Tod D. Rutherford
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Tod D. Rutherford has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- John Holmes
Department of Geography, Queen’s University, Mackintosh-Corry Hall, Kingston, Ontario, Canada, K7L 3N6
2 shared publications - John Holmes
Department of Geography, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada
2 shared publications - Gregor Murray
Professeur titulaire, École de relations industrielles, Faculté des arts et des sciences; directeur, Centre de recherche interuniversitaire sur la mondialisation et le travail (CRIMT), Université de Montréal
1 shared publication Lorenzo Frangi
Département d’organisation et ressources humaines, ESG Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada
1 shared publication- Lorenzo Frangi
Associate Professor, Department of Organization and Human Resources, Université du Québec à Montréal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
1 shared publication - Matthieu Pelard
Canada Research Chair on Globalization and Work, École de relations industrielles and Interuniversity Research Centre on Globalization and Work (CRIMT), Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 September 2021
- Published by Lyson Center for Civic Agriculture and Food Systems in Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development
- Vol. 10 (4) , 9-10
Tribute: Evan Weissman
First paragraph: It is very difficult for me to write this tribute to Evan. It is easy to find wonderful things to say about his life and work, but it still does not seem possible or right that someone as young, vital, and exceptional should no longer be with us. I will say that I had the great fortune to know Evan, serving as his Ph.D. supervisor in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Syracuse University from August 2006 until his successful defense of his dissertation “Cultivating the City: Urban Agriculture and the Agrarian Question in Brooklyn, New York” in January 2012. He entered our program having recently completed his MA in sociology at the University of Tennessee, and it was clear early on to me that he was a gifted, dedicated student. However, what really stood out for me was not just Evan’s self-evident intellectual and scholarly abilities, but his dedication to community activism, combined with his genuine enthusiasm, generosity, and good-naturedness. . . .
- 16 September 2021
- Published by Lyson Center for Civic Agriculture and Food Systems in Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development
- Vol. 10 (4) , 9-10
Open AccessTribute: Evan Weissman
First paragraph: It is very difficult for me to write this tribute to Evan. It is easy to find wonderful things to say about his life and work, but it still does not seem possible or right that someone as young, vital, and exceptional should no longer be with us. I will say that I had the great fortune to know Evan, serving as his Ph.D. supervisor in the Department of Geography and the Environment at Syracuse University from August 2006 until his successful defense of his dissertation “Cultivating the City: Urban Agriculture and the Agrarian Question in Brooklyn, New York” in January 2012. He entered our program having recently completed his MA in sociology at the University of Tennessee, and it was clear early on to me that he was a gifted, dedicated student. However, what really stood out for me was not just Evan’s self-evident intellectual and scholarly abilities, but his dedication to community activism, combined with his genuine enthusiasm, generosity, and good-naturedness. . . .
