Andrew J. Imdieke
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Andrew J. Imdieke has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Sarah B. Stuber
Texas A&M University - Mays Business School
5 shared publications - Matthew Ege
Texas A&M University–College Station
4 shared publications Joseph H. Schroeder
Indiana University - Kelley School of Business - Department of Accounting
3 shared publicationsYadav Gopalan
Indiana University - Kelley School of Business - Department of Accounting
3 shared publications- Dain C. Donelson
University of Iowa
2 shared publications - Eldar Maksymov
W.P. Carey School of Business Arizona State University Tempe Arizona USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 September 2026
- Published by American Accounting Association in AUDITING: A Journal of Practice & Theory
- p. 1-24
Linking Auditor Independence and Audit Quality: A Review and Synthesis of Academic Literature from 2015–2025
SUMMARY: This paper synthesizes academic studies published between 2015 and 2025 examining the relation between auditor independence and audit quality. We review evidence from the literature related to regulatory and professional factors (e.g., nonaudit services, auditor tenure, auditor switching), organizational factors (e.g., client importance, client dismissal of the auditor, social bonding), and individual auditor attributes (e.g., professional skepticism, expertise, and ethical orientation). Contemporary auditor independence research reports mixed and context-specific findings. For example, nonaudit services can either impair or enhance audit quality depending on service type, regulatory safeguards, and knowledge spillovers. Mandatory partner rotation tends to enhance audit quality, although mandatory firm rotation yields limited benefits and higher costs. We highlight the need for more research on independence and auditors’ duty to the public interest, proposing future directions to inform policy, practice, and standard setting. JEL Classifications: M40; M42; M48.
- 1 September 2026
- Published by American Accounting Association in AUDITING: A Journal of Practice & Theory
- p. 1-24
Linking Auditor Independence and Audit Quality: A Review and Synthesis of Academic Literature from 2015–2025
SUMMARY: This paper synthesizes academic studies published between 2015 and 2025 examining the relation between auditor independence and audit quality. We review evidence from the literature related to regulatory and professional factors (e.g., nonaudit services, auditor tenure, auditor switching), organizational factors (e.g., client importance, client dismissal of the auditor, social bonding), and individual auditor attributes (e.g., professional skepticism, expertise, and ethical orientation). Contemporary auditor independence research reports mixed and context-specific findings. For example, nonaudit services can either impair or enhance audit quality depending on service type, regulatory safeguards, and knowledge spillovers. Mandatory partner rotation tends to enhance audit quality, although mandatory firm rotation yields limited benefits and higher costs. We highlight the need for more research on independence and auditors’ duty to the public interest, proposing future directions to inform policy, practice, and standard setting. JEL Classifications: M40; M42; M48.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Accounting Association in Accounting Horizons
- p. 1-20
An Examination of Office-Level and Client-Level Non-Audit Services and Audit Quality
SYNOPSIS: Prior academic studies have investigated client- or office-level non-audit services (NAS) and found either positive effects through knowledge spillover or negative effects due to independence impairment or distraction. This study complements existing research by examining whether the effects of office-level and client-level NAS on audit quality vary with an audit office’s NAS focus. Specifically, we find a nonlinear association between office-level NAS provision and audit quality, with client misstatement rates lowest when the office provides moderate levels of NAS. Tax-related NAS drives these results. Further analysis reveals that the office-level focus on NAS affects the association between client-level NAS purchases and audit quality. This study enhances our understanding of the office-level and client-level dynamics of NAS provision to audit clients, offering regulators and practitioners relevant insights as they navigate this issue. Data Availability: All data sources are noted in the manuscript. JEL Classifications: M4; M41; M42.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Accounting Association in Accounting Horizons
- p. 1-20
An Examination of Office-Level and Client-Level Non-Audit Services and Audit Quality
SYNOPSIS: Prior academic studies have investigated client- or office-level non-audit services (NAS) and found either positive effects through knowledge spillover or negative effects due to independence impairment or distraction. This study complements existing research by examining whether the effects of office-level and client-level NAS on audit quality vary with an audit office’s NAS focus. Specifically, we find a nonlinear association between office-level NAS provision and audit quality, with client misstatement rates lowest when the office provides moderate levels of NAS. Tax-related NAS drives these results. Further analysis reveals that the office-level focus on NAS affects the association between client-level NAS purchases and audit quality. This study enhances our understanding of the office-level and client-level dynamics of NAS provision to audit clients, offering regulators and practitioners relevant insights as they navigate this issue. Data Availability: All data sources are noted in the manuscript. JEL Classifications: M4; M41; M42.
