SHScott R. Hinze

Scott R. Hinze

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Scott R. Hinze has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Effects of AI Feedback on College Students’ Reading and Writing Performance in an Intelligent Text Framework

    by Siqi Shen, Alyssa Friend Wise, Wesley Morris, Langdon Holmes, Scott R. Hinze, Scott Crossley

    This study investigates how AI feedback influences college students’ reading and writing performance within an intelligent text aligned with the Interactive Constructive Active and Passive (ICAP) framework. Using a within-subjects design, students completed two read-to-write tasks — constructed response items (CRIs) and summaries — under two conditions: (1) Strategic Thinking And Interactive Reading Support (STAIRS), which provided AI feedback to support interactive engagement, and (2) Random Reread, a control condition without AI feedback to support constructive engagement. STAIRS offered automated scoring of read-to-write tasks, targeted rereading, and a chatbot that engaged students in interactive dialogues to support revision. Results showed that STAIRS significantly improved students’ summary revisions and subsequent summary performance, suggesting that AI feedback functions not only as guidance for improving current summaries but also benefits future performance. However, students in the STAIRS condition did not show higher CRI or summative quiz scores. CRI scores may have been limited by a ceiling effect, while the lack of quiz benefits may reflect a tradeoff in the study design, where the classroom tasks did not fully match the system’s activities. These mixed outcomes highlight the need to further explore how AI feedback may support different aspects of reading with an intelligent text.

  • Stage 2 Registered Report—You've Got Some Explaining to Do: Effects of Explanation Prompts on Science Text Comprehension

    by Kathryn S. McCarthy, Scott R. Hinze

    The use of active comprehension strategies that encourage students to explain what they have read can improve students' comprehension of complex scientific texts. Most research has focused on either strategies that are engaged during reading (online) or those used after reading (offline)—often ignoring potential interactions that might occur in authentic learning. This study used a 2 (online: think‐aloud, self‐explain) × 3 (offline: reread, free recall, explanatory retrieval) design with a 7‐day delayed comprehension test to examine how explanatory prompts might affect comprehension. Analyses from this Stage 2 Registered Report revealed a main effect of online condition, but no main effect offline condition. This was qualified by an interaction such that retrieval of any kind supported the comprehension benefits of self‐explanation. These findings highlight the importance of considering how comprehension strategies interact and the conditions under which they are most effective.


  • You've got some explaining to do: Effects of explanation prompts on science text comprehension

    by Kathryn S. McCarthy, Scott R. Hinze

    Summary: The use of active comprehension strategies that encourage students to explain what they have read can improve students' comprehension of complex scientific texts. Most research has focused on either strategies that are engaged during reading (online) or those used after reading (offline)—often ignoring potential interactions that might occur in authentic learning. This study uses a 2(online: think‐aloud, self‐explain) 3(offline: reread, free recall, explanatory retrieval) design with a 7‐day delayed comprehension test to examine how online and offline explanation strategies affect comprehension. Linear mixed effects modeling will be used to examine both main effects and interactions.


    • 10 June 2020
      • Vol. 12164, 197-202

    Predicting Reading Comprehension from Constructed Responses: Explanatory Retrievals as Stealth Assessment

    by Kathryn S. McCarthy, Laura K. Allen, Scott R. Hinze

    Open-ended constructed responses promote deeper processing of course materials. Further, evaluation of these explanations can yield important information about students’ cognition. This study examined how students’ constructed responses, generated at different points during learning, relate to their later comprehension outcomes. College students (N = 75) produced self-explanations during reading and explanatory retrievals after reading. The Constructed Response Assessment Tool (CRAT) was used to analyze these responses across multiple dimensions of language and relate these textual features to comprehension performance. Results indicate that the linguistic features of post-reading explanatory retrievals were more predictive of comprehension outcomes than self-explanations. Further, these models relied on different indices to predict performance.