- 19 January 2021
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Relations Industrielles / Industrial Relations
- Vol. 75 (4) , 751-773
Is Industry 4.0 a Good Fit for High Performance Work Systems? Trade Unions and Workplace Change in the Southern Ontario Automotive Assembly Sector
L’industrie automobile est, depuis longtemps, un chef de file dans l’introduction de nouvelles formes d’organisation du travail et de technologie, y compris la production de masse et les modèles de gestion à haute performance (MGHP, High Perfomance Work Systems-HPWS en anglais). Il a également été un point focal quant à la manière dont les syndicats négocient de tels systèmes. Récemment, une grande attention s’est portée sur l’Industrie 4.0 (I 4.0), un système de fabrication doté de la robotique avancée, du numérique et de l’intelligence artificielle. Cependant, dans l’industrie automobile, l’I 4.0 est confronté à des défis techniques et sociaux considérables. De plus, les paradigmes I 4.0 ont été critiqués pour avoir marginalisé l’importance continue des employés dans la conception, sinon ‘l’hybridation’, de ces nouveaux processus de production. En nous fondant sur une étude des sections locales des syndicats d’UNIFOR dans les usines d’assemblage de véhicules automobiles au Canada, nous soutenons que l’I 4.0 doit être analysé en fonction de la manière dont les syndicats ont influencé l’adoption presque universelle des MGHP dans ce secteur. Nous examinons donc les effets des syndicats sur les MGHP et les implications de leur rôle dans l’intégration de l’I 4.0 sur le lieu de travail. En tant que tels, nous soutenons d’abord que, bien qu’ils se chevauchent, les MGHP et l’I 4.0 représentent des stratégies managériales différentes. Deuxièmement, nous développons un cadre d’analyse exploratoire à utiliser afin d’examiner les rôles des syndicats dans la négociation des MGHP et l’adoption de la technologie numérique. Grâce à ce cadre d’analyse, nous analysons ensuite 18 entrevues que nous avons menées en 2017-2018 avec des directeurs d’usine et des représentants-clés d’UNIFOR dans cinq usines d’assemblage du sud de l’Ontario. Les entretiens illustrent, non seulement les points communs dans l’adoption des MGHP, mais aussi les différentes manières dont le syndicat influence ‘l’hybridation’ des MGHP. Les pratiques syndicales diffèrent significativement d’une usine à l’autre en fonction de trois variables: 1- la position concurrentielle entreprise-usine; 2- le visage global du monopole syndical; et 3- la solidarité et les récits internes du syndicat local autour de MGHP. En gardant à l’esprit ces points communs et ces différences, nous examinons, ensuite, les défis auxquels les syndicats sont susceptibles de faire face lorsqu’ils entament les négociations I 4.0.
- 19 January 2021
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Relations Industrielles / Industrial Relations
- Vol. 75 (4) , 751-773
Is Industry 4.0 a Good Fit for High Performance Work Systems? Trade Unions and Workplace Change in the Southern Ontario Automotive Assembly Sector
L’industrie automobile est, depuis longtemps, un chef de file dans l’introduction de nouvelles formes d’organisation du travail et de technologie, y compris la production de masse et les modèles de gestion à haute performance (MGHP, High Perfomance Work Systems-HPWS en anglais). Il a également été un point focal quant à la manière dont les syndicats négocient de tels systèmes. Récemment, une grande attention s’est portée sur l’Industrie 4.0 (I 4.0), un système de fabrication doté de la robotique avancée, du numérique et de l’intelligence artificielle. Cependant, dans l’industrie automobile, l’I 4.0 est confronté à des défis techniques et sociaux considérables. De plus, les paradigmes I 4.0 ont été critiqués pour avoir marginalisé l’importance continue des employés dans la conception, sinon ‘l’hybridation’, de ces nouveaux processus de production. En nous fondant sur une étude des sections locales des syndicats d’UNIFOR dans les usines d’assemblage de véhicules automobiles au Canada, nous soutenons que l’I 4.0 doit être analysé en fonction de la manière dont les syndicats ont influencé l’adoption presque universelle des MGHP dans ce secteur. Nous examinons donc les effets des syndicats sur les MGHP et les implications de leur rôle dans l’intégration de l’I 4.0 sur le lieu de travail. En tant que tels, nous soutenons d’abord que, bien qu’ils se chevauchent, les MGHP et l’I 4.0 représentent des stratégies managériales différentes. Deuxièmement, nous développons un cadre d’analyse exploratoire à utiliser afin d’examiner les rôles des syndicats dans la négociation des MGHP et l’adoption de la technologie numérique. Grâce à ce cadre d’analyse, nous analysons ensuite 18 entrevues que nous avons menées en 2017-2018 avec des directeurs d’usine et des représentants-clés d’UNIFOR dans cinq usines d’assemblage du sud de l’Ontario. Les entretiens illustrent, non seulement les points communs dans l’adoption des MGHP, mais aussi les différentes manières dont le syndicat influence ‘l’hybridation’ des MGHP. Les pratiques syndicales diffèrent significativement d’une usine à l’autre en fonction de trois variables: 1- la position concurrentielle entreprise-usine; 2- le visage global du monopole syndical; et 3- la solidarité et les récits internes du syndicat local autour de MGHP. En gardant à l’esprit ces points communs et ces différences, nous examinons, ensuite, les défis auxquels les syndicats sont susceptibles de faire face lorsqu’ils entament les négociations I 4.0.
