KSKatja Seltmann

Katja Seltmann

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Katja Seltmann has a total of 608 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    DNA barcoding of more than one million insect specimens indicates that at least one third of California's insect biodiversity remains undiscovered

    by Austin J. Baker, Brad Balukjian, Hilary Bayer, Jen Bayer, Daniel Gluesenkamp, Christopher C. Grinter, John M. Heraty, Amanda K. Hodson, Eva Sofia Horna Lowell, Colleen Kamoroff, et al.

    Insects are the most diverse terrestrial organisms, yet they are underrepresented in large‐scale conservation assessments. To address this gap, the California Insect Barcoding Initiative is developing a publicly accessible, statewide DNA‐barcode reference library for California insects to support scalable surveys, establish baseline biodiversity measurements, and generate potential distribution maps that inform conservation planning. Specimens are collected with a hybrid strategy that combines standardized Malaise trapping, to enable replicable sampling, and opportunistic collecting, to maximize taxonomic coverage. Using samples collected primarily from 2022–2024 at 72 longer‐term Malaise trap sites, coupled with collecting using varied methods at 454 additional locations across California, we have barcoded over one million specimens. Preliminary completeness analyses suggest that current sampling captures roughly 65–69% of the fauna, implying a conservative minimum of circa 61 000 insect species in California, as delimited by their DNA barcode sequence. Using all sequenced specimen records, we generated rule‐based spatial range interpolations constrained by ecoregion and vegetation type, and used these to infer spatial patterns in insect species richness across the state. We identify areas of both high and low potential species richness, with current peaks in the Southern California Mountains ecoregion and the Mojave Basin and Range ecoregion. Our species richness estimates and spatial patterns are explicitly provisional and are expected to evolve as sampling gaps are addressed. Finally, we make all sequence data, specimen images, and occurrence records publicly available via the Barcode of Life Datasystem. This ongoing effort constitutes the first large‐scale DNA barcode‐based survey for California insects, providing an expandable foundation for tracking temporal change, testing drivers of insect diversity, and prioritizing regions for conservation and targeted inventory.

  • Open Access

    Wing venation reflects phylogenetic divergence and allometric scaling in bees

    by Jorge De La Cruz, Charles Thrift, Madeleine Ostwald, Katja Seltmann

    Wing venation is widely used in insect systematics, but the extent to which bee wing morphology reflects phylogenetic divergence, taxonomic identity, and body-size scaling remains poorly understood. Here, we used geometric morphometrics to quantify forewing venation across 17 bee species representing 17 genera and five families. We placed nine homologous landmarks on wing vein intersections and analyzed shape variation among species, subfamilies, and families. We also tested whether wing morphology contained phylogenetic signal, compared a morphology-inferred tree with a molecular reference phylogeny, and evaluated whether wing shape covaried with intertegular distance, a proxy for body size. Wing morphology reliably distinguished taxa at multiple hierarchical levels, with high classification accuracy among species, subfamilies, and families. Landmark data also showed strong phylogenetic signal, and the wing morphology-inferred tree showed moderate concordance with the molecular reference phylogeny. However, intertegular distance explained a substantial proportion of variation in the primary canonical variate, indicating that allometric scaling is a major driver of bee wing venation. These findings suggest that bee forewing morphology contains taxonomic and phylogenetic information, but that this signal is strongly shaped by size-related constraints. Our results highlight allometry as a key factor in interpreting wing morphometric variation and support the use of wing venation as a complementary tool for bee identification, comparative morphology, and studies of evolutionary divergence.

  • Open Access

    Patterns of species richness and endemism in bee and plant communities in California

    by Gilbert F. Alarcon-Cruz, Sarah Jacobs, Bruce G. Baldwin, Katja C. Seltmann, Gretchen Le Buhn

    Summary: Understanding the spatial distribution of species and their patterns of endemism is necessary for establishing effective conservation priorities. Despite the vital pollination services bees provide, California’s native bee distribution patterns remain largely unexplored relative to plants and butterflies. We analyzed bee species richness and endemism across California and their concordance with plant distributions. Richness was high across areas of the California Floristic Province, including the Sierra Nevada, San Francisco Bay Area and Central Coast, South Coast Ranges, and the Transverse and Peninsular ranges. Bee endemism was more localized, concentrated in the San Joaquin Valley, eastern Sierra Nevada and adjacent Great Basin, Sierra Nevada foothills, and California deserts. Because richness and endemism appear to operate at different spatial scales and likely respond to different environmental drivers, effective conservation strategies must address both. Additionally, conservation plans that incorporate both plant and bee diversity are needed to achieve more comprehensive biodiversity protection.