- 30 September 2025
- Published by American Accounting Association in Journal of International Accounting Research
- Vol. 24 (3) , 35-58
Does Codetermination Reduce Shareholder Value? Board-Level Employee Representation, Firm Value, Performance, and Rent-Seeking Behavior
We analyze the relation between board-level codetermination and shareholder value. We use a unique dataset of listed German companies that enables us to identify heterogeneous aspects of codetermination and overcome otherwise common identification issues. We find that codetermination reduces firm value but does not have a corresponding negative effect on firm performance. However, we find that codetermination increases employee wages and employee count while decreasing dividends paid to shareholders, thus providing some justification for the decrease in firm value. Our findings highlight how heterogeneity of firm governance structures can result in tradeoffs in economic outcomes that are a function of the structure’s economic characteristics. This study should improve policy makers’ understanding of the economic consequences of codetermination. Data Availability: Please contact the authors. JEL Classifications: G30; J53; L25.
- 30 September 2025
- Published by American Accounting Association in Journal of International Accounting Research
- Vol. 24 (3) , 35-58
Does Codetermination Reduce Shareholder Value? Board-Level Employee Representation, Firm Value, Performance, and Rent-Seeking Behavior
We analyze the relation between board-level codetermination and shareholder value. We use a unique dataset of listed German companies that enables us to identify heterogeneous aspects of codetermination and overcome otherwise common identification issues. We find that codetermination reduces firm value but does not have a corresponding negative effect on firm performance. However, we find that codetermination increases employee wages and employee count while decreasing dividends paid to shareholders, thus providing some justification for the decrease in firm value. Our findings highlight how heterogeneity of firm governance structures can result in tradeoffs in economic outcomes that are a function of the structure’s economic characteristics. This study should improve policy makers’ understanding of the economic consequences of codetermination. Data Availability: Please contact the authors. JEL Classifications: G30; J53; L25.
- Open Access
- 21 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Review of Accounting Studies
- Vol. 30 (4) , 3954-3995
The use of client-engaged specialists to support opportunistic estimates: evidence from the insurance industry
We use unique disclosures in the insurance industry to examine whether client-engaged specialists (i.e., external actuaries) affect opportunism within the claim loss reserve. Using a fixed-effects approach, we find that external actuaries significantly affect the opportunism in the claim loss reserve, approaching half the effect of the auditor. With respect to actuary characteristics, we find a positive (negative) association between actuary permissiveness (actuary size) and opportunism in the claim loss reserve. In additional analyses, we find that the relation between actuary permissiveness and claim loss reserve opportunism is stronger when insurers have incentives to opportunistically manage the claim loss reserve. This relation continues to persist in the presence of high-quality auditors. Overall, we provide evidence suggesting that client-engaged external actuaries can be used to support opportunistic claim loss reserve estimates.
