Mehmet Ungan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Mehmet Ungan has a total of 192 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Davorina Petek
Department of Family Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia
7 shared publications - Thomas Frese
Institute of General Practice and Family Medicine, Medical Faculty, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Magdeburger Straße 8, 06112 Halle (Saale), Germany
7 shared publications - Adam Windak
Department of Family Medicine, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland
6 shared publications - Claire Collins
Irish College of General Practitioners, Dublin, Ireland
6 shared publications - Katarzyna Nessler
Department of Family Medicine, Jagiellonian University Medical College
6 shared publications - Shlomo Vinker
Department of Family Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Primary Care
Predictors of European general practitioners’ attitudes towards person-centered care across 24 countries: results from the PACE GP/FP study
Background: Person-centeredness is a widely recognized key dimension of quality of care, but its implementation in primary care varies substantially. Understanding attitudes and challenges that support or hinder adoption is essential for effective integration. This paper explores general practitioners’/family physicians’ (GPs’) attitudes toward person-centered care (PCC) across 24 European countries and examines socio-demographic, professional, and work-related factors associated with these attitudes. Methods: An online self-reported survey was conducted among GPs across Europe. Attitudes were assessed with the Patient-Practitioner Orientation Scale (PPOS), a validated instrument scored from 1 to 6 where higher scores reflect a more patient-centered orientation, including the Caring and Sharing sub-scales. Because GPs were nested within countries, linear mixed-effects (multilevel) models were used with country as a random effect and practitioner- and practice-level characteristics as fixed effects. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) quantified between-country variation. Analyses used cleaned data from the 24 countries available as of December 12, 2024. Results: In total, 3,691 GPs participated, and the mixed-model analysis of the PPOS total score included 3,370 respondents across 24 countries. Approximately 31% of the variance in PPOS total scores lay between countries (ICC = 0.31), indicating substantial cross-national variation. Regional grouping captured this variation better than EU integration status in descriptive comparisons; however, between-group variance was estimated from very few clusters and was therefore statistically unstable, thus exploratory. After adjustment, teaching involvement, specialist training in General Practice/Family Medicine, urban practice, an above-average share of psychiatrically vulnerable patients, and lower daily patient-contact volume were associated with higher (more patient-centered) scores, whereas higher perceived work-related stress, older age, and the least experience were associated with lower scores. Broadly similar patterns emerged for the Caring and Sharing sub-scales, with some dimensional differences. Conclusions: In this pan-European study, individual, professional, and practice-level factors were associated with GPs’ attitudes toward PCC, and a substantial share of the variation was attributable to differences between countries. Given the cross-sectional design and that PPOS measures attitudes rather than delivered care, results should be interpreted as associations at the attitudinal level. Identifying these factors may support strategies to foster person-centered attitudes across diverse European primary care settings. Trial registration: Not applicable.