  • Open Access

    Concentrated vulnerabilities in bees: Diet specialists have smaller geographic ranges

    by Charles N. Thrift, Thomas J. Wood, An Bui, Hillary S. Young, Katja C. Seltmann

    Wild bees are widely believed to be in decline, yet most species remain unassessed for IUCN extinction risk. Geographic range size is used in risk assessments under the assumption that species with smaller ranges are more vulnerable to anthropogenic impacts. Narrow diet breadth can also increase vulnerability but is not currently incorporated into assessments. Niche breadth theory predicts a positive association between range size and diet breadth, which could concentrate risk among dietary specialists, but this relationship is not well established for bees and may differ among taxa. Here, we combined pollen‐use data from natural history collections with global occurrence records to test the relationship between diet breadth and range size across bees and among bee families. We assigned diet breadth using three metrics (categorical, numerical and phylogenetic) and estimated range size as the extent of occurrence for 633 species from six families. Across bees, range size increased with diet breadth, and diet specialists tended to occupy smaller ranges. These results suggest that range size and diet breadth jointly contribute to increased vulnerability in bees, indicating that some specialist species may merit conservation prioritisation. Our findings support the integration of trait‐based approaches for assessing extinction risk and highlight the high value of natural history data in identifying patterns of vulnerability among pollinators.


  • Open Access

    Leveraging local species data, a global database, and an occupancy model to explore bee–plant interactions

    by Michelle J. Lee, Graziella V. DiRenzo, Chengyi Diao, Katja C. Seltmann

    Global declines in bee populations are threatening the ecosystem services they provide, including pollination. Many bee–plant interactions are understudied, producing an incomplete understanding of resulting ecosystem‐level vulnerabilities. The last decade has generated a wealth of opportunistic data originating from natural history collection records, published ecological datasets, and citizen/community science initiatives in online databases such as Global Biotic Interactions (GloBI). Here, we explore hypotheses related to bee–plant interactions and detection processes using the GloBI database, curated checklists of bee and flowering plant species, and an occupancy model. We hypothesized that larger, social bees would visit a larger number of plant species, while smaller, solitary bees would visit fewer. We also predicted that flowers with open, bowl‐like shapes would attract a greater diversity of bee visitors compared to closed shapes. Further, we hypothesized that both floral and bee traits, such as bright colors and conspicuous patterns, would increase detectability, and that different data collection methods would vary in their ability to capture bee–plant interactions. Lastly, we hypothesized that the interaction network generated by the output of the occupancy model, which accounted for imperfect bee–plant detection, would yield more interactions, thereby increasing measures of evenness and decreasing nestedness and specialization, as compared to the network generated from recorded interaction data. We found that smaller bees exhibited higher probabilities of plant interactions than larger bees, but we did not find evidence that bee sociality influenced the probability of interacting with plants. We found that blue flowers and closed (not‐bowl‐shaped) flowers had higher probabilities of bee‐plant interaction than other flower colors or bowl‐shaped flowers, respectively. We also found that larger bee size, blue flowers, bowl shapes, and community science sources were associated with higher detection probabilities of bee–plant interactions. Lastly, the interaction network generated by the occupancy model output showed higher levels of evenness, nestedness, and connectance than the network generated by the GloBI data. Our study is among the first to utilize occupancy modeling to directly model species' interactions, leverage aggregated, open‐source databases and expert checklists, and highlight the influence of detection and collection biases on our understanding of ecological interactions.


  • Open Access

    A curated and integrated dataset for exploring global bee-plant interactions

    by Sajad Noori, Alice C. Hughes, Thais N. C. Vasconcelos, John S. Ascher, Jared T. Miller, Sarah M. Gaugel, Madeleine M. Ostwald, James B. Dorey, Victor H. Gonzalez, Aline C. Martins, et al.

    Bees are one of the most important pollinators in terrestrial ecosystems, supporting biodiversity and food production. However, global knowledge of their interactions with host plants remains limited. To address this, we describe and refine a subset of the Global Biotic Interactions (GloBI) database focused on bee-plant interactions. We updated taxonomy using current checklists and enhanced the dataset with metadata on geography, endemism, and human uses of plants. The resulting dataset includes 981,982 unique interaction records between 5,537 bee species and 12,699 plant taxa. Despite its scale, the dataset is affected by strong taxonomic and geographic biases. It covers only 26% of described bee species and 4% of flowering plant taxa—primarily those used by humans—and is heavily skewed toward North America and Western Europe. Nevertheless, GloBI represents a valuable resource for incorporating bee-plant interactions into biodiversity and conservation-oriented research and represents a considerable advance in our current knowledge.