- Open Access
- 16 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Dialectical Anthropology
- Vol. 42 (4) , 467-470
Commentary on Bryan Palmer’s “Approaching working-class history as struggle: a Canadian contemplation; a Marxist meditation”
- 16 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Dialectical Anthropology
- Vol. 42 (4) , 467-470
Open AccessCommentary on Bryan Palmer’s “Approaching working-class history as struggle: a Canadian contemplation; a Marxist meditation”
- Open Access
- 8 August 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Regional Studies
- Vol. 52 (4) , 572-584
State accumulation projects and inward investment regimes strategies
State accumulation projects and inward investment regimes strategies. Regional Studies. Based on Kitchener–Waterloo, Ontario, and Saguenay–Lac-Saint-Jean, Quebec, case studies, we link inward investment regimes (IIR) to the strategic relational approach to the state. The state continues to be significant in (1) selecting multinational enterprise (MNE) value-chain segments; (2) policies maximizing foreign direct investment (FDI) spillovers; (3) empowering IIR participants; and (4) managing the institutionalized compromises underlying these policies. Quebec’s developmental state (QDS) reflects labour’s greater power and has stronger levers to maximize FDI spillovers than Ontario’s competition state (OCS); however, both confront significant FDI challenges.
- 8 August 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Regional Studies
- Vol. 52 (4) , 572-584
Open AccessState accumulation projects and inward investment regimes strategies
State accumulation projects and inward investment regimes strategies. Regional Studies. Based on Kitchener–Waterloo, Ontario, and Saguenay–Lac-Saint-Jean, Quebec, case studies, we link inward investment regimes (IIR) to the strategic relational approach to the state. The state continues to be significant in (1) selecting multinational enterprise (MNE) value-chain segments; (2) policies maximizing foreign direct investment (FDI) spillovers; (3) empowering IIR participants; and (4) managing the institutionalized compromises underlying these policies. Quebec’s developmental state (QDS) reflects labour’s greater power and has stronger levers to maximize FDI spillovers than Ontario’s competition state (OCS); however, both confront significant FDI challenges.
- 11 March 2016
- Published by SAGE Publications in Economic and Industrial Democracy
- Vol. 39 (3) , 439-457
Overturning Italy’s Article 18: Exogenous and endogenous pressures, and role of the state
Since 1970 Article 18 provided important employment protection for workers in larger firms in Italy. Its core aspect (i.e. reinstatement in the case of unfair dismissal) was recently overturned by the Jobs Act for employees hired after its approval. To explain Article 18’s abolition, the authors assess the explicative power of (1) stronger exogenous pressures from economic international institutions, and (2) weaker endogenous pressures from unions and business organizations. Documentary analyses and semi-structured interviews with key informants reveal that while these two forces are critical, they tend to ‘read off’ the state policy decision making role, which, the authors argue, is central to explaining the overturning of Article 18.
- 11 March 2016
- Published by SAGE Publications in Economic and Industrial Democracy
- Vol. 39 (3) , 439-457
Overturning Italy’s Article 18: Exogenous and endogenous pressures, and role of the state
Since 1970 Article 18 provided important employment protection for workers in larger firms in Italy. Its core aspect (i.e. reinstatement in the case of unfair dismissal) was recently overturned by the Jobs Act for employees hired after its approval. To explain Article 18’s abolition, the authors assess the explicative power of (1) stronger exogenous pressures from economic international institutions, and (2) weaker endogenous pressures from unions and business organizations. Documentary analyses and semi-structured interviews with key informants reveal that while these two forces are critical, they tend to ‘read off’ the state policy decision making role, which, the authors argue, is central to explaining the overturning of Article 18.
