Stephen Cummins
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Stephen Cummins has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Max Stille
Max Planck Inst Human Dev, Berlin, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Social Science History
- Vol. 48 (4) , 603-619
Feeling the rules: Historical and contemporary perspectives on emotional norms and social distinction
Feeling rules are norms surrounding emotions, particularly emotional expressions in social contexts, and are a well-known aspect of human societies in both the past and present. As a subdiscipline, the history of emotions has found great profit in tracking changing feeling rules over time to better understand social formations. Emotional norms are culturally, geographically, and socially specific, providing coherence to communities or serving as instruments of distinction within them. Yet some historians have found a sole focus on the normative insufficient for grasping, in their entirety, the historical aspects of emotions and their specific functions. This special issue suggests some new ways to think about escaping the dualism of emotional norms and emotional experiences – or, put more broadly, of structure and subjectivity – without privileging either as the determining factor in shaping social relations. To show the interrelations between rules and experiences, we draw from sociological work on taste and social distinction, arguing that emotions become socially potent and drivers of historical change by being both means and objects of value judgments. This introduction provides an overview of feelings rules and emotional norms in the history of emotions, connects these to work in the sociology of taste, and introduces the case studies in the special issue.
- 11 December 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Social Science History
- Vol. 48 (4) , 603-619
Open AccessFeeling the rules: Historical and contemporary perspectives on emotional norms and social distinction
Feeling rules are norms surrounding emotions, particularly emotional expressions in social contexts, and are a well-known aspect of human societies in both the past and present. As a subdiscipline, the history of emotions has found great profit in tracking changing feeling rules over time to better understand social formations. Emotional norms are culturally, geographically, and socially specific, providing coherence to communities or serving as instruments of distinction within them. Yet some historians have found a sole focus on the normative insufficient for grasping, in their entirety, the historical aspects of emotions and their specific functions. This special issue suggests some new ways to think about escaping the dualism of emotional norms and emotional experiences – or, put more broadly, of structure and subjectivity – without privileging either as the determining factor in shaping social relations. To show the interrelations between rules and experiences, we draw from sociological work on taste and social distinction, arguing that emotions become socially potent and drivers of historical change by being both means and objects of value judgments. This introduction provides an overview of feelings rules and emotional norms in the history of emotions, connects these to work in the sociology of taste, and introduces the case studies in the special issue.
- Open Access
- 24 October 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Social Science History
- Vol. 48 (4) , 621-641
Disgust and the duel: Aristocratic violence, the scienza cavalleresca, and feeling rules in early modern Italy
Many early modern Italian nobles were obsessed with duelling. Despite bans from secular authorities and the Council of Trent, the violent honor complex was veiled in part under the title of the scienza cavalleresca, the knightly science, which provided rules for the conduct of conflicts between aristocrats and those with noble aspirations. Such rules were both concerned with emotions and the object of emotions. Using the tools of the history and sociology of emotions, this article contributes to the emotional history of the scienza cavalleresca through examining the rules proposed both as feeling rules in themselves and as objects of emotional judgment. Toward the turn of the eighteenth century, more aristocrats began rejecting such codes with explicit objections to the scienza cavalleresca and its ethical basis. One such noble was Paolo Mattia Doria (1667–1746), a notorious duellist in the closing years of the Spanish regime, who renounced the vendetta and expressed disgust with its practitioners. A zealous convert against the noble vengeance system, he will serve as an example to explore the wider struggle over emotional values in early modern Italy and, more generally, in societies with high levels of violence. The article traces the role of emotions in the scienza cavalleresca, the taste for dispute through one genre (letters of challenge or cartelli di sfida), then explores the case of Doria. From these three stages, the article argues for the significance of adopting approaches from the sociology of emotions to analyze elite cultures of violence.
- 24 October 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Social Science History
- Vol. 48 (4) , 621-641
Open AccessDisgust and the duel: Aristocratic violence, the scienza cavalleresca, and feeling rules in early modern Italy
Many early modern Italian nobles were obsessed with duelling. Despite bans from secular authorities and the Council of Trent, the violent honor complex was veiled in part under the title of the scienza cavalleresca, the knightly science, which provided rules for the conduct of conflicts between aristocrats and those with noble aspirations. Such rules were both concerned with emotions and the object of emotions. Using the tools of the history and sociology of emotions, this article contributes to the emotional history of the scienza cavalleresca through examining the rules proposed both as feeling rules in themselves and as objects of emotional judgment. Toward the turn of the eighteenth century, more aristocrats began rejecting such codes with explicit objections to the scienza cavalleresca and its ethical basis. One such noble was Paolo Mattia Doria (1667–1746), a notorious duellist in the closing years of the Spanish regime, who renounced the vendetta and expressed disgust with its practitioners. A zealous convert against the noble vengeance system, he will serve as an example to explore the wider struggle over emotional values in early modern Italy and, more generally, in societies with high levels of violence. The article traces the role of emotions in the scienza cavalleresca, the taste for dispute through one genre (letters of challenge or cartelli di sfida), then explores the case of Doria. From these three stages, the article argues for the significance of adopting approaches from the sociology of emotions to analyze elite cultures of violence.