- 4 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Primary Care
Open AccessPredictors of European general practitioners’ attitudes towards person-centered care across 24 countries: results from the PACE GP/FP study
Background: Person-centeredness is a widely recognized key dimension of quality of care, but its implementation in primary care varies substantially. Understanding attitudes and challenges that support or hinder adoption is essential for effective integration. This paper explores general practitioners’/family physicians’ (GPs’) attitudes toward person-centered care (PCC) across 24 European countries and examines socio-demographic, professional, and work-related factors associated with these attitudes. Methods: An online self-reported survey was conducted among GPs across Europe. Attitudes were assessed with the Patient-Practitioner Orientation Scale (PPOS), a validated instrument scored from 1 to 6 where higher scores reflect a more patient-centered orientation, including the Caring and Sharing sub-scales. Because GPs were nested within countries, linear mixed-effects (multilevel) models were used with country as a random effect and practitioner- and practice-level characteristics as fixed effects. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) quantified between-country variation. Analyses used cleaned data from the 24 countries available as of December 12, 2024. Results: In total, 3,691 GPs participated, and the mixed-model analysis of the PPOS total score included 3,370 respondents across 24 countries. Approximately 31% of the variance in PPOS total scores lay between countries (ICC = 0.31), indicating substantial cross-national variation. Regional grouping captured this variation better than EU integration status in descriptive comparisons; however, between-group variance was estimated from very few clusters and was therefore statistically unstable, thus exploratory. After adjustment, teaching involvement, specialist training in General Practice/Family Medicine, urban practice, an above-average share of psychiatrically vulnerable patients, and lower daily patient-contact volume were associated with higher (more patient-centered) scores, whereas higher perceived work-related stress, older age, and the least experience were associated with lower scores. Broadly similar patterns emerged for the Caring and Sharing sub-scales, with some dimensional differences. Conclusions: In this pan-European study, individual, professional, and practice-level factors were associated with GPs’ attitudes toward PCC, and a substantial share of the variation was attributable to differences between countries. Given the cross-sectional design and that PPOS measures attitudes rather than delivered care, results should be interpreted as associations at the attitudinal level. Identifying these factors may support strategies to foster person-centered attitudes across diverse European primary care settings. Trial registration: Not applicable.
- Open Access
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 32 (1) , 2652678
The impact of professional characteristics and person-centred care on general practitioners’ stress levels. Findings from the cross-sectional PACE GP/FP study in 24 European countries
Healthcare professionals, especially general practitioners (GPs), are significantly more likely to experience work-related stress [1–3]. Chronic work-related stress is associated with adverse outco...
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 32 (1) , 2652678
Open AccessThe impact of professional characteristics and person-centred care on general practitioners’ stress levels. Findings from the cross-sectional PACE GP/FP study in 24 European countries
Healthcare professionals, especially general practitioners (GPs), are significantly more likely to experience work-related stress [1–3]. Chronic work-related stress is associated with adverse outco...
- Open Access
- 4 March 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Primary Health Care Research & Development
- Vol. 27, e33
Person-centred, community-oriented, and diversity sensitive primary care for migrants; a EFPC position paper
Aim: This paper aims to describe what constitutes good-quality, accessible, affordable and acceptable primary care for migrants. This includes identifying system adaptations and offering evidence- and practice-based recommendations and guidance for primary care organizations and professionals on how to deliver such care. Background: Migration has significantly diversified European populations. Migrants often face structural, linguistic, cultural, and systemic barriers in accessing appropriate primary care. While these challenges are well-documented, implementation of effective, inclusive care remains inconsistent across countries. Methods: This position paper presents a narrative synthesis of existing literature, expert opinions, and recent policy developments. It draws on evidence from healthcare research, policy analyses, and recommendations developed by the European Forum for Primary Care working group on migrants, primarily covering developments from the past decade. Findings: High-quality primary care for migrants requires coordinated action across care delivery, capacity building, and system-level structures. Care delivery must be person-centred and comprehensive, supported by interprofessional collaboration and professional interpretation. Capacity building depends on training and education that embed diversity-sensitive care, cultural humility, and structural competency. At the system level, policies should guarantee equitable access, continuity of care, and inclusive quality monitoring, while fostering intersectoral partnerships and community engagement. Conclusion: Embedding person-centred, diversity-sensitive, and community-oriented principles into primary care systems is essential for achieving equitable healthcare for migrant populations. This is an urgent plea to healthcare policymakers, organizations, and professionals to undertake action to realise these reforms as they not only improve care for migrants but contribute to stronger, sustainable and more resilient health systems overall.