- 21 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Review of Accounting Studies
- Vol. 30 (4) , 3954-3995
Open AccessThe use of client-engaged specialists to support opportunistic estimates: evidence from the insurance industry
We use unique disclosures in the insurance industry to examine whether client-engaged specialists (i.e., external actuaries) affect opportunism within the claim loss reserve. Using a fixed-effects approach, we find that external actuaries significantly affect the opportunism in the claim loss reserve, approaching half the effect of the auditor. With respect to actuary characteristics, we find a positive (negative) association between actuary permissiveness (actuary size) and opportunism in the claim loss reserve. In additional analyses, we find that the relation between actuary permissiveness and claim loss reserve opportunism is stronger when insurers have incentives to opportunistically manage the claim loss reserve. This relation continues to persist in the presence of high-quality auditors. Overall, we provide evidence suggesting that client-engaged external actuaries can be used to support opportunistic claim loss reserve estimates.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
The use of client-engaged specialists to support opportunistic estimates: Evidence from the insurance industry
We utilize unique disclosures in the insurance industry to examine whether clientengaged specialists (i.e., external actuaries) affect opportunism within the claim loss reserve. Using a fixed-effects approach, we find that external actuaries have a significant effect on the opportunism in the claim loss reserve, approaching half the effect of the auditor. With respect to actuary characteristics, we find a positive (negative) association between actuary permissiveness (actuary size) and opportunism in the claim loss reserve. In additional analyses, we find that the relation between actuary permissiveness and claim loss reserve opportunism is stronger when insurers have incentives to opportunistically manage the claim loss reserve. This relation continues to persist in the presence of high-quality auditors. Overall, we provide evidence suggesting that client-engaged external actuaries can be used to support opportunistic claim loss reserve estimates.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessThe use of client-engaged specialists to support opportunistic estimates: Evidence from the insurance industry
We utilize unique disclosures in the insurance industry to examine whether clientengaged specialists (i.e., external actuaries) affect opportunism within the claim loss reserve. Using a fixed-effects approach, we find that external actuaries have a significant effect on the opportunism in the claim loss reserve, approaching half the effect of the auditor. With respect to actuary characteristics, we find a positive (negative) association between actuary permissiveness (actuary size) and opportunism in the claim loss reserve. In additional analyses, we find that the relation between actuary permissiveness and claim loss reserve opportunism is stronger when insurers have incentives to opportunistically manage the claim loss reserve. This relation continues to persist in the presence of high-quality auditors. Overall, we provide evidence suggesting that client-engaged external actuaries can be used to support opportunistic claim loss reserve estimates.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2024
- Published by American Accounting Association in The Accounting Review
- Vol. 99 (3) , 201-224
Reliance on External Assurance in Regulatory Monitoring
We exploit a regulatory change to examine whether bank regulator strictness is affected when regulators no longer rely on external assurance. In the absence of external assurance, we find that banks report higher nonaccrual loans, higher troubled debt restructurings, and both a timelier loan loss provision and higher quality allowance for loan loss reserve. Further, regulators spend more days performing targeted bank examinations for banks affected by the regulatory change. We do not find evidence of operational deterioration, but rather the findings are consistent with increased regulator strictness over the reporting of problem assets, particularly during targeted examinations. Overall, our results suggest that regulators become stricter when they can no longer rely on the work of external auditors and that third-party assurance is an imperfect substitute for direct regulatory monitoring. Data Availability: Bank regulatory rating and examination dates are confidential and were obtained from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. All other data are available from the public sources cited in the text. JEL Classifications: G21; G28; M42.
