of the same species coexist alongside many distantly-related taxa. Yet strain coexistence remains poorly understood, largely because most studies neglect the diverse communities in which strains are embedded. Here we combine community ecology and statistical physics to study the dynamics of closely-related strains in a community context. We demonstrate that in a diverse community, indirect interactions between strains—mediated through the surrounding community members—can be as strong as direct ones. These community-mediated feedbacks cause conspecific strains to behave as if they have correlated growth rates and reduced competition. Using modern coexistence theory, we show that these effects correspond to equalizing and stabilizing mechanisms which together promote strain coexistence. The same equalizing and stabilizing mechanisms also qualitatively transform strain abundance correlations: strains that compete strongly and show negative correlations in isolation instead show positive correlations in a community, appearing mutualistic despite being competitors. Our results demonstrate that strain dynamics are emergent consequences of the surrounding community, and that capturing community feedbacks does not require the full interaction network; only a small number of emergent parameters.
Open AccessDiverse communities promote the coexistence of closely-related strains through emergent equalization and stabilization
Microbial communities harbor extensive fine-scale diversity: closely-related strains of the same species coexist alongside many distantly-related taxa. Yet strain coexistence remains poorly understood, largely because most studies neglect the diverse communities in which strains are embedded. Here we combine community ecology and statistical physics to study the dynamics of closely-related strains in a community context. We demonstrate that in a diverse community, indirect interactions between strains—mediated through the surrounding community members—can be as strong as direct ones. These community-mediated feedbacks cause conspecific strains to behave as if they have correlated growth rates and reduced competition. Using modern coexistence theory, we show that these effects correspond to equalizing and stabilizing mechanisms which together promote strain coexistence. The same equalizing and stabilizing mechanisms also qualitatively transform strain abundance correlations: strains that compete strongly and show negative correlations in isolation instead show positive correlations in a community, appearing mutualistic despite being competitors. Our results demonstrate that strain dynamics are emergent consequences of the surrounding community, and that capturing community feedbacks does not require the full interaction network; only a small number of emergent parameters.
- Open Access
Coexistence of coinvading species with mutualism and competition
All interactions between multiple species invading together (coinvasion) must be accounted for to predict species coexistence patterns across space. Mutualisms, particularly, are known to influence species' population dynamics and their invasive ability (e.g., mycorrhizal fungi with partner plants). Yet, while modeling coinvasion, their role in mediating coexistence is overlooked. Here, we build a spatially explicit model of coinvasion of two competing plant species with a shared fungal mutualist to study how mutualism and competition interact to shape the local and regional coexistence of competitors. We observe four main results. First, mutualist presence generates regional coexistence between competitors even when local coexistence between them is impossible. Second, increasing partner mutualist dispersal leads to abrupt changes in competitor coexistence outcomes. Third, differences in mutualist partner dependence and competitive ability interact to produce a variety of local and regional coexistence outcomes. Fourth, asymmetry in the dispersal ability arising from dependence‐dispersal trade‐offs leads to greater exclusion of species less dependent on mutualist partners for growth. In toto, incorporating mutualism‐specific trait trade‐offs and dispersal asymmetries into coinvasion models offers new insights into regional coexistence and invasive species distributions.