- 4 March 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Primary Health Care Research & Development
- Vol. 27, e33
Open AccessPerson-centred, community-oriented, and diversity sensitive primary care for migrants; a EFPC position paper
Aim: This paper aims to describe what constitutes good-quality, accessible, affordable and acceptable primary care for migrants. This includes identifying system adaptations and offering evidence- and practice-based recommendations and guidance for primary care organizations and professionals on how to deliver such care. Background: Migration has significantly diversified European populations. Migrants often face structural, linguistic, cultural, and systemic barriers in accessing appropriate primary care. While these challenges are well-documented, implementation of effective, inclusive care remains inconsistent across countries. Methods: This position paper presents a narrative synthesis of existing literature, expert opinions, and recent policy developments. It draws on evidence from healthcare research, policy analyses, and recommendations developed by the European Forum for Primary Care working group on migrants, primarily covering developments from the past decade. Findings: High-quality primary care for migrants requires coordinated action across care delivery, capacity building, and system-level structures. Care delivery must be person-centred and comprehensive, supported by interprofessional collaboration and professional interpretation. Capacity building depends on training and education that embed diversity-sensitive care, cultural humility, and structural competency. At the system level, policies should guarantee equitable access, continuity of care, and inclusive quality monitoring, while fostering intersectoral partnerships and community engagement. Conclusion: Embedding person-centred, diversity-sensitive, and community-oriented principles into primary care systems is essential for achieving equitable healthcare for migrant populations. This is an urgent plea to healthcare policymakers, organizations, and professionals to undertake action to realise these reforms as they not only improve care for migrants but contribute to stronger, sustainable and more resilient health systems overall.
- Open Access
- 20 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Validating a Virtual Consultation Implementation Framework for Global Primary Care Settings: An International Electronic Delphi Study
Background: Virtual consultations (VC) are now integral to primary care delivery, but their implementation has been hampered by technological limitations, user engagement issues, and the lack of validated implementation frameworks.Objective: This study sought to identify and validate key elements required for the successful adoption of high-quality VC and to develop recommendations for its implementation in primary care.Methods: An electronic Delphi (eDelphi) study was conducted between March and December 2024 with Primary Care Physicians (PCPs) from 24 countries who had experience using VC in routine practice. Participants assessed 25 proposed toolkit components across six domains using a 5-point Likert scale. Descriptive statistics were applied, and consensus was defined as ≥70% agreement.Results: A total of 135 PCPs participated across three Delphi rounds. Consensus was achieved for 24 of the 25 framework elements. High priority was placed on long-term strategic planning and financial sustainability, sustained investment in VC infrastructure, enhanced cybersecurity and system resilience, improved digital literacy, and clear communication strategies for end-users. The sole component failing to reach consensus related to religious factors affecting VC acceptability, with most participants favouring inclusion of religion within broader cultural considerations rather than as a separate element.Conclusion: This study validated key components of a flexible VC implementation framework for primary care. The lack of consensus on certain contextual factors highlights the importance of culturally sensitive adaptation when implementing VC. Future work should focus on real-world piloting of the framework to evaluate its effectiveness at practice, policy, and system levels.
- 20 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessValidating a Virtual Consultation Implementation Framework for Global Primary Care Settings: An International Electronic Delphi Study
Background: Virtual consultations (VC) are now integral to primary care delivery, but their implementation has been hampered by technological limitations, user engagement issues, and the lack of validated implementation frameworks.Objective: This study sought to identify and validate key elements required for the successful adoption of high-quality VC and to develop recommendations for its implementation in primary care.Methods: An electronic Delphi (eDelphi) study was conducted between March and December 2024 with Primary Care Physicians (PCPs) from 24 countries who had experience using VC in routine practice. Participants assessed 25 proposed toolkit components across six domains using a 5-point Likert scale. Descriptive statistics were applied, and consensus was defined as ≥70% agreement.Results: A total of 135 PCPs participated across three Delphi rounds. Consensus was achieved for 24 of the 25 framework elements. High priority was placed on long-term