- 3 September 2014
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society
- Vol. 7 (3) , 359-378
Manufacturing resiliency: economic restructuring and automotive manufacturing in the Great Lakes region
Through a case study of the Great Lakes region automotive industry spanning the USA–Canada international border, this article critically reassesses the concept of regional resiliency and the sustainability of the recent resurgence of American manufacturing. We argue that regional resiliency needs to be reframed around regional integration into global production networks and the restructuring of workplace governance especially with regard to the significant ‘recalibration’ of labour relations reflected in declining rates of unionisation, lowered labour costs and more ‘flexible’ employment relations. The region is no longer as dominant in North American automotive manufacturing as it once was and must respond to increasing competition from emergent auto-making regions in the southern USA and Mexico.
- 3 September 2014
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society
- Vol. 7 (3) , 359-378
Manufacturing resiliency: economic restructuring and automotive manufacturing in the Great Lakes region
Through a case study of the Great Lakes region automotive industry spanning the USA–Canada international border, this article critically reassesses the concept of regional resiliency and the sustainability of the recent resurgence of American manufacturing. We argue that regional resiliency needs to be reframed around regional integration into global production networks and the restructuring of workplace governance especially with regard to the significant ‘recalibration’ of labour relations reflected in declining rates of unionisation, lowered labour costs and more ‘flexible’ employment relations. The region is no longer as dominant in North American automotive manufacturing as it once was and must respond to increasing competition from emergent auto-making regions in the southern USA and Mexico.
- Open Access
- 13 April 2012
- Published by Wiley in Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
- Vol. 38 (1) , 25-35
Scaling up by law? Canadian labour law, the nation‐state and the case of the British Columbia Health Employees Union
This paper examines the Canadian Supreme Court’s 2007 ruling in favour of the Health Employees Union (HEU) versus the British Columbia government. Based on international labour law, this ruling recognised collective bargaining as part of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. While recent research in human and labour geography on labour law and the state have emphasised its contingent, topological and site‐based nature I argue: (i) that this case reflects how Canadian unions became deeply embedded in post‐war hegemonic splicings of law and space and the state’s role in the reproduction of the wage‐labour relation and (ii) while the HEU’s struggles and the use of international law contest such splicings, these are still sharply inflected by existing nation‐state legal systems that remain both relatively resilient and ambivalent about labour rights. The HEU case thus reveals that scaling up by law may not protect worker interests if labour is otherwise weak.
- 13 April 2012
- Published by Wiley in Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers
- Vol. 38 (1) , 25-35
Open AccessScaling up by law? Canadian labour law, the nation‐state and the case of the British Columbia Health Employees Union
This paper examines the Canadian Supreme Court’s 2007 ruling in favour of the Health Employees Union (HEU) versus the British Columbia government. Based on international labour law, this ruling recognised collective bargaining as part of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. While recent research in human and labour geography on labour law and the state have emphasised its contingent, topological and site‐based nature I argue: (i) that this case reflects how Canadian unions became deeply embedded in post‐war hegemonic splicings of law and space and the state’s role in the reproduction of the wage‐labour relation and (ii) while the HEU’s struggles and the use of international law contest such splicings, these are still sharply inflected by existing nation‐state legal systems that remain both relatively resilient and ambivalent about labour rights. The HEU case thus reveals that scaling up by law may not protect worker interests if labour is otherwise weak.