- Open Access
- 22 January 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Religious History
- Vol. 45 (1) , 3-24
Religious Emotions and Emotions in Religion: The Case of Sermons
- 22 January 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Religious History
- Vol. 45 (1) , 3-24
Open AccessReligious Emotions and Emotions in Religion: The Case of Sermons
- 15 May 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 255-279
Forgiving Crimes in Early Modern Naples
This chapter aims to tracing the relations between remissions, other legal practices and social life. Remissions of crimes did not remain private arrangements but were central to the 'transaction' or 'composition' of crime, for which settlement with the offended party was often regarded as an indispensable precursor. The chapter argues that in order to understand the Neapolitan state's attitude towards high rates of violence in the Kingdom and investigates the relationship between victims and offending parties on a number of different levels. The legal arrangements surrounding peace and pardon in the Kingdom could both empower and expose those who could provide legal forgiveness. The chapter considers peacemaking as both from the plural centres of the Neapolitan state and in local contexts. The institutional frameworks of remission and composition also created challenges for the government of Naples throughout the early modern period.
- 15 May 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 255-279
Forgiving Crimes in Early Modern Naples
This chapter aims to tracing the relations between remissions, other legal practices and social life. Remissions of crimes did not remain private arrangements but were central to the 'transaction' or 'composition' of crime, for which settlement with the offended party was often regarded as an indispensable precursor. The chapter argues that in order to understand the Neapolitan state's attitude towards high rates of violence in the Kingdom and investigates the relationship between victims and offending parties on a number of different levels. The legal arrangements surrounding peace and pardon in the Kingdom could both empower and expose those who could provide legal forgiveness. The chapter considers peacemaking as both from the plural centres of the Neapolitan state and in local contexts. The institutional frameworks of remission and composition also created challenges for the government of Naples throughout the early modern period.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Max Planck Institute for Legal History and Legal Theory in Rechtsgeschichte - Legal History
- Vol. 2017 (25)
Negotiating Justice and Passion in European Legal Cultures, ca. 1500–1800
This article explores two interrelated facets of early modern law and emotions. It first examines the emotional dynamics of negotiated justice in early modern Europe, tackling one of the clearest characteristics of European legal culture in this period. In so doing, it underscores how the complex emotional worlds connected with justice practices that were transactional, negotiable and often explicitly based on the reproduction of society’s hierarchies and relationships through settlements and arbitration. Secondly, it moves to consider such changes in legal thought that occurred as critiques of practices of Old Regime justice. Reconsideration of the relations between emotion and law in the Enlightenment occurred as part of a twinned project of the critique of existing practices of law and speculative imaginings of the potential of legislation to influence behaviour and feelings. Innovative accounts of the relation between passions and law were the product of this reconsideration of the status quo. Laws were reconsidered as tools to channel human passions in certain directions. This article explores the place of emotions in legal change in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries by looking both at the defining practices of early modern justice and how they were the spur for new conceptions of the relationship between legislation and the passions.
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Max Planck Institute for Legal History and Legal Theory in Rechtsgeschichte - Legal History
- Vol. 2017 (25)
Open AccessNegotiating Justice and Passion in European Legal Cultures, ca. 1500–1800
This article explores two interrelated facets of early modern law and emotions. It first examines the emotional dynamics of negotiated justice in early modern Europe, tackling one of the clearest characteristics of European legal culture in this period. In so doing, it underscores how the complex emotional worlds connected with justice practices that were transactional, negotiable and often explicitly based on the reproduction of society’s hierarchies and relationships through settlements and arbitration. Secondly, it moves to consider such changes in legal thought that occurred as critiques of practices of Old Regime justice. Reconsideration of the relations between emotion and law in the Enlightenment occurred as part of a twinned project of the critique of existing practices of law and speculative imaginings of the potential of legislation to influence behaviour and feelings. Innovative accounts of the relation between passions and law were the product of this reconsideration of the status quo. Laws were reconsidered as tools to channel human passions in certain directions. This article explores the place of emotions in legal change in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries by looking both at the defining practices of early modern justice and how they were the spur for new conceptions of the relationship between legislation and the passions.