strategic planning and financial sustainability, sustained investment in VC infrastructure, enhanced cybersecurity and system resilience, improved digital literacy, and clear communication strategies for end-users. The sole component failing to reach consensus related to religious factors affecting VC acceptability, with most participants favouring inclusion of religion within broader cultural considerations rather than as a separate element.Conclusion: This study validated key components of a flexible VC implementation framework for primary care. The lack of consensus on certain contextual factors highlights the importance of culturally sensitive adaptation when implementing VC. Future work should focus on real-world piloting of the framework to evaluate its effectiveness at practice, policy, and system levels.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 26 (1)
Validation of the Shame Frequency Questionnaire in Turkish Medical Students
This study aims to evaluate the Turkish validity and reliability of the Shame Frequency Questionnaire in Medical Students. The authors conducted this metho
- 31 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 26 (1)
Open AccessValidation of the Shame Frequency Questionnaire in Turkish Medical Students
This study aims to evaluate the Turkish validity and reliability of the Shame Frequency Questionnaire in Medical Students. The authors conducted this metho
- Open Access
- 15 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 31 (1) , 2555819
Factors influencing primary care physicians recommending patients to use digital health technologies for self-management: A cross-sectional study across 20 countries
Expanding access to self-management via Digital Health Technologies may supplement traditional care, mitigating pressures on primary care through self-management. Primary Care Physicians (PCP) can play a critical role in the integration of digital health technologies into patient care, but it is unclear what factors influence PCPs' recommendation of such technologies. To identify the factors associated with PCPs recommending digital health technologies to patients for self-management before and during the pandemic. PCPs across 20 countries completed an online questionnaire between June and September 2020. The outcome was a self-report of recommending patients to at least one of six listed forms of digital health technologies. Univariable logistic regression models were performed to explore factors associated with recommending digital health technologies to patients before and during the pandemic. 1,592 PCPs were included. Before the pandemic, the odds of recommending digital health technologies for self-management were lower for PCPs not involved in teaching, or practising in Turkey, Australia, Chile, Colombia, France, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia, and Spain. During the pandemic, PCPs practising in rural settings had higher odds of starting to recommend digital health technologies, as well as those from Brazil, Colombia, and Italy. There was no significant difference in recommending digital health technologies before and during the pandemic. Involvement in teaching (pre-pandemic) and practising in a rural setting (during the pandemic) positively influenced the recommendation of digital health technologies. Significant variation in recommending digital health technologies was present across countries.
- 15 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 31 (1) , 2555819
Open AccessFactors influencing primary care physicians recommending patients to use digital health technologies for self-management: A cross-sectional study across 20 countries
Expanding access to self-management via Digital Health Technologies may supplement traditional care, mitigating pressures on primary care through self-management. Primary Care Physicians (PCP) can play a critical role in the integration of digital health technologies into patient care, but it is unclear what factors influence PCPs' recommendation of such technologies. To identify the factors associated with PCPs recommending digital health technologies to patients for self-management before and during the pandemic. PCPs across 20 countries completed an online questionnaire between June and September 2020. The outcome was a self-report of recommending patients to at least one of six listed forms of digital health technologies. Univariable logistic regression models were performed to explore factors associated with recommending digital health technologies to patients before and during the pandemic. 1,592 PCPs were included. Before the pandemic, the odds of recommending digital health technologies for self-management were lower for PCPs not involved in teaching, or practising in Turkey, Australia, Chile, Colombia, France, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia, and Spain. During the pandemic, PCPs practising in rural settings had higher odds of starting to recommend digital health technologies, as well as those from Brazil, Colombia, and Italy. There was no significant difference in recommending digital health technologies before and during the pandemic. Involvement in teaching (pre-pandemic) and practising in a rural setting (during the pandemic) positively influenced the recommendation of digital health technologies. Significant variation in recommending digital health technologies was present across countries.