- 21 February 2012
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Regional Studies
- Vol. 47 (1) , 116-127
(Small) Differences that (Still) Matter? Cross-Border Regions and Work Place Governance in the Southern Ontario and US Great Lakes Automotive Industry
Rutherford T. D. and Holmes J. (Small) differences that (still) matter? Cross-border regions and work place governance in the Southern Ontario and US Great Lakes automotive industry, Regional Studies. Workplace governance is a critical element in determining regional competitiveness. While contemporary rescaling of economic and social relations has produced new territorial configurations, including cross-border regions (CBRs), there is little research on the reshaping of workplace governance within such regions. It is argued that changes in CBR workplace governance are contingent upon (1) firms' ability to transfer corporate employment practices across national borders; (2) labour law and other employment regulatory institutions; and (3) the response of labour organizations. Using this framework, workplace governance change in the automotive industry in the Southern Ontario and US Great Lakes States CBR is examined. 跨境区域 管治 工作场所 汽车工业 Rutherford T. D. and Holmes J. 小差异(还)起作用吗?南安大略及美国大湖区汽车工业的跨境区域与工作场所管治. 区域研究. 工作场所管治是决定区域竞争力的关键因素。尽管当今经济与社会关系的尺度变化已经产生了新的地域结构,如跨境区域,但有关这些区域内工作场所管治重构的研究几乎还没有。本文认为跨境区域工作场所管治具有不确定性,它取决于:(1)企业跨越边境复制公司雇员习惯的能力;(2)劳动法及其他就业管制机构;(3)劳工组织的响应。利用这个研究框架,本文探究了南安大略及美国大湖区汽车工业工作场所管治的变化。 Régions transfrontalières Gouvernance Lieu de travail Industrie automobile Rutherford T. D. et Holmes J. De (légères) différences qui comptent (toujours)? Les régions transfrontalières et la gouvernance du lieu de travail dans l'industrie automobile située dans le Sud de l'Ontario et dans la région des Grands Lacs au E-U, Regional Studies. La gouvernance du lieu de travavil constitue un facteur déterminant primordial de la compétitivité régionale. Alors que la reterritorialisation des rapports économiques et sociaux a produit de nouvelles configurations territoriales, y compris les régions transfrontalières, rares sont les recherches sur la transformation de la gouvernance du lieu de travail au sein de telles régions. On affirme que des transformations de la gouvernance du lieu de travail dans les régions transfrontalières sont subordonnées (1) à la capacité des entreprises de transférer leurs pratiques en matière d'emploi au-delà des frontières nationales; (2) au droit du travail et à d'autres institutions de régulation en matière d'emploi; et (3) à la réponse des organisations ouvrières. Ce cadre permet d'examiner la transformation de la gouvernance du lieu de travail dans l'industrie automobile située dans les régions transfrontalières du Sud de l'Ontario et de la région des Grands Lacs au E-U. Grenzübergreifende Regionen Unternehmensführung Arbeitsplatz Automobilindustrie Rutherford T. D. und Holmes J. (Kleine) Unterschiede, auf die es (immer noch) ankommt? Grenzübergreifende Regionen und Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz in der Automobilindustrie von Südontario (Kanada) und Great Lakes (USA), Regional Studies. Die Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz ist ein wesentliches Element zur Bestimmung der regionalen Wettbewerbsfähigkeit. Die aktuelle Neuskalierung der Wirtschafts- und Sozialbeziehungen hat zu neuen territorialen Konfigurationen wie z. B. grenzübergreifenden Regionen geführt, doch die Umgestaltung der Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz innerhalb solcher Regionen wurde bisher nur wenig untersucht. Wir argumentieren, dass die Veränderungen bei der Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz in grenzübergreifenden Regionen abhängig sind von (1) der Fähigkeit der Firmen, Unternehmenspraktiken bei der Beschäftigung von Arbeitnehmern über nationale Grenzen hinweg zu übertragen, (2) dem Arbeitsrecht und weiteren Institutionen zur Regelung der Arbeitsbeziehungen und (3) der Reaktion der Arbeitnehmerorganisationen. Anhand dieses Rahmens werden die Veränderungen bei der Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz in der Automobilindustrie der grenzübergreifenden Region von Südontario (Kanada) und Great Lakes (USA) untersucht. Regiones transfronterizas Dirección Lugar de trabajo Industria de automoción Rutherford T. D. y Holmes J. ¿(Pequeñas) diferencias que (todavía) importan? Regiones transfronterizas y dirección en el lugar de trabajo en la industria de automoción del sur de Ontario (Canadá) y los Estados de los Grandes Lagos (Estados Unidos), Regional Studies. La dirección en el lugar de trabajo es un elemento esencial a la hora de determinar la competitividad regional. Aunque el reescalamiento contemporáneo de las relaciones económicas y sociales ha producido nuevas configuraciones territoriales, como por ejemplo las regiones transfronterizas, existen pocos estudios sobre la reorganización de la dirección en el lugar de trabajo en tales regiones. Sostenemos que los cambios de la dirección en el lugar de trabajo de las regiones transfronterizas dependen de (1) la capacidad de las empresas de transferir las prácticas corporativas de empleo a través de las fronteras nacionales; (2) la legislación laboral y otras instituciones de reglamentación laboral; y (3) la respuesta de los sindicatos. Con ayuda de este marco de trabajo, analizamos el cambio de dirección en el lugar de trabajo en la industria de automoción en la región transfronteriza del sur de Ontario (Canadá) y los Estados de los Grandes Lagos (Estados Unidos).