  • Open Access

    Realistic 3D morphology reshapes insect heat budgets

    by Madeleine Ostwald, Meredith Johnson, Abigail Youngblood, Alexis Childress, Katja Seltmann

  • Open Access

    Improving the standardization of wild bee occurrence data: Towards a formal wild bee data standard

    by Brianne Du Clos, Katja C. Seltmann, Nash E. Turley, Clare Maffei, Erika M. Tucker, Ian G. Lane, Hannah K. Levenson, S. Hollis Woodard

    Conservation and management of wild bees is hindered by the variety of ways wild bee occurrence data are recorded, managed, and shared. Here, we present solutions to address this issue and introduce The Wild Bee Data Standard, a standardized means of recording and reporting data associated with wild bee occurrences, including physical specimens and photo observations. This standard aligns with contemporary data management practices widely adopted by the broader biodiversity data community. We propose a set of terms for the standard that describe various features of bee occurrences, including collection method and location, taxonomic verification, and final record storage. We emphasize the importance of providing sampling protocol and effort information with wild bee occurrence data and offer guidance to make this a more common practice. We describe how to translate data not currently aligned with the standard to meet its conditions, and how to upload those data to an accessible online repository. We provide case studies, data entry templates, a glossary of terms, and additional resources to guide new users to implementing the standard. We also present a forum, established as a GitHub repository, to support continued development of the standard. Recognizing the significant change this represents for current data practices, we outline the benefits for the bee research and conservation community that will result from improved data standards. We advocate for making all historical, current, and future bee occurrence data openly available to facilitate more rigorous and comprehensive research, conservation, and management of wild bees. This contribution is part of a series developed in association with the U.S. National Native Bee Monitoring Network to standardize bee monitoring practices.


  • Open Access

    DNA barcoding of more than one million insect specimens indicates that at least one third of California's insect biodiversity remains undiscovered

    by Austin Baker, Brad Balukjian, Hilary Bayer, Jen Bayer, Daniel Gluesenkamp, Christopher Grinter, John Heraty, Amanda Hodson, Eva Horna Lowell, Colleen Kamoroff, et al.

    Insects are the most diverse terrestrial organisms, yet they are underrepresented in large-scale conservation assessments. To address this gap, the California Insect Barcoding Initiative is developing a publicly accessible, statewide DNA-barcode reference library for California insects to support scalable surveys, establish baseline biodiversity measurements, and generate potential distribution maps that inform conservation planning. Specimens are collected with a hybrid strategy that combines standardized Malaise trapping, to enable replicable sampling, and opportunistic collecting, to maximize taxonomic coverage. To date, we have barcoded over one million specimens; preliminary completeness analyses suggest that current sampling captures roughly 65–69% of the fauna, implying a conservative minimum of circa 61,000 insect species in California. Using all sequenced specimen records, we generated rule-based spatial range interpolations constrained by ecoregion and vegetation type, and used these to infer spatial patterns in insect species richness across the state. We identify areas of both high and low potential species richness, with current peaks in the Southern California Mountains ecoregion and the Mojave Basin and Range ecoregion. Our species richness estimates and spatial patterns are explicitly provisional and are expected to evolve as sampling gaps are addressed. Finally, we make all sequence data, specimen images, and occurrence records publicly available via the Barcode of Life Datasystem. This ongoing effort constitutes the first large-scale DNA barcode-based survey for California insects, providing an expandable foundation for tracking temporal change, testing drivers of insect diversity, and prioritizing regions for conservation and targeted inventory.


  • Open Access

    Sociality and nesting strategy shape the bimodal diversity gradient in bees

    by Lena R. Heinrich, Aline C. Martins, Silas Bossert, Alice C. Hughes, Michael C. Orr, Katja C. Seltmann, Anshuman Swain, Thais Vasconcelos

    Bees are dominant pollinators across native and agricultural plant communities, yet the drivers of their patterns of geographic distribution and functional diversity remain poorly understood. Notably, bees exhibit a bimodal latitudinal diversity gradient, peaking in species diversity in temperate and arid regions rather than the tropics despite their close ecological and evolutionary ties to flowering plants, which show the opposite pattern. Here, we investigated whether two key life history traits thought to shape where bees can live—sociality and nesting strategy—may influence this pattern. We compiled data on sociality and nesting strategy for 4,293 bee species and combined it with a comprehensive phylogeny, curated global occurrence records, and newly-developed models of trait evolution to test 1) whether sociality and nesting biology are evolutionarily correlated, 2) how these life history traits shape bees’ climatic niches and niche breadths, and 3) whether the evolutionary dynamics of these traits may explain the bimodal latitudinal gradient in bee diversity. We find that the evolution of above-ground nesting is closely tied to the evolution of social behavior, but this trait combination has evolved rarely across the evolutionary history of bees. Where this combination does arise, species that are both social and above-ground nesters tend to have narrower climatic niches and are associated with environments that are warmer, wetter, and experience little seasonal temperature variation, making them more prevalent in tropical bee communities. Together, our results indicate that the bimodal diversity gradient in bees is driven by phylogenetic niche conservatism, where most bee lineages retain ancestral traits suited to arid environments and the derived syndrome necessary for thriving in the tropics evolves rarely.