- 29 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-9
Understanding Digital Health in Primary Care
Primary Care provides accessible and community-based healthcare in many countries. In recent decades, Digital Health has transformed Primary Care through advances in communication, diagnostic, and management technologies. This chapter explores the different definitions of Digital Health as outlined by the World Health Organization, the European Commission, and the United States Food and Drug Administration. By examining the adoption and evolution of Digital Health in Primary Care globally, this chapter highlights the variations across high-, middle-, and low-income countries. Specific examples, such as telehealth and remote monitoring wearables, have demonstrated their capabilities in enhancing accessibility and care quality, but barriers, such as digital literacy, data security, data ownership issues, and resource inequities, still persist. Moving forward, efforts to integrate emerging Digital Health technologies in Primary Care need to prioritise sustainability, equity, and patient-centred care while remaining tailored to the local context.
- 29 August 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-9
Understanding Digital Health in Primary Care
Primary Care provides accessible and community-based healthcare in many countries. In recent decades, Digital Health has transformed Primary Care through advances in communication, diagnostic, and management technologies. This chapter explores the different definitions of Digital Health as outlined by the World Health Organization, the European Commission, and the United States Food and Drug Administration. By examining the adoption and evolution of Digital Health in Primary Care globally, this chapter highlights the variations across high-, middle-, and low-income countries. Specific examples, such as telehealth and remote monitoring wearables, have demonstrated their capabilities in enhancing accessibility and care quality, but barriers, such as digital literacy, data security, data ownership issues, and resource inequities, still persist. Moving forward, efforts to integrate emerging Digital Health technologies in Primary Care need to prioritise sustainability, equity, and patient-centred care while remaining tailored to the local context.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 31 (1) , 2463630
European general practitioners’ attitudes towards person-centred care and factors that influence its implementation in everyday practice: The protocol of the cross-sectional PACE GP/FP study in 24 European countries
Person-centred care (PCC) is a fundamental principle in general practice, emphasising practices tailored to individual patient preferences, needs, and values. Despite the importance of PCC, general practitioners (GPs) face obstacles in effectively implementing it, with associated factors remaining unclear. The PACE GP/FP study aims to explore GPs' attitudes towards PCC and the factors facilitating or hindering its implementation in daily practice across European countries. This paper outlines the PACE GP/FP study protocol. The cross-sectional design with data collection via an online survey distribution to GPs in 24 European countries. Study instruments include two validated questionnaires (Perceived Stress Scale (PSS) and Patient Physician Orientation Scale (PPOS)) and additional items covering general information about the doctor and their practice, as well as facilitators and barriers to PCC. These additional items were specifically developed for the study, translated using the forward-backward method, evaluated through cognitive debriefing, and integrated into the REDCap platform to create language and country-specific survey links. The STROBE checklist guides the reporting of the manuscript. The PACE GP/FP study will provide a comprehensive exploration of GPs' attitudes towards PCC and the factors shaping its practice in Europe. The findings from the PACE GP/FP study will provide evidence for designing future implementation strategies and guide targeted interventions to promote PCC in primary care across Europe.
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 31 (1) , 2463630
Open AccessEuropean general practitioners’ attitudes towards person-centred care and factors that influence its implementation in everyday practice: The protocol of the cross-sectional PACE GP/FP study in 24 European countries
Person-centred care (PCC) is a fundamental principle in general practice, emphasising practices tailored to individual patient preferences, needs, and values. Despite the importance of PCC, general practitioners (GPs) face obstacles in effectively implementing it, with associated factors remaining unclear. The PACE GP/FP study aims to explore GPs' attitudes towards PCC and the factors facilitating or hindering its implementation in daily practice across European countries. This paper outlines the PACE GP/FP study protocol. The cross-sectional design with data collection via an online survey distribution to GPs in 24 European countries. Study instruments include two validated questionnaires (Perceived Stress Scale (PSS) and Patient Physician Orientation Scale (PPOS)) and additional items covering general information about the doctor and their practice, as well as facilitators and barriers to PCC. These additional items were specifically developed for the study, translated using the forward-backward method, evaluated through cognitive debriefing, and integrated into the REDCap platform to create language and country-specific survey links. The STROBE checklist guides the reporting of the manuscript. The PACE GP/FP study will provide a comprehensive exploration of GPs' attitudes towards PCC and the factors shaping its practice in Europe. The findings from the PACE GP/FP study will provide evidence for designing future implementation strategies and guide targeted interventions to promote PCC in primary care across Europe.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Public Health