- 21 February 2012
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Regional Studies
- Vol. 47 (1) , 116-127
(Small) Differences that (Still) Matter? Cross-Border Regions and Work Place Governance in the Southern Ontario and US Great Lakes Automotive Industry
Rutherford T. D. and Holmes J. (Small) differences that (still) matter? Cross-border regions and work place governance in the Southern Ontario and US Great Lakes automotive industry, Regional Studies. Workplace governance is a critical element in determining regional competitiveness. While contemporary rescaling of economic and social relations has produced new territorial configurations, including cross-border regions (CBRs), there is little research on the reshaping of workplace governance within such regions. It is argued that changes in CBR workplace governance are contingent upon (1) firms' ability to transfer corporate employment practices across national borders; (2) labour law and other employment regulatory institutions; and (3) the response of labour organizations. Using this framework, workplace governance change in the automotive industry in the Southern Ontario and US Great Lakes States CBR is examined. 跨境区域 管治 工作场所 汽车工业 Rutherford T. D. and Holmes J. 小差异(还)起作用吗?南安大略及美国大湖区汽车工业的跨境区域与工作场所管治. 区域研究. 工作场所管治是决定区域竞争力的关键因素。尽管当今经济与社会关系的尺度变化已经产生了新的地域结构,如跨境区域,但有关这些区域内工作场所管治重构的研究几乎还没有。本文认为跨境区域工作场所管治具有不确定性,它取决于:(1)企业跨越边境复制公司雇员习惯的能力;(2)劳动法及其他就业管制机构;(3)劳工组织的响应。利用这个研究框架,本文探究了南安大略及美国大湖区汽车工业工作场所管治的变化。 Régions transfrontalières Gouvernance Lieu de travail Industrie automobile Rutherford T. D. et Holmes J. De (légères) différences qui comptent (toujours)? Les régions transfrontalières et la gouvernance du lieu de travail dans l'industrie automobile située dans le Sud de l'Ontario et dans la région des Grands Lacs au E-U, Regional Studies. La gouvernance du lieu de travavil constitue un facteur déterminant primordial de la compétitivité régionale. Alors que la reterritorialisation des rapports économiques et sociaux a produit de nouvelles configurations territoriales, y compris les régions transfrontalières, rares sont les recherches sur la transformation de la gouvernance du lieu de travail au sein de telles régions. On affirme que des transformations de la gouvernance du lieu de travail dans les régions transfrontalières sont subordonnées (1) à la capacité des entreprises de transférer leurs pratiques en matière d'emploi au-delà des frontières nationales; (2) au droit du travail et à d'autres institutions de régulation en matière d'emploi; et (3) à la réponse des organisations ouvrières. Ce cadre permet d'examiner la transformation de la gouvernance du lieu de travail dans l'industrie automobile située dans les régions transfrontalières du Sud de l'Ontario et de la région des Grands Lacs au E-U. Grenzübergreifende Regionen Unternehmensführung Arbeitsplatz Automobilindustrie Rutherford T. D. und Holmes J. (Kleine) Unterschiede, auf die es (immer noch) ankommt? Grenzübergreifende Regionen und Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz in der Automobilindustrie von Südontario (Kanada) und Great Lakes (USA), Regional Studies. Die Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz ist ein wesentliches Element zur Bestimmung der regionalen Wettbewerbsfähigkeit. Die aktuelle Neuskalierung der Wirtschafts- und Sozialbeziehungen hat zu neuen territorialen Konfigurationen wie z. B. grenzübergreifenden Regionen geführt, doch die Umgestaltung der Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz innerhalb solcher Regionen wurde bisher nur wenig untersucht. Wir argumentieren, dass die Veränderungen bei der Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz in grenzübergreifenden Regionen abhängig sind von (1) der Fähigkeit der Firmen, Unternehmenspraktiken bei der Beschäftigung von Arbeitnehmern über