Open AccessCoexistence of coinvading species with mutualism and competition
All interactions between multiple species invading together (coinvasion) must be accounted for to predict species coexistence patterns across space. Mutualisms, particularly, are known to influence species' population dynamics and their invasive ability (e.g., mycorrhizal fungi with partner plants). Yet, while modeling coinvasion, their role in mediating coexistence is overlooked. Here, we build a spatially explicit model of coinvasion of two competing plant species with a shared fungal mutualist to study how mutualism and competition interact to shape the local and regional coexistence of competitors. We observe four main results. First, mutualist presence generates regional coexistence between competitors even when local coexistence between them is impossible. Second, increasing partner mutualist dispersal leads to abrupt changes in competitor coexistence outcomes. Third, differences in mutualist partner dependence and competitive ability interact to produce a variety of local and regional coexistence outcomes. Fourth, asymmetry in the dispersal ability arising from dependence‐dispersal trade‐offs leads to greater exclusion of species less dependent on mutualist partners for growth. In toto, incorporating mutualism‐specific trait trade‐offs and dispersal asymmetries into coinvasion models offers new insights into regional coexistence and invasive species distributions.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 291 (2031) , 20240803
Six personas to adopt when framing theoretical research questions in biology
Theory is a critical component of the biological research process, and complements observational and experimental approaches. However, most biologists receive little training on how to frame a theoretical question and, thus, how to evaluate when theory has successfully answered the research question. Here, we develop a guide with six verbal framings for theoretical models in biology. These correspond to different personas one might adopt as a theorist: ‘Advocate’, ‘Explainer’, ‘Instigator’, ‘Mediator’, ‘Semantician' and ‘Tinkerer’. These personas are drawn from combinations of two starting points (pattern or mechanism) and three foci (novelty, robustness or conflict). We illustrate each of these framings with examples of specific theoretical questions, by drawing on recent theoretical papers in the fields of ecology and evolutionary biology. We show how the same research topic can be approached from slightly different perspectives, using different framings. We show how clarifying a model’s framing can debunk common misconceptions of theory: that simplifying assumptions are bad, more detail is always better, models show anything you want and modelling requires substantial maths knowledge. Finally, we provide a roadmap that researchers new to theoretical research can use to identify a framing to serve as a blueprint for their own theoretical research projects.
- 18 September 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 291 (2031) , 20240803
Open AccessSix personas to adopt when framing theoretical research questions in biology
Theory is a critical component of the biological research process, and complements observational and experimental approaches. However, most biologists receive little training on how to frame a theoretical question and, thus, how to evaluate when theory has successfully answered the research question. Here, we develop a guide with six verbal framings for theoretical models in biology. These correspond to different personas one might adopt as a theorist: ‘Advocate’, ‘Explainer’, ‘Instigator’, ‘Mediator’, ‘Semantician' and ‘Tinkerer’. These personas are drawn from combinations of two starting points (pattern or mechanism) and three foci (novelty, robustness or conflict). We illustrate each of these framings with examples of specific theoretical questions, by drawing on recent theoretical papers in the fields of ecology and evolutionary biology. We show how the same research topic can be approached from slightly different perspectives, using different framings. We show how clarifying a model’s framing can debunk common misconceptions of theory: that simplifying assumptions are bad, more detail is always better, models show anything you want and modelling requires substantial maths knowledge. Finally, we provide a roadmap that researchers new to theoretical research can use to identify a framing to serve as a blueprint for their own theoretical research projects.
- Open Access
- 9 September 2024
- Published by Wiley
Context-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation
- 9 September 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessContext-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation
- Open Access
- 29 August 2024
- Published by Wiley
Context-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation. Context-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation. Context-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation.
- 29 August 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessContext-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation. Context-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation. Context-dependent dispersal mutualisms mediate coexistence of unequal competitors in a metapopulation.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2024
- Published by Wiley
Six personas to adopt when framing theoretical research questions in biology
- 18 July 2024
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessSix personas to adopt when framing theoretical research questions in biology
- Open Access
Mutualisms impact species' range expansion speeds and spatial distributions
Species engage in mutually beneficial interspecific interactions (mutualisms) that shape their population dynamics in ecological communities. Species engaged in mutualisms vary greatly in their degree of dependence on their partner from complete dependence (e.g., yucca and yucca moth mutualism) to low dependence (e.g., generalist bee with multiple plant species). While current empirical studies show that, in mutualisms, partner dependence can alter the speed of a species' range expansion, there is no theory that provides conditions when expansion is sped up or slowed down. To address this, we built a spatially explicit model incorporating the population dynamics of two dispersing species interacting mutualistically. We explored how mutualisms impacted range expansion across a gradient of dependence (from complete independence to obligacy) between the two species. We then studied the conditions in which the magnitude of the mutualistic benefits could hinder versus enhance the speed of range expansion. We showed that either complete dependence, no dependence, or intermediate degree of dependence on a mutualist partner can lead to the greatest speeds of a focal species' range expansion based on the magnitude of benefits exchanged between partner species in the mutualism. We then showed how different degrees of dependence between species could alter the spatial distribution of the range expanding populations. Finally, we identified the conditions under which mutualistic interactions can turn exploitative across space, leading to the formation of a species' range limits. Our work highlights how couching mutualisms and mutualist dependence in a spatial context can provide insights about species range expansions, limits, and ultimately their distributions.