- Vol. 238, 214-220
Unlocking the key to HPV prevention: Exploring factors influencing HPV vaccination decisions among young people and their parents
- 16 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Public Health
- Vol. 238, 214-220
Open AccessUnlocking the key to HPV prevention: Exploring factors influencing HPV vaccination decisions among young people and their parents
- Open Access
- 30 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 30 (1) , 2393858
How to overcome information and communication barriers in Human Papillomavirus vaccination? A SWOT analysis based on the opinions of European family doctors in contact with young people and their parents
Family doctors (FDs)/General practitioners (GPs) are the key contact points for young people and their parents regarding Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination. However, their recommendations are influenced by communication skills. Under the EU4Health project, PROTECT-EUROPE, WONCA Europe led a task to identify and analyse strategies for clinicians' interpersonal communication skills when discussing HPV and its vaccination with young people and their parents. Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats (SWOT) analysis using qualitative data focused on HPV vaccine acceptance and communication with the target population. FDs/GPs, members of WONCA Europe, were recruited using convenience and snowball sampling through surveys at conferences and emails. 223 FDs/GPs from 36 countries participated. Strengths included face-to-face communication, extensively used to promote the HPV vaccine. Weaknesses involved financial constraints, limited knowledge about gender-neutral vaccination, safety concerns, and time pressure during the consultations. Opportunities included confidentiality, open dialogue, trusting relationship between FDs/GPs and the target population, continuing medical education, school training, and questions & answers sessions to increase vaccine communication. Threats included social norms and cultures, stigmas against HPV, and anti-vaccination movements hindering discussions on HPV vaccination. It is crucial to train FDs/GPs to address knowledge gaps, enhance communication skills, and maintain a trusting relationship with patients when discussing HPV vaccination. Overcoming financial barriers and ensuring gender-neutral vaccination programs are accessible across Europe are also essential. Providing accurate information through the web- and school-based channels and developing community-oriented approaches targeting sociocultural factors and different needs to eliminate HPV vaccine stigmas should be considered when recommending the vaccine.
- 30 August 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 30 (1) , 2393858
Open AccessHow to overcome information and communication barriers in Human Papillomavirus vaccination? A SWOT analysis based on the opinions of European family doctors in contact with young people and their parents
Family doctors (FDs)/General practitioners (GPs) are the key contact points for young people and their parents regarding Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination. However, their recommendations are influenced by communication skills. Under the EU4Health project, PROTECT-EUROPE, WONCA Europe led a task to identify and analyse strategies for clinicians' interpersonal communication skills when discussing HPV and its vaccination with young people and their parents. Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats (SWOT) analysis using qualitative data focused on HPV vaccine acceptance and communication with the target population. FDs/GPs, members of WONCA Europe, were recruited using convenience and snowball sampling through surveys at conferences and emails. 223 FDs/GPs from 36 countries participated. Strengths included face-to-face communication, extensively used to promote the HPV vaccine. Weaknesses involved financial constraints, limited knowledge about gender-neutral vaccination, safety concerns, and time pressure during the consultations. Opportunities included confidentiality, open dialogue, trusting relationship between FDs/GPs and the target population, continuing medical education, school training, and questions & answers sessions to increase vaccine communication. Threats included social norms and cultures, stigmas against HPV, and anti-vaccination movements hindering discussions on HPV vaccination. It is crucial to train FDs/GPs to address knowledge gaps, enhance communication skills, and maintain a trusting relationship with patients when discussing HPV vaccination. Overcoming financial barriers and ensuring gender-neutral vaccination programs are accessible across Europe are also essential. Providing accurate information through the web- and school-based channels and developing community-oriented approaches targeting sociocultural factors and different needs to eliminate HPV vaccine stigmas should be considered when recommending the vaccine.