nationale Grenzen hinweg zu übertragen, (2) dem Arbeitsrecht und weiteren Institutionen zur Regelung der Arbeitsbeziehungen und (3) der Reaktion der Arbeitnehmerorganisationen. Anhand dieses Rahmens werden die Veränderungen bei der Unternehmensführung am Arbeitsplatz in der Automobilindustrie der grenzübergreifenden Region von Südontario (Kanada) und Great Lakes (USA) untersucht. Regiones transfronterizas Dirección Lugar de trabajo Industria de automoción Rutherford T. D. y Holmes J. ¿(Pequeñas) diferencias que (todavía) importan? Regiones transfronterizas y dirección en el lugar de trabajo en la industria de automoción del sur de Ontario (Canadá) y los Estados de los Grandes Lagos (Estados Unidos), Regional Studies. La dirección en el lugar de trabajo es un elemento esencial a la hora de determinar la competitividad regional. Aunque el reescalamiento contemporáneo de las relaciones económicas y sociales ha producido nuevas configuraciones territoriales, como por ejemplo las regiones transfronterizas, existen pocos estudios sobre la reorganización de la dirección en el lugar de trabajo en tales regiones. Sostenemos que los cambios de la dirección en el lugar de trabajo de las regiones transfronterizas dependen de (1) la capacidad de las empresas de transferir las prácticas corporativas de empleo a través de las fronteras nacionales; (2) la legislación laboral y otras instituciones de reglamentación laboral; y (3) la respuesta de los sindicatos. Con ayuda de este marco de trabajo, analizamos el cambio de dirección en el lugar de trabajo en la industria de automoción en la región transfronteriza del sur de Ontario (Canadá) y los Estados de los Grandes Lagos (Estados Unidos).
- 23 November 2007
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Economic Geography
- Vol. 8 (4) , 519-544
'The flea on the tail of the dog': power in global production networks and the restructuring of Canadian automotive clusters
Recently, studies of industrial clusters and global production networks (GPNs) between large transnational corporations (TNCs) and smaller firms have focused on how power differentials shape, and sometimes undermine cluster innovation and governance. Such studies raise issues of how to conceptualize TNCs power within GPNs and some economic geographers have adopted approaches that seek to integrate the post-structural insights of actor network theory (ANT) with heterodox and Marxian value theory. Based on a case study of the Canadian automotive industry, we engage in a sympathetic critique of this perspective via a realist position that distinguishes between structural and actual power. We argue that differences in structural position derived from financial size matter, although do not necessarily determine actor network relations. Yet, TNC Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) have a tendential actual or ‘power over’ smaller automotive suppliers due to superior financial resources, their strategic position within GPNs and especially their relationship with state accumulation projects designed to capture those segments of GPNs, which offer the greatest potential for the creation and enhancement of value. We show that such projects were critical to the development of the Canadian automotive industry and the Kitchener and Windsor, Ontario automotive clusters. Although large firms were generally favoured by such policies, suppliers and SMEs were able to partially offset power asymmetries through innovation, often by accessing informal local networks in clusters. More recently, however, smaller component firms and the coherence of these clusters are being threatened by neo-liberal Schumpterian Competition State policies that privilege OEMs and larger firms and by the restructuring of automotive GPNs in response to overcapacity and falling profits.