  • Biology Textbook Graphics and Their Impact on Expectations of Understanding

    by Jennifer Wiley, David Sarmento, Thomas D. Griffin, Scott R. Hinze

    Graphics presented alongside expository science texts can have a number of positive effects for instruction, including facilitating engagement, arousing interest, and improving understanding. However, because students harbor expectations about which contexts are likely to support better understanding, the mere presence of graphics also has the potential to lead to inaccurate judgments of understanding when those graphics do not actually lead to presumed levels of performance. Previous work has demonstrated that including graphics alongside text can alter the judgment process. The present work explores different categories of instructional graphics found in biology textbooks and tests how different graphic types, classified by their form and function, can affect expectations of understanding prior to actual reading. Experiment 1 found that realistic, depictive graphics predominated in a middle school text, whereas more abstract and explanatory graphics predominated in a college text. Experiment 2 demonstrated that different categories of graphics led to differences in expectations of how helpful graphics would be for understanding.


  • Fool Me Twice: The Consequences of Reading (and Rereading) Inaccurate Information

    by Matthew E. Jacovina, Scott R. Hinze, David N. Rapp

    Summary: Readers frequently encounter inaccuracies in texts that contradict what they should know to be true. The current project examined readers' moment‐by‐moment processing of inaccuracies and whether any difficulty with such material is reduced when readers are already familiar with accurate versions of that content. In two experiments, participants read stories that either accurately or inaccurately described the outcome of a well‐known historic event. Preceding story contexts supported accurate outcomes or introduced suspense to create uncertainty about outcome likelihoods. During initial readings, participants took longer to read inaccurate than accurate outcomes. But this difficulty was substantially reduced when suspenseful contexts called into question the likelihood of well‐known outcomes. Similar reading patterns emerged when participants read the exact same material after week‐long and 5‐minute delays. These results indicate that biasing contexts can influence readers' processing of inaccuracies for even familiar events. Rereading proves insufficient for encouraging reliance on accurate prior knowledge. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.


  • Retrieval (Sometimes) Enhances Learning: Performance Pressure Reduces the Benefits of Retrieval Practice

    by Scott R. Hinze, David N. Rapp

    Summary: Academic testing has received substantial support as a useful educational activity with robust retention benefits, given that tests can promote retrieval practice. However, testing can also instantiate performance‐related pressure and anxiety that may misappropriate the resources responsible for producing learning benefits. The current project examined the effects of performance pressure on retrieval practice. In two experiments, we instantiated performance pressure with either high‐stakes or low‐stakes quizzes, and assessed memory and comprehension of content on both quizzes and final tests. Quiz performance was equivalent under high‐stakes and low‐stakes conditions, demonstrating that learners adapted to high‐pressure quizzes. However, final test performance was better after low‐stakes versus high‐stakes quizzes, and only low‐stakes quizzes led to a performance advantage over a rereading control group. Participants additionally exhibited some sensitivity to the difficulty of retrieving under pressure. These data highlight the benefits of retrieval practice but indicate that they can be disrupted under pressure‐driven conditions. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.


  • Amazing Stories: Acquiring and Avoiding Inaccurate Information From Fiction

    by David N. Rapp, Scott R. Hinze, Daniel G. Slaten, William S. Horton

    Authors of fiction need not provide accurate accounts of the world, which might generate concern about the kinds of information people can acquire from narratives. Research has demonstrated that readers liberally encode and rely upon the information provided in fictional stories. To date, materials used to demonstrate these effects have largely included stories taking place in real-world settings. We tested whether readers might exhibit more conservative use of information from stories with unrealistic settings and characers, as in science fiction and fantasy genres. In two experiments, participants read texts containing accurate, misleading, or neutral information, embedded in realistic or unrealistic stories. They subsequently completed a general knowledge test that included probes for story information. Unrealistic stories, in comparison to realistic stories, led to reductions in the use of misinformation. Source monitoring judgments suggest explanations for these reductions. The findings offer intriguing possibilities for encouraging readers' critical evaluation of text content.