- 22 April 2024
- Published by American Accounting Association in The Accounting Review
- Vol. 99 (3) , 201-224
Open AccessReliance on External Assurance in Regulatory Monitoring
We exploit a regulatory change to examine whether bank regulator strictness is affected when regulators no longer rely on external assurance. In the absence of external assurance, we find that banks report higher nonaccrual loans, higher troubled debt restructurings, and both a timelier loan loss provision and higher quality allowance for loan loss reserve. Further, regulators spend more days performing targeted bank examinations for banks affected by the regulatory change. We do not find evidence of operational deterioration, but rather the findings are consistent with increased regulator strictness over the reporting of problem assets, particularly during targeted examinations. Overall, our results suggest that regulators become stricter when they can no longer rely on the work of external auditors and that third-party assurance is an imperfect substitute for direct regulatory monitoring. Data Availability: Bank regulatory rating and examination dates are confidential and were obtained from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. All other data are available from the public sources cited in the text. JEL Classifications: G21; G28; M42.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2023
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Reliance on External Assurance in Regulatory Monitoring
We exploit a regulatory change to examine whether bank regulator strictness is affected when regulators no longer rely on external assurance. In the absence of external assurance, we find that banks report higher nonaccrual loans, higher troubled debt restructurings, and both a timelier loan loss provision and higher quality allowance for loan loss reserve. Further, regulators spend more days performing targeted bank examinations for banks affected by the regulatory change. We do not find evidence of operational deterioration, but rather the findings are consistent with increased regulator strictness in the reporting of problem assets, particularly during targeted examinations. Overall, our results suggest that regulators become stricter when they can no longer rely on the work of external auditors and that third-party assurance is an imperfect substitute for direct regulatory monitoring.
- 2 April 2023
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessReliance on External Assurance in Regulatory Monitoring
We exploit a regulatory change to examine whether bank regulator strictness is affected when regulators no longer rely on external assurance. In the absence of external assurance, we find that banks report higher nonaccrual loans, higher troubled debt restructurings, and both a timelier loan loss provision and higher quality allowance for loan loss reserve. Further, regulators spend more days performing targeted bank examinations for banks affected by the regulatory change. We do not find evidence of operational deterioration, but rather the findings are consistent with increased regulator strictness in the reporting of problem assets, particularly during targeted examinations. Overall, our results suggest that regulators become stricter when they can no longer rely on the work of external auditors and that third-party assurance is an imperfect substitute for direct regulatory monitoring.
- 7 February 2023
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 40 (2) , 952-980
Does the Presence of an Internal Control Audit Affect Firm Operational Efficiency?*
This study examines whether auditors' evaluation and reporting of firms' internal control over financial reporting (ICFR) affects firm operational efficiency. Prior research indicates that the strength of internal controls is positively associated with economic benefits. However, notwithstanding the underlying strength of controls, whether the mere presence of an ICFR audit provides similar economic benefits is unclear. We predict and find that small firms with ICFR audits have significantly higher overall operational efficiency than small firms with only management ICFR reports, even after controlling for underlying internal control strength. We find this effect manifests through improvements in inventory turnover and innovation, and through increased relative product market share. Separately, we find ICFR audits are associated with lower efficiency in SG&A expenses. Cross‐sectional analyses indicate that the mechanism by which ICFR audits affect overall operational efficiency is through auditor detection of internal control problems and through knowledge spillover from auditing other highly efficient firms in the audit office's metropolitan statistical area. These results provide additional evidence on the ongoing cost and benefit debate of ICFR audits for small firms.
- 7 February 2023
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 40 (2) , 952-980
Does the Presence of an Internal Control Audit Affect Firm Operational Efficiency?*
This study examines whether auditors' evaluation and reporting of firms' internal control over financial reporting (ICFR) affects firm operational efficiency. Prior research indicates that the strength of internal controls is positively associated with economic benefits. However, notwithstanding the underlying strength of controls, whether the mere presence of an ICFR audit provides similar economic benefits is unclear. We predict and find that small firms with ICFR audits have significantly higher overall operational efficiency than small firms with only management ICFR reports, even after controlling for underlying internal control strength. We find this effect manifests through improvements in inventory turnover and innovation, and through increased relative product market share. Separately, we find ICFR audits are associated with lower efficiency in SG&A expenses. Cross‐sectional analyses indicate that the mechanism by which ICFR audits affect overall operational efficiency is through auditor detection of internal control problems and through knowledge spillover from auditing other highly efficient firms in the audit office's metropolitan statistical area. These results provide additional evidence on the ongoing cost and benefit debate of ICFR audits for small firms.