Open AccessMutualisms impact species' range expansion speeds and spatial distributions
Species engage in mutually beneficial interspecific interactions (mutualisms) that shape their population dynamics in ecological communities. Species engaged in mutualisms vary greatly in their degree of dependence on their partner from complete dependence (e.g., yucca and yucca moth mutualism) to low dependence (e.g., generalist bee with multiple plant species). While current empirical studies show that, in mutualisms, partner dependence can alter the speed of a species' range expansion, there is no theory that provides conditions when expansion is sped up or slowed down. To address this, we built a spatially explicit model incorporating the population dynamics of two dispersing species interacting mutualistically. We explored how mutualisms impacted range expansion across a gradient of dependence (from complete independence to obligacy) between the two species. We then studied the conditions in which the magnitude of the mutualistic benefits could hinder versus enhance the speed of range expansion. We showed that either complete dependence, no dependence, or intermediate degree of dependence on a mutualist partner can lead to the greatest speeds of a focal species' range expansion based on the magnitude of benefits exchanged between partner species in the mutualism. We then showed how different degrees of dependence between species could alter the spatial distribution of the range expanding populations. Finally, we identified the conditions under which mutualistic interactions can turn exploitative across space, leading to the formation of a species' range limits. Our work highlights how couching mutualisms and mutualist dependence in a spatial context can provide insights about species range expansions, limits, and ultimately their distributions.
- Open Access
- 19 September 2023
- Published by Wiley
Spatial coexistence of coinvading communities with mutualism and competition
All interactions between multiple species invading together (coinvasion) must be accounted for to predict species coexistence patterns across space. Mutualisms, particularly, are known to influence species’ population dynamics and their invasive ability (e.g. mycorrhizal fungi with partner plants). Yet, while modelling coinvasion, their role in mediating coexistence is overlooked. We build a spatial model of coinvasion of two competing plant species with a shared fungal mutualist to study how mutualism and competition shape the spatial coexistence of competitors. We find that mutualist presence engenders regional (spatial) coexistence between competitors even when local coexistence between them is impossible. Further, increasing mutualist dispersal results in sharp transitions in competitor coexistence outcomes. Finally, differences in mutualist partner dependence and competitive ability interact to produce a variety of local and regional coexistence outcomes. Thus, incorporating mutualism dependence and dispersal behaviour into coinvasion models offers new insights into spatial coexistence and invasive species distributions.
- 19 September 2023
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessSpatial coexistence of coinvading communities with mutualism and competition
All interactions between multiple species invading together (coinvasion) must be accounted for to predict species coexistence patterns across space. Mutualisms, particularly, are known to influence species’ population dynamics and their invasive ability (e.g. mycorrhizal fungi with partner plants). Yet, while modelling coinvasion, their role in mediating coexistence is overlooked. We build a spatial model of coinvasion of two competing plant species with a shared fungal mutualist to study how mutualism and competition shape the spatial coexistence of competitors. We find that mutualist presence engenders regional (spatial) coexistence between competitors even when local coexistence between them is impossible. Further, increasing mutualist dispersal results in sharp transitions in competitor coexistence outcomes. Finally, differences in mutualist partner dependence and competitive ability interact to produce a variety of local and regional coexistence outcomes. Thus, incorporating mutualism dependence and dispersal behaviour into coinvasion models offers new insights into spatial coexistence and invasive species distributions.
- Open Access
- 20 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America
- Vol. 104 (2)
Theoretical Advances in the Ecology and Evolution of Mutualistic Interactions – Review of a Symposium (SYMP 14) Organized at ESA + CSEE 2022 Joint Meeting
- 20 March 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America
- Vol. 104 (2)
Open AccessTheoretical Advances in the Ecology and Evolution of Mutualistic Interactions – Review of a Symposium (SYMP 14) Organized at ESA + CSEE 2022 Joint Meeting