- 23 November 2007
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Economic Geography
- Vol. 8 (4) , 519-544
'The flea on the tail of the dog': power in global production networks and the restructuring of Canadian automotive clusters
Recently, studies of industrial clusters and global production networks (GPNs) between large transnational corporations (TNCs) and smaller firms have focused on how power differentials shape, and sometimes undermine cluster innovation and governance. Such studies raise issues of how to conceptualize TNCs power within GPNs and some economic geographers have adopted approaches that seek to integrate the post-structural insights of actor network theory (ANT) with heterodox and Marxian value theory. Based on a case study of the Canadian automotive industry, we engage in a sympathetic critique of this perspective via a realist position that distinguishes between structural and actual power. We argue that differences in structural position derived from financial size matter, although do not necessarily determine actor network relations. Yet, TNC Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) have a tendential actual or ‘power over’ smaller automotive suppliers due to superior financial resources, their strategic position within GPNs and especially their relationship with state accumulation projects designed to capture those segments of GPNs, which offer the greatest potential for the creation and enhancement of value. We show that such projects were critical to the development of the Canadian automotive industry and the Kitchener and Windsor, Ontario automotive clusters. Although large firms were generally favoured by such policies, suppliers and SMEs were able to partially offset power asymmetries through innovation, often by accessing informal local networks in clusters. More recently, however, smaller component firms and the coherence of these clusters are being threatened by neo-liberal Schumpterian Competition State policies that privilege OEMs and larger firms and by the restructuring of automotive GPNs in response to overcapacity and falling profits.
“We Simply Have to Do that Stuff for our Survival”: Labour, Firm Innovation and Cluster Governance in the Canadian Automotive Parts Industry
Based on a case study of the Canadian Auto Workers (CAW) union in southern Ontario we argue for a critical reconstruction of both the labour geography and industrial cluster literature. The former stresses the active role of labour in the formation of economic landscapes, but has yet to explore labour's agency in production and how labour institutions shape technological change, firm innovation and industrial policy and strategy. Conversely, much of the industrial cluster and regional innovation systems literature is silent on the role of unions and industrial relations institutions in fostering innovation. We conclude with two main points. First, while some contend that positive union roles in innovation can only stem from partnerships with management and team working, we argue that innovation is more likely to emerge and worker interests are better protected when traditional collective bargaining structures and progressive employment legislation play a central role. Second, positive workplace and cluster level cooperation in the Canadian automotive parts industry are jeopardized by the broader and ongoing macro‐economic restructuring of OEM global production networks due to over‐capacity and intense cost‐cutting pressures reverberating down the supply chain.
“We Simply Have to Do that Stuff for our Survival”: Labour, Firm Innovation and Cluster Governance in the Canadian Automotive Parts Industry
Based on a case study of the Canadian Auto Workers (CAW) union in southern Ontario we argue for a critical reconstruction of both the labour geography and industrial cluster literature. The former stresses the active role of labour in the formation of economic landscapes, but has yet to explore labour's agency in production and how labour institutions shape technological change, firm innovation and industrial policy and strategy. Conversely, much of the industrial cluster and regional innovation systems literature is silent on the role of unions and industrial relations institutions in fostering innovation. We conclude with two main points. First, while some contend that positive union roles in innovation can only stem from partnerships with management and team working, we argue that innovation is more likely to emerge and worker interests are better protected when traditional collective bargaining structures and progressive employment legislation play a central role. Second, positive workplace and cluster level cooperation in the Canadian automotive parts industry are jeopardized by the broader and ongoing macro‐economic restructuring of OEM global production networks due to over‐capacity and intense cost‐cutting pressures reverberating down the supply chain.