- Open Access
- 25 March 2022
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Audit Partner Tenure and Accounting Estimates
This paper examines how the effect of the audit partner on accounting estimates varies across the tenure of a partner/client relationship. Using confidential data on audit partner identity in the banking industry, we find that banks systematically report higher loan loss reserves (LLRs) at the beginning of audit partner/client relationships relative to later years. We also find that the estimate of the LLR is more accurate early in the partner/client relationship. Collectively, these results suggest that audit partners enforce higher quality accounting estimates in the early years of the relationship relative to later years. Additional analyses reveal that the difference in the partner effect in the early years relative to the later years is limited to a partner’s initial engagement with a client and does not exist for boomerang partners. While the magnitude of the LLR early in the partner/client relationship is higher for public compared to private banks, where regulatory scrutiny and reputational risks are higher, we do not find evidence of significant differences in the quality of the LLR estimate. Our results suggest that the effect of audit partners on accounting estimates varies across the tenure of partner/client relationships.
- 25 March 2022
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessAudit Partner Tenure and Accounting Estimates
This paper examines how the effect of the audit partner on accounting estimates varies across the tenure of a partner/client relationship. Using confidential data on audit partner identity in the banking industry, we find that banks systematically report higher loan loss reserves (LLRs) at the beginning of audit partner/client relationships relative to later years. We also find that the estimate of the LLR is more accurate early in the partner/client relationship. Collectively, these results suggest that audit partners enforce higher quality accounting estimates in the early years of the relationship relative to later years. Additional analyses reveal that the difference in the partner effect in the early years relative to the later years is limited to a partner’s initial engagement with a client and does not exist for boomerang partners. While the magnitude of the LLR early in the partner/client relationship is higher for public compared to private banks, where regulatory scrutiny and reputational risks are higher, we do not find evidence of significant differences in the quality of the LLR estimate. Our results suggest that the effect of audit partners on accounting estimates varies across the tenure of partner/client relationships.
- 14 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 39 (1) , 157-198
The Role of Timing and Management's Remediation Actions in Preventing Failed Remediation of Material Weaknesses in Internal Controls*
Prior research finds that signals of remediation of internal control weaknesses do not guarantee that all weaknesses are fully resolved. However, why certain remediation strategies fail is unclear. This study examines how remediation timing and actions affect the likelihood of a failed remediation. I predict and find that the likelihood of a failed remediation is decreasing in both the time a company takes to remediate and in the extent of remediation actions employed. Importantly, this study documents that disclosures of material changes in internal control provide information useful in assessing the likelihood of a failed remediation, as well as evidence that prompt remediation does not necessarily result in a successful remediation. Moreover, I find that there are consequences to remediation failures in the form of a higher likelihood of management and board turnover. Finally, I find evidence that economic benefits of remediation found in prior research may be understated. This study can provide stakeholders with insights into how the nature, extent, and timing of a remediation strategy can reduce the likelihood of a failed remediation.
- 14 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Contemporary Accounting Research
- Vol. 39 (1) , 157-198
The Role of Timing and Management's Remediation Actions in Preventing Failed Remediation of Material Weaknesses in Internal Controls*
Prior research finds that signals of remediation of internal control weaknesses do not guarantee that all weaknesses are fully resolved. However, why certain remediation strategies fail is unclear. This study examines how remediation timing and actions affect the likelihood of a failed remediation. I predict and find that the likelihood of a failed remediation is decreasing in both the time a company takes to remediate and in the extent of remediation actions employed. Importantly, this study documents that disclosures of material changes in internal control provide information useful in assessing the likelihood of a failed remediation, as well as evidence that prompt remediation does not necessarily result in a successful remediation. Moreover, I find that there are consequences to remediation failures in the form of a higher likelihood of management and board turnover. Finally, I find evidence that economic benefits of remediation found in prior research may be understated. This study can provide stakeholders with insights into how the nature, extent, and timing of a remediation strategy can reduce the likelihood